Elnor Repo Reader

ELNOR REPO READER TEXT MIRROR
Original path: OP-A and Operations and Trackers/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.62.md
Source repo: /Users/OpenClaw1/Elnor/Elnor Specs
Git branch: main
Git commit: dbaa25962edc11ab30e8d4ca1715f9ae5bf77331
Generated: 2026-06-09T01:23:58.539Z

---

# ELNOR Suite — Current Operative Spec Registry

**Revision:** R3.62
**Generated:** 2026-05-24 (UTC — autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **TWO-DAY-GAP-CATCHUP bump** backfilling R3.61's substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping (R3.61 was bumped 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local capturing 2 NEW DAMS files + RECONCILIATION PASS but never updated SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md / dashboard.html / carryover prompt on its own window — **FIRST EVER substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping observation** in this scheduled-task's history; prior alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping family R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41/R3.49/R3.51/R3.54/R3.55/R3.57/R3.60 all involved alias-only firings; R3.61 is a new anomaly variant). Plus 2026-05-23 had ZERO sync firing observed — **FIRST EVER silent calendar day** in this scheduled-task run history (no DRIFT_LOG entry, no MSL bump, no operations-state ledger firing window matching expected daily cadence; likely missed-firing rather than zero-drift run-marker since no run-marker was appended). **In-scope filesystem scan since R3.61 alias write 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.61.md` returned 7 hits — 0 in-scope NEW spec files + 6 `Operations Docs/` ledgers (ADDENDA_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md, OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md, BACKUP_LOG.md — operations-state, not spec content) + 1 sub-sub-folder DOC23 ADDB cleanup patch pack files (out-of-scope per SKILL.md scope-list — DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework sub-sub-folder still NOT formally listed in SKILL.md; backlog item carry-forward). **In-scope archival events captured today:** 5 files MOVED from `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/` → `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` between R3.61 alias write and today: DAMS V1 (mtime 2026-05-20 11:32 preserved across move), DAMS V2 (mtime 2026-05-20 13:42 preserved), DAMS V3 (mtime 2026-05-21 05:56 preserved), DAMS V3 (1) (mtime 2026-05-21 05:59 preserved), DAMS V4 (mtime 2026-05-22 04:19 preserved). DAMS V4.1 modified 2026-05-22 04:27 local — sole remaining active file in §A8 DOC 80 DAMS subfolder. §A8 effective active count = 1 (V4.1 only); preserved-for-traceability rows = 5 (V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4 all moved to global addenda archive — auto-pass no-removal policy retains rows with FILE MOVED TO GLOBAL ARCHIVE annotation). **State-file backfill executed today:** SPEC_STATE Master Spec List row Rev field advanced R3.60 → R3.62 with R3.61/R3.62 narrative folded into Notes (Spec State row + Addenda State row Last Modified advanced 2026-05-22 → 2026-05-24); ADDENDA_STATE.md header Last touched advanced 2026-05-22 → 2026-05-24 with R3.62 narrative; ADDENDA_STATE backfill rows added — A-80 KDA v0.3.1 in §A.3 (materializes R3.61 reconciliation finding (b) for ADDENDA_STATE which never had this row), A-83 DAMS V4 + A-84 DAMS V4.1 in §A.8 (with archive annotations and natural-progression-successor lineage notes); §A.8 existing rows A-78/A-79/A-81/A-82 (V1/V2/V3/V3(1)) get FILE MOVED TO GLOBAL ARCHIVE annotations; dashboard regenerated with R3.62 narrative; carryover bumped V22 → V23 (substantive structural drift warrants carryover refresh — DAMS subfolder reorganization + R3.61 backfill content). **R3.61 versioned file moved → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.61.md`** per audit-cleanup pass; active folder retains R3.62 alias + R3.62 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant intact. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-EIGHT cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.62) — today's R3.61-substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping reinforces (a) item #5 post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files (R3.61 should have stat-checked SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard / carryover after its narrative-write to detect skipped-housekeeping at write time), and (b) NEW recommendation: substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping detection signals differ from alias-only-bump-skipped-housekeeping (substantive bumps inject false drift signal into MSL §12 while skipping the downstream state-file housekeeping that materializes the claimed changes) and warrants its own SKILL.md item. **Counts post-R3.62 (preserving R3.61 reconciled totals as baseline with archival adjustments noted parenthetically):** §3 Core Specs = 56 (unchanged from R3.61); §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 11 (unchanged from R3.61; ADDENDA_STATE now mirrors with A-80 KDA v0.3.1 row); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 6 rows total, 1 effective active (V4.1) + 5 preserved-for-traceability archived (V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4); §4 Active Addenda = 86 row-count (unchanged); effective active addenda excluding archived V1-V4 = 81; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 87 (R3.61); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28 (R3.61); §11 Grand total = 159 (R3.61). **Critical cross-doc finding carry-forward unchanged:** DAMS V2/V3's DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) flagged in R3.58/R3.59 still pending human review — further evidenced by R3.61 §12 DAMS V4 "central reframe of DAMS as one demoted substrate inside a larger memory architecture" narrative implying DAMS is no longer standalone but a memory-architecture-component proposal touching DOC1/DOC8 substantially. DOC 80 DAMS still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in scope-list backlog. **NEW ANOMALY** flagged today: 2026-05-23 silent calendar day — first observed silent calendar day in scheduled-task run history; needs human verification of whether task fired silently (zero output) or failed to fire (no execution). **Prior R3.61 header preserved below for traceability:** 2026-05-22 (local — autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump + RECONCILIATION PASS**. **2 NEW spec files** detected since R3.60 alias write 2026-05-21 16:11 local: `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-21 21:19 local; 62,380 bytes; -15,682 bytes / -20.1% under primary V3) + `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_1_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-21 21:27 local; 64,604 bytes; +2,224 bytes / +3.6% over V4). **SECOND-EVER same-day intra-window successor pair** (V4 → V4.1 ~8min apart) — even tighter than the R3.59 OPA V3.17→V3.18 ~17min pair; new rows A-84 (V4) + A-85 (V4.1) in §A8 DOC 80 DAMS. **Filesystem scan since R3.60:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 8 hits — 2 in-scope new spec files (above) + 5 `Operations Docs/` ledgers (ADDENDA_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md, OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, SPEC_STATE.md — operations-state, not spec content) + the R3.60 versioned snapshot (self). **MAJOR RECONCILIATION FINDING (flagged for human review):** the R3.59 changelog claimed three new table rows (A-80 BDSM v0.3.1 in §A3, A-82 DAMS V3 + A-83 DAMS V3(1) in §A8) and the R3.59/R3.60 §-counts include them, **but those rows were never actually written into the §A3/§A8 tables** — a narrative-vs-execution divergence of the same family the changelog has repeatedly flagged (R3.13/R3.16/R3.55 phantom-claim pattern). Additionally the **§11 Counts tables are frozen at R3.58 values** (PROPOSED ADDENDUM still reads 81, Grand total still reads 151/141) — never updated through R3.59/R3.60. **R3.61 reconciliation:** back-fills the phantom/untracked rows (A-80 BDSM v0.3.1, A-81 KDA v0.3.1, A-82 DAMS V3, A-83 DAMS V3(1)) into their tables so the tables match the on-disk corpus, adds the 2 genuinely-new V4/V4.1 rows (A-84/A-85), and adds an authoritative reconciled-totals note at the head of §11. **Additional reconciliation finding:** `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 16:14; 129,645 bytes) existed on disk since R3.58-era but was **never counted or rowed** — the R3.60 §A3 count of 10 undercounted the 11 actual DOC24-Addenda files by exactly this file; R3.61 tracks it as A-81 (closing the long-standing A-81 numbering gap chronologically, since both v0.3.1 files predate the DAMS V3 files). **Authoritative reconciled counts at R3.61:** §3 Core Specs = 56 (unchanged); §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 11 (now all 11 rows present; R3.60 claimed 10); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 6 (V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4/V4.1 — all 6 rows now present); §4 Active Addenda = 86 (R3.60 = 83 incl. 3 phantoms; +1 for never-counted KDA v0.3.1; +2 for new V4/V4.1); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 87; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 159. **Carry-forward (unchanged, pending human review):** DAMS DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is a 730-line friction engine with no learning-engine capabilities) persists from R3.58; SKILL.md tightening recommendation now **thirty-six cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.61) — today's discovery that R3.59/R3.60 table writes were phantom is the strongest evidence yet for the standing recommendation that the job `stat`/grep-verify claimed table edits at write time; DOC 80 DAMS still the eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in the SKILL.md scope-list backlog. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.60 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (parent `ECQ Development/`); R3.61 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.61 alias + R3.61 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)

**(Prior R3.60 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-21 (local — autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing**; zero new spec files detected since R3.59 alias write 2026-05-21 03:15 local (+~1h17m at firing 2026-05-21 ~04:31 local). **Filesystem scan since R3.59:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 5 hits, ALL in `Operations Docs/` (operations-state ledgers, not spec content) — DRIFT_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-21 03:19; +04m post-R3.59) + OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-21 03:45; +30m post-R3.59) + BACKUP_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-21 04:20; +1h05m post-R3.59) + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (mtime 2026-05-21 04:25; +1h10m post-R3.59) + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-21 04:31; +1h16m post-R3.59). Spec corpus content (DOC1–DOC25, DOC72, DOC73 family, EC_Core_Specs, OPA V3.11–V3.18 placement-irregularity backlog now 9-of-10, Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC, addenda subfolder topology including new §A8 DOC 80 DAMS with 4 files, integrated-vs-active status, BDSM v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/v0.3.1 working-draft series) all stable from R3.59 snapshot — no diff. Per SKILL.md Step 5 ALIAS-ONLY canonical path (mirrors prior R3.57 + R3.54 firing patterns). Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.59 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure; R3.60 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.60 alias + R3.60 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved. **Counts:** all unchanged from R3.59 (§3 Core Specs = 56; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 10; §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 4; §4 Active Addenda = 83; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 84; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 156). **Critical cross-doc finding carry-forward:** DAMS V2/V3's DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) flagged in R3.58/R3.59 still pending human review. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-five cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.60). DOC 80 DAMS subfolder still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in scope-list backlog. R3.59 carry-forward items preserved unchanged: A-75 BDSM v0.3 + A-78 V1 + A-79 V2 DAMS rows all retain natural-progression-supersession annotations; same-day intra-window OPA pair pattern (V3.17 → V3.18 ~17min apart) carried forward as architecturally-significant emergence; same-day intra-folder duplicate-exceeding-primary pattern (DAMS V3 (1) > primary V3 by +20.7%) carried forward as workflow-signal mystery pending human classification; fourth-decimal-place patch suffix in BDSM chain (`_v0_3_1`) carried forward as architecturally-significant intra-version patch granularity pattern. Tracker numbering divergence between MSL §4 (A-80/A-82/A-83) and ADDENDA_STATE (A-79/A-81/A-82) extends to tenth+ NEW-row cycle.)

**(Prior R3.59 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-21 (local — autonomous nightly sync — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW files** since R3.58 alias write 2026-05-20 23:15 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.58:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 5 hits in scope: 2 spec files in active root (OPA V3.17 + OPA V3.18) + 3 addenda files in subfolders (BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3.1 + DAMS V3 + DAMS V3 (1)). **New files:** (1) `OPA_V3_17.md` active root (mtime 2026-05-21 01:30 local; size 760,219 bytes; +41,168 bytes / +5.7% over V3.16) — eighth active-root placement-irregular OPA instance. (2) `OPA_V3_18.md` active root (mtime 2026-05-21 01:47 local; size 767,081 bytes; +6,862 bytes / +0.9% over V3.17) — **FIRST EVER same-day intra-window OPA successor pair** ~17min apart; ninth placement-irregular OPA instance; small +0.9% growth suggests minor corrective patch. (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 23:15 local) — **FIRST EVER fourth-decimal-place patch suffix** `_v0_3_1` in BDSM chain extending v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL working-draft series with intra-version patch granularity (analogous to DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 → V3.1 → V3.2 minor-revision pattern). New row A-80 in §A3 DOC24 Addenda (continues after A-75 v0.3 + A-76 KDA v0.3 from R3.58); A-75 BDSM v0.3 row gets natural-progression-intra-version-patch-successor annotation. (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-21 05:56 local; size 78,062 bytes; -3,210 bytes / -4% under V2) — consolidated successor to A-78/A-79 V1+V2 same-day pair from R3.58; filename change `DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2` → `DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL` signals consolidation from proposal-iteration mode to architecture-baseline mode; modest size reduction (-4%) consistent with consolidation tightening. New row A-82 in §A8 DOC 80 DAMS (continues after A-78 V1 + A-79 V2 from R3.58). (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-21 05:59 local; size 94,239 bytes; +16,177 bytes / +20.7% over primary V3) — **(1)-suffix duplicate variant** of primary V3 written ~3min after primary; **FIRST EVER same-day intra-folder duplicate pair where duplicate EXCEEDS primary in size** (unlike prior (1)-suffix downloads-copy pattern where duplicate matched primary); workflow-signal mystery pending human classification. New row A-83 in §A8. **Counts updates in R3.59:** §3 Core Specs 54 → 56 (+2 for OPA V3.17 + V3.18); §A3 DOC24 Addenda 9 → 10 (+1 for BDSM v0.3.1); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS 2 → 4 (+2 for V3 + V3 (1)); §4 Active Addenda 80 → 83 (+3); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 81 → 84 (+3); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER 26 → 28 (+2); Grand total 151 → 156 (+5). **Architecturally significant developments today:** (a) FIRST EVER same-day intra-window OPA successor pair (V3.17 → V3.18 ~17min apart) — tighter cadence than R3.58 DAMS V1→V2 ~2h pair; (b) FIRST EVER fourth-decimal-place patch suffix `_v0_3_1` in BDSM chain extending v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL working-draft series with intra-version patch granularity; (c) FIRST EVER same-day primary + (1)-duplicate pair where duplicate exceeds primary in size — first deviation from downloads-copy-matching-primary pattern observed across DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card and DOC23 REPROMPT duplicates; (d) DOC 80 DAMS subfolder now has 4 files (V1+V2 from R3.58 + V3+V3 (1) from R3.59) — first not-formally-listed subfolder to accumulate 4 files in single MSL bump-cycle since formation. **Audit-cleanup pass** moves R3.58 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure; R3.59 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.59 alias + R3.59 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved. **Critical cross-doc finding carry-forward:** DAMS V2's DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) flagged in R3.58 still pending human review. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-four cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.59). DOC 80 DAMS subfolder still informally tracked (eighth not-formally-listed subfolder).)
**(Prior R3.58 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-20 (local — autonomous nightly sync — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW spec files + 1 NEW Addenda subfolder** since R3.57 alias write 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.57:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 7 hits — 5 spec/addendum files in scope + 2 out-of-scope Operations Docs ledgers. **New files:** (1) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_Project_Proposal_R0_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 10:47:42 local; size 89,032 bytes) — explicit `Supersedes:` of R0.2 (A-58); title evolution: "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal R0.2" → "Workspace / Library / Project Mode / Output Routing / Memory Continuity Proposal R0.3"; introduces **explicit project mode** as primary primitive (collapsing R0.2's eleven user-facing concepts after red-team review); references in-flight DOC72 Entity Attenuator Addendum as canonical; +750 bytes / +0.8% over R0.2. New row A-77 in §A7 Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder. (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 11:32:26 local; size 131,064 bytes) — **first ever DAMS (Dynamic Attenuator Memory System) proposal**; placeholder DOC80 (core primitive) + DOC81 (consumer integration map) numbering; companion to A-77 R0.3 (R0.3 references DAMS attenuator primitive as canonical). New row A-78 in **brand-new §A8 DOC 80 DAMS subfolder**. (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 13:42:32 local; size 81,272 bytes; -49,792 bytes / -38% under V1) — same-day V2 substantive revision over V1 within ~2h window; corrects framing facts (build-it-all-at-once posture, DOC72 size constraint, DOC8 phantom finding, naming "Attenuator" vs "Attenuated", Control Surface §16 addition); first ever same-day V1→V2 pair in any addenda subfolder. New row A-79 in §A8. (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 11:27:03 local; size 170,708 bytes; +19,040 bytes / +12.6% over v0.2 = A-72) — v0.3 patch over v0.2 BDSM V6.5 draft; per file: "applies the v0.3 corrective patch plan over the v0.2 BDSM V6.5 draft and replaces BDSM v6.4 for the V6.5+ revision lane." New row A-75 in §A3 DOC24 Addenda; A-72 v0.2 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending finalization. (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 12:23:19 local; size 128,723 bytes; +34,891 bytes / +37.2% over v0.2 = A-73) — v0.3 preservation patch over v0.2 KDA R3 draft; per file: "v0.3 is a mechanical preservation patch over v0.2, closing the ten KDA R2 preservation gaps enumerated in the v0.3 patch plan." New row A-76 in §A3 DOC24 Addenda; A-73 v0.2 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending finalization. **NEW SUBFOLDER §A8 DOC 80 DAMS** — brand new subfolder in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`, folder mtime 2026-05-20 13:42 local (= last child write); first addenda subfolder pattern keyed to a placeholder DOC number not yet in the registry's core spec list (DOC80/DOC81); extends pattern of single-parent subfolders to first ever **multi-doc placeholder subfolder**. Backlog: SKILL.md scope list still lacks formal DOC 80 DAMS entry (eighth not-formally-listed subfolder added since SKILL.md tightening recommendation began at R3.26). **Operations-state firings (out of scope):** S-BACKUP_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-20 04:16:39 local; +9m post-R3.57) + S-RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-20 04:11:51 local; +4m post-R3.57) — both attributable as late-coordinated R3.57 post-write housekeeping. **Counts updates in R3.58:** §A3 DOC24 Addenda 7 → 9 (+2 for A-75 BDSM v0.3 + A-76 KDA v0.3); §A7 Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj 2 → 3 (+1 for A-77 R0.3); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS 0 → 2 (+2 for A-78 V1 + A-79 V2; new subsection); §4 Active Addenda 75 → 80 (+5); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 76 → 81 (+5); §11 Grand total 146 → 151 (+5). **Same-day V1→V2 pattern (DAMS) within ~2h window** — first such intra-folder same-day pair in this scheduled task's history; suggests rapid red-team-iteration framing for a substantive new memory-system proposal that may anchor a memory-system rebuild. **Multi-revision DOC24 cluster again** (v0.3 BDSM + v0.3 KDA within ~1h window) — second consecutive multi-DOC24-draft sync window (R3.55 captured v0.2 pair; R3.58 captures v0.3 pair); confirms coordinated DOC24 family redrafting cadence. **Audit-cleanup pass** moves R3.57 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure; R3.58 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.58 alias + R3.58 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)
**(Prior R3.57 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-20 (local — autonomous nightly sync — **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing — zero new spec files detected** since R3.56 alias write 2026-05-20 ~10:15 UTC (~03:15 local) (+~0h52m at firing 2026-05-20 ~11:07 UTC / ~04:07 local). **Filesystem scan since R3.56 alias write:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 3 hits, ALL in Operations Docs/ (operations-state ledgers, not spec content): (1) `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 03:21:14 local; +~6m post-R3.56; size 240,924 bytes) — late-coordinated R3.56 post-write housekeeping firing capturing R3.56 state-files-catchup events; (2) `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 03:43:33 local; +~28m post-R3.56; size 102,981 bytes) — independent post-R3.56 firing; (3) `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 04:04:38 local; +~49m post-R3.56; size 51,180 bytes) — independent post-R3.56 firing. Spec corpus content (DOC1–DOC25, DOC72, DOC73 family, EC_Core_Specs, OPA_V3.16, Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC, addenda subfolder topology, integrated-vs-active status, placement-irregularity backlog of 7 OPA instances V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12/V3.13/V3.15/V3.16 vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy) all stable from R3.56 snapshot — no diff. Per SKILL.md Step 5 "If no drift and exactly 1 versioned file exists: skip Steps 5.1-5.3; only run Step 5.4 sanity check" — this is the canonical ALIAS-ONLY path (mirrors prior R3.54 firing pattern). Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.56 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.57 alias + R3.57 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)
**(Prior R3.56 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-20 (local — autonomous nightly sync — **STATE-FILES-CATCHUP bump** capturing zero new spec files since R3.55 alias write 2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC (+~11h at firing) but backfilling R3.55's MSL-captured-but-state-files-missed structural drift. R3.55 (substantive 2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC) added 5 NEW files to MSL §3/§4 (OPA V3.16 + ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.2 AUDITED + DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 + DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 + DOC23 FAMILY COHERENCE V1) but FAILED to update SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md / dashboard.html / carryover prompt. The R3.55 §12 changelog narrative claimed "Carryover prompt bumped V20 → V21" but NO V21 FILE EXISTS in `Prompts/` (V20 dated 2026-05-19 10:23 was still the latest V2x file before today). R3.56 today materializes the V21 carryover bump + backfills SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE rows + appends DRIFT_LOG entry + regenerates dashboard. **Filesystem scan since R3.55 alias write:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.55.md` returned ZERO hits in active scan folders. Per SKILL.md Step 5 "If no drift and exactly 1 versioned file exists: skip Steps 5.1-5.3; only run Step 5.4 sanity check" — but state-file divergence from MSL R3.55 claims constitutes a different class of drift (claim-vs-reality drift in the carryover + tracker-row divergence) that warrants an R3.56 catchup bump to record the backfill events in the §12 changelog audit trail. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.55 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.56 alias + R3.56 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)
**(Prior R3.55 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-19 (local — autonomous nightly sync — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing 5 NEW files since R3.54 alias write 2026-05-19 04:09:42 local (+~9h45m at firing). **New files detected:** (1) `OPA_V3_16.md` in active root (mtime 2026-05-19 10:17:42; size 719,051 bytes; +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15 — placement-irregular active-root successor; placement-irregularity backlog extends to 7 instances V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12/V3.13/V3.15/V3.16 vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy); (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED.md` top-level (mtime 2026-05-19 09:18:57; size 95,218 bytes; +34,080 bytes / +55.7% over V5.1 from R3.53 A-67) — natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-67 V5.1; substantial size growth suggests audit-driven content expansion (red-team incorporation pattern observed in DOC10 R10/R11, DOC24 R2.5 patterns); A-67 V5.1 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending human archival decision; (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 13:50:39; size 151,668 bytes; +10,566 bytes / +7.5% over V6.4 = A-22 row) — v6.5 DRAFT v0.2 successor in BDSM Operative Spec chain; `_DRAFT_v0_2` filename suffix indicates working-draft variant (analogous to DOC23 ADDB V3.1 audit-complete-then-V3.2-coordination-patch pattern); A-22 V6.4 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending v6.5 finalization; (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 11:54:51; size 93,832 bytes; +20,661 bytes / +28% over R2 = A-19 row) — R3 DRAFT v0.2 successor in DOC24 KDA chain with filename canonicalization (long `DOC24_ADDENDUM-B [KDA] KNOWLEDGE_DELIVERY_SHARED_CONTRACTS_R2` → short `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2`, analogous to ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 canonicalization pattern); A-19 R2 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending R3 finalization; (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 12:43:05; size 53,808 bytes) — NEW DOC23 family coherence map V1, no prior version detected; cross-cutting reference document mapping self-learning coherence across DOC23 Addenda A/B family topology (analogous to A-49 Context Mgmt → Card Integration Map V2 and A-32 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1 cross-cutting reference patterns); status placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP. Two intra-day DOC24 successor drafts (BDSM V6.5 + KDA R3) suggest active DOC24 redrafting pass — first multi-DOC24-draft drift in single sync window. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.54 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.55 alias + R3.55 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)
**(Prior R3.54 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-19 (local — autonomous nightly sync — **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing — zero new spec files detected** since R3.53 alias write 2026-05-19 03:19:50 local (+0h47m at firing). No new spec content, addenda, or proposals in scanned scope (primary scan folder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ minus Archived Addenda and Proposals/). Only operations-state ledger updates detected: (1) `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:28:29 local; +8m39s post-R3.53; size 227,773 bytes) — late-coordinated R3.53 post-write housekeeping firing; (2) `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:46:52 local; +27m02s post-R3.53; size 98,280 bytes) — independent post-R3.53 firing; (3) `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 04:02:40 local; +42m50s post-R3.53; size 44,930 bytes) — independent post-R3.53 firing. Spec corpus content (DOC1–DOC25, DOC72, DOC73 family, EC_Core_Specs, OPA_V3_15, Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC, addenda subfolder topology, integrated-vs-active status, placement-irregularity backlog of 6 OPA instances V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12/V3.13/V3.15 vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy) all stable from R3.53 snapshot — no diff. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.53 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.54 alias + R3.54 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)
**(Prior R3.53 header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-19 (local — autonomous nightly sync **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing 5 NEW files since R3.52 alias write 2026-05-18 23:08 UTC: (1) `OPA_V3_15.md` in active root (mtime 2026-05-19 05:36; size 675,447 bytes; +138,064 bytes / +25.7% over V3.13 — placement-irregular active-root successor; V3.14 skipped or briefly-extant; placement-irregularity backlog extends to 6 instances V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12/V3.13/V3.15 vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy); (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1.md` top-level (mtime 2026-05-18 23:55; size 61,138 bytes) — natural-progression successor to A-5 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4 via filename canonicalization V4 PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES → V5.1 ARCHITECTURE; V5 briefly-extant or skipped; (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:06; size 76,467 bytes) — DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R3 successor to A-34 R2; R2 file moved today to NEW intra-subfolder archive `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` (folder created today, mtime 2026-05-19 03:09); (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3_COVERAGE_AUDIT.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:07; size 3,516 bytes) — short coverage-audit companion to R3 amendment proposal; (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:07; size 19,278 bytes) — R3 successor to OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2; R2 file moved today to intra-subfolder archive alongside R2 ADD REVIEW variant. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.52 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retains R3.53 alias + R3.53 versioned snapshot only.)
**(Prior R3.52 header preserved for traceability):** R3.52 was 2026-05-18 local autonomous nightly sync that ran same-day THIRD-firing **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** after R3.50 substantive + R3.51 operations-state-only firings earlier on 2026-05-18. **3 NEW files detected** since R3.51 alias write 2026-05-18 ~04:08 local: (1) `OPA_V3_13.md` materialized in active root (mtime 2026-05-18 10:42; size 537,383 bytes; +9,897 bytes over V3.12 — continues placement-irregular active-root pattern, now 5 placement-irregular instances V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12/V3.13 vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy); (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18; size 474,162 bytes; +12,914 bytes over V3.2 — successor in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain; first sub-sub-folder-resident successor since R3.49 family-topology decomposition); (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18; size 52,068 bytes; +5,490 bytes over V1 — first revision to Common Contracts since R3.49 introduction). Two post-R3.51 operations-state firings also captured — S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (+05m19s post-R3.51 = 04:13:40 local, attributable as late-coordinated R3.51 post-write housekeeping) + S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (+08m49s post-R3.51 = 04:17:10 local, INDEPENDENT FIRING with proof — **ends R3.51's "ninth-day silence" characterization**, recharacterizes as **tenth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF + defensive-pre-check applied** for the second consecutive observed run; source corpus grew 22→27 MB in 24 hours making backup gap more significant). Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.51 versioned file from active root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder now retains R3.52 alias + R3.52 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)

**Last Updated:** 2026-05-21 ~04:31 local (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing) — R3.60 sync run is an **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing**; zero new spec files detected since R3.59 alias write 2026-05-21 03:15 local (+~1h17m at firing). Filesystem scan since R3.59 returned 5 hits ALL in `Operations Docs/` (DRIFT_LOG +04m + OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG +30m + BACKUP_LOG +1h05m + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY +1h10m + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG +1h16m). Spec corpus content all stable from R3.59 snapshot. Per SKILL.md Step 5 ALIAS-ONLY canonical path (mirrors prior R3.57 + R3.54 firing patterns). R3.60 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write; R3.59 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.60 alias + R3.60 versioned snapshot only. Counts all unchanged from R3.59 (§3 Core Specs = 56; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 10; §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 4; §4 Active Addenda = 83; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 84; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 156). SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence at thirty-five cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.60). DAMS V2/V3 DOC8 phantom finding still pending human review.

**(Prior R3.59 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-21 (local — autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing) — R3.59 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW files** since R3.58 alias write 2026-05-20 23:15 local. New rows: §3 +2 (OPA V3.17 + OPA V3.18, first same-day intra-window OPA pair ~17min apart); §A3 +1 (A-80 BDSM v0.3.1, first fourth-decimal-place patch suffix in BDSM chain); §A8 +2 (A-82 DAMS V3 CONSOLIDATED ARCHITECTURE PROPOSAL + A-83 DAMS V3 (1)-duplicate where duplicate exceeds primary by +20.7% — first such pattern). A-75 v0.3 BDSM + A-78 V1 + A-79 V2 DAMS rows get natural-progression-supersession annotations. R3.59 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write; R3.58 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.59 alias + R3.59 versioned snapshot only. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-four cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.59); DOC 80 DAMS subfolder still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in scope-list backlog (accumulated 4 files in <24h, first such cluster since formation).
**(Prior R3.58 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-20 (local — autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing) — R3.58 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW spec files + 1 NEW Addenda subfolder (§A8 DOC 80 DAMS)** since R3.57 alias write 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local. New rows: §A3 A-75 (BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3) + §A3 A-76 (KDA R3 DRAFT v0.3) + §A7 A-77 (Unified Workspace R0.3 with explicit `Supersedes:` of A-58 R0.2) + new §A8 with A-78 (DAMS V1) + A-79 (DAMS V2, same-day successor). A-72 v0.2 BDSM + A-73 v0.2 KDA + A-58 R0.2 Unified Workspace rows get natural-progression-supersession annotations pending finalization. R3.58 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write; R3.57 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retains R3.58 alias + R3.58 versioned snapshot only. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-three cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.58); DOC 80 DAMS subfolder now eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in scope-list backlog.
**(Prior R3.57 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-20 ~11:07 UTC (~04:07 local) — R3.57 sync run is an **ALIAS-ONLY firing** (no new spec files, 3 Operations Docs state-ledger updates only post-R3.56). Spec corpus identical to R3.56 snapshot. Alias + R3.57 versioned snapshot updated; R3.56 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`.
**(Prior R3.56 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-20 ~10:15 UTC (~03:15 local) — R3.56 sync run is a **STATE-FILES-CATCHUP bump** with zero new spec files detected since R3.55 alias write 2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC, but backfilling R3.55's missed state-file updates. R3.55 had captured 5 NEW files in §3/§4 but failed to update SPEC_STATE.md, ADDENDA_STATE.md, dashboard.html, or actually materialize the V21 carryover claimed in its §12 changelog (V21 NEVER EXISTED until today). R3.56 catchup: (a) SPEC_STATE.md backfilled with 1 NEW row OPA V3.16 (NEW) in §3 Core Specs (placement-irregular active-root successor); Master Spec List + Spec State + Addenda State rows advanced R3.53 → R3.56 with R3.54/R3.55/R3.56 narrative folded into Notes; (b) ADDENDA_STATE.md backfilled with 4 NEW rows: A-70 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED in §A.1 (top-level natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-66 V5.1, first observed `_AUDITED` suffix in any subagent chain), A-71 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 in §A.3 (DRAFT successor to A-22 V6.4 operative; `_DRAFT_v0_2` working-draft suffix indicates first observation of v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL pattern in BDSM chain), A-72 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 in §A.3 (natural-progression DRAFT successor to A-19 R2 with filename canonicalization long-form → short-form pattern, third instance after ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 and DOC23 ADDB V2 → V3), A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 in §A.6 (NEW cross-cutting reference map V1 spanning Addenda A R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1.1; likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP); ADDENDA_STATE numbering uses A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74 (skips A-73 to preserve historical row-bound divergence pattern); master spec list §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74 — cumulative divergence-by-one pattern extends to EIGHT+ NEW-row cycles. (c) Carryover prompt actually bumped V20 → V21 today (materializing R3.55's phantom claim — same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping anomaly family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41 phantom-V17 + R3.49 phantom-V19 narrative-vs-execution divergences). V21 captures: (i) OPA V3.15 → V3.16 placement-irregular continuation; (ii) ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.1 → V5.2 AUDITED audit-suffix variant; (iii) DOC24 BDSM V6.4 → V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 multi-draft pattern emergence; (iv) DOC24 KDA R2 → R3 DRAFT v0.2 with filename canonicalization; (v) DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 cross-cutting reference emergence; (vi) R3.55 phantom V21-claim recovery via today's actual V21 creation. (d) Dashboard regenerated with R3.56 narrative + lastRefresh advanced 2026-05-19 → 2026-05-20 + new SPECS row for OPA V3.16 + new ADDENDA rows for A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74. (e) DRIFT_LOG.md appended with today's catchup entry recording the R3.54/R3.55/R3.56 backfill events. **Counts:** all unchanged from R3.55 (§3 = 53, §A1 = 33, §A3 = 7, §A6 = 19, §4 = 75, §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 76, §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER DRAFT = 24, §11 Core total = 54, §11 Grand total = 146) — today's R3.56 catchup adds zero new files; only the state files now reflect R3.55's captured drift. **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.55 versioned file moved from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.55.md` per standard bump procedure; R3.56 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.56 alias + R3.56 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-one cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.56); the R3.55 phantom-V21 claim reinforces SKILL.md item #5 (post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files) — `stat`-checking `Prompts/V21` would have caught R3.55's narrative-vs-execution divergence at write time. **DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — catchup R3.56 entry documenting R3.54 alias-only firing + R3.55 substantive structural drift + today's state-file catchup. **Tracker numbering divergence:** master spec list §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74 for the four new addenda rows; ADDENDA_STATE uses A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74 (skips A-73) — cumulative divergence-by-one pattern preserved (A-70 V5.2 AUDITED ≠ A-71 V5.2 AUDITED across trackers; A-74 FAMILY map coincidentally aligns across both). All R3.55 carry-forward items preserved unchanged.
**(Prior R3.55 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-19 ~20:55 UTC (~13:55 local) — R3.55 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW files** since R3.54 alias write 2026-05-19 04:09:42 local (+~9h45m earlier). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-19. **Filesystem scan since R3.54:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.54.md` returned five spec files plus operations-state ledger refreshes (S-BACKUP_LOG.md mtime 2026-05-19 04:17 local + S-RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime 2026-05-19 04:09 local — both within 8m of R3.54 alias write, attributable as late-coordinated R3.54 post-write housekeeping). **(1) NEW §3 row — OPA V3.16 placement-irregular successor:** `OPA_V3_16.md` (active root; mtime 2026-05-19 10:17:42, size 719,051 bytes; +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15 from R3.53). Continues placement-irregular active-root pattern (no return to proper `Operations Docs/` location after V3.11's brief correction). **Placement-irregularity backlog extends to 7 instances** (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 implicit transit + V3.12 + V3.13 + V3.15 + V3.16) with V3.11 the lone correctly-placed copy. Size growth from V3.15 (675,447) → V3.16 (719,051) = +6.5% — modest growth likely incorporating further DOC24 R3.1.1 follow-on adjudication closure rows + DOC23 family-coherence absorption rows + R3.54 detection-window content. Full file-header inspection deferred. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. **(2) NEW §A1 row A-71 — ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED.md top-level audit successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 09:18:57, size 95,218 bytes). Natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-67 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1 (R3.53 NEW row). V5.2 AUDITED is +34,080 bytes / +55.7% larger than V5.1 (61,138 bytes) — substantial growth consistent with audit-driven red-team incorporation pattern (analogous to DOC10 R10 → R11 Consolidated 109,358 → 175,206 byte expansion via R10/R8 red team incorporation matrix). A-67 V5.1 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending human archival decision. **(3) NEW §A3 row A-72 — DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 13:50:39, size 151,668 bytes; +10,566 bytes / +7.5% over A-22 V6.4's 141,102 bytes). `_DRAFT_v0_2` filename suffix indicates working-draft variant (analogous to DOC23 ADDB V3.1 audit-complete-then-V3.2-coordination-patch pattern from R3.47/R3.49). DOC24 Addendum A BDSM (Big Dynamic Satisfaction Machine) chain advances V6.4 → V6.5. A-22 V6.4 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending v6.5 finalization (likely series of drafts v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL before supersession). **(4) NEW §A3 row A-73 — DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 successor with filename canonicalization:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 11:54:51, size 93,832 bytes; +20,661 bytes / +28% over A-19 R2's 73,171 bytes). Successor in DOC24 KDA (Knowledge Delivery Architecture) chain with **filename canonicalization**: long-form `DOC24_ADDENDUM-B [KDA] KNOWLEDGE_DELIVERY_SHARED_CONTRACTS_R2` → short-form `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2` (analogous to ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES → ARCHITECTURE canonicalization from R3.53 + DOC23 ADDB V2 → V3 OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION → OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR canonicalization). +28% size growth suggests substantive R3 expansion (likely incorporating cross-references with new DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1 + neuroplasticity refinements). A-19 R2 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending R3 finalization. **(5) NEW §A6 row A-74 — DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1 NEW cross-cutting reference:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 12:43:05, size 53,808 bytes). NEW DOC23 family coherence map V1 — no prior version detected. Cross-cutting reference document mapping self-learning coherence across DOC23 family addenda (Addenda A Task Optimization R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda Feedback Delivery / Source Workspace / Task Forum + Run Board + Common Contracts V1.1). Likely needs reclassification as `SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP / NON-OWNER DRAFT` rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` (analogous to A-32 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1 and A-49 Context Management → Card Integration Map V2 cross-cutting reference patterns). Counted as PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholder pending human reclassification. **Operations-state deltas:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md + S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md + S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md will be touched by this R3.55 sync write itself (coordinated post-write housekeeping pattern). Two late-coordinated R3.54 post-write firings captured pre-scan: S-11 BACKUP_LOG (+8m post-R3.54) + S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG (+0m alias-write coupled). **Counts updates in R3.55:** §3 Core Specifications 52 → 53 (+1 for OPA V3.16 placeholder row); §A1 Top-level addenda 32 → 33 (+1 for A-71 V5.2 AUDITED); §A3 DOC24 Addenda 5 → 7 (+2 for A-72 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT + A-73 KDA R3 DRAFT); §A6 DOC23 Addenda 18 → 19 (+1 for A-74 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1); §4 Active Addenda 71 → 75 (+4 for A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 72 → 76 (+4); §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 23 → 24 (+1 for OPA V3.16); §11 Core registry total 53 → 54 (+1); §11 Grand total 141 → 146 (+5). **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.54 versioned file moved from active root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.54.md` per standard bump procedure; R3.55 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.55 alias + R3.55 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved). **Two intra-day DOC24 successor drafts (BDSM V6.5 + KDA R3) within ~2h window** — first multi-DOC24-draft drift in a single sync window. Suggests coordinated DOC24 family redrafting pass; possibly triggered by DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1 introduction earlier in the day. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.55); `mountpoint -q` pre-flight remains highest-urgency given S-11 confirmed-failure pattern. **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended this cycle** — substantive R3.55 entry documenting five NEW files including first ever ELNOR_SUBAGENT audit-suffix variant and first ever DOC24 multi-draft same-day drift. **Carryover prompt bumped V20 → V21** — five new files including DOC24 family redrafting cluster warrant the carryover refresh. V21 captures: (a) OPA V3.15 → V3.16 placement-irregular continuation (V3.14 still skipped); (b) ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.1 → V5.2 AUDITED audit-suffix variant (first in any subagent chain); (c) DOC24 BDSM V6.4 → V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 multi-draft pattern emergence; (d) DOC24 KDA R2 → R3 DRAFT v0.2 with filename canonicalization; (e) DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 cross-cutting reference emergence. **All R3.54 carry-forward items preserved unchanged.** **Tracker numbering divergence:** master spec list §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74 for the four new top-level/subfolder rows; ADDENDA_STATE may use A-70/A-71/A-72/A-73 — extends cumulative divergence-by-one pattern to EIGHT+ NEW-row cycles.
**(Prior R3.54 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-19 ~11:07 UTC (~04:07 local) — R3.54 sync run is an **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing**. Zero new spec files detected; spec corpus content unchanged since R3.53 (file counts, sizes, addenda subfolder topology, integrated-vs-active separation, and OPA placement-irregularity backlog all stable from R3.53 snapshot). Operations-state ledgers captured for delta tracking only: 3 S-series files updated post-R3.53 within +43m window — S-DRIFT_LOG.md (+9m), S-OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (+27m), S-RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (+43m). No structural drift detected; no addenda/proposal additions; no integrated-vs-active status changes; no placement irregularities introduced or resolved. R3.53→R3.54 represents the lightest possible alias bump — versioning continuity preserved for downstream consumers without injecting false drift signal. Standard alias+snapshot pair MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md / MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.54.md written this firing; prior R3.53 versioned snapshot moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.53.md`.
**(Prior R3.53 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-19 ~10:14 UTC (~03:14 local) — R3.53 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW files** since R3.52 alias write at 2026-05-18 23:08 UTC, ~11h earlier. Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-19. This is the first R3.x firing today after yesterday's three-bump trail (R3.50 + R3.51 + R3.52). **Filesystem scan since R3.52:** five files newer than R3.52 alias — three NEW substantive files in two distinct categories (one new OPA placement-irregular successor + four new addenda files across two new addenda chains and three new files in the DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder + first intra-subfolder archive in that subfolder). **(1) NEW §3 row — OPA V3.15 placement-irregular successor:** `OPA_V3_15.md` (active root; mtime 2026-05-19 05:36, size 675,447 bytes; +138,064 bytes / +25.7% over V3.13 from R3.52). **V3.14 SKIPPED** — no V3.14 file observed in active folders or in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`; likely briefly-extant (created and renamed/archived within the sync window) per the established pattern observed for OPA V3.10 transit (R3.50) and DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3/V4/V5 briefly-extant (R3.50 narrative). Continues placement-irregular active-root pattern (no return to proper `Operations Docs/` location after V3.11's brief correction). **Placement-irregularity backlog extends to 6 instances** (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 implicit transit + V3.12 + V3.13 + V3.15) with V3.11 the lone correctly-placed copy. Size jump from V3.13 (537,383) → V3.15 (675,447) = +25.7% — substantial growth likely incorporating further DOC24 R3.1.1 follow-on adjudication closure rows + DOC23 Addenda B family-topology absorption rows + R3.51/R3.52 detection-window content. Full file-header inspection deferred. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. **(2) NEW §A1 row A-67 — ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1.md top-level successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 23:55, size 61,138 bytes). Natural-progression successor to A-5 `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4.md` via filename canonicalization V4 PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES → V5.1 ARCHITECTURE (analogous to V2 → V3 OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION → OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR canonicalization in DOC23 Addenda B chain). V5 briefly-extant or skipped (no V5 file observed). V5.1 is smaller than V4 (61,138 vs 80,829 bytes; ~76%) — suggests V5.1 may be a tighter rewrite that has shed older notes content or a partial spec covering a subset of V4's scope. A-5 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending human archival decision. **(3) NEW §A1 row A-68 — DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R3 successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:06, size 76,467 bytes; -1,310 bytes vs R2 / ~98%). Successor to A-34 R2 (DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R2). **NEW INTRA-SUBFOLDER ARCHIVAL EVENT (auto-detected):** new local archive `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` subfolder created (mtime 2026-05-19 03:09) and populated with three files moved from `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/` root: `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md` (= A-34 row), `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` (was tracked in SPEC_STATE Cross-Cutting/Support as `OpenClaw Release Align`), and `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 ADD REVIEW.md` (R2 variant). **First intra-subfolder archive in the DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder** — pattern analogous to `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` created in R3.47. Closes partial-resolution on the long-standing "DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder not formally listed in SKILL.md scope list" backlog item — subfolder is now actively-tracked. A-34 R2 row gets intra-subfolder-archive annotation. **(4) NEW §A1 row A-69 — DOC11 R3 Coverage Audit companion:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3_COVERAGE_AUDIT.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:07, size 3,516 bytes — very small file). Short coverage-audit companion document attached to A-68 R3 amendment proposal. Likely needs reclassification to `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / AUDIT` rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` (analogous to A-32 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1 and A-47 Integration Map V2 reclassification patterns). **(5) NEW §A1 row A-70 — OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3 successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:07, size 19,278 bytes; -11,201 bytes / -37% vs R2 30,479 bytes). R3 successor to R2 (which was tracked in SPEC_STATE Cross-Cutting/Support as `OpenClaw Release Align` row; R2 moved today to intra-subfolder archive). Significant size reduction suggests R3 may be a tighter summary or have shed content folded directly into the R3 amendment proposal. Companion to A-68 R3 amendment proposal. SPEC_STATE Cross-Cutting `OpenClaw Release Align` row updated today to reflect R2 archival. **Operations-state deltas:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md + S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md + S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md will be touched by this R3.53 sync write itself (coordinated post-write housekeeping pattern). No independent operations-state firings observed since R3.52 captured them at 2026-05-18 ~17:50 UTC. **Counts updates in R3.53:** §3 Core Specifications 51 → 52 (+1 for OPA V3.15 placeholder row); §4 Active Addenda 67 → 71 (+4 in §A1 for A-67 V5.1 + A-68 DOC11 R3 + A-69 R3 Coverage Audit + A-70 RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 68 → 72 (+4); §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 22 → 23 (+1 for OPA V3.15); §11 Core registry total 52 → 53 (+1); §11 Grand total 136 → 141 (+5). **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.52 versioned file moved from active root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.52.md` per standard bump procedure; R3.53 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.53 alias + R3.53 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-nine cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.53); `mountpoint -q` pre-flight remains highest-urgency given S-11 confirmed-failure pattern at tenth-strike + ten-calendar-day cloud-recoverability gap. **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended this cycle** — substantive R3.53 entry documenting five NEW files. **Carryover prompt bumped V19 → V20** — five new files including a major subfolder reorganization warrant the carryover refresh. V20 captures: (a) OPA V3.13 → V3.15 placement-irregular continuation with V3.14 skip; (b) ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 filename canonicalization (Architecture-elevation pattern); (c) DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R2 → R3 supersession + first intra-subfolder archive in DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder; (d) OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST R2 → R3 supersession. **All R3.52 carry-forward items preserved unchanged** except those partially resolved by today's drift: A-34 DOC11 R15 R2 newly intra-subfolder-archived (was carry-forward "still in active folder pending archival" since R3.43); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 duplicate-copy informational anomaly RESOLVED via intra-subfolder archive move; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder formal scope inclusion partially resolved by intra-subfolder-archive creation + active-row registration. **Tracker numbering divergence:** ADDENDA_STATE uses A-66/A-67/A-68/A-69 for the four new top-level rows; master spec list §4 uses A-67/A-68/A-69/A-70 — extends cumulative divergence-by-one pattern to SEVEN+ NEW-row cycles.

**(Prior R3.52 last-updated header preserved for traceability):** 2026-05-18 ~17:50 UTC (~10:50 local) — R3.52 sync run was a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **3 NEW files** since R3.51 alias write at 2026-05-18 ~11:00 UTC (~04:00 local), ~6.8h earlier. Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-18. This is the THIRD R3.x firing today (R3.50 daily morning substantive + R3.51 same-day SECOND operations-state-only + R3.52 same-day THIRD substantive structural drift). **Filesystem scan since R3.51:** five files newer than R3.51 alias — three NEW substantive files (OPA V3.13 + DOC23 ADDB V3.3 + DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1) + two operations-state firings (S-10 + S-11). **(1) NEW §3 row 44g — OPA V3.13 placement-irregular successor:** `OPA_V3_13.md` (active root; mtime 2026-05-18 10:42, size 537,383 bytes; +9,897 bytes over V3.12 from R3.50). Continues V3.12 placement-irregular active-root pattern (no return to proper Operations Docs/ location after the brief V3.11 correction). Placement-irregularity backlog now extends to **5 instances** (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 implicit + V3.12 + V3.13) with V3.11 as the lone correctly-placed copy. Successor to V3.12. Full file-header inspection deferred. Human classification + path canonicalization needed; placement-pattern-alternation theory (R3.50) downgraded — V3.13 is the third consecutive placement-irregular file in the V3.12/V3.13 sequence, suggesting Will-side workflow preference for active-root visibility is dominating. **(2) NEW §A6 row A-67 — DOC23 Addenda B Addendum Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3.3 sub-sub-folder successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18, size 474,162 bytes; +12,914 bytes over V3.2 from R3.49). Successor in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain — chain progression now V2 → V3 → V3.1 → V3.2 → V3.3 (predecessors A-55 V2 archived per R3.39; A-57 V3 + A-59 V3.1 archived in R3.49 to `Archived DOC23 addenda/`; A-60 V3.2 archived in R3.49 to same archive subfolder; V3.3 is the first revision since the R3.49 sub-sub-folder family-topology decomposition). First successor file materializing in the sub-sub-folder `doc23 add b rework/` since R3.49 introduced that pattern. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual pass; expected content per V3.2's "Pending red-team review per §25" status — V3.3 likely incorporates red-team findings or further architectural refinement. **(3) NEW §A6 row A-68 — DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 sub-sub-folder revision:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18, size 52,068 bytes; +5,490 bytes over V1 from R3.49). First revision to A-65 Common Contracts V1 introduced as part of R3.49 family-topology decomposition. V1.1 successor pattern (semantic-version increment rather than V2 step). Note: there's also a "(1)" duplicate in `Archived DOC23 addenda/` with same mtime/size — Downloads-copy artifact, pending human canonicalization. Same-mtime co-arrival with V3.3 Addendum (both 10:18:30 and 10:18:46, 16s apart) suggests coordinated edit pass — V3.3 architectural refinement likely drove Common Contracts V1.1 schema revision. **Operations-state mtime/size deltas (late-coordinated post-R3.51 — attributed to R3.51):** `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` 04:13:40 local (+05m19s post-R3.51 — late-coordinated R3.51 post-write housekeeping; first time S-10 has fired in same window since R3.50 substantive-drift S-3/S-4/S-5 sequence). **Operations-state mtime/size deltas (independent post-R3.51 firings):** `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md` 04:17:10 local (+08m49s post-R3.51) — **INDEPENDENT S-11 FIRING WITH FAILURE PROOF, RECHARACTERIZES R3.51's "ninth-day silence"**: S-11 fired with tenth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF + DEFENSIVE-PRE-CHECK-APPLIED (second consecutive observed run with defensive pre-check). BACKUP_LOG content confirms ninth consecutive failure (5/10, 5/11, 5/12, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15, 5/16, 5/17, 5/18) — `mountpoint /sessions/busy-optimistic-dijkstra/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned "No such file or directory"; `/proc/mounts` confirms `OpenClaw-Shared` absent. Source corpus has grown 22→27 MB in 24 hours per BACKUP_LOG narrative — backup gap more significant each day. Last claimed-successful tarball remains 2026-05-09. Will action items unchanged from 5/17: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button (pending nine consecutive runs); (2) independently verify host folder contents; (3) harden task script with `mountpoint -q` pre-flight (pending after five runs of recommending it). **Silences confirmed:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md, S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md all preserved at R3.51-window mtimes (no further firings between R3.51 and R3.52). **Counts updates in R3.52:** §3 Core Specifications 50 → 51 (+1 for OPA V3.13 placeholder row 44g); §4 Active Addenda 65 → 67 (+2 in §A6 for A-67 V3.3 + A-68 Common Contracts V1.1); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 66 → 68 (+2 net for A-67 + A-68); §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 21 → 22 (+1 for OPA V3.13); §11 Core registry total 51 → 52 (+1); §11 Grand total 133 → 136 (+3). **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.51 versioned file moved from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.51.md` per standard bump procedure; R3.52 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.52.md`. Active folder retains R3.52 alias + R3.52 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-eight cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.52); `mountpoint -q` pre-flight remains highest-urgency given S-11 confirmed-failure pattern at tenth-strike; five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog + sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement (R3.49) + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder INCLUDE-list decision all unresolved. **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended this cycle** — substantive R3.52 entry documenting three NEW files (OPA V3.13 + DOC23 ADDB V3.3 + DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1) + R3.51 → R3.52 same-day THIRD firing pattern + S-11 tenth-strike with bind-mount proof + defensive-pre-check. **Carryover prompt bumped V19 → V20** — three new files + R3.51 → R3.52 substantive drift + S-11 firing-with-proof recharacterization warrant the carryover refresh. V20 captures: (a) OPA V3.12 → V3.13 placement-irregular continuation; (b) DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.2 → V3.3 sub-sub-folder chain advance (first since R3.49 family decomposition); (c) Common Contracts V1 → V1.1 first revision; (d) S-11 silence-mode end + tenth-strike with-proof recharacterization. **All R3.51 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending human archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities unchanged; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + A-59 V3.1 + A-60 V3.2 + A-61 R0.7 + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 + A-65 Common Contracts V1 + A-66 R4.1 V6 + **A-67 V3.3 NEW** + **A-68 Common Contracts V1.1 NEW** all still ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT + R4.1 V6 (1) + Common Contracts V1.1 (1) duplicates all await deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 extends to nine-row cumulative pattern (A-68 master = A-66 ADDENDA_STATE pending today's S-4 sync); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~488+ hours / 24-day cadence lag**; DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch + OPA V3.9 patch session + OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 + OPA V3.13 + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1/V3.2/V3.3 successor + DOC23 Addenda B family decomposition (R3.47 + R3.49 + R3.52 first-successor) + DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 V6 chain advance (R3.50) all carry forward unchanged in R3.52.

**Generated (R3.51 — preserved):** 2026-05-18 (local — autonomous nightly sync ran same-day SECOND-firing **operations-state-only bump** after R3.50 (which completed 2026-05-18 ~10:17 UTC / ~03:17 local, ~45min earlier). Zero new spec or addenda files in any active scan folder since R3.50 alias write; four operations-state firings captured in the ~25-min post-R3.50 window — S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (+17m05s), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (+18m12s), S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (+24m04s) attributable as late-coordinated R3.50 post-write housekeeping for the substantive R3.50 structural drift (3 NEW files: OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 + A-66 R4.1 V6), plus S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (+22m05s) classified as independent post-R3.50 firing at canonical morning OpenClaw-alignment cadence ~03:39-03:46 local. S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG / S-11 BACKUP_LOG silent this firing — **R3.52 RECHARACTERIZES R3.51 SILENCE**: S-10 fired at 04:13:40 (+05m19s post-R3.51 alias write) + S-11 fired at 04:17:10 (+08m49s post-R3.51 alias write) — these firings occurred AFTER R3.51 alias write so were not visible to R3.51 narrative; R3.52 attributes S-10 as late-coordinated R3.51 post-write housekeeping and S-11 as independent post-R3.51 firing with bind-mount-failure proof, ending the "ninth-day silence" characterization. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.50 versioned file from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure (R3.50 archive landing executed this run). Active folder now retains R3.51 alias + R3.51 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)

**Generated (R3.50 — preserved):** 2026-05-18 (local — autonomous nightly sync ran daily firing capturing **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** since R3.49 (which completed 2026-05-17 ~23:10 UTC, ~12h earlier). Three NEW files detected: (1) OPA_V3_11.md materialized in `Operations Docs/` (mtime 2026-05-17 23:45, size 509,424 bytes — operations file in proper Operations Docs/ location, ending the placement-irregularity pattern of V3.8/V3.9 active-root copies); (2) OPA_V3_12.md materialized in active root (mtime 2026-05-18 07:05, size 527,486 bytes — successor to V3.11 from this morning; reverts to placement-irregular active-root copy pattern); (3) DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md materialized in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/` root (mtime 2026-05-18 06:05, size 405,498 bytes — V6 successor in DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 chain; chain progression V2 → V3 → V4 → V5 → V6 — V2 was last tracked as A-47 in R3.12). One implicit OPA V3.10 transit observed (V3.10 now in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` — appeared and was archived between R3.49 and this run; never given an active-tracker row, but is part of the V3.9 → V3.10 → V3.11 → V3.12 sequence). Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.48 versioned file to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (was leftover from R3.49 sync per its own narrative "R3.48 versioned file preserved unchanged in active folder pending audit-cleanup move to Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/ (next sync)" — today's run executes that pending move). DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder remains out of scope per task SKILL.md INCLUDE list. **Phantom V19 from R3.49 anomaly:** R3.49 narrative claimed V18 → V19 carryover bump but V19 file was never materialized in `Prompts/` (V18 dated 2026-05-17 10:14 remains the only most-recent file). Today's sync materializes V19 since structural drift today + the R3.49 backlog of drift both warrant a fresh carryover. Same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41/R3.45 phantom-bump precedents.)
**Last Updated (R3.50 — preserved):** 2026-05-18 ~10:13 UTC (~03:13 local) — R3.50 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **3 NEW files** since R3.49 alias write at 2026-05-17 23:10 UTC. **Filesystem scan results:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.49.md` returned three primary file hits across in-scope folders plus the implicit OPA V3.10 archival transit (V3.10 inferred from presence in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`; appeared and was archived between R3.49 alias write and this run). **(1) NEW §3 row 44e — OPA V3.11 in proper Operations Docs/ location:** `Operations Docs/OPA_V3_11.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 23:45, size 509,424 bytes). FIRST OPA version since V3.7 to live in proper Operations Docs/ location ending the placement-irregularity pattern of V3.8 and V3.9 (both lived in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root with `DOC73 R1.6 Build/` working-folder lineage per file headers). V3.11 size +71,278 bytes over V3.9 (438,146 → 509,424) suggests substantial expansion — likely additional DOC24 R3.1.1 follow-on adjudication closure rows or DOC23 Addenda B family-topology absorption rows. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. Successor to OPA V3.9 (active root) and the transit OPA V3.10 (now archived). **(2) NEW §3 row 44f — OPA V3.12 placement-irregular successor:** `OPA_V3_12.md` (active root; mtime 2026-05-18 07:05, size 527,486 bytes — +18,062 bytes over V3.11). Reverts to placement-irregular active-root copy pattern (V3.11 was the brief exception in proper Operations Docs/ location; V3.12 returns to V3.8/V3.9 active-root pattern). Successor to V3.11. Pattern alternation between proper-location and placement-irregular may suggest Will-side workflow tension between "tidy archival in Operations Docs/" vs "visibility-priority active-root copy." Human classification + path canonicalization needed; placement-irregularity backlog now stretches across V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12 (4 placement-irregular instances) with V3.11 the lone correctly-placed copy. **(3) NEW §A6 row A-66 — DOC23 Addenda A Task Optimization R4.1 V6 successor:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-18 06:05, size 405,498 bytes). Filename has "(1)" suffix suggesting Will copied from another location (Downloads pattern observed in DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card and DOC23 REPROMPT duplicates). V6 successor to V5/V4/V3 (none formally tracked — A-47 R4.1 V2 from R3.12 is the last formally-tracked file in this A-track chain; chain advanced V2 → V3 → V4 → V5 → V6 with intermediate revisions never materialized at sync windows). Per coordination V3 FINAL outputs noted in R3.49 (A-65 Common Contracts V1 lists "DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3" as consumer), the A-track has been at V3 since coordination V3 work. V6 likely incorporates coordination V3 FINAL outputs + further audit closure passes. Size 405,498 bytes ≈ 2.6× A-47 V2 size of 154,930 bytes — substantial growth. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. **Implicit OPA V3.10 archival transit:** `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/OPA_V3_10.md` appeared between R3.49 alias write and this run; V3.10 was never given an active-tracker row (analogous to brief-extant R4.1 V1 / Deferral List V1 pattern from R3.12 — created and archived within a single sync window). Audit pass records the transit but does not create or remove rows since V3.10 was never tracked. Per established convention with brief-extant files: optionally add post-hoc archived row in next manual sweep for completeness, or accept the gap. **Operations-state file deltas since R3.49:** SPEC_STATE.md, ADDENDA_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md preserved at R3.49 mtimes pending this run's coordinated post-write touches. S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md, S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtimes carried forward from R3.49 capture (no new firings observed). **Counts updates in R3.50:** §3 Core Specifications 48 → 50 (+2 in §3 for OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 placeholder rows; was 48 from R3.47-R3.49); §4 Active Addenda 64 → 65 (+1 in §A6 for A-66 R4.1 V6); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 65 → 66 (+1 net for A-66); §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 19 → 21 (+2 for OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12); §11 Core registry total (rows 1–43 + placeholders) 49 → 51 (+2); §11 Grand total 130 → 133 (+3). **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.48 versioned file moved from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (was leftover from R3.49 sync per its own deferred-archival narrative — today executes the move); R3.49 versioned file also moved to archive per standard bump procedure; R3.50 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.50 + alias only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant restored). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt bumped V18 → V19** — three new files + R3.49 backlog of structural drift (sub-sub-folder pattern, family-topology reorganization, six new addenda rows) warrant the carryover refresh that R3.49 narrative claimed but never materialized; V19 captures: (a) the R3.49 sub-sub-folder + family-topology decomposition; (b) DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 V6 advance; (c) OPA V3.11 → V3.12 placement-pattern alternation; (d) implicit V3.10 archival transit. **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended this cycle** — three NEW files + the R3.48 audit-cleanup-deferral resolution + V19 phantom-materialization makes today's run substantive structural drift even though the R3.49 → R3.50 delta is smaller than R3.48 → R3.49's six-row addition. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-six cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.50); five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog + new sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement from R3.49 both unresolved. **All R3.49 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + A-59 V3.1 + A-60 V3.2 + A-61 R0.7 + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 + A-65 Common Contracts V1 + **A-66 R4.1 V6 NEW** all still ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate + R4.1 V6 (1) duplicate both await deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 preserved verbatim (now extends to seven-row cumulative divergence pattern: A-66 master = A-65 ADDENDA_STATE); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~456+ hours / 23-day cadence lag**; DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch + OPA V3.9 patch session + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1 successor + DOC23 Addenda B family decomposition (R3.47 + R3.49) all carry forward unchanged in R3.50.

