Elnor Repo Reader

# DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R3 — Coverage Audit

**Date:** 2026-05-19  
**Audited document:** `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3.md`  
**Release ceiling:** stable OpenClaw through `2026.5.18`; `2026.5.19-beta.1` watch-only.  

## Result

The R3 proposal is complete enough to use as the source document for drafting the DOC11 R14 → R15 redline. It supersedes Proposal R2 before implementation.

## Coverage checklist

| Area | Included in R3? | Notes |
|---|---:|---|
| Stable release basis through `2026.5.18` | Yes | Watch-only handling for `2026.5.19-beta.1` included. |
| No-phantom-control / desired-effective discipline | Yes | Common primitives and acceptance tests require it. |
| Unified OpenClaw feature dashboard | Yes | Section 3. |
| `commands.list` / command catalog | Yes | Section 4. |
| Externalized plugin lifecycle | Yes | Section 5. |
| Plugin runtime deps / install repair / ClawHub metadata | Yes | Section 5. |
| Plugin-owned Gateway method registry | Yes | Sections 4 and 5. |
| Typed tool-plugin builder | Yes | Section 5. |
| Active-run `/steer` | Yes | Section 6. |
| `/btw` / `/side` side-result behavior | Yes | Section 6. |
| Side-result memory policy correction | Yes | Section 6.3. |
| Follow-up / collect / interrupt queue modes | Yes | Section 6. |
| Branch metadata without fake branch UI | Yes | Section 7. |
| Dual browser model | Yes | Section 8. |
| Browser dialogs / `blockedByDialog` / dialog answer | Yes | Section 8. |
| Browser evaluate timeout and URL allowlist | Yes | Section 8. |
| Chrome extension observation bridge | Yes | Section 8. |
| Browser artifacts / DOC20 obligations | Yes | Section 8.4. |
| Provider-native and plugin-backed search policy | Yes | Section 9. |
| SSRF/private-network/proxy controls | Yes | Section 9. |
| Codex app-server/code-mode migration | Yes | Section 10. |
| Codex Computer Use | Yes | Section 10. |
| Voice/Talk/TTS/STT/realtime controls | Yes | Section 11. |
| Google Meet deferred / inventory-only | Yes | Sections 11 and 25. |
| Compaction owner/trigger/source refs/capture guard | Yes | Section 12. |
| OpenClaw memory controls and ELNOR precedence | Yes | Section 13. |
| Diagnostics/export/startup/restart/trajectory | Yes | Section 14. |
| Config reloadability | Yes | Section 14. |
| Provider quota usage | Yes | Sections 14 and 15. |
| Model catalog source plan/auth/fallback | Yes | Section 15. |
| Subagent readback / parent review / handoff | Yes | Section 16. |
| Paired-node file-transfer controls | Yes | Section 17. |
| Sender-scoped tool authority | Yes | Section 18. |
| Streaming/progress/final delivery normalization | Yes | Section 19. |
| ACP fallback backends | Yes | Section 20. |
| Settings page implementation map | Yes | Section 21. |
| Route/event closure | Yes | Section 22. |
| Acceptance tests | Yes | Section 23. |
| Deferrals/watch-only rows | Yes | Section 25. |

## Known issues remaining

No blocking issue remains in the proposal. The actual DOC11 redline must still perform route appendix, event appendix, control matrix, and Appendix U closure against the compiled DOC11 R14 document.

## Follow-up before redline

Review R3 for desired scope choices, especially:

1. whether to keep `2026.5.19-beta.1` watch-only;
2. whether to include any branch-chat UI commitments beyond readback hooks;
3. how aggressively to expose provider-native search in the default settings page;
4. whether paired-node file transfer should default to disabled or approval-required.