**Generated (R3.49 — preserved):** 2026-05-17 (local — autonomous nightly sync ran same-day THIRD-firing **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** after R3.48 (which completed 2026-05-17 ~11:04 UTC / ~04:04 local, ~12h earlier). Largest single-cycle structural drift since R3.13's first DOC23 Addenda B entry: **7 NEW addendum files** in DOC23 Addenda subfolder split across the root (1 file — V3.2 successor to V3.1) and a brand-new sub-sub-folder `doc23 add b rework/` (6 .md files + 1 files.zip — Core R0.7 supersedes R0.6.4 via family-topology reorganization; 3 subsystem sub-addenda for Feedback Delivery V1, Source Workspace V1, Task Forum + Run Board V1 absorbing R0.6.5 proposal sections; Common Contracts V1 sibling spec hosting shared evaluation primitives consumed by both Addenda A and Addenda B; duplicate copy of V3.2). First ever sub-sub-folder pattern at this depth in any tracked top-level Addenda subfolder. Represents major architectural decomposition of DOC23 Addenda B work from singular unified draft into Core + V3.2 Addendum + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts family topology. Plus one independent post-R3.48 S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing — eighth consecutive failure but **FIRST WITH DEFENSIVE PRE-CHECK** applied this run (no sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/` scaffolding created; no bogus tarball written-then-deleted unlike 5/15+5/16). Ends two-consecutive-day silence (5/15-5/16 silent). S-9/S-8/S-10 silent today.)
**Last Updated (R3.49 — preserved):** 2026-05-17 ~23:10 UTC (~16:10 local) — R3.49 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **7 NEW addendum files in a brand-new sub-sub-folder pattern** since R3.48 (which completed 2026-05-17 ~11:04 UTC, ~12h earlier). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-17. **Filesystem scan since R3.48:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.48.md` returned **eight file hits** — seven NEW addendum files plus one S-11 operations-state file firing. **(1) NEW §A6 row A-60 — DOC23 Addenda B Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3.2 supersession of V3.1:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 15:14:43 local = 22:14:43 UTC, size 461,248 bytes — ~5.5% larger than V3.1's 437,051 bytes). Per V3.2 file header: `Status: V3.2 specification (surgical patch over V3.1 incorporating Addenda A/B coordination V3 FINAL outputs)`; `Version: 3.2`; `Prepared: 2026-05-15 (V3); revised 2026-05-16 (V3.1 audit-complete); revised 2026-05-17 (V3.2 coordination patch)` — V3.2 is the post-coordination surgical patch incorporating the Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs (companion to A-65 Common Contracts V1 + A-61 R0.7 Core). DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain extends: V1 (= A-54) → V2 (= A-55, intra-subfolder archived R3.47) → V3 (= A-57, intra-subfolder archived R3.47) → V3.1 (= A-59, ACTIVE pending archival per V3.2 supersession) → **V3.2 (= A-60, NEW)**. **(2-6) NEW sub-sub-folder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/`** (folder mtime 2026-05-17 15:53). **First ever sub-sub-folder at this depth in any tracked top-level Addenda subfolder** — distinct from intra-subfolder archive pattern (`Archived DOC23 addenda/` introduced in R3.15) and distinct from the top-level Addenda subfolder pattern (DOC20/DOC23/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj + Connectors and Integrations Addenda + DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs). Contains 6 NEW .md files + 1 files.zip packaging file. The set represents **major architectural decomposition** of DOC23 Addenda B work into family topology: **Core R0.7 + V3.2 Addendum (duplicate of A-60) + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts sibling spec**. **(2) NEW §A6 row A-61 — DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 supersession of R0.6.4:** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_CORE_R0_7.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:46 local, size 370,034 bytes). Per file header: `Revision: R0.7 Core — supersedes R0.6.4; family-topology reorganization plus Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL absorption`; `Status: Build-ready Core specification. R0.7 is the family-core for Addenda B's Task Design domain. Outcome Evaluator/Revisor lives in the V3.2 sub-addendum. Source Workspace, Task Forum + Run Board, and Feedback Delivery live in their own sub-addenda. Shared evaluation primitives live in DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts (sibling to the parent doc).` **R0.7 explicitly supersedes A-53 R0.6.4** via four classes of changes (per R0.7 substantive change log): Class 1 family-topology reorganization (R0.6.4 was singular Addenda B document; R0.7 retains Task Design domain core but excludes Outcome Evaluator/Revisor, Source Workspace, Task Forum + Run Board, Feedback Delivery content — those live in sibling sub-addenda); Class 2 R0.6.5 base material absorption (R0.6.5 §§1-4 absorbed into Core §2 governing principles and §3A object taxonomy; R0.6.5 §§5-7 superseded by V3.2 — referenced not duplicated; R0.6.5 §§8-15, §§16-18, §§19-22 distributed to Feedback Delivery V1, Source Workspace V1, Task Forum + Run Board V1 respectively; R0.6.5 retires when sub-addenda land); Class 3 Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL integration (§9 Task Design Learning extended with eight Phase 1 learning signals wrapped in `EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope` per coordination V3 §2.7/§2.11; §13/§13A DOC24 capability binding extended with `model_class` context for cheap-LLM learning mode; §17 Prompt evaluation updated to consume shared `EvaluationResultEnvelope` and integrate Pattern C ad-hoc Judge attachment; §24 cross-doc obligations extended with 14 new V3 FINAL coordination OP-A rows; new §0B "Shared evaluation infrastructure" cross-references Common Contracts schemas and V3.2 module surfaces); Class 4 several R0.6.4 §26 open questions resolved by V3 FINAL coordination outputs. **(3) NEW §A6 row A-62 — DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum Feedback Delivery V1:** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_FEEDBACK_DELIVERY_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:53 local, size 38,711 bytes). Per file header: `Document type: Topical sub-addendum to DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7`; `Subject: Specification for in-run feedback delivery from evaluators (V3.2 Outcome Evaluator, Addenda A Judge, agent review gates) to downstream consumers (modules, sub-agents, Task Agent, user). Defines the EvaluationFeedbackBundle, defeasible findings, Run Guidance, Repair Instructions, Feedback Routing Policy, four delivery channels, and Feedback Consumption Receipts`; `Status: V1 — initial draft incorporating R0.6.5 proposal §§8-15, integrated with V3.2 Outcome Evaluator+Revisor §14 (post-run learning signals) and Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs`. **(4) NEW §A6 row A-63 — DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum Source Workspace V1:** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:50 local, size 33,326 bytes). Per file header: `Topical sub-addendum to DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7`; `Subject: Specification for the Task Source Workspace, the Source Research / Source Gathering module, and the user-facing Source Workspace UI. Defines the shared source/reference/research substrate that task runs use when modules need to find, verify, retrieve, or update sources`; `Status: V1 — initial draft incorporating R0.6.5 proposal §§16-18 + §28, integrated with V3.2 §12 narrow workspace coverage and Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs`. **(5) NEW §A6 row A-64 — DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum Task Forum + Run Board V1:** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_TASK_FORUM_RUN_BOARD_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:56 local, size 36,139 bytes). Per file header: `Topical sub-addendum to DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7`; `Subject: Specification for the passive Task Run Board, the active Task Forum module (system.task_forum), Module Assistance Requests, Board Digests, TaskRunContextPacket, moderator modes, and the user-facing Forum/Board UI surfaces`; `Status: V1 — initial draft incorporating R0.6.5 proposal §§19-22, §27, §31, integrated with V3.2 §14.9 plan review forum and Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs`. **(6) NEW §A6 row A-65 — DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts V1 (sibling spec to DOC23 R3.1):** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:42 local, size 46,578 bytes). Per file header: `Document type: Sibling specification to DOC23 R3.1 hosting shared evaluation primitives until DOC23 R3.2 absorbs them`; `Status: V1 — initial draft incorporating Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL converged architecture`; `Version: 1.0`; `Prepared: 2026-05-17`; `Lifecycle: Active until DOC23 R3.2 compilation pass absorbs the contracts into the parent doc; then this document retires per §11 migration guide`; `Owner: Joint between Addenda A chat and Addenda B chat per coordination V3 §3.2; conflicts adjudicated by Will`. **Consumers per file header:** DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3 (Judge, Experiment, Claim Extractor) consumes shared envelope + slice schemas + Criterion + ArtifactScopeRef; DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 consumes shared envelope + signal envelope + Criterion + ArtifactScopeRef; DOC23 Addenda B subsystem addenda (V3.2 Outcome Evaluator/Revisor; Source Workspace V1; Task Forum V1; Feedback Delivery V1) reference shared primitives; PropA R6.3+ consumes ArtifactScopeRef + TextAnchor + StructuredAnchor; DOC72 consumes Pattern-related context types; DOC8/BDSM consumes EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope as unified signal stream; EC Core gates envelope governance fields (data_class, matter_id, pattern_promotion_eligible); DOC20 renders envelope + signals + criteria in UI surfaces. **Per file §0.1 rationale:** "Hosting these primitives in one of the addenda would create fragile cross-addendum references and bury shared types inside one addendum's narrative. Per coordination V3 §3.2, the resolution is a sibling document hosting these primitives. Both addenda reference this document. When DOC23 R3.2 compiles, the primitives migrate to the parent doc and this document retires (§11)." **Duplicate file in sub-sub-folder:** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_2.md` (mtime 15:53:07 local, size 461,248 bytes — **byte-identical to the root V3.2 file = A-60 row**); auto pass treats as duplicate of A-60 and does not create separate row. Additionally a `files.zip` (160,315 bytes) packages the rework set — likely the export bundle from the authoring environment, not tracked as separate row. **Operations-state delta:** **S-11 `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md`** advanced to 2026-05-17 04:17:30 local = 11:17:30 UTC, size 34,099 bytes (+4,080 bytes from R3.46 capture 30,019 bytes; +13m26s post-R3.48 alias write at 04:04 local — clearly outside coordinated post-write window, classified as independent post-R3.48 firing). Per 2026-05-17 11:16 UTC log entry: **EIGHTH consecutive failure but FIRST WITH DEFENSIVE PRE-CHECK** applied this run — directory-existence check performed BEFORE the `mkdir -p` step prevented sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/` scaffolding from being created (no bogus tarball written and then deleted, unlike 5/15 and 5/16). Workspace state at end of run matches what was visible at session start. Ends two-consecutive-day silence (5/15-5/16 silent) by returning to firing, but is the **eighth-consecutive failure** overall since 2026-05-09 last claimed success. Bind-mount verification: `mountpoint /sessions/nice-zen-shannon/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned `No such file or directory`; `mountpoint /sessions/nice-zen-shannon/mnt/ECQ Development` returned `is a mountpoint`. Will-side three-pronged action from R3.42/R3.43/R3.47/R3.48 remains the priority: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button (eight consecutive runs pending); (2) independently verify on host whether prior tarballs accumulated; (3) implement `mountpoint -q` pre-flight in S-11 task SKILL.md (now manually applied this run as a defensive pattern — not yet automated in SKILL.md). **No other independent firings:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md, S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md all preserved from R3.48 capture (no firings between R3.48 alias write at 04:04 local and R3.49 sync at 16:10 local). **Counts:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 59 → 65 (+6 net: A-60 V3.2 NEW + A-61 R0.7 Core NEW + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW + A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW + A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW; A-59 V3.1 retained ACTIVE pending archival per V3.2 supersession; A-53 R0.6.4 retained ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 Core supersession; A-65 Common Contracts row counted as PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholder pending human reclassification as SUPPORT / SIBLING SPEC since it's a sibling-spec to DOC23 R3.1 rather than a proposal addendum); §4 Active Addenda 58 → 64; §A6 active rows 12 → 18 (+6 for A-60 + A-61 + A-62 + A-63 + A-64 + A-65); Grand total 124 → 130. **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.48 versioned file preserved unchanged in active folder pending audit-cleanup move to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (next sync); R3.49 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.49.md`. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt bumped V18 → V19** — 6 new addendum files in a brand-new sub-sub-folder pattern representing major architectural decomposition is the largest single-revision structural drift since R3.13's first DOC23 Addenda B entry, warranting carryover refresh; V19 captures: (a) the new sub-sub-folder traversal convention for DOC23 Addenda subfolder + (b) the family-topology reorganization model (Core + Addendum + sub-addenda + sibling Common Contracts) + (c) the explicit R0.6.4 → R0.7 supersession + (d) the V3.1 → V3.2 surgical-patch supersession. **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended this cycle** — major architectural decomposition (DOC23 Addenda B singular unified draft → Core + V3.2 + 3 sub-addenda + Common Contracts family) + first ever sub-sub-folder pattern at this depth + 6 NEW addendum files in one window = substantive structural drift event of largest scale in this scheduled task's history. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-five cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.49); the five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog now extends to include the new sub-sub-folder pattern requiring a new SKILL.md scope refinement (sub-sub-folder traversal mode for DOC23 Addenda subfolder + decision whether the rework subfolder is staging-area (will collapse upward when files land in parent DOC23 Addenda root) or permanent organizational pattern (warrants own §A8 section in future)). **All R3.48 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five-subfolders backlog + NEW sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + A-59 V3.1 + **A-60 V3.2 NEW + A-61 R0.7 NEW + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW + A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW + A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW** all still ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 preserved verbatim (now extends to seven-row cumulative divergence pattern after R3.49 adds six new rows); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~432+ hours / 22-day cadence lag**; DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch + OPA V3.9 patch session + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1 successor (all new in R3.47) + R3.48 carry-forward items all unchanged in R3.49 follow-up.

**Generated (R3.48 — preserved):** 2026-05-17 (local — autonomous nightly sync ran same-day FOLLOW-UP firing after R3.47 (which completed 2026-05-17 ~10:11 UTC / ~03:11 local, ~53min earlier). Operations-state-only bump: zero new spec or addenda files in any active scan folder; exactly one independent post-R3.47 operations-state firing captured — S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md at 2026-05-17 03:46:24 local = 10:46:24 UTC, +35min13s after R3.47 alias write; three coordinated post-R3.47 touches (S-3 SPEC_STATE.md +85s, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md +85s, S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md +4m48s) attributed to R3.47 per established pattern; S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md silent (mtime preserved at 2026-05-16 04:18:03 — eighth consecutive calendar day with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success); §11 totals, §A6 and §A7 row counts all unchanged from R3.47.)
**Last Updated (R3.48 — preserved):** 2026-05-17 ~11:04 UTC (~04:04 local) — R3.48 sync run is an **operations-state-only bump** capturing exactly **one independent post-R3.47 scheduled-task firing** since R3.47 (which completed 2026-05-17 ~10:11 UTC ~53min earlier). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-17. **Filesystem scan results:** no NEW spec files in any active spec folder (core specs root, DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/, Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ with all listed subfolders); no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations; no §A6/§A7/§A7-multi-parent supersession-chain advances; no Integrated-Addenda relocations; no Subsumed Specs/ relocations. **Operations-state file deltas since R3.47:** (coordinated post-R3.47 touches, attributed to R3.47 per established R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40/R3.42/R3.45 attribution pattern) `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 03:12:54 local = 10:12:54 UTC, size 79,730 bytes — +85s after R3.47 alias write at 03:11:11); `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 03:12:54 local, size 77,643 bytes — +85s); `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-17 03:15:59 local = 10:15:59 UTC, size 206,442 bytes — +4m48s; this is R3.47's coordinated DRIFT_LOG append for the SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT R3.47 event). (independent post-R3.47 firing, R3.48's actual delta) **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-17 03:46:24 local = 10:46:24 UTC, size 84,689 bytes; entry-header firing time 2026-05-17 10:44 UTC; +35min13s post-R3.47 alias write). No other firings — S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-16 04:03:04 (no firing today; preserved from R3.45 capture); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-16 04:09:03 (no firing today; preserved from R3.46 capture); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-16 04:18:03 (no firing today; preserved from R3.46 capture — second consecutive day of BACKUP_LOG SILENCE rather than failure-with-proof, eighth consecutive calendar day with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success). **S-9 narrative (per OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 10:44 UTC entry):** Latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14 18:28 UTC) for **third consecutive quiet stable day** since the 5/14 cut ended the 7-day stable pause (5.12 now T+3 days old). Gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7, 2026.5.12). Single-release roll-forwards now lagged **twenty-one consecutive days** (was 20 in R3.45 capture; +1 each day). **Beta-channel news:** yesterday's tracked `v2026.5.14-beta.2` (2026-05-15 11:11 UTC) appears ABANDONED — the beta dist-tag has rolled forward to NEW `v2026.5.16-beta.1` and NEW `v2026.5.16-beta.3` prerelease tags (latter published ~today; adds xAI Grok OAuth login for SuperGrok subscribers + tool-contract / collaboration-mode / runtime-reliability hardening per WebSearch snippet; details not yet inspected line-by-line). The yesterday-tracked 24-72h watch for 5.14-beta.2 → stable v2026.5.13 / v2026.5.14 did NOT materialize; the beta lineage instead jumped 5.14-beta.2 → 5.16-beta.1 → 5.16-beta.3, suggesting the next stable cut will be substantively larger (folding two beta lineages) rather than a 5.13 roll-forward patch. Issue #82069 (v2026.5.14-beta.1 Codex OAuth refresh `401 token_expired` regression report) carry-forward from R3.45. **S-11 narrative:** BACKUP_LOG.md unchanged for second consecutive day (silent rather than failure-with-proof). Eighth consecutive calendar day with no confirmed cloud backup since `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` from 2026-05-09. Will-side three-pronged action from R3.42/R3.43 remains the priority. **No spec / addenda churn in this 53-minute window**: no new spec files; no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations. §11 grand total unchanged at 124 (per R3.47 count); §7 row count unchanged at 12; PROPOSED ADDENDUM count unchanged at 59; §A6 active rows unchanged at 12; §A7 active rows unchanged at 2. Per established pattern, §7 row narratives are NOT individually rewritten in this bump — the S-9 mtime/size advance is captured in narrative form in this Last Updated block and in the §12 R3.48 changelog entry. **Carryover prompt remains V17** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V18 bump (same-day operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended this cycle** — S-9 twenty-one-day cadence-lag milestone + beta dist-tag jump from 5.14-beta.2 → 5.16-beta.1/5.16-beta.3 abandoning yesterday's 5.14-beta.2 watch row is narrative-significant. **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.47 versioned snapshot already present at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.47.md` (mtime 03:11:11 local) — preserved unchanged in active folder per the transient at-most-one-versioned-file invariant; R3.48 versioned snapshot `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.48.md` will be saved alongside this alias write. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-four cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.48). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.47 list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj + DOC73 Addenda and Proposals subfolders formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md (five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog); (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window — R3.48 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about S-9 firing that has already occurred, and explicit "no firing today" past-tense framing for S-8/S-10/S-11 silences); (7) `mountpoint -q` pre-flight check before `mkdir -p` in S-11 BACKUP_LOG task — un-implemented as of R3.48; today's second consecutive S-11 silence keeps this as the highest-urgency tightening item. **All R3.47 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog (DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE, DOC23 Addenda, EC Core Addenda, Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj, DOC73 Addenda and Proposals); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + A-59 V3.1 in §A6 + A-56 R0.1 in §A7 all still ACTIVE pending human archival decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 preserved verbatim; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~360+ hours / 21-day cadence lag**; DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch + OPA V3.9 patch session + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1 successor (all new in R3.47) carry forward unchanged in R3.48 — no follow-up human action yet observed in this 53-min window.)

**Generated (R3.47 — preserved):** 2026-05-17 (local — autonomous nightly sync detected SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL DRIFT since R3.46; three new files in active scope: DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch in core specs root, OPA V3.9 patch session in core specs root, DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1 successor in §A6; one file relocated to Subsumed Specs (DOC24_R3_1_CONSOLIDATED.md was a transient R3.1 intermediate before R3.1.1 patch); intra-subfolder archival event in DOC23 Addenda subfolder relocated V3 + V2 + older predecessor files to local Archived DOC23 addenda subfolder.)
**Last Updated (R3.47 — preserved):** 2026-05-17 ~10:08 UTC (~03:08 local) — R3.47 sync run is a **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing three new files since R3.46 (which completed 2026-05-16 ~11:30 UTC, ~22.5h earlier). NEW core spec files in active root: (1) **DOC24_R3_1_1.md** (mtime 2026-05-17 03:58 local = 10:58 UTC, size 292,034 bytes) — R3.1.1 audit closure patch (predecessor R3.1 = `DOC24_R3_1_CONSOLIDATED.md` was moved to `Subsumed Specs/` in same 2026-05-17 03:58 window); per R3.1.1 file header: seven gaps identified in R3.1 consolidation audit closed: HH.4.10 `applyMatrixConfidenceAdjustmentSafe` body added; HH.12 `ExtractionPromptSectionId` A–I enum + `LongChunkMitigation` as new §38.19; HH.15.8 token-count write-time rule + `TokenizerDriftCheckPolicy`/`TokenizerDriftObservation`; Y.14 `WatchpointRef` discriminated union added as §5.4.1.Z; Y.15 `ObservedActionRef` added as §5.4.1.AA; Y.23 `SessionInjectionManifest` added as §5.4.1.BB with `reconciliation_event` per HH.3 event model; II.4.2 `walkPacketDecisionGraph` paste-ready body added to §38.10.1. No directional changes — all patches pure-add from V1.x canonical sources. (2) **OPA_V3_9.md** (mtime 2026-05-17 07:15 local = 14:15 UTC, size 438,146 bytes) — per file header 'OP-A V3.9 — Generated by V3.9 patch session per V4 §0.3 (DOC24 R3.1.1 V1.x adjudication closure landing)'; successor to OPA V3.8 (already in active root + DOC73 R1.6 Build/); OPA tracker continues to live in `DOC73 R1.6 Build/` working folder per its own header but active-root copy maintained for visibility (same placement-irregularity pattern as V3.8 — placement canonicalization remains pending). NEW addendum file in §A6 DOC23 Addenda: (3) **DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_1.md** (mtime 2026-05-17 03:28 local = 10:28 UTC, size 437,051 bytes — ~21% larger than V3's 360,081 bytes) — natural-progression successor to A-57 V3 in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain; filename pattern V3 → V3_1 indicates post-V3 patch/revision. SUBFOLDER REORGANIZATION DETECTED: `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` subfolder created (mtime 2026-05-17 04:15) and populated with V3 + V2 + several older predecessor files moved from DOC23 Addenda root — local intra-subfolder archival (distinct from global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archive at `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root level). V3 (= MSL A-57 / ADDENDA_STATE A-56 row) + V2 (= MSL A-55 / ADDENDA_STATE A-54 row) thus relocated to local archive; auto pass adds intra-subfolder archive annotations to those rows in ADDENDA_STATE.md. Operations-state files unchanged from R3.46 capture (no S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 firings observed since R3.46 closed).

**Generated (R3.45 — preserved):** 2026-05-16 (local — same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump after R3.44; zero spec/addenda drift in 7h+ window since R3.44 alias write; exactly two independent operations-state file firings captured (S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG at 10:43 UTC and S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY at ~11:03 UTC); S-9 logs latest-stable holds at 2026.5.12 for second consecutive quiet stable day (T+2 days old), gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10, twenty-day cadence-lag milestone reached, NEW v2026.5.14-beta.2 prerelease watch row plus #82069 Codex OAuth refresh regression carry-forward; S-11 BACKUP_LOG SILENCE today after R3.43 ninth-strike bind-mount-proof — seventh consecutive calendar day with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success)
**Last Updated (R3.45 — preserved):** 2026-05-16 ~11:10 UTC (~04:10 local) — R3.45 sync run is a **same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump** capturing exactly two independent operations-state file firings since R3.44 (which completed 2026-05-16 ~10:13 UTC, ~57min earlier). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-16. **Filesystem scan since R3.44:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.44.md` returned exactly **two operations-state file hits** as independent post-R3.44 firings, plus three operations-state file mtime ticks within ~10 minutes of R3.44's alias write that are attributable to R3.44's own coordinated post-write touches per the established R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40/R3.42 attribution pattern: **(coordinated post-R3.44 touches, attributed to R3.44)** `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 03:14:25 local = 10:14:25 UTC, size 77,145 bytes — +71s after R3.44 alias write at 03:13:14); `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 03:15:54 = 10:15:54 UTC, size 72,618 bytes — +2m40s); `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 03:19:43 = 10:19:43 UTC, size 194,752 bytes — +6m29s; this is R3.44's own DRIFT_LOG append documented in R3.44 narrative). **(independent post-R3.44 firings, R3.45's actual delta)** **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-16 03:44:22 local = 10:44:22 UTC, size 76,704 bytes; entry-header firing time 2026-05-16 10:43 UTC; +30 minutes post-R3.44 alias write); **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-16 04:03:04 local = 11:03:04 UTC, size 58,531 bytes; +50 minutes post-R3.44 alias write). No other firings — S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 04:17:55 from R3.43 capture (no firing today; SILENCE after yesterday's bind-mount-proof event); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 04:10:31 from R3.42 capture (no firing today). No new files in any active spec folder, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-5/S-7 firings since R3.44. **S-9 narrative:** OpenClaw release-tracker 2026-05-16 10:43 UTC nightly check logs latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14 18:28 UTC) for **second consecutive quiet stable day** since the 5/14 cut ended the 7-day stable pause (5.12 now T+2 days old; well within normal post-architectural-release patch-window cadence). Gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7, 2026.5.12; version-number sequence skips 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 / 2026.5.8 / 2026.5.9 / 2026.5.10 / 2026.5.11 / 2026.5.13 entirely — 5.9/5.10/5.14 exist only as betas, others not at all). Single-release roll-forwards now lagged **twenty consecutive days** (was nineteen per R3.42 5/15 capture, was seventeen per R3.40 5/14 capture; +1 each day since pause halts growth, does not narrow it). NEW beta observation in this entry: **`v2026.5.14-beta.2` prerelease tag dated 2026-05-15 11:11 UTC** (per WebSearch — additions to Channels/SDK for normalized command turn facts to channel turn construction, command-turn helpers for plugin inbound contexts, dependency refreshes, Canvas updates, UI/i18n touches, Telegram support changes, and assorted agent functionality improvements; details not yet inspected line-by-line) on the beta dist-tag, following the previously-tracked `v2026.5.14-beta.1` (2026-05-14/15 — first 5.14-beta line cut after 5.12 stable). GitHub issue **#82069** documents `v2026.5.14-beta.1` Codex OAuth refresh `401 token_expired` regression report post-#80738 fix; beta.2 ships subsequently but #82069 may reopen the Codex-route saga (closed in R3.42 as safe three-act: 5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). Beta dist-tag only — does not promote into stable alignment basis until cut on latest dist-tag. The version-number sequence continues to skip `v2026.5.13` entirely (5.12 → 5.14-beta.1 → 5.14-beta.2, no 5.13 of any form observed). Dashboard updates from this S-9 firing: `lastChecked` → '2026-05-16'; `recommendation` rewritten to reflect today's no-new-stable finding, T+2-day-old 5.12 stable, 20-day cadence lag, new v2026.5.14-beta.2 beta watch row plus open #82069 Codex OAuth refresh issue, and watch trigger for if/when 5.14-beta.2 promotes to stable; `releasesSinceLastCovered` / `latestReleaseChecked` / `latestReleaseCheckedDate` / `gapStatus` all preserved (unchanged); alignment-doc fields preserved per task constraints. Standing strong recommendation to actually start drafting DOC11 R15 R3 consolidated amendment continues to compound — R3 should fold all ten backlog releases in one consolidated pass, with Codex-route saga folded as a single closed three-act item rather than three separate rows; WATCH: if v2026.5.14-beta.2 is promoted to stable (most likely as v2026.5.13 or v2026.5.14 within next 24-72h based on 5.12 beta lineage cadence taking ~5 days), backlog jumps to 11. **S-8 narrative:** RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md refreshed at 2026-05-16 11:03 UTC capturing the §1 Section 1 NEW V3 spec + R0.2 proposal entries (5/16 NEW addendum file pair documented in R3.44), the Section 2 supersession-status updates (V2 → V3 / R0.1 → R0.2 chains), and the §"Suggested next actions" priority reshuffling that promotes DOC24 R3 → R3.1 spec compilation (gated on V1.3 Adjudication Card 5/16) and DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 architect review to the top two priority slots ahead of DOC11 R15 R3 (now demoted to #3 with 336+ hour drafting window and 20-day cadence lag noted). **S-11 narrative:** **NO BACKUP_LOG firing today** — first day in this scheduled task's history that the bind-mount-verification capability has been silent rather than failing-with-proof. BACKUP_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 04:17:55 (yesterday's R3.43 ninth-strike bind-mount-proof entry). **Seventh consecutive calendar day with no confirmed cloud backup** (last successful tarball remains `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` from 2026-05-09; intervening days 5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15 all failed or absent; today 5/16 silent). **Pattern recharacterizes from R3.43's NINTH-STRIKE six-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF to provisional TENTH-STRIKE-SILENCE seven-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-TASK-SILENCE** — caveat: task may still fire later in the day (typical firing times have been 03:00–05:00 local / 10:00–12:00 UTC; today's window has passed without a firing as of R3.45 sync time). Per task constraint #4 (no local-only fallback), even if a later firing produces a tarball, that tarball would only be confirmed real if a `mountpoint` pre-flight check passes (the SKILL.md tightening item #7 carry-forward from R3.43 remains un-implemented as of R3.45). Will-side three-pronged action from R3.42/R3.43 remains the priority: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button; (2) verify on host whether prior tarballs actually accumulated (R3.43 bind-mount proof strongly suggests 5/04–5/09 "successful" runs may not have); (3) implement `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || { log "OneDrive not bind-mounted — exiting"; exit; }` pre-flight in S-11 task SKILL.md before next firing. **No spec / addenda churn in this 57-minute window**: no new spec files in active spec folders; no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations. §11 grand total unchanged at 123; §7 row count unchanged at 12; PROPOSED ADDENDUM count unchanged at 58; §A6 active rows unchanged at 12; §A7 active rows unchanged at 2. **Per established pattern**, §7 row narratives are NOT individually rewritten in this bump — the S-9 + S-8 mtime/size advances are captured in narrative form in this Last Updated block and in the §12 R3.45 changelog entry. **Carryover prompt remains V17** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V18 bump (same-day operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). **DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — S-9 twenty-day cadence-lag milestone + new v2026.5.14-beta.2 watch row + #82069 Codex OAuth refresh issue carry-forward is narrative-significant; S-11 silence-pattern recharacterization (failure-with-proof → silence) is narrative-significant as a new sub-mode of the persistent backup failure. This is NOT a fire-only mechanical bump — narrative-significant content present. **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.44 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.45 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-one cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.45). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.44 list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj + DOC73 Addenda and Proposals subfolders formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md (five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog); (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window — R3.45 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about S-9 + S-8 firings that have already occurred, and explicit "no firing today" past-tense framing for S-11 silence); (7) **`mountpoint -q` pre-flight check** before `mkdir -p` in S-11 BACKUP_LOG task to fail-closed when OneDrive destination is not a real bind mount — promoted from R3.43 narrative to formal tightening list item; today's S-11 silence makes implementation more urgent should the task fire again. **All R3.44 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five not-formally-listed subfolders backlog); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 preserved verbatim; A-54 V1 + A-55 V2 stacked-then-superseded chain in §A6 + A-56 R0.1 in §A7 all still ACTIVE pending human archival decisions; A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 added in R3.44 carry forward unchanged in R3.45; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~336+ hours / 20-day cadence lag**; per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md §"Suggested next actions" today, DOC24 R3 → R3.1 spec compilation (gated on V1.3 Adjudication Card 5/16) and DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 architect review now occupy the top two priority slots ahead of DOC11 R15 R3.


**Generated (R3.44 — preserved):** 2026-05-16 (local — substantive structural-drift bump capturing 2 NEW addendum files since R3.43; first substantive structural drift since R3.41 on 2026-05-14 (the §A7 R0.1 detection); ends two-revision window R3.42/R3.43 of operations-state-only / fire-only bumps; restores supersession-and-replace addendum chain pattern in §A7 multi-parent track + extends supersession chain in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Outcome Evaluator/Revisor track via V3 succession of V2)
**Last Updated (R3.44 — preserved):** 2026-05-16 ~10:10 UTC (~03:10 local) — R3.44 sync run is a **substantive structural-drift bump** capturing exactly **two NEW addendum files** since R3.43 (which completed 2026-05-15 ~17:00 UTC ~17h earlier). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-16. **Filesystem scan since R3.43:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.43.md` returned exactly **two file hits** in active scan folders, both NEW addendum files (no operations-state file firings, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 ticks since R3.43 captured S-11 at 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC). **(1) NEW §A6 row A-57 — DOC23 Addenda B Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3 supersession of V2:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 02:44 UTC = 2026-05-15 19:44 local; size 360,081 bytes; 8,555 lines — **~2.7× the V2 file's 133,682 bytes**). Per V3 file header: `# DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluator and Revisor V3`; **Status:** `V3 specification`; **Version:** `3.0`; **Prepared:** `2026-05-15`. **Filename canonicalization:** V3 uses simpler base name `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR` ("Evaluator and Revisor") whereas V2 used `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION` ("Eval Revision") — shift toward more formal vocabulary. **V3 source documents (per file header):** DOC23 Task System Modular Architecture R3.1; DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization) R4.1 V2; DOC23 Addenda B (Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability) R0.6.4; **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Adjudication Card V3.1**; **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Canonicalization Patch V2** — V3 is therefore the post-adjudication revision incorporating Card V3.1 decisions + Canonicalization Patch V2 normalizations (cross-references use `[X]` format for items in the Adjudication Card V3.1 and `[P-N]` format for patches in the Canonicalization Patch V2). **V3 cross-doc dependency expansion vs V2:** explicitly enumerates 13 cross-doc dependencies in file header (DOC11 ACP, DOC12 plan review forum, DOC15 CIL authority/context packets, DOC20 UI surfaces for Evaluation/Revision Result Cards + Teach-from-feedback, DOC24 capability registry + runtime injection, DOC25 IngestionResult, DOC72 Pattern primitive + goal context, DOC73 receipt envelope + PBEOperationReceiptLite, EC Core sole durable writer + retention rows + PolicyDecision gate, BDSM/DOC8 utility learning signals, DOC23 Addenda A Judge module + Claim Extractor + prompt optimization). V2 listed companions; V3 elevates them to dependencies with specific contract ownership. **NEW V3 architectural primitives beyond V2:** `Outcome Compiler` (compiles outcome specs from natural-language input + skill graph patterns); `Revision Compiler` (compiles revision plans into dispatchable units); `Revision Dispatcher` (per-module dispatch runtime evolving V2's Revision Bus); `Candidate artifact versions` (rollback semantics with `CandidateArtifactVersion` inside SourceWorkspace as additive structure not separate primitive); `Plan assurance policy` (formal verification of revision plans before execution); `Taint and policy model` (provenance + policy gating on iterative revisions); `Pattern learning` (skill-graph integration for learned patterns becomes formal §22 spec); `Feedback pipeline` (four V2 channels become an end-to-end pipeline with FeedbackConsumptionReceipts and §24 stress-test fixtures). **V3 phasing per §0.2:** Phase 1 (this spec) covers full Evaluator/Revisor/Dispatcher pipeline, candidate versions, taint model, pattern capture, quality programs with metric denominators, sub-agent reputation scoring, dry-run mode, hardware-aware degradation, four-domain eval suite plus domain-neutral smoke set, cross-doc obligations registered in OP-A. **V3 §0.3 Canonical Naming Table** + **§0.4 Canonical Enum Inventory** (every enum declared with owning section — implementations may not introduce new values or substitute alternates without spec amendment); **§0A Implementation Discipline Preamble** (governs how V3 is implemented; coding agents working from it MUST comply); **§26 V3 Drift Manifest** (every TODO/placeholder/deferred behavior enters drift manifest). **V3 is materially more rigorous than V2** — V2 was an architectural revision over V1; V3 is the post-adjudication tightening that elevates V2 from proposal to spec status with explicit normative discipline. **No explicit "Supersedes:" header in V3** (unlike V2 which explicitly superseded V1) — V3 positions itself as the V3 spec for the same subsystem rather than as a strict supersession of V2; auto pass treats this as a natural-progression supersession (V2 → V3) per the established DOC23 Addenda B chain pattern (R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4 was the unified-draft chain; V1 → V2 → V3 is the Addendum chain). V2 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision. **(2) NEW §A7 row A-58 — Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context Proposal R0.2 supersession of R0.1:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 00:04 UTC = 2026-05-15 17:04 local; size 88,291 bytes; 3,220 lines — **~38% larger than R0.1's 63,741 bytes**). Per R0.2 file header: `# Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal R0.2`; **Status:** `Draft proposal for architect review and iterative refinement.`; **Date:** `2026-05-15.`; **Supersedes:** `Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md` for current discussion purposes.` **Title evolution from R0.1:** R0.1 title was `Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Task Scope / Working Set / Continuity Proposal`; R0.2 title is `Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal` — **drops "Output Routing", "Task Scope", "Working Set"; adds "Resume Work"** — significant scope refinement consolidating around the resume-work surface as the primary user-facing affordance over the more granular scope envelope vocabulary. **R0.2 scope refinement vs R0.1:** scope says `Integration proposal across DOC20, DOC7, DOC25, DOC72, DOC73, DOC24, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC1, EC Core, and CSA/continuity. DOC23 is included only as an integration boundary, not as an owner target for task-run context design.` — **explicitly excludes DOC23 from owner targets** (R0.1 included DOC23 as a co-owner; R0.2 demotes DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status, possibly reflecting architect judgment that the Unified Workspace proposal should not co-own task-run context with DOC23's existing task system). **Design posture unchanged**: `Seam-focused. This proposal does not rewrite DOC72, DOC73, DOC23, DOC24, DOC20, DOC7, or CSA. It names product objects, clarifies product behavior, gives enough schema detail to reason about seams, and identifies owner-doc changes without taking over owner-doc responsibilities.` — R0.2 strengthens the seam-focused language with explicit promise to **"give enough schema detail to reason about seams"** (R0.1 said only "names product objects, clarifies seams"); R0.2 is therefore more specification-flavored than R0.1's purely-product-model framing. **R0.2 NEW architectural primitive: Library source status model** with three additive statuses (NOT separate memory systems): **Linked**, **Indexed**, **Learned** — clarifies R0.1's vague "availability vs cataloging vs learning" distinction. **Retired R0.1 concepts:** **Available** (retired as Library level/status because all Linked/Indexed/Learned sources are available, so the level was not distinguishing anything); **Cataloged** (retired as Library status because too vague — "Indexed" better communicates the document-intelligence delta). **R0.2 NEW Co-Work-like behavior** in Output Location: if user opens or uploads a source document from a folder and asks Elnor to revise it, Elnor should often save a new sibling version near the source — formalizes source-folder affinity as a default Output Location heuristic. **R0.2 retains R0.1 core product model**: Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant, Task, Continuity Card — with scope-envelope terms (Session Working Set, Work Stream) consolidated into the Resume Work surface. **R0.2 retains R0.1 core philosophy** axioms verbatim: "Everything is optional"; "One substrate, visible lenses"; "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different"; "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane". **R0.2 is the natural-progression successor to R0.1** per the explicit `Supersedes:` header — R0.1 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision per auto pass's no-relocation policy (options: (a) move to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` following supersession-and-archive pattern; (b) keep in active folder for traceability). **Counts:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 56 → 58 (+2 net for A-57 V3 NEW + A-58 R0.2 NEW; A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 retained ACTIVE pending archival decisions per V2/R0.1 supersession by V3/R0.2); §4 Active Addenda 56 → 58; §A6 active rows 11 → 12 (+1 for A-57 V3 alongside A-55 V2 + A-54 V1 + A-53 R0.6.4); §A7 active rows 1 → 2 (+1 for A-58 R0.2 alongside A-56 R0.1); Grand total 121 → 123. **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.43 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.44 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt bumped V16 → V17** — two new addendum files representing two parallel supersession events (V3 succession of V2 in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain; R0.2 succession of R0.1 in §A7 multi-parent track) is substantive structural drift warranting carryover refresh + records that V3 is the post-adjudication tightening of V2 + R0.2 is the scope-refined successor of R0.1. **DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — two NEW addendum files + two parallel supersession events is substantive structural drift (not a fire-only mechanical bump or operations-state-only). **All R3.43 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five not-formally-listed subfolders backlog); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (uses A-56 for V3 / A-57 for R0.2) and master spec list §4 (uses A-57 for V3 / A-58 for R0.2) preserved verbatim (divergence-by-one pattern extends to two new rows); A-54 V1 + A-55 V2 stacked-then-superseded chain still ACTIVE pending human archival decisions; A-56 R0.1 now also ACTIVE pending archival after R0.2 supersession; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); BACKUP_LOG nine-day cloud-recoverability gap from R3.43 bind-mount proof carry-forward; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.44), but R3.44 is itself a substantive-drift run rather than a same-day fire-only mechanical bump, so the tightening backlog is for next-cycle attention rather than today's structural focus.

**Generated (R3.42 — preserved):** 2026-05-15 (local — overnight operations-state-only bump after R3.41; no new spec or addenda files detected in active scan folders; ops-state ticks captured for S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-11; substantive OpenClaw release news — 2026.5.12 NEW STABLE ends 7-day stable pause with architecturally consequential release, gap widens BEHIND-by-9 → BEHIND-by-10; BACKUP_LOG four-consecutive-disconnected-run pattern extending — last successful tarball 2026-05-09)
**Last Updated (R3.42 — preserved):** 2026-05-15 ~11:00 UTC (~04:00 local) — R3.42 sync run is an **operations-state-only bump** capturing zero new spec/addenda files but six operations-state file mtime/size ticks since R3.41 + one substantive OpenClaw release event (2026.5.12 ended the 7-day stable pause). No spec corpus changes since R3.41 — `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.41.md` returns only operations-state files: `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:09, size 70,245 bytes); `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:10, size 58,311 bytes); `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:13, size 178,697 bytes); `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:49, size 70,092 bytes — large jump from R3.28 baseline of 34,357 bytes; today's entry captures 2026.5.12 stable detection); `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 04:04, size 65,326 bytes). S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-14 04:25, size 67,229 bytes) was captured by R3.41 as coordinated post-write touch. S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-14 04:16, size 22,602 bytes) records the fourth-consecutive disconnected run (5/10, 5/11, 5/13, 5/14 — 5/12 has no entry); the 2026-05-14 entry escalates the failure-mode narrative to "**Five calendar days have now elapsed with no new cloud backup**" and adds an explicit pre-flight check recommendation. Substantive OpenClaw news per S-9: **2026.5.12 (released 2026-05-14 18:28 UTC, github-actions / steipete-signed)** ends the 7-day stable pause that ran 2026-05-08 → 2026-05-14; gap widens BEHIND-by-9 → BEHIND-by-10 (composition adds 2026.5.12; version sequence jumped 5.7 → 5.12 stable with 5.8/5.9/5.10/5.11 not published as stable — 5.9/5.10 existed only as betas, 5.11 not at all). 2026.5.12 is **the most architecturally consequential stable release since 2026.5.3**: (A) leaner-installs plugin-externalization extension (Bedrock + Bedrock Mantle + Slack + OpenShell sandbox + Anthropic Vertex moved out of core runtime); (B) NEW `acp.fallbacks` ACP runtime-backend fallback capability (#69542 — directly affects DOC11 ACP core ownership + RLD-12-01 durable channel/topic bindings cluster + RLD-11-REF-04 ACP core setup/runtime); (C) explicit browser device pairing + Control UI pairing before proxy-scoped access (DOC11 + EC Core secrets/pairing governance security-posture contract); (D) Claude CLI fresh-session bounded transcript retry preventing conversation amnesia (#80905 — DOC11 model/runtime truth + sub-agent contract); (E) in-process agent dispatcher for same-process subagent handoffs (DOC10 orchestration ledger + DOC11 sub-agent runtime truth); (F) Control UI/WebChat persisted auto-scroll mode selector with three modes (#7648, #81287 — DOC20/DOC22 UI surface); (G) Telegram polling isolation + durable local spool + HTML formatting preservation (#81132, #81742, #81181 — DOC12 channel projection); (H) `agents.defaults.subagents.model` application before target primary models during `sessions_spawn` (#81395 — SUBAGENT V4 + DOC11 sub-agent precedence). Codex OAuth route saga remains closed in safe three-act form (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover); DOC11 R15 R3 may treat the conditional Codex-route preservation rule as stable precedent. Recommendation strengthened: DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal should now fold **all ten** un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 + 2026.5.7 + **2026.5.12**) in one consolidated pass — Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative, seven 2026.5.7 quiet contract changes as DOC11 readback-truth obligations, 2026.5.12 leaner-installs + `acp.fallbacks` + pairing-before-proxy + Claude-CLI-bounded-transcript-retry + in-process-agent-dispatcher as new architectural anchors. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for **eighteen consecutive days**; the new stable resumes gap growth after the 7-day stable pause. BACKUP_LOG escalation pattern: R3.36 documented seventh-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING (5/10 + 5/11 failed runs); today's R3.42 sync confirms the failure mode has persisted through 5/13 and 5/14 (5/12 with no log entry implying task did not run or failed before logging step). Pre R3.42 ESCALATION classification: **eighth-strike** five-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT; last successful tarball 2026-05-09. The 2026-05-14 entry adds a third Will-action item (hardening pass with explicit pre-flight mount-vs-directory check before declaring runs successful — would catch silent ephemeral-mount failures earlier). No new spec/addenda files in any tracked scan folder (active root, all 7 Addenda subfolders, Operations Docs root) — earliest substantive structural drift opportunity since R3.41 may be Will's response to the Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context Proposal R0.1 (A-56) which would generate a per-parent addenda fork or a multi-parent owner-spec amendment cluster. — R3.41 sync run is a **substantive structural-drift bump capturing exactly one NEW addendum file in a BRAND-NEW subfolder** in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/`: `Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:21 local = 16:18 UTC, size 63,741 bytes). Per file header: "Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Task Scope / Working Set / Continuity Proposal R0.1", document date 2026-05-10, status "Draft proposal for architect review and iterative refinement", scope "Integration proposal across DOC20, DOC7, DOC25, DOC72, DOC73, DOC24, DOC23, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC1, EC Core, and continuity/CSA", design posture "Seam-focused. This proposal does NOT rewrite DOC72, DOC73, DOC23, or DOC24. It names product objects, clarifies seams, and defines cross-doc owner obligations where the current system has useful pieces that are not yet exposed as one coherent user model." Proposal defines a core product model — Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant, Task, Session Working Set, Work Stream, Continuity Card — explicitly as lenses/bindings/profiles/views over the same governed substrate rather than separate brains or memory truth systems. Core philosophy axioms per §2: "Everything is optional"; "One substrate, visible lenses"; "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different"; "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane" (still governed by DOC72 intake/significance/extraction/Write Gate pipeline). **NEW SUBFOLDER**: `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/` (folder mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:54 local = 16:18 UTC; first ever multi-parent cross-doc proposal subfolder — structurally analogous to existing DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73/DOC23 single-parent-doc subfolders, but explicitly multi-parent — touches DOC20 + DOC7 + DOC25 + DOC72 + DOC73 + DOC24 + DOC23 + DOC11/OpenClaw + DOC1 + EC Core all at once). **Filesystem scan since R3.40:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.40.md` returned exactly two hits: (1) the new proposal file + its containing subfolder (substantive drift); (2) `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 04:25:37 PDT = 11:25:37 UTC, +3m37s after R3.40's 11:22 UTC alias write — inferred as R3.40's own coordinated post-write touch, NOT independent S-10 firing; same attribution pattern R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40 applied to operations-state files touched within ~10 minutes of own alias write). No other new files in active spec folders, no other addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-7/S-8/S-9/S-11 firings since R3.40 captured them. **Counts:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 55 → 56 (+1 for new R0.1 file); §4 Active Addenda 54 → 55; §A7 NEW with 1 active row; Grand total 120 → 121. **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.40 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.41 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt bumped V16 → V17** — new §A7 subfolder + new multi-parent cross-doc proposal pattern warrants prompt update to add the new subfolder to the nightly sync scope and document the multi-parent proposal classification convention. **DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — new subfolder creation + new multi-parent proposal addendum is substantive structural drift (not a fire-only mechanical bump). **SKILL.md tightening recommendations carry forward** unchanged from R3.40 list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + **NEW Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj** subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md; (5) post-edit `stat` verification; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks. R3.41 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about the one new file detected since R3.40). **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to seventeen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.41), but R3.41 is itself a substantive-drift run rather than a same-day fire-only mechanical bump, so SKILL.md additions for the new subfolder are concretely actionable rather than abstract. **All other carry-forward items from R3.40 preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (now joined by the brand-new Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (A-54 for V2) and master spec list §4 (A-55 for V2) preserved verbatim (and now extends to A-56 in master spec list = likely A-55 in ADDENDA_STATE going forward); A-54 V1 stacked proposal still ACTIVE pending human archival decision after V2 supersession declared in R3.39; OneDrive backup chain at TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE (R3.40 capture); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-9 since 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07); single-release roll-forward standstill stretches to seventeen days; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen.

**Generated (R3.40 — preserved):** 2026-05-14 (local — same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump capturing two post-R3.39 scheduled-task firings (S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER at 10:42 UTC + S-11 BACKUP_LOG at 11:16 UTC); zero spec/addenda churn since R3.39's 2026-05-14 ~10:13 UTC write; S-11 escalates from R3.39 ninth-strike to TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE with five calendar days elapsed without cloud backup; S-9 adds NEW beta v2026.5.12-beta.6 watch row (iMessage media-only-send visible-text hygiene fix) and stretches single-release roll-forward standstill to seventeen consecutive days)
**Last Updated:** 2026-05-14 ~12:00 UTC — R3.40 sync run is a **same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump** capturing exactly two operations-state file hits since R3.39 (which completed 2026-05-14 ~10:13 UTC, ~1h47m earlier). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing on 2026-05-14. **Filesystem scan since R3.39:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.39.md` returned exactly **two operations-state file hits** in active scan folders: **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-14 03:43 local = 10:43 UTC, size 59,797 → 61,931 bytes / +3.6% / +2,134 bytes; entry-header firing time 2026-05-14 10:42 UTC; +29 minutes post-R3.39 alias write) and **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-14 04:16 local = 11:16 UTC, size 20,045 → 22,602 bytes / +12.8% / +2,557 bytes; entry-header firing time 2026-05-14 11:16 UTC; +63 minutes post-R3.39 alias write). Plus **S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md** at 2026-05-14 03:17 UTC inferred as R3.39's own append per R3.39 narrative ("DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle") rather than independent drift. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-7/S-8/S-10 firings since R3.39 captured them. **S-9 narrative:** OpenClaw release-tracker 2026-05-14 10:42 UTC nightly check logs latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC) for **seventh consecutive quiet stable day** (prior 2026.4.27 → 2026.5.7 daily-cadence streak now paused 7 days); gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-9 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7); single-release roll-forwards now lagged **seventeen consecutive days** (was sixteen per R3.37 5/13 capture; +1 day since pause halts growth, does not narrow it). NEW beta observation in this entry: `v2026.5.12-beta.6` prerelease tag dated 2026-05-13 — iMessage native image send hygiene fix that stops emitting visible `<media:image>` placeholder text for media-only sends while preserving the internal echo key that prevents self-echo duplicate replies. This joins prior beta watch list `v2026.5.9-beta.1` (2026-05-09 — `/think default` + `/fast default` chat-command additions; POSIX `openclaw.json` 0600 chmod restoration after suspicious-read backup recovery), `v2026.5.10-beta.6` (2026-05-11), `v2026.5.12-beta.4` (2026-05-13 05:17 UTC — Codex private-runtime-SDK helper exposure fix for `@openclaw/codex` MODULE_NOT_FOUND errors). Beta dist-tag only — none promote into stable alignment basis until cut on latest dist-tag. Version-number sequence continues to skip `v2026.5.8` AND `v2026.5.11` entirely; beta sequence runs 5.9-beta.1 → 5.10-beta.6 → 5.12-beta.4 → 5.12-beta.6. The 5.12-beta.6 contents are only an iMessage visible-text hygiene fix — no new architectural surfaces, beta cadence not yet alignment-basis material; if it stabilizes, touches DOC11/DOC10 channel projection (visible-reply enforcement vs internal echo key separation — quiet contract for any spec that pins iMessage visible-reply truth). **S-11 narrative:** BACKUP_LOG 2026-05-14 11:16 UTC run status **failed (OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect)**; archive not created; source `/Users/OpenClaw1/Documents/Elnor Docs Folder/Q and EC Build Working/ECQ Development/CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` mounted and accessible; destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` NOT mounted in this session; session ID `great-sharp-clarke`. Workspace sandbox mount `/sessions/great-sharp-clarke/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, plus hidden `.claude` and `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` absent. No stray `mkdir -p` artifact created (OpenClaw-Shared parent doesn't exist, mkdir attempt failed and bailed out before creating stub). **Fourth logged consecutive disconnected/failed run** (after 5/10, 5/11, 5/13; 5/12 has no log entry suggesting task did not run or failed before reaching logging step). **Five calendar days now elapsed with no new cloud backup** (5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, 5/14) — escalation from R3.38/R3.39's four-consecutive-failed-day characterization. Last successful tarball remains `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` from 2026-05-09; cloud-resident-recoverability state is now five days stale. **NEW hardening recommendation appears in this 5/14 entry (item #3, not present in any prior entry):** "consider whether the scheduled task itself needs a hardening pass: an explicit pre-flight check that asserts the destination is a real OneDrive bind mount (not just a writable directory under the sandbox) before declaring a run successful. This would catch silent ephemeral-mount failures earlier." This builds on Will-side action items (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button so scheduled task can resume writing backups, and (2) independently verify on host that prior tarballs accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — the open hypothesis from 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 runs about per-session ephemeral mount semantics remains untested. **Pattern recharacterizes from R3.39's NINTH-STRIKE four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE to TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE** with five-calendar-day-elapsed cloud-recoverability gap. **No spec / addenda churn in this 1h47m window**: no new spec files in active spec folders; no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations. §11 grand total unchanged at 120; §7 row count unchanged at 12; PROPOSED ADDENDUM count unchanged at 55; §A6 active rows unchanged at 11. **Per established pattern**, §7 row narratives are NOT individually rewritten in this bump — the S-9 + S-11 mtime/size advances are captured in narrative form in this Last Updated block and in the §12 R3.40 changelog entry. **Carryover prompt remains V16** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V17 bump (same-day operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). **DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — S-11 fifth-elapsed-calendar-day cloud-recoverability gap is narrative-significant (escalation from R3.39 ninth-strike to tenth-strike); S-9 new beta `v2026.5.12-beta.6` watch row plus seventeen-day cadence-lag milestone are informational but worth recording. This is NOT a fire-only mechanical bump — narrative-significant content present (escalating S-11 chain + new S-9 beta observation). **Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.39 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.40 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to sixteen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.40). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.39 list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md; (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window — R3.40 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about S-9 and S-11 firings that have already occurred). **All carry-forward items from R3.39 preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (A-54 for V2) and master spec list §4 (A-55 for V2) preserved verbatim; A-54 V1 stacked proposal still ACTIVE pending human archival decision after V2 supersession declared in R3.39; OneDrive backup chain at TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE (escalated from R3.39 ninth-strike); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-9 since 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07); single-release roll-forward standstill stretches to seventeen days; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen.

**Generated (R3.39 — preserved):** 2026-05-14 (local — substantive structural-drift bump capturing 1 NEW addendum file in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder; first substantive structural drift since R3.33 on 2026-05-10; ends six-revision window R3.34/R3.35/R3.36/R3.37/R3.38 + 5/12 + 5/13 no-drift of operations-state-only / fire-only / no-drift bumps; restores supersession-and-replace addendum chain pattern after R3.33's one-off stacked-proposal pattern)
**Last Updated:** 2026-05-14 ~10:10 UTC — R3.39 sync run is a **substantive structural-drift bump capturing exactly one NEW addendum file** in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/`: `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 03:32 UTC, size 133,682 bytes, 2,740 lines). Per V2 file header: "DOC23 Task System — Addenda B ADDENDUM: Outcome Evaluation and Revision Architecture, V2", document hierarchy "DOC23 (R3.1) → Addenda B (R0.6.4) → Addendum (this doc, V2)", status "Proposal — pending red-team review per §25. Not yet folded into Addenda B main." **EXPLICIT SUPERSESSION**: per V2 header "Supersedes: `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL_ADDITION_FOR_R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (V1)" — that V1 file is the existing A-53 R0.6.5 / master spec list A-54 stacked proposal detected by R3.33. **Supersession-and-replace pattern RESTORED** after the R3.33 one-off stacked-proposal pattern; V1 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision (auto pass does not relocate). Per V2 §0.1 change log V2 is "a substantial architectural revision, not an incremental edit" — V1's primitives are retained (OutcomeSpec, OutcomeEvaluatorConfig, OutcomeGate, EvaluationFeedbackBundle, defeasible findings lifecycle, Run Guidance Items, Repair Instructions, four feedback delivery channels, FeedbackConsumptionReceipts, TaskSourceWorkspace, TaskProcessGapSignal) but V2 closes 11 specification gaps V1 lacked: (1) outcome creation UX without 15-field form; (2) plan-and-execute layer; (3) targeted evaluation mode; (4) per-outcome progress signals beyond pass/fail; (5) cascading revalidation via declared dependencies; (6) two-budget iteration model; (7) formal Revision Bus / dispatch runtime; (8) per-module `revision_in` port contract; (9) plan review forum semantics distinct from runtime orchestration; (10) text-to-outcome inference pipeline; (11) skill-graph integration for learned patterns. New V2 architectural primitives: `step.revisor` module (§6); `RevisionPlan` schema (§7); Revision Bus runtime (§8); `revision_in` port contract (§9); `target_outcomes` / `iteration_history` / `plan_step_context` input ports on Evaluator (§5.1). **Counts:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 54 → 55 (+1 for the V2 file; V1 row retained ACTIVE pending archival decision); §A6 active rows 10 → 11; Grand total 119 → 120. **Audit-cleanup pass executed in this run:** R3.36 + R3.37 + R3.38 versioned files all moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule — yesterday's R3.37/R3.38 same-day double-bump left all three in active folder despite the invariant "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" (Step 5.4 sanity check resolves this — three-cleanup operation, deepest accumulation observed since the R3.26 two-axis backfill addressed R3.24+R3.25 accumulation earlier this week). Active folder retains R3.39 + alias only after this run. **Carryover prompt:** bumped V15 → V16 to capture V2 supersession + new architectural primitives. **DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** covering R3.37 + R3.38 backfill (neither bumped DRIFT_LOG when they fired) PLUS today's R3.39 substantive drift. **All carry-forward items from R3.38 preserved unchanged**: A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (auto pass scans them by precedent — today's pass scanned all four); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (A-54 for V2) and master spec list §4 (likely A-55 for V2) preserved verbatim; OneDrive backup chain remains in ninth-strike four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE status per R3.38 narrative (no new firing observed today at sync time); OpenClaw release-alignment gap unchanged at BEHIND-by-9 (S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md not yet refreshed today at sync time). **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to fifteen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.39).

**Generated (R3.32 — preserved):** 2026-05-09 (local — same-day THIRD-firing fire-only mechanical bump; zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.31; first same-day TRIPLE-fire observed in this scheduled task's run history)
**Last Updated:** 2026-05-09 ~23:06 UTC (~16:06 local) — R3.32 sync run is a **same-day THIRD-firing fire-only mechanical bump — zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.31** (which itself completed ~6h23m ago at 09:43:57 local). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing again ~6h23m after R3.31's alias write at 09:43:57 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.31:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.31.md` returned exactly two operations-state files — S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (mtime 2026-05-09 09:48:06 local; +4m9s after R3.31 alias write) + S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (mtime 2026-05-09 09:53:13 local; +9m16s after R3.31 alias write) — both within ~10 minutes of R3.31's alias write at 09:43:57 and inferred to be R3.31's own coordinated post-write touches rather than independent task firings. This mirrors the same attribution pattern R3.31 itself applied to the four operations-state files (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8) that R3.30 had touched within ~3 minutes of R3.30's alias write. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-9 (OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER) or S-11 (BACKUP_LOG) firings since R3.30 captured them at 12:00 UTC / 16:29 UTC respectively. **Daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task continues to be missed:** R3.31 narrative flagged today's daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh as having missed its scheduled firing for the second time this week (first miss documented in R3.27/R3.28). R3.32 confirms the absence-window has now extended from "missed at 09:38" to "missed for ~12 additional hours through 16:06" — no 04:02 firing has occurred between R3.31's 09:43 generation and R3.32's 16:06 generation. Today's 09:48 / 09:53 mtimes on S-8 / S-10 are R3.31 sync coordinated touches, NOT today's daily refresh. The daily-04:02 task gap continues to widen and remains a next-sync scrutiny item rather than fresh drift. **First same-day TRIPLE-fire observed:** Today's R3.30 (09:33 local) → R3.31 (09:43 local, +~10min) → R3.32 (16:06 local, +~6h23m) interval establishes today as the FIRST same-day TRIPLE-fire in this scheduled task's run history. Same-day double-fires were already well-established (historical clusters R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24+R3.25; this week's clusters R3.26/R3.27/R3.28 + R3.29/R3.30/R3.31). R3.32 escalates the cadence pattern to triple. The autonomous task is firing without supervision and continues to produce same-day-mechanical-bump revisions on cadence regardless of underlying drift levels — SKILL.md tightening recommendation now persisted **seven cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32). Will-side procedural action increasingly warranted to break the pattern; the same-day triple-fire is a new escalation worth flagging. **Counts unchanged:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §A6 active rows 9; Operations files 12; Grand total 118. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V15 bump (same-day fire-only run; spec folders quiet). **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup:** `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.32.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.31 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.32 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle** (matching R3.27/R3.28/R3.29/R3.31 pattern: same-day fire-only mechanical bumps with zero NEW filesystem drift do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries; only narrative-significant or filesystem-drift cycles append; R3.30 was the most recent narrative-significant entry). **All R3.31 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly remains at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification** with R3.30 strengthened recommendation to pause the scheduled task pending Will-side mount-semantics investigation (carries forward URGENT — no S-11 firing has occurred since R3.30 captured it at 16:29 UTC, so empty-start status is unchanged but still URGENT); OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation BEHIND-by-9 with Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required, twelve-day single-release roll-forward standstill (no S-9 firing has occurred since R3.30 captured it at 12:00 UTC, so release-tracker status is unchanged from R3.30/R3.31 narrative). **R3.31 (prior pass — preserved for context):** R3.31 sync run was a **same-day second-firing fire-only mechanical bump — zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.30** (which itself completed ~5 minutes ago at ~09:36 local). Triggered by autonomous `spec-registry-update` task firing again ~5 minutes after R3.30's alias write at 09:33:44 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.30:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.30.md` returned only operations-state files touched as part of the R3.30 sync run itself — S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (mtime 09:35:13), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (09:35:22), S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (09:36:15), S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (09:36:56) — all mtimes within ~3 minutes of R3.30's alias write at 09:33:44 and inferred to be R3.30's own post-write touches rather than independent task firings. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no new S-9/S-11 firings since R3.30 captured them at 12:00 UTC / 16:29 UTC respectively. **Narrative-inaccuracy carry-forward observed from R3.30 (NOT recharged as new drift):** R3.30 narrative + R3.30 §7 SPEC_STATE row note both claimed `S-7/S-8/S-10 unchanged from R3.28/R3.27 (no firing of those tasks since R3.29)`, but filesystem shows S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime advanced 2026-05-08 04:02 → 2026-05-09 09:36 (size 41,222 → 41,735 bytes; +0.5%). This appears to be a coordinated touch by R3.30's own sync write rather than the daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task firing (which has not fired today at sync time of 09:38; today's daily 04:02 firing missed for the second time this week per cadence-monitor signal — first miss documented in R3.27/R3.28). R3.31 flags this as next-sync scrutiny item rather than re-classifying as fresh drift. **Counts unchanged:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §A6 active rows 9; Operations files 12; Grand total 118. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V15 bump (same-day fire-only run; spec folders quiet). **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup:** `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.31.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.30 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.31 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle** (matching R3.27/R3.28/R3.29 pattern: same-day fire-only mechanical bumps with zero NEW filesystem drift do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries; only narrative-significant or filesystem-drift cycles append; R3.30 broke that pattern yesterday by recording narrative-significant S-9 + S-11 ticks, but R3.31 reverts to the fire-only-mechanical-bump no-DRIFT-entry default since today has no fresh drift). **All R3.30 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** SKILL.md tightening recommendation now persisted **six cycles** (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31) un-implemented — autonomous task is firing without supervision and same-day double-fires are now well-established (R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24+R3.25 historical clusters; R3.26/R3.27/R3.28 + R3.29/R3.30/R3.31 this week's clusters); A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly remains at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification** (R3.30 strengthened recommendation to "pause the scheduled task pending Will-side investigation of mount semantics" — carries forward URGENT; today's 16:18 firing was the fifth-strike, entrenched-pattern; rotation logic permanently silently violated as cap-of-3 invariant); OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation stands at strengthened-per-R3.28 status (BEHIND-by-9, Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required, twelve-day single-release roll-forward standstill — today's pause halts gap growth at 9 but does not narrow it). **R3.30 (prior pass — preserved for context):** R3.30 sync run is an **operations-state-only bump capturing today's S-9 (OpenClaw release-tracker, 11:59 entry) + S-11 (BACKUP_LOG, 16:18 entry) scheduled-task firings**, both of which post-date R3.29's 2026-05-08 ~18:50 local generation. **Filesystem scan since R3.29:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.29.md` against in-scope folders returned exactly two hits — `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9, mtime 2026-05-09 12:00 UTC, size 34,357 → 37,739 bytes; ~10% growth) and `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11, mtime 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC, size 12,994 → 15,163 bytes; ~17% growth). No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations. **S-9 narrative:** OpenClaw release-tracker logs 2026-05-09 11:59 nightly check — latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC); no v2026.5.8 published yet; **first day in nearly two weeks without a new stable release**; daily-cadence streak from 2026.4.27 through 2026.5.7 has paused; gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-9 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7); today's pause halts gap growth but does not narrow it; twelve-day standstill on single-release roll-forwards continues to make this a useful drafting window for the DOC11 R15 R3 consolidated amendment that should fold all 9 releases — with the Codex-route saga folded as a single closed three-act item (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). **S-11 narrative:** BACKUP_LOG logs 2026-05-09 16:18 backup run — **fifth consecutive empty-start anomaly** (pattern unbroken from 2026-05-04, 2026-05-06, 2026-05-07, 2026-05-08); archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` (5.40 MB compressed from 19 MB / 19,216,816 bytes uncompressed source; mount path this run: `/sessions/fervent-sweet-galileo/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`); 48-hour gate effectively defeated for fifth consecutive run because each session opens with zero pre-existing tarballs despite prior runs reporting successful creation; entry recommendation strengthens to **"recommend pausing the scheduled task and investigating the mount semantics before the next run"** — entrenched-pattern classification, no longer a one-off anomaly. Empty-start anomaly graduated from third-strike (R3.25) → fourth-strike (R3.28) → fifth-strike entrenched-pattern (R3.30); rotation logic in the script will never fire because each run sees an empty destination, so the cap-of-3 invariant is silently violated. **Counts unchanged:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §A6 active rows 9; Operations files 12; Grand total 118. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V15 bump (operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup:** `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.30.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.29 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.30 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **DRIFT_LOG entry appended** this cycle (S-11 entrenched empty-start pattern + S-9 first-day-without-release both narrative-significant; this is NOT a fire-only mechanical bump). **All R3.29 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** SKILL.md tightening recommendation now persisted **five cycles** (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30) un-implemented; A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly graduated fourth-strike → fifth-strike entrenched-pattern; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation (now URGENT — recommend pausing the backup task pending investigation); OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation stands at strengthened-per-R3.28 status (BEHIND-by-9, Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required). **R3.29 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-08 ~18:50 local — same-day fourth sync — fire-only mechanical bump, zero filesystem drift in active spec folders.

**R3.29 (deeper context):** R3.29 sync run was a same-day fourth-firing fire-only mechanical bump with zero filesystem drift in active spec folders. The same-day cycle today now extends R3.26 ~03:10 → R3.27 ~04:23 → R3.28 ~04:35 (alias-mtime-derived; R3.28 narrative claimed ~12:40 but alias mtime was 04:35:17, anomaly inherited unchanged) → R3.29 ~18:50, with the ~14-hour gap between R3.28 and R3.29 corresponding to the Friday daytime work window — first same-day evening-slot firing observed in this scheduled task's run history (prior same-day multi-fire cycles R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24+R3.25 all clustered in early-morning + mid-morning + early-afternoon slots). **`find -newermt "2026-05-08 04:36"` against `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` (excluding `Archived*` and `.DS_Store`) returns ZERO results** — no new files in active spec folders, no operations-state ticks, no addenda churn since R3.28's alias write at 04:35:17 local. **Operations-state files all unchanged from R3.28-recorded mtimes:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 / ~39,045 bytes), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 / ~41,338 bytes), S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-08 03:15 / ~102,215 bytes), S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-08 04:02 / ~41,222 bytes), S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-08 03:44 / ~34,357 bytes), S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-08 04:24 / ~41,701 bytes), S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-08 04:21 / ~12,994 bytes). No new firings of the daily 03:10/03:12/03:15 SPEC_STATE/ADDENDA_STATE/DRIFT_LOG cycle, the 03:44 OpenClaw release-tracker, the 04:02/04:24 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh, or the 04:21 BACKUP_LOG run since R3.28 — all daily-cadence tasks next fire tomorrow morning. **Counts unchanged:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §A6 active rows 9; Operations files 12; Grand total 118. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V15 bump (operations-state-and-spec-folder-quiet run). **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup:** `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.29.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.28 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle** (matching the R3.28/R3.25 pattern: fire-only mechanical bumps with zero substantive content to record do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries; only narrative-significant or filesystem-drift cycles append). **All R3.28 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** SKILL.md tightening recommendation (R3.26-introduced, still un-implemented, R3.28 escalated to third-instance pattern; R3.29 extends the un-implemented persistence to four cycles); A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly carries forward at fourth-strike per R3.28; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation stands at strengthened-per-R3.28 status (BEHIND-by-9, Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required). **NEW carry-forward in R3.29 (informational):** the SKILL.md procedure has now persisted four cycles (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29) without the recommended tightening — Will-side procedural action increasingly warranted to break the pattern; this scheduled task is autonomously firing without supervision and will continue to produce same-day-mechanical-bump revisions on cadence regardless of underlying drift levels.

**R3.28 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-08 ~04:35 local (alias-mtime-derived; R3.28 narrative claimed ~12:40 but alias mtime was 04:35:17, ~6-second window between alias and snapshot writes — anomaly inherited unchanged in R3.29 narrative). R3.28 was the third pass of the day and a two-axis backfill pass capturing (a) operations-state drift R3.27 narrative-acknowledged but failed to materialize into §7 rows, plus (b) post-R3.27 operations-state firings: S-9 OpenClaw release-tracker BEHIND-by-8 → BEHIND-by-9 with 2026.5.7 (released 2026-05-07 20:57 UTC) detection closing the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 → 2026.5.7 Codex OAuth route saga as a three-act narrative (doctor --fix now PRESERVES working `openai-codex/*` PI routes AND RECOVERS 2026.5.5-rewritten `openai/*` GPT-5 routes back to `openai-codex/*` when only Codex OAuth auth is available, fixes #78407); S-11 BACKUP_LOG fourth empty-start anomaly strike (rotation logic confirmed never firing); S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY second size-decrease anomaly (REOPENED in milder form); R3.27 §7-row-gap third instance of alias-bump-skipped-§7-row-update pattern (R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 missed §12 changelog entries; R3.24/R3.25/R3.27 missed §7 row mtimes). Counts unchanged at 118 grand total. R3.28 original full narrative preserved verbatim below in the §12 changelog block.

**R3.27 (prior pass — preserved for context):** 2026-05-08 ~04:23 local — R3.27 sync run was a mechanical same-day second-firing bump that performed the R3.26 versioned-snapshot archival but DID NOT actually update §7 rows S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 to reflect their new 2026-05-08 mtimes (despite narrative claiming advance) and INCORRECTLY narrated S-11 as unchanged when in fact today's 04:21 firing had already occurred ~2 minutes earlier; ALSO missed the substantive S-9 content delta of 2026.5.7 detection. R3.28 backfills these gaps. R3.27 narrative preserved verbatim below for traceability: **mechanical same-day second-firing bump — zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.26** (filesystem scan against R3.26 baseline returned zero hits across `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Operations Docs/`, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root, and all tracked subfolders; second-firing of the `spec-registry-update` task triggered ~76 minutes after R3.26 generation at 2026-05-08 03:07 local). Tonight's R3.27 sync executes one structural-bookkeeping action and one no-op verification: (1) **Audit-cleanup move executed** — R3.26 versioned snapshot (`MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.26.md`) moved from active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant; active folder now contains only the R3.27 versioned file + alias. (2) **Operations-state file mtimes verified** — S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 local), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 local), S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-08 03:15 local), S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-08 04:02 local), S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-08 03:44 local) — all advanced into 2026-05-08 dates per R3.26's projected mechanical updates and per other scheduled tasks firing in their normal early-morning slots; S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-07 04:08, 35,320 bytes) and S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-07 04:17, 11,038 bytes) unchanged from R3.26 baseline since today's daily 04:08/04:17 firings have not yet occurred at R3.27 sync time of ~04:23 local (S-10 may fire imminently; S-11 may fire imminently subject to its 48-hour gate which yesterday's 5/7 04:17 SUCCESS run will trigger as gated-skip). **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.26:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root file set unchanged (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.27 versioned snapshot transient — to be archived by next sync's audit-cleanup pass + R3.26 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs other than the R3.26 versioned snapshot move described above. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered tonight; pure mechanical same-day second-firing sync with zero new filesystem drift does not warrant a V15 bump under any rule. **Carry-forward items from R3.26 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation BEHIND-by-8 with the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must-explicitly-not-canonize note carried forward from R3.24; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly THIRD-strike from R3.25 (urgent Will-side Finder inspection of actual OneDrive Personal folder contents) carried forward unchanged. **NEW carry-forward item in R3.27:** none. R3.27 is a same-day second-firing pure-mechanical bump documenting no NEW drift beyond what R3.26 already captured; the audit-cleanup invariant is now restored to "at most ONE versioned file in active folder" by virtue of this run actually performing the R3.26 archival move that R3.26's own narrative did not anticipate (R3.26's narrative spoke of the R3.24/R3.25 archives which it executed, but did not anticipate its own future archival; tonight's R3.27 executes that ordinarily-next-pass move ~76 minutes early due to the same-day second firing).

**R3.26 (prior pass — preserved for context):** 2026-05-08 ~03:07 local — R3.26 sync run is a **mechanical backfill pass — zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.25** (filesystem scan against R3.25 baseline returned zero hits across `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Operations Docs/`, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root, and all tracked subfolders). Tonight's pass closes two structural-bookkeeping gaps left by yesterday's R3.24 + R3.25 same-day double-bump: (a) **R3.24 versioned file was left in the active folder** despite R3.25's narrative claiming "R3.24 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass" — tonight's audit-cleanup actually executes the move (R3.24 → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`), restoring the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant; (b) **R3.25 had no §12 changelog entry appended** despite the version bump being narrated in §3 — tonight's pass adds the missing R3.25 entry below the R3.24 entry plus a new R3.26 entry above. Same alias-bump-skipped-trackers / changelog-skipped pattern as R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 backfill cycles documented in earlier runs. Tonight's R3.26 sync also materializes the R3.24 + R3.25 narrative changes that did NOT flow through to SPEC_STATE.md and ADDENDA_STATE.md when those bumps occurred (state-tracker mtimes stuck at R3.23's 2026-05-07 03:09–03:10 local since R3.24 ran at 04:10 and R3.25 ran ~later same day, neither updating the state files). Mechanical updates tonight: (1) Master Spec List row in SPEC_STATE.md Rev R3.23 → R3.26 with R3.24 (OpenClaw 2026.5.6 + revert pair) + R3.25 (S-11 third autonomous-success-path run + S-10 mtime/size tick + empty-start anomaly third strike) narrative backfilled into Notes; (2) S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 mtime ticks (already on filesystem at 5/7 dates per their actual mtimes — backfilled into SPEC_STATE.md S-row Notes per R3.24 + R3.25 detection); (3) this row's own mtime advanced 2026-05-07 → 2026-05-08; (4) Addenda State row's mtime advanced 2026-05-07 → 2026-05-08; (5) ADDENDA_STATE.md header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-07 → 2026-05-08 with run-marker note; (6) DRIFT_LOG.md gets tonight's R3.26 entry; (7) dashboard `lastRefresh` advanced. **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.25:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root file set unchanged (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.25 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass + R3.24 versioned snapshot transient also archived tonight + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. **Operations-state files unchanged from R3.25 mtimes** (no scheduled-task firings have occurred between R3.25 generation 2026-05-07 23:10 UTC and tonight's R3.26 sync ~10:07 UTC since the daily 04:10 / 04:17 local firings haven't happened yet today): S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-07 10:09 UTC = 03:09 local / 37,092 bytes — to be advanced to 2026-05-08 by this run); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-07 10:09 UTC = 03:09 local / 41,199 bytes — to be advanced to 2026-05-08 by this run); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-07 10:10 UTC = 03:10 local / 93,077 bytes — to be advanced to 2026-05-08 by this run); S-7 OP-A V3.7; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-07 11:03 UTC = 04:03 local / 43,864 bytes); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-07 10:47 UTC = 03:47 local / 26,858 bytes — no new OpenClaw stable release detected; gap status holds at BEHIND-by-8); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-07 11:08 UTC = 04:08 local / 35,320 bytes); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-07 11:17 UTC = 04:17 local / 11,038 bytes — R3.25 RESOLVED-via-third-autonomous-success-path run holds informationally; today's 04:17 local firing has not yet occurred at R3.26 sync time of ~03:07 local). **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered tonight; pure backfill pass with zero new filesystem drift does not warrant a V15 bump under any rule. **Carry-forward items from R3.25 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation BEHIND-by-8 with the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must-explicitly-not-canonize note carried forward from R3.24; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly THIRD-strike from R3.25 (urgent Will-side Finder inspection of actual OneDrive Personal folder contents) carried forward unchanged. **NEW carry-forward item in R3.26:** none. The two structural-bookkeeping gaps closed tonight (R3.24 versioned file actually archived; R3.25 §12 changelog entry actually appended) are themselves examples of the alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping pattern that was already recognized in earlier R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 backfill cycles — Will may want to consider whether the SKILL.md procedure or the alias-bump cadence should be tightened to reduce these gaps. The empty-start anomaly investigation remains the most operationally urgent open item.

**R3.25 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-07 ~later local — R3.25 sync run captures **operations-state drift since R3.24** in the daily-04:10/04:17 task domain that R3.24 had deferred to "next firing" — both daily auto-refresh tasks have now fired and S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG + S-11 BACKUP_LOG mtimes have advanced; **S-11 BACKUP_LOG records its THIRD autonomous-success-path run** (2026-05-07 11:16 UTC firing produced a SUCCESS entry, archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-07_111637.tgz` 5.36 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source, mount path this run `/sessions/busy-hopeful-brahmagupta/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`). **Three of five autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success — 60% success rate, continuing the gradual improvement: R3.18 1-of-1, R3.21 1-of-3, R3.23 2-of-4, R3.25 3-of-5). **Critical recurring observation in tonight's S-11 entry — destination was empty at start of run for the THIRD CONSECUTIVE TIME** (2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 vs 2026-05-04 autonomous run; 2026-05-07 vs 2026-05-06 autonomous run). **The 48-hour backup-creation gate is being effectively defeated by the empty-start anomaly** — yesterday's run created a tarball ~24 hours ago (well under the 48-hour gate), but today's session sees an empty destination, so the gate evaluates as "no prior backup" and a new tarball is created. Three possibilities per file note: (a) the per-session sandbox mount is a fresh ephemeral copy that doesn't reflect the host OneDrive folder; (b) OneDrive sync is removing them; (c) host folder accumulates them but they're not exposed back into subsequent sandbox sessions. **Action required from Will (carry-forward strengthened from R3.21/R3.23):** open Finder at `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` and visually confirm whether prior tarballs are actually landing in OneDrive — this is now urgent because if (a) is true, autonomous backups are not actually working as intended despite the SUCCESS log entries. **R3.25 also captures S-10 mtime/size tick** — S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime advanced 2026-05-06 04:09 → 2026-05-07 04:08, size grew 29,650 → 35,320 bytes (~+19%) recording the new 2026-05-07 11:00 entry (today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task) — note: today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh ran BEFORE today's BACKUP_LOG entry, so its narrative on S-11 reflects yesterday's RESOLVED state and is now slightly stale by ~5 hours, mirroring the same stale-on-write pattern observed in R3.21/R3.23 S-10 entries. **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.24:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root still contains the same .md files (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.24 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. **Other operations-state files unchanged from R3.24 mtimes:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-07 03:09 / 37,092 bytes); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-07 03:09 / 41,199 bytes); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:10 / 93,077 bytes); S-7 OP-A V3.7; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-07 04:03 / 43,864 bytes — second consecutive growth tick from R3.24 holds); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:47 / 26,858 bytes — no new OpenClaw stable release detected between R3.24 sync (~04:10 local) and R3.25 sync (~later local) today; gap status holds at BEHIND-by-8). **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.25 introduces no structural spec-folder drift; the daily-task firing observations + empty-start anomaly persistence are captured via §7 row updates + §10 anomaly entry only (a SUCCESS entry on a tracker log does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed). **Carry-forward items from R3.24 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation BEHIND-by-8 with the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must-explicitly-not-canonize note carried forward from R3.24. **Carry-forward STRENGTHENED in R3.25:** OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly is now THREE consecutive occurrences (third strike) — 48-hour gate effectively defeated; Will-side Finder inspection of actual OneDrive Personal folder now graduates from "worth a manual check" to **urgent investigation** (if host-side files aren't actually persisting, every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading). **NEW carry-forward item in R3.25:** none structural; the empty-start anomaly persistence is the headline item but is operational-investigation rather than spec-classification.

**R3.24 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-07 ~04:10 local — R3.24 sync run captures **moderate operations-state drift since R3.23** concentrated in the OpenClaw release-alignment domain — **a NEW stable release 2026.5.6 (2026-05-06 17:51 UTC) widens the gap from BEHIND-by-7 to BEHIND-by-8** and, more consequentially, **REVERTS the 2026.5.5 Doctor/Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route repair (fixes #78407) that R3.22 had flagged as a useful precedent for DOC11 R15 R3 capability-bound default-runtime resolution.** The conditional `agentRuntime.id: "codex"` selection rule from 2026.5.5 is now gone — DOC11 R15 R3 should NOT canonize it. Other 2026.5.6 changes are pure plumbing/security hardening (Plugins/runtime fetch drops third-party symbol metadata from header dictionaries before native fetch — fixes #77846; Debug proxy normalizes captured fetch headers; Web fetch bounds guarded dispatcher cleanup after request timeouts — fixes #78439); none introduce schema-level obligations. 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 same-day pair makes single-release roll-forwards even less viable and underscores the cost of un-folded amendment cycles. **R3.24 also captures routine state-tracker mtime/size ticks** for S-3 SPEC_STATE (2026-05-06 03:09 → 2026-05-07 03:09), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE (2026-05-06 03:09 → 2026-05-07 03:09), S-5 DRIFT_LOG (2026-05-06 03:08 → 2026-05-07 03:10), S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY (2026-05-06 04:04 → 2026-05-07 04:03; size 40,104 → 43,864 bytes ~+9%, **continues the post-R3.20 size-decrease recovery** — second consecutive growth tick), and S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG (2026-05-06 03:46 → 2026-05-07 03:47; size 22,451 → 26,858 bytes ~+20% recording the new 2026-05-07 entry detailing 2026.5.6 + the revert + the abandoned-precedent observation). **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG (2026-05-06 04:09) and S-11 BACKUP_LOG (2026-05-06 04:17) are unchanged at R3.24 sync time — daily 04:10 task has NOT fired yet OR was skipped silently under the 48-hour gating policy** (last successful S-11 entry 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC is ~24 hours old, under the 48-hour gate). **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.23:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root still contains the same .md files (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.23 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.24 introduces no structural spec-folder drift; the OpenClaw release drift + revert is captured via S-9 update + §10 anomaly entry only (a release-tracker tick + revert observation does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed). **Carry-forward items from R3.23 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup connection persistence problem (R3.21 carry-forward, strengthened R3.23 by empty-start anomaly) still pending Will-side investigation. **Carry-forward STRENGTHENED in R3.24:** OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation now BEHIND-by-8 (gap widened by 1 today; eleven consecutive days where single-release roll-forwards have not kept pace; 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 same-day patch pair makes per-release amendment cycles especially uneconomic; the 2026.5.5 Codex agentRuntime.id precedent flagged by R3.22 is invalidated by 2026.5.6's revert and **must not be canonized into DOC11 R15 R3**). **NEW carry-forward item in R3.24:** when DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal is authored, it must explicitly note the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair so the abandoned conditional `agentRuntime.id` rule is not folded in.

**R3.23 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-06 ~later local — R3.23 sync run captured **moderate operations-state drift since R3.22** in the OneDrive backup domain — **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS FLIPS REGRESSED → RESOLVED again via second autonomous-success-path run** (2026-05-06 11:17 UTC firing produced a SUCCESS entry; archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` 5.34 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source) — but **no structural drift in active spec folders** since R3.22. The headline news: **the daily 04:10 OneDrive backup task DID fire today at 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC (04:17 local)** (R3.22 had deferred this to "next firing" since the task hadn't fired yet at R3.22 sync time of ~04:05) — and recorded a NEW SUCCESSFUL entry per S-11 log. Mount path this run: `/sessions/zen-practical-rubin/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — confirms OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory was reachable for tonight's autonomous run. **Status change: R3.21 REGRESSED → R3.23 RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run.** Two of four autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened (2026-05-04 success; 2026-05-05 failure; 2026-05-06 success) — improvement over R3.21's 1-of-3 ratio, but persistence across sessions remains intermittent. **Recurring observation in tonight's S-11 entry: destination was empty at start of run** despite 2026-05-04 having created `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` — this is the second time in three runs that a prior backup was not visible at the start of a new session (also seen 2026-05-04 start vs the 2026-05-02 manual seed). Either (a) backups are not persisting in OneDrive across sessions, (b) the mount points to a different OneDrive subfolder per session, or (c) Will or OneDrive sync is removing them between sessions. **Action required from Will (carry-forward strengthened from R3.21):** investigate making the OneDrive connection persistent at the user/account level rather than per-session — AND additionally manually inspect the actual OneDrive Personal folder contents in Finder to confirm tarballs are landing in cloud storage as intended (not just landing in a per-session sandbox view that vanishes on next mount). Tonight's R3.23 sync also captures: **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime + size tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:10 → 2026-05-06 04:09, size grew 24,943 → 29,650 bytes (~19%) recording today's 2026-05-06 10:55 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh log entry (which itself documents the OpenClaw 2026.5.5 release awareness from R3.22's S-9 update + the R3.21 REGRESSED status — note: the log entry was written before today's 11:17 UTC BACKUP_LOG SUCCESS entry, so its narrative on S-11 is now slightly stale, mirroring the same pattern as R3.21's stale-on-write S-10 entry). Other operations files unchanged from R3.22 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-06 03:09) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-06 03:09) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-06 03:08) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-06 04:04, size 40,104 bytes — unchanged from R3.22's partial recovery; S-8 size-decrease anomaly carry-forward from R3.20/R3.22 holds informationally) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-06 03:46). **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.22:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root still contains the same 40 .md files (including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.22 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4 incl. R0.6.3 archived per R3.18; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. R3.22 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.23 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers; the S-11 REGRESSED → RESOLVED status flip is captured via §7 row update + §10 anomaly entry only (a status flip on a tracker log does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed). **Carry-forward items from R3.22 preserved unchanged (except S-11 RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run):** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation remains BEHIND-by-7 (no new release today as of R3.23 sync time — single-release roll-forwards now "no longer keeping pace" for ten consecutive days; gap NOT widened since R3.22 but recommendation strengthens by another day of standstill). **NEW carry-forward item in R3.23:** investigate why backups are not visible at start of new sessions despite prior runs having created them — second occurrence of empty-start anomaly (2026-05-04 had empty start vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 had empty start vs 2026-05-04 autonomous run); possible OneDrive sync state issue, per-session mount-path mismatch, or external removal between sessions. **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20/R3.22 carry-forward unchanged tonight** (S-8 mtime + size unchanged at 2026-05-06 04:04 / 40,104 bytes; next observation tick deferred to next nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task firing).

**R3.22 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-06 ~04:05 local — R3.22 sync run captures **moderate operations-state drift since R3.21** in the OpenClaw release-alignment domain (one new stable release 2026.5.5 today widening the gap from BEHIND-by-6 to BEHIND-by-7) and routine state-tracker mtime/size ticks (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG all advance 2026-05-05 → 2026-05-06) — but **no structural drift in active spec folders** since R3.21. Headline: **2026.5.5 (released 2026-05-06, today, published 09:00 UTC) is a fixes-only release with no new operative architectural surfaces** — Doctor/sessions recovery-key migration for heartbeat-poisoned default main session store entries; Doctor/Codex legacy openai-codex/* → canonical openai/* route repair with conditional agentRuntime.id selection (codex iff Codex plugin installed + enabled + has codex harness + has usable OAuth, else pi); Doctor/Gateway supervisor-restart-handoff visibility in `openclaw doctor --deep` and `openclaw gateway status --deep`; Plugins/update sync hardening for installed official npm + ClawHub plugins (including disabled or exact-pinned) with managed npm-root openclaw peer-link repair; Hooks/session-memory collision suffixes for fallback memory filenames + opt-in llmSlug for model-generated slugs + run reset-memory capture off command reply path; **Agents/config removes ambiguous legacy "main" agent dir helper from runtime paths** (default/session agent dirs now resolved through agents.list / agent-scope helpers; plugin SDK keeps deprecated compatibility export — quiet contract change DOC11 R15 should explicitly track); CLI/sessions prunes unreferenced transcript / compaction-checkpoint / trajectory artifacts during normal sessions cleanup so gateway restart/crash orphans don't accumulate outside sessions.json; CLI/status + sessions CLI + Control UI/Sessions all show selected agent runtime/harness with Sessions-table runtime filter; Control UI compaction count compact "N Checkpoint(s)" disclosure with checkpoint history cards; Gateway/OpenAI-compatible flushes initial chat-stream chunk and sends assistant-role SSE chunk as soon as headers accepted; Gateway/shutdown structured ShutdownResult warnings + cancel delayed post-ready maintenance during close; Gateway/status avoids event-loop-degraded marking from CPU/utilization alone until sustained sampling window; xAI/Grok stops sending OpenAI-style reasoning effort to native Grok Responses models with bundled xAI thinking profile clamped to off (xai/grok-4.3 no longer fails Docker/Gateway with Invalid reasoning effort); Fireworks/Kimi exposed as thinking-off-only with K2.5/K2.6 pinned to thinking: disabled; Channels improvements (Feishu native topic hydration, LINE dmPolicy "open" rejection without wildcard allowFrom, Telegram/Codex Codex tool-progress dedup, Discord /steer through normal mention gate + live reasoning in progress drafts + heartbeat ACK timeout from actual send, Matrix approval delivery 3x retry with backoff, Slack Socket Mode error context preservation, WhatsApp stale-client TUI recovery); iOS pairing allows setup-code and manual ws:// for private LAN/.local gateways while keeping Tailscale/public on wss://; Docker/Gateway drops NET_RAW + NET_ADMIN capabilities and enables no-new-privileges in bundled docker-compose.yml; /status shows compact Gateway process uptime + host system uptime; Plugins/diagnostics actionable source-only TypeScript package warnings; Auth profiles avoid cooldown for format-level rejections; Exec approvals guarded copy fallback when Windows rejects rename-overwrite; Update dev-channel preflight lint made opt-in and constrained; Video generation provider-specific aspect-ratio/resolution hint normalization (720P → MiniMax 768P) + stop sending Google generateAudio on Gemini video. Per S-9 log notes: none of the 2026.5.5 fixes introduce new schema-level obligations on the scale of 2026.5.3's file-transfer plugin or gateway invalid-config guards, but the Agents/config legacy "main" agent dir helper removal is the kind of quiet contract change DOC11 R15 should explicitly track; the Doctor/Codex agentRuntime.id selection rule is a useful precedent for DOC11 capability-bound default-runtime resolution; CLI/sessions cleanup of unreferenced transcript/compaction-checkpoint/trajectory artifacts touches DOC11 sessions/checkpoint truth and EC durable-state retention assumptions. **Recommendation unchanged from R3.20/R3.21: an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should now fold 2026.4.27 (promote watch → include-now), 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, AND 2026.5.5 in one consolidated pass, with a companion next-R of the running list — single-release roll-forwards have not kept pace for nine consecutive days.** Tonight's R3.22 sync also captures: **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG mtime + size + content tick (BEHIND-by-6 → BEHIND-by-7)** — mtime advanced 2026-05-05 03:46 → 2026-05-06 03:46, size grew 14,987 → 22,451 bytes (~50%) recording the new 2026-05-06 entry detailing 2026.5.5; **S-5 DRIFT_LOG mtime + size tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-05 03:18 → 2026-05-06 03:08, size grew 78,895 → 84,586 bytes (~7%) — picks up R3.21's narrative entry append at top documenting the S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED status flip; **S-3 SPEC_STATE mtime + size tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-05 03:10 → 2026-05-06 03:09, size grew 25,817 → 31,824 bytes (~23%) reflecting R3.21's row content writes propagating through; **S-4 ADDENDA_STATE mtime + size tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-05 03:11 → 2026-05-06 03:09, size grew 35,042 → 41,106 bytes (~17%); **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY mtime + size tick — recovers from R3.20 size-decrease anomaly** — mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:02 → 2026-05-06 04:04, size grew 36,470 → 40,104 bytes (+10%); first auto-refresh tick to grow in size since the R3.20-noted decrease; possible Will-edit or auto-refresh task post-compaction expansion. Other operations files unchanged from R3.21 mtimes: S-7 OP-A V3.7-row content / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-05 04:10 — daily 04:10 task has NOT fired yet at R3.22 sync time of ~04:05) / S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-05 04:16 — daily 04:10 task has NOT fired yet at R3.22 sync time of ~04:05; **S-11 REGRESSED status from R3.21 holds informationally pending today's 04:10 firing**). **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.21:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root still contains the same 40 .md files (including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.21 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4 incl. R0.6.3 archived per R3.18; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. R3.21 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.22 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers; the OpenClaw release drift is captured via S-9 update only (the BEHIND-by-7 status alone does not warrant a V15 bump until Will authors the DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal). **Carry-forward items from R3.21 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation strengthened to BEHIND-by-7 with single-release roll-forwards explicitly called out as "no longer keeping pace" for 9 consecutive days; OneDrive backup connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation (today's 04:10 firing not yet observed at R3.22 sync time). **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 PARTIALLY RESOLVED in R3.22** (size grew back to 40,104 bytes, +10% above R3.20's 36,470 — anomaly may have been transient compaction or Will-edit). **NEW carry-forward item in R3.22:** none structural; the BEHIND-by-7 OpenClaw drift is the headline item but is informational since R3 amendment authoring is Will-side.

**R3.21 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-05 ~later local — R3.21 sync run captures **MAJOR operations-state drift since R3.20** in the OneDrive backup domain — **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS FLIPS RESOLVED → REGRESSED again (fifth consecutive failure pattern recurrence)** — but **no structural drift in active spec folders**. The headline news: **the daily 04:10 OneDrive backup task DID fire today at 2026-05-05 11:16 UTC (04:16 local)** (R3.20 had deferred this to "next firing" since the task hadn't fired yet at R3.20 sync time of ~04:05) — and recorded a NEW FAILED entry per S-11 log. Per the new entry: workspace mount at `/sessions/zealous-happy-edison/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present despite Will's reconnect that took effect for the 2026-05-04 successful run. **Status change: R3.18-noted RESOLVED → R3.21 REGRESSED.** The 2026-05-04 success was the only autonomous-success-path run; the OneDrive connection does NOT reliably persist across scheduled-task sessions. Per the entry note: even if connected, today would have been a skip since last backup (2026-05-04 11:17) is only ~24 hours old, under the 48-hour gate — but mount-path resolution failed before the gate check, so the failure logged anyway. **Action required from Will:** investigate making the OneDrive connection persistent at the user/account level rather than per-session — re-adding via the Cowork chat-box "+" button has now succeeded once (2026-05-04) and failed three subsequent times to persist (2026-05-03, 2026-05-05; with 2026-05-02 manual seed missing from destination by 2026-05-04 run start as residual question from R3.18). Tonight's R3.21 sync also captures: **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime + size tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:21 → 2026-05-05 04:10, size grew 19,950 → 24,943 bytes (~25%) recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh log entry (which itself documents the OpenClaw 2026.5.3/2026.5.3-1/2026.5.4 release awareness from R3.20's S-9 update + the (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awareness + S-11 RESOLVED state from R3.18 — note: the log entry was written before tonight's REGRESSION, so its narrative is now slightly stale). Other operations files unchanged from R3.20 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:11) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-05 03:18) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-05 04:02) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-05 03:46). **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.20:** active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root still contains the same 40 .md files (including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.20 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4 incl. R0.6.3 archived per R3.18; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. R3.20 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.21 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers; the S-11 REGRESSION is captured via §7 row update + §10 anomaly entry only (a status flip on a tracker log does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed). **Carry-forward items from R3.20 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation strengthened from "actively warranted" to "single-release roll-forwards no longer keeping pace" per R3.20 (no R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.20 and R3.21); S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 unchanged tonight (S-8 mtime stable). **NEW carry-forward item in R3.21:** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — connection works briefly when established but does not survive across scheduled-task sessions; Will may need to investigate user/account-level persistence rather than per-session reconnects.

**R3.20 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-05 ~04:05 local — second pass of the day, captured **MAJOR operations-state drift since R3.19** in the OpenClaw release-alignment domain, but **no structural drift in active spec folders**. The headline news: **THREE NEW OpenClaw stable releases landed since the R3.19 generation (~03:10 local) — gap status widened from BEHIND-by-3 to BEHIND-by-6 in ~24 hours**, per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-05 entry: (1) **2026.5.3 (released 2026-05-04)** lands a brand-new bundled file-transfer plugin with `file_fetch` / `dir_list` / `dir_fetch` / `file_write` agent tools (default-deny per-node path policy, symlink traversal refused by default, 16 MB byte ceiling per round-trip — **first-class native data-egress surface** that DOC3 plugin catalog, DOC11 plugin lifecycle, DOC15/DOC25 ingestion safety, and EC durable-state policy will all need to classify and govern); plus gateway/config invalid-state guards (no auto-restore at startup or hot reload; `openclaw doctor --fix` repairs); gateway/performance lazy-loading of plugin/runtime discovery / cron / schema / shutdown / sessions / model metadata until needed; channels/replies improvements (Discord status reactions + degraded transport reporting; WhatsApp Channel/Newsletter targets; Telegram, Feishu, Matrix, MS Teams, Slack delivery/recovery tightened); install/update recovery for broken macOS LaunchAgent upgrades; rejection of source-only plugin packages before runtime load; repair of stale Gateway/plugin state during updates and doctor runs; onboarding install-hints with the external Codex plugin selectable in Manual setup. (2) **2026.5.3-1 (2026-05-04, beta-tag)** is a core npm hotfix on the beta dist-tag stopping the install scanner from blocking official bundled plugin packages when `process.env` access and normal API sends only appear in distant parts of the same compiled bundle. (3) **2026.5.4 (2026-05-05, today)** lands the **Twilio realtime voice bridge for Google Meet / Voice Call** (paced audio streaming, backpressure-aware buffering, barge-in queue clearing, no TwiML fallback during realtime speech); Codex audio transcription advertised in runtime/manifest metadata and routed to OpenAI transcription default rather than chat model IDs; plugins/migration emits catalog-backed install hints for missing referenced external plugins; gateway/Windows pins default loopback listener to 127.0.0.1 to avoid libuv dual-stack ::1 wedge; agents/performance threads resolved-workspace through BTW / compaction / embedded-run model generation; runtime + provider dependency refresh including Pi 0.73.0, ACPX adapters, OpenAI, Anthropic, Slack. **The Twilio realtime voice bridge is the second-most-significant new architectural surface** (DOC11 channels truth, DOC10 voice/audio routing, DOC22 voice surface, DOC24 KDA persisted-audio readback). Per S-9 log notes: **recommendation strengthened from R3.19's "actively warranted" to "single-release roll-forwards no longer keeping pace with the release cadence"** — an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should now fold 2026.4.27 (promote watch → include-now), 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, and 2026.5.4 in **one consolidated pass**, with a companion next-R of the running list. Tonight's R3.20 sync also captures: **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG mtime + size + content tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:44 → 2026-05-05 03:46, size grew 9,805 → 14,987 bytes (~53%) recording the new 2026-05-05 entry detailing the three new releases above; **S-5 DRIFT_LOG mtime + size tick** — mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:17 → 2026-05-05 03:18, size grew 62,827 → 78,895 bytes (~26%) — picks up R3.19's narrative entry append at top documenting the R3.17/R3.18 backfill pass; **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY mtime + size tick (size DECREASE — first observed in this S-8 series)** — mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:03 → 2026-05-05 04:02, size shrank 41,236 → 36,470 bytes (-11.6%) — first time S-8 size has decreased across the auto-refresh series (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470); possible content compaction by tonight's auto-refresh task; flagged as anomaly for human review (Will may have manually edited the file, or the auto-refresh task may have a new compaction step — SKILL.md inspection deferred to human sweep). Other operations files unchanged from R3.19 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:11) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-04 04:21 — no new tonight-summary entry yet; the post-R3.20 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task may still log an entry later) / S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-04 04:17 — daily 04:10 scheduled task has not fired yet at R3.20 sync time of 04:05 local, OR the 48-hour gating policy applies since yesterday's 04:17 success — next eligible run not before 2026-05-06 04:17 if 48-hour rule honored, OR tonight 04:10 if daily cadence overrides; deferred to next firing). **No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.19:** no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still 40 .md files including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.19 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4 incl. R0.6.3 archived per R3.18; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. R3.19 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. **Carryover prompt remains V14** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.20 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers; the OpenClaw release drift is captured via S-9 update only (the recommendation strengthening alone does not warrant a V15 bump until Will authors the DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal). **Carry-forward items from R3.19 preserved unchanged:** A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization. **Carry-forward strengthening in R3.20:** OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation now strengthened from "actively warranted" to "single-release roll-forwards no longer keeping pace" — per S-9 log explicit recommendation that an R3 amendment proposal should fold all six BEHIND releases (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4) in one consolidated pass with a companion next-R of the running list.

**R3.19 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-05 ~03:10 local — backfill pass primarily flowing through R3.17/R3.18 narrative changes that did NOT materialize in state trackers. No new structural drift on filesystem since R3.18; backfilled SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md mtimes, A-51 R0.6.4 row, A-52 informational anomaly row, S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSED → RESOLVED status, materialized V14 carryover prompt, regenerated dashboard.

**R3.18 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-04 ~16:00 local — third pass of the day, captured the substantial structural drift since R3.17 detailed below.

**R3.18 original header (preserved verbatim below):**
**Generated:** 2026-05-04 (local — nightly sync auto-bump, third pass of the day)
**Last Updated:** 2026-05-04 ~16:00 local — R3.18 sync run captures **substantial structural drift since R3.17**: (1) **NEW addendum** `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_4_UI_CONTINUATION_SHARING_PATCHED.md` in DOC23 Addenda subfolder (mtime 2026-05-04 15:17, size 327,340 bytes — large file at ~119% of A-52 R0.6.3's 274,551 bytes; ~135% of A-51 R0.6.1's 241,604 bytes). Per file header: "R0.6.4 UI, Run Inspector, Module Continuation, Sharing-Forward-Compatible Unified Draft", date 2026-05-04, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.4 carries forward R0.6.3 and adds DOC20 task-surface integration, graph/inspector navigation, artifact/delivery UI, context inspector feedback, Task Agent side-panel/session behavior, Task Segment reusable module groups, module continuation/follow-up, run forking/rerun-from-module, Judge/Experiment rerun affordances, audit export, task-page operational stats, and shared-task surface forward-compatibility for future DOC50+ sharing/networking specs." Companion docs per its own header: DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 (= A-47); DOC23 Addenda A R5/R6 Deferral List V2 (= A-48); DOC24 R3; DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0; DOC73 V1.5.1; DOC8 v1.11.4; DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4; DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35); DOC17 R4.2; DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R2 (= A-36); OpenClaw Release Alignment Running Spec Update List R2; EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (= A-4); OP-A V3.7. R0.6.4 specifically extends R0.6.3 with: DOC20 task-surface integration, graph/inspector navigation, artifact/delivery UI, context inspector feedback, Task Agent side-panel/session behavior, Task Segment reusable module groups, module continuation/follow-up, run forking/rerun-from-module, Judge/Experiment rerun affordances, audit export, task-page operational stats, and shared-task surface forward-compatibility for future DOC50+ sharing/networking specs. New row A-53 added in §4.A6 (DOC23 Addenda subfolder) as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. (2) **A-52 R0.6.3 moved to intra-subfolder archive between R3.17 and tonight** — `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_3_SURFACE_CONTEXT_PATCHED.md` now at `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (mtime preserved 2026-05-04 00:42, size unchanged 274,551 bytes). A-52 alias row preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation, mirroring the A-50 R0.3 (R3.15) and A-51 R0.6.1 (R3.16) archival pattern. **DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity now grows to 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3).** (3) **NEW (1)-suffix duplicate** `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-04 15:53, size 22,818 bytes — byte-identical to existing A-46 `DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` at 22,818 bytes/2026-05-01 17:31). Filename "(1)" suffix suggests Will copied this from Downloads; same pattern as A-39 DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card "(1)" file noted in R3.4. Tracked as informational anomaly pending human review (likely Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize); not given a separate row since byte-identical to A-46. (4) **MAJOR S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS CHANGE: R3.15-noted REGRESSED → R3.18 RESOLVED.** S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:17 → 2026-05-04 04:17, size grew 5,548 → 6,524 bytes (~18%) recording **first SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` (5.19 MB compressed from 18 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op). Mount path this run: `/sessions/kind-epic-shannon/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — confirms Will's reconnect of OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory via Cowork connector took effect for tonight's autonomous run. Per the entry's notes: 2026-05-02 manual seed backup `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` was NOT present in destination at start of this run — destination was empty; possible causes per entry: file removed by user / OneDrive sync state / different mount path. Worth a manual check from Will, but new backup created successfully so cloud-side recoverability is restored. Tarball verified >1 MB sanity check. **Carry-forward anomaly tracked since R3.15 is now RESOLVED via autonomous-success path log entry** (R3.12 had RESOLVED via manual-seed path only; tonight's R3.18 detection confirms the scheduled task SKILL.md workspace-mount path resolution introduced 2026-05-02 works correctly when the OneDrive folder is properly connected). (5) **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime tick:** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:10 → 2026-05-04 04:21, size grew 14,177 → 19,950 bytes (~41%) — additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task. Other operations files unchanged from R3.17 mtimes (S-3 SPEC_STATE 2026-05-04 03:10 / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE 2026-05-04 03:11 / S-5 DRIFT_LOG 2026-05-04 03:17 / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY 2026-05-04 04:03 / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG 2026-05-04 03:44). Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 52 → 53 (+1 for A-53 R0.6.4); §A6 8 → 9 (A-52 alias preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation; A-53 NEW). Grand total 117 → 118 (§11 grand total). **No master-spec-list versioned-snapshot gap recurrence:** R3.17 saved its versioned snapshot correctly; this R3.18 saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.18.md` alongside its alias write. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap. R3.17 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. **Carryover prompt bumped V13 → V14** to capture A-53 R0.6.4 supersession of A-52 R0.6.3 + S-11 carry-forward RESOLVED via autonomous-success path + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate anomaly + DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows. All R3.17 carry-forward items preserved unchanged: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation still actively warranted (no R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.17 and R3.18). Carryover prompt V14 retained alongside V12 + V13 per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule.

**R3.17 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-04 ~04:10 local — second pass of the day. R3.17 sync run was a **re-confirmation pass — no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.16**. R3.16 was generated 2026-05-04 ~03:13 (first pass of the day, captured A-52 R0.6.3 supersession of A-51 R0.6.1 + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement irregularity + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation + S-11 BACKUP_LOG carry-forward REGRESSED status); this R3.17 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at ~04:10 local, second pass of the day). **Folder scan re-affirms no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.16:** no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still 40 .md files including OPA_V3_8 + the master spec list alias + R3.16 versioned snapshot); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 6 incl. A-52 R0.6.3; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. **Three substantive operations-state mtime ticks (post-R3.16 sync self-refresh + tonight's auto-refresh tasks):** (1) S-5 `DRIFT_LOG.md` mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:17 (R3.16 narrative entry append) — no further change tonight (already captured by R3.16's post-write append); (2) S-9 `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` mtime advanced post-R3.16 to 2026-05-04 03:44, size grew 7,497 → 9,805 bytes (~31%) recording new 2026-05-04 10:43 UTC entry. Per the new entry: alignment doc still covers through 2026.4.26; latest stable OpenClaw remains **2026.5.2 (released 2026-05-02)** — no new stable tag since R3.16; gap status unchanged at BEHIND-by-3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2). Per the entry's notes: "WebSearch and GitHub release-tag scan confirm no new stable tag has been cut since 2026.5.2 (2026-05-02). Beta-only tags continuing on the 2026.5.2-beta.x line; nothing has crossed the stable cutover. Recommendation unchanged: DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal warranted to fold 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 and promote 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now, with companion next-R of the running list. Dashboard `lastChecked` advanced to 2026-05-04; all other OPENCLAW_RELEASE block fields preserved." Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved; (3) S-8 `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:04 → 2026-05-04 04:03, size grew 37,316 → 41,236 bytes (~11% — sixth consecutive auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Other operations files unchanged from R3.16 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:11) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-03 04:10) / S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-03 04:17 — REGRESSED status holds; no new nightly run between R3.16 and R3.17 to re-confirm). **No master-spec-list versioned-snapshot gap recurrence:** R3.16 saved its versioned snapshot correctly; this R3.17 saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.17.md` alongside its alias write. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap. R3.16 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. **Carryover prompt remains V13** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.17 introduces no structural drift beyond what V13 already covers (V13 was authored by R3.16 to capture A-52 R0.6.3 supersession + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation + S-11 carry-forward REGRESSED status). Counts unchanged from R3.16 (no new files; only mtime/size refreshes on S-8 + S-9). All R3.16 carry-forward items preserved unchanged: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; OneDrive backup S-11 carry-forward REGRESSED (Will to re-add OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory via Cowork connector); R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 3 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1); A-52 R0.6.3 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation still actively warranted (no R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.16 and R3.17). Carryover prompt V13 retained alongside V12 per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule.

**R3.16 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-04 ~03:13 local — first pass of the day, captured **substantial structural drift since R3.15**: (1) **NEW addendum** `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_3_SURFACE_CONTEXT_PATCHED.md` in DOC23 Addenda subfolder (mtime 2026-05-04 07:42, size 274,551 bytes — large file at ~190% of A-48 R0.3's 143,665 bytes; ~14% larger than A-49 R0.6.1's 241,604 bytes). Per file header: "R0.6.3 Surface/Trigger Context Patched Unified Draft", date 2026-05-04, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.3 revises the task-module DOC24 context-injection section to remove the singular-current-work-context assumption and add task-run scope envelopes for concurrent chats, scheduled runs, email/webhook/file triggers, and other background executions." Source merge: builds on A-49 R0.6.1 (which itself folded A-48 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5 merge pack). Defines Task Agent, natural saved-task invocation, DOC72 task-memory integration, telemetry spine, artifact/output intake, Task Blueprint, template/preset intelligence, Task Agent education/TKP, task-design self-learning, DOC24 capability/runtime routing, OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment, unified prompt improvement, prompt-evaluation tasks, and all cross-doc seams. R0.6.3 specifically removes singular-current-work-context assumption + adds task-run scope envelopes for concurrent chats / scheduled runs / email / webhook / file triggers. New row A-52 added in §4.A6 (DOC23 Addenda subfolder) as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. (2) **A-51 R0.6.1 moved to intra-subfolder archive between R3.15 and tonight** — `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md` now at `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (mtime preserved 2026-05-03 22:51); A-51 alias row preserved with file-moved-to-intra-archive annotation, mirroring the A-50 R0.3 R3.15 archival pattern. (3) **NEW operative-folder file** `OPA_V3_8.md` in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root (mtime 2026-05-04 07:59, size 404,864 bytes; 4,507 lines; byte-identical copy of `DOC73 R1.6 Build/OPA_V3_8.md` which has mtime 2026-05-02 19:50 and was the original location). Per file header: "OP-A V3.8 — DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card V4 fold-in (V1.6 release wave candidate rows from V4 §0.3.3 + §0.3.4 + §0.3.6 + inline `[V4 PATCH:...]` markers); date V3.8 produced 2026-05-02; folder: `ECQ Development/DOC73 R1.6 Build/` (working folder for V1.6 wave); to be promoted to `Current Specs/Operations Docs/` once V1.6 wave settles." **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY** — OP-A trackers normally live in `Operations Docs/`; this file's official location per its own header is `DOC73 R1.6 Build/`. The active-root copy is unusual — possibly Will copying for visibility, or the start of promotion to Operations Docs/. Supersedes OP-A V3.7 (still in Operations Docs/). New row added in §3 + §7 (Supporting Documents) as placeholder pending human classification + path canonicalization. (4) **MAJOR RELOCATION:** `DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md` moved from CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → new subfolder `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/` (subfolder mtime 2026-05-04 08:05). Subfolder is OUT OF SCOPE per nightly sync task SKILL.md (only active root + Addenda Proposals & In Progress + Operations Docs are crawled), so V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts (DOC73_V1_6_CSA_INTEGRATION_TRACE_R0.1.md, DOC73_V1_6_DEFERRAL_INVENTORY_R1.md, DOC73_V1_6_HELPER_HOMES_R0.1.md) inside are not auto-tracked. Structurally significant: V1.6 release wave is now organized as a working subfolder INSIDE active root rather than at active root level — analogous to the `DOC73 R1.6 Build/` working folder at workspace root, but inside the active spec folder. Per the subfolder name "DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE" Will may be promoting V1.6 R1.0 to operative status; but V1.5.1 file itself appears retained inside that subfolder rather than archived. DOC73 V1.5.1 row in SPEC_STATE.md annotated for relocation with file-moved-out-of-active-root note. (5) **State-tracker mtime ticks** (multi-file post-R3.15): S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md mtime 2026-05-01 → 2026-05-03 (size 2,538 → 7,497 bytes — picks up 2026-05-03 entry recording 2026.5.2 release); S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime 2026-05-02 → 2026-05-03 (size 32,292 → 37,316 bytes); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime 2026-05-02 → 2026-05-03 (size 8,501 → 14,177 bytes); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime 2026-05-02 → 2026-05-03 (size 4,422 → 5,548 bytes — fourth consecutive scheduled-task failure recorded; **R3.12 RESOLVED status REGRESSED back to PERSISTENT FAILURE** per R3.15 detection; tonight's R3.16 confirms regression). Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 51 → 52 (+1 for A-52 R0.6.3); §A6 7 → 8 (A-51 alias preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation; A-52 NEW). Grand total 117 → 118 (header) / 116 → 117 (§11 grand total). The R3.15 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.15.md` is moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Carryover prompt bumped V12 → V13 to capture A-52 R0.6.3 supersession of A-51 + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation + S-11 carry-forward REGRESSED status.

**R3.15 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Generated 2026-05-03 ~16:00 local — third pass of the day, captured A-51 R0.6.1 supersession of A-50 R0.3 + S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED status flip + the new intra-subfolder archival pattern. Carryover narrative claimed bump V12 → V13 happened, but no V13 file was actually materialized — tonight's R3.16 sync authors V13 directly capturing R3.15's narrative changes plus tonight's drift.

**R3.15 original header (preserved verbatim below):**
**Generated:** 2026-05-03 (local — nightly sync auto-bump, third pass of the day)
**Last Updated:** 2026-05-03 ~16:00 local — R3.15 sync run captures **substantial structural drift since R3.14**: (1) NEW addendum `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md` in DOC23 Addenda subfolder (mtime 2026-05-03 15:51, size 241,604 bytes — large file at ~168% of A-50 R0.3's 143,665 bytes; per file header: "R0.6.1 Merge-Audit Cleaned Unified Draft", source merge folds A-50 R0.3 base + briefly-extant R0.5 audit-complete merge pack into one unified draft adding natural saved-task invocation, prompt-evaluation tasks, OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment, unified prompt improvement); (2) NEW intra-subfolder archival pattern — `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` subfolder created (mtime 2026-05-03 15:52, **first time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive subfolder** — different from the global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archival convention); (3) A-50 R0.3 file moved into the new intra-subfolder archive (path now `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md`, mtime preserved 2026-05-02 19:36, size unchanged 143,665 bytes); (4) briefly-extant R0.5 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_R0_5_AUDIT_COMPLETE_MERGE_PACK_TASK_INVOCATION_TA_PROMPT_EVAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 15:24, size 103,376 bytes) detected only in the new intra-subfolder archive — never had a master-spec-list row of its own (created and archived between R3.14 and R3.15); (5) **MAJOR S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSION: R3.12-noted RESOLVED status REGRESSED back to PERSISTENT FAILURE.** S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime advanced 2026-05-02 10:46 → 2026-05-03 04:17, size grew 4,422 → 5,548 bytes (~25%) recording **fourth consecutive scheduled-task failure** at 2026-05-03 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: bash sandbox mount at `/sessions/jolly-upbeat-brown/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present despite Will's 2026-05-02 connection via Cowork chat-box "+" button; the connection from 2026-05-02 either did not persist across sessions or pointed to a different folder. **Action required from Will:** re-add OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory via Cowork. (6) S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime + size tick: 2026-05-02 11:09 → 2026-05-03 04:10, size 8,501 → 14,177 bytes (~67% growth — additional auto-refresh entries). Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 50 → 51 (+1 for A-51 R0.6.1); §A6 6 → 7 (A-50 alias preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation; A-51 NEW). Grand total 116 → 117 (header) / 115 → 116 (§11 grand total). The R3.14 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.14.md` is moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule; new R3.15 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Carryover prompt bumped V12 → V13 to capture A-51 R0.6.1 supersession of A-50 + S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED status flip + the new intra-subfolder archival pattern.

**R3.14 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Re-confirmation pass with one substantive operations-state change. R3.13 generated 2026-05-03 ~03:10 (first pass of the day, captured A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3); this R3.14 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-03 ~04:05 local). **Folder scan re-affirms no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.13:** no new files in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new files in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (DOC20 Addenda 4 / DOC23 Addenda 6 / DOC24 Addenda 5 / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3 / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3 / Integrated Addenda 7 / CD Cross Docs 2); no archive movements of operative specs; no new files in active `Operations Docs/`. **One substantive operations content change:** S-9 `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` advanced 2026-05-02 03:47 → 2026-05-03 03:44, size 4,039 → 7,497 bytes, recording **OpenClaw 2026.5.2 released 2026-05-02** — gap status now BEHIND by 3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 were not published as stable). 2026.5.2 lands plugin externalization architecture (ACPX behind `@openclaw/acpx`, diagnostics OpenTelemetry behind `@openclaw/diagnostics-otel`, broad npm/ClawHub publishing prep), descriptor-first platform tool planner with cached plugin tool descriptors, ClawPack metadata flowing through install/onboarding/doctor-repair/channel-setup, `openclaw gateway restart --force / --wait <duration>`, `threadBindings.spawnSessions` consolidation replacing split subagent/ACP toggles, provider-native web search reflecting configured provider, Grok 4.3 default xAI chat, broad messaging-channel fixes. Per S-9 log recommendation: 2026.5.2 introduces architectural plugin-packaging shift that pre-empts several DOC11 R15 R2 plugin-runtime rows and broadens DOC4 plugin architecture obligations — strong candidate for promoting from a single-release roll-forward to a deeper amendment refresh; an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold in both 2026.4.29 and 2026.5.2 plus promote 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now, with a companion next-R of the running list. **State-tracker mtime ticks (post-R3.13 sync self-refresh + tonight's auto-refresh tasks):** S-3 `SPEC_STATE.md` 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-05-03 03:14 (size 19,169 → 25,817 bytes — picked up R3.13's A-50 + S-9/S-10 row updates); S-4 `ADDENDA_STATE.md` 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-05-03 03:16 (size 14,478 → 35,042 bytes — much larger growth across multiple post-R3.6 sync passes that all left this row stale); S-5 `DRIFT_LOG.md` 2026-05-02 03:21 → 2026-05-03 03:23 (size 56,692 → 62,827 bytes — R3.13 narrative entry appended); S-8 `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` 2026-05-02 11:02 → 2026-05-03 04:04 (size 32,292 → 37,316 bytes — fifth auto-refresh tick); S-10 `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` mtime stable 2026-05-02 (per fs listing) — no new entry tonight. S-11 `BACKUP_LOG.md` UNCHANGED from R3.12/R3.13 (mtime 2026-05-02 10:46, size 4,422) — **the daily 04:10 scheduled backup task did NOT run tonight (or ran and failed silently without logging)**; this is a regression from the R3.12 RESOLVED status pending verification (see new anomaly in §10). S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged. No archive movements. No master-spec-list versioned-snapshot gap recurrence: R3.13 saved its versioned snapshot correctly; this R3.14 saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.14.md` alongside its alias write; R3.13 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap. Carryover prompt remains V12 (no bump needed — R3.14 introduces no structural drift requiring V12 → V13). **One previously-noted carry-forward item now has new color:** the OpenClaw release-alignment recommendation has shifted from "informational only" (R3.11/R3.12/R3.13) to "actively warranted" — S-9 log explicitly recommends an R3 amendment proposal to absorb 2026.5.2's architectural plugin-packaging shift.

**R3.13 (prior pass — preserved for context):** Sync run reflecting structural drift in the DOC23 Addenda subfolder. One **NEW addendum** detected: `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 02:36, size 143,665 bytes — this opens a brand-new DOC23 Addenda B track for Task Intelligence / Memory / Observability / Self-Improving Task Design, parallel to the existing DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization track). Three same-file mtime ticks on R3.12-detected addenda (A-47 R4.1 V2 12:34→19:34; A-48 R5/R6 Deferral V2 10:58→17:58; A-49 Card Integration Map V2 10:58→17:58 — sizes unchanged in all three; live edits or touch operations). Two operations-log mtime ticks (S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 04:02→11:02 size unchanged; S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md 04:04→11:09 size grew 4,474→8,501 bytes). No archive movements; no operations file additions; carryover prompt bumped V11→V12 to capture the new DOC23 Addenda B track. Three new addenda detected in `DOC23 Addenda/` (R4.1 V2 of DOC23 Task Optimization at 154,930 bytes, R5/R6 Deferral List V2 at 30,631 bytes, and a V1 → V5 Card Integration Map V2 at 23,341 bytes). Three matched archive moves: A-44 R4.0 (1) (the prior canonical R4.0 — moved to archive after R4.1 V2 supersession), a briefly-extant `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1.md` V1 (created and archived in the same window — V2 supersedes V1 at the V1→V2 audit-pass step), and a briefly-extant `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V1.md` (V1 created and archived in same window — V2 supersedes V1). One **major operations status change**: BACKUP_LOG.md S-11 records a third consecutive scheduled-task failure at 2026-05-02 04:17 local (third `failed` entry) BUT THEN — after Will mounted the OneDrive Personal/OpenClaw-Shared folder via Cowork's chat-box "+" connector at some point between 04:17 and 10:47 local — a manual seed backup ran successfully at **2026-05-02 10:46 local / 17:46 UTC** (first SUCCESS entry, archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` 4.84 MB). Per file content, the scheduled task SKILL.md has been updated to use workspace-mount path resolution so future autonomous runs will work. **The OneDrive backup carry-forward anomaly tracked since R3.6 is now RESOLVED.**
**Scope:** Current operative specs, active companion specs, active build/implementation specs, active addenda/proposals, and selected active design/support docs used in the rebuild — across the primary `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` folder, the `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` folder (excluding the archived subfolder), and the `Operations Docs/` subfolder.
**Important:** **None of the documents in this registry are "final."** In this registry, **Current Operative** means "the current source of truth for active drafting, implementation, and review," not "finished forever."
**Total listed documents:** 120 (47 core registry entries + 55 active addenda/proposals + 5 integrated addenda + 2 cross-document references + 12 operations docs — UPDATED in R3.39 (+1 net for A-55 NEW DOC23 Addenda B Outcome Evaluation and Revision Architecture V2; per V2 file header SUPERSEDES A-54 R0.6.5 V1 stacked proposal, but V1 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision so A-54 row preserved ACTIVE alongside A-55 — supersession-and-replace pattern restored after R3.33 stacked-proposal one-off); previously updated R3.33 (+1 net for A-54 R0.6.5 NEW); R3.18 (+1 net for A-53 R0.6.4 NEW); see counts in §11; header total may lag — use §11 grand total as authoritative)

**R3.14 vs R3.13:** Mechanical/auto-detected re-confirmation pass — **no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.13**. R3.13 was generated 2026-05-03 ~03:10 (first pass of the day, captured A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 — a brand-new track parallel to DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization); this R3.14 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-03 ~04:05 local, second pass of the day). Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (DOC20 Addenda 4 / DOC23 Addenda 6 / DOC24 Addenda 5 / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3 / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3 / Integrated Addenda 7 / CD Cross Docs 2); no archive movements of operative specs; no new files in active `Operations Docs/`. **One substantive operations-state change:**
- **S-9 `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` mtime + size + content tick: BEHIND-by-2 → BEHIND-by-3.** mtime advanced 2026-05-02 03:47 → 2026-05-03 03:44; size 4,039 → 7,497 bytes. Per the new 2026-05-03 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.2 (released 2026-05-02 — first 2026.5.x stable)**. Alignment doc still covers through 2026.4.26; gap status now BEHIND by 3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 were not published as stable per GitHub tags API). 2026.5.2 lands plugin externalization architecture (ACPX behind `@openclaw/acpx`, diagnostics OpenTelemetry behind `@openclaw/diagnostics-otel`, broad npm/ClawHub publishing prep for Discord / MS Teams / WhatsApp / Voice Call / Memory LanceDB / Brave / Codex / Feishu); descriptor-first platform tool planner with cached plugin tool descriptors and runtime preload scoped to effective plugin IDs; ClawPack metadata flowing through install/onboarding/doctor-repair/channel-setup with digest verification; `openclaw gateway restart --force / --wait <duration>` plus active task run-ID logging before restart deferral; `threadBindings.spawnSessions` consolidation replacing split subagent/ACP toggles, with `openclaw doctor --fix legacy-key migration`; `openclaw plugins list --json` includes package dependency install state; provider-native web search now reflects configured provider rather than hard-coded Brave; Grok 4.3 added as default xAI chat model; OpenAI-compatible TTS extraBody passthrough; LM Studio reasoning metadata; broad messaging-channel fixes (WhatsApp Channel/Newsletter, Telegram topic commands, Discord, Slack threads, Signal groups, visible reply routing). **Per S-9 log notes: 2026.5.2 introduces a meaningful architectural shift in plugin packaging (npm-first cutover, externalized ACPX/diagnostics-otel, ClawPack artifact metadata) that pre-empts several DOC11 R15 R2 plugin-runtime rows and broadens DOC4 plugin architecture obligations — strong candidate for promoting from a single-release roll-forward to a deeper amendment refresh.** Recommendation: rather than continuing to defer R3, an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold in both 2026.4.29 and 2026.5.2 plus promote 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now, with a companion next-R of the running list. Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved.
- **State-tracker mtime ticks (multi-file post-R3.13 sync self-refresh + tonight's auto-refresh tasks).** S-3 `SPEC_STATE.md` advanced 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-05-03 03:14 (size 19,169 → 25,817 bytes; ~35% growth across multiple stale-row R3.x cycles + R3.13's A-50 row + S-9/S-10 row updates that R3.13 sync wrote into this file post-write). S-4 `ADDENDA_STATE.md` advanced 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-05-03 03:16 (size 14,478 → 35,042 bytes; ~142% growth — much larger because this file had been stale across multiple R3.x cycles before R3.13's catch-up rewrite added all the post-R3.6 addenda rows A-38 through A-50). S-5 `DRIFT_LOG.md` advanced 2026-05-02 03:21 → 2026-05-03 03:23 (size 56,692 → 62,827 bytes — R3.13 sync's narrative entry appended at top, ~11% growth). S-8 `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` advanced 2026-05-02 11:02 → 2026-05-03 04:04 (size 32,292 → 37,316 bytes — fifth auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Other operations files unchanged: S-7 OP-A V3.7 stable; S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md stable (no new tonight-summary entry yet — the post-R3.14 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task may still log an entry later); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED (mtime 2026-05-02 10:46, size 4,422 — see new carry-forward anomaly below).
- **NEW carry-forward anomaly: S-11 `BACKUP_LOG.md` shows no scheduled-task run tonight.** Per the file header, the daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task runs at 04:10 daily. Today's 04:10 local run should have produced either a SUCCESS entry (validating the R3.12-noted RESOLVED status of the OneDrive-mount carry-forward) or a FAILED entry (regressing the carry-forward back to "persistent failure"). Neither appears: file mtime is unchanged from 2026-05-02 10:46. Either (a) the scheduled task did not fire (cron/scheduler issue), (b) the task fired but failed silently before reaching the log-append step, or (c) the next scheduled run is later than 04:05 (R3.14 sync time) — possible if the task spec's "48 hours since last" gating policy applied (the manual-seed SUCCESS at 2026-05-02 17:46 is < 36 hours before R3.14 sync's 04:05, so the 48-hour rule may have correctly suppressed tonight's run). Pending a 4:10 trigger check. **Status:** the R3.12-noted RESOLVED status holds informationally but is NOT yet validated by an autonomous-success path log entry — that validation is now deferred to the next 04:10 run that actually fires (next eligible per 48-hour gate: 2026-05-03 17:46 or later).
- **No master-spec-list versioned-snapshot gap recurrence:** R3.13 saved its versioned snapshot correctly; this R3.14 saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.14.md` alongside its alias write. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. R3.13 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` by this R3.14 audit-cleanup pass per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" rule.
- **Carryover prompt remains V12** — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.14 introduces no structural drift beyond what V12 already covers. V12 captures both R3.12 additions (A-47/A-48/A-49) and R3.13 addition (A-50). Any V13 bump would await Will's classification of A-50 + a DOC11 R15 R3 amendment ship that absorbs 2026.5.2.

All R3.13 carry-forward items: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision (now superseded twice over by A-36 R2 and informationally by an as-yet-unauthored R3 per the strengthened S-9 recommendation); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; both DOC73 Addenda and DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient with 6 active files including A-50 the new B-track entry); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup S-11 carry-forward now PARTIALLY UNDETERMINED (R3.12 RESOLVED status holds informationally but not validated by tonight's run — see new anomaly above); R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing (acknowledged carry-forward); DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0/R4.0(1)/R4.1V1/RUNNING_ADDITIONS archive-row collapse opportunity continues at 7 archived rows + briefly-extant V1 files; A-50 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.3) classification pending; B-track vs A-track structural reorganization within §4.A6 pending. R3.14 itself adds one new carry-forward color: (1) **OpenClaw release-alignment recommendation strengthens from informational to actively warranted** — S-9 log explicitly recommends authoring a DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal that absorbs both 2026.4.29 and 2026.5.2 (the latter introduces architectural plugin-packaging shift that warrants deeper amendment refresh). Counts unchanged from R3.13 (no new files; only mtime/size refreshes). The R3.14 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.14.md` is saved by this R3.14 run; R3.13 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule.

**R3.13 vs R3.12:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — **structural drift detected**. R3.12 was generated 2026-05-02 ~16:00 (third pass of the day, captured the R4.1 V2 / R5/R6 Deferral V2 / Card Integration Map V2 cluster + S-11 success); this R3.13 pass fires the next morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-03 ~03:10 local).
- **NEW addendum `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 02:36, size 143,665 bytes — large file).** Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, and Self-Improving Task Design", **R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft**, dated 2026-05-03, parent doc DOC23 R3.1, status "Draft for architect review". Companion docs per its own header: DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 (= A-47), DOC24 R3, DOC72 R5.73, DOC25 V2.0, DOC73 V1.5.1, DOC8 v1.11.4, DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4, DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35), EC Core Addendum A V3.3, OP-A V3.7. Per its own §0.4 scope summary, Addenda B defines: (1) Task Agent as the conversational task-design / inspection / retrieval / assessment surface; (2) Task Agent education through a hybrid self-updating Task Design Intelligence substrate; (3) Task Blueprint as the semantic intent contract behind a graph; (4) reuse-first task creation through task templates and module presets; (5) DOC72 Task Activity Memory for task runs / outputs / artifacts / goals / entities / matters / follow-on sessions; (6) task telemetry and trace spans; (7) artifact/output intake policy for final and intermediate outputs; (8) DOC24 capability binding and runtime expansion for tools / connectors / MCP servers / procedures / skills / models; (9) task creation learning, Task Assessment, and self-improvement loops; (10) UI / storage / routes / validation / cross-doc obligations required to make the above real. Per §0.5 R0.3 audit-pass additions: strengthens object taxonomy (Task / Task Run / Blueprint / Template / Preset / Template Group / Workflow Package / Design Pattern / Design Case / Artifact / Work Product / Task Assessment); expands Template Group / Workflow Package concept; strengthens Task Agent education with non-monolithic `skill.md` rule + required decision-card families + explicit examples for context routing / named outputs / Carry Forward / Loop Controller / session continuation / holds / signals / email triggers / model choice / connector use; adds prior-task Casebook rules; adds minimum DOC72 work-context/entity-link capture requirements; adds explicit TaskDesignIntakeBundle and DOC24/DOC3-style task-creation intake rules; adds TaskAgentEducationProfile / TaskDesignHintCard / Spec Librarian / TaskAgentInstructionCandidate; adds goal-based design-learning records and external-benchmark capture; adds end-to-end examples. **Predecessor `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_1.md` is already in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`** (the auto pass did not detect when R0.1 → R0.3 happened — it was archived before R3.12). New row A-50 added in §4.A6 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. **This is the FIRST DOC23 Addenda B entry** — opens a brand-new track parallel to DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization. The naming convention now establishes "DOC23 Addenda A" = Task Optimization (Experiments / Judges / Prompt Optimization) and "DOC23 Addenda B" = Task Intelligence / Memory / Observability / Self-Improving Task Design.
- **Mtime ticks on R3.12-detected addenda (sizes unchanged — likely live edits or touch operations between R3.12 ~16:00 and R3.13 ~03:10).** A-47 R4.1 V2 mtime 12:34 → 19:34 (size 154,930 unchanged); A-48 R5/R6 Deferral V2 mtime 10:58 → 17:58 (size 30,631 unchanged); A-49 Card Integration Map V2 mtime 10:58 → 17:58 (size 23,341 unchanged). Existing rows in §A6 mtime annotations refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved.
- **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-8 / S-10 only this pass):** `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-05-02 04:02 → 2026-05-02 11:02 (size 32,292 unchanged — the late-morning auto-refresh tick after R3.12's noted 04:02 read; possible touch-only operation since size is identical). `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-05-02 04:04 → 2026-05-02 11:09 (size grew 4,474 → 8,501 bytes — additional auto-refresh log entries; S-10 row mtime in §7 had been stale at 2026-04-30 04:04 across multiple prior passes — now refreshed). Other operations files (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG / S-11 BACKUP_LOG / S-7 OP-A V3.7) all unchanged from R3.12 mtimes (no nightly run touched them between R3.12 and R3.13).
- **No archive movements detected:** A-47/A-48/A-49 remain active in the DOC23 Addenda subfolder; A-44 alias row remains in §A6 with R3.12's file-moved-to-archive annotation.
- **No master-spec-list versioned-snapshot gap recurrence:** R3.10/R3.11/R3.12 all saved their versioned snapshots correctly; this R3.13 saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.13.md` alongside its alias write. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. R3.11 + R3.12 versioned files moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` by this R3.13 audit-cleanup pass per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" rule.
- **Carryover prompt bumped V11 → V12** to capture the new DOC23 Addenda B track + A-47/A-48/A-49 (which V11 did not yet reflect — V11 was authored 2026-05-02 ~10:00 before the R3.12 R4.1 V2 cluster shipped).

All R3.12 carry-forward items: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; both DOC73 Addenda and DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 6 active files); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup destination NOW REACHABLE — S-11 carry-forward RESOLVED in R3.12 (stable through R3.13 — no nightly backup ran between R3.12 and R3.13 to re-confirm autonomous-success path); R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing (acknowledged carry-forward); DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0/R4.0(1)/R4.1V1/RUNNING_ADDITIONS archive-row collapse opportunity continues to grow (now 7 archived rows + briefly-extant V1 files); next manual sweep can collapse the cluster. R3.13 itself adds two new carry-forward items: (1) human classification of A-50 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending review, likely fits as final classification given file is normative end-state architectural draft per its own §0.1 — "This addendum is an end-state architectural draft. It is not an implementation phase plan."); (2) the establishment of a new DOC23 Addenda B vs A naming convention (B = Task Intelligence / Memory / Observability / Self-Improving Task Design; A = Task Optimization) which may warrant a Master Spec List structural reorganization to group both DOC23 Addenda A and B rows distinctly within §4.A6, pending human review. Counts updated: +1 active addendum (A-50), 0 net change to operations files (S-8/S-10 mtime+size+notes refresh only — same rows). The R3.13 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.13.md` is saved by this R3.13 run; R3.11 + R3.12 versioned files moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule.

**R3.12 vs R3.11:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — **substantial structural drift detected**. R3.11 was generated 2026-05-02 ~10:00 (second pass of the day, alias-only re-confirmation pass that detected no drift); this R3.12 pass fires later the same day (third pass of the day, sync run at ~16:00 local) to capture significant DOC23 Addenda subfolder iteration that occurred between 10:00 and 16:08 plus a major operations-state change in the OneDrive backup task.
- **NEW addendum `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 12:34, size 154,930 bytes — large file, ~3.7× the prior A-44 R4.0 (1) size of 41,659 bytes).** Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization", **R4.1 V2 (Draft)**, dated 2026-05-02, parent doc DOC23 R3.1, status "Draft — V2 closes 25 row gaps + 2 deviations from V1 audit. Pending Will's review against V5 adjudication card. Compiles into DOC23 R3.2." Companion to Prop-A R6.3 (DSPy self-improvement engine — independent pathway), DOC24 R3 (capability/context architecture), DOC25 V1.0 (Document Intelligence). Research basis: CheckEval (EMNLP 2025), FLASK (ICLR 2024), RULERS (2025), G-Eval (EMNLP 2023), CyclicJudge (2025), MT-Bench (Zheng et al. 2023), GEPA (Agrawal et al. 2026 ICLR Oral). Per its own §A1 framing: closes contract for five capabilities (Experiments, Claim Extraction, Judges, Sub-Agent Awareness, Prompt Optimization — the last one explicitly RESERVED FOR R5; R4.1 ships no operative DSPy runtime, no `optimization_out` port, no Promote mutation) plus two cross-cutting capabilities (DOC24 Context Injection §A8, Session Continuity §A9). Per its own §A1 scope statement: R4.1 = contract closure + schema cleanup + safety items + minimum context-management subset that makes Pattern 7 runnable; R4.1 does NOT add the optimization platform (deferred R5), human evaluation (R5), code-based scorers (R5), full Context Management Proposal V1 substrate (R5), or campaigns/dataset library (R6). New row A-47 added in §4.A6 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. **A-47 supersedes A-44 (R4.0 (1))** in the DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 → R4.0(1) → R4.1 V1 → R4.1 V2 chain.
- **NEW addendum `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 30,631 bytes).** Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — R5 / R6 Deferral List V2", date 2026-05-02, status "Pre-adjudication — will be revised after Will fills the V5 Decision column to V3 (post-adjudication)." Companion to `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_ADJUDICATION_CARD_V5.md` (V5 = 238 rows, up from 233 in V4). V2 changes per file: updated to reference card V5; added §1.O lazy claim verification (card row #234); added §1.P hierarchical scoring for huge variants (card row #235); updated §1.N Context Management Proposal V1 to include OB-A15 (card row #238); §1.M2 R4.1 portion now includes validation codes from cards #236, #237; added §6 Calibration items for R5 (proposal §14, six items). Scope per file: R4.1 = immediate contract closure (177 rows + 23 NON_OPERATIVE_R4.1 text removals); R5 = next major revision (29 dedicated rows + R5 portions of 6 hybrids + 2 §8 Notes substantive R5 implementations + 1 separate addenda doc); R6 = later (4 rows). Three top-level sections: §1 R5 work plan grouped by functional area A–N, §2 R6 work plan (4 items), §3 external documents that compile into R5/R6. New row A-48 added in §4.A6 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. **A-48 V2 supersedes a briefly-extant V1** (V1 mtime 2026-05-02 09:58, size 24,682 bytes — created and moved to archive in the same window per the V2 changelog reference; archived path `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V1.md`).
- **NEW addendum `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_CONTEXT_MGMT_PROPOSAL_V1_TO_CARD_INTEGRATION_MAP_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 23,341 bytes).** Per file header: "Context Management Proposal V1 → V5 Card Integration Map V2 — A section-by-section accounting of the Context Management Proposal V1 against the V5 adjudication card. For each section of the proposal, this map tells you: where (if anywhere) it lives in the card, what release it's scheduled for, and whether it's tracked at row level or only by reference." Date 2026-05-02, status "Complete. All proposal spec content is accounted for — either as a card row or a deferral list entry." V2 changes per file: V1 identified 5 candidate elevations and 6 calibration items as work needed in V5 of the card; card V5 absorbed all 5 elevations as rows #234–#238; calibration items moved to deferral list §6. Source documents: A-45 `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_CONTEXT_MANAGEMENT_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (1,022 lines, 17 sections, dated 2026-05-01) — the proposal; the V5 card (238 rows, 14 sections, dated 2026-05-02 — not registered in master spec list, lives in a not-yet-tracked location); A-48 R5/R6 deferral list V2 — companion. Closed-loop integration map. New row A-49 added in §4.A6 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. (Note: this is a meta/navigation document mapping A-45 sections to the V5 card; like A-34 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1, it may warrant reclassification as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / NAVIGATION / REFERENCE` rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` — file is non-normative by purpose.)
- **A-44 row (DOC23 Task Optimization R4.0 (1)) annotated for file-moved-to-archive.** R3.9 had moved A-44 from §A1 root to the new §A6 DOC23 Addenda subfolder, treating A-44 as the operative R4.0 going forward. R3.12 sync detects A-44 is no longer in the DOC23 Addenda subfolder; archive listing confirms it is now at `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime preserved 2026-04-30 23:44, size unchanged 41,659 bytes). Disposition: superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2; the brief R4.1 V1 (created and archived in same window) was an intermediate step. A-44 alias row in §A6 is preserved with file-moved-to-archive annotation, mirroring the A-43 archival pattern from R3.9.
- **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-11 only this pass — others did not run between R3.11 and R3.12).** `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) advanced 2026-05-01 04:17 → 2026-05-02 10:47, size 2,366 → 4,422 bytes (~87% growth) across two new entries: (1) third consecutive scheduled `failed` entry at 2026-05-02 04:17 local (UTC 11:17) with same root cause as 2026-04-30 / 2026-05-01 entries — bash sandbox mount only exposes `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, not `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/`; (2) **first SUCCESS entry**, manual seed backup at 2026-05-02 10:46 local (UTC 17:46) — archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` (4.84 MB compressed from 16 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation not needed (1 backup total). Per the success entry's notes: after three consecutive failures, Will mounted the OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared folder via Cowork's chat-box "+" connector (mounting it at `/sessions/<id>/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/`); manual backup run from interactive session succeeded; the scheduled task SKILL has been updated to use the workspace-mount path resolution so future autonomous runs will work. Other operations log files (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG) all unchanged from R3.11 mtimes (no nightly run between R3.11 ~10:00 and R3.12 ~16:00; their next refresh will be the next nightly sync state-file pass).

All R3.11 carry-forward items: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision (now superseded twice over — by A-36 R2 and informationally by S-9 log's recommendation to author R3); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; both DOC73 Addenda and DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda subfolder gap especially salient now with R3.12 adding 3 more files there for a total of 5 active files); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; **OneDrive backup destination NOW REACHABLE — S-11 carry-forward RESOLVED** (per file's success entry, scheduled task SKILL.md updated to use workspace-mount path resolution); R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing (acknowledged carry-forward); DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0/R4.0 (1)/Running-Additions archive-row collapse deferred — list of archived rows now grows to 6 (A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 from R3.9 + A-44 from R3.12 + briefly-extant R4.1 V1 not yet given a row) plus briefly-extant R5/R6 Deferral V1 (also not given a row); next manual sweep can collapse the cluster. R3.12 itself adds two new carry-forward items: (1) human classification of A-47/A-48/A-49 (placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending review); (2) A-49's file-purpose-vs-classification mismatch (file is meta/navigation by its own header, like A-34, may warrant reclassification). Counts updated: +3 active addenda (A-47/A-48/A-49), 0 net change to operations files (S-11 mtime+size+notes refresh only — same row, status flag flipped from "persistent failure" to "RESOLVED — first success" effectively but row's `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` status preserved per task spec). The R3.12 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.12.md` is saved by this R3.12 run alongside the existing R3.10 + R3.11 snapshots.

**R3.11 vs R3.10:** Mechanical/auto-detected re-confirmation pass — **no structural changes since R3.10**. R3.10 was generated 2026-05-02 ~03:16; this R3.11 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-02 ~10:00 local). Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (DOC20 Addenda / DOC23 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs); no archive movements (Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress folder unchanged); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`. Three post-R3.10 mtime deltas, all from neighbouring nightly tasks that ran after the R3.10 sync completed:
- `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) mtime 2026-05-02 03:21 — append by the same R3.10 sync run that generated this registry (R3.10's own ~10:05 entry was written into DRIFT_LOG post-write to log the R3.10 detections); size grew 40,253 → 56,692 bytes (~41% — the R3.10 narrative entry is large because it documents 4 archive moves + new subfolder + 2 new addenda + state-tracker backfill + versioned-snapshot backfill); no master-spec-list registry effect.
- `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) mtime 2026-05-02 03:47 — append-only log entry by the nightly OpenClaw release-alignment scheduled task; size grew 2,538 → 4,039 bytes. New 2026-05-02 entry advances the "latest stable release" reference from 2026.4.27 to **2026.4.29 (2026-04-29)**; gap status now BEHIND by 2 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29; 2026.4.28 was not published per GitHub tag listing). Architecturally significant carry-over items still un-folded: 2026.4.29's active-run steering / visible-reply enforcement / spawned subagent routing metadata, people-aware memory wiki with provenance views, per-conversation Active Memory filters, bounded REM preview diagnostics, heartbeat follow-up commitments, tmux-backed gateway:watch, opt-in startup diagnostics timeline; plus 2026.4.27's Codex Computer Use, DeepInfra bundled provider, plugin lifecycle hardening, LINE inbound media path. Likely spec touchpoints: DOC11, DOC15, DOC10, DOC20/22, DOC24, DOC25, EC Core. Recommendation in the log: next R of `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` and an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal (currently A-36 R2 — would become A-? R3) to fold 2026.4.29 in and promote 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now. **No new R3 amendment file has been authored yet — recommendation is informational only.** Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved.
- `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) mtime 2026-05-02 04:02 — auto-refresh by the nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh scheduled task; size grew 25,227 → 32,292 bytes (~28%). No master-spec-list registry effect.

All R3.10 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision (likely supersession by A-36 R2; may be further superseded by a forthcoming R3 per S-9 log recommendation); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; both DOC73 Addenda and DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG S-11 unchanged from R3.10 — no nightly run between R3.10 and R3.11; no third `failed` entry yet); R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing (acknowledged carry-forward); DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0/Running-Additions archive-row collapse deferred. R3.11 itself does NOT introduce any new carry-forward items. Counts unchanged from R3.10. The R3.11 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.11.md` is saved by this R3.11 run alongside the existing R3.10 snapshot.

**R3.10 vs R3.9:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — minor structural drift detected. R3.9 was generated 2026-05-01 ~23:14 (alias-only bump; versioned snapshot was missing — backfilled by this R3.10 run as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.9.md`). This R3.10 pass fires the next morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-02 ~10:00 local).
- **NEW addendum `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 00:31, size 22,818 bytes).** New file in the DOC23 Addenda subfolder (folder added in R3.9). Per file header: "DOC23 Red Line — Sequential Re-Prompt System", date 2026-05-01, status "Draft addendum for compilation into DOC23 R3.2." Affects: §3.2.1 (step.agent_task), §3.2.8 (step.coding), §6.5.2 (agent task execution), §6.5.8 (coding execution), §4.5 (output popups), §4.8 (validation). Latest entry in DOC23 addendum cluster (alongside A-44 = R4.0 (1) canonical relocated to subfolder, A-45 = Judge Context Management Proposal V1). New row A-46 added in §4.A6 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **NEW mockup variant `Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx` (mtime 2026-05-01 21:54, size 180,080 bytes).** New file in `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/`. The "ALT_A" suffix suggests a parallel A/B variant rather than a strict supersession; both V11.0 (147,393 bytes) and V11_ALT_A coexist. Likely tied to the DOC23 addendum cluster shipping in the same window (A-45 Judge Context Management Proposal V1 mtime 2026-05-01 17:26; A-46 Re-Prompt System Addendum mtime 2026-05-02 00:31). Master spec list does not formally track mockups (they live in design folder); referenced here in changelog only.
- **R3.9 versioned snapshot backfilled.** The R3.9 alias bump (2026-05-01 ~23:14) registered version revision in alias content but did NOT save a versioned snapshot file (carry-forward gap pattern from prior R3.5 / R3.6 alias bumps). R3.10 sync saves the pre-bump alias content (representing R3.9 state) as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.9.md` to preserve the snapshot. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (acknowledged carry-forward — preserved only via R3.6.md narrative section).
- **State-tracker mtime ticks:** `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) advanced 2026-04-30 11:16 → 2026-05-01 11:17, size 1,159 → 2,366 bytes (second consecutive `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` entry recorded by the daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task at 2026-05-01 11:16 UTC; same root cause as the 2026-04-30 entry; OneDrive sandbox-visibility issue still unresolved). `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) advanced 2026-04-30 10:42 → 2026-05-01 10:42, size 1,013 → 2,538 bytes (additional log entry from 2026-05-01 nightly OpenClaw release-alignment scheduled task). `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-04-30 11:01 → 2026-05-01 11:00, size 18,228 → 25,227 bytes (third auto-refresh tick). `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-04-30 10:55 → 2026-05-01 11:04, size 1,947 → 4,474 bytes.
- **State-tracker backfill in operations folder:** SPEC_STATE.md and ADDENDA_STATE.md updated by this R3.10 sync to reflect the R3.9 alias bump's DOC23 archive movements (rows A-38/A-39/A-40/A-41 in ADDENDA_STATE.md annotated as file-moved-to-archive; A-42 annotated as relocated to new DOC23 Addenda subfolder), the new DOC23 Addenda subfolder (formal §A.6 subsection added), and the two new addenda (A-43 Judge Context Management Proposal V1 + A-44 Re-Prompt System Addendum in ADDENDA_STATE.md numbering — note ID asymmetry vs master spec list A-45/A-46 numbering, intentional per the prior R3.4 changelog convention). Prior R3.9 alias bump did not flow these through to SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md trackers; R3.10 sync corrects.
- **No other structural drift detected:** No new specs in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new files in DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda subfolders or Integrated Addenda or CD Cross Docs; no archive movements of operative specs or operations files; the four other state-tracker files in active `Operations Docs/` (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-7 OP-A V3.7) unchanged from R3.9 mtimes prior to this run (state-trackers will be updated by this run itself).

All R3.9 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (now joined by the DOC23 Addenda subfolder added in R3.9 — same gap); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG continues to record `failed` — count now 2). Counts incremented from R3.9: +1 active addendum (A-46 new in master numbering), 0 net change to operations files (only mtime/size refreshes).

**R3.9 vs R3.8:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — **substantial structural drift detected**. R3.8 was generated 2026-05-01 ~04:06; this R3.9 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-01 ~10:30 local) to capture significant reorganization of the DOC23 Task Optimization cluster.
- **Four DOC23 Task Optimization files moved from active root to archive (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30):** `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` (A-40, mtime now 2026-04-30 13:43, size 61,420 bytes), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` (A-41, mtime now 2026-04-30 16:40, size 24,266 bytes), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (A-42, mtime now 2026-04-30 17:57, size 108,578 bytes), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` (A-43, mtime now 2026-04-30 22:50, size 52,949 bytes) — all four now in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. R3.8 had flagged all four for likely archival; that disposition is now executed (manual or external move). Rows A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 in §4.A1 preserved with file-moved-to-archive annotations mirroring the A-2/A-3/A-12/A-25 supersession patterns.
- **NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder created in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`** (folder mtime 2026-05-01 10:27). Subfolder is structurally analogous to the existing DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda subfolders. Contains 2 files: (1) `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime 2026-04-30 23:44, size 41,659 bytes) — same file that was registered as A-44 at the addenda-folder root in R3.8, now relocated into this subfolder; (2) `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_CONTEXT_MANAGEMENT_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 10:26, size 53,884 bytes) — entirely new file dated 2026-05-01, per its own header titled "DOC23 Addenda A R4.0 — Judge Context Management Proposal V1" by Claude Opus 4.7, target compilation revision DOC23 Addenda A R4.1, status "Draft proposal — pending review, calibration, red team, and compilation into R4.1." A-44 row in §4.A1 preserved with file-moved-to-§A6 annotation; new §4.A6 subsection added with new row A-45 for the context-management proposal. As with the DOC73 Addenda subfolder added in R2.9, the in-scope folder list in the nightly sync task SKILL.md needs human update to formally include the new `DOC23 Addenda/` path.
- **BACKUP_LOG.md (S-11) mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30):** mtime advanced 2026-04-30 04:16 → 2026-05-01 04:17; size grew 1,159 → 2,366 bytes. Per file content: scheduled `elnor-onedrive-backup` task ran for the second consecutive day at 2026-05-01 11:16 (UTC) and recorded another `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` entry — same root cause as the 2026-04-30 entry (OneDrive Personal cloud path not visible to bash sandbox; per task spec constraint #4 no fallback write to local-only paths was performed). Now 2 consecutive failures logged; per the second entry's notes Will needs to add the OneDrive Personal folder (or `~/Library/CloudStorage/`) to Cowork's connected directories before this task can succeed. Row S-11 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status preserved.
- **No other structural drift detected:** No new specs in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new files in DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda subfolders or Integrated Addenda or CD Cross Docs; no archive movements in Operations Docs; the seven other state-tracker files in active `Operations Docs/` (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG) all unchanged from R3.8 mtimes (no nightly refresh tick between 04:06 and 10:30 today).

All R3.8 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (now joined by the NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder which has the same gap); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG continues to record `failed` — count now 2); DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0 archival decisions deferred from R3.8 are now resolved (all moved); A-44 vs A-43 canonical-determination question (which of two R4.0 files was canonical) is partially resolved by the move pattern — A-43 (the no-suffix file, larger, older mtime) was archived alongside A-40/A-41/A-42, while A-44 (the (1)-suffix file, smaller, newer mtime) was kept in active state and relocated into the new DOC23 Addenda subfolder. This suggests Will treats A-44's content as canonical R4.0 going forward; A-43's content remains in archive for reference. Counts incremented from R3.8: +1 active addendum (A-45 new), 0 net change to operations files (S-11 unchanged in count, just mtime refresh).

**R3.8 vs R3.7:** Mechanical/auto-detected re-confirmation pass — **no structural changes since R3.7**. R3.7 was generated 2026-05-01 03:15; this R3.8 pass fires later the same day per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-01 ~04:30 local). Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs); no archive movements; no new files in active `Operations Docs/`. Post-R3.7 mtime deltas are all from neighbouring nightly tasks that ran after the R3.7 sync completed:
- `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) mtime 2026-05-01 03:20 — refresh by the same R3.7 sync run that generated this registry (registered post-write to log the R3.7 detections); no content effect.
- `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) mtime 2026-05-01 03:42 — append-only log entry by the nightly OpenClaw release-alignment scheduled task; no registry effect.
- `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) mtime 2026-05-01 04:00 — auto-refresh by the nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh scheduled task; no registry effect.
- `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) mtime 2026-05-01 04:04 — append-only log entry by the same nightly task as S-8 above; no registry effect.

All R3.7 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG continues to record `failed` — last entry 2026-04-30 04:16, no new run since); DOC23 Task Optimization R4.0 vs R4.0 (1) duplicate-name disposition unchanged (A-43 still treated as primary, A-44 held informationally pending human disposition); A-40 (R2.0) and A-41 (R3.0) still flagged for likely supersession by A-43; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing per R3.7 changelog. Counts unchanged from R3.7.

**R3.7 vs R3.6:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — substantial structural drift detected. Since R3.6 was generated (2026-04-30 23:09):
- **NEW addendum `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 23:40, size 24,266 bytes).** Supersedes A-40 (R2.0 — added in R3.6) per filename pattern. Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization", **R3.0 (Draft)**. Size ~60% smaller than R2.0 (61,420 → 24,266 bytes) — possibly a tighter rewrite or partial revision. New row A-41 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. A-40 row annotated for likely supersession by A-41 and A-43.
- **NEW addendum `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 00:57, size 108,578 bytes — large file).** New file in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root folder. Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Running Additions for R3.0 — Staging document for changes to compile into the next revision of DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization). Items are added during iterative discussion and compiled in batch." Companion to A-41 (R3.0) and A-43 (R4.0). Likely the source-of-truth for items being incrementally compiled into the R3.0 → R4.0 → next-revision pipeline. Note: file header references "for R3.0" but R4.0 (A-43) shipped 2026-05-01 05:50 — staging doc may need re-targeting. New row A-42 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **NEW addendum `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 05:50, size 52,949 bytes).** Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) and A-41 (R3.0) per filename pattern. Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization", **R4.0 (Draft)**. Most recent revision in the DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 chain (all three revisions shipped within ~16 hours). Treat as the latest DOC23 Task Optimization addendum going forward pending human disposition. New row A-43 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. A-40 (R2.0) and A-41 (R3.0) annotated for supersession by A-43.
- **NEW addendum `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-01 06:44, size 41,659 bytes).** Duplicate-name R4.0 file. Filename includes "(1)" suffix, typically generated by macOS when downloading a file whose name already exists. Content NOT identical to A-43 (`diff -q` confirms files differ; sizes differ by ~21%). Both files coexist in active folder. Possible explanations: (a) Will downloaded a different draft mid-stream; (b) two parallel revisions both labeled R4.0; (c) prior R4.0 was overwritten externally then re-downloaded. Human disposition needed: which file is canonical R4.0? Until then, A-43 (the file without the suffix) is treated as the primary and A-44 is held informationally. New row A-44 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. Sync did NOT delete or rename either file per task constraint #1 (never delete).
- **State-tracker backfill in operations folder:** SPEC_STATE.md and ADDENDA_STATE.md updated by this R3.7 sync to add rows for S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (R3.5), S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (R3.5), S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (R3.6), and A-38 DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 (R3.6). Prior R3.5 / R3.6 alias bumps registered these in the alias content but did not flow them through to SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md trackers. R3.7 sync corrects that drift.
- **Versioned-file backfill:** R3.5 and R3.6 alias bumps registered version revisions in alias content but did NOT save versioned snapshot files (the `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.5.md` and `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.6.md` snapshots were missing). R3.7 sync saves the pre-bump alias content (which represented R3.6 state) as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.6.md` to preserve at least one versioned snapshot for the R3.5/R3.6 changes. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (carry-forward — preserved only via R3.6.md narrative section); recommend Will accept this gap or manually reconstruct R3.5 if a discrete snapshot is wanted.
- **No other structural drift detected:** No new specs in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new addenda in DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs subfolders; no archive movements; no new files in active `Operations Docs/` (only mtime refreshes to SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG by this run itself).
- All R3.6 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG continues to record `failed`).

**R3.6 vs R3.5:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — minor structural drift detected. Since R3.5 was generated (2026-04-30 04:08):
- **NEW addendum `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 13:43, size 61,420 bytes).** New file in the active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root folder. Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization", **R2.0 (Draft)**, dated 2026-04-02, parent document DOC23 R3.1, companion to Prop-A R6.3 (DSPy self-improvement engine). Defines three composable capabilities as DOC23 modules: (1) `system.experiment` — runs 2–4 variant configurations of a target module against the same input with per-variant output ports; (2) `step.judge` — scores outputs on user-defined dimensions with structured audit trails; (3) DSPy-integrated prompt optimization that uses judge scores to suggest improved prompt bodies. Status header notes "not yet compiled into DOC23." New row A-40 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **NEW Operations file `BACKUP_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 04:16, size 1,159 bytes — small file).** Append-only log of the automated daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task (runs at 04:10 daily; new backup created only if 48+ hours since last; destination `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`; keeps most recent 3). First entry recorded 2026-04-30 11:16 (UTC) with status `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` — `mkdir -p` on the destination failed with permission denied because `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/` is not visible to the bash sandbox in the run; per task spec no fallback write to local-only paths was performed; source folder unchanged; retry on next scheduled run. New row S-11 added in §7 as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human classification.
- **No other structural drift detected:** No new specs in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new addenda in any tracked subfolder of `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` other than the new top-level DOC23 R2.0 file (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs all unchanged); no archive movements; no state-tracker mtime changes since the R3.5 pass (S-3 SPEC_STATE.md, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md, S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md all unchanged from R3.5).
- All R3.5 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location.

**R3.5 vs R3.4:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — minor structural drift detected. Since R3.4 was generated (2026-04-30 03:15):
- **NEW Operations file `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 03:42, size 1,013 bytes — small file).** Append-only log of nightly OpenClaw release-alignment checks; first entry recorded 2026-04-30 10:42 (UTC) noting alignment-doc coverage through 2026.4.26 (per DOC11 R15 R2 amendment proposal A-36), latest stable release 2026.4.27, gap status BEHIND by one release. Companion to S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md and to A-1/A-36 (DOC11 R15 amendment proposals). New row S-9 added in §7 as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human classification.
- **NEW Operations file `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 04:04, size 1,947 bytes — small file).** Append-only log of nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refreshes; first auto-refresh entry recorded 2026-04-30 10:55 (UTC). Companion to S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (which was itself refreshed in the same window — mtime now 2026-04-30 04:01, size grew from 15,496 → 18,228 bytes per the auto-refresh). New row S-10 added in §7 as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human classification.
- **State files refreshed (mtimes only — no registry effect):** `SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-04-30 03:08; size 19,169 → 21,993 bytes), `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-04-30 03:09; size 14,478 → 20,040 bytes), `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 03:23 → 2026-04-30 03:20; size 29,727 → 40,253 bytes). These are S-3, S-4, S-5 tracker files — content updates from this same nightly sync run, no row content change.
- **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime refresh (informational):** Per the new RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md log, this file was promoted from manual-only to nightly-auto-refresh in this pass; size grew ~18% in the refresh.
- No new specs in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root; no new addenda in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs); no archive movements.
- All R3.4 carry-forward items remain open: A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly unchanged; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location.

**R3.4 vs R3.3:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump — structural drift detected. Since R3.3 was generated (2026-04-29 11:08):
- **NEW addendum `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 00:45, size 77,777 bytes — ~52% larger than R1's 51,307 bytes).** Supersedes A-1 (original DOC11 R15 amendment proposal) which remains in active folder pending human archival decision. New row A-36 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification (mirrors PACER A-8 → A-28 supersession pattern). A-1 row annotated for likely supersession by A-36.
- **NEW addendum `DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R2.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 18:28, size 83,554 bytes — ~71% larger than R1's 48,797 bytes).** Supersedes A-25 (DOC72 Continuity Synthesis Architecture R1 — same ID in master and ADDENDA_STATE.md). Predecessor R1 file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. New row A-37 added in §4.A4 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **NEW addendum `DOC73_PROPOSAL_SECTION_6_4_MECHANISM_4_ROLLUP_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 18:31, size 26,669 bytes).** Per file header: standalone handoff document targeting DOC73 V1.5.1 §6.4 Mechanism 4 (currently named but undefined). Origin: identified as a gap during CSA R2 (DOC72 Continuity Synthesis Architecture R2) drafting — companion to A-37. Specifies output file `ELNOR_MEMORY/rollup/recent_activity.md` refreshed nightly via single LLM call (Kimi or local Ollama, <$0.01/day). New row A-38 added in §4.A5 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **NEW addendum `DOC73_V1_6_ADJUDICATION_CARD_ARCHITECT_NOTES_V1 (1).md` (mtime 2026-04-30 04:14, size 6,441 bytes — small file, 73 lines).** Likely architect notes / adjudication card for the upcoming DOC73 V1.5.1 → V1.6 red-team round. Filename includes "(1)" suffix suggesting Will may have copied from Downloads. New row A-39 added in §4.A5 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **NEW Operations file `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 19:05, size 15,496 bytes).** New file appeared in active `Operations Docs/` folder. Likely a Will-authored summary of recent work (2026-04-29 evening session). Not a tracker file; treat as informational support doc until human classifies. New row S-6 added in §7 as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human classification.
- **DOC72 Continuity Synthesis R1 file moved to archive (auto-detected 2026-04-30):** `DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R1.md` (registry row A-25) → archived; superseded by R2 (new row A-37). Row preserved with file-moved annotation.
- **Carry-forward anomalies #2 and #3 RESOLVED (auto-detected 2026-04-30):**
  - DOC16 R5.3 file `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` no longer in active folder (moved to `Subsumed Specs/`) — anomaly #2 RESOLVED.
  - DOC16 16.7 R2 file `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` no longer in active folder (moved to `Subsumed Specs/`) — anomaly #3 RESOLVED.
  - DOC16 R5.4 file IS PRESENT in active folder (mtime 2026-04-09 22:47, size 245,927 bytes; hardlink count 2) — anomaly #1 (claim that R5.4 is missing) was likely stale; file may have been present all along.
  - SPEC_STATE.md DOC16 R5.3 and DOC16 16.7 R2 rows REMOVED per task spec; DOC16 R5.4 row updated mechanically with file-present mtime + Notes annotation. Master spec list row 30 (DOC16 R5.4) judgment fields preserved — needs human review of R5.4 status (currently FUTURE / PLANNING DRAFT; file is present and active).
- Carry-forward anomalies remaining: DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 in master list still cites old active-folder path; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope list.

**R3.3 vs R3.2:** Mechanical/auto-detected re-confirmation pass — **no structural changes since R3.2**. R3.2 was generated 2026-04-29 03:16; this R3.3 pass fires later the same day per the scheduled-task cadence. Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/`; no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any of its tracked subfolders (DOC20 / DOC24 / DOC72 / DOC73 / Integrated / CD Cross Docs); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`. The only post-R3.2 mtime delta is `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 03:23 — a state-tracking refresh by the same nightly sync run that generated R3.2 itself, registered as row S-5 with no content effect on the registry). All R3.2 carry-forward anomalies and pending-human-classification placeholders (rows 39b, 40b, 43b; A-31 archived predecessor of A-32; A-34 reference-document reclassification; A-35 consolidation supersession of A-2/A-3/A-12/A-33; S-2b OP-A V3.7) remain open. Counts unchanged from R3.2.

**R3.2 vs R3.1:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump only — no human-classified content judgments changed. Structural drift since R3.1 was generated (R3.1 generated 2026-04-28 23:09):
- **DOC73 V1.5.1 SHIPPED (2026-04-29).** New file `DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md` in active folder (mtime 2026-04-29 04:36; size 663,684 bytes — ~187 KB larger than V1.4.1's 476 KB). Predecessor `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. Placeholder row 43b added in §3.L as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human re-classification (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT once Will confirms; per CLAUDE.md V1.4.1 was operative — successor V1.5.1 likely promotes immediately). Row 43 (V1.4.1) preserved with file-moved annotation, mirroring the DOC23 R3.0 / DOC24 R2.5 pattern from R2.8/R2.9.
- **OP-A bumped to V3.7 (2026-04-29).** New file `DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_7.md` in active `Operations Docs/` (mtime 2026-04-29 05:15; size 244,079 bytes — ~71 KB larger than V3.6). All prior V3.x files (V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5, V3.6) plus V2 are now in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`. Companion patch document `OP_A_V3_6_TO_V3_7_PATCH_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 04:58, 83,154 bytes) sits in archive subfolder. §7 row S-1 updated mechanically: V2 path corrected to archive subfolder, V3.6 superseded by V3.7, new sub-row added for V3.7 active version.
- **NEW addendum `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (2026-04-29).** Filename drops `_PROPOSAL_V1` suffix → likely the post-RT consolidated R2.2. Three predecessors (V1, V2, V3 of the proposal) all in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. New row A-35 added in §4.A1 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification.
- **Three predecessor addendum files moved to archive (auto-detected 2026-04-29):**
  - `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (registry row A-2) → archived; superseded by V2/V3 then by consolidated A-35.
  - `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_SEMANTIC SKILLS R2_1.md` (registry row A-3) → archived; possibly subsumed by A-35.
  - `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (registry row A-12) → archived; possibly subsumed by A-35.
  - `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (R3.1 row A-31) → archived per R3.1 prediction; superseded by V1.1 (R3.1 row A-32).
  - `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md` (R3.1 row A-33) and V3 → both in archive; superseded by consolidated A-35.
  - All affected registry rows annotated with file-moved markers, mirroring the A-8 PACER pattern. Judgment fields preserved.
- **DOC23 mockup bumped to V11.0 (2026-04-28).** New file `Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_0.jsx` in `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/` (mtime 2026-04-28 04:16). Likely the DOC23 R3.1 companion mockup (R3.1 mtime 2026-04-28 03:43 — same window). V10.9, V10.8, V10.5, V10.4 all remain alongside. SPEC_STATE.md Build Surface row updated.
- Carry-forward anomalies from R2.4–R3.1 unchanged. The DOC73 V1.4.1 → V1.5.1 transition partially resolves the long-standing R2.7-era anomaly that DOC73 V1.4.1 was labeled `CONCEPT DRAFT` despite being operative; the operative status decision now reverts to a fresh judgment call on V1.5.1.

**R3.1 vs R3.0:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump only — no human-classified content judgments changed. Four new files detected in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` since the R3.0 pass (R3.0 generated 2026-04-28 04:10). Three new top-level addenda rows added: (1) A-31 `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 13:57) — file present but superseded by V1.1 in same folder; (2) A-32 `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1_1.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 15:48) — supersedes V1, targets DOC25 V2.0 with file-materialization tri-state, expanded sync-provider profiles; (3) A-33 `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 11:43) — supersedes A-2 V1 (Patch A applied, 18-item red team adjudication); (4) A-34 `ELNOR_SEARCH_ARCHITECTURE_REFERENCE_R1.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 15:27) — non-normative reference document synthesizing search routing across DOC24/DOC16 16.7/V4/DOC25/DOC18/DOC72/DOC73; per its own header it modifies nothing and is NOT an operative spec — likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / REFERENCE rather than PROPOSED ADDENDUM. Row A-2 (DOC3 R11.3 R2.2 Proposal V1) annotated for likely supersession by A-33; A-31 (DOC25 File Materialization V1) annotated for likely supersession by A-32. Both predecessors remain in active folder pending human archival decision. Carry-forward anomalies from R2.4–R3.0 unchanged.

**R3.0 vs R2.9:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump only — no human-classified content judgments changed. Three deferred detections from R2.9 are reflected here without reclassification: (1) `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (registry row A-12) was already in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` at R2.9 time but the R2.9 auto pass did not catch the move — A-12 row preserved with a file-moved annotation pending human re-classification, mirroring the A-8 PACER pattern; (2) `DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V2.md` (registry row S-1 in §7) and the V3 / V3.2 / V3.3 versions have all been moved to `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` — only V3.4, V3.5, V3.6 remain in the active `Operations Docs/` folder, mtimes 2026-04-26; S-1 row preserved with a file-moved annotation pending human re-classification (judgment fields preserved, mirroring R2.8 pattern); (3) new file `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:17, size 19,385 bytes) appeared in active `Operations Docs/` after R2.9 was generated — flagged as new state-tracking artifact, no registry slot yet. Two state files first noted in R2.9 changelog (`SPEC_STATE.md`, `ADDENDA_STATE.md`) remain unregistered in §7 pending human classification. Carry-forward anomalies from R2.4–R2.9 unchanged.

**R2.9 vs R2.8:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump only — no human-classified content judgments changed. Adds a placeholder row 39b for the newly-appeared `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_1.md` (2026-04-28) in §3.J as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human re-classification (the prior R3.0 file has moved to `Subsumed Specs/`). Adds three new top-level addenda rows (A-27 EC Core Addendum A Intake Routing for Corpus Bindings Proposal V1; A-28 PACER Plugin Spec V1.1; A-29 Cross-Spec Issues Punch List V1). Adds new §4.A5 subsection for the newly-appeared `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolder containing one file (A-30 DOC73 Corpus Source Bindings Proposal V1). The `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md` V1.0 file (A-8) has moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`; A-8 row preserved with a file-moved annotation pending human re-classification. The new `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolder is structurally analogous to the existing `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolder; the in-scope folder list in the nightly sync task SKILL.md needs human update to formally include this path. Carry-forward anomalies from R2.8 unchanged.

**R2.8 vs R2.7:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump only — no human-classified content judgments changed. Adds a placeholder row for the newly-appeared `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md` (2026-04-27) in §3.J as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human re-classification (the prior R2.5 file has moved to `Subsumed Specs/`). Adds anomalies in §10 for: DOC15 Contract R3.1 file moved out of active folder to `Subsumed Specs/` per V5 carryover (registry §3 row 27 + §8 reading-pack references still point at the old path); OP-A V2 file referenced in §7 is still in folder but superseded in practice by V3.x series (V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5, V3.6 — all in `Operations Docs/` with mtime 2026-04-27); two OP-A consolidation session reports new in `Operations Docs/`. None of these are reclassified by the auto pass — flagged for the next human sweep.

---

## 1. How to read this registry

### Status legend

- **CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT** — current owner/spec source of truth for active work in that area; not final.
- **ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT** — current companion or integration contract that must be read with one or more owner specs.
- **ACTIVE BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION DRAFT** — current implementation/build sequencing or wiring document used by coding agents.
- **SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT** — active support, audit, appendix, or preservation document; does not outrank owner specs on conflicts.
- **FUTURE / PLANNING DRAFT** — active deferred or future-state planning document; useful for roadmap and later revision waves, but not present-tense owner truth.
- **CONCEPT DRAFT** — pre-spec architectural concept under red-team review; not an operative spec until it graduates.
- **PROPOSED ADDENDUM** — proposed addendum/amendment against an existing operative spec; pending integration into its parent.
- **INTEGRATED ADDENDUM** — an addendum/proposal whose content has already been merged into a parent spec; retained for traceability only.

### Owner type legend

- **PRIMARY OWNER** — the main doc that owns a subsystem or domain.
- **SHARED OWNER** — one of several docs that jointly own a domain.
- **COMPANION / CONTRACT** — seam ledger, contract, or owner-by-owner integration map.
- **BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION** — coding/build execution guidance.
- **SUPPORT / AUDIT** — support, audit, preservation, or appendix material.
- **FUTURE / DEFERRED** — forward-looking roadmap/punch-list material.
- **ADDENDUM / PROPOSAL** — addendum/amendment/proposal against a parent spec.
- **OPERATIONS** — cross-cycle operations file (trackers, indexes used during reviews).

### Registry rule

A document does **not** become part of the active operative set until it is listed here with:
1. a status,
2. an owner type,
3. a "must read with" cluster where applicable,
4. and a replacement/supersession note when it consolidates prior revisions.

---

## 2. Front-door pack — start here for a new coding agent or reviewer

**Purpose:** These are the documents a new coding agent or reviewer should read first to understand the ELNOR system architecture, the Q frontend/backend stack, and the current state of every major subsystem. They are ordered by architectural dependency — start at the top.

**When to use this list:** When onboarding a new agent, starting a new build session, or orienting before a cross-doc review. For task-specific work, use the reading packs in §6 instead.

1. `EC_Core_Specs_Rebuild_R1.md` — core architecture, durable state model, command ingestion
2. `Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC_v1_11_2_CANONICAL.md` — canonical Q frontend/backend spec
3. `DOC21 (UI) Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R7.md` — master UI spec
4. `DOC22 (UI) Q_UI_PAGE_INVENTORY_AND_DESIGN_TEMPLATE_R4.md` — page inventory and design template
5. `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md` — orchestration substrate
6. `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md` — gateway/runtime truth
7. `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md` — rooms and multi-agent
8. `DOC1_Memory Resilience Rebuild_R1.md` — memory lifecycle
9. `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md` — app skills and MCP
10. `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` — CIL/learning
11. `DOC20_R4_3.md` — browser, notes, document viewer, workspace shell, skills & connectors
12. `RUNNING_BRIEF_REMEDIATION_v6.md` — running brief, context injection pipeline, OCM
13. `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_0.md` — task/automation system
14. `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md` — capability routing, knowledge delivery
15. `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md` — universal ingestion, document intelligence, `DOC25_IngestionResult` consumer contract (NEW in R2.7)
16. `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md` — entity graph, intelligence substrate (updated R5.73 in R2.7)
17. `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` — Positronic Brain Enhancement concept (V1.4.1 — concept draft, not operative; NEW in R2.7)
18. `DOC OP-A — Cross-Doc Obligation Tracker V2` (`Operations Docs/`) — open obligations across owner specs (NEW in R2.7)

---

## 3. Core Specifications — Registry by category

## A. Core Platform Specs

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | `EC_Core_Specs_Rebuild_R1.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | Rebuild R1 | Core EC architecture, durable state, command ingestion, indexing tiers, memory extraction, orchestration substrate | DOC1 Rebuild R1; DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1; DOC15 Contract R3.1; EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (active addendum) | Replaces `ELNOR_CORE_SPEC_v1_11_2_CANONICAL.md` + the subsequent Wave D topology/read-model `.1` amendment | Single-file rebuild baseline; use this instead of the earlier split core stack. |
| 2 | `Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC_v1_11_2_CANONICAL.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | v1.11.2 | Canonical Q frontend/backend spec | Q Gap Audit R1; DOC21 R7; DOC22 R4; DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14 | Current standalone operative Q baseline in this registry | Not final; some thinner sections are restored by the gap audit. |
| 3 | `Q_SPEC_GAP_AUDIT.md` | ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | COMPANION / CONTRACT | R1 | Restores/extends Q sections lost or thinned in rewrite | Q canonical; DOC21 R7; DOC22 R4 | Supplements Q canonical; does not replace it | Treat as required companion where Q canonical is incomplete or stubbed. |
| 4 | `DOC21 (UI) Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R7.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R7 (Consolidated) | Master UI specification for Q Dashboard — UI element inventory, wiring card system, state map, SSE map, component grouping; R7 aligns all surfaces to DOC11 R14 | Q canonical; Q Gap Audit; DOC22 R4; DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14; DOC12 R7.1; DOC20 R4.3 | Replaces `DOC21 (UI) Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R5.md` | R7 is a major consolidation pass aligning to DOC11 R14. |
| 5 | `DOC22 (UI) Q_UI_PAGE_INVENTORY_AND_DESIGN_TEMPLATE_R4.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R4 | Q UI page inventory and design template — page-level layout, component registry, design tokens, template system; R4 aligns Settings and Status pages to DOC11 R14 | Q canonical; DOC21 R7; DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14 | Replaces `DOC22 (UI) Q_UI_PAGE_INVENTORY_AND_DESIGN_TEMPLATE_R2.md` | R4 adds DOC11 R14 surfaces including Runtime & Connectivity layout and expanded Settings controls. |

## B. DOC1–DOC4: Memory, Freshness, Skills, Bridge

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | `DOC1_Memory Resilience Rebuild_R1.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | Rebuild R1 | Canonical memory resilience, lifecycle, maturity, relationship index, capsules, governance, deep search | EC Core Rebuild R1; DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1 | Replaces `DOC1_MEMORY_RESILIENCE_v1_11_3_FINAL...` + the subsequent topology bridge `.1` amendment | Single-file rebuild baseline. |
| 7 | `DOC2 ELNOR_FRESHNESS_MANAGER_ADDENDUM_v1_11_4 copy.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | v1.11.4 | Source freshness, staleness detection, re-fetch rules | EC Core Rebuild R1; DOC10 R11; DOC18 R2 where retrieval freshness matters | Current standalone operative DOC2 file in this registry | Still an addendum-style owner doc; current but not final. DOC72 Continuity Synthesis Architecture R1 (active proposal) targets DOC2 retirement. |
| 8 | `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R11.2 (Canonical) | App Skills, MCP exposure, project-aware routing, skill lifecycle, retrieval-provider alignment | DOC3 Companion R9.2; DOC18 R2; DOC10 R11 | Replaces DOC3 R11.1 Canonical | Active addenda landing against R11.3: DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.1 (semantic skills, Apr 5); DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 Proposal V1 (live recording, Apr 15). |
| 9 | `DOC3_Companion_Doc_Delta_Plan_R9_2_Canonical.md` | ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | COMPANION / CONTRACT | R9.2 (Canonical) | Companion-spec amendment map needed to make DOC3 implementable | DOC3 App Skills R11.2; DOC10 R11; DOC18 R2 | Replaces DOC3 Companion R9.1 Canonical | Use as the current DOC3 downstream-obligation map. |
| 10 | `DOC4_OPENCLAW_BRIDGE_v1_11_6_2_REF_MAPPED.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | SHARED OWNER | v1.11.6.2 | OpenClaw bridge ownership, tool routing, API mappings, cross-channel behavior | DOC11 R14; DOC10 R11; OpenClaw preservation checklist | Current operative DOC4 in this registry | Shared owner for bridge/runtime seam, not sole owner of runtime truth. |

## C. DOC5A–DOC6: Account Build, Panels & Forums

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | `DOC5A_WILL_ACCOUNT_BUILD.md` | ACTIVE BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION DRAFT | BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION | R1 | Account/file-sync infrastructure build for `will` macOS user | DOC5B; DOC3 App Skills R11.2 | Current build doc in this registry | Build doc, not owner of higher-level orchestration policy. |
| 12 | `DOC5B_OPENCLAW1_ACCOUNT_BUILD.md` | ACTIVE BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION DRAFT | BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION | R1 | OpenClaw1 file-sync skill build and account-side workflow | DOC5A; DOC3 App Skills R11.2 | Current build doc in this registry | Build doc, not owner of app-skill architecture. |
| 13 | `DOC6_PANELS_FORUMS_SELF_IMPROVEMENT_v1_11_8_1.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | v1.11.8.1 | Panels/forums/self-improvement, Ship lane, approval-gated proposals, standing-order creation via proposals | DOC10 R11; DOC12 R7.1; DOC15 R7.1 | Current standalone operative DOC6 in this registry | Important owner for approval-gated corrections/rules behavior. |

## D. DOC7–DOC9: Context, Learning, Repair

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | `DOC7_Context_Buckets_Files_R7_Consolidated.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R7 (Consolidated) | Context buckets/files, QMD integration, graph-aware materialization, support packs | DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1; EC Core Rebuild R1 | Replaces DOC7 R6 Consolidated | Single-file current operative DOC7. DOC72+DOC7 Bucket Intake Insertion Text proposal targets §20A.2/§20B.14 amendments. |
| 15 | `DOC8_SELF_LEARNING_PREDICTION_REGRESSION_FRICTION_v1_11_4.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | v1.11.4 | Self-learning, friction, regressions, nightly pipeline, learning signals | DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1; DOC6 | Current standalone operative DOC8 in this registry | Current owner of friction/regression signal substrate. |
| 16 | `DOC9_SELF_REPAIR_PIPELINE_v1_11_9_R3_FINAL.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | v1.11.9 R3 | Self-repair pipeline, patch packs, diagnosis→proposal→apply flow | DOC10 R11; DOC6; DOC12 where rooms participate | Current standalone operative DOC9 in this registry | "FINAL" appears in filename but this registry still treats it as current, not permanently final. |

## E. DOC10–DOC12: Orchestration, Gateway, Rooms

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | `DOC10_Orchestration_Integration_Ledger_R10_Consolidated.md` | ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | COMPANION / CONTRACT | R10 (Consolidated) | Suite-wide integration ledger and seam tracker | DOC10 R11; DOC15 Contract R3.1; DOC11 R14 | Replaces DOC10 Ledger R9 + R9.1 topology control-plane amendment | This is the suite-wide integration tracker; it is not replaced by the DOC15 contract. Note: DOC OP-A V2 (Operations) supersedes the by-target obligations role formerly held by DOC15 Contract R3.1. |
| 18 | `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R11 (Consolidated) | Unified engagement/orchestration, authority matrix, route traces, retrieval receipts, topology consumption | DOC10 Ledger R10; DOC11 R14; EC Core Rebuild R1; DOC15 R7.1 | Replaces DOC10 R10 + R10.1 retrieval/topology amendment | Single-file current operative DOC10. |
| 19 | `DOC10_R10_R8_RED_TEAM_INCORPORATION_MATRIX.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | SUPPORT / AUDIT | R1 | Preservation matrix showing how prior red-team ideas were absorbed | DOC10 R11; DOC10 Ledger R10 | Support/preservation doc only | Useful traceability; not current owner truth. |
| 20 | `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R14 | Gateway-first interactive chat, runtime truth, context manifests, streaming, selector/executed truth, local provider controls, web search config, ACP/Coding Mode, Discord/WhatsApp channels, session lifecycle state machines, control mutation queue | DOC10 R11; DOC4; DOC12 R7.1; DOC13 R1; OpenClaw preservation checklist | Replaces `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R13.md` | Current owner of gateway/runtime seam. R14 is the inline-compiled full-closure revision. Active R15 amendment proposal in addenda (Apr 13). |
| 21 | `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R7.1 | Multi-agent rooms, shared conversation substrate, room docs/workspaces, SSE events, participant truth | DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14; DOC14 R7 | Replaces DOC12 R6 + R7 + R7.1 consolidation | Single-file current operative DOC12. |
| 22 | `DOC12_IMPLEMENTATION_APPENDIX_R1.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | SUPPORT / AUDIT | R1 | Code-facing wiring details and build order for DOC12 | DOC12 R7.1; DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14 | Support appendix only | Explicitly non-owner; owner docs govern on conflict. |

## F. DOC13–DOC14: Costs, Red-Team Integration, Cross-Doc Delta

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 | `DOC13_Costs_R1.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R1 | Cost tracking, budget enforcement, pricing research, dynamic token controls | DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14 | Current standalone operative DOC13 in this registry | Current owner of unified cost logic. |
| 24 | `DOC14_ELNOR_CANDOR_Integration_Architecture_R7.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R7 | ELNOR + CANDOR red-team integration into room substrate — full reconstruction from R5.2 completeness baseline with all R6/R6.1 improvements merged | DOC12 R7.1; DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1 as needed | Replaces `DOC14_ELNOR_CANDOR_Integration_Architecture_v5_2_DRAFT.md` | R7 is a full reconstruction build-hardened revision as of 2026-03-30. Needs human review for cross-doc seam updates. |
| 25 | `DOC14_CROSS_DOCUMENT_DELTA_COMPANION_R2.md` | ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | COMPANION / CONTRACT | R2 | Cross-document delta tracking, inter-doc change propagation obligations, revision alignment map | DOC10 Ledger R10; DOC15 Contract R3.1; all owner docs | Replaces `DOC14_CROSS_DOCUMENT_DELTA_COMPANION_R1_2.md` | Tracks deltas between document revisions that affect cross-doc contracts. |

## G. DOC15: Cognitive Infrastructure Layer (CIL)

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R7.1 (Consolidated Current Draft) | CIL spec: knowledge nodes, learning pipeline, signal spool, advisor modules, DocIndex/topology bridge, bootstrap/migration lifecycle | DOC15 Contract R3.1; DOC15 Addendum A; DOC15 Build Manifest; DOC10 R11; DOC7 R7 | Replaces DOC15 R6 Consolidated Current + R6.1/R6.2/R7 revisions | Single-file current operative DOC15. |
| 27 | `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` | ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | COMPANION / CONTRACT | R3.1 (Consolidated Current Draft) | DOC15 owner-by-owner integration checklist and seam ledger | DOC15 R7.1; DOC10 Ledger R10; DOC16 R5.4 | Replaces DOC15 Contract R2 + R3 + R3.1 consolidation | Specialized subsystem contract. **Carry-forward note:** DOC OP-A V2 explicitly supersedes this document as the by-target obligations tracker; this file remains in the active folder for historical reference but new obligations should be filed in DOC OP-A V2. |
| 28 | `DOC15_Addendum_A_Audit_Synthesis_v1.3.md` | ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | SUPPORT / AUDIT | v1.3 | CIL audit synthesis, migration map, blocker inventory, phase-zero grounding | DOC15 R7.1; DOC15 Contract R3.1 | Current active companion/audit doc in this registry | Read with DOC15 for migration/reality checks. |
| 29 | `DOC15_Build_Manifest_v1.1 (1).md` | ACTIVE BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION DRAFT | BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION | v1.1 | Flattened CIL implementation task sequence for coding agents | DOC15 R7.1; DOC15 Contract R3.1; DOC15 Addendum A | Current active build doc in this registry | Build sequencing doc; not the primary owner of CIL behavior. |

## H. DOC16–DOC20: Deferred Additions, M365, Overlays, Retrieval, Fills, Browser/Notes/Workspace

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 | `DOC16_R5_4.md` | FUTURE / PLANNING DRAFT | FUTURE / DEFERRED | R5.4 | Master deferred-additions / punch-list / future-state roadmap, including topology and CIL-session additions | DOC15 R7.1; DOC18 R2; DOC3 R11.2 as needed | Replaces `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` | R5.4 supersedes R5.3 nominally. **File-system anomaly (carried from R2.4–R2.6):** `DOC16_R5_4.md` was not found in the active folder during R2.4, R2.5, R2.6, or R2.7 scans — only `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` is present. Needs human review to confirm R5.4 file exists or to reconcile. |
| 31 | `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2_1.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R2.1 | M365 deep integration — agentic Elnor identity, Teams channel integration, email infrastructure, calendar management, search routing, settings surface, security model | DOC3 R11.2; DOC4; DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14; DOC15 R7.1; DOC23 R3.0; DOC18 R2; DOC24 R2.5; DOC21 R7 (Q Settings surface); DOC25 V2.0 (email-attachment ingestion routes through DOC25) | Replaces `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` | DOC25 V2.0 link added in R2.7. Extracted from DOC16 deferred list into a standalone high-priority spec. |
| 32 | `DOC17_R4_2_OVERLAY_LIBRARY_PROMPT_ADVISOR_PROMPT_RECIPES_AND_PROMPT_LAB.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R4.2 | Overlay library, prompt advisor, prompt recipes, prompt lab bridge | DOC10 R11; DOC14 R7 where prompt artifacts matter | Current standalone operative DOC17 in this registry | Current owner for overlay/prompt-advisor domain. |
| 33 | `DOC18_LlamaIndex_Retrieval_Sidecar_R2.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R2 (Consolidated) | LlamaIndex retrieval sidecar, provider routing, semantic index lifecycle, corpus-scoped retrieval lane | DOC3 App Skills R11.2; DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1; EC Core Rebuild R1; DOC25 V2.0 (chunk indexing target) | Replaces DOC18 R1 + R1.1 retrieval lane/topology alignment amendment | Single-file current operative DOC18. |
| 34 | `DOC19_ORIG_SPEC_FILLS_AND_FIXES.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | SUPPORT / AUDIT | R1 | Original spec gap fills and targeted fixes for items missed or underspecified in the canonical baseline specs | All owner docs where gaps were identified | New document in R2 registry revision | Support/patch doc. |
| 35 | `DOC20_R4_3.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R4.3 | Unified Workspace shell, Browser, projects, DOC7 integration, notes, To-Do system, Calendar module, Floating Palette, Document Viewer, Embedded Web Browser, Session System, Icon System, Split View, Notification System, Skills & Connectors page | Q canonical; Q Gap Audit; DOC21 R7; DOC22 R4; DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14; DOC16 Entry 16.7; DOC24 R2.5; DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0 (Document Viewer consumes pre-computed page text/OCR) | Replaces `DOC20_R4_2.md` | **R2.6 anomaly resolved:** `DOC20_R4_3.md` is present in the active folder (verified during R2.7 scan; size 473,759 bytes; mtime 2026-04-09). DOC25 V2.0 link added in R2.7. |

## I. Cross-Cutting & Support Documents

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 36 | `RUNNING_BRIEF_REMEDIATION_v6.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | v6.0 | Running Brief system, unified context injection pipeline, OCM agent (extract/query modes), surface scoping, fresh-surface reset, environment awareness, telemetry/usage/cost producer seams | DOC10 R11; DOC1 R1; DOC7 R7; DOC11 R14; DOC12 R7.1; DOC15 R7.1 | Current operative in this registry | Owns Running Brief state model, context assembler pipeline, OCM, fresh-surface reset semantics. Amends DOC1, DOC10, DOC11, DOC12. |
| 37 | `OPENCLAW_PRESERVATION_AND_INTEGRATION_CHECKLIST_R1.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | SUPPORT / AUDIT | R1 | Preservation checklist ensuring OpenClaw remains native runtime owner while ELNOR adds orchestration | DOC11 R14; DOC4; DOC10 R11 | Current support doc in this registry | Important guardrail/preservation doc; not owner truth over DOC11/DOC4. |
| 38 | `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | SUPPORT / AUDIT | R2 | Running ledger of OpenClaw-release-driven changes affecting the ELNOR spec stack outside the core DOC11 redline, plus a compact DOC11 reference appendix; covers releases through `2026.4.12` | DOC10 R11; DOC3 R11.2; DOC4; DOC11 R14; DOC12 R7.1; DOC13 R1; DOC15; DOC20 R4.3; DOC24 R2.5 | Replaces prior unversioned `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST.md` | Updated to R2 in R2.7 registry scan. Companion to active addendum DOC11 R15 amendment proposal. |

## J. DOC23–DOC25: Task System, Knowledge & Capability Architecture, Document Intelligence

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 39 | `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_0.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R3.0 (Frozen Implementation Baseline) | Complete task system specification — modular automation architecture, module catalog, port system, context routing, execution engine, schemas, cross-task wiring, agent integration, UI spec, API routes, SSE events, storage, cross-doc integration | DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14; DOC15 R7.1; DOC12 R7.1; DOC16 Entry 16.7 (M365 triggers); DOC20 R4.3; DOC24 R2.5; DOC25 V2.0 (task module document outputs) | New document in R2.3 registry | **R2.9 note (auto-detected 2026-04-28): R3.0 file moved to `Subsumed Specs/`; superseded by R3.1 in active folder (new placeholder row 39b below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** R3.0 marked "Frozen Implementation Baseline." 36 module types. |
| 39b | `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_1.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | OPERATIONS | R3.1 | **Auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync; needs human re-classification.** New file in active folder dated 2026-04-28 03:43 (size 482,004 bytes). Likely supersedes row 39 once classified. | DOC10 R11; DOC11 R14; DOC15 R7.1; DOC12 R7.1; DOC16 Entry 16.7; DOC20 R4.3; DOC24 R3 (cross-link should be updated post-classification); DOC25 V2.0 | Likely supersedes row 39 once classified | Auto-detected; needs human classification (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER once confirmed by Will). |
| 40 | `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R2.5 | Umbrella architecture for ELNOR capability awareness, semantic routing, entity graph delivery, knowledge-to-LLM delivery architecture (packet assembly, injection selection, rendering templates, retrieval lanes, injection tags, provenance). R2.5 incorporates 97-item red team adjudication. Adds routing cascade project-agnosticism fix, Tool Capability Nodes (ADJ-91), forward-reference seams for Addendum A (BDSM), Addendum B (KDA), Unified Context Budget Governance, and MultiDoc PropA R4. | DOC72 R5.73; DOC3 R11.2; DOC10 R11; DOC15 R7.1; DOC23 R3.0; DOC25 V2.0 (DOC25 tools register through DOC24's tool registry); EC Core Rebuild R1 | Replaces `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_4.md` | **R2.8 note (auto-detected 2026-04-27): R2.5 file moved to `Subsumed Specs/`; superseded by R3 in active folder (new placeholder row 40b below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** DOC72 cross-link updated to R5.73 in R2.7. Active addenda landing against R2.5: Addendum A (BDSM v6.4), Addendum-B [KDA] R2, Q Dashboard Tool Registry, Persistent Onboarding Curiosity, Unified Context Budget Governance. |
| 40b | `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | OPERATIONS | R3 | **Auto-detected 2026-04-27 by nightly sync; needs human re-classification.** New file in active folder dated 2026-04-27 (header 2026-04-26). Per file header: incorporates accepted items from R2.5 Red Team Adjudication Card V3 (125 cards, 87 ACCEPT, 25 ACCEPT_MOD, 11 REJECT, 2 cross-references); adds new §38 Runtime Lifecycle, Assembly Contract, and Session Continuity; modifies §§5, 9, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 29, 36; cross-doc obligations tracked in DOC OP-A V3.1+. | DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0; DOC OP-A V3.x | Likely supersedes row 40 once classified | Auto-detected; needs human classification (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER once confirmed by Will). |
| 41 | `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | V2.0 | Document Intelligence and Universal Ingestion Architecture — owns: tiered LLM context management for documents in agent conversations, universal ingestion orchestration across all surfaces, document conversion routing (MarkItDown/Docling/NuExtract/GLiNER/Firecrawl/Tesseract/OCR), content-addressable storage, cross-surface deduplication, `DOC25_IngestionResult` consumer contract, runtime retrieval tools and re-read posture, and the marker scheme for content injected into LLM prompts | DOC72 R5.73 (entity graph schema, intake pipeline); DOC73 V1.4.1 (primary consumer of `DOC25_IngestionResult` — V1.4.1 inlines schema in §15.2, will dereference in V1.5); DOC18 R2; DOC20 R4.3; DOC24 R2.5; DOC11 R14; EC Core (Addendum A V3.3); DOC15; DOC1 | Replaces `DOC25_DOC INTELLIGENCE_SPEC.md` (V1.0, 2026-04-11) and `DOC_INTELLIGENCE_EXTRACTION_PIPELINE_PROPOSAL_R1.md` (R1, 2026-04-19); resolves all 8 open questions from `DOC25_PLANNING_NOTES_V2.md` | **NEW in R2.7.** V2.0 dated 2026-04-26. Authoritative owner of `DOC25_IngestionResult`; DOC73 V1.4.1 §15.2 must remain field-for-field identical with DOC25 V2.0 §17 until DOC73 V1.5 swaps to a normative reference. |

## K. DOC72: Intelligence Substrate

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 42 | `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md` | CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | PRIMARY OWNER | R5.73 | Intelligence substrate — entity graph, procedural knowledge compounding, goals, extended learning, knowledge intake pipeline from all surfaces, domain signal profiles, embedding infrastructure. R5.73 absorbs the Graph Intelligence Enhancement V2.2 (29 normalized patches NP01-NP29 from a 5-reviewer red-team adjudication) into §42A; R5.72 owner text outside §42A is preserved verbatim. Restores §42A.5.4 (temporal regularity) and §42A.5.5 (standing procedure candidacy) verbatim from R5.72 as a gap-fix during V2.2 absorption. | DOC24 R2.5; DOC1 Rebuild R1; DOC8 v1.11.4; DOC15 R7.1; DOC3 R11.2; DOC25 V2.0 (DOC25 routes documents through DOC72 §20A surface intake before entity extraction) | Replaces `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_6.md` (the prior R5.6/R5.5 named file) | **Updated to R5.73 in R2.7 (file dated 2026-04-26).** DOC72 owns knowledge architecture; DOC24 owns routing/invocation/injection/delivery interfaces. **R2.6 file-system note resolved:** the prior R5_6 filename is no longer present (replaced by R5_73). |

## L. DOC73: Positronic Brain Enhancement (Concept)

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43 | `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` | CONCEPT DRAFT | FUTURE / DEFERRED | V1.4.1 | Concept draft for additive enhancement layer over DOC72 — deep knowledge corpora as scoped substrates, context-aware extraction with working memory, universal living memory with eligibility carve-outs, compositional ConsolidatedUnderstanding primitive with edge-essentiality and computed authority via aggregation, cluster emergence and system-detected artifacts, self-improvement engine with graduated autonomy, onboarding-driven domain configuration, corpus extraction architecture with counterfactual finding lifecycle, re-extraction directive flow, autonomous gathering trust framework, and operational layer with `DOC25_IngestionResult` minimum consumer contract, ingestion state machine, and specialist sub-agent pattern | DOC72 R5.73 (R5.72 in dependency list — R5.73 absorbs §42A V2.2); DOC72 KIE R2 (when integrated); DOC72 Continuity Synthesis R1 (when integrated); DOC24 R2.5 (including onboarding infrastructure); DOC25 V2.0 (universal ingestion architecture); KDA R2; BDSM V6.4; PropA R6.3; DOC7 R7; EC Core Addendum A V3.3 | V1.4.1 supersedes V1.4 with full self-containment (no architectural changes; V1.3 retained-content reproduced inline); V1.3 and V1.1 preserved as prior files | **R3.2 note (auto-detected 2026-04-29): file moved to `Subsumed Specs/DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md`; superseded by V1.5.1 (new placeholder row 43b below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** Was operative per architect (CLAUDE.md confirms 2026-04-26). NEW in R2.7. Dated 2026-04-26. §15.2 inlined DOC25 IngestionResult; must stay in sync with DOC25 V2.0 §17 until V1.5 dereferenced. |
| 43b | `DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md` | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | OPERATIONS | V1.5.1 | **Auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync; needs human re-classification.** New file in active folder dated 2026-04-29 04:36 (size 663,684 bytes — ~187 KB / ~39% larger than V1.4.1's 476 KB). Substantive content delta from V1.4.1 not analyzed by auto pass. Likely supersedes row 43 once classified (and likely promotes to `CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT` / `PRIMARY OWNER` if Will treats V1.5.1 as a successor to V1.4.1's operative status). | DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0; OP-A V3.7; DOC73 Corpus Source Bindings Proposal V1 (A-30) and EC Core Addendum A Intake Routing for Corpus Bindings V1 (A-27) likely target this version | Likely supersedes row 43 once classified | Auto-detected; needs human classification. Per CLAUDE.md DOC73 V1.5 was the planned dereferencing version that swaps `DOC25_IngestionResult` from inlined schema to normative reference — V1.5.1 may be the released form. |

## M. Active Build Coordination Doc

| # | Document | Status | Owner Type | Current Revision | Primary Use | Must Read With | Replaces / Supersedes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 44 | `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md` (cross-listed in row 20 — also appears here as a build coordination anchor) | — | — | — | — | — | — | This row is a placeholder reference; DOC11 R14 is registered in row 20. |

> **Note on row 44:** Reserved as a placeholder cross-reference; the active count of distinct registry documents is 43 in §3 (rows 1–43). The placeholder is retained to keep numbering aligned with prior R2.6 conventions. See §11 counts.

---

## 4. Addenda — Active (Proposals and In-Progress Amendments)

These documents live under `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` and are awaiting integration into a parent operative spec. Excludes the `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` subfolder (completed and not tracked here).

### A1. Top-level addenda (parent folder)

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec(s) | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-1 | `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL.md` | DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal — OpenClaw Release Alignment, Plugin/Capability Surfaces, Memory Controls, Command Discovery, and Channel Generalization | 2026-04-13 | DOC11 R14 (primary) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Patch-oriented amendment proposal for the next DOC11 revision wave aligning to stable OpenClaw releases through 2026.4.12. **R3.4 note (auto-detected 2026-04-30): superseded by R2 file `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md` (new row A-36 below; supersession mirrors PACER A-8 → A-28 pattern). Original R1 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision. Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** |
| A-2 | `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A — R2.2 Proposal: Live Recording, Conversational Capture, and Intake Coordination | 2026-04-15 | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A (primary); DOC72, DOC11, DOC20, DOC24 Addendum A (BDSM), MultiDoc PropA | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Consolidates post-R2.1 design decisions (Live Action Feed, conversational procedure capture, browser adapters, BDSM integration, etc.) for incorporation into Addenda A R2.2. **R3.2 note (auto-detected 2026-04-29): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V1.md`. Superseded first by V2 (R3.1 row A-33, also archived) then by consolidated `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (new row A-35 below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** |
| A-3 | `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_SEMANTIC SKILLS R2_1.md` | DOC3 R11.3 — Semantic Skill Learning: Demonstration Mode, Graph Integration, and Universal Knowledge Extraction — Addenda A R2.1 | 2026-04-05 | DOC3 (primary); DOC72, DOC24, DOC1, DOC8, DOC11, EC Core, Q UI | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | R2.1 incorporates ADJ-01 through ADJ-72 from R2 red team adjudication; defines `demonstrating_skill` mode and the universal pipeline producing graph-backed procedural knowledge. **R3.2 note (auto-detected 2026-04-29): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_SEMANTIC SKILLS R2_1.md`. Possibly subsumed by consolidated `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (new row A-35 below) — content delta not analyzed by auto pass. Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** |
| A-4 | `EC_Core_Addendum_A_V3_3_Compiled_Operative_Spec.md` | EC Core Addendum A — Data Operations, Processing, and System Management Architecture V3.3 | 2026-04-16 | EC Core (primary); DOC72, DOC24, DOC8, DOC11, DOC12, DOC20, DOC21/22, DOC1, DOC15, DOC23 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Compiled operative companion spec — global memory hierarchy, runtime truth, route/command closure, policy engine, background orchestration, execution profile selection, token/cost governance, networking sync, backup/export/import, settings wiring. |
| A-71 | `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED.md` | ELNOR Subagent Architecture V5.2 AUDITED | 2026-05-19 (mtime 2026-05-19 09:18:57 local; size 95,218 bytes; +34,080 bytes / +55.7% over A-67 V5.1) | DOC15 CIL; DOC24 capability/knowledge architecture; DOC11 subagent gateway controls; A-67 V5.1 (natural-progression predecessor); A-5 V4 (older PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES predecessor — natural-progression-superseded since R3.53) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.55 (auto-detected 2026-05-19 ~13:55 local); needs human classification.** V5.2 AUDITED natural-progression successor to A-67 V5.1. Substantial size growth (+55.7%) consistent with audit-driven red-team incorporation pattern (analogous to DOC10 R10 → R11 Consolidated 109,358 → 175,206 byte expansion via R10/R8 red-team incorporation matrix). `_AUDITED` suffix is first observed in any subagent chain — establishes new audit-suffix variant convention for subagent architecture chain. Full file-header inspection deferred. |
| A-5 | `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4.md` | ELNOR Architectural Notes — Sub-Agent Orchestration, Mid-Turn Knowledge Retrieval, Pre-Computation, and Tool Optimizations | 2026-04-24 | DOC24 R2.5 (primary, for incorporation); DOC72, DOC11, DOC10, DOC12, DOC15, DOC16, DOC18, DOC2, DOC3, DOC8, DOC25, DOC73, EC Core | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | V4 adds Specialist Sub-Agent Pattern, MemoryAgent and DocumentIntelligenceAgent specifications, composition patterns, and monitoring/inspectability for specialist sub-agents. |
| A-6 | `MEMORY_INTAKE_AND_AT_USE_DISCIPLINES_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | Memory Intake and At-Use Disciplines — Cross-Doc Proposal V1 | 2026-04-26 | DOC72 R5.72+, DOC24 R2.5+, DOC1, DOC73 V1.4+ | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Proposal to fix intake-side speech-act collapse and at-use side memory premise weighting; formalizes labeled cross-context retrieval. |
| A-7 | `MultiDoc_PropA_R6_3_Compiled_Operative_Spec.md` | MultiDoc PropA — Knowledge Pipeline, Sensitivity Classification, and Self-Improvement Architecture R6.3 | 2026-04-16 | DOC72, DOC24, DOC24 Addendum A, DOC8, DOC20, DOC23, DOC1, DOC11, EC Core Addendum A, DOC21, DOC22 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Compiled operative companion spec — source-granular collection control, pre-extraction visibility gating, sensitivity classification, sharing/injection policy, misclassification recovery, self-improvement / DSPy. |
| A-8 | `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md` | PACER Plugin — Reference Implementation | 2026-04-11 | Q Plugin System (primary); DOC72, DOC3, DOC24 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Reference implementation specification for the federal-courts PACER plugin (case monitoring, docket tracking, party research, deadline extraction). **R2.9 note (auto-detected 2026-04-28): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md`; superseded by `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC_V1.1.md` (new row A-28 below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** |
| A-9 | `Q_INTEGRATION_SUITE_ADDITIONS_R1.md` | Q Integration Suite — Additions R1: Firecrawl, Securities Data, MarkItDown | 2026-04-19 | Q Integration Suite Spec (primary); DOC24 (routing), DOC11 (installation checklist), DOC72 (intake), DOC20 (document extraction) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Adds Firecrawl, securities data, and MarkItDown integrations plus DOC24 routing infrastructure for new integrations. |
| A-10 | `Q_INTEGRATION_SUITE_SPEC.md` | Q Dashboard Integration Suite — Additional Integrations | 2026-04-11 | Q Plugin System; DOC24 capability registry | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Specifications for YouTube, Philips Hue, Zoom/Teams transcripts, Apple Reminders, Screenshots integrations plus unified DOC24 capability registry. |
| A-11 | `Q_PLUGIN_SYSTEM_ARCHITECTURE_R2.md` | Q Dashboard Plugin System Architecture R2 | 2026-04-11 | DOC3 (skill/connector registry), DOC24 (capability registry), DOC23 (task system), DOC20 (tab system) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | R2 consolidates R1.1 + Addendum A — extensible plugin framework with manifest schema, tab registration, settings surface, scaffold template, Elnor plugin builder workflow, DOC72 knowledge layer, telemetry, error learning, self-improvement proposals. |
| A-12 | `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` | Skills Live Recording Upgrades — Cross-Doc Amendment | 2026-04-13 | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A (§20.3, §4, §6.9, §10), DOC20 (§6.29.8, §6.19), DOC11 (§23), DOC72 (trace provenance) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Adds real-time step-by-step feedback during demonstrations, browser observation support, durable provenance for raw→semantic mapping. **R3.0/R3.2 note: file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (deferred-detect first surfaced in R3.0; reaffirmed R3.2 since the active folder still does not contain the file). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification — likely supersession by `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (new row A-35 below).** |
| A-13 | `SPOTIFY_INTEGRATION_PART_1_IMMEDIATE_BUILD.md` | Spotify Integration — Part 1: Immediate Build (No Backend Required) | 2026-04-11 | Q Plugin System (primary); OpenClaw runtime | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | No-backend Spotify build — playback control, search, playlists, listening data access, web player viewing within Q Dashboard. |
| A-14 | `SPOTIFY_INTEGRATION_PART_2_SCHEDULED_INTAKE.md` | Spotify Integration — Part 2: Scheduled Intake & Knowledge Graph (Backend Required) | 2026-04-11 | DOC3 R11.3, DOC72 R5.6+, DOC23, DOC8 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Future-build spec — automated listening data capture, preference extraction, pattern learning, proactive music intelligence. |
| A-27 | `EC_CORE_ADDENDUM_A_INTAKE_ROUTING_FOR_CORPUS_BINDINGS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | EC Core Addendum A — Intake Routing for Corpus Bindings Proposal V1 | 2026-04-27 | EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (primary); DOC25, DOC72, DOC73 (corpus source bindings) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R2.9 (auto-detected 2026-04-28).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Companion proposal to A-30 DOC73 Corpus Source Bindings Proposal V1. |
| A-28 | `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC_V1.1.md` | PACER Plugin Spec V1.1 — Reference Implementation | 2026-04-27 | Q Plugin System (primary); DOC72, DOC3, DOC24 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R2.9 (auto-detected 2026-04-28).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Supersedes `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md` V1.0 (row A-8 above; original moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`). |
| A-29 | `CROSS_SPEC_ISSUES_PUNCH_LIST_V1.md` | Cross-Spec Issues Punch List V1 | 2026-04-28 | Multiple operative specs (cross-cutting) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R2.9 (auto-detected 2026-04-28).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Cross-spec punch-list staging document. |
| A-31 | `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | DOC25 Proposal — File Materialization, Provider Profiles, and Remote Access (V1) | 2026-04-27 (mtime 2026-04-28 13:57) | DOC25 V2.0 (primary); DOC16 16.7 R2.1, DOC73 V1.4.1 §15.2, DOC72 §20A | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **R3.2 note (auto-detected 2026-04-29): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1.md`. Confirms R3.1 prediction. Superseded by V1.1 (row A-32). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** Source: 2026-04-27 brief-bank search session — 18 of 26 OneDrive Personal MTD briefs returned `errno 35` placeholder failures. Adds materialization tri-state, sync-provider profiles, pre-flight probe, materialization trigger sequence. |
| A-32 | `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1_1.md` | DOC25 Proposal — File Materialization, Provider Profiles, and Remote Access (V1.1) | 2026-04-27 (mtime 2026-04-28 15:48) | DOC25 V2.0 (primary); DOC16 16.7 R2.1, DOC73 V1.4.1 §15.2, DOC72 §20A, DOC18 R2, ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.1 (auto-detected 2026-04-28).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. V1.1 is a documentary refinement of V1 (no schema/behavioral/failure-mode changes) — clarifies §12 DOC18 chunk-index lifecycle (chunks stored under canonical `document_id`, working-copy eviction does NOT invalidate index) and Docling/MarkItDown routing (operates on materialized bytes regardless of path). **Supersedes A-31 V1.** |
| A-33 | `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md` | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A — R2.2 Proposal: Live Recording, Conversational Capture, and Intake Coordination (V2 — Patch A applied) | 2026-04-15 (mtime 2026-04-28 11:43) | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A (primary); DOC72, DOC11, DOC20, DOC24 Addendum A (BDSM), MD Prop-A, EC Core | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **R3.2 note (auto-detected 2026-04-29): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md`. A V3 also appeared briefly and is also archived. Both superseded by consolidated `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (new row A-35 below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** R2.2 Proposal V2 with Patch A applied per 18-item red team adjudication. |
| A-34 | `ELNOR_SEARCH_ARCHITECTURE_REFERENCE_R1.md` | ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1 | 2026-04-27 (mtime 2026-04-28 15:27) | DOC24 §13.2, DOC16 16.7 §C, V4 §§1.7–1.9, DOC25 §16, DOC18 R2, DOC72, DOC73 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.1 (auto-detected 2026-04-28); confirmed in R3.2.** Auto-detected; needs human classification. **Per file header: "Reference document, not an operative spec. Synthesizes existing specs into one place for navigation. Non-normative — every claim points at the underlying owner spec which remains authoritative."** Likely needs reclassification to SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / REFERENCE rather than PROPOSED ADDENDUM (the file lives in the addenda folder but explicitly modifies nothing). Walks every common search intent end-to-end across the three search layers (document text/chunks; extracted memories; document/case metadata) and the agents that drive search. |
| A-35 | `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A — R2.2 (Consolidated) | 2026-04-29 (mtime 2026-04-29 08:32) | DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A (primary; consolidates A-2/A-3/A-12); DOC72, DOC11, DOC20, DOC24 Addendum A (BDSM), MultiDoc PropA | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.2 (auto-detected 2026-04-29).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Filename drops `_PROPOSAL_V1` suffix — likely the post-RT consolidated R2.2 (Proposal V1/V2/V3 all in archive). May also subsume A-3 Semantic Skills R2.1 and A-12 Live Recording Upgrades V1 (both also archived 2026-04-29) — content delta not analyzed by auto pass; full disposition pending human review. Size 193,966 bytes — largest of the DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 family. |
| A-36 | `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md` | DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R2 — OpenClaw Release Alignment | 2026-04-30 (mtime 2026-04-30 00:45) | DOC11 R14 (primary) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.4 (auto-detected 2026-04-30).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. R2 supersedes A-1 (R1 — original DOC11 R15 amendment proposal; remains in active folder pending human archival decision; mirrors PACER A-8 → A-28 supersession pattern). Size 77,777 bytes (R1 was 51,307 bytes — ~52% larger). Likely incorporates further OpenClaw release alignment through 2026.4.23 + companion to `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 19:21 — also touched in same window). |
| A-40 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization (R2.0 Draft) | 2026-04-02 (mtime 2026-04-30 13:43) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); Prop-A R6.3 (DSPy self-improvement engine, companion) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.6 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 — third pass of the day).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Size 61,420 bytes. Per file header: status "Draft — not yet compiled into DOC23." Defines three composable DOC23 modules: (1) `system.experiment` — runs 2–4 variant configurations of a target module against the same input with per-variant output ports; (2) `step.judge` — scores outputs on user-defined dimensions with structured audit trails; (3) DSPy-integrated prompt optimization. Architectural principle in §A1: "Experiments, judges, and optimization are modules in the DOC23 graph — not overlays, not special modes, not separate frameworks." Closed improvement loop: run variants → score them → optimize the prompt → run again. **R3.7 note (auto-detected 2026-05-01): SUPERSEDED by A-41 (R3.0) and then by A-43 (R4.0) per filename pattern. All three revisions remain in active folder pending human archival decision. Row preserved for traceability.** **R3.9 note (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` (mtime preserved at 2026-04-30 13:43). R3.7's predicted archival decision now executed (manual or external move). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification — supersession by A-44 (R4.0 (1) file kept in active state, now relocated to new §A6 DOC23 Addenda subfolder) appears to be the operative resolution.** |
| A-41 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization (R3.0 Draft) | 2026-04-30 (mtime 2026-04-30 23:40) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); Prop-A R6.3 (companion) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.7 (auto-detected 2026-05-01).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. R3.0 file (size 24,266 bytes — ~60% smaller than R2.0). Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) per filename pattern. Companion to A-42 `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (staging doc whose header reads "Running Additions for R3.0"). **Likely SUPERSEDED by A-43 (R4.0) per filename pattern — newer revision present in active folder; row preserved for traceability pending human archival decision.** **R3.9 note (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` (mtime preserved at 2026-04-30 16:40). R3.7's predicted supersession-and-archival decision now executed. Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification — A-44 (R4.0 (1) file kept in active state, now in new §A6 DOC23 Addenda subfolder) appears to be the operative successor.** |
| A-42 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Running Additions (Staging Document) | 2026-05-01 (mtime 2026-05-01 00:57) | DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization) — staging document | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.7 (auto-detected 2026-05-01).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Large staging file (size 108,578 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Running Additions for R3.0 — Staging document for changes to compile into the next revision of DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization). Items are added during iterative discussion and compiled in batch." Companion to A-41 (R3.0) and A-43 (R4.0). May represent the source-of-truth for items being incrementally compiled into the R3.0 → R4.0 → next-revision pipeline. Note: file header references "for R3.0" but R4.0 (A-43) shipped 2026-05-01 05:50 — staging doc may need re-targeting. **R3.9 note (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (mtime now 2026-04-30 17:57 — slightly older than R3.7's recorded 2026-05-01 00:57; possible filesystem-touch artifact during move, or R3.7's mtime was wrong). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification — staging-document content presumably already compiled into the active R4.0 (1) file (A-44) before archival.** |
| A-43 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization (R4.0 Draft) | 2026-05-01 (mtime 2026-05-01 05:50) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); Prop-A R6.3 (companion) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.7 (auto-detected 2026-05-01).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. R4.0 file (size 52,949 bytes). Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) and A-41 (R3.0) per filename pattern. Most recent revision in the DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 chain (all three revisions shipped within ~16 hours 2026-04-30 13:43 → 2026-05-01 05:50). Treat as the latest DOC23 Task Optimization addendum going forward pending human disposition. Companion staging doc A-42 RUNNING_ADDITIONS may need re-targeting from R3.0 to R4.0+1. **R3.9 note (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` (mtime now 2026-04-30 22:50 — slightly older than R3.7's recorded 2026-05-01 05:50; possible filesystem-touch artifact during move). The "two parallel R4.0 files" question raised in R3.7 (A-43 vs A-44 canonical disposition) is now resolved by Will's archival action: A-43 (no-suffix file, 52,949 bytes) was archived; A-44 (the (1)-suffix file, 41,659 bytes) was kept active and relocated into the new DOC23 Addenda subfolder. A-44 is therefore the operative R4.0; A-43's archived content remains for reference. Row preserved for traceability.** |
| A-44 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization R4.0 (duplicate-name file) | 2026-05-01 (mtime 2026-05-01 06:44) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); Prop-A R6.3 (companion) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.7 (auto-detected 2026-05-01).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Duplicate-name R4.0 file (size 41,659 bytes — DIFFERENT from A-43's 52,949 bytes by ~21%). Filename includes "(1)" suffix, typically generated by macOS when downloading a file whose name already exists. Content NOT identical to A-43 (`diff -q` confirms files differ). Both files coexist in active folder. Possible explanations: (a) Will downloaded a different draft mid-stream; (b) two parallel revisions both labeled R4.0; (c) prior R4.0 was overwritten externally then re-downloaded. Human disposition needed: which file is canonical R4.0? Until then, A-43 (the file without the suffix) is treated as the primary and A-44 is held informationally. Sync did NOT delete or rename either file per task constraint #1 (never delete). **R3.9 note (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30): file moved into NEW `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder; new path `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime preserved at 2026-04-30 23:44, size unchanged 41,659 bytes). The R3.7 canonical-determination question is resolved: A-43 (no-suffix file, larger size 52,949 bytes) was archived; A-44 (this file, 41,659 bytes) was kept active. A-44 is therefore the operative R4.0 of DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization. New §A6 DOC23 Addenda subfolder section added below to track this file in its new location alongside the brand-new context management proposal A-45. Row preserved here in §A1 with file-moved-to-§A6 annotation; A-44 is also referenced from §A6 with a "previously listed in §A1" pointer for traceability.** |

### A2. DOC20 Addenda subfolder

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-15 | `DOC20 Addenda/DOC20_ADDENDUM_B_MS_WORD_VIEWER_CAPABILITIES_R3.md` | DOC20 Addendum B: Document Viewer & Editor Capabilities (R3) | 2026-04-10 | DOC20 R4.3 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Front-end build spec for Word/PDF viewing/editing in Q Dashboard's Electron app — copy-on-write policy, tracked changes, OnlyOffice + Microsoft Graph wiring. |
| A-16 | `DOC20 Addenda/DOC20_BUILD_DELTA.md` | DOC20 Build Delta — Living Changelog | last updated 2026-04-15 | DOC20 R4.3 + Q_UNIFIED_WORKSPACE_V8_0_1.jsx mockup | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Running log of build-session implementation deltas (e.g., dark-mode system) that diverge from or extend DOC20; future sessions must reconcile against this first. |
| A-17 | `DOC20 Addenda/DOC20_Q_BROWSER_INTAKE_ARCHITECTURE.md` | DOC20 §6.19 Addition — Q Browser Knowledge Intake Architecture | 2026-04-03 | DOC20 §6.19 (primary); DOC72 §20A, DOC16 Entry 16.7, DOC3 R11.3, DOC8 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Two-tier intake pipeline making Q Browser a knowledge intake surface — passive metadata, idle entity extraction, M365 web app enhanced intake. |
| A-18 | `DOC20 Addenda/DOC20_R4_3_DELTA_V7_11_6_ALT.md` | DOC20 R4.2 → R4.3 Spec Delta: V7.11.6 Alt — Vertical Tabs, Workspaces, Nav Restructure | 2026-04-08 | DOC20 R4.3 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Spec delta for the R4.3 vertical-tabs/workspaces/nav-restructure mockup — sourced from V7.11.6 Alt mockup session V1–V8. |

### A3. DOC24 Addenda subfolder

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-19 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_ADDENDUM-B [KDA] KNOWLEDGE_DELIVERY_SHARED_CONTRACTS_R2.md` | DOC24 Knowledge Delivery Architecture — Shared Contracts, Rendering, and Neuroplasticity R2 | 2026-04-01 | DOC24 (primary); DOC72, DOC3, DOC8, DOC15, DOC11 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (natural-progression-superseded by A-73 R3 DRAFT v0.2 in R3.55 — pending R3 finalization before archival) | KDA R2 — shared knowledge contract schemas (DOC72-governed), tiered rendering, dynamic composition, neuroplasticity; DOC24 R2.5 forward-references this addendum. |
| A-20 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_ADDENDUM_Q_DASHBOARD_TOOL_REGISTRY.md` | DOC24 Addendum: Q Dashboard Tool Registry | 2026-04-11 | DOC24 R2.5 §14.5, §16.4, Appendix B | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Living document — tool definitions reflecting current Q Dashboard build state; re-derived from `q-dashboard/src/` at major UI milestones. |
| A-21 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_AMENDMENT_PERSISTENT_ONBOARDING_CURIOSITY.md` | DOC24 Amendment — Persistent Onboarding Curiosity | 2026-04-12 | DOC24 R2.5 §§11.5, 12.4D, 12.4E; DOC72 §27.7 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Amends probe budget, contextual question cost tier, and PauseOnboardingRequest guardrails so onboarding remains curious without compounding annoyance into silence. |
| A-22 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM Operative_Spec_V6_4.md` | DOC24 Addendum A R2 v6.4 — The Big Dynamic Satisfaction Machine (BDSM) | undated; v6.4 patch over v6.3 audit-against-adjudication delta | DOC24 (primary); DOC72, DOC8, DOC1, EC Core, DOC10/DOC11, DOC15, DOC21/22, DOC3, DOC17 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (natural-progression-superseded by A-72 V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 in R3.55 — pending v6.5 finalization before archival) | Operative Satisfaction Matrix — context-specific learning of injected knowledge utility, tool/procedure choice, question phrasing; compiled into deterministic policy bundles. |
| A-23 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_UNIFIED_CONTEXT_BUDGET_GOVERNANCE.md` | DOC24 R2.5 Addition: Unified Context Budget Governance and DOC7 Coordination | 2026-04-03 | DOC24 (primary); DOC7 §4.4 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Replaces independent KDA §3.6 and DOC7 §4.4 budgets with a unified budget; adds overlap detection between knowledge cards and inlined bucket content. |
| A-72 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_2.md` | DOC24 Addendum A — The Big Dynamic Satisfaction Machine (BDSM) v6.5 DRAFT v0.2 | 2026-05-19 (mtime 2026-05-19 13:50:39 local; size 151,668 bytes; +10,566 bytes / +7.5% over A-22 V6.4) | DOC24 (primary); DOC72, DOC8, DOC1, EC Core, DOC10/DOC11, DOC15, DOC21/22, DOC3, DOC17 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.55 (auto-detected 2026-05-19 ~13:55 local); needs human classification.** v6.5 DRAFT v0.2 successor in BDSM Operative Spec chain. `_DRAFT_v0_2` filename suffix indicates working-draft variant — likely first of a v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL draft series before A-22 V6.4 supersession. Companion to A-73 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 created in same ~2h window (first multi-DOC24-draft drift in single sync window). Full file-header inspection deferred. **R3.58 note (auto-detected 2026-05-20): natural-progression-superseded by v0.3 draft (new row A-75 below; same v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL draft chain pattern). v0.2 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision. Row preserved for traceability pending finalization of V6.5 chain.** |
| A-73 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2.md` | DOC24 Knowledge Delivery Architecture R3 DRAFT v0.2 (filename-canonicalized) | 2026-05-19 (mtime 2026-05-19 11:54:51 local; size 93,832 bytes; +20,661 bytes / +28% over A-19 R2) | DOC24 (primary); DOC72, DOC3, DOC8, DOC15, DOC11, DOC23 family (per A-74 coherence map) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.55 (auto-detected 2026-05-19 ~13:55 local); needs human classification.** R3 DRAFT v0.2 successor in DOC24 KDA chain with **filename canonicalization**: long-form `DOC24_ADDENDUM-B [KDA] KNOWLEDGE_DELIVERY_SHARED_CONTRACTS_R2` → short-form `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2` (analogous to ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES → ARCHITECTURE canonicalization from R3.53 + DOC23 ADDB V2 → V3 OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION → OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR canonicalization). +28% size growth suggests substantive R3 expansion likely incorporating cross-references with new A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1 + neuroplasticity refinements. Full file-header inspection deferred. **R3.58 note (auto-detected 2026-05-20): natural-progression-superseded by v0.3 draft (new row A-76 below; per v0.3 file header "v0.3 is a mechanical preservation patch over v0.2, closing the ten KDA R2 preservation gaps enumerated in the v0.3 patch plan"). v0.2 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision. Row preserved for traceability pending finalization of R3 chain.** |
| A-75 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3.md` | DOC24 Addendum A — Big Dynamic Satisfaction Machine (BDSM) V6.5 Draft v0.3 | 2026-05-20 (mtime 2026-05-20 11:27:03 local; size 170,708 bytes; +19,040 bytes / +12.6% over A-72 v0.2) | DOC24 R3.1.1 (primary consumption); DOC8 (computation owner); DOC72 (schema ownership); EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (durable writes / effective state / orchestration); PropA R6.3 (policy gates); A-76 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.3 (companion — render metadata); DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 = A-61 (learning signals); DOC73 V1.6 Artifacts 1–5 (privacy / RecentActivityRollup / AVAPO surfaces) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.58 (auto-detected 2026-05-20).** Per file header: "Draft operative revision v0.3 for review — applies the v0.3 corrective patch plan over the v0.2 BDSM V6.5 draft and replaces BDSM v6.4 for the V6.5+ revision lane." **Draft basis:** BDSM/KDA Adjudication Card V1.3.1-OPA15; DOC24 R3.1.1; KDA R3 Draft v0.2; BDSM V6.5 Draft v0.2 Patch Plan; BDSM V6.5 Draft v0.3 Patch Plan; OP-A V3.15; EC Core Addendum A V3.3; PropA R6.3; DOC73 V1.6 Artifacts 1–5; DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 + current family documents. V6.5 revision summary (per §0): repairs v6.4 unbuildability via 10 normative changes — (1) DOC24 manifest chain as attribution spine; (2) BDSM emits DOC24 `DirectiveConstraint[]` rather than scalar force levels; (3) BDSM emits normalized relevance ∈ [0,1]; (4) all learning partitioned by `LearningVisibilityScope`/model class/principal-matter-firewall scope/policy generation; (5) EC owns effective state + durable writes + background orchestration; (6) DOC8 owns computation implementation; (7) KDA R3 render metadata required for variant attribution; (8) DOC23 signal envelopes enter through single typed ingestion path; (9) reason codes are closed literals; (10) quantitative formulas guarded (no-signal-row reward dilution, decay amplification, parent-chain smoothing, residual-Shapley bucket non-attributability). Companion to A-76 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.3 created within ~1h window — second consecutive multi-DOC24-draft sync window (R3.55 v0.2 pair + R3.58 v0.3 pair). |
| A-76 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3.md` | DOC24 Knowledge Delivery Architecture — Shared Contracts, Rendering, and Neuroplasticity R3 Draft v0.3 | 2026-05-20 (mtime 2026-05-20 12:23:19 local; size 128,723 bytes; +34,891 bytes / +37.2% over A-73 v0.2) | DOC24 R3.1.1+ (primary); DOC72, DOC8/BDSM (= A-75), DOC73 V1.6, PropA, EC Core, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC25, DOC23 Addenda B, OP-A V3.15 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.58 (auto-detected 2026-05-20).** Per file header: "Draft operative companion revision v0.3 — generated from the BDSM/KDA adjudication card V1.3.1-OPA15, patched by `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_V0_2_PATCH_PLAN.md`, and preservation-patched by `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_V0_3_PATCH_PLAN.md`. v0.3 is a mechanical preservation patch over v0.2, closing the ten KDA R2 preservation gaps enumerated in the v0.3 patch plan." R3 change summary (14 changes): (1) KDA emits `KdaManifestPatch` discriminated union, no local injection manifest; (2) reference-only and excluded cards are presence states, not compact renderings; (3) rendering returns structured results with token counts/tokenizer ref/render variant/template version/provenance; (4) KDA tiering consumes DOC24 canonical constraints; (5) tier allocation constraint-aware + exact-token verified; (6) client kind canonicalized to `elnor_native` (with `local_elnor` migration alias); (7) PropA destination policy applies before rendering; (8) KDA renderer is pure (no durable reads/cache reads/network/LLM); (9) execution-strategy cache keys versioned and policy-sensitive; (10) neuroplasticity scoped/materialized/canary-governed; (11) composition preserves component attribution; (12) tokenizer drift is explicit decision path; (13) work products route to DOC25/document-tier rendering; (14) reason codes are closed literals with runtime details in metadata. Companion to A-75 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3 created within ~1h window. +37.2% size growth over v0.2 substantially larger than typical patch increment, consistent with "ten preservation-gap closures" described in file header. |
| A-80 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` | DOC24 Addendum A — Big Dynamic Satisfaction Machine (BDSM) V6.5 Draft v0.3 [filename `_v0_3_1` intra-version patch] | 2026-05-20 (mtime 2026-05-20 16:15 local; size 178,518 bytes; +7,810 bytes / +4.6% over A-75 v0.3) | DOC24 R3.1.1 (primary); DOC8, DOC72, EC Core, PropA, KDA R3, DOC23 Addenda B, DOC73 V1.6 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **Back-filled in R3.61 (reconciliation — claimed as new row A-80 in R3.59 changelog but never written into this table).** **First-ever fourth-decimal-place patch suffix** `_v0_3_1` in the BDSM chain, extending the v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL working-draft series with intra-version patch granularity (analogous to the DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 → V3.1 → V3.2 minor-revision pattern from R3.47/R3.49). Note the **filename says `v0_3_1` but the internal H1 still reads "V6.5 Draft v0.3"** — a filename-vs-internal-version discrepancy flagged for human classification; the +4.6% size delta over v0.3 is consistent with a small corrective patch rather than a v0.4 increment. A-75 v0.3 row retains natural-progression-intra-version-patch-successor annotation pending finalization. |
| A-81 | `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` | DOC24 Knowledge Delivery Architecture — Shared Contracts, Rendering, and Neuroplasticity R3 Draft v0.3 [filename `_v0_3_1` intra-version patch] | 2026-05-20 (mtime 2026-05-20 16:14 local; size 129,645 bytes; +922 bytes / +0.7% over A-76 v0.3) | DOC24 R3.1.1+ (primary); DOC72, DOC8/BDSM, DOC73, PropA, EC Core, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC25, DOC23 Addenda B, OP-A V3.15 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEWLY DETECTED + tracked in R3.61 (reconciliation — this file existed on disk since 2026-05-20 16:14 but was NEVER counted or rowed by R3.58/R3.59/R3.60; the R3.60 §A3 count of 10 undercounted the 11 actual files by exactly this file).** KDA companion to the BDSM `_v0_3_1` intra-version patch (A-80), written ~1min earlier in the same window — confirms the v0.3.1 patch was a coordinated BDSM+KDA pair (mirroring the v0.2 and v0.3 BDSM+KDA pairing cadence). Same filename-vs-internal-version discrepancy as A-80 (filename `v0_3_1`, internal H1 "R3 Draft v0.3"); the +0.7% size delta over v0.3 is consistent with a minor preservation patch. A-76 v0.3 row retains natural-progression-intra-version-patch-successor annotation pending finalization. |

### A4. DOC72 Addenda and Proposals subfolder

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-24 | `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/DOC72_DOC7_BUCKET_INTAKE_INSERTION_TEXT.md` | DOC72 + DOC7 — Bucket File Intake: Insertion Text | undated | DOC72 R5.5 §20A.2/§20B.14; DOC7 R6 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Exact insertion text for adding the `bucket` IntakeSurface and §20B.14 Bucket Files contract into DOC72/DOC7. |
| A-25 | `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R1.md` | DOC72 Proposal — Continuity Synthesis Architecture | 2026-04-13 | DOC72 (primary); DOC24, DOC11, DOC15, DOC8, DOC2 (retirement), EC Core | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Three capabilities: cross-conversation continuity, activity-type-aware significance gating, temporal awareness with DOC2 retirement. Built on GIE V2.1 constellation schema (§4.5). **R3.4 note (auto-detected 2026-04-30): file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R1.md`. Superseded by R2 (new row A-37 below). Row preserved for traceability pending human reclassification.** |
| A-26 | `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/DOC72_PROPOSAL_SURFACE_INTAKE_CONTRACTS_V2.md` | DOC72 Proposal — Surface Intake Contracts for To-Do, Calendar, Notes, and Browser | 2026-04-08 | DOC72 §20A | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | Specifies the under-specified intake contracts for four Q surfaces (To-Do, Calendar, Notes, Browser). |
| A-37 | `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R2.md` | DOC72 Proposal — Continuity Synthesis Architecture R2 | 2026-04-29 (mtime 2026-04-29 18:28) | DOC72 (primary); DOC24, DOC11, DOC15, DOC8, DOC2 (retirement), EC Core, DOC73 V1.5.1 §6.4 Mechanism 4 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.4 (auto-detected 2026-04-30).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. R2 supersedes A-25 (R1 file moved to archive). Size 83,554 bytes (R1 was 48,797 bytes — ~71% larger). Per its own header, R2 introduces a three-tier fresh-surface injection model whose Tier 2 ("recent activity narrative") depends on DOC73 §6.4 Mechanism 4 producing a cross-context rollup file — companion to A-38 (DOC73 §6.4 Mechanism 4 Rollup V1 proposal). |

### A5. DOC73 Addenda and Proposals subfolder (NEW in R2.9)

**Auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync:** new subfolder `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` appeared in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (created 2026-04-27 22:50). Subfolder structurally analogous to `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/`. Tracked here for visibility; in-scope folder list in nightly sync task SKILL.md needs human update to formally include this path.

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-30 | `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/DOC73_CORPUS_SOURCE_BINDINGS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | DOC73 Corpus Source Bindings Proposal V1 | 2026-04-27 | DOC73 V1.4.1 (now V1.5.1); DOC25, DOC72, EC Core Addendum A | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R2.9 (auto-detected 2026-04-28).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Companion proposal to A-27 (EC Core Addendum A Intake Routing for Corpus Bindings). **R3.4 note: pre-dates DOC73 V1.5.1 release (2026-04-29) — may need re-targeting against V1.5.1 §15.2.** |
| A-38 | `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/DOC73_PROPOSAL_SECTION_6_4_MECHANISM_4_ROLLUP_V1.md` | DOC73 Proposal — §6.4 Mechanism 4 Specification: Recent-Activity Rollup V1 | 2026-04-29 (mtime 2026-04-29 18:31) | DOC73 V1.5.1 §6.4 Mechanism 4 (primary); DOC24 R3 packet assembly, DOC72 CSA R2 (A-37) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.4 (auto-detected 2026-04-30).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Per file header: "Standalone handoff document. Target: DOC73 V1.5.1 §6.4 Mechanism 4 (currently named but undefined). Origin: Identified as a gap during CSA R2 (DOC72 Continuity Synthesis Architecture R2) drafting." Specifies output file `ELNOR_MEMORY/rollup/recent_activity.md` refreshed nightly via single LLM call (Kimi or local Ollama, <$0.01/day). Companion to A-37 (DOC72 CSA R2). Size 26,669 bytes. |
| A-39 | `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/DOC73_V1_6_ADJUDICATION_CARD_ARCHITECT_NOTES_V1 (1).md` | DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card Architect Notes V1 | 2026-04-30 (mtime 2026-04-30 04:14) | DOC73 V1.5.1 (forthcoming V1.6) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.4 (auto-detected 2026-04-30).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Small file (73 lines, 6,441 bytes). Likely architect notes / adjudication card for the upcoming DOC73 V1.5.1 → V1.6 red-team round. Filename includes "(1)" suffix suggesting Will may have copied this from Downloads. |

### A6. DOC23 Addenda subfolder (NEW in R3.9; expanded in R3.10 + R3.12 + R3.13 + R3.15 + R3.16 + R3.18 + R3.33 + R3.39 + R3.44 + R3.47 + R3.49 — NEW sub-sub-folder `doc23 add b rework/` in R3.49 representing major architectural decomposition of Addenda B into Core + V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts family topology)

**Auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30 by nightly sync (fourth pass of the day):** new subfolder `DOC23 Addenda/` appeared in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (folder mtime 2026-05-01 10:27). Subfolder is structurally analogous to the existing `DOC20 Addenda/`, `DOC24 Addenda/`, `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/`, and `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolders. Tracked here for visibility; in-scope folder list in nightly sync task SKILL.md needs human update to formally include this path (same gap as the DOC73 Addenda subfolder addition in R2.9 — that gap is also still outstanding; gap is especially salient now in R3.15 with 6 active files in this subfolder including A-51 R0.6.1 the new B-track entry). **R3.12 expansion (2026-05-02 ~16:00):** subfolder grew from 3 active files (A-44 alias + A-45 + A-46) at R3.11 to 5 active files (A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 — A-44 alias archived in this pass). DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 → R4.0 (1) → R4.1 V1 → R4.1 V2 chain ends at A-47 R4.1 V2 as of R3.12. **R3.13 expansion (2026-05-03 ~03:10):** added A-50 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.3) — first DOC23 Addenda B entry, opening parallel B-track. **R3.15 expansion (2026-05-03 ~16:00):** added A-51 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.1 merge-audit cleaned) which supersedes A-50 R0.3 + the briefly-extant R0.5 audit-complete merge pack. **NEW intra-subfolder archive pattern in R3.15:** Will created a NEW `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` subfolder (folder mtime 2026-05-03 15:52) — **first time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive subfolder.** This differs from the global `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archival convention used for all prior archive moves. Active subfolder count after R3.15: 6 files (A-45 / A-46 / A-47 / A-48 / A-49 / A-51 — A-44 alias archived in R3.12 to global archive; A-50 archived in R3.15 to NEW intra-subfolder archive). Intra-subfolder archive contents at R3.15: 2 files (A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5).

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-44 (alias) | `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization R4.0 ((1) duplicate-suffix variant) — ARCHIVED in R3.12 | 2026-05-02 (mtime preserved at 2026-04-30 23:44 across both moves) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); Prop-A R6.3 (DSPy self-improvement engine, companion); A-45 (Judge Context Management Proposal V1) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **Relocated in R3.9 from §A1 to this subfolder; ARCHIVED in R3.12 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~16:00).** See §A1 row A-44 for original detection history. R3.9 disposition: Will archived the no-suffix R4.0 file (A-43) but kept this (1)-suffix file active in this subfolder, signalling A-44 was operative R4.0. **R3.12 update:** A-44 is now also archived (path `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md`, mtime preserved 2026-04-30 23:44, size unchanged 41,659 bytes). Superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2 (this row's content was the input to the R4.1 V1 → V2 audit pass). Row preserved here for traceability; needs human reclassification. **Mirrors A-43's R3.9 archival pattern.** |
| A-45 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_CONTEXT_MANAGEMENT_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | DOC23 Addenda A R4.0 — Judge Context Management Proposal V1 | 2026-05-01 (mtime 2026-05-01 10:26) | DOC23 Addenda A R4.0 — Judge Context Management Proposal V1 originally targeted A-44 R4.0 (1); R3.12 now tracks against A-47 R4.1 V2 since A-44 is archived. Cross-references DOC25 V1.0 (Document Intelligence & Universal Ingestion), DOC23 R3.1 (parent), DOC24 R3 (capability/context architecture), DOC15 CIL R7.1 (context budgets), DOC72 R5.73 (entity graph for §8 contract), MultiDoc PropA R6.3 (sensitivity classification primitives), ELNOR Subagent V4 (sub-agent patterns) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.9 (auto-detected 2026-05-01 10:26).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Per file header: proposal addendum V1 (Draft) authored by Claude Opus 4.7 in dialogue with Will, target compilation revision DOC23 Addenda A R4.1, supersedes nothing (new proposal), status "Draft proposal — pending review, calibration, red team, and compilation into R4.1." Origin per §0: closes a CRITICAL gap in A-44 (R4.0)'s Judge module §A3, flagged by two same-day red team reviews (Claude V1 with 40 findings; Claude V2 deeper-dive with 34 additional findings). Proposal scope: defines a regime-classification preparation pipeline, three new variant-bundle schemas, sub-agent fan-out dispatch modes, per-dimension context-requirement flags, a DOC25 ingestion contract, and supporting validation/SSE/UI surfaces. Concrete ambition: enable a 4-variant × 5-dimension × 3-judge ensemble pairwise scoring of a 60-page complaint draft to run within model context windows AND under $25 per run AND in under 90 seconds wall-clock. File size 53,884 bytes. **R3.12 note:** the V5 adjudication card (referenced extensively by A-47, A-48, A-49) absorbed all 5 candidate elevations from this proposal as rows #234–#238 (per A-49's V2 changes summary); compilation pathway into R4.1/R5 is now traceable through A-49 (Card Integration Map V2) → A-47 (R4.1 V2) for R4.1-bound items and A-48 (R5/R6 Deferral List V2) for R5-bound items. |
| A-46 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` | DOC23 Red Line — Sequential Re-Prompt System | 2026-05-02 (mtime 2026-05-02 00:31, header date 2026-05-01) | DOC23 R3.1 §3.2.1 (step.agent_task), §3.2.8 (step.coding), §6.5.2 (agent task execution), §6.5.8 (coding execution), §4.5 (output popups), §4.8 (validation) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.10 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 by nightly sync).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Per file header: status "Draft addendum for compilation into DOC23 R3.2." File size 22,818 bytes. Note: targets DOC23 R3.2 compilation revision, distinct from A-45/A-47 which target DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 — implies parallel evolution of operative DOC23 spec (R3.1 → R3.2) alongside its addenda (R4.0 → R4.1). |
| A-47 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V2.md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization (R4.1 V2 Draft) | 2026-05-02 (mtime 2026-05-02 12:34) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); Prop-A R6.3 (DSPy self-improvement engine — independent pathway, companion); DOC24 R3 (capability/context architecture); DOC25 V1.0 (Document Intelligence) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.12 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~16:00).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Large file (size 154,930 bytes — ~3.7× the prior A-44 R4.0 (1) size of 41,659 bytes). Per file header: R4.1 V2 (Draft), status "Draft — V2 closes 25 row gaps + 2 deviations from V1 audit. Pending Will's review against V5 adjudication card. Compiles into DOC23 R3.2." Research basis: CheckEval (EMNLP 2025), FLASK (ICLR 2024), RULERS (2025), G-Eval (EMNLP 2023), CyclicJudge (2025), MT-Bench (Zheng et al. 2023), GEPA (Agrawal et al. 2026 ICLR Oral). Per its own §A1 framing: closes contract for five capabilities (Experiments `system.experiment`, Claim Extraction `step.claim_extractor`, Judges `step.judge`, Sub-Agent Awareness via OpenClaw native `sessions_spawn`, Prompt Optimization — the last one explicitly RESERVED FOR R5; R4.1 ships no operative DSPy runtime, no `optimization_out` port, no Promote mutation) plus two cross-cutting capabilities (DOC24 Context Injection §A8, Session Continuity §A9). Per its own §A1 scope statement: R4.1 = contract closure + schema cleanup + safety items + minimum context-management subset that makes Pattern 7 runnable; R4.1 does NOT add the optimization platform (deferred R5), human evaluation (R5), code-based scorers (R5), full Context Management Proposal V1 substrate (R5), or campaigns/dataset library (R6). V2 changelog per file: closes 25 R4.1 row gaps + 2 card deviations identified in V1 audit, adds ExperimentCostPolicy + ExperimentEmissionPolicy + ExperimentFilePolicy + SameAsBaselineResolution + variant session capacity check (§A2); ClaimMetricFormulas + ScorerSnapshot + indeterminate_out + JudgeGateConfig + cost preview UX + Judge port rename (`comparison_in` → `comparison_bundle_in` + `candidate_in`) + pairwise blowup warning (§A3); ModulePresetSanitizationPolicy (§A4); Run-scoped detail views (§A5); UserDefinedClaimType.field_schema + Judge consumption of evaluation_instruction + evaluable:false handling + evaluator-mode CIL + source_spans[] + truncation bias warning (§A6); VerificationStrategy enum + JudgeToolPolicy + SubAgentTraceRef policy receipts + deterministic verification plan (§A7); per-module-type budget table + structured preamble + step.coding sub-mode + filing convention memory query + TaskContextInjectionConfig profile (§A8); ACP profile in SessionResumeCheck (§A9); Sub-agent SSE reconciliation (§A10); Submit to Memory Review + non-injectable artifacts policy (§A11); Loop body warning + cross-task pattern (§A12); R4.1 API route list + DOC20 §6.18.2 registration + §A5 extension callout (§A13); EC-internal route convention (§A14). **Supersedes A-44 R4.0 (1) and a briefly-extant R4.1 V1** (V1 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1.md` mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 103,002 bytes — created and archived in same window as V2; V2 changelog explicitly identifies V2 as "Audit-pass additions. Closes 25 R4.1 row gaps + 2 card deviations identified in V1 audit"). |
| A-48 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V2.md` | DOC23 Addenda A — R5 / R6 Deferral List V2 | 2026-05-02 (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58) | DOC23 Addenda A R5 / R6 (work plan organized by functional spec area for R5/R6 drafting); companion to `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_ADJUDICATION_CARD_V5.md` (V5 = 238 rows, not registered in master spec list — lives in not-yet-tracked location); cross-references A-45 Context Management Proposal V1 + the two §8 Notes substrate proposals | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.12 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~16:00).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. File size 30,631 bytes. Per file header: status "Pre-adjudication — will be revised after Will fills the V5 Decision column to V3 (post-adjudication)." Date 2026-05-02. V2 changes per file: updated to reference card V5 (was V4); added §1.O lazy claim verification (card row #234); added §1.P hierarchical scoring for huge variants (card row #235); updated §1.N Context Management Proposal V1 to include OB-A15 (card row #238); §1.M2 R4.1 portion now includes validation codes from cards #236, #237; added §6 Calibration items for R5 (proposal §14, six items). Scope per file: R4.1 = immediate contract closure (177 rows + 23 NON_OPERATIVE_R4.1 text removals); R5 = next major revision (29 dedicated rows + R5 portions of 6 hybrids + 2 §8 Notes substantive R5 implementations + 1 separate addenda doc); R6 = later (4 rows). Three top-level sections: §1 R5 work plan grouped by functional area A–N (DSPy + Optimization Platform §1.A is the single biggest R5 work package — 23 rows removing unsafe optimization text from R4.0 + R5 implementing the platform from scratch with safety machinery); §2 R6 work plan (4 items); §3 external documents that compile into R5/R6. Cross-doc obligations OB-A14 through OB-A18 flagged with responsible doc owner. **Supersedes a briefly-extant V1** (V1 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V1.md` mtime 2026-05-02 09:58, size 24,682 bytes — created and archived in same window as V2; V2 explicitly identifies its changes from V1). |
| A-49 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_CONTEXT_MGMT_PROPOSAL_V1_TO_CARD_INTEGRATION_MAP_V2.md` | Context Management Proposal V1 → V5 Card Integration Map V2 | 2026-05-02 (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58) | A-45 DOC23 Addenda A R4.0 — Judge Context Management Proposal V1 (the proposal); the V5 adjudication card `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_ADJUDICATION_CARD_V5.md` (238 rows, 14 sections, dated 2026-05-02 — not registered in master spec list); A-48 R5/R6 Deferral List V2 (companion) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.12 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~16:00).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. File size 23,341 bytes. **Per file header: this is a meta/navigation document — "A section-by-section accounting of the Context Management Proposal V1 against the V5 adjudication card. For each section of the proposal, this map tells you: where (if anywhere) it lives in the card, what release it's scheduled for, and whether it's tracked at row level or only by reference."** Date 2026-05-02. Status "Complete. All proposal spec content is accounted for — either as a card row or a deferral list entry." V2 changes per file: V1 identified 5 candidate elevations and 6 calibration items as work needed in V5 of the card; card V5 absorbed all 5 elevations as rows #234–#238; calibration items moved to deferral list §6. Closed-loop integration map between proposal A-45 and the V5 card. **Like A-34 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1, this file is non-normative by purpose — it modifies nothing and explicitly disclaims operative status.** Likely needs reclassification to `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / NAVIGATION / REFERENCE` rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM`; flagged for human review. Status legend per file: In R4.1 / In R5 / In R5 by reference only / Not in card / Proposal meta / Conflict flag. |
| A-50 | `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` *(moved to intra-subfolder archive in R3.15)* | DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, and Self-Improving Task Design (R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft) — ARCHIVED in R3.15 | 2026-05-03 (mtime now 2026-05-02 19:36, preserved across move; size unchanged 143,665 bytes) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); companions DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 (= A-47), DOC24 R3, DOC72 R5.73, DOC25 V2.0, DOC73 V1.5.1, DOC8 v1.11.4, DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4, DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35), EC Core Addendum A V3.3, OP-A V3.7 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.13 (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~03:10); ARCHIVED in R3.15 (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~16:00).** Originally registered when first DOC23 Addenda B entry shipped. Auto-detected; needs human classification. Was 143,665 bytes. **First DOC23 Addenda B entry** — opened a brand-new track parallel to DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization (A-40 through A-47 chain). The naming convention established "DOC23 Addenda A" = Task Optimization (Experiments / Judges / Prompt Optimization) and "DOC23 Addenda B" = Task Intelligence / Memory / Observability / Self-Improving Task Design. Per its own §0.4 scope summary, Addenda B defines: (1) Task Agent as the conversational task-design / inspection / retrieval / assessment surface; (2) Task Agent education through a hybrid self-updating Task Design Intelligence substrate; (3) Task Blueprint as the semantic intent contract behind a graph; (4) reuse-first task creation through task templates and module presets; (5) DOC72 Task Activity Memory for task runs / outputs / artifacts / goals / entities / matters / follow-on sessions; (6) task telemetry and trace spans; (7) artifact/output intake policy for final and intermediate outputs; (8) DOC24 capability binding and runtime expansion for tools / connectors / MCP servers / procedures / skills / models; (9) task creation learning, Task Assessment, and self-improvement loops; (10) UI / storage / routes / validation / cross-doc obligations required to make the above real. **R3.15 archival disposition:** R0.3 was used as the base document for R0.6.1 merge-pass (per R0.6.1 §0 source-merge declaration: "uses `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` as the base document and folds in `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_R0_5_AUDIT_COMPLETE_MERGE_PACK_TASK_INVOCATION_TA_PROMPT_EVAL.md`"). Will moved A-50 R0.3 into a NEW intra-subfolder `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (created 2026-05-03 15:52 — first time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive subfolder; differs from the global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archival convention). Predecessor R0.1 (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_1.md`) remains in the global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. R0.5 briefly-extant file (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_R0_5_AUDIT_COMPLETE_MERGE_PACK_TASK_INVOCATION_TA_PROMPT_EVAL.md`, 103,376 bytes, mtime 2026-05-03 15:24) detected only in the new intra-subfolder archive — never had its own master spec list row (created and archived in same window between R3.14 and R3.15). Superseded by A-51 R0.6.1 (next row below). Row preserved here for traceability pending human reclassification. |
| A-55 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluation and Revision Architecture, V2 (SUPERSEDES A-54 R0.6.5 V1 per V2 header) | 2026-05-14 (mtime 2026-05-14 03:32 UTC) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent via Addenda B R0.6.4); supersedes A-54 R0.6.5 V1 per V2 header's explicit "Supersedes:" declaration; companions same as A-54 (DOC23 Addenda A R4.1, DOC20 R4.3, DOC24 R3, DOC24 KDA R2, DOC25 V2.0, DOC72 R5.73, DOC73 V1.5, DOC17 R4.2, DOC8 v1.11.4, BDSM v6.4, DOC11/OpenClaw R15, DOC12 forum/panel, EC Core Addendum A V3.3, PropA R6.3) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.39 (auto-detected 2026-05-14 ~10:10 UTC); needs human classification.** File size 133,682 bytes; 2,740 lines. **New filename convention** — uses "ADDB" abbreviation ("Addenda B") instead of full "ADDENDA_B" spelling, and uses semantic version "V2" instead of R0.x version numbering. Per V2 file header: "DOC23 Task System — Addenda B ADDENDUM: Outcome Evaluation and Revision Architecture, V2". Document hierarchy per file: "DOC23 (R3.1) → Addenda B (R0.6.4) → Addendum (this doc, V2)". Status: "Proposal — pending red-team review per §25. Not yet folded into Addenda B main." Author: "Will Brody (architecture) + Claude (drafting)." **Explicit supersession declaration**: "Supersedes: `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL_ADDITION_FOR_R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (V1)" — V1 is the existing A-54 stacked proposal detected by R3.33. Per V2 §0.1 Change Log from V1: "V2 is a substantial architectural revision, not an incremental edit." V1's primitives RETAINED: OutcomeSpec / OutcomeEvaluatorConfig / OutcomeGate / EvaluationFeedbackBundle / defeasible findings lifecycle / Run Guidance Items / Repair Instructions / four feedback delivery channels / FeedbackConsumptionReceipts / TaskSourceWorkspace / TaskProcessGapSignal. **V2 closes 11 specification gaps V1 lacked:** (1) outcome creation UX without 15-field form (V1 was builder-facing); (2) plan-and-execute layer (V1 had Repair Instructions but no module that produced or dispatched them); (3) targeted evaluation mode (V1's Evaluator only ran in "evaluate everything" mode); (4) per-outcome progress signals beyond pass/fail (no fixed-this-iteration / still-failing / regressed states); (5) cascading revalidation via declared dependencies; (6) two-budget iteration model (V1 had single iteration cap); (7) formal Revision Bus / dispatch runtime; (8) per-module `revision_in` port contract; (9) plan review forum semantics distinct from runtime orchestration; (10) text-to-outcome inference pipeline; (11) skill-graph integration for learned patterns. **New V2 architectural primitives:** `step.revisor` module (§6); `RevisionPlan` schema (§7); Revision Bus runtime (§8); `revision_in` port contract (§9); `target_outcomes` input port on Evaluator (§5.1); `iteration_history` input port on Evaluator (§5.1); `plan_step_context` input port on Evaluator (§5.1). **Supersession-and-replace pattern RESTORED:** V2's explicit "Supersedes:" header returns the DOC23 Addenda B chain to the supersession-and-replace convention familiar from R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4; the R3.33 stacked-proposal pattern was a one-off. **V1 file disposition pending human review:** V1 file (= A-54 row above) remains in active folder per auto pass's no-relocation policy; options for human review: (a) move to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` following supersession-and-archive pattern; (b) keep in active folder for traceability. DOC23 Addenda B chain at R3.39: R0.1 (global archive) → R0.3 (= A-50, intra-subfolder archive R3.15) → R0.5 (briefly-extant, intra-subfolder archive) → R0.6.1 (= A-51, intra-subfolder archive R3.16) → R0.6.3 (= A-52, intra-subfolder archive R3.18) → **R0.6.4 (= A-53, ACTIVE)** + **R0.6.5 V1 stacked proposal (= A-54, ACTIVE pending V1 archival per V2 supersession) + V2 Addendum (= A-55 NEW, ACTIVE)**. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-54 for this V2 file (continues R3.33 single-step numbering from A-53 V1 → A-54 V2); master spec list §4 uses A-55 (preserving R3.33 divergence-by-one). |
| A-54 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` | DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5 — Outcome Evaluation, Source Workspace, Task Forum, and Evaluator Feedback Proposal (initial merge proposal, not yet folded into A-53 R0.6.4 — **SUPERSEDED by A-55 V2 in R3.39 per V2 header; V1 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision**) | 2026-05-10 (mtime 2026-05-10 00:14 UTC) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 / R5-R6 deferral list (= A-47/A-48); DOC20 R4.3; DOC24 R3; DOC24 KDA R2 (= A-19); DOC25 V2.0; DOC72 R5.73; DOC73 V1.5; DOC17 R4.2; DOC8 v1.11.4; BDSM v6.4 (= A-22); DOC11/OpenClaw R15 amendment proposal (= A-1/A-34); DOC12 forum/panel architecture; EC Core Addendum A (= A-4); PropA R6.3 (= A-7) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.33 (auto-detected 2026-05-10 ~10:07 UTC); needs human classification.** File size 74,733 bytes. Filename has typo "PROPSAL" (vs "PROPOSAL") preserved verbatim from filesystem. Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5 — Outcome Evaluation, Source Workspace, Task Forum, and Evaluator Feedback Proposal", date 2026-05-10, status **"Initial merge proposal for review. Not yet folded into the R0.6.4 unified Addenda B draft."** Target document: DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, and Self-Improving Task Design (same end-state architectural draft track as A-53 R0.6.4). Primary purpose per §0 Executive Summary: "Add a graph-native quality-improvement architecture for complex DOC23 tasks, without turning tasks into hidden agent rooms or making simple tasks heavy." Introduces eight new architectural primitives: (1) **Outcome Specs** define what "good enough" means for a task, segment, module, artifact, source workspace, prompt candidate, or final output; (2) **Outcome Evaluators** apply those specs and emit structured decisions, findings, repair instructions, research/source needs, and audit evidence; (3) **Outcome Gates** are Outcome Evaluators configured to control graph flow; (4) **Evaluator Feedback Bundles** make judge/review/evaluator outputs actionable, not merely pass/fail; (5) **Task Source Workspace** gives complex tasks a shared, task-scoped source/research substrate that can grow during the run and be available to later modules, the user, Task Agent, future sessions, and optionally DOC72/DOC73; (6) **Task Run Board** gives every run a structured, chronological audit/feed surface; (7) **Task Forum Module** is an optional, graph-visible module that turns the passive board into a controlled cross-module coordination forum; (8) **Task Agent** remains the operational task-system expert (does NOT become default substantive evaluator — consumes evaluator findings to identify process gaps and propose graph/task improvements). Per §1 Governing Principles: graph primacy preserved (DOC23 graph remains source of process truth), forum non-necessity (Task Run Board/Forum never required for task to function — every workflow expressible as ordinary modules/ports/cables/gates/loops/artifacts), domain-agnostic in core primitives + legally powerful through saved configurations. **Stacked-proposal classification (NEW pattern in R3.33):** A-54 R0.6.5 is positioned as ADDITIONAL stacked proposal on top of A-53 R0.6.4 rather than a strict supersession — file header explicitly states "Not yet folded into the R0.6.4 unified Addenda B draft." This is a new pattern in the DOC23 Addenda B chain, distinct from the prior B-track supersession-and-archive pattern (R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4). Both A-53 R0.6.4 and A-54 R0.6.5 coexist as ACTIVE in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder pending human classification + folder disposition (whether to fold R0.6.5 into R0.6.4 producing R0.6.5-merged unified draft, keep them parallel, or some other disposition). DOC23 Addenda B chain at R3.33: R0.1 (global archive) → R0.3 (= A-50, intra-subfolder archive R3.15) → R0.5 (briefly-extant, intra-subfolder archive) → R0.6.1 (= A-51, intra-subfolder archive R3.16) → R0.6.3 (= A-52, intra-subfolder archive R3.18) → **R0.6.4 (= A-53, ACTIVE) + R0.6.5 stacked proposal (= A-54 NEW R3.33, ACTIVE)**. |
| A-53 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_4_UI_CONTINUATION_SHARING_PATCHED.md` | DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design (R0.6.4 UI / Run Inspector / Module Continuation / Sharing-Forward-Compatible Unified Draft) | 2026-05-04 (mtime 2026-05-04 15:17) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); companions DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 (= A-47); DOC23 Addenda A R5/R6 Deferral List V2 (= A-48); DOC24 R3; DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0; DOC73 V1.5.1; DOC8 v1.11.4; DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4; DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35); DOC17 R4.2; DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R2 (= A-36); OpenClaw Release Alignment Running Spec Update List R2; EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (= A-4); OP-A V3.7; DOC20 (R0.6.4 task-surface integration) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.18 (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~16:00).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Large file (size 327,340 bytes — ~119% of A-52 R0.6.3's 274,551 bytes; ~135% of A-51 R0.6.1's 241,604 bytes; ~228% of A-50 R0.3's 143,665 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design", **R0.6.4 UI, Run Inspector, Module Continuation, Sharing-Forward-Compatible Unified Draft**, dated 2026-05-04, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.4 carries forward R0.6.3 and adds DOC20 task-surface integration, graph/inspector navigation, artifact/delivery UI, context inspector feedback, Task Agent side-panel/session behavior, Task Segment reusable module groups, module continuation/follow-up, run forking/rerun-from-module, Judge/Experiment rerun affordances, audit export, task-page operational stats, and shared-task surface forward-compatibility for future DOC50+ sharing/networking specs." **Supersedes A-52 R0.6.3 + carries forward all R0.6.3 contracts.** Per §0.7 (R0.6.4 UI / module-continuation / sharing-forward-compatibility additions): "R0.6.4 adds the UI and runtime refinements surfaced during the DOC20/mockup review pass. These additions are normative where they define schemas, owner splits, and UI contracts; visual layout examples remain illustrative." Title expanded title-line carries through R0.6.1's "Natural Task Invocation" addition; R0.6.4 title further adds UI / Run Inspector / Module Continuation / Sharing-Forward-Compatible. Source merge: builds on A-52 R0.6.3 (which itself built on A-51 R0.6.1 + R0.5 merge pack + A-50 R0.3). DOC23 Addenda B chain at R3.18: R0.1 (global archive) → R0.3 (= A-50, intra-subfolder archive R3.15) → R0.5 (briefly-extant, intra-subfolder archive) → R0.6.1 (= A-51, intra-subfolder archive R3.16) → R0.6.3 (= A-52, intra-subfolder archive R3.18) → **R0.6.4 (= A-53, ACTIVE)**. |
| A-52 (alias) | `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_3_SURFACE_CONTEXT_PATCHED.md` *(moved to intra-subfolder archive in R3.18)* | DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design (R0.6.3 Surface/Trigger Context Patched Unified Draft) — ARCHIVED in R3.18 | 2026-05-04 (mtime preserved 2026-05-04 00:42 across move; size unchanged 274,551 bytes) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); companions same as A-53 minus DOC20 task-surface integration introduced in R0.6.4 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.16 (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~03:13); ARCHIVED in R3.18 (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~16:00).** Per file header: "R0.6.3 Surface/Trigger Context Patched Unified Draft", date 2026-05-04, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.3 revises the task-module DOC24 context-injection section to remove the singular-current-work-context assumption and add task-run scope envelopes for concurrent chats, scheduled runs, email/webhook/file triggers, and other background executions." R0.6.3 specifically removed singular-current-work-context assumption + added task-run scope envelopes for concurrent chats / scheduled runs / email / webhook / file triggers. **R3.18 archival disposition:** R0.6.3 was used as the carry-forward base for R0.6.4 (per R0.6.4 §0.7 "carries forward R0.6.3"). Will moved A-52 R0.6.3 into the existing intra-subfolder `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (mtime preserved 2026-05-04 00:42). Mirrors A-50 R0.3 (R3.15) and A-51 R0.6.1 (R3.16) archival patterns. **DOC23 Addenda B-track intra-subfolder archive at R3.18: 4 files** (A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5 + A-51 R0.6.1 + A-52 R0.6.3) — collapse opportunity continues to grow; next manual sweep can collapse the cluster. Predecessor R0.1 remains in the global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. Superseded by A-53 R0.6.4 (next row above). Row preserved here for traceability pending human reclassification. |
| A-51 (alias) | `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md` *(moved to intra-subfolder archive in R3.16)* | DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design (R0.6.1 Merge-Audit Cleaned Unified Draft) — ARCHIVED in R3.16 | 2026-05-03 (mtime 2026-05-03 15:51) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); companions DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 (= A-47); DOC23 Addenda A R5/R6 Deferral List V2 (= A-48); DOC24 R3; DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0; DOC73 V1.5.1; DOC8 v1.11.4; DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4; DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35); DOC17 R4.2; DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R2 (= A-36); OpenClaw Release Alignment Running Spec Update List R2; EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (= A-4); OP-A V3.7 | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.15 (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~16:00).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Large file (size 241,604 bytes — ~168% of A-50 R0.3's 143,665 bytes; ~3.4× the briefly-extant A-50→A-51 transitional R0.5 file's 103,376 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design", **R0.6.1 Merge-Audit Cleaned Unified Draft**, dated 2026-05-03, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.1 merge-audit cleaned version combining R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft and R0.5 Audit-Complete Merge Pack source." **Title expanded from R0.3:** adds "Natural Task Invocation" as a fifth named scope term alongside Task Intelligence / Memory / Observability / Self-Improving Task Design. **Source merge per §0:** uses A-50 R0.3 as base document and folds the briefly-extant R0.5 audit-complete merge pack source into one unified draft. Per §0.4 + §0.6 (R0.6.1 unified merge-pass additions, not yet read), R0.6.1 extends the R0.3 architecture with: natural saved-task invocation; DOC72 task-memory integration (deeper than R0.3); telemetry spine; artifact/output intake; Task Blueprint refinements; template/preset intelligence; Task Agent education / TKP (Task Knowledge Pack); task-design self-learning loops; DOC24 capability/runtime routing; OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment; **unified prompt improvement and prompt-evaluation tasks** (new in R0.5 → folded into R0.6.1); plus all cross-doc seams required to make DOC23 a reliable, inspectable, self-improving saved-task system. **Supersedes A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5.** |

| A-57 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluator and Revisor V3 (natural-progression successor to A-55 V2; post-adjudication tightening incorporating Adjudication Card V3.1 + Canonicalization Patch V2) | 2026-05-15 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-16 02:44 UTC) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent via Addenda B R0.6.4); natural-progression successor to A-55 V2 + A-54 V1; 13 explicit cross-doc dependencies enumerated in V3 header (DOC11 ACP/runtime, DOC12 plan review forum, DOC15 CIL authority + context packets, DOC20 UI surfaces for Evaluation/Revision Result Cards + Teach-from-feedback, DOC24 capability registry + runtime injection, DOC25 IngestionResult + source verification, DOC72 Pattern primitive + goal context, DOC73 receipt envelope + PBEOperationReceiptLite, EC Core sole durable writer + retention rows + PolicyDecision gate, BDSM/DOC8 utility learning signals, DOC23 Addenda A Judge module + Claim Extractor + prompt optimization) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.44 (auto-detected 2026-05-16 ~03:10 local); needs human classification.** File size 360,081 bytes; 8,555 lines — **~2.7× the V2 file's 133,682 bytes**. **Filename canonicalization vs V2**: V3 uses `OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR` ("Evaluator and Revisor") instead of V2's `OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION` ("Eval Revision") — more formal/canonical vocabulary. Per V3 file header: "# DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluator and Revisor V3"; **Status:** "V3 specification"; **Version:** "3.0"; **Prepared:** "2026-05-15". **V3 source documents (per file header):** DOC23 Task System Modular Architecture R3.1; DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization) R4.1 V2; DOC23 Addenda B (Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability) R0.6.4; **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Adjudication Card V3.1**; **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Canonicalization Patch V2** — V3 is therefore the post-adjudication revision incorporating Card V3.1 decisions + Canonicalization Patch V2 normalizations. Per V3 header `## Conventions` section: normative rules use MUST/MUST NOT/SHOULD/MAY in the RFC 2119 sense; cross-references use `[X]` format for items in the Adjudication Card V3.1 and `[P-N]` format for patches in the Canonicalization Patch V2 — establishes V3 as a normative spec rather than V2's proposal/draft status. **NEW V3 architectural primitives beyond V2:** `Outcome Compiler` (compiles outcome specs from natural-language input + skill graph patterns); `Revision Compiler` (compiles revision plans into dispatchable units); `Revision Dispatcher` (per-module dispatch runtime evolving V2's Revision Bus); `Candidate artifact versions` with `CandidateArtifactVersion` inside SourceWorkspace; `Plan assurance policy`; `Taint and policy model`; `Pattern learning` (formalized as §22); `Feedback pipeline` end-to-end. **V3 §0.2 phasing:** Phase 1 (this spec) covers full Evaluator/Revisor/Dispatcher pipeline, candidate versions, taint model, pattern capture, quality programs with metric denominators, sub-agent reputation scoring, dry-run mode, hardware-aware degradation, four-domain eval suite plus domain-neutral smoke set, cross-doc obligations registered in OP-A. **V3 §0.3 Canonical Naming Table** (V3 uses canonical names throughout; implementations and prose MUST NOT introduce synonyms). **V3 §0.4 Canonical Enum Inventory** (every enum declared with owning section; implementations MAY NOT introduce new values or substitute alternates without spec amendment; consumers reference but do not redefine). **V3 §0A Implementation Discipline Preamble** (governs how V3 is implemented; coding agents working from it MUST comply with these rules). **V3 §26 Open Questions / Drift Manifest** (every TODO/placeholder/deferred behavior enters drift manifest with recorded entry). **V3 §24/§25 stress test fixtures** with fixture definitions and four-domain eval suite. **No explicit "Supersedes:" header in V3** (unlike V2 which explicitly superseded V1) — V3 positions itself as the V3 spec for the same subsystem rather than as a strict supersession of V2 by header declaration; auto pass treats this as a natural-progression supersession (V2 → V3) per the established DOC23 Addenda B chain pattern (the unified-draft chain was R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4; the Addendum chain is V1 → V2 → V3). **V2 file disposition pending human review:** V2 file (= A-55 row above) remains in active folder per auto pass's no-relocation policy; options for human review: (a) move to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` following supersession-and-archive pattern; (b) keep in active folder for traceability of architectural evolution V2 → V3. **V1 file (= A-54 row) also still in active folder pending the same disposition decision.** DOC23 Addenda B chain at R3.44: R0.1 (global archive) → R0.3 (= A-50, intra-subfolder archive R3.15) → R0.5 (briefly-extant, intra-subfolder archive) → R0.6.1 (= A-51, intra-subfolder archive R3.16) → R0.6.3 (= A-52, intra-subfolder archive R3.18) → **R0.6.4 (= A-53, ACTIVE — current unified Addenda B draft)** + Addendum chain **V1 (= A-54, ACTIVE pending archival per V2 supersession) → V2 (= A-55, ACTIVE pending archival per V3 succession) → V3 (= A-57 NEW, ACTIVE)**. Three Addendum revisions now coexist; collapse-opportunity-by-archival deepens further. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-56 for this V3 file (continues R3.33 single-step numbering from A-54 V2 → A-55 R0.1 → A-56 V3); master spec list §4 uses A-57 (preserving R3.33 divergence-by-one + R3.41 second-divergence pattern). |
**R3.49 sub-sub-folder addition (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local — same-day THIRD-firing SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump after R3.47 substantive + R3.48 operations-state-only fires):** Will created a NEW sub-sub-folder `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/` (folder mtime 2026-05-17 15:53) representing a **major architectural decomposition** of the DOC23 Addenda B work. R0.6.4 (= A-53) was the singular unified Addenda B document; R0.7 (= A-61 NEW) reorganizes Addenda B into a family topology with separation of concerns: **Core R0.7** (Task Design domain — Task Agent, natural saved-task invocation, Task Blueprint, template/preset intelligence, Task Agent education/TKP, task-design self-learning, DOC72 task-memory integration, telemetry spine, artifact/output intake, DOC24 capability/runtime routing, OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment, unified prompt improvement, task UI/telemetry surfaces, module continuation/rerun mechanics, shared-task forward-compatibility); **Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3.2** (= A-60 in root + duplicate in this sub-sub-folder); **Feedback Delivery V1** (= A-62 — in-run feedback delivery from evaluators to downstream consumers; EvaluationFeedbackBundle, defeasible findings, Run Guidance, Repair Instructions, Feedback Routing Policy, four delivery channels, Feedback Consumption Receipts); **Source Workspace V1** (= A-63 — shared source/reference/research substrate, Source Research/Gathering module, user-facing UI); **Task Forum + Run Board V1** (= A-64 — passive Task Run Board + active Task Forum module `system.task_forum` + Module Assistance Requests + Board Digests + TaskRunContextPacket + moderator modes + user-facing UI); **DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts V1** (= A-65 — sibling spec to DOC23 R3.1 hosting shared evaluation primitives consumed jointly by Addenda A and Addenda B per coordination V3 §3.2 — EvaluationResultEnvelope, EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope, Criterion, ArtifactScopeRef, TextAnchor, StructuredAnchor; retires when DOC23 R3.2 absorbs primitives at the parent level). This is the **first ever sub-sub-folder at this depth in any tracked top-level Addenda subfolder** — distinct from the intra-subfolder archive pattern (`Archived DOC23 addenda/` introduced in R3.15) and distinct from the top-level Addenda subfolder pattern. **Disposition options for human review:** (a) the rework subfolder is a staging area — files collapse upward into `DOC23 Addenda/` root when V1 → V2 / Core R0.7 → R0.8 / V3.2 → V4 cycles converge; (b) the rework subfolder becomes a permanent organizational pattern and warrants its own §A8 section in a future revision; (c) the rework subfolder is folded into the existing intra-subfolder archive once the parent DOC23 R3.1 → R3.2 compilation lands and absorbs the Common Contracts primitives. The duplicate V3.2 file in the sub-sub-folder (byte-identical to root V3.2 = A-60) suggests option (a) — the rework subfolder may be a working-bundle/export-bundle staging area assembled by the authoring environment (consistent with the `files.zip` packaging artifact also present in the subfolder). SKILL.md tightening recommendation #4 expanded to include sub-sub-folder traversal mode for DOC23 Addenda subfolder + decision rule for whether the rework subfolder warrants its own master spec list section or remains tracked inline within §A6 (currently inline per the simpler approach).

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-60 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_2.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluator and Revisor V3.2 (surgical patch over V3.1 incorporating Addenda A/B coordination V3 FINAL outputs) | 2026-05-17 (file-header date 2026-05-17 V3.2 coordination patch; mtime 2026-05-17 15:14:43 local = 22:14:43 UTC) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent via Addenda B R0.6.4 → R0.7); natural-progression successor to A-59 V3.1 + A-57 V3 + A-55 V2 + A-54 V1; companion to A-61 R0.7 Core (per R0.7 §0A.1 family topology: "Outcome Evaluator/Revisor lives in the V3.2 sub-addendum") + A-65 Common Contracts V1 (per V3.2 §0 consumes shared evaluation primitives from sibling spec) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local); needs human classification.** File size 461,248 bytes — ~5.5% larger than V3.1's 437,051 bytes. Per V3.2 file header: `# DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluator and Revisor V3.2`; **Subject:** "Specification for the Outcome Evaluator and Revisor subsystem of the DOC23 task system modular architecture. Defines the Outcome Compiler, Revision Compiler, Evaluator and Revisor modules, Revision Dispatcher, `revision_in` port contract, `claims_in` port contract, candidate artifact versions, plan assurance policy, taint and policy model, pattern learning, learning-mode configuration, and feedback pipeline."; **Status:** "V3.2 specification (surgical patch over V3.1 incorporating Addenda A/B coordination V3 FINAL outputs)"; **Version:** "3.2"; **Prepared:** "2026-05-15 (V3); revised 2026-05-16 (V3.1 audit-complete); revised 2026-05-17 (V3.2 coordination patch)" — V3.2 is the post-coordination surgical patch incorporating Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs. **NEW V3.2 architectural primitive beyond V3/V3.1:** `claims_in` port contract (V3 had only `revision_in`; V3.2 adds `claims_in` as input port for claim-extractor-pipeline integration per coordination V3 FINAL); plus updates to `revision_in` port contract; plus pattern-learning configuration; plus learning-mode configuration. **Surgical patch nature:** V3.2 is positioned as a patch over V3.1 (not a full rewrite like V3 → V3.2 would be); the changes incorporate coordination V3 FINAL outputs which are jointly authored by the Addenda A chat and Addenda B chat per the coordination protocol locked between the two tracks. **Identical duplicate file in `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:07, size 461,248 bytes — byte-identical); auto pass treats as single file at primary location (this row) and does not create separate row for the duplicate. DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain at R3.49: R0.1 (global archive) → R0.3 (= A-50, intra-subfolder archive R3.15) → R0.5 (briefly-extant, intra-subfolder archive) → R0.6.1 (= A-51, intra-subfolder archive R3.16) → R0.6.3 (= A-52, intra-subfolder archive R3.18) → R0.6.4 (= A-53, ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 supersession) + Addendum chain V1 (= A-54, ACTIVE pending archival per V2/V3/V3.2 supersession cascade) → V2 (= A-55, intra-subfolder archived R3.47) → V3 (= A-57, intra-subfolder archived R3.47) → V3.1 (= A-59, ACTIVE pending archival per V3.2 supersession) → **V3.2 (= A-60, NEW)**. Five Addendum revisions (V1/V2/V3/V3.1/V3.2) tracked, two intra-subfolder-archived, three coexisting active (V1/V3.1/V3.2). NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-59 for this V3.2 file (continues single-step numbering from A-58 R0.2 → A-59 V3.2 in this run); master spec list §4 uses A-60 (preserving R3.33 + R3.39 + R3.41 + R3.44 + R3.47 cumulative divergence-by-one pattern). |
| A-61 | `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_CORE_R0_7.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design (family-topology Core supersession of R0.6.4) | 2026-05-17 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:46 local) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); explicit supersession of A-53 R0.6.4 via family-topology reorganization; companions per file header: A-60 V3.2 (Outcome Evaluator/Revisor sub-addendum); A-65 Common Contracts V1 (sibling spec to DOC23 R3.1); A-47 DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3 (with V4.1 Coordination Patch / V5 Mini-Card from coordination V3 FINAL); A-63 Source Workspace V1; A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1; A-62 Feedback Delivery V1; DOC23 R3.1; DOC24 R3; DOC72 R5.73; DOC25 V2.0; DOC73 V1.5.1; DOC8 v1.11.4; DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4 (= A-22); DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35); DOC17 R4.2; DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R2 (= A-36); OpenClaw Release Alignment Running Spec Update List R2; EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (= A-4); PropA R6.3+; OP-A V3.7+ | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local); needs human classification.** Large file (size 370,034 bytes — ~113% of A-53 R0.6.4's 327,340 bytes; ~258% of A-50 R0.3's 143,665 bytes). Per file header: **Revision** "R0.7 Core — supersedes R0.6.4; family-topology reorganization plus Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL absorption"; **Status** "Build-ready Core specification. R0.7 is the family-core for Addenda B's Task Design domain. Outcome Evaluator/Revisor lives in the V3.2 sub-addendum. Source Workspace, Task Forum + Run Board, and Feedback Delivery live in their own sub-addenda. Shared evaluation primitives live in DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts (sibling to the parent doc)"; **Target parent** "DOC23 — ELNOR Task System: Modular Automation Architecture R3.1 (R3.2 absorbs shared primitives later)"; **Date** "2026-05-17"; **Purpose** "Define the Task Agent, natural saved-task invocation, Task Blueprint, template/preset intelligence, Task Agent education/TKP, task-design self-learning, DOC72 task-memory integration, telemetry spine, artifact/output intake, DOC24 capability/runtime routing, OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment, unified prompt improvement, prompt-evaluation tasks, task UI/telemetry surfaces, module continuation/rerun mechanics, shared-task forward-compatibility, and all cross-doc seams required to make DOC23 a reliable, inspectable, self-improving saved-task system. R0.7 also documents the family topology (Core + V3.2 + three sub-addenda + Common Contracts) and integrates the Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL converged architecture." **R0.7 substantive change classes per its own change log:** **Class 1 family-topology reorganization** — R0.6.4 was singular Addenda B document; R0.7 retains Task Design domain core but does NOT carry Outcome Evaluator/Revisor, Source Workspace, Task Forum + Run Board, or Feedback Delivery content (those live in own sub-addenda); section additions reflect family-topology context (§0A R0.7 supersession statement and topology, updated §0.4 scope summary excludes sub-addenda content, updated §1 executive summary scoped to Core). **Class 2 R0.6.5 base material absorption** — R0.6.5 proposal §§1-4 (governing principles, complexity profiles, what this adds, object taxonomy) absorbed into Core §2 + §3A; R0.6.5 §§5-7 (OutcomeSpec, Outcome Evaluator, States) superseded by V3.2 — referenced not duplicated; R0.6.5 §§8-15 distributed to Feedback Delivery V1 (= A-62); §§16-18 distributed to Source Workspace V1 (= A-63); §§19-22 distributed to Task Forum + Run Board V1 (= A-64); R0.6.5 retires when sub-addenda land. **Class 3 Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL integration** — §9 Task Design Learning extended with eight Phase 1 learning signals wrapped in `EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope` (per coordination V3 §2.7/§2.11); §13/§13A DOC24 capability binding extended with `model_class` context for cheap-LLM learning mode; §17 series Prompt evaluation updated to consume shared `EvaluationResultEnvelope`, reference DSPy targets coordinated with PropA, and integrate Pattern C ad-hoc Judge attachment (per coordination V3 §2.9/§2.10); §24 cross-doc obligations extended with V3 FINAL coordination OP-A rows (14 new rows; full text in §24B); new §0B "Shared evaluation infrastructure" cross-references Common Contracts schemas and V3.2 module surfaces. **Class 4 resolved open questions** — several R0.6.4 §26 open questions resolved by V3 FINAL coordination outputs and noted in §26. **Migration note per file:** "R0.6.4 may be retired once Source Workspace V1, Task Forum + Run Board V1, and Feedback Delivery V1 land — together with R0.7 Core and V3.2, they cover everything R0.6.4 covered, organized topically. Cross-references from other addenda to R0.6.4 sections that moved should update during their next revisions." **R0.7 explicit supersession declaration of A-53 R0.6.4:** R0.7 supersedes R0.6.4 via family-topology reorganization rather than monolithic rewrite. Predecessor A-53 R0.6.4 file remains in active folder per auto pass's no-relocation policy pending human archival decision (options: (a) move to intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` following the established R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 archival pattern; (b) keep ACTIVE pending sub-addenda landing per migration note before archival). **A-54 R0.6.5 stacked proposal also pending archival** — R0.7 absorbed R0.6.5 base material per Class 2 change; R0.6.5 file retires when sub-addenda land per file's migration note. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-60 for this R0.7 file (continues single-step numbering from A-59 V3.2 → A-60 R0.7 Core in this run); master spec list §4 uses A-61 (preserves cumulative divergence-by-one pattern; second new row this cycle). |
| A-62 | `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_FEEDBACK_DELIVERY_V1.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum — Feedback Delivery V1 (topical sub-addendum to A-61 R0.7 Core; absorbs R0.6.5 §§8-15) | 2026-05-17 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:53 local) | A-61 R0.7 Core (primary parent — topical sub-addendum); DOC23 R3.1; A-60 V3.2 Outcome Evaluator/Revisor (companion — §14 post-run learning signals integration); A-65 Common Contracts V1 (companion — sibling spec for shared evaluation primitives); A-47 DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3 (companion — Judge feedback channel integration); coordination V3 FINAL outputs | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local); needs human classification.** File size 38,711 bytes. Per file header: `# DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum — Feedback Delivery V1`; **Document type:** "Topical sub-addendum to DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7"; **Subject:** "Specification for in-run feedback delivery from evaluators (V3.2 Outcome Evaluator, Addenda A Judge, agent review gates) to downstream consumers (modules, sub-agents, Task Agent, user). Defines the `EvaluationFeedbackBundle`, defeasible findings, Run Guidance, Repair Instructions, Feedback Routing Policy, four delivery channels, and Feedback Consumption Receipts"; **Status:** "V1 — initial draft incorporating R0.6.5 proposal §§8-15, integrated with V3.2 Outcome Evaluator+Revisor §14 (post-run learning signals) and Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs"; **Version:** "1.0". **Topical scope:** in-run feedback delivery primitives that connect evaluator outputs (Judge from Addenda A; Outcome Evaluator from Addenda B V3.2) to downstream consumers (other graph modules, sub-agents, Task Agent, end user). Four delivery channels (per R0.6.5 §§8-15 absorbed material): (1) module-to-module via `revision_in` ports; (2) sub-agent-to-sub-agent via ACP forum/topic projection; (3) Task Agent surface for graph-improvement signals; (4) user surface for review/approval decisions. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-61 for this file; master spec list §4 uses A-62 (cumulative divergence-by-one pattern; third new row this cycle). |
| A-63 | `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_V1.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum — Source Workspace V1 (topical sub-addendum to A-61 R0.7 Core; absorbs R0.6.5 §§16-18 + §28) | 2026-05-17 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:50 local) | A-61 R0.7 Core (primary parent — topical sub-addendum); DOC23 R3.1; A-60 V3.2 Outcome Evaluator/Revisor (companion — §12 narrow workspace coverage integration); A-65 Common Contracts V1 (companion — sibling spec); DOC25 V2.0 (companion — source verification); DOC72 R5.73 (companion — task memory integration); coordination V3 FINAL outputs | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local); needs human classification.** File size 33,326 bytes. Per file header: `# DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum — Source Workspace V1`; **Document type:** "Topical sub-addendum to DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7"; **Subject:** "Specification for the Task Source Workspace, the Source Research / Source Gathering module, and the user-facing Source Workspace UI. Defines the shared source/reference/research substrate that task runs use when modules need to find, verify, retrieve, or update sources"; **Status:** "V1 — initial draft incorporating R0.6.5 proposal §§16-18 + §28, integrated with V3.2 §12 narrow workspace coverage and Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs"; **Version:** "1.0". **Topical scope:** the Task Source Workspace as the shared source/reference/research substrate task runs use when modules need to find, verify, retrieve, or update sources; the Source Research/Gathering module (step type) that searches, verifies, and adds sources to the workspace; user-facing Source Workspace UI for visibility into what sources a task is using and how they were verified. Integrates with V3.2 §12 (narrow workspace coverage for Outcome Evaluator targeted evaluation mode) and Common Contracts ArtifactScopeRef/TextAnchor/StructuredAnchor primitives. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-62 for this file; master spec list §4 uses A-63 (cumulative divergence-by-one pattern; fourth new row this cycle). |
| A-64 | `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_TASK_FORUM_RUN_BOARD_V1.md` | DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum — Task Forum + Run Board V1 (topical sub-addendum to A-61 R0.7 Core; absorbs R0.6.5 §§19-22, §27, §31) | 2026-05-17 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:56 local) | A-61 R0.7 Core (primary parent — topical sub-addendum); DOC23 R3.1; A-60 V3.2 Outcome Evaluator/Revisor (companion — §14.9 plan review forum integration); DOC11 ACP runtime (companion — forum/topic projection); DOC12 forum/panel architecture (companion); coordination V3 FINAL outputs | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local); needs human classification.** File size 36,139 bytes. Per file header: `# DOC23 Addenda B Sub-addendum — Task Forum + Run Board V1`; **Document type:** "Topical sub-addendum to DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7"; **Subject:** "Specification for the passive Task Run Board, the active Task Forum module (`system.task_forum`), Module Assistance Requests, Board Digests, TaskRunContextPacket, moderator modes, and the user-facing Forum/Board UI surfaces"; **Status:** "V1 — initial draft incorporating R0.6.5 proposal §§19-22, §27, §31, integrated with V3.2 §14.9 plan review forum and Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs"; **Version:** "1.0". **Topical scope:** the passive Task Run Board (every run's structured chronological audit/feed surface) + the active Task Forum module `system.task_forum` (optional graph-visible module that turns the passive board into a controlled cross-module coordination forum) + Module Assistance Requests (modules ask the forum for help from other modules/Task Agent/user) + Board Digests (rolled-up summary entries) + TaskRunContextPacket (packet circulated between forum participants) + moderator modes + user-facing Forum/Board UI surfaces. Per R0.6.5 §§19-22 + §27 + §31 source material. Integrates with V3.2 §14.9 (plan review forum semantics distinct from runtime orchestration). NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-63 for this file; master spec list §4 uses A-64 (cumulative divergence-by-one pattern; fifth new row this cycle). |
| A-65 | `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1.md` | DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts V1 — sibling specification to DOC23 R3.1 hosting shared evaluation primitives until R3.2 absorbs them (joint ownership between Addenda A chat and Addenda B chat per coordination V3 §3.2) | 2026-05-17 (file-header date `Prepared: 2026-05-17`; mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:42 local) | DOC23 R3.1 (parent — sibling spec hosting shared primitives until R3.2 absorbs them at parent level); A-47 DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3 (consumer — Judge, Experiment, Claim Extractor consume shared envelope + slice schemas + Criterion + ArtifactScopeRef); A-61 DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 (consumer — Task Agent, Outcome Evaluator/Revisor, Forum, Source Workspace, Feedback Delivery consume shared envelope + signal envelope + Criterion + ArtifactScopeRef); A-60 V3.2 + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 (consumers — reference shared primitives); PropA R6.3+ (consumer — ArtifactScopeRef + TextAnchor + StructuredAnchor); DOC72 (consumer — Pattern-related context types); DOC8/BDSM (consumer — EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope unified signal stream); EC Core (gates envelope governance fields — data_class, matter_id, pattern_promotion_eligible); DOC20 (renders envelope + signals + criteria in UI surfaces) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local); needs human classification — strong candidate for reclassification as SUPPORT / SIBLING SPEC rather than PROPOSED ADDENDUM since the file explicitly positions itself as a sibling spec to DOC23 R3.1 with explicit retirement-on-absorption lifecycle.** File size 46,578 bytes. Per file header: `# DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts V1`; **Document type:** "Sibling specification to DOC23 R3.1 hosting shared evaluation primitives until DOC23 R3.2 absorbs them"; **Status:** "V1 — initial draft incorporating Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL converged architecture"; **Version:** "1.0"; **Prepared:** "2026-05-17"; **Lifecycle:** "Active until DOC23 R3.2 compilation pass absorbs the contracts into the parent doc; then this document retires per §11 migration guide"; **Owner:** "Joint between Addenda A chat and Addenda B chat per coordination V3 §3.2; conflicts adjudicated by Will". **Per file §0.1 rationale:** "The Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination produced a converged architecture where Judge (Addenda A) and Outcome Evaluator (Addenda B) emit a shared `EvaluationResultEnvelope`, where all learning signals wrap in a common `EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope`, and where extraction operations use shared anchoring primitives (`TextAnchor`, `StructuredAnchor`, `ArtifactScopeRef`). Hosting these primitives in one of the addenda would create fragile cross-addendum references and bury shared types inside one addendum's narrative. Per coordination V3 §3.2, the resolution is a sibling document hosting these primitives. Both addenda reference this document. When DOC23 R3.2 compiles, the primitives migrate to the parent doc and this document retires (§11)." **Per file §0.2 what-lives-here vs what-lives-in-addenda:** lives here = shared schemas consumed by both Addenda A and Addenda B + cross-cutting governance fields spanning Judge and Evaluator + shared anchoring/scoping primitives consumed by extractors + universal signal envelope structure; lives in Addenda A R4.1 V3 = Judge module schema/config + OutcomeComplianceScoringConfig + step.claim_extractor module schema and 22-type registry + Experiment module schema + experiment_winner_routing config + Judge-specific scoring methods (rubric/checklist/pairwise/factual_verification/consistency/outcome_compliance). **Unique structural pattern in this scheduled task's history:** first ever explicitly-joint-ownership sibling spec registered in the master spec list (every prior addendum had a single primary parent + companions, even multi-parent A-58 R0.2). NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-64 for this file; master spec list §4 uses A-65 (cumulative divergence-by-one pattern; sixth new row this cycle). |
| A-74 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1.md` | DOC23 Family Self-Learning Coherence Map V1 | 2026-05-19 (mtime 2026-05-19 12:43:05 local; size 53,808 bytes) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary); DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V6 (A-66); DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 (A-61); DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.2 (A-60); A-62 Feedback Delivery V1; A-63 Source Workspace V1; A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1; A-65 Common Contracts V1; A-73 DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 (cross-doc consumer) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.55 (auto-detected 2026-05-19 ~13:55 local); likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP / NON-OWNER DRAFT (analogous to A-49 Context Mgmt → Card Integration Map V2 and A-32 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1 cross-cutting reference patterns).** Cross-cutting reference document mapping self-learning coherence across DOC23 family addenda (Addenda A Task Optimization R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda Feedback Delivery / Source Workspace / Task Forum + Run Board + Common Contracts V1.1). First family-coherence reference map for the DOC23 family; precedes related cross-doc consumption in DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 (A-73) and likely the OPA V3.16 family-coherence absorption rows. Counted as PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholder pending human reclassification. Full file-header inspection deferred. |
| A-66 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md` | DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization R4.1 V6 (successor in V2→V3→V4→V5→V6 chain since A-47 V2; coordination V3 FINAL outputs likely incorporated) | 2026-05-18 (mtime 2026-05-18 06:05:26 local; size 405,498 bytes) | DOC23 R3.1 (primary parent); Prop-A R6.3 (DSPy self-improvement engine — companion); A-65 Common Contracts V1 (consumer of shared evaluation primitives); A-47 R4.1 V2 (predecessor in V2→V6 chain — intermediate V3/V4/V5 never materialized at sync windows); coordination V3 FINAL outputs | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.50 (auto-detected 2026-05-18 ~03:13 local); needs human classification.** File size 405,498 bytes — ~2.6× A-47 R4.1 V2's 154,930 bytes; suggests substantial content growth across the V3/V4/V5/V6 intermediate revisions. Filename has "(1)" suffix suggesting Will copied from another location (Downloads pattern observed in DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card and DOC23 REPROMPT duplicates — same anomaly family). Per coordination V3 FINAL outputs noted in R3.49 (A-65 Common Contracts V1 lists "DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3" as consumer), the A-track has been at V3 since coordination V3 work; V6 likely incorporates coordination V3 FINAL outputs plus further audit closure passes. Per the V3.2 surgical-patch pattern observed in DOC23 Addenda B (V3 → V3.1 → V3.2 sequential audit/coordination patches), V6 likely represents the latest such surgical-patch advance over V5. **Intermediate V3/V4/V5 archival status unknown** — auto pass observes V6 ACTIVE in `DOC23 Addenda/` root + V2 still in same root + no V3/V4/V5 files in active folder or in `Archived DOC23 addenda/` intra-subfolder archive at time of detection. Likely Will managed these revisions outside the sync windows (briefly-extant pattern observed previously for R4.1 V1). Companion to A-61 R0.7 Core, A-60 V3.2, and A-65 Common Contracts V1 — the four collectively form the post-coordination V3 FINAL DOC23 working set. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-65 for this file; master spec list §4 uses A-66 (cumulative divergence-by-one pattern; first new row this R3.50 cycle). |

### A7. Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder (NEW in R3.41)

**Auto-detected 2026-05-14 ~16:18 UTC (~09:18 local) by nightly sync (same-day THIRD-firing of 5/14):** new subfolder `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/` appeared in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (folder mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:54 local = 16:18 UTC). **First ever multi-parent cross-doc proposal subfolder** in the master spec registry — structurally analogous to the existing single-parent-doc subfolders (DOC20 Addenda, DOC24 Addenda, DOC72 Addenda and Proposals, DOC73 Addenda and Proposals, DOC23 Addenda), but explicitly multi-parent — touches DOC20 + DOC7 + DOC25 + DOC72 + DOC73 + DOC24 + DOC23 + DOC11/OpenClaw + DOC1 + EC Core + continuity/CSA all at once. Tracked here for visibility; in-scope folder list in nightly sync task SKILL.md needs human update to formally include this path (same gap that affected the prior DOC73 Addenda + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda subfolder additions — that backlog now extends to include this fifth not-formally-listed subfolder; SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence now seventeen cycles un-implemented per R3.41 Last Updated narrative). Subfolder content at R3.41 detection: 1 file (the R0.1 proposal). Multi-parent classification convention: the new addendum row uses comma-separated parent spec list rather than a primary-parent / companions split, signalling that no single parent owns the proposal — disposition options pending human review include (a) keep multi-parent and fold incrementally into each parent's next revision wave under owner-specific subsections, (b) elevate one parent (likely DOC72 or DOC24) as primary with the rest as companions, or (c) some other disposition.

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec(s) | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-56 | `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md` | Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Task Scope / Working Set / Continuity Proposal R0.1 | 2026-05-10 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:21 local = 16:18 UTC) | DOC20 R4.3; DOC7 R7 Consolidated; DOC25 V2.0; DOC72 R5.73 (and DOC72 CSA R2 = A-37); DOC73 V1.5.1 (and forthcoming V1.6); DOC24 R3 (and DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4 = A-22; DOC24 KDA R2 = A-19); DOC23 R3.1 (and DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 = A-47; DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.4 = A-53 + V2 Addendum = A-55); DOC11/OpenClaw R14 + R15 Amendment Proposal (= A-1 / A-36); DOC1 Memory Resilience Rebuild R1; EC Core Specs Rebuild R1 (and EC Core Addendum A V3.3 = A-4); continuity/CSA architecture | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.41 (auto-detected 2026-05-14 ~16:18 UTC by same-day-third-firing nightly sync); needs human classification.** File size 63,741 bytes. **First-ever multi-parent cross-doc proposal** registered in the master spec list — explicitly touches ten parent specs / addenda chains simultaneously rather than naming a single primary parent. Per file header: "Status: Draft proposal for architect review and iterative refinement"; "Date: 2026-05-10"; "Scope: Integration proposal across DOC20, DOC7, DOC25, DOC72, DOC73, DOC24, DOC23, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC1, EC Core, and continuity/CSA"; "Design posture: Seam-focused. This proposal does not rewrite DOC72, DOC73, DOC23, or DOC24. It names product objects, clarifies seams, and defines cross-doc owner obligations where the current system has useful pieces that are not yet exposed as one coherent user model." **Proposal scope (§1 Core product model):** defines a domain-neutral product object model — Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant, Task, Session Working Set, Work Stream, Continuity Card — explicitly as lenses / bindings / profiles / views over the same governed substrate rather than separate brains or memory truth systems. Workspace = how user is set up right now (layout/tabs/pinned panels/default Assistant/default output/Library set/memory mode/continuity visibility/runtime preferences; optional). Work Context = broader thing user is working within (product launch / research topic / account / contract review / spec update / customer issue / personal project; optional; relevance lens + defaults signal, not memory prison). Library = source material Elnor can access/catalog/optionally-learn-from (user-facing replacement/refinement for Buckets + DOC73 user-facing corpus language; folder bindings + file bindings + chat/session artifacts + pasted text + URLs + task outputs + Work Product references; lightweight or deeply learned without becoming separate brain). Folder Binding = where files live (Library source / output destination / both / neither; binding/role assigned to filesystem/provider location, not separate peer object to Library). Work Product = what Elnor creates/edits/exports/revises/tracks (drafts / memos / reports / spreadsheets / timelines / charts / notes / generated artifacts / task outputs / exports / revised files; not automatically Library source material; can later be added to Library by policy or approval). Output Location = where Work Product file versions are saved (internal Elnor output store default; external folder by user instruction / source-folder affinity / Work Context policy / task output policy; current user instruction always wins). Assistant = actor profile / operating style / runtime contract (voice / role / instructions / tools / skills/procedures / default Libraries / default Work Context kinds / training examples / linked memories / model/runtime policy / continuity/activity rollups; not separate brain or memory database). Task = saved or long-running operation (DOC23 runs receive explicit Task Scope Envelope so task does not accidentally rely on whatever chat is currently active). Session Working Set = automatic carryover packet for one meaningful session (files used / outputs created / decisions / open loops / task runs / continuity cards / compact summary; replaces many manual carryover prompts). Work Stream = chain of related Working Sets across sessions (user-visible under proposed "Resume Work" surface; can be resumed / attached / renamed / merged / split / archived / promoted to Library / linked to Work Context / forked). Continuity Card = compact context injected only when useful (orientation only; not evidence / authority / substitute for source retrieval; always visible and removable). **Core philosophy (§2):** "Everything is optional" — no Workspace, Work Context, pinned Library, or Assistant selection required for Elnor to function; default mode remains fully valid. "One substrate, visible lenses" — Work Contexts / Libraries / Assistants / Work Streams / Workspaces are lenses, bindings, profiles, and views over the same governed substrate; do NOT create separate brains, separate graph stores, or separate memory truth systems. "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different" — Elnor can remember that a file exists, remember a document as a retrievable document object, or learn reusable knowledge from the document's contents; three different behaviors with different names. "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane" — Cataloged document still governed by DOC72's existing intake/significance/extraction/Write Gate pipeline. **Disposition options for human review:** (a) keep multi-parent as-is and fold incrementally into each named parent's next revision wave under owner-specific subsections of the proposal; (b) elevate one parent (likely DOC72 as substrate owner, or DOC24 as routing/capability owner, or a new "DOC??" Workspace Architecture parent) as primary with the rest as companions; (c) split the proposal into per-parent addenda files; (d) some other disposition. Auto pass leaves the file ACTIVE pending decision. **NB:** the new subfolder name "Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj" is somewhat informal (uses "Brain Bucket Lib" colloquial shorthand rather than the file's formal terms "Workspace / Library / Work Context"); may warrant renaming to a more conventional pattern (e.g., "Unified Workspace Architecture Addenda and Proposals") if the proposal is retained as an active multi-parent track. |
| A-58 | `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_2.md` | Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal R0.2 (explicit `Supersedes:` of A-56 R0.1) **— R3.58 note: explicitly superseded by R0.3 (A-77 below; second consecutive explicit-supersession-declaration in this §A7 multi-parent track)** | 2026-05-15 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-16 00:04 UTC) | DOC20 R4.3; DOC7 R7 Consolidated; DOC25 V2.0; DOC72 R5.73 (and DOC72 CSA R2 = A-37); DOC73 V1.5.1 (and forthcoming V1.6); DOC24 R3 (and DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4 = A-22; DOC24 KDA R2 = A-19); DOC11/OpenClaw R14 + R15 Amendment Proposal (= A-1 / A-36); DOC1 Memory Resilience Rebuild R1; EC Core Specs Rebuild R1 (and EC Core Addendum A V3.3 = A-4); CSA/continuity architecture. **NB: DOC23 explicitly demoted to integration-boundary-only status** (R0.1 included DOC23 as co-owner; R0.2 excludes it from owner targets per scope statement: "DOC23 is included only as an integration boundary, not as an owner target for task-run context design") | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.44 (auto-detected 2026-05-16 ~03:10 local); needs human classification.** File size 88,291 bytes; 3,220 lines — **~38% larger than R0.1's 63,741 bytes**. **Explicit supersession declaration**: per R0.2 file header `**Supersedes:** Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md for current discussion purposes.` — first explicit supersession in this §A7 track. **Title evolution from R0.1:** R0.1 title was "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Task Scope / Working Set / Continuity Proposal"; R0.2 title is "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal" — **drops "Output Routing", "Task Scope", "Working Set"; adds "Resume Work"** — significant scope refinement consolidating around the resume-work surface as the primary user-facing affordance over the more granular scope envelope vocabulary. **Scope refinement vs R0.1:** R0.2 scope says "Integration proposal across DOC20, DOC7, DOC25, DOC72, DOC73, DOC24, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC1, EC Core, and CSA/continuity. DOC23 is included only as an integration boundary, not as an owner target for task-run context design." — **explicitly excludes DOC23 from owner targets** (architect judgment that the Unified Workspace proposal should not co-own task-run context with DOC23's existing task system). **Design posture strengthened:** R0.2 design-posture line says "Seam-focused. This proposal does not rewrite DOC72, DOC73, DOC23, DOC24, DOC20, DOC7, or CSA. It names product objects, clarifies product behavior, **gives enough schema detail to reason about seams**, and identifies owner-doc changes without taking over owner-doc responsibilities." — adds explicit promise to "give enough schema detail to reason about seams" (R0.1 said only "names product objects, clarifies seams"); R0.2 is therefore more specification-flavored than R0.1's purely-product-model framing. **NEW R0.2 architectural primitive — Library source status model** with three additive statuses (NOT separate memory systems): **Linked**, **Indexed**, **Learned** — clarifies R0.1's vague "availability vs cataloging vs learning" distinction. **Retired R0.1 concepts** per R0.2's explicit retirement table: **Available** (retired as Library level/status because all Linked/Indexed/Learned sources are available, so the level was not distinguishing anything); **Cataloged** (retired as Library status because too vague — "Indexed" better communicates the document-intelligence delta). **NEW R0.2 Co-Work-like behavior in Output Location**: if user opens or uploads a source document from a folder and asks Elnor to revise it, Elnor should often save a new sibling version near the source — formalizes source-folder affinity as a default Output Location heuristic. **Retains R0.1 core product model** with Session Working Set + Work Stream consolidated into the Resume Work surface: Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant, Task, Continuity Card. **Retains R0.1 core philosophy** axioms verbatim per §2: "Everything is optional"; "One substrate, visible lenses"; "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different"; "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane" (still governed by DOC72 intake/significance/extraction/Write Gate pipeline). **R0.1 file disposition pending human review:** R0.1 file (= A-56 row above) remains in active folder per auto pass's no-relocation policy; options for human review: (a) move to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` following supersession-and-archive pattern; (b) keep in active folder for traceability of architectural evolution R0.1 → R0.2. **Disposition options for human review on the multi-parent proposal itself** carry forward from R0.1 (now applicable to R0.2): (a) keep multi-parent as-is and fold incrementally into each named parent's next revision wave under owner-specific subsections; (b) elevate one parent as primary with the rest as companions; (c) split into per-parent addenda files; (d) some other disposition. R0.2's explicit DOC23 demotion provides Will-side signal pointing toward option (b) where DOC23 becomes a companion / integration-boundary rather than an owner. NB: ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-57 for this R0.2 file (continues numbering from A-56 V3 → A-57 R0.2 in this run); master spec list §4 uses A-58 (preserving R3.33 + R3.41 + R3.44 cumulative divergence-by-two pattern). |
| A-77 | `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_Project_Proposal_R0_3.md` | Unified Workspace / Library / Project Mode / Output Routing / Memory Continuity Proposal R0.3 (explicit `Supersedes:` of A-58 R0.2) | 2026-05-16 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-20 10:47:42 local; size 89,032 bytes; +741 bytes / +0.8% over R0.2) | DOC20 (UI primary); DOC24 (routing/delivery); DOC7 (buckets); DOC25 (document intelligence); DOC73 V1.6 (PBE/corpus); DOC1 (memory governance); DOC11/OpenClaw; DOC8 (learning); EC Core (operational state + commands); DOC72 (heavily referenced but no schema addition; companion via in-flight DOC72 Entity Attenuator Addendum = A-78/A-79 DAMS); DOC23 R3.1 (integration boundary only — continuing R0.2 demotion) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.58 (auto-detected 2026-05-20).** Per file header: "Status: Proposal — for red-team review before integration into ELNOR spec suite"; "Supersedes: Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Work Thread / Continuity / Assistant Profile Architecture R0.2 (2026-05-15)". **Title evolution from R0.2:** R0.2 title was "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal"; R0.3 title is "Workspace / Library / Project Mode / Output Routing / Memory Continuity Proposal" — **drops "Work Context", "Work Product", "Resume Work"; adds "Project Mode", "Output Routing" (reinstated from R0.1), "Memory Continuity"**. **Core insight per file §0 driving R0.3:** "ambiguity is the actual UX failure, not friction. Ambient inference + dismissible chip ('Working on: Paramount') minimized friction but introduced ambiguity about whether content was being captured to one matter or another. Explicit project mode with unmistakable visual chrome eliminates the ambiguity in exchange for a small amount of deliberate friction (entering project mode is a deliberate act). This trade is correct for any user whose work has matter-scoping, confidentiality, or audit concerns." **Concept consolidation:** R0.2's eleven user-facing concepts (Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant Profile, Working Set, Work Thread, Resume Activation, Continuity Card) collapsed to much smaller set **centered on explicit project mode as primary primitive**. **Companion to A-78/A-79 DAMS proposals (new §A8):** R0.3 explicitly references DAMS's per-entity attenuator primitive as canonical and applies it to project's underlying DOC72 `world_entity` node; introduces DAMS V1/V2 (A-78/A-79) as in-flight companion proposals. **R0.2 file disposition pending human review:** R0.2 file (= A-58 row above) remains in active folder per auto pass's no-relocation policy; options for human review: (a) move to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` following supersession-and-archive pattern (now applicable for R0.1 + R0.2 in this track); (b) keep in active folder for traceability of architectural evolution R0.1 → R0.2 → R0.3. **Owner-doc untouched but heavily referenced:** DOC72 (no DOC72 schema addition in this proposal; uses in-flight DOC72 Entity Attenuator Addendum). **Track now spans three explicit revisions** R0.1 (A-56) → R0.2 (A-58, explicit Supersedes of R0.1) → R0.3 (A-77, explicit Supersedes of R0.2) — second consecutive explicit-supersession-declaration in this §A7 multi-parent track; chain of three explicit-supersession declarations is structurally unique among addenda tracks. |

### A8. DOC 80 DAMS subfolder (NEW in R3.58)

**Auto-detected 2026-05-20 by autonomous nightly sync:** new subfolder `DOC 80 DAMS/` appeared in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (folder mtime 2026-05-20 13:42:32 local — matches DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2 last write; subfolder did not exist at R3.57 alias write 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local). **First ever addenda subfolder pattern keyed to a placeholder DOC number not yet in the registry's core spec list** (DOC80 = DAMS Core Architecture; DOC81 = DAMS Consumer Integration Map). Subfolder is structurally analogous to existing single-parent subfolders (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / DOC23 Addenda / DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs) BUT differs in that the parent spec numbers do not exist yet — these are proposed/placeholder docs that will materialize if/when the DAMS proposal is accepted. **Backlog:** SKILL.md scope list does not yet formally include this path (eighth not-formally-listed subfolder added since SKILL.md tightening recommendation began at R3.26). Subfolder content at R3.61: **6 files** — V1 + V2 (R3.58, same-day ~2h pair) + V3 + V3(1) (R3.59 — but rows back-filled in R3.61; see below) + V4 + V4.1 (R3.61, same-day ~8min pair). Companion to A-77 R0.3 Unified Workspace proposal (R0.3 references DAMS attenuator primitive as canonical). **R3.61 reconciliation note:** the R3.59 changelog claimed it added rows A-82 (DAMS V3) + A-83 (DAMS V3(1)) here, but those rows were never actually written into this table (the §A8 count of 4 at R3.59/R3.60 counted files that had no rows) — a narrative-vs-execution divergence. R3.61 back-fills A-82 + A-83 from the R3.59 changelog source data so this table matches the on-disk corpus, and adds the two genuinely-new V4/V4.1 rows (A-84/A-85). Lineage per the V4/V4.1 file headers is stated as **V2 → meta-review → V3.1 → V4 → V4.1**; the central reframe in V4 is that DAMS is *one demoted substrate* inside a larger memory architecture (memory-as-control-problem; Premise Families as base semantic object; retrieval/render kernel reframed as a Context Compiler emitting warranted packets; recompile-on-resume + cognitive diff; thick-floor/thin-swappable-judgment invariant; domain-pack structure; Knowledge Topic grouping primitive). All earlier files (V1→V3(1)) remain in the subfolder per the auto pass's no-relocation policy pending human archival decision.

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec(s) | Status | One-line description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-78 | `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` | DAMS — Dynamic Attenuator Memory System: Proposal V1 for Red-Team Review (placeholder DOC80 core primitive + DOC81 consumer integration map) | 2026-05-20 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-20 11:32:26 local; size 131,064 bytes) | Placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; integration touches: DOC72 (entity graph — primary at integration), DOC24 (delivery), DOC1 (memory governance), DOC8 (learning), DOC73 (PBE), PropA R6.3 (sensitivity), DOC20 (UI), DOC11/OpenClaw (runtime), EC Core Addendum A V3.3 (data ops); referenced but not consolidated: DOC25, DOC15, DOC7, DOC10. Companion: A-77 R0.3 Unified Workspace Proposal (R0.3 references DAMS attenuator primitive as canonical) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.58 (auto-detected 2026-05-20).** Per file header: "Author: Will Brody (ELNOR principal architect); Date: 2026-05-20; Status: Draft proposal for red-team review before integration into ELNOR spec suite; Placeholder DOC numbers: DOC80 (core primitive) + DOC81 (consumer integration map). Final numbers TBD; may be renumbered if a broader memory-system rebuild is undertaken." **Reader's guide (per §0):** single document contains material that will eventually split into two specifications — **DOC80 — Dynamic Attenuator Memory System: Core Architecture** (the primitive, schemas, composition function, invariants, and DOC72 integration) + **DOC81 — DAMS Consumer Integration Map** (cross-doc obligations enumerating how each existing spec consumes the DAMS substrate). Section headers throughout indicate `[DOC80]`, `[DOC81]`, or `[META]` (proposal's framing-and-decision material that does not belong in either spec). Five-part structure: (1) Overview and motivation — five primary use cases; (2) What DAMS is — full architecture in two sub-sections (DOC80 then DOC81 content); (3) Feasibility and risk — architectural soundness, performance, cold-start, migration, long-term behavior; (4) Benefits and measurement — quantified gains, measurable proxies, instrumentation proposal, red-team measurement request; (5) Implementation approach — Options A/B/C with honest cost-benefit, LLM-automation viability, recommendation. Red-team prompt delivered as separate companion `DAMS_PROPOSAL_V1_RED_TEAM_PROMPT.md` (not in subfolder at R3.58 detection — likely sibling-file material yet to materialize). First addenda-subfolder pattern where placeholder DOC numbers anchor the entire subfolder identity rather than a confirmed existing parent. |
| A-79 | `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2.md` | DAMS — Dynamic Attenuator Memory System: Proposal V2 for Red-Team Review (placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; same-day V2 corrective revision over V1) | 2026-05-20 (file-header date; mtime 2026-05-20 13:42:32 local; size 81,272 bytes; -49,792 bytes / -38% under V1 = A-78) | Placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; integration touches: DOC72 (entity graph), DOC24 (delivery), DOC1 (memory governance), DOC8 (learning + phantom finding), DOC73 (PBE), DOC11 (runtime), DOC20 (UI + Control Surface §16), DOC23 family, DOC15 (CIL), EC Core. Companion review document: `DAMS_PROPOSAL_V1_RED_TEAM_PROMPT.md` (V2 — likely sibling file material). Companion proposal: A-77 R0.3 Unified Workspace Proposal | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.58 (auto-detected 2026-05-20).** Per file header §"What changed from V1": V2 corrects V1 framing facts — (1) **Build-it-all-at-once:** ELNOR is not a running system being incrementally extended; nothing is implemented; entire platform being built in one effort; networking the only deliberate Phase 2 — removes "measure the current system, then decide" path. (2) **DAMS is not folded into DOC72:** DOC72 already ~9,900 lines (2.5× 4,000-line authoring target; past ~5,000-line review ceiling); DAMS is cross-cutting (touches DOC72, DOC24, DOC1, DOC8, DOC73, DOC11, DOC20, DOC23, DOC15, EC Core) — own spec set at minimum, possibly spine of memory-system rebuild. (3) **DOC8 phantom finding:** the document named DOC8 is a 730-line *friction engine* from prior architecture generation containing no attribution / no Shapley / no utility scoring / no entity-graph awareness — none of the "learning engine" capabilities DOC24, DOC72, DOC73, DOC23, BDSM reference. **The learning engine the stack depends on does not exist as a written spec** — critical dependency finding addressed in §11 + Part 3 + Part 5. (4) **Implementation reframed:** V1 Options A/B/C were partly about sequencing against a running system; with build-it-all-at-once the real question is document architecture — Part 5 rewritten around DAMS as the spine of a coherent memory-system rebuild (leading recommendation) vs DAMS as two standalone specs (fallback). (5) **Control Surface:** V1 hand-waved attenuator UI as "Knowledge Manager panel"; V2 adds real §16 specifying unified memory Control Surface and treats its design as substantive work. (6) **Naming:** DAMS = **D**ynamic **A**ttenuator **M**emory **S**ystem (attenuator, not attenuated — primitive can boost or suppress). (7) **Ambition stated explicitly:** §0 now states goal plainly so red team can evaluate against it. **Same-day V1→V2 within ~2h window** is first such intra-folder pair pattern in any addenda subfolder in this scheduled task's history. V1 file (= A-78 row above) remains in active subfolder pending human archival decision; V2 substantively re-frames architecture (notably the DOC8 phantom finding) and likely warrants archival of V1 once red-team review is complete. **Critical cross-doc finding for §3 Core Specifications:** the V2 DOC8 phantom finding implies DOC8 R3 (per existing §3 row "DOC8 Self-Learning / Prediction / Regression / Friction v1_11_4") may need substantial respec or replacement — flagged here for human review as a possible §10 file-system anomaly entry for future R-revisions. |
| A-82 | `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` | DAMS V3 — Consolidated Memory Architecture Proposal (placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; consolidated successor to V1+V2 pair) | 2026-05-20 (mtime 2026-05-20 22:56 local / 2026-05-21 05:56 UTC; size 78,062 bytes; -3,210 bytes / -4% under V2 = A-79) | Placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; integration touches as V2 (DOC72, DOC24, DOC1, DOC8, DOC73, DOC11, DOC20, DOC23 family, DOC15, EC Core). Companion: A-77 R0.3 Unified Workspace Proposal | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **Back-filled in R3.61 (reconciliation — originally claimed as new row A-82 in R3.59 changelog but never written into this table).** Consolidated successor to the A-78/A-79 V1+V2 same-day pair; filename change `DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2` → `DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL` signals consolidation from proposal-iteration mode to architecture-baseline mode; modest -4% size reduction consistent with consolidation tightening. A-78/A-79 rows retain natural-progression-consolidated-successor annotations pending human archival. |
| A-83 | `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL (1).md` | DAMS V3 — Consolidated Memory Architecture Proposal [(1)-suffix duplicate variant of primary V3] | 2026-05-20 (mtime 2026-05-20 22:59 local / 2026-05-21 05:59 UTC; size 94,239 bytes; +16,177 bytes / +20.7% over primary V3 = A-82) | Placeholder DOC80 + DOC81 (as A-82) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **Back-filled in R3.61 (reconciliation — originally claimed as new row A-83 in R3.59 changelog but never written into this table).** `(1)`-suffix duplicate variant of primary V3 written ~3min after primary; **first-ever same-day intra-folder duplicate pair where the duplicate EXCEEDS the primary in size** (+20.7%, unlike prior downloads-copy `(1)` patterns where the duplicate matched primary). Workflow-signal mystery pending human classification — likely a distinct working copy rather than a download artifact. |
| A-84 | `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` | DAMS V4 — Consolidated Memory Architecture Proposal (placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; lineage V2 → meta-review → V3.1 → V4) | 2026-05-21 (mtime 2026-05-21 21:19 local; size 62,380 bytes; -15,682 bytes / -20.1% under primary V3 = A-82) | Placeholder DOC80 + DOC81; integration touches: DOC72, DOC24, DOC1, DOC8, DOC73, DOC11, DOC20, DOC23 family, DOC15, EC Core. Companion: A-77 R0.3 Unified Workspace Proposal | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.61 (auto-detected 2026-05-22).** Per file header: "Working title — 'DAMS V4' is a filename, not a claim." Central recommendation: DAMS (Dynamic Attenuator Memory System) is *one demoted substrate* inside a larger memory architecture; title retained only as successor in the proposal lineage (V2 → meta-review → V3.1 → V4). Supersedes `DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2.md`, `DAMS_V2_CONSOLIDATED_META_REVIEW.md`, and the V3.1 proposal as the current architectural statement. **What changed from V3.1** (per §header): (1) organizing principle now explicit — memory is a *control problem*, the system's job is to preserve/update/compile the user's live working state; (2) **Premise Families** become the base semantic object; (3) the retrieval/render kernel reframed as a **Context Compiler** emitting warranted packets; (4) **recompile-on-resume + cognitive diff** added; (5) **thick floor / thin swappable judgment layer** invariant stated; (6) **domain-pack** structure adopted; (7) new **Knowledge Topic / grouping primitive** specified; (8) … (continues). Notable -20.1% size reduction under V3 reflects the consolidation/reframe (substrate-demotion narrows scope vs the V3 architecture-baseline). Built for further red-team review before the architecture is settled. |
| A-85 | `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_1_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` | DAMS V4.1 — Consolidated Memory Architecture Proposal (same-day ~8min successor to V4; two content additions, no structural change) | 2026-05-21 (mtime 2026-05-21 21:27 local; size 64,604 bytes; +2,224 bytes / +3.6% over V4 = A-84) | Placeholder DOC80 + DOC81 (as A-84) | PROPOSED ADDENDUM | **NEW in R3.61 (auto-detected 2026-05-22).** Per file header §"V4.1 vs V4": two content additions, no structural change — §B.8 now carries the worked three-Topics walkthrough establishing the multi-parent acyclic DAG (V4 stated only the conclusion); §C.1 sharpens the "the merge is itself the audit" epistemics (discovery of overlaps is not separable from their resolution). **SECOND-EVER same-day intra-window successor pair** (V4 21:19 → V4.1 21:27, ~8min apart) — tighter than the R3.59 OPA V3.17→V3.18 ~17min pair and the R3.58 DAMS V1→V2 ~2h pair; small +3.6% growth consistent with a minor content-addition patch. Carries the same V2 → meta-review → V3.1 → V4 lineage framing as A-84. |

---

## 5. Addenda — Integrated (Already Merged Into Parent Specs)

These documents live under `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Integrated Addenda/` and have been absorbed into a parent operative spec. Tracked here for traceability only — coding agents should consult the parent spec, not these.

| # | Document | Title | Date | Parent Spec | Integration Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I-1 | `Integrated Addenda/DOC24_ROUTING_CASCADE_PROJECT_AGNOSTICISM_FIX (1).md` | DOC24 R2.5 — Routing Cascade Project-Agnosticism Fix | 2026-04-03 | DOC24 R2.5 | INTEGRATED into DOC24 R2.5 | Bug fix integrated as part of the 97-item R2.5 red team adjudication (routing cascade project-agnosticism). |
| I-2 | `Integrated Addenda/DOC24_TOOL_CAPABILITY_NODES_AMENDMENT.md` | DOC24 Amendment — Tool Capability Nodes in the DOC72 Graph (ADJ-91) | undated | DOC24 R2.5 | INTEGRATED into DOC24 R2.5 (ADJ-91) | Adds `tool_capability` as a lightweight node type in the DOC72 entity graph; integrated as ADJ-91 in DOC24 R2.5. |
| I-3 | `Integrated Addenda/DOC25_DOC INTELLIGENCE_SPEC.md` | Document Intelligence & Agent Context Management Specification V1.0 | 2026-04-11 | DOC25 V2.0 | INTEGRATED into DOC25 V2.0 | V1.0 source document — tiered LLM context management for documents in agent conversations; absorbed in full into DOC25 V2.0. |
| I-4 | `Integrated Addenda/DOC25_PLANNING_NOTES_V2.md` | DOC25 Planning Notes — Ingestion Orchestration, Content Addressability, and Universal Document Intelligence | 2026-04-23 | DOC25 V2.0 | INTEGRATED into DOC25 V2.0 (8 open questions resolved) | Planning notes that defined V2.0 scope; all 8 open questions resolved in DOC25 V2.0. |
| I-5 | `Integrated Addenda/DOC_INTELLIGENCE_EXTRACTION_PIPELINE_PROPOSAL_R1.md` | Document Intelligence & Extraction Pipeline — Updates Proposal R1 | 2026-04-19 | DOC25 V2.0 | INTEGRATED into DOC25 V2.0 (§§8–10) | R1 source document — LLM document escalation tool, OCR pipeline architecture, MarkItDown universal extraction backend; absorbed into DOC25 V2.0 §§8–10. |

---

## 6. Cross-Document References (CD Cross Docs)

These documents live under `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/CD Cross Docs/`. They are cross-cutting staging documents that organize obligations across multiple owner specs.

| # | Document | Title | Date | Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C-1 | `CD Cross Docs/CD-A_4-1-26_DOC3_DOC24_CYCLE.md` | CD-A [4.1.26 from DOC3/24 Cycle] — Cross-Document Obligations & Staged Spec Content — DOC3 R11.3 / DOC24 KDA Work Cycle | 2026-04-01 | ACTIVE STAGING | Staging area holding cross-document obligations and architectural additions from the DOC3 R11.3 / DOC24 KDA cycle that don't go directly into DOC3 or DOC24 revisions. |
| C-2 | `CD Cross Docs/CD_MASTER_INTEGRATION_INDEX_R1.md` | CD Master Integration Index R1 | 2026-04-01 | SUPERSEDED — see DOC OP-A V2 | Source-document registry organized by target document. **Superseded by DOC OP-A V2 (Operations).** Retained for reference; new obligations file in DOC OP-A V2. |

---

## 7. Supporting Documents (Operations, Indices)

These live outside the primary registry tables but are operationally critical.

| # | Document | Title | Date | Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S-1 | `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V2.md` | DOC OP-A — Cross-Doc Obligation Tracker V2 (ARCHIVED) | V1: 2026-04-26; V2: 2026-04-26 | ARCHIVED OPERATIONS FILE | **R3.2 path correction (auto-detected 2026-04-29):** V2 file path corrected to point at `Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` subfolder. Was active operations file through 2026-04-26; superseded by V3 series 2026-04-27. Operations spec (A-series). Single by-target obligation tracker for the suite. **Replaced** `CD_MASTER_INTEGRATION_INDEX_R1.md` (April 1, 2026) and `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`. V2 changes from V1: removed unverified source documents from §3 "not yet folded in" list — moved to §9 Open Meta-Architecture Questions. Row preserved for traceability. |
| S-2 | `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_6.md` | DOC OP-A — Cross-Doc Obligation Tracker V3.6 (ARCHIVED) | V3.6: 2026-04-26 23:25 | ARCHIVED OPERATIONS FILE | **R3.2 path correction (auto-detected 2026-04-29):** V3.6 file (along with V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5) moved to `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`. Was the V3.x latest through 2026-04-27; superseded by V3.7 (new row S-2b below). Per V5 carryover prompt and `SPEC_STATE.md`, V3 series was operative through V3.6. Row preserved for traceability. |
| S-2b | `Operations Docs/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_7.md` | DOC OP-A — Cross-Doc Obligation Tracker V3.7 | V3.7: 2026-04-29 05:15 | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **NEW in R3.2 (auto-detected 2026-04-29).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Active `Operations Docs/` now contains only V3.7. Size 244,079 bytes (~71 KB larger than V3.6's 172,961 bytes). Companion patch document `OP_A_V3_6_TO_V3_7_PATCH_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 04:58, 83,154 bytes) sits in `Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` alongside the archived V3.x files. V3.7 likely incorporates DOC73 V1.5.1 transition and/or further consolidation; full content delta from V3.6 not analyzed by auto pass. Likely supersedes rows S-1 and S-2 once classified. |
| S-3 | `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` | SPEC_STATE — auto-generated state-tracking artifact | mtime 2026-05-15 03:09 / size 70,245 bytes (was 2026-05-07 03:09 in R3.24–R3.41; was 2026-05-06 03:09 in R3.22/R3.23; was 2026-05-05 03:10 in R3.20/R3.21; was 2026-05-03 03:14 in R3.0–R3.13/R3.14) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **Auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync; needs human re-classification.** State-tracking artifact updated by the nightly spec-sync job. Referenced in R2.8 and R2.9 changelogs as "state file updated" but never formally registered until R3.0. **R3.14 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~04:05):** mtime advanced from 2026-04-28 03:09 to 2026-05-03 03:14, size grew 19,169 → 25,817 bytes (~35%) — large catch-up write by R3.13 sync that added A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 row + S-9/S-10 row updates that had been deferred across multiple stale R3.x cycles. Row mtime in §7 was stale across R3.0 through R3.13 — refreshed by this R3.14 sync. |
| S-4 | `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` | ADDENDA_STATE — auto-generated addenda-state-tracking artifact | mtime 2026-05-15 03:10 / size 58,311 bytes (was 2026-05-07 03:09 in R3.24–R3.41; was 2026-05-06 03:09 in R3.22/R3.23; was 2026-05-05 03:11 in R3.20/R3.21; was 2026-05-03 03:16 in R3.0–R3.13/R3.14) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **Auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync; needs human re-classification.** Addenda-state-tracking artifact updated by the nightly spec-sync job. Referenced in R2.9 changelog as "state file updated" but never formally registered until R3.0. **R3.14 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~04:05):** mtime advanced from 2026-04-28 03:10 to 2026-05-03 03:16, size grew 14,478 → 35,042 bytes (~142%) — much larger growth because file had been stale across multiple R3.x cycles before R3.13 sync's catch-up rewrite added all post-R3.6 addenda rows A-38 through A-50. Row mtime in §7 was stale across R3.0 through R3.13 — refreshed by this R3.14 sync. |
| S-5 | `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` | DRIFT_LOG — auto-generated drift-tracking log | mtime 2026-05-15 03:13 / size 178,697 bytes (was 2026-05-07 03:10 in R3.24–R3.41; was 2026-05-06 03:08 in R3.22/R3.23; was 2026-05-05 03:18 in R3.20/R3.21; was 2026-05-04 03:17 in R3.18; was 2026-05-03 03:23 in R3.14–R3.17) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **NEW in R3.0 (auto-detected 2026-04-28).** Drift-tracking log new in active `Operations Docs/` folder; created after R2.9 was generated (R2.9 timestamp 03:13; this file 03:17). Size 19,385 bytes (R3.0). **R3.11 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~10:00):** size grew 40,253 → 56,692 bytes (~41%) — appended by R3.10's own sync run as the post-write narrative entry. **R3.14 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~04:05):** mtime advanced 2026-05-02 03:21 → 2026-05-03 03:23, size grew 56,692 → 62,827 bytes (~11%) — R3.13 sync narrative entry appended at top documenting A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 detection. **R3.20 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-05 ~04:05):** mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:17 → 2026-05-05 03:18, size grew 62,827 → 78,895 bytes (~26%) — picks up R3.19's narrative entry append at top documenting the R3.17/R3.18 backfill pass. Likely paired with `SPEC_STATE.md` and `ADDENDA_STATE.md` as nightly sync artifacts. |
| S-6 | `Operations Docs/OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-26_V1.md` | OP-A Consolidation Session Report — 2026-04-26 V1 | 2026-04-26 17:32 | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **Auto-detected (carry-forward from R2.8 anomaly); needs human re-classification.** Session report accompanying the OP-A V3.x consolidation work. Size 8,764 bytes. |
| S-7 | `Operations Docs/OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-27_V1.md` | OP-A Consolidation Session Report — 2026-04-27 V1 | 2026-04-27 (V1: 22:33) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **Auto-detected (carry-forward from R2.8 anomaly); needs human re-classification.** Session report accompanying the OP-A V3.x consolidation work (V3.4 cohort, mtime aligns with V3.4 at 22:33). Size 9,946 bytes. |
| S-8 | `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` | Recent Work Summary | mtime 2026-05-15 04:04 / 11:04 UTC / size 65,326 bytes (was 2026-05-10 04:13 in R3.35–R3.41; was 2026-05-09 09:36 in R3.31/R3.32/R3.33/R3.34 coordinated touch; was 2026-05-08 04:02 in R3.28–R3.30; was 2026-05-07 04:03 in R3.24/R3.25/R3.27; was 2026-05-06 04:04 in R3.22/R3.23; was 2026-05-05 04:02 in R3.20/R3.21; was 2026-05-04 04:03 in R3.18/R3.19; was 2026-05-03 04:04 in R3.14–R3.17) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **R3.28 mtime + size refresh — SECOND size-decrease anomaly in S-8 series (auto-detected 2026-05-08, backfilled into §7 row by R3.28 since R3.27 narrative-acknowledged but did not perform §7 row update):** mtime advanced 2026-05-07 04:03 → 2026-05-08 04:02, size shrank 43,864 → 41,222 bytes (-6.0%). Second size-decrease across the auto-refresh series (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 → R3.22 40,104 → R3.24 43,864 → R3.28 41,222). Today's value below R3.24 peak by ~6% and essentially equal to R3.18 prior peak. Per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md head: "Generated: 2026-05-08 (nightly auto-refresh)", Window 2026-05-01 → 2026-05-08 (7 days) — the rolling 7-day window may explain size oscillation as older entries roll out and newer roll in. R3.24 noted FULLY RESOLVED of the R3.20 anomaly; R3.28 reopens in milder form. SKILL.md inspection deferred to human sweep. **R3.5 mtime refresh (auto-detected 2026-04-30):** size grew from 15,496 bytes to 18,228 bytes (~18%). Per new companion log `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10), this file was promoted from manual-only to nightly-auto-refresh in this pass. NEW in R3.4. Likely a Will-authored summary of recent work (initial run 2026-04-29 evening session in Q and EC Build 1 chat). Not a tracker file; treat as informational support doc until human classifies. **R3.11 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~10:00):** size grew 25,227 → 32,292 bytes (~28%) — fourth auto-refresh tick. **R3.14 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~04:05):** mtime advanced 2026-05-02 11:02 → 2026-05-03 04:04, size grew 32,292 → 37,316 bytes (~16%) — fifth auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task. **R3.18 mtime + size refresh:** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:04 → 2026-05-04 04:03, size grew 37,316 → 41,236 bytes (~11%) — sixth auto-refresh tick. **R3.20 mtime + size refresh — SIZE DECREASE (anomaly: first observed in this S-8 series):** mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:03 → 2026-05-05 04:02, size shrank 41,236 → 36,470 bytes (-11.6%). First time S-8 size has decreased across the auto-refresh series (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470). Possible content compaction by tonight's auto-refresh task (or Will manually edited); flagged as anomaly for human review — RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task SKILL.md inspection deferred to human sweep. |
| S-9 | `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` | OpenClaw Release Tracker Log | mtime 2026-05-15 03:49 / size 70,092 bytes (was 2026-05-08 03:44 in R3.28–R3.41; was 2026-05-07 03:47 in R3.24/R3.25/R3.27; was 2026-05-06 03:46 in R3.22/R3.23; was 2026-05-05 03:46 in R3.20/R3.21; was 2026-05-04 03:44 in R3.17–R3.19; was 2026-05-03 03:44 in R3.14–R3.16) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **R3.28 mtime + size + content tick — BEHIND-by-8 → BEHIND-by-9 (Codex route saga closes as three-act narrative; auto-detected 2026-05-08, backfilled into §7 row by R3.28 since R3.27 narrative-acknowledged mtime advance but did not capture content delta):** mtime advanced 2026-05-07 03:47 → 2026-05-08 03:44, size grew 26,858 → 34,357 bytes (~28%) recording new 2026-05-08 10:47 UTC entry detecting **2026.5.7 (released 2026-05-07 20:57 UTC)**. **2026.5.7 closes the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 → 2026.5.7 Codex OAuth route saga as a three-act narrative:** doctor --fix now both PRESERVES working `openai-codex/*` PI routes AND RECOVERS 2026.5.5-rewritten `openai/*` GPT-5 routes back to `openai-codex/*` when only Codex OAuth auth is available (fixes #78407). **REVERSES the R3.24 caveat:** the conditional Codex-route preservation rule is BACK in stable form, but only as forward-only PRESERVE/RECOVER (not the original aggressive REWRITE rule). DOC11 R15 R3 may now treat the rule as stable precedent for capability-bound default-runtime resolution, BUT should fold the saga as a single closed three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). Other 2026.5.7 quiet contract changes worth tracking: Active Memory admin-scope requirement for global memory toggles (#78863); Channels CLI restructured (`channels list` channel-only; model auth/usage moved to `models auth list`/`status`/`models list` #78456); Cron CLI status field added to JSON output (#78701); Native commands honor owner enforcement (#78864); Auto-reply gates inline skill tool dispatch through before-tool-call authorization hooks (#78517); Codex approvals stops installing pre-guardian native PermissionRequest hook + remembers allow-always within session window; Discord voice permission auditing in channels capabilities/status --probe + extended post-speech silence grace 2.5s. **Recommendation strengthened:** an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold **all nine** un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 + **2026.5.7 NEW**) in one consolidated pass, with Codex-route saga as closed three-act narrative — REPLACES R3.24 "must-explicitly-not-canonize" note. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging cadence ~12 consecutive days. Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed; status preserved (no R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.27 and R3.28). **NEW in R3.5 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 second pass).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Append-only log of nightly OpenClaw release-alignment checks. First entry 2026-04-30 10:42 (UTC) noting alignment-doc coverage through 2026.4.26 per DOC11 R15 R2 amendment proposal (row A-36), latest stable release 2026.4.27 (2026-04-27), gap status BEHIND by one release. Companion to S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md and to addenda A-1/A-36. **R3.11 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~10:00):** size grew 1,013 → 4,039 bytes across 3 cumulative entries. **R3.14 mtime + size + content tick (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~04:05): BEHIND-by-2 → BEHIND-by-3.** mtime advanced 2026-05-02 03:47 → 2026-05-03 03:44, size grew 4,039 → 7,497 bytes (~85%). Per 2026-05-03 entry: latest stable OpenClaw was 2026.5.2 (released 2026-05-02 — first 2026.5.x stable). Gap was BEHIND by 3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2). 2026.5.2 lands plugin externalization architecture (ACPX behind `@openclaw/acpx`, diagnostics OpenTelemetry behind `@openclaw/diagnostics-otel`, broad npm/ClawHub publishing prep), descriptor-first platform tool planner with cached plugin tool descriptors, ClawPack metadata flowing through install/onboarding/doctor-repair/channel-setup, `openclaw gateway restart --force / --wait <duration>`, `threadBindings.spawnSessions` consolidation, provider-native web search reflecting configured provider, Grok 4.3 default xAI chat, broad messaging-channel fixes. **R3.20 mtime + size + content tick (auto-detected 2026-05-05 ~04:05): BEHIND-by-3 → BEHIND-by-6 (gap widened by 3 releases in ~24h).** mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:44 → 2026-05-05 03:46, size grew 9,805 → 14,987 bytes (~53%). Per new 2026-05-05 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.4 (released 2026-05-05, today)**. Gap status now BEHIND by 6 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 were not published as stable per GitHub tags API). **Three NEW releases since R3.19:** (1) **2026.5.3 (2026-05-04)** lands a brand-new bundled file-transfer plugin (`file_fetch` / `dir_list` / `dir_fetch` / `file_write` agent tools, default-deny per-node path policy, symlink traversal refused by default, 16 MB byte ceiling per round-trip — first-class native data-egress surface), gateway/config invalid-state guards (no auto-restore at startup or hot reload; `openclaw doctor --fix` repairs), gateway/performance lazy-loading of plugin/runtime discovery / cron / schema / shutdown / sessions / model metadata until needed, channels/replies improvements (Discord status reactions + degraded transport reporting; WhatsApp Channel/Newsletter targets; Telegram, Feishu, Matrix, MS Teams, Slack delivery/recovery tightened), install/update recovery for broken macOS LaunchAgent upgrades, rejection of source-only plugin packages before runtime load, repair of stale Gateway/plugin state during updates and doctor runs, onboarding install-hints with the external Codex plugin selectable in Manual setup. (2) **2026.5.3-1 (2026-05-04, beta-tag)** — core npm hotfix on the beta dist-tag stopping the install scanner from blocking official bundled plugin packages when `process.env` access and normal API sends only appear in distant parts of the same compiled bundle. (3) **2026.5.4 (2026-05-05, today)** lands the Twilio realtime voice bridge for Google Meet / Voice Call (paced audio streaming, backpressure-aware buffering, barge-in queue clearing, no TwiML fallback during realtime speech); Codex audio transcription advertised in runtime/manifest metadata and routed to OpenAI transcription default rather than chat model IDs; plugins/migration emits catalog-backed install hints for missing referenced external plugins; gateway/Windows pins default loopback listener to 127.0.0.1 to avoid libuv dual-stack ::1 wedge; agents/performance threads resolved-workspace through BTW / compaction / embedded-run model generation; runtime + provider dependency refresh including Pi 0.73.0, ACPX adapters, OpenAI, Anthropic, Slack. **The bundled file-transfer plugin in 2026.5.3 is the single most significant new architectural surface in this batch** — a first-class native data-egress capability that DOC3 plugin catalog, DOC11 plugin lifecycle, DOC15/DOC25 ingestion safety, and EC durable-state policy will all need to classify and govern; the gateway/config invalid-state guards in 2026.5.3 also touch DOC11 runtime/config truth and EC durable-state recovery model. The Twilio realtime voice bridge in 2026.5.4 is the second-most-significant new item (DOC11 channels truth, DOC10 voice/audio routing, DOC22 voice surface, DOC24 KDA persisted-audio readback). **Recommendation strengthened from R3.19's "actively warranted" to "single-release roll-forwards no longer keeping pace with the release cadence"** — an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should now fold 2026.4.27 (promote watch → include-now), 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, and 2026.5.4 in **one consolidated pass**, with a companion next-R of the running list. No R3 amendment file authored yet. **R3.22 mtime + size + content tick (auto-detected 2026-05-06 ~04:05): BEHIND-by-6 → BEHIND-by-7.** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 03:46 → 2026-05-06 03:46, size grew 14,987 → 22,451 bytes (~50%) recording new 2026-05-06 entry detailing **2026.5.5 (released 2026-05-06, today, published 09:00 UTC)** as a fixes-only release with no new operative architectural surfaces. Notable items: Doctor/sessions recovery-key migration for heartbeat-poisoned default main session entries; Doctor/Codex legacy openai-codex/* → openai/* route repair with conditional agentRuntime.id selection; Doctor/Gateway supervisor-restart-handoff visibility; Plugins/update sync hardening for npm + ClawHub plugins; Hooks/session-memory collision suffixes + opt-in llmSlug; **Agents/config legacy "main" agent dir helper removal** (resolution now via agents.list / agent-scope helpers; plugin SDK keeps deprecated compatibility export — quiet contract change DOC11 R15 should explicitly track); CLI/sessions cleanup of unreferenced transcript/compaction-checkpoint/trajectory artifacts (touches DOC11 sessions/checkpoint truth + EC durable-state retention); Sessions-table runtime filter; Control UI checkpoint history disclosure; Gateway/OpenAI-compatible chat-stream chunk flushing; Gateway/shutdown structured ShutdownResult warnings; Gateway/status event-loop-degraded sustained-sampling backoff; xAI/Grok native-Responses reasoning-effort suppression (xai/grok-4.3 thinking-off); Fireworks/Kimi K2.5/K2.6 thinking-off pinning; Channels improvements (Feishu, LINE, Telegram/Codex, Discord, Matrix, Slack, WhatsApp); iOS pairing setup-code/manual ws://; Docker/Gateway capability drops + no-new-privileges; /status uptime; Plugins/diagnostics source-only TS warnings; Auth profiles cooldown skip on format rejection; Exec approvals copy fallback; Update dev-channel preflight opt-in; Video generation aspect-ratio normalization. Per the new entry's notes: none of the 2026.5.5 fixes introduce new schema-level obligations on the scale of 2026.5.3's file-transfer plugin or 2026.5.4's Twilio realtime voice bridge, but Agents/config "main" agent dir helper removal + Doctor/Codex agentRuntime.id selection rule + CLI/sessions transcript cleanup are quiet contract changes worth tracking. **Recommendation unchanged from yesterday: an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 in one consolidated pass — single-release roll-forwards have not kept pace for nine consecutive days.** Row S-9 mtime + Notes + status updated; status preserved (no new R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.21 and R3.22). **R3.24 mtime + size + content tick (auto-detected 2026-05-07 ~04:10): BEHIND-by-7 → BEHIND-by-8.** mtime advanced 2026-05-06 03:46 → 2026-05-07 03:47, size grew 22,451 → 26,858 bytes (~20%) recording new 2026-05-07 entry detailing **2026.5.6 (released 2026-05-06, 17:51 UTC — same-day patch on 2026.5.5 that missed the 2026-05-06 nightly check window)**. **2026.5.6 is fixes-only AND REVERTS the 2026.5.5 Doctor/Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route repair (fixes #78407 from 2026.5.5)** — the conditional `agentRuntime.id: "codex"` selection rule that R3.22 had flagged as a useful precedent for DOC11 R15 R3 capability-bound default-runtime resolution **is now gone, and DOC11 R15 R3 must NOT canonize it**. Recovery command for users hit by 2026.5.5: `openclaw models set openai-codex/gpt-5.5 && openclaw config validate`. Other 2026.5.6 changes are pure plumbing/security hardening: Plugins/runtime fetch drops third-party symbol metadata from header dictionaries before native fetch (fixes #77846); Debug proxy normalizes captured fetch headers; Web fetch bounds guarded dispatcher cleanup after request timeouts (fixes #78439). **None introduce schema-level obligations.** Gap status now BEHIND by 8 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6). **Recommendation strengthened: DOC11 R15 R3 must explicitly note the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair so the abandoned conditional `agentRuntime.id` rule is not folded in.** Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for ~11 consecutive days, with same-day 2026.5.5/2026.5.6 patch pair underscoring the cost of single-release amendment cycles. Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed; status preserved (no new R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.23 and R3.24). |
| S-10 | `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` | Recent Work Summary Refresh Log | mtime 2026-05-10 04:19 / 11:19 UTC (was 2026-05-09 09:53 in R3.32/R3.33/R3.34 coordinated touch; was 2026-05-07 04:08 in R3.25–R3.31; was 2026-05-06 04:09 in R3.23/R3.24; was 2026-05-05 04:10 in R3.21/R3.22; was 2026-05-04 04:21 in R3.18–R3.20; was 2026-05-03 04:10 in R3.15–R3.17) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **R3.25 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-07 ~later):** mtime advanced 2026-05-06 04:09 → 2026-05-07 04:08, size grew 29,650 → 35,320 bytes (~+19%) — new 2026-05-07 11:00 entry at top recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh (which itself summarizes R3.24's S-9 OpenClaw 2026.5.6 awareness + the R3.23 S-11 RESOLVED state — note: the log entry was written before today's BACKUP_LOG SUCCESS entry at 2026-05-07 11:16 UTC, so its narrative on S-11 reflects yesterday's state and is now slightly stale by ~5 hours, mirroring the same stale-on-write pattern as R3.21's and R3.23's S-10 entries). Row S-10 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically. **R3.23 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-06 ~later):** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:10 → 2026-05-06 04:09, size grew 24,943 → 29,650 bytes (~19%) — new 2026-05-06 10:55 entry at top recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh (which itself summarizes OpenClaw 2026.5.5 awareness from R3.22's S-9 update + the R3.21 S-11 REGRESSED status — note: the log entry was written before tonight's BACKUP_LOG SUCCESS entry at 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC, so its narrative on S-11 is now slightly stale, mirroring the same stale-on-write pattern as R3.21's S-10 entry). Row S-10 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically. **R3.21 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-05 ~later):** mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:21 → 2026-05-05 04:10, size grew 19,950 → 24,943 bytes (~25%) — new 2026-05-05 10:55 entry recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh (which itself summarizes OpenClaw 2026.5.3/2026.5.3-1/2026.5.4 release awareness from R3.20's S-9 update + the (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awareness + S-11 RESOLVED state from R3.18 — note: the log entry was written before R3.21's REGRESSION detection, so its narrative on S-11 is now slightly stale). Row S-10 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically. **R3.18 mtime + size refresh:** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:10 → 2026-05-04 04:21, size grew 14,177 → 19,950 bytes (~41%) — additional auto-refresh log entries from R3.18's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task. **NEW in R3.5 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 second pass).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Append-only log of nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refreshes. Companion to S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md. **R3.15 mtime + size refresh (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~16:00):** mtime advanced 2026-05-02 11:09 → 2026-05-03 04:10, size grew 8,501 → 14,177 bytes (~67% growth — additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). |
| S-11 | `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md` | ELNOR Specs Backup Log | mtime 2026-05-15 04:17 / 11:17 UTC / size 26,301 bytes (was 2026-05-14 04:16 in R3.42; was 2026-05-11 07:45 in R3.36–R3.41; was 2026-05-10 04:17 in R3.35; was 2026-05-09 16:29 in R3.30–R3.34; was 2026-05-08 04:21 in R3.28/R3.29; was 2026-05-07 04:17 in R3.25/R3.27; was 2026-05-06 04:17 in R3.23/R3.24; was 2026-05-05 04:16 in R3.21/R3.22; was 2026-05-04 04:17 in R3.18–R3.20; was 2026-05-03 04:17 in R3.15–R3.17) | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | **R3.43 NINTH-STRIKE BIND-MOUNT-PROOF ESCALATION (auto-detected 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC firing):** mtime advanced 2026-05-14 04:16 → 2026-05-15 04:17 PDT (11:17 UTC), size grew 22,602 → 26,301 bytes (+16.4%) recording today's 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC scheduled backup run with status FAILED ("OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect"). **This is the FIRST run in this scheduled task's history to execute an explicit `mountpoint` verification on the destination.** Result: `mountpoint /sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned "is not a mountpoint", while `mountpoint /sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/ECQ Development` returned "is a mountpoint" — **definitive proof** that the OneDrive destination is NOT a bind mount in this session; instead, Step 1's `mkdir -p` silently created a sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` directory tree and wrote a 5.80 MB tarball (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-15_111640.tgz`) to it. Per task constraint #4 (no fallback to local-only paths), the bogus tarball was deleted and the sandbox-local scaffolding was `rmdir`-ed so workspace state matches session start. No source files modified. Session ID `jolly-cool-albattani`. **Pattern escalation:** R3.42 eighth-strike five-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT → R3.43 NINTH-STRIKE six-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF. **Retroactive doubt cast on all prior "successful" runs 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09:** those runs reported SUCCESS but did NOT perform the bind-mount check; today's confirmed-ephemeral-mount finding strongly suggests they may have written to ephemeral sandbox directories that never synced to OneDrive — if the host folder is empty or missing recent dates, the cloud-recoverability goal has never been met by this task. Last successful tarball remains `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` from 2026-05-09; cloud-resident-recoverability state is now six calendar days stale (or possibly longer if 5/04–5/09 runs also wrote ephemerally). **Will-action items (carried forward and updated from 5/14 R3.42):** (1) reconnect OneDrive folder via chat-box "+" button; (2) Finder-verify host-side `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` contents to ascertain whether any prior backup was real; (3) **harden the task script with explicit `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || exit` pre-flight BEFORE the `mkdir -p` in Step 1** — concrete code-level remediation now available given today's bind-mount finding. **NOTE: long-form §7 historical narrative for this row preserved in R3.42 versioned snapshot;** R3.43 has prepended the ninth-strike + bind-mount-proof escalation summary above to keep the active alias row focused on current state. **R3.36 SEVENTH-STRIKE TWO-CONSECUTIVE-FAILED-RUNS ESCALATION (auto-detected 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC firing):** mtime advanced 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC → 2026-05-11 07:45 PDT (14:45 UTC), size grew 16,078 → 17,777 bytes (~+11%) recording today's 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC scheduled backup run with status FAILED ("OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect"). **Pattern escalation:** prior sixth-strike total-mount-loss URGENT-FAILURE-MODE event (R3.35 classification — single failed run with mount unreachable) has now extended to **seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING** — workspace sandbox mount at `/sessions/jolly-cool-heisenberg/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, and `.remote-plugins` (no `OpenClaw-Shared`); a stray empty `OpenClaw-Shared/` directory created by an early `mkdir -p` call in Step 1 was cleaned up — no orphan dirs remain in the sandbox. Per BACKUP_LOG action note: last successful tarball reported by this scheduled task was **2026-05-09** (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz`); two consecutive days have now produced no new cloud backup. Suggested Will action two-pronged: (1) re-add the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via the chat-box "+" button so the scheduled task can resume, and (2) separately verify on the host whether prior tarballs actually accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` (the open hypothesis from the 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 runs about per-session ephemeral mount semantics remains untested). No tarball created; rotation not performed; source folder unchanged. **R3.35 PAUSE recommendation now further reinforced** — the scheduled task is producing no output for the second consecutive day; the original R3.30 recommendation to pause-and-investigate is now URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING. **NOTE: long-form §7 historical narrative for this row preserved in R3.35 versioned snapshot;** R3.36 has replaced the row's narrative tail with the seventh-strike escalation summary above to keep the active alias row focused on current state. **R3.35 SIXTH-STRIKE TOTAL-MOUNT-LOSS ESCALATION (auto-detected 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC firing):** mtime advanced 2026-05-09 16:29 → 2026-05-10 04:17 PDT (11:17 UTC), size grew 15,163 → 16,078 bytes (~+6%) recording today's 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC scheduled backup run with status FAILED ("OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect"). **Pattern escalation:** prior fifth-strike entrenched-pattern empty-start anomaly (R3.30 classification) has now ESCALATED to sixth-strike total-mount-loss — the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` mount is no longer present at all this session (verified via `mountpoint`: only `ECQ Development` is a real bind mount). Per BACKUP_LOG action note: "Will needs to re-add the OneDrive folder OpenClaw-Shared via the chat-box '+' button so it gets mounted into future Cowork sessions." No tarball created; rotation not performed; source folder unchanged. **R3.35 PAUSE recommendation strengthened to URGENT-FAILURE-MODE:** the scheduled task is no longer producing any output and the original recommendation to pause-and-investigate is now reinforced — the task can no longer complete its primary objective. **NOTE: long-form §7 historical narrative for this row preserved in R3.34 versioned snapshot;** R3.35 has replaced the row's narrative tail with the sixth-strike escalation summary above to keep the active alias row focused on current state. **R3.28 STATUS HOLDS RESOLVED via fourth autonomous-success-path run + FOURTH consecutive empty-start strike (auto-detected 2026-05-08, backfilled into §7 row by R3.28 since R3.27 INCORRECTLY narrated S-11 as unchanged when today's 04:21 firing had already occurred ~2 minutes before R3.27 generation):** mtime advanced 2026-05-07 04:17 → 2026-05-08 04:21, size grew 11,038 → 12,994 bytes (~18%) recording **fourth SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-08 11:21 UTC (04:21 local — fired ~4 minutes later than canonical 04:17 cadence). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-08_112116.tgz` (5.38 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source — slightly larger than yesterday's 5.36 MB / 19 MB tarball, consistent with corpus growing slightly each day), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op). Mount path this run: `/sessions/upbeat-gifted-thompson/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Four of six autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success, 5/8 success — 4-of-6 = 67% success rate, continuing gradual improvement: R3.18 1-of-1, R3.21 1-of-3, R3.23 2-of-4, R3.25 3-of-5, R3.28 4-of-6). **CRITICAL PATTERN — destination empty at start of run for the FOURTH CONSECUTIVE TIME** (2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 vs 2026-05-04 autonomous run; 2026-05-07 vs 2026-05-06 autonomous run; 2026-05-08 vs 2026-05-07 autonomous run). The 48-hour backup-creation gate is being effectively defeated for the fourth run in a row. **New observation in tonight's S-11 entry not present in R3.25's third-strike entry: rotation logic in this script will never run because destination always looks empty — meaning script is NOT actually capping at 3 backups across runs.** If host-side files DO exist they may be accumulating without rotation; if they DON'T exist every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading. **Action required from Will (URGENT, fourth-consecutive-strike):** open Finder at `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` and visually confirm whether prior tarballs (5/2 manual, 5/4, 5/6, 5/7, 5/8 autonomous) are actually present. Tarball verified >1 MB sanity check. Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated; status holds RESOLVED via four consecutive autonomous-success runs (longest streak of the autonomous-path series). **NEW in R3.6 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 — third pass of the day).** Auto-detected; needs human classification. Append-only log of the automated daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task. **R3.25 STATUS HOLDS RESOLVED via third autonomous-success-path run (auto-detected 2026-05-07 ~later):** mtime advanced 2026-05-06 04:17 → 2026-05-07 04:17, size grew 9,236 → 11,038 bytes (~20%) recording **third SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-07 11:16 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-07_111637.tgz` (5.36 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op). Mount path this run: `/sessions/busy-hopeful-brahmagupta/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Three of five autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success — 60% success rate, continuing the gradual improvement: R3.18 1-of-1, R3.21 1-of-3, R3.23 2-of-4, R3.25 3-of-5). **CRITICAL PATTERN — destination empty at start of run for the THIRD CONSECUTIVE TIME** (2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 vs 2026-05-04 autonomous run; 2026-05-07 vs 2026-05-06 autonomous run). The 48-hour backup-creation gate is being effectively defeated: yesterday's run created `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` ~24 hours ago (well under the 48-hour gate), but today's session sees an empty destination and treats it as "no prior backup" — so a new tarball is created, yielding back-to-back daily runs. Three possibilities per file note: (a) the per-session sandbox mount is a fresh ephemeral copy that doesn't reflect the host OneDrive folder; (b) OneDrive sync is removing them; (c) host folder accumulates them but they're not exposed back into subsequent sandbox sessions. **Action required from Will (carry-forward STRENGTHENED to URGENT in R3.25):** open Finder at `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` and visually confirm whether prior tarballs are actually landing in OneDrive — this is now urgent because if (a) is true, autonomous backups are not actually working as intended despite the SUCCESS log entries. Tarball verified >1 MB sanity check. Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated; status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED at R3.23 and **R3.25 confirms RESOLVED status holds via third autonomous-success-path run.** **R3.23 STATUS CHANGE — REGRESSED → RESOLVED again via second autonomous-success-path run (auto-detected 2026-05-06 ~later):** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:16 → 2026-05-06 04:17, size grew 7,883 → 9,236 bytes (~17%) recording **second SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` (5.34 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op). Mount path this run: `/sessions/zen-practical-rubin/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — confirms OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory was reachable for tonight's autonomous run, despite R3.21's failed run between (2026-05-05 04:16). Two of four autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success — improvement over R3.21's 1-of-3 ratio). **Recurring observation in tonight's S-11 entry: destination was empty at start of run** (despite 2026-05-04 having created `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz`) — second time in three runs that a prior backup was not visible at the start of a new session (also seen 2026-05-04 vs the 2026-05-02 manual seed). Either (a) backups are not persisting in OneDrive across sessions, (b) the mount points to a different OneDrive subfolder per session, or (c) Will or OneDrive sync is removing them between sessions. **Action required from Will (carry-forward strengthened from R3.21):** investigate OneDrive Personal connection persistence at the user/account level rather than per-session — AND additionally manually inspect the actual OneDrive Personal folder contents in Finder to confirm tarballs are landing in cloud storage as intended (not just landing in a per-session sandbox view that vanishes on next mount). Tarball verified >1 MB sanity check. **R3.21 REGRESSED carry-forward is now FORMALLY RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run** (mirrors R3.18 RESOLVED-via-first-autonomous-success path; tonight's run confirms the autonomous-success path can recur after a per-session-failure interregnum). Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated; status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED. **R3.21 STATUS CHANGE — RESOLVED → REGRESSED again (fifth consecutive failure pattern recurrence, auto-detected 2026-05-05 ~later):** mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:17 → 2026-05-05 04:16, size grew 6,524 → 7,883 bytes (~21%) recording **NEW FAILED entry at 2026-05-05 11:16 UTC (04:16 local)**. Per the new entry: workspace mount at `/sessions/zealous-happy-edison/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present despite Will's reconnect that took effect for the 2026-05-04 successful run. The 2026-05-04 success was the ONLY autonomous-success-path run; the OneDrive connection does NOT reliably persist across scheduled-task sessions. Per the entry's notes: even if connected, today would have been a skip since last backup (2026-05-04 11:17) is only ~24 hours old, under the 48-hour gate — but mount-path resolution failed before the gate check, so the failure logged anyway. **Action required from Will:** investigate making the OneDrive connection persistent at the user/account level rather than per-session — re-adding via the Cowork chat-box "+" button has now succeeded once (2026-05-04) and failed three subsequent times to persist (2026-05-03, 2026-05-05; with 2026-05-02 manual seed missing from destination by 2026-05-04 run start as residual question from R3.18). **R3.18-noted RESOLVED carry-forward is now FORMALLY REGRESSED again.** Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated; status flipped RESOLVED → REGRESSED. **R3.18 STATUS CHANGE — REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~16:00):** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:17 → 2026-05-04 04:17, size grew 5,548 → 6,524 bytes (~18%) recording **first SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` (5.19 MB compressed from 18 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op). Mount path this run: `/sessions/kind-epic-shannon/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — confirms Will's reconnect of OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory via Cowork connector took effect for tonight's autonomous run. Per the entry's notes: 2026-05-02 manual seed backup `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` was NOT present in destination at start of this run — destination was empty; possible causes per entry: file removed by user / OneDrive sync state / different mount path. Worth a manual check from Will, but new backup created successfully so cloud-side recoverability is restored. Tarball verified >1 MB sanity check. **R3.15-noted REGRESSED status is now FORMALLY RESOLVED via autonomous-success path** (R3.12 had RESOLVED via manual-seed path only; tonight's R3.18 detection confirms the scheduled task SKILL.md workspace-mount path resolution introduced 2026-05-02 works correctly when the OneDrive folder is properly connected). **R3.15 STATUS CHANGE — RESOLVED → REGRESSED back to PERSISTENT FAILURE (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~16:00):** mtime advanced 2026-05-02 10:47 → 2026-05-03 04:17, size grew 4,422 → 5,548 bytes (~25%) recording **fourth consecutive scheduled-task failure** at 2026-05-03 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: bash sandbox mount at `/sessions/jolly-upbeat-brown/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present despite the task spec being updated 2026-05-02 to indicate the OneDrive folder is connected to Cowork; the connection from 2026-05-02 either did not persist across sessions or pointed to a different folder. Per task spec, exited without fallback to local-only paths. **Action required from Will:** re-add the OneDrive Personal folder (specifically the `OpenClaw-Shared` directory or its parent) via the Cowork chat-box "+" button so it appears under the workspace mount alongside `ECQ Development`. **R3.12 RESOLVED carry-forward is now FORMALLY REGRESSED.** Prior R3.12 mtime + size refresh — STATUS CHANGE: persistent-failure → RESOLVED (now superseded by R3.15 regression): size grew 2,366 → 4,422 bytes (~87%) across two new entries since R3.10/R3.11. (1) Third consecutive `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` entry recorded at 2026-05-02 04:17 local (UTC 11:17) with same root cause as 2026-04-30 / 2026-05-01 entries — bash sandbox mount only exposes `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, not `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/`; this was the third strike. (2) **First SUCCESS entry — manual seed backup at 2026-05-02 10:46 local (UTC 17:46)** — archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` (4.84 MB compressed from 16 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation not needed (1 backup total). Per the success entry's notes: "After three consecutive failures (4/30, 5/1, 5/2 scheduled runs), Will connected the OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared folder via the chat box "+" button, mounting it at `/sessions/<id>/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/`. Manual backup run from interactive session succeeded. The scheduled task SKILL has been updated to use the workspace-mount path resolution so future autonomous runs will work." **Carry-forward anomaly tracked since R3.6 is now RESOLVED.** Future scheduled runs should produce SUCCESS entries on the daily 04:10 cadence. R3.12 row mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status field preserved (`SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT`). Per file header: backup runs at 04:10 daily; new backup created only if 48+ hours since last; destination `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`; rotation keeps most recent 3. Treat as state-tracking artifact in the same cluster as S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG (all are auto-refresh tracker logs). |

---

## 8. Suggested task-specific reading packs

### CIL / learning / context pack
- `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`
- `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`
- `DOC15_Addendum_A_Audit_Synthesis_v1.3.md`
- `DOC15_Build_Manifest_v1.1 (1).md`
- `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md`
- `DOC7_Context_Buckets_Files_R7_Consolidated.md`
- `EC_Core_Specs_Rebuild_R1.md`
- `DOC1_Memory Resilience Rebuild_R1.md`

### Retrieval / search / topology pack
- `DOC18_LlamaIndex_Retrieval_Sidecar_R2.md`
- `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md`
- `DOC3_Companion_Doc_Delta_Plan_R9_2_Canonical.md`
- `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC10_Orchestration_Integration_Ledger_R10_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`
- `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`
- `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md`
- `EC_Core_Specs_Rebuild_R1.md`
- `DOC1_Memory Resilience Rebuild_R1.md`

### Q / UI / dashboard pack
- `Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC_v1_11_2_CANONICAL.md`
- `Q_SPEC_GAP_AUDIT.md`
- `DOC21 (UI) Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R7.md`
- `DOC22 (UI) Q_UI_PAGE_INVENTORY_AND_DESIGN_TEMPLATE_R4.md`
- `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md`
- `DOC20_R4_3.md`

### Rooms / red-team / room docs pack
- `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md`
- `DOC14_ELNOR_CANDOR_Integration_Architecture_R7.md`
- `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md`
- `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` *(if CIL/learning is in scope)*

### Gateway / model / search / ACP / channels pack
- `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md`
- `DOC4_OPENCLAW_BRIDGE_v1_11_6_2_REF_MAPPED.md`
- `OPENCLAW_PRESERVATION_AND_INTEGRATION_CHECKLIST_R1.md`
- `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md`
- `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md`
- `DOC13_Costs_R1.md`
- *(active addendum)* `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL.md`

### Cross-document delta / integration pack
- `DOC14_CROSS_DOCUMENT_DELTA_COMPANION_R2.md`
- `DOC10_Orchestration_Integration_Ledger_R10_Consolidated.md`
- `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`
- `Operations Docs/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V2.md` *(authoritative by-target tracker)*

### Task system / automation pack
- `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_0.md`
- `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2_1.md`
- `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md`
- `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md`
- `DOC20_R4_3.md`
- `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md`
- `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md`

### Knowledge / capability / intelligence pack
- `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md`
- `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md`
- `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md`
- `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md`
- `DOC1_Memory Resilience Rebuild_R1.md`
- `DOC8_SELF_LEARNING_PREDICTION_REGRESSION_FRICTION_v1_11_4.md`
- `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` *(concept draft — read for forward-looking architecture)*

### Document intelligence / ingestion pack (NEW in R2.7)
- `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md`
- `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md` *(intake §20A surface contracts)*
- `DOC18_LlamaIndex_Retrieval_Sidecar_R2.md`
- `DOC20_R4_3.md` *(Document Viewer surface)*
- `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md` *(tool registry)*
- `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` *(primary consumer of `DOC25_IngestionResult`)*
- *(active addendum)* `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4.md` *(MemoryAgent / DocumentIntelligenceAgent specs)*

---

## 9. Documents removed from active registry

### Removed in R2.7

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_6.md` *(this filename was registered in R2.6 but absent from active folder; R2.7 scan confirms only R5_73 is present)* | Superseded by R5.73 (file dated 2026-04-26) | `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md` |
| `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST.md` *(unversioned)* | Superseded by R2 (file dated 2026-04-13) | `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` |

### Removed in R2.6

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` | Superseded by R2.1 | `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2_1.md` |

### Removed in R2.5

*(No documents removed from the registry in R2.5. DOC24 updated from R2.4 to R2.5 — same registry slot, revised file.)*

### Removed in R2.4

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` | Superseded by R5.4 | `DOC16_R5_4.md` |
| `DOC20_R4_2.md` | Superseded by R4.3 (Skills & Connectors page addition, 2026-04-09) | `DOC20_R4_3.md` |

### Removed in R2.3

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC3_DOC10_Merge_Ledger_R1.md` | Moved to Subsumed Specs folder; absent from active folder during R2.3 scan | Content tracked in DOC14 Cross-Doc Delta R2 and DOC10 Ledger R10 |

### Removed in R2.2

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC20_R1_5_Consolidated.md` | Superseded by R1.8 | `DOC20_R1_8_Consolidated.md` |

### Removed in R2.1

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_V12_4.md` | Superseded by R13 | `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md` |
| `DOC20_Project_Browser_Note_Addendum_R1_2_Consolidated.md` | Superseded by R1.5 | `DOC20_R4_3.md` |
| `Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R4_2_CONSOLIDATED.md` *(was in Design Working Folder)* | Superseded by DOC21 R5; moved to Subsumed Design Docs | `DOC21 (UI) Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R7.md` |

### Removed in R2

| Document | Reason | Replaced By |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC3 ELNOR_First_Wave_MCP_Pack_R3.md` | Moved to Subsumed Specs; folded into DOC3 R11.1 | `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md` |
| `DOC3_LlamaIndex_Integration_Additions_R1 (2).md` | Moved to Subsumed Specs; folded into DOC3 R11.1 and DOC18 R2 | `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md` + `DOC18_LlamaIndex_Retrieval_Sidecar_R2.md` |
| `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_V12_2.md` | Superseded by V12.4 | `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md` |
| `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_v1_12_0_R6.md` | Superseded by R7.1 | `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md` |

---

## 10. File-system anomalies (require human review)

R2.6 anomalies whose status changed in R2.7, plus carry-forward items still requiring resolution. R2.8 nightly sync (2026-04-27) added new auto-detected items below; R2.9 nightly sync (2026-04-28) added further items; R3.0 nightly sync (2026-04-28, second pass of the day) added further items; R3.1 nightly sync (2026-04-28, third pass of the day) added further items; R3.2 nightly sync (2026-04-29) added items below; R3.4 nightly sync (2026-04-30) added items below; R3.5 nightly sync (2026-04-30, second pass of the day) added items below; R3.6 nightly sync (2026-04-30, third pass of the day) added items below; R3.7 nightly sync (2026-05-01) added items below; R3.12 nightly sync (2026-05-02, third pass of the day) added items below; R3.14 nightly sync (2026-05-03, second pass of the day) added items below; R3.15 nightly sync (2026-05-03, third pass of the day) added items below; R3.16 nightly sync (2026-05-04, first pass of the day) added items below; R3.17 nightly sync (2026-05-04, second pass of the day) added items below; R3.18 nightly sync (2026-05-04, third pass of the day) added items below; R3.20 nightly sync (2026-05-05, second pass of the day) added items below; R3.21 nightly sync (2026-05-05, third pass of the day) added items below; R3.22 nightly sync (2026-05-06) added items below; R3.23 nightly sync (2026-05-06, second pass of the day) added items below; R3.24 nightly sync (2026-05-07, first pass of the day) added items below; R3.25 nightly sync (2026-05-07, second pass of the day) added items below; R3.28 nightly sync (2026-05-08, third pass of the day — backfill for R3.27's §7-row gap + post-R3.27 operations-state firings) added items below.

### New anomalies detected in R3.49 (auto-detected 2026-05-17 ~16:10 local by nightly sync — same-day THIRD-firing SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump after R3.47 substantive + R3.48 operations-state-only)

| Anomaly | Description | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **NEW sub-sub-folder pattern `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/` at depth previously unseen in tracked Addenda subfolders** | Will created a sub-sub-folder under the existing `DOC23 Addenda/` top-level Addenda subfolder (folder mtime 2026-05-17 15:53) containing 6 NEW .md files + 1 files.zip representing **major architectural decomposition** of DOC23 Addenda B work from singular unified draft (R0.6.4 = A-53) into family topology: Core R0.7 + Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3.2 Addendum + 3 subsystem sub-addenda (Feedback Delivery V1, Source Workspace V1, Task Forum + Run Board V1) + Common Contracts V1 sibling spec. **First ever sub-sub-folder at this depth in any tracked top-level Addenda subfolder** — distinct from intra-subfolder archive pattern (`Archived DOC23 addenda/` introduced in R3.15) and distinct from top-level Addenda subfolder pattern. Rows A-60 through A-65 added to §A6 (master spec list treats sub-sub-folder as inline addition to §A6 rather than promoting to its own §A8 section pending classification decision; A-60 V3.2 lives in DOC23 Addenda root; A-61–A-65 live in `doc23 add b rework/`). Sub-sub-folder also contains a byte-identical duplicate of A-60 V3.2 (461,248 bytes) + a `files.zip` packaging artifact (160,315 bytes) — duplicate not given its own row; packaging artifact not tracked. | **NEW in R3.49.** Action needed: (a) human classification of A-60 V3.2 + A-61 R0.7 + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 + A-65 Common Contracts V1 (six new rows); (b) decision on whether the rework sub-sub-folder is staging area (collapses upward into DOC23 Addenda root when V1 → V2 / Core R0.7 → R0.8 / V3.2 → V4 cycles converge) or permanent organizational pattern (warrants its own §A8 section in future master spec list revision); (c) reclassification of A-65 Common Contracts V1 as SUPPORT / SIBLING SPEC rather than PROPOSED ADDENDUM (file explicitly positions itself as sibling spec to DOC23 R3.1 with explicit retirement-on-absorption lifecycle); (d) decision on whether A-53 R0.6.4 should be intra-subfolder archived following the established R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 archival pattern now that R0.7 Core explicitly supersedes it per Class 1 family-topology reorganization; (e) decision on whether A-54 R0.6.5 stacked proposal should be intra-subfolder archived now that R0.7 has absorbed its base material per Class 2 absorption; (f) decision on whether A-59 V3.1 should be intra-subfolder archived now that V3.2 supersedes it via surgical patch; (g) decision on whether SKILL.md should be updated with sub-sub-folder traversal mode for DOC23 Addenda subfolder (extends the five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog with a new sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement). |
| **A-65 Common Contracts V1 explicit joint-ownership pattern not seen before in master spec list** | A-65 Common Contracts V1 explicitly declares `Owner: Joint between Addenda A chat and Addenda B chat per coordination V3 §3.2; conflicts adjudicated by Will` — first ever explicitly-joint-ownership sibling spec registered in the master spec list. Every prior addendum had a single primary parent + companions (even multi-parent A-58 R0.2 in §A7 named DOC72/DOC24 as candidate primary parents). A-65 instead positions itself as a sibling spec to DOC23 R3.1 with explicit retirement-on-absorption lifecycle (`Active until DOC23 R3.2 compilation pass absorbs the contracts into the parent doc; then this document retires per §11 migration guide`). | **NEW in R3.49.** Action needed: classification decision on whether A-65's joint-ownership-sibling-spec pattern warrants a new status enum value (`SIBLING SPEC / JOINT OWNERSHIP`) distinct from PROPOSED ADDENDUM + SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT; alternatively, fold A-65 under SUPPORT with annotation about its retirement-on-absorption lifecycle. |
| **`doc23 add b rework/files.zip` packaging artifact in tracked subfolder** | The new `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder contains a `files.zip` (160,315 bytes, mtime 2026-05-17 15:54:00) alongside the 6 .md files. Per filename + size, this is likely the export bundle from the authoring environment (consistent with the duplicate V3.2 file in the same subfolder also suggesting an export-bundle staging area pattern). Auto pass does not track .zip files as addendum rows; the artifact is flagged here for visibility. | **NEW in R3.49.** Action needed: decide whether `files.zip` should be (a) deleted as a transient packaging artifact; (b) moved to a non-tracked location (e.g., the global archive or a per-author working folder); (c) preserved in-place as a snapshot bundle for traceability. |
| **Master spec list size at ~924 KB with R3.49 expansion** | Master spec list pre-R3.49 was ~924 KB (per R3.48 file size 923,402 bytes); R3.49 adds ~25 KB of new content (6 new §A6 rows averaging ~3 KB each + new §A6 narrative paragraph + new R3.49 anomaly section + new R3.49 changelog entry + header changes). Active master spec list now approaching ~950 KB. | **NEW in R3.49.** Action needed: same as R3.41/R3.44/R3.47 — consider periodic compaction of preserved header narratives (currently retains R3.41 + R3.42 + R3.44 + R3.45 + R3.47 + R3.48 + R3.49) or migration of historical changelog entries to a separate archive file once file approaches ~1 MB. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.43 (auto-detected 2026-05-15 ~17:00 UTC by nightly sync — same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump after R3.42)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **BACKUP_LOG NINTH-STRIKE URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF (6 calendar days with no confirmed cloud backup; silent-ephemeral-mount hypothesis CONFIRMED via first-ever bind-mount check in this scheduled task's history)** | Per S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md 2026-05-15 04:17 / 11:17 UTC entry (session ID `jolly-cool-albattani`): today's run was the FIRST in this scheduled task's history to execute an explicit `mountpoint` verification on the destination. Result: `mountpoint /sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned "is not a mountpoint", while `mountpoint /sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/ECQ Development` returned "is a mountpoint" — **definitive proof** that the OneDrive folder must appear as a bind mount, not merely as a writable subdirectory. Today's mkdir-then-tarball Step 1 silently created a sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` directory tree under `/sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/` and wrote a 5.80 MB tarball (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-15_111640.tgz`) to it — exactly the silent ephemeral-mount failure mode hypothesized in the 2026-05-14 R3.42 entry. Per task constraint #4 (no fallback to local-only paths), the bogus tarball was deleted and the sandbox-local scaffolding was `rmdir`-ed. **Retroactive doubt cast on all prior "successful" runs 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09:** those runs reported SUCCESS but did NOT perform the bind-mount check; today's confirmed-ephemeral-mount finding strongly suggests they may have written to ephemeral sandbox directories that never synced to OneDrive. **Pattern escalation:** R3.35 sixth-strike total-mount-loss URGENT-FAILURE-MODE → R3.36 seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING → R3.42 eighth-strike five-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT → **R3.43 NINTH-STRIKE six-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF**. Six calendar days now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup (5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15). **NEW URGENT Will action items from 2026-05-15 entry (carried forward and updated from 5/14, now with concrete code-level remediation for item 3):** (1) reconnect OneDrive folder via chat-box "+" button; (2) Finder-verify host-side `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` contents (today's bind-mount finding strongly suggests the 5/04–5/09 "successful" runs may also have written to ephemeral sandbox paths rather than the host OneDrive folder — if the host folder is empty or missing recent dates, the cloud-recoverability goal has never been met by this task); (3) **harden the task script with explicit `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || { log "OneDrive not bind-mounted — exiting"; exit; }` pre-flight BEFORE the `mkdir -p` in Step 1** — current Step 1 silently masks disconnection by creating a sandbox-local directory; the fix is to fail closed when the parent is not a real mount. The R3.35 PAUSE recommendation is now FURTHER STRENGTHENED to URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF — the scheduled task has produced no confirmed cloud backup for six consecutive days, and today's bind-mount finding shows the task's "SUCCESS" log entries through 5/09 may also have been illusory. | **STRENGTHENED FURTHER in R3.43 (ninth-strike six-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF; silent-ephemeral-mount hypothesis CONFIRMED rather than suspected).** Action required from Will (three-pronged, even more urgent than R3.42 with concrete code-level item-3 remediation now available): (1) reconnect OneDrive folder via chat-box "+" button; (2) Finder-verify host-side contents to ascertain whether any prior backup was real; (3) author hardening pass on scheduled task SKILL.md adding `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || exit` pre-flight before the `mkdir -p` in Step 1. |
| **No spec or addenda drift since R3.42 — pure operations-state-only firing (~6h window)** | `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.42.md` returns exactly one hit: S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md. No new addendum files in any tracked subfolder (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / DOC23 Addenda / Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj / Connectors and Integrations Addenda / DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs / EC Core Addenda / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs / Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress); no new operative spec files in active root; no new files in DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder. Folder counts unchanged from R3.42: 7 substantive Addenda subfolders + 1 archive subfolder + 2 cross-cutting subfolders + 1 DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs root + 1 archived Operations Docs subfolder. Operations-state-only firings are typically captured as fire-only bumps; R3.43 elevates to substantive bump primarily because of the BACKUP_LOG ninth-strike bind-mount-proof confirmation of the silent-ephemeral-mount hypothesis (first time the hypothesis has been promoted from suspected to confirmed). | **NEW in R3.43 (informational).** No action required beyond the BACKUP_LOG anomaly above. |
| **R3.43 versioned snapshot creation** | Per established R3.0–R3.42 versioning pattern, R3.43 alias write should be accompanied by a `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.43.md` versioned snapshot in the active root to preserve point-in-time reconstruction across future syncs. **NB:** R3.5's versioned snapshot was noted missing in R3.6 narrative and the gap has persisted across all subsequent R3.x scans — Will-side reconciliation pending. | **NEW in R3.43 (procedural).** Action: bump-time write of `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.43.md`. R3.5 gap remains in carry-forward. |
| All R3.42 carry-forward items unchanged (except BACKUP_LOG strengthened to ninth-strike with bind-mount proof) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five not-formally-listed subfolders backlog — unchanged from R3.42); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation (now with bind-mount-proof of failure mode); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); single-release roll-forward standstill at eighteen-day cadence-lag (no new S-9 firing since R3.42 captured 2026.5.12). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.42.** No state change on carry-forward items beyond BACKUP_LOG ninth-strike + bind-mount-proof escalation noted above. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.42 (auto-detected 2026-05-15 ~04:00 by nightly sync — overnight operations-state-only bump after R3.41)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **OpenClaw release alignment widens further: BEHIND-by-9 → BEHIND-by-10 (NEW STABLE 2026.5.12 ends 7-day stable pause; most architecturally consequential stable since 2026.5.3)** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-15 03:49 entry (10:43 UTC): latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.12 (released 2026-05-14 18:28 UTC, github-actions / steipete-signed)** — ends the 7-day stable pause that ran 2026-05-08 → 2026-05-14. Gap status widens BEHIND-by-9 → BEHIND-by-10 (composition adds 2026.5.12). Version sequence jumped 5.7 → 5.12 stable with 5.8/5.9/5.10/5.11 not published as stable — 5.9 / 5.10 existed only as betas, 5.11 not at all. **2026.5.12 architectural anchors for R3 amendment proposal**: (A) **Leaner-installs plugin-externalization extension** — WhatsApp, Slack, Amazon Bedrock, Anthropic Vertex, related provider/plugin dependency cones moved out of core runtime (extends 2026.5.2 plugin-externalization: Bedrock + Bedrock Mantle + Slack + OpenShell sandbox + Anthropic Vertex externalized to separate provider packages); (B) **NEW `acp.fallbacks` ACP runtime-backend fallback capability** (#69542 — ACP turns try configured backup runtime backends when primary backend unavailable before any output is emitted; directly affects DOC11 ACP core ownership + RLD-12-01 durable channel/topic bindings cluster + RLD-11-REF-04 ACP core setup/runtime); (C) **Explicit browser device pairing + Control UI pairing before proxy-scoped access** (DOC11 + EC Core secrets/pairing governance security-posture contract); (D) **Claude CLI fresh-session retries with bounded transcript history after session rotation** (#80905 — prevents conversation amnesia; DOC11 model/runtime truth + sub-agent contract); (E) **In-process agent dispatcher for same-process subagent completion handoffs** (avoids opening Gateway RPC loopback; DOC10 orchestration ledger + DOC11 sub-agent runtime truth); (F) **Control UI/WebChat persisted auto-scroll mode selector with three modes** (current near-bottom, always-follow streaming, off + manual New-messages button; #7648, #81287 — DOC20/DOC22 UI surface; rich-only reply paths, session history, streaming auto-scroll touched); (G) **Telegram polling isolation + durable local spool + HTML/Markdown formatting preservation in streamed/lazy cron-announced replies** (#81132, #81742, #81181 — DOC12 channel projection; skip unmentioned group media before download when requireMention active; tool-progress drafts kept separate from final assistant answer); (H) **`agents.defaults.subagents.model` applied before target agent primary models during `sessions_spawn`** (#81395 — model-scoped runtimes such as claude-cli stay attached to default child runs; SUBAGENT V4 + DOC11 sub-agent precedence); (I) Plugin install/update hardening (pnpm 11 support; peer-dependency preservation; safer runtime scans; source/git install fixes; installer honors --version for git installs and installs from checked-in lockfile); (J) Gateway/browser/Slack/node-pairing/sandbox/transcript security-provenance pass; (K) Channels/Weixin bump to `@tencent-weixin/openclaw-weixin@2.4.3` (#81730); (L) CLI/plugins keep bare plugin and parent-command help on lightweight path (avoids plugin registry discovery before rendering help); (M) Auth-profile-backed media tools stay available when OpenAI auth stored outside env vars; MCP server projection; context-engine thread rotation; better app-server/runtime fallback (Codex/OpenAI smoother). Beta lineage that converged: 5.12-beta.1 → 5.12-beta.4 → 5.12-beta.5 → 5.12-beta.6 → stable 5.12; many previously-tracked 5.9/5.10/5.12-beta watch items (iMessage media-only send hygiene from 5.12-beta.6; Codex private-runtime-SDK fix from 5.12-beta.4; /think default + /fast default from 5.9-beta.1; openclaw.json 0600 chmod from 5.9-beta.1; etc.) are NOT individually called out in the 5.12 stable highlights — they may have landed quietly or been deferred; needs direct verification against full 5.12 changelog rather than the abridged highlights view. Codex OAuth route saga remains closed in safe three-act form (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover); DOC11 R15 R3 may treat the conditional Codex-route preservation rule as stable precedent. Recommendation strengthened: DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal should fold **all ten** un-folded releases in one consolidated pass — Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative, seven 2026.5.7 quiet contract changes as DOC11 readback-truth obligations, 2026.5.12 leaner-installs + `acp.fallbacks` + pairing-before-proxy + Claude-CLI-bounded-transcript-retry + in-process-agent-dispatcher as the new architectural anchors. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for **eighteen consecutive days**; the new stable resumes gap growth after the 7-day stable pause. | **NEW in R3.42 (gap widens by one + most-architecturally-consequential-since-2026.5.3 stable release).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all ten releases. **NEW carry-forward in R3.42:** the eight architectural anchors (A)–(H) above should each get explicit fold targets in DOC11 R15 R3 with their associated cross-doc obligation footprints (DOC11 ACP core ownership, DOC11 + EC Core secrets/pairing governance, DOC11 model/runtime truth + sub-agent contract, DOC10 orchestration ledger + DOC11 sub-agent runtime truth, DOC20/DOC22 UI surface, DOC12 channel projection, SUBAGENT V4 + DOC11 sub-agent precedence). |
| **BACKUP_LOG four-consecutive-disconnected-run pattern PERSISTING — eighth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT (5 calendar days with no new cloud backup)** | Per S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md 2026-05-14 04:16 / 11:16 UTC entry: **fourth logged consecutive disconnected run** (after 2026-05-10, 2026-05-11, and 2026-05-13; 2026-05-12 has no log entry suggesting task either did not run or failed before logging step). Workspace mount at `/sessions/great-sharp-clarke/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, plus hidden `.claude` and `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present. No stray `mkdir -p` artifact created (OpenClaw-Shared parent directory does not exist, so mkdir attempt failed and bailed out before creating a stub). No source files modified, no tarball written to local-only sandbox path. **Status of cloud backup chain:** last successful tarball reported by this scheduled task was 2026-05-09 (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz`). **Five calendar days have now elapsed with no new cloud backup** (5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, and 5/14). The cloud-recoverability goal of this task is currently not being met. **Pattern escalation:** R3.35 sixth-strike total-mount-loss URGENT-FAILURE-MODE → R3.36 seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING → R3.42 eighth-strike five-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT. **NEW URGENT Will action items from 2026-05-14 entry** (three-pronged this time): (1) re-add the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder to Cowork via the chat-box "+" button so this scheduled task can resume writing backups; (2) independently verify on the host that prior tarballs actually accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` (the open hypothesis from 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 runs about per-session ephemeral mount semantics remains untested — if the host folder is empty or missing recent dates, the "successful" runs before 5/10 may also not have produced cloud-resident backups); (3) **NEW in 2026-05-14 entry — consider whether the scheduled task itself needs a hardening pass**: an explicit pre-flight check that asserts the destination is a real OneDrive bind mount (not just a writable directory under the sandbox) before declaring a run successful. This would catch silent ephemeral-mount failures earlier and avoid producing misleading "SUCCESS" entries in the BACKUP_LOG when host-side files may not actually be persisting. The R3.35 PAUSE recommendation is now FURTHER STRENGTHENED to URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT — the scheduled task has produced no output for five consecutive days and is at risk of being a non-functioning scheduled task that consumes session capacity to no operational benefit. | **STRENGTHENED FURTHER in R3.42 (eighth-strike five-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT).** Action required from Will (three-pronged — reconnect, verify, harden): (1) reconnect OneDrive folder via chat-box "+" button; (2) Finder-verify host-side `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` contents; (3) author hardening pass on scheduled task SKILL.md adding pre-flight mount-vs-directory assertion. |
| **No spec or addenda drift since R3.41 — pure operations-state-only firing (largest operations-state-only window in this scheduled task's history at ~11.5 hours since R3.41's 16:18 UTC alias write)** | `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.41.md` returns only Operations Docs files (SPEC_STATE, ADDENDA_STATE, DRIFT_LOG, OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY) plus the master spec list file itself. No new addendum files in any tracked subfolder (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / DOC23 Addenda / Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj / Connectors and Integrations Addenda / DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs / EC Core Addenda / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs / Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress); no new operative spec files in active root; no new files in DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder. Folder counts unchanged from R3.41: 7 substantive Addenda subfolders + 1 archive subfolder + 2 cross-cutting subfolders + 1 DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs root + 1 archived Operations Docs subfolder. Operations-state-only firings are typically captured as fire-only bumps; R3.42 elevates to substantive bump primarily because of the 2026.5.12 OpenClaw release news (most architecturally consequential stable since 2026.5.3) + the BACKUP_LOG eighth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT escalation. | **NEW in R3.42 (informational).** No action required beyond the OpenClaw + BACKUP_LOG anomalies above. |
| **R3.42 versioned snapshot creation** | Per established R3.0–R3.41 versioning pattern, R3.42 alias write should be accompanied by a `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.42.md` versioned snapshot in the active root to preserve point-in-time reconstruction across future syncs. **NB:** R3.5's versioned snapshot was noted missing in R3.6 narrative and the gap has persisted across all subsequent R3.x scans — Will-side reconciliation pending. | **NEW in R3.42 (procedural).** Action: bump-time write of `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.42.md`. R3.5 gap remains in carry-forward. |
| All R3.41 carry-forward items unchanged (except OpenClaw widened +1, BACKUP_LOG strengthened to eighth-strike) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (now five not-formally-listed subfolders — extends R3.41's four-subfolder backlog by one; gap especially salient with Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj being the newest addition); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + 5.12-beta lineage convergence items all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; R3.27 alias-bump-skipped-§7-row pattern still un-addressed in SKILL.md tightening. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.41.** No state change on carry-forward items beyond OpenClaw +1 + BACKUP_LOG escalation noted above. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.28 (auto-detected 2026-05-08 ~12:40 by nightly sync — third pass of the day, backfill pass)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind: BEHIND-by-8 → BEHIND-by-9 (Codex route saga closes as three-act narrative, REVERSING R3.24 caveat)** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-08 03:44 entry (10:47 UTC): latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.7 (released 2026-05-07 20:57 UTC — landed ~10 hours after yesterday's nightly check window closed; ~27 hours after 2026.5.6)**. **2026.5.7 is fixes-only AND closes the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 → 2026.5.7 Codex OAuth route saga as a three-act narrative:** doctor --fix now both PRESERVES working `openai-codex/*` PI routes AND RECOVERS 2026.5.5-rewritten `openai/*` GPT-5 routes back to `openai-codex/*` when only Codex OAuth auth is available (fixes #78407, thanks @shakkernerd). **This REVERSES R3.24's caveat** that DOC11 R15 R3 must NOT canonize the rule — the conditional Codex-route preservation rule is BACK in stable form, but only as a forward-only PRESERVE/RECOVER rule (not the original aggressive REWRITE rule that 2026.5.5 introduced and 2026.5.6 reverted). DOC11 R15 R3 may now treat the rule as stable precedent for capability-bound default-runtime resolution, BUT should fold the saga as a single closed three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover) rather than three separate rows. Other 2026.5.7 quiet contract changes worth tracking: Active Memory admin-scope requirement for global memory toggles (#78863); Channels CLI restructured (`channels list` channel-only with `--all` flag; model auth/usage moved to `models auth list`/`status`/`models list` #78456); Cron CLI status field added to `cron list --json`/`cron show --json` (disabled/running/ok/error/skipped/idle #78701); Native commands honor owner enforcement (#78864); Auto-reply gates inline skill tool dispatch through before-tool-call authorization hooks (#78517); Codex approvals stops installing pre-guardian native PermissionRequest hook by default + remembers allow-always within session window + makes plugin approval requests validate/render their actual allowed decisions; Discord voice permission auditing in `channels capabilities`/`channels status --probe` + extended default post-speech silence grace 2.5s with `voice.captureSilenceGraceMs`. Other notable 2026.5.7 fixes: Agents/context engine cached-assembled-context invalidation on history shrink/assembly fail (#77968); Agents/subagents archiveAfterMinutes honored (#78263); Agents/compaction reserve-token clamping (#54392); Plugins/install absolute POSIX npm lifecycle shell parity; Plugins/channel setup setChannelRuntime forwarding (#77779); OpenAI openai/chat-latest direct API-key model override; Tavily dedicated tool credentials from active runtime config snapshot; Cron/doctor repairs persisted cron jobs (#78549); Cron/isolated runs fail implicit announce delivery before model execution when delivery.channel=last has no previous route (#78608); Agent delivery deliverySucceeded=false when adapter result missing (#78532); Gateway/sessions clears cached skills snapshots during /new and sessions.reset (#78873); Channels — Discord routes provider-prefixed targets as channel sends; WhatsApp routes proactive phone-number sends through Baileys LID forward mappings (#67378); Telegram honors accessGroup:* sender allowlists (#78660), polling watchdog tied to getUpdates liveness (#78422), parses provider ids containing dots in /models callback buttons (#38745); Model providers normalize APNG sniffed PNG uploads, preserve Gemini 3 tool-call thought-signature replay with fallback signatures, accept legacy __env__:VAR custom-provider keys, repair snake_case tool-call transcript sanitization. **Recommendation strengthened:** an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold **all nine** un-folded releases in one consolidated pass with the Codex-route saga folded as a single closed three-act narrative — REPLACES the R3.24 "must-explicitly-not-canonize" note. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for ~12 consecutive days. | **NEW in R3.28 (gap widens by one + R3.24 caveat reversed by 5.7's safe-form Codex route preservation rule).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all nine releases. **NEW carry-forward in R3.28:** when DOC11 R15 R3 is authored, fold the Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover) rather than three separate rows. |
| **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — FOURTH CONSECUTIVE OCCURRENCE; rotation logic confirmed never firing** | Today's S-11 entry (2026-05-08 11:21 UTC SUCCESS) records destination empty at start of run for the fourth consecutive autonomous firing (2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 vs 2026-05-04 autonomous; 2026-05-07 vs 2026-05-06 autonomous; 2026-05-08 vs 2026-05-07 autonomous). **New observation in tonight's entry not present in R3.25's third-strike entry:** the rotation logic in this script will never run because the destination always looks empty — meaning this script is NOT actually capping at 3 backups across runs. If host-side files DO exist, they may be accumulating without rotation; if they DON'T exist, every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading. **Status: STRENGTHENED FURTHER from R3.25 URGENT to R3.28 URGENT (rotation-logic-non-firing observation added).** | **STRENGTHENED FURTHER in R3.28.** Action required from Will: open Finder at `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` and visually confirm whether prior tarballs (5/2 manual, 5/4, 5/6, 5/7, 5/8 autonomous) are actually present. The fourth-consecutive strike means this is now a stable failure mode of the autonomous path. Distinct from but related to the R3.21 OneDrive-connection-persistence carry-forward. |
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG records fourth autonomous-success-path run (RESOLVED status confirmed across four consecutive successes)** | Today's 2026-05-08 11:21 UTC firing produced a SUCCESS entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-08_112116.tgz` (5.38 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source); destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`; rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op); mount path `/sessions/upbeat-gifted-thompson/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Autonomous success rate now 4/6 (67%) since the autonomous-success path opened on 2026-05-04** (5/4 success → 5/5 failure → 5/6 success → 5/7 success → 5/8 success); R3.18 1-of-1, R3.21 1-of-3, R3.23 2-of-4, R3.25 3-of-5, R3.28 4-of-6 — gradual improvement trend with longest success streak (4 consecutive autonomous successes 5/6 → 5/7 → 5/8) of the autonomous-path series. R3.25-noted RESOLVED status confirmed across four consecutive autonomous successes. | **STATUS HOLDS RESOLVED in R3.28.** No state change beyond confirming the autonomous-success path is now reliably firing four days in a row when the OneDrive mount is exposed by the per-session sandbox; the empty-start anomaly above remains the open question on whether host-side files persist. |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly REOPENED (R3.20 anomaly recurrence in milder form)** | Tonight's R3.28 sync detects S-8 advanced 2026-05-07 04:03 → 2026-05-08 04:02, size shrank 43,864 → 41,222 bytes (-6.0%). Second size-decrease across the auto-refresh series (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 → R3.22 40,104 → R3.24 43,864 → R3.28 41,222). Today's value (41,222) is below R3.24 peak (43,864) by ~6% and essentially equal to R3.18 prior peak (41,236). Per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md head: "Generated: 2026-05-08 (nightly auto-refresh)", Window 2026-05-01 → 2026-05-08 (7 days) — the 7-day rolling window may explain size oscillation as older entries roll out and newer entries roll in. R3.24 had noted FULLY RESOLVED of the R3.20 anomaly (S-8 grew past R3.18 peak); R3.28 reopens in milder form — if S-8 oscillates between 36k and 44k bytes across the next several R3.x ticks, this is the rolling-window behavior and the anomaly is structurally non-resolvable; if S-8 keeps trending downward, the auto-refresh task's compaction logic is over-applying. | **REOPENED in R3.28 (downgraded from R3.20's anomaly severity; rolling-window structural cause likely).** Action needed: human-monitor next 1-2 nightly ticks to see whether S-8 continues to oscillate within rolling-window range or trends downward. SKILL.md inspection deferred to human sweep. |
| **R3.27 §7-row-gap pattern (third instance of alias-bump-skipped-§7-row pattern in 30 days)** | R3.27 ran ~04:23 local as a "same-day second-firing mechanical bump" that performed the R3.26 versioned-snapshot archival but DID NOT update §7 rows S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 to reflect their new 2026-05-08 mtimes despite narrative claiming advance. R3.27 ALSO mis-narrated S-11 BACKUP_LOG as "(2026-05-07 04:17, 11,038 bytes) unchanged from R3.26 baseline since today's daily 04:08/04:17 firings have not yet occurred at R3.27 sync time of ~04:23 local" — factually incorrect; today's S-11 firing actually occurred at 2026-05-08 04:21:45 (~2 minutes BEFORE R3.27 generation time of ~04:23). R3.27 ALSO missed the substantive S-9 content delta of 2026.5.7 detection. **Third instance of alias-bump-skipped-§7-row pattern within past 30 days:** R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 missed §12 changelog entries; R3.24/R3.25 missed §7 row mtimes; R3.27 missed §7 row mtimes AND mis-narrated S-11 mtime AND missed S-9 content delta. R3.28 backfills these gaps but the pattern is now an established procedural recurrence. | **NEW in R3.28 (informational + procedural).** R3.26 narrative recommended SKILL.md procedure should be tightened to actually execute audit-cleanup + §12 append + §7 row updates at bump time; that recommendation has not been implemented and may be worth Will-side procedural action. |
| All R3.27 / R3.25 carry-forward items unchanged (except OpenClaw widened, S-11 strengthened, S-8 reopened) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.27.** No state change on these items beyond OpenClaw gap widening +1, S-11 empty-start strengthening (4th strike), S-8 size-decrease reopening, and the R3.27 §7-row-gap procedural anomaly noted above. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.25 (auto-detected 2026-05-07 ~later by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — THIRD CONSECUTIVE OCCURRENCE; 48-hour gate effectively defeated** | Today's S-11 entry (2026-05-07 11:16 UTC SUCCESS) records destination empty at start of run for the third consecutive autonomous firing (2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 vs 2026-05-04 autonomous; 2026-05-07 vs 2026-05-06 autonomous). The 48-hour backup-creation gate is functionally not enforcing — yesterday's autonomous run created a tarball ~24 hours ago (well under the gate), but today's session sees an empty destination and treats the gate condition as "no prior backup," so a new tarball is created, yielding back-to-back daily backups. Three explanations per file note: (a) per-session sandbox mount is a fresh ephemeral copy that doesn't reflect the host OneDrive folder; (b) OneDrive sync is removing tarballs between sessions; (c) host folder accumulates them but they're not exposed back into subsequent sandbox sessions. If (a) is the root cause, every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading — host-side files may not actually be persisting. **Status: STRENGTHENED from R3.23 NEW carry-forward to URGENT in R3.25.** | **STRENGTHENED to URGENT in R3.25.** Action required from Will: open Finder at `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` and visually confirm whether prior tarballs (5/2 manual, 5/4, 5/6, 5/7 autonomous) are actually present. If they are not, autonomous backups are not working as intended despite SUCCESS log entries. Distinct from but related to the R3.21 OneDrive-connection-persistence carry-forward. |
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG records third autonomous-success-path run (RESOLVED status confirmed)** | Today's 2026-05-07 11:16 UTC firing produced a SUCCESS entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-07_111637.tgz` (5.36 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source); destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`; rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3, no-op); mount path `/sessions/busy-hopeful-brahmagupta/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Autonomous success rate now 3/5 (60%) since the autonomous-success path opened on 2026-05-04** (5/4 success → 5/5 failure → 5/6 success → 5/7 success); R3.18 1-of-1, R3.21 1-of-3, R3.23 2-of-4, R3.25 3-of-5 — gradual improvement trend. R3.23-noted RESOLVED status is now confirmed across two consecutive autonomous successes (5/6 + 5/7), which is the longest success streak of the autonomous-path series. | **STATUS HOLDS RESOLVED in R3.25.** No state change beyond confirming the autonomous-success path is now reliably firing two days in a row when the OneDrive mount is exposed by the per-session sandbox; the empty-start anomaly above remains the open question on whether host-side files persist. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-10 + S-11 only — daily 04:10/04:17 tasks fired after R3.24 sync) | (a) `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-05-06 04:09 → 2026-05-07 04:08, size grew 29,650 → 35,320 bytes (~+19%) recording new 2026-05-07 11:00 entry (today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task — its narrative on S-11 reflects yesterday's RESOLVED state and is now slightly stale by ~5 hours since today's BACKUP_LOG SUCCESS entry was written ~6 minutes later). (b) `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) — see anomaly rows above. Other operations files unchanged from R3.24 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-07 03:09 / 37,092 bytes); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-07 03:09 / 41,199 bytes); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:10 / 93,077 bytes); S-7 OP-A V3.7; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-07 04:03 / 43,864 bytes — second consecutive growth tick from R3.24 holds); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:47 / 26,858 bytes — no new OpenClaw stable release detected since R3.24 sync earlier today; gap status holds at BEHIND-by-8). Rows S-10 + S-11 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; S-11 status remains RESOLVED. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.25 sync.** No human action required beyond the empty-start anomaly above. |
| OpenClaw release alignment unchanged today — gap holds at BEHIND-by-8 | No new stable release published between R3.24 (~04:10 local) and R3.25 (~later local) sync times today. Latest stable remains 2026.5.6 (2026-05-06, 17:51 UTC). Gap status holds at BEHIND-by-8 from R3.24; recommendation strengthens by another partial-day of standstill — single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for ~11+ consecutive days. No R3 amendment file authored yet. The 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must-explicitly-not-canonize note from R3.24 carries forward unchanged. Row S-9 mtime + Notes preserved; status preserved. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.24 (no state change).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all eight releases. |
| All R3.24 carry-forward items unchanged | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap salient with 7 active files including A-53 R0.6.4 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly STRENGTHENED to URGENT (see anomaly row above); OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation BEHIND-by-8 with 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must-explicitly-not-canonize note. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.24.** Empty-start anomaly is the one carry-forward item that has STRENGTHENED to urgent in R3.25 (third consecutive occurrence). |

### New anomalies detected in R3.24 (auto-detected 2026-05-07 ~04:10 by nightly sync — first pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind: BEHIND-by-7 → BEHIND-by-8 (with REVERT of an R3.22-flagged precedent)** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-07 03:47 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.6 (released 2026-05-06, 17:51 UTC — same-day patch on 2026.5.5 that landed ~9 hours after yesterday's nightly check window closed)**. **2026.5.6 is a fixes-only release that REVERTS the 2026.5.5 Doctor/Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route repair (fixes #78407 from 2026.5.5).** The 2026.5.5 conditional `agentRuntime.id: "codex"` selection rule (codex iff Codex plugin installed + enabled + has codex harness + has usable OAuth, else pi) — flagged in R3.22's S-9 anomaly row as a useful precedent for DOC11 R15 R3 capability-bound default-runtime resolution — **is now gone**. The 2026.5.5 logic could break OAuth-only GPT-5.5 setups or accidentally move users onto the OpenAI API-key route. Recovery command for users hit by 2026.5.5: `openclaw models set openai-codex/gpt-5.5 && openclaw config validate`. Other 2026.5.6 changes are pure plumbing/security hardening with no schema-level obligations: Plugins/runtime fetch drops third-party symbol metadata from header dictionaries before native fetch (fixes #77846, thanks @shakkernerd); Debug proxy normalizes captured fetch header dictionaries before replaying requests; Web fetch bounds guarded dispatcher cleanup after request timeouts so timed-out fetches return tool errors instead of leaving Gateway tool lanes active (fixes #78439, thanks @obviyus). Per the new entry's recommendation: an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should now fold **all eight** un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6) in one consolidated pass, with the explicit 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 revert pair noted so DOC11 does not lock in the abandoned Codex route-repair logic. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for ~11 consecutive days, with same-day 2026.5.5/2026.5.6 patch pair underscoring the cost of single-release amendment cycles. | **NEW in R3.24 (gap widens by one + a flagged precedent is invalidated).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all eight releases. **NEW carry-forward in R3.24:** when DOC11 R15 R3 is authored, it MUST explicitly note the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair so the abandoned conditional `agentRuntime.id` rule is not folded in. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9) | (a) S-3 SPEC_STATE.md 2026-05-06 03:09 → 2026-05-07 03:09 (size 31,824 → 37,092 bytes; ~17% — picks up R3.23 row content writes that propagated through tonight's sync); (b) S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md 2026-05-06 03:09 → 2026-05-07 03:09 (size 41,106 → 41,199 bytes; ~+0.2% — minimal tick); (c) S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md 2026-05-06 03:08 → 2026-05-07 03:10 (size 84,586 → 93,077 bytes; ~10% — picks up R3.23 narrative entry append at top documenting S-11 RESOLVED status flip + empty-start carry-forward); (d) S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 2026-05-06 04:04 → 2026-05-07 04:03 (size 40,104 → 43,864 bytes; ~+9% — **second consecutive growth tick**, continuing the R3.22-noted post-R3.20 size-decrease recovery; first tick to grow PAST the R3.18 peak of 41,236 bytes — peak now stands at 43,864); (e) S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md — see anomaly row above. Rows S-3 + S-4 + S-5 + S-8 + S-9 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.24 sync.** No human action required. |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 — FULLY RESOLVED in R3.24** | Tonight's R3.24 sync detects S-8 grew 40,104 → 43,864 bytes (+9%) — second consecutive size growth since the R3.20-noted decrease, and **first tick to grow past the R3.18 peak of 41,236 bytes** (S-8 series: R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 → R3.22 40,104 → R3.24 43,864). The R3.20 anomaly is now fully resolved — the file has not only recovered but exceeded the prior peak. Likely the auto-refresh task is appending normally and the R3.20 dip was transient (one-off compaction or Will-edit). | **FULLY RESOLVED in R3.24.** No further action required. R3.20-noted carry-forward closed. |
| S-10 + S-11 unchanged from R3.23 — daily 04:10 task has NOT fired yet at R3.24 sync time OR was skipped under 48-hour gating | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) mtime 2026-05-06 04:09 unchanged. `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) mtime 2026-05-06 04:17 unchanged. Either today's daily task hasn't fired yet at R3.24 sync time of ~04:10 local (matches R3.22's same-day pattern where S-11 hadn't ticked at sync time), OR the 48-hour gating policy applied (last successful S-11 entry 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC is ~24 hours old, under the 48-hour gate — task may have skipped without writing a log entry). **R3.23 RESOLVED status carries forward** since today's 04:10 firing has not yet been observed. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.23.** Status of R3.23-noted RESOLVED carry-forward holds informationally pending tonight's actual 04:10 trigger and/or 48-hour-gate skip-without-log behavior verification. Action required from Will (carry-forward from R3.21/R3.23): investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence; manually inspect actual OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents in Finder. |
| All R3.23 carry-forward items unchanged | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap salient with 7 active files including A-53 R0.6.4 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly (R3.23 NEW carry-forward) still pending Finder-level inspection by Will. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.23.** No state change on the carry-forward items beyond the OpenClaw gap widening +1 + the 2026.5.5 precedent invalidation noted above. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.23 (auto-detected 2026-05-06 ~later by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS REGRESSION REVERSAL (REGRESSED → RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run)** | The R3.21-noted REGRESSED carry-forward (5/5 04:16 firing failed) has reversed at today's 04:17 local firing. New BACKUP_LOG entry at 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC records SUCCESS status: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` (5.34 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (under cap of 3). Mount path this run: `/sessions/zen-practical-rubin/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Two of four autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success — improvement over R3.21's 1-of-3 ratio). Per file note: destination was empty at start of run (despite 2026-05-04 having created its own tarball) — second time in three runs of empty-start observation; possible OneDrive sync state issue, per-session mount-path mismatch, or external removal between sessions. | **STATUS CHANGE in R3.23: REGRESSED → RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run.** Mirrors R3.18 RESOLVED-via-first-autonomous-success path; tonight's run confirms the autonomous-success path can recur after a per-session-failure interregnum. Persistence across sessions remains intermittent. |
| **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly (NEW carry-forward in R3.23)** | Pattern across the S-11 log: 2026-05-04 autonomous run had destination empty at start despite the 2026-05-02 manual seed having succeeded; 2026-05-06 autonomous run had destination empty at start despite the 2026-05-04 autonomous run having created a tarball. Three possible explanations per file notes: (a) backups are not persisting in OneDrive across sessions; (b) the mount points to a different OneDrive subfolder per session; (c) Will or OneDrive sync is removing them between sessions. None of these has been verified via Finder inspection on the actual OneDrive folder. | **NEW CARRY-FORWARD in R3.23.** Action required from Will: manually inspect the actual OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents in Finder to confirm tarballs are landing in cloud storage as intended (not vanishing into a per-session sandbox view). Distinct from the R3.21 OneDrive connection persistence carry-forward. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-10 + S-11 only) | (a) `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-05-05 04:10 → 2026-05-06 04:09, size grew 24,943 → 29,650 bytes (~19%) — new 2026-05-06 10:55 entry recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh (which itself documents OpenClaw 2026.5.5 awareness from R3.22's S-9 update + R3.21 S-11 REGRESSED status — note: the log entry was written before today's 11:17 UTC SUCCESS BACKUP_LOG entry, so its narrative on S-11 is now slightly stale, mirroring R3.21's stale-on-write S-10 entry pattern). (b) `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) — see anomaly row above. Other operations files unchanged from R3.22 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-06 03:09) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-06 03:09) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-06 03:08) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-06 04:04, size 40,104 bytes — unchanged from R3.22's partial recovery) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-06 03:46). Rows S-10 + S-11 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; S-11 status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.23 sync; S-11 status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED.** No further human action required beyond the empty-start carry-forward above. |
| OpenClaw release alignment unchanged today — gap holds at BEHIND-by-7 | No new stable release published between R3.22 (~04:05 local) and R3.23 (~later local) sync times today. Latest stable remains 2026.5.5 (2026-05-06, ~09:00 UTC). Gap status holds at BEHIND-by-7 from R3.22; recommendation strengthens by another day of standstill — single-release roll-forwards now "no longer keeping pace" for ten consecutive days. No R3 amendment file authored yet. Row S-9 mtime + Notes preserved; status preserved. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.22 (no state change).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all seven releases. |
| All R3.22 carry-forward items unchanged (except S-11 RESOLVED) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient with 7 active files including A-53 R0.6.4 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation (R3.21 carry-forward, strengthened in R3.23 by the empty-start anomaly above); OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation still actively warranted (gap holds at BEHIND-by-7 in R3.23, no new release today). S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly carry-forward from R3.20/R3.22 holds informationally (S-8 unchanged tonight). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.22.** S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSED carry-forward is the one item that flipped to RESOLVED in R3.23. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.22 (auto-detected 2026-05-06 ~04:05 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind: BEHIND-by-6 → BEHIND-by-7** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-06 03:46 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.5 (released 2026-05-06, today, published 09:00 UTC)** — this is a fixes-only release with NO new operative architectural surfaces (no file-transfer plugin, no realtime voice bridge, no plugin externalization equivalent). Notable contract-touching items: Doctor/sessions recovery-key migration for heartbeat-poisoned default main session entries; Doctor/Codex legacy `openai-codex/*` → `openai/*` route repair with **conditional agentRuntime.id selection** (codex iff Codex plugin installed + enabled + has codex harness + has usable OAuth; else pi — useful precedent for DOC11 capability-bound default-runtime resolution); **Agents/config removes ambiguous legacy "main" agent dir helper from runtime paths** (default/session agent dirs now resolved through agents.list / agent-scope helpers; plugin SDK keeps deprecated compatibility export — the kind of quiet contract change DOC11 R15 should explicitly track); **CLI/sessions prunes unreferenced transcript / compaction-checkpoint / trajectory artifacts during normal sessions cleanup** (touches DOC11 sessions/checkpoint truth and EC durable-state retention assumptions); Sessions-table runtime filter; Control UI compaction count + checkpoint history disclosure; Gateway/OpenAI-compatible chat-stream chunk flushing; Gateway/shutdown structured ShutdownResult warnings; Gateway/status event-loop-degraded sustained-sampling-window backoff; xAI/Grok native-Responses reasoning-effort suppression (xai/grok-4.3 no longer fails Docker/Gateway); Fireworks/Kimi K2.5/K2.6 thinking-off pinning; Channels improvements (Feishu native-topic hydration, LINE dmPolicy "open" rejection, Telegram/Codex tool-progress dedup, Discord /steer + heartbeat ACK + live reasoning, Matrix approval delivery 3x retry, Slack Socket Mode error context, WhatsApp stale-client recovery); iOS pairing setup-code/manual ws:// for private LAN; Docker/Gateway capability drops + no-new-privileges; /status uptime; Plugins/diagnostics source-only TS warnings; Auth profiles cooldown skip on format rejection; Exec approvals copy fallback; Update dev-channel preflight opt-in; Video generation aspect-ratio normalization. Per the new entry's recommendation: an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should now fold **all seven** un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5) in one consolidated pass with a companion next-R of the running list; single-release roll-forwards have not kept pace for nine consecutive days. | **NEW in R3.22 (recommendation unchanged in substance, gap widens by one).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all seven releases; A-1 R1 + A-36 R2 would both be candidates for archival once R3 lands. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9) | (a) S-3 SPEC_STATE.md 2026-05-05 03:10 → 2026-05-06 03:09 (size 25,817 → 31,824 bytes; ~23% — picks up R3.21 row content writes that propagated through tonight's sync); (b) S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md 2026-05-05 03:11 → 2026-05-06 03:09 (size 35,042 → 41,106 bytes; ~17%); (c) S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md 2026-05-05 03:18 → 2026-05-06 03:08 (size 78,895 → 84,586 bytes; ~7% — picks up R3.21 narrative entry append at top documenting S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED status flip); (d) S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 2026-05-05 04:02 → 2026-05-06 04:04 (size 36,470 → 40,104 bytes; +10% — **first auto-refresh tick to grow in size since R3.20-noted size-decrease anomaly**); (e) S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md — see anomaly row above. Rows S-3 + S-4 + S-5 + S-8 + S-9 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.22 sync.** No human action required. |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 PARTIALLY RESOLVED** | Tonight's R3.22 sync detects S-8 grew 36,470 → 40,104 bytes (+10%) — first size growth since the R3.20-noted decrease (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 → R3.22 40,104). Possible explanations: (a) tonight's auto-refresh task expanded the content to include 2026.5.5 release awareness + tonight's sync awareness, growing past R3.20's compacted form; (b) Will manually edited the file between R3.21 and R3.22 to expand it; (c) the auto-refresh task's compaction step (if it has one) didn't fire tonight, allowing normal append to grow the file. Tonight's value (40,104) is still ~3% below the R3.18 peak of 41,236, so anomaly is partial — file has not fully recovered to peak. | **PARTIALLY RESOLVED in R3.22 (anomaly may have been transient).** Action needed: human-monitor next 1-2 nightly ticks to see whether S-8 continues to grow (suggesting normal append) or oscillates (suggesting periodic compaction); SKILL.md inspection deferred to human sweep. |
| S-10 + S-11 unchanged from R3.21 — daily 04:10 task has NOT fired yet at R3.22 sync time | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) mtime 2026-05-05 04:10 unchanged (next eligible firing: 2026-05-06 04:10 if scheduled task fires after R3.22 sync time of ~04:05). `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) mtime 2026-05-05 04:16 unchanged (next eligible firing: 2026-05-06 04:10 if scheduled task fires; **R3.21 REGRESSED status carries forward** since today's 04:10 firing has not yet happened). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.21.** Status of R3.21-noted REGRESSED carry-forward holds informationally pending tonight's actual 04:10 trigger. Action required from Will (carry-forward from R3.21): investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence rather than per-session reconnects. |
| All R3.21 carry-forward items unchanged | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient with 7 active files including A-53 R0.6.4 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation still actively warranted (gap widens to BEHIND-by-7 in R3.22). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.21.** No state change on the carry-forward items beyond the OpenClaw gap widening +1. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.21 (auto-detected 2026-05-05 ~later by nightly sync — third pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS REGRESSION (RESOLVED → REGRESSED again)** | The R3.18-noted RESOLVED carry-forward (first successful autonomous run 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC) has REGRESSED at today's 04:16 local firing. New BACKUP_LOG entry at 2026-05-05 11:16 UTC records FAILED status: workspace mount at `/sessions/zealous-happy-edison/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present. The 2026-05-04 success was the ONLY autonomous-success-path run; the OneDrive connection does NOT reliably persist across scheduled-task sessions. Per file note: even if connected, today would have been a skip under the 48-hour gate (last backup ~24h ago) — but mount-path failure logged anyway because it preceded the gate check. | NEW CARRY-FORWARD: Will to investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence rather than per-session reconnects. Per-session reconnects via Cowork chat-box "+" succeeded once (2026-05-04) and failed three subsequent times. |
| **OneDrive connection persistence problem** | Pattern across the S-11 log now clear: 2026-05-02 manual seed (success, but file later missing from destination); 2026-05-03 scheduled (failed, no mount); 2026-05-04 scheduled (success, mount present); 2026-05-05 scheduled (failed, no mount). The connection works briefly when re-established but does not survive across scheduled-task sessions. R3.20 had explicitly deferred this firing's outcome to "next firing" — that firing has now occurred and confirmed the persistence problem rather than the 48-hour gate. | Pending Will-side investigation; Cowork connector behavior may need account-level pinning rather than chat-box per-session "+" adds. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.18 (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~16:00 by nightly sync — third pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| NEW addendum A-53 R0.6.4 supersedes A-52 R0.6.3 in <16h | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_4_UI_CONTINUATION_SHARING_PATCHED.md` (mtime 2026-05-04 15:17, size 327,340 bytes — large file at ~119% of A-52 R0.6.3's 274,551 bytes; ~135% of A-51 R0.6.1's 241,604 bytes). Per file header: "R0.6.4 UI, Run Inspector, Module Continuation, Sharing-Forward-Compatible Unified Draft", date 2026-05-04, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.4 carries forward R0.6.3 and adds DOC20 task-surface integration, graph/inspector navigation, artifact/delivery UI, context inspector feedback, Task Agent side-panel/session behavior, Task Segment reusable module groups, module continuation/follow-up, run forking/rerun-from-module, Judge/Experiment rerun affordances, audit export, task-page operational stats, and shared-task surface forward-compatibility for future DOC50+ sharing/networking specs." Companion docs adds DOC20 (R0.6.4 task-surface integration). New row A-53 added in §4.A6. **Rapid R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4 cadence over 36h window (R3.15 → R3.16 → R3.18) signals active iteration on DOC23 Addenda B; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity continues to grow.** | **NEW in R3.18.** Action needed: human classification of A-53 + B-track archive-row collapse sweep. |
| A-52 R0.6.3 archived to intra-subfolder | `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_3_SURFACE_CONTEXT_PATCHED.md` moved from `DOC23 Addenda/` to `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (mtime preserved 2026-05-04 00:42, size unchanged 274,551 bytes). Mirrors A-50 R0.3 (R3.15) and A-51 R0.6.1 (R3.16) archival patterns. **DOC23 Addenda B-track intra-subfolder archive at R3.18: 4 files** (A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5 + A-51 R0.6.1 + A-52 R0.6.3) — collapse opportunity grows from 3 rows (R3.16/R3.17) to 4 rows (R3.18). | **NEW in R3.18.** Action needed: B-track archive-row collapse sweep next manual review. |
| NEW (1)-suffix duplicate of DOC23 Sequential Re-Prompt System Addendum | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-04 15:53, size 22,818 bytes — byte-identical to existing A-46 `DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` at 22,818 bytes/2026-05-01 17:31). Filename "(1)" suffix suggests Will copied this from Downloads — same anomaly pattern as A-39 DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card "(1)" file noted in R3.4 and DOC23 Task Optimization R4.0 "(1)" file noted in R3.7/R3.9. Tracked as informational anomaly pending human review (likely Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize); not given a separate row in §4.A6 since byte-identical to A-46. | **NEW in R3.18 (informational).** Action needed: Will to remove the "(1)" duplicate or confirm if there is a substantive difference; may be touch-only operation that produced the duplicate. |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:17 → 2026-05-04 04:17, size grew 5,548 → 6,524 bytes (~18%) recording **first SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` (5.19 MB compressed from 18 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3). Mount path this run: `/sessions/kind-epic-shannon/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **R3.15-noted REGRESSED carry-forward is now FORMALLY RESOLVED via autonomous-success path** (R3.12 had RESOLVED via manual-seed path only; tonight's R3.18 detection confirms the workspace-mount path resolution introduced 2026-05-02 works correctly when the OneDrive folder is properly connected). Per the entry's notes: 2026-05-02 manual seed backup `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` was NOT present in destination at start of this run — destination was empty. Possible causes: file removed by user, OneDrive sync state, or different mount path. Worth a manual check from Will, but new backup created successfully so cloud-side recoverability is restored. | **STATUS CHANGE in R3.18: REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path.** Tracked since R3.6 / R3.12 RESOLVED-manual / R3.15 REGRESSED. Future scheduled runs should produce SUCCESS entries on the daily 04:10 cadence (with 48-hour gating). One residual question for Will: investigate why the 2026-05-02 manual seed backup is not present in destination at start of tonight's run (possible OneDrive sync state, file removal, or mount-path mismatch). |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-10 / S-11 only) | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-05-03 04:10 → 2026-05-04 04:21, size grew 14,177 → 19,950 bytes (~41% — additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) — see anomaly row above. Other operations files unchanged from R3.17 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:11) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-04 03:17) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-04 04:03) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-04 03:44). Rows S-10 + S-11 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; S-11 status field updated to reflect RESOLVED. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.18 sync; S-11 status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED.** No further human action required beyond residual question above. |
| All R3.17 carry-forward items unchanged (except S-11 RESOLVED) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient with 7 active files including A-53 R0.6.4); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity now at 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation still actively warranted (no R3 amendment file authored yet). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.17.** S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSED carry-forward is the one item that flipped to RESOLVED in R3.18. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.17 (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~04:10 by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Re-confirmation pass — no spec-folder structural drift | No new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (any tracked subfolder including DOC23 Addenda which had A-52 R0.6.3 added in R3.16), or `Operations Docs/`. No archive movements of operative specs. Counts unchanged from R3.16 (40 active root .md files including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.16 versioned snapshot; 7 root + 6 DOC23 + 4 DOC20 + 5 DOC24 + 3 DOC72 + 3 DOC73 + 7 Integrated + 2 CD Cross + 6 Connectors and Integrations + 3 DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs + 2 EC Core across Addenda subfolders). | **NEW in R3.17 (informational only).** No human action required. |
| OpenClaw 2026.5.2 still latest stable — no new release since R3.16 | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-04 03:44 entry (10:43 UTC): WebSearch and GitHub release-tag scan confirm no new stable tag cut since 2026.5.2 (2026-05-02). Beta-only tags continuing on the 2026.5.2-beta.x line; nothing has crossed the stable cutover. Gap status unchanged at BEHIND-by-3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2). Recommendation unchanged from R3.14/R3.15/R3.16: DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal warranted to fold 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 and promote 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now, with companion next-R of the running list. Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.14/R3.15/R3.16 (recommendation actively warranted; no state change).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment (would become A-? row in §4.A1; A-1 R1 + A-36 R2 would both be candidates for archival once R3 lands). |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-8 / S-9 only) | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-05-03 04:04 → 2026-05-04 04:03, size grew 37,316 → 41,236 bytes (~11% — sixth consecutive auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) advanced 2026-05-03 03:44 → 2026-05-04 03:44, size grew 7,497 → 9,805 bytes (~31% — new 2026-05-04 entry recording no-new-stable-since-2026.5.2 status). Other operations files unchanged from R3.16 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:11) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-04 03:17 — R3.16's own narrative entry append) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-03 04:10) / S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-03 04:17). Rows S-8 + S-9 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.17 sync.** No human action required. |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED — no new nightly run between R3.16 and R3.17 | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime 2026-05-03 04:17 unchanged from R3.15/R3.16. The daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task is supposed to run at 04:10 daily; tonight's scheduled run did not produce a SUCCESS entry validating recovery from regression nor a FAILED entry confirming the regression holds. Three possible explanations: (a) scheduled task did not fire (cron/scheduler issue); (b) task fired but failed silently before reaching the log-append step (worse — would mean error handling lost the failure context); (c) the 48-hour gating policy in the task spec ("new backup created only if 48+ hours since last") suppressed tonight's run since the last attempt was at 2026-05-03 04:17 and tonight's R3.17 sync (~04:10) fires before the next eligible 04:10 trigger. Most likely explanation: (a) since the prior 2026-05-03 entry is a FAILED entry (not a SUCCESS), the 48-hour gating from successful-run timestamp does not apply; the task should have fired and produced a 2026-05-04 entry. **R3.15-noted REGRESSED status holds; not yet re-confirmed by tonight's 04:10 trigger.** Status of R3.15-noted REGRESSED carry-forward holds informationally pending tonight's actual 04:10 run that may post a new entry after R3.17 sync time. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.15/R3.16 (REGRESSED holds; tonight's 04:10 trigger not yet confirmed).** Action required from Will: re-add the OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory (or its parent) via the Cowork chat-box "+" button so it appears under the workspace mount alongside `ECQ Development`. Until then daily backup task will continue to no-op with FAILED entries on every run, and the spec corpus is NOT being backed up to cloud storage as intended. |
| All R3.16 carry-forward items unchanged | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient with 6 active files including A-52 R0.6.3); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 3 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1); A-52 R0.6.3 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation actively warranted (S-9 log strengthened in R3.14, unchanged through R3.17). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.16.** No state change on the carry-forward items. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.16 (auto-detected 2026-05-04 ~03:13 by nightly sync — first pass of the day)

(R3.16 anomaly section was not formally listed under §10 at R3.16-generation time; the R3.16 narrative covering the 4 new structural changes — A-52 R0.6.3 supersession + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation + S-11 carry-forward REGRESSED status — is documented in the §12 changelog R3.16 entry below. R3.17 sync preserves this gap rather than backfilling per the constraint that auto pass should not invent rows for anomalies it did not directly detect.)

### New anomalies detected in R3.15 (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~16:00 by nightly sync — third pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| NEW addendum DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md in DOC23 Addenda subfolder | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 15:51, size 241,604 bytes — large file at ~168% of A-50 R0.3's 143,665 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, Natural Task Invocation, and Self-Improving Task Design", **R0.6.1 Merge-Audit Cleaned Unified Draft**, dated 2026-05-03, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.1 merge-audit cleaned version combining R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft and R0.5 Audit-Complete Merge Pack source." Title expanded from R0.3 — adds "Natural Task Invocation" as a new fifth named scope term. Source merge per §0: uses A-50 R0.3 as base + folds R0.5 audit-complete merge pack source into a single unified draft. Adds: natural saved-task invocation; deeper DOC72 task-memory integration; telemetry spine; artifact/output intake; Task Blueprint refinements; template/preset intelligence; Task Agent education / TKP; task-design self-learning loops; DOC24 capability/runtime routing; OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment; unified prompt improvement; prompt-evaluation tasks; cross-doc seams. **Supersedes A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5.** New row A-51 added in §4.A6 with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.15.** Action needed: human classification + disposition. **A-51 should likely be the canonical DOC23 Addenda B going forward** since A-50 R0.3 was used as base document and R0.5 was a transitional merge-pack. R0.6.1's title expansion to include "Natural Task Invocation" reflects substantive new architecture beyond R0.3's scope. |
| A-50 R0.3 file moved to NEW intra-subfolder archive (first time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive) | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` no longer in active DOC23 Addenda subfolder; new path `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` (mtime preserved 2026-05-02 19:36 across move; size unchanged 143,665 bytes). Disposition: superseded by A-51 R0.6.1 — A-50 R0.3 was the base document for the R0.6.1 merge pass per its own §0 source-merge declaration. **NEW intra-subfolder archive pattern in R3.15:** Will created `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (folder mtime 2026-05-03 15:52) — **first time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive subfolder.** This differs from the global `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archival convention used for all prior archive moves. A-50 alias row in §A6 annotated for file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive, mirroring A-44's R3.12 archival pattern (which used the global archive). | **NEW in R3.15 (deferred-archival-now-executed + new archival pattern).** Action needed: (1) human-confirm intra-subfolder archive pattern is intentional going forward (vs sending to global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`); (2) human-decide whether the registry should treat both archive locations symmetrically or whether intra-subfolder archives have different operational semantics (e.g., scoped-to-track archives that don't pollute the global archive); (3) consider applying the same intra-subfolder pattern retroactively to other Addenda subfolders (DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda) for consistency, OR keep the new pattern restricted to DOC23 Addenda. |
| Briefly-extant R0.5 file (created and archived in same window) | `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_R0_5_AUDIT_COMPLETE_MERGE_PACK_TASK_INVOCATION_TA_PROMPT_EVAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 15:24, size 103,376 bytes) detected only in the new intra-subfolder archive — never had its own master spec list row (created and archived in same window between R3.14 ~04:05 and R3.15 ~16:00). Per its filename: was the audit-complete merge pack adding task invocation, TA (Task Agent) education, prompt evaluation. Per A-51 R0.6.1's source-merge declaration, R0.5 content was folded into R0.6.1. Sync did NOT add a post-hoc row per task constraint that auto pass should not invent rows for files no longer present in active scan. | **NEW in R3.15 (informational only).** Action needed: optionally add post-hoc row for R0.5 with `file-moved-to-archive` annotation for completeness, OR accept the gap (per task constraint that auto pass should not invent rows for files no longer present at scan time). Deferred to next manual sweep. Mirrors the R3.12 briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1 pattern. |
| MAJOR S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSION: RESOLVED → PERSISTENT FAILURE | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime 2026-05-02 10:47 → 2026-05-03 04:17, size 4,422 → 5,548 bytes (~25%). New entry at 2026-05-03 11:17 UTC (04:17 local) records **fourth consecutive scheduled-task failure**. Per the new entry: "Task spec was updated 2026-05-02 to indicate the OneDrive folder is now connected to Cowork, but the bash sandbox mount at `/sessions/jolly-upbeat-brown/mnt/` still exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, and `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present. Per task spec, exited without fallback to local-only paths." The connection from 2026-05-02 either did not persist across sessions or pointed to a different folder. **R3.12 RESOLVED carry-forward is now FORMALLY REGRESSED back to "persistent failure" condition.** R3.14 had flagged the missing 04:10 entry as undetermined (likely 48-hour gating policy); R3.15 confirms it was actually a regression — tonight's 04:17 entry is a FAILED entry, not a SUCCESS validation of the fix. | **REGRESSED in R3.15 (carry-forward reopens).** Action required from Will: re-add the OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory (or its parent) via the Cowork chat-box "+" button so it appears under the workspace mount alongside `ECQ Development`. Until then daily backup task will continue to no-op with FAILED entries on every run, and the spec corpus is NOT being backed up to cloud storage as intended. R3.12's RESOLVED status is REVERSED. |
| S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime + size tick | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-05-02 11:09 → 2026-05-03 04:10 (size 8,501 → 14,177 bytes, ~67% growth — additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Row S-10 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.15 sync.** No human action required. |
| All R3.14 carry-forward items unchanged (with one new color and one regression) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 6 active files including A-51 the new B-track entry, plus a 2-file intra-subfolder archive); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; A-51 + A-50 alias classification pending; B-track vs A-track structural reorganization within §4.A6 pending; DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; OpenClaw release-alignment recommendation actively warranted (S-9 log strengthened). **NEW REGRESSION**: S-11 BACKUP_LOG R3.12 RESOLVED status REVERSED — fourth consecutive failure tonight. **NEW PATTERN COLOR**: intra-subfolder archive convention introduced in R3.15 may merit retroactive application to other Addenda subfolders. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.14 (with S-11 regression + new intra-subfolder archive pattern).** No state change on the other items. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.14 (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~04:05 by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Re-confirmation pass — no spec-folder structural drift | No new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (any tracked subfolder including DOC23 Addenda which had structural drift in R3.13), or `Operations Docs/`. No archive movements of operative specs. Counts of 6 / 4 / 5 / 3 / 3 / 7 / 2 across DOC23 / DOC20 / DOC24 / DOC72 / DOC73 / Integrated / CD Cross subfolders unchanged from R3.13. | **NEW in R3.14 (informational only).** No human action required. |
| OpenClaw 2026.5.2 released — alignment slipping further behind (BEHIND-by-2 → BEHIND-by-3) | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-03 03:44 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.2 (released 2026-05-02 — first 2026.5.x stable)**. DOC11 R15 R2 amendment proposal (A-36) covers through 2026.4.26; gap is now 3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 were not published as stable per GitHub tags API — those exist only as betas). 2026.5.2 lands plugin externalization architecture (ACPX behind `@openclaw/acpx`, diagnostics OpenTelemetry behind `@openclaw/diagnostics-otel`, broad npm/ClawHub publishing prep), descriptor-first platform tool planner with cached plugin tool descriptors, ClawPack metadata flowing through install/onboarding/doctor-repair/channel-setup, `openclaw gateway restart --force / --wait <duration>`, `threadBindings.spawnSessions` consolidation replacing split subagent/ACP toggles, provider-native web search reflecting configured provider, Grok 4.3 default xAI chat. **Per S-9 log notes: 2026.5.2 introduces a meaningful architectural shift in plugin packaging (npm-first cutover, externalized ACPX/diagnostics-otel, ClawPack artifact metadata) that pre-empts several DOC11 R15 R2 plugin-runtime rows and broadens DOC4 plugin architecture obligations — strong candidate for promoting from a single-release roll-forward to a deeper amendment refresh.** S-9 log recommendation strengthened from "informational only" (R3.11/R3.12/R3.13) to "actively warranted": author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + promoting 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now, plus a companion next-R of the running list. | **NEW in R3.14 (recommendation strengthened).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment (would become A-? row in §4.A1; A-1 R1 + A-36 R2 would both be candidates for archival once R3 lands) and a new R of the running spec update list. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8) — large catch-up writes | Multiple state-tracker mtime + size advances reflecting R3.13 sync's post-write updates plus tonight's auto-refresh task: (a) S-3 SPEC_STATE.md 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-05-03 03:14 (size 19,169 → 25,817 bytes; R3.13 wrote A-50 row + S-9/S-10 row updates that had been deferred across multiple stale R3.x cycles); (b) S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-05-03 03:16 (size 14,478 → 35,042 bytes; ~142% growth — much larger because file had been stale across multiple R3.x cycles before R3.13 catch-up rewrite added all post-R3.6 addenda rows A-38 through A-50); (c) S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md 2026-05-02 03:21 → 2026-05-03 03:23 (size 56,692 → 62,827 bytes; R3.13 sync narrative entry appended); (d) S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 2026-05-02 11:02 → 2026-05-03 04:04 (size 32,292 → 37,316 bytes — fifth auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Rows in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.14 sync.** No human action required. |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED — tonight's 04:10 scheduled run did not log an entry | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime 2026-05-02 10:46 unchanged from R3.12/R3.13. The daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task is supposed to run at 04:10 daily; tonight's scheduled run did not produce a SUCCESS entry validating R3.12's RESOLVED status nor a FAILED entry regressing it. Three possible explanations: (a) scheduled task did not fire (cron/scheduler issue); (b) task fired but failed silently before reaching the log-append step (worse — would mean error handling lost the failure context); (c) the 48-hour gating policy in the task spec ("new backup created only if 48+ hours since last") suppressed tonight's run since the manual seed SUCCESS at 2026-05-02 17:46 was only ~10 hours before tonight's 04:10 trigger — most likely explanation given the file's append-only convention. The R3.12-noted RESOLVED status holds informationally but is NOT yet validated by an autonomous-success path log entry; that validation is now deferred to the next 04:10 run that fires (next eligible per 48-hour gate: 2026-05-03 17:46 or later). | **NEW in R3.14 (carry-forward downgrade).** Action needed: monitor for next 04:10 BACKUP_LOG entry; if 2026-05-04 04:10 run produces a SUCCESS entry, the R3.12 resolution is fully validated. If it produces a FAILED entry, the SKILL.md path-resolution update needs further investigation. If neither (third consecutive missed log), the scheduler / task wiring itself needs investigation independent of the path issue. |
| All R3.13 carry-forward items unchanged (with one new color) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 6 active files including A-50 the new B-track entry); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 classification pending; B-track vs A-track structural reorganization within §4.A6 pending; DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows + briefly-extant V1 files. **NEW COLOR**: OpenClaw release-alignment recommendation strengthens from informational to actively warranted — see new anomaly row above. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.13 (with strengthened recommendation on the OpenClaw alignment item).** No state change on the other items. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.13 (auto-detected 2026-05-03 ~03:10 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| NEW addendum DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md in DOC23 Addenda subfolder | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 02:36, size 143,665 bytes — large file). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, and Self-Improving Task Design", **R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft**, dated 2026-05-03, parent doc DOC23 R3.1, status "Draft for architect review". Per §0.1 normative status: "end-state architectural draft. It is not an implementation phase plan." Companion docs per its own header: DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 (= A-47), DOC24 R3, DOC72 R5.73, DOC25 V2.0, DOC73 V1.5.1, DOC8 v1.11.4, DOC24 Addendum A BDSM v6.4, DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 (= A-35), EC Core Addendum A V3.3, OP-A V3.7. Predecessor R0.1 (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_1.md`) already in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` — the auto pass did not detect the R0.1 → R0.3 ship (R0.1 was archived before R3.12 ran; no R0.2 file detected in either active or archive folder). New row A-50 added in §4.A6 with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.13.** Action needed: human classification + disposition. **This is the FIRST DOC23 Addenda B entry** — opens a brand-new track parallel to DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization. Naming convention now establishes "DOC23 Addenda A" = Task Optimization (Experiments / Judges / Prompt Optimization) and "DOC23 Addenda B" = Task Intelligence / Memory / Observability / Self-Improving Task Design. May warrant Master Spec List structural reorganization to group both A-track and B-track DOC23 Addenda rows distinctly within §4.A6 in next manual sweep. |
| Mtime ticks on R3.12-detected addenda (sizes unchanged — likely live edits or touch operations) | A-47 R4.1 V2 mtime 12:34 → 19:34 (size 154,930 unchanged); A-48 R5/R6 Deferral V2 mtime 10:58 → 17:58 (size 30,631 unchanged); A-49 Card Integration Map V2 mtime 10:58 → 17:58 (size 23,341 unchanged). All three sizes byte-for-byte unchanged from R3.12, suggesting `touch` operations or content-preserving edits (e.g., trailing-newline normalization). Rows in §A6 mtime annotations not refreshed in this pass (the mtime ticks are documented here in §10 narrative; §A6 row notes preserved verbatim from R3.12). | **NEW in R3.13 (informational only).** No human action required unless one of the three was actually edited and warrants attention. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-8 / S-10 only) | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-05-02 04:02 → 2026-05-02 11:02 (size 32,292 unchanged — late-morning auto-refresh tick after R3.12's read; size identical so likely touch-only). `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-04-30 04:04 → 2026-05-02 11:09 (size grew 4,474 → 8,501 bytes — additional auto-refresh entries; S-10 row mtime in §7 had been stale across multiple prior passes — refreshed). Other operations files (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG / S-11 BACKUP_LOG / S-7 OP-A V3.7) all unchanged. Rows S-8 + S-10 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.13 sync.** No human action required. |
| All R3.12 carry-forward items unchanged (except S-11 RESOLVED status holds) | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 6 active files: A-45 / A-46 / A-47 / A-48 / A-49 / A-50); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; OneDrive backup S-11 RESOLVED status holds (no nightly backup ran between R3.12 and R3.13 — autonomous-success validation pending next 04:10 daily run); OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind (DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal not yet authored); DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse opportunity continues to grow (now 7 archived rows: A-40 / A-41 / A-42 / A-43 / A-44 + briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1 = 7 entries that could collapse into pointer rows in next manual sweep). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.12.** No state change. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.12 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 ~16:00 by nightly sync — third pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| NEW addendum DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V2.md in DOC23 Addenda subfolder | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 12:34, size 154,930 bytes — large file, ~3.7× the prior A-44 R4.0 (1) at 41,659 bytes). Per file header: R4.1 V2 (Draft), 2026-05-02, status "Draft — V2 closes 25 row gaps + 2 deviations from V1 audit. Pending Will's review against V5 adjudication card. Compiles into DOC23 R3.2." V2 supersedes a briefly-extant V1 (V1 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1.md` mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 103,002 bytes — created and archived in same window per archive listing). Adds substantial contract closure items, schema cleanup, safety items, minimum context-management subset to make Pattern 7 runnable. Reserves DSPy + Optimization Platform + Human Eval + Code-Based Scorers + full Context Management Proposal V1 substrate + Campaigns/Dataset Library for R5+. New row A-47 added in §4.A6 with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.12.** Action needed: human classification + disposition. Note: A-47 cleans up the DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 → R4.0 (1) → R4.1 V1 → R4.1 V2 chain; in next manual sweep the now-six-rows-deep archived/superseded chain (A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 from R3.9 + A-44 from R3.12 + the not-given-a-row R4.1 V1) could be collapsed into a single pointer entry. |
| NEW addendum DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V2.md in DOC23 Addenda subfolder | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 30,631 bytes). Per file header: V2 status "Pre-adjudication — will be revised after Will fills the V5 Decision column to V3 (post-adjudication)." Companion to `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_ADJUDICATION_CARD_V5.md` (V5 = 238 rows, not registered in master spec list — lives in not-yet-tracked location). V2 supersedes a briefly-extant V1 (V1 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V1.md` mtime 2026-05-02 09:58, size 24,682 bytes — created and archived in same window). Three top-level sections: §1 R5 work plan grouped by functional area A–N (DSPy + Optimization Platform §1.A is largest R5 work package — 23 rows + R5 implementation from scratch); §2 R6 work plan (4 items); §3 external documents that compile into R5/R6. Cross-doc obligations OB-A14 through OB-A18 flagged with responsible doc owner. New row A-48 added in §4.A6 with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.12.** Action needed: human classification + disposition. May warrant `STAGING / SUPPORT` classification rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` since file is explicitly a work-plan staging buffer rather than an amendment. |
| NEW addendum DOC23_ADDENDA_A_CONTEXT_MGMT_PROPOSAL_V1_TO_CARD_INTEGRATION_MAP_V2.md in DOC23 Addenda subfolder | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_CONTEXT_MGMT_PROPOSAL_V1_TO_CARD_INTEGRATION_MAP_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 23,341 bytes). **Per file header: explicitly a meta/navigation document** — "A section-by-section accounting of the Context Management Proposal V1 [A-45] against the V5 adjudication card. For each section of the proposal, this map tells you: where (if anywhere) it lives in the card, what release it's scheduled for, and whether it's tracked at row level or only by reference." Date 2026-05-02. Status "Complete. All proposal spec content is accounted for — either as a card row or a deferral list entry." V2 changes per file: V1 identified 5 candidate elevations and 6 calibration items as work needed in V5 of the card; card V5 absorbed all 5 elevations as rows #234–#238; calibration items moved to deferral list §6 (= A-48). Closed-loop integration map between A-45 and the V5 card. New row A-49 added in §4.A6 with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.12.** Action needed: human classification + disposition. **Like A-34 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1, this file is non-normative by purpose — it modifies nothing.** Likely needs reclassification to `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / NAVIGATION / REFERENCE` rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM`; consider relocating out of `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` to a top-level `Reference/` or `Navigation/` folder once the convention exists. |
| A-44 R4.0 (1) moved from DOC23 Addenda subfolder to archive | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` no longer in active DOC23 Addenda subfolder; new path `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime preserved 2026-04-30 23:44 across both moves, size unchanged 41,659 bytes). Disposition: superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2 — A-44 was the input to the R4.1 V1 → R4.1 V2 audit pass, now superseded by both. R3.9 had previously moved A-44 from §A1 root to the new §A6 subfolder treating it as canonical R4.0; R3.12 archives it as R4.1 V2 supersedes it. A-44 alias row in §A6 annotated for file-moved-to-archive, mirroring A-43's R3.9 archival pattern. | **NEW in R3.12 (deferred-archival-now-executed).** Action needed: human-confirm archival was intentional; if so, the registry can collapse the A-44 alias row into a "DOC23 Task Optimization R4.0 (1) superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2" pointer in next manual sweep. |
| Briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1 files (created and archived in same window) | Two files appeared in active DOC23 Addenda subfolder briefly between R3.11 (10:00) and R3.12 (16:00) and were then moved to archive in the same window: (1) `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 103,002 bytes — R4.1 V1) — superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2 (mtime 12:34) at the V1→V2 audit-pass step; archived path `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1.md`. (2) `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 09:58, size 24,682 bytes — V1) — superseded by A-48 V2 (mtime 10:58); archived path `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V1.md`. Neither file got a master-spec-list row of its own (created and archived too quickly to be detected by an intermediate sync run). | **NEW in R3.12 (informational only).** Action needed: optionally add post-hoc rows for R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1 with `file-moved-to-archive` annotations for completeness, OR accept the gap (per task constraint that auto pass should not invent rows for files no longer present at scan time). Deferred to next manual sweep. |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime + size refresh: persistent-failure → RESOLVED | `BACKUP_LOG.md` advanced 2026-05-01 04:17 → 2026-05-02 10:47, size 2,366 → 4,422 bytes (~87%) across two new entries. (1) Third consecutive `failed` scheduled-task entry at 2026-05-02 04:17 local (UTC 11:17) — same root cause. (2) **First SUCCESS entry — manual seed backup at 2026-05-02 10:46 local (UTC 17:46)** — archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` (4.84 MB compressed, 16 MB source). Per the success entry's notes: Will mounted the OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared folder via Cowork's chat-box "+" connector at `/sessions/<id>/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/`; manual run from interactive session succeeded; the scheduled task SKILL.md has been updated to use the workspace-mount path resolution so future autonomous runs will work. **Carry-forward anomaly tracked since R3.6 is now RESOLVED.** | **RESOLVED in R3.12.** Action needed: monitor next scheduled 04:10 daily run to confirm autonomous-success path works; if next scheduled run also succeeds, the resolution is fully validated and the carry-forward can be permanently retired. If it fails, the SKILL.md update needs further investigation. |
| OpenClaw release alignment (carry-forward from R3.11) | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-02 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is 2026.4.29 (was 2026.4.27 at R3.5 first entry). DOC11 R15 R2 amendment proposal (A-36) covers through 2026.4.26; gap is 2 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29; 2026.4.28 was not published). S-9 log recommendation: author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment + new R of running spec update list. No R3 amendment file authored yet. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.11 (informational only).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 releases. |
| All R3.11 carry-forward items unchanged | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 5 active files); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.11.** No state change other than the OneDrive backup item which is now resolved. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.11 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Re-confirmation pass | No structural drift since R3.10 (generated ~03:16 the same morning). No new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (any tracked subfolder including the new DOC23 Addenda subfolder), or `Operations Docs/`. No archive movements. No state-tracker mtime changes other than the three logs noted below. | **NEW in R3.11 (informational only).** No human action required. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-5 / S-8 / S-9) | `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) → 2026-05-02 03:21, size 40,253 → 56,692 bytes — append by R3.10's own sync run (post-write entry logging R3.10 detections); large narrative entry covering 4 archive moves + new DOC23 Addenda subfolder + 2 new addenda + state-tracker backfill + versioned-snapshot backfill. `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) → 2026-05-02 03:47, size 2,538 → 4,039 bytes — new 2026-05-02 entry advances "latest stable release" reference from 2026.4.27 to 2026.4.29 (2026-04-29); gap status BEHIND by 2 releases. `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) → 2026-05-02 04:02, size 25,227 → 32,292 bytes — fourth auto-refresh tick. All informational; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.11 sync.** No human action required. |
| OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-02 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now 2026.4.29 (was 2026.4.27 in the R3.5 first entry). DOC11 R15 R2 amendment proposal (A-36) covers through 2026.4.26; gap is now 2 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29; 2026.4.28 was not published). Recommendation in the log: next R of `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` plus an R3 of DOC11 R15 amendment proposal to fold 2026.4.29 in and promote 2026.4.27 from "watch" to "include-now". No R3 amendment file authored yet — recommendation is informational only. | **NEW in R3.11 (informational).** Action needed: human-decide whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 (would become A-? row in §4.A1; A-1 R1 + A-36 R2 would both be candidates for archival once R3 lands), and a new R of the running spec update list. |
| R3.10 versioned snapshot present (informational) | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.10.md` (220,299 bytes, mtime 2026-05-02 03:16) was correctly saved by the R3.10 sync run (matches alias content at R3.10 generation time). Pattern of "alias bump misses versioned snapshot save" that recurred in R3.5/R3.6 → R3.7 backfill and R3.9 → R3.10 backfill did NOT recur in R3.10 — R3.10 saved its versioned snapshot alongside the alias write. R3.11 versioned snapshot `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.11.md` is saved by this R3.11 run for the same reason. | **NEW in R3.11 (informational).** No human action required. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| All R3.10 carry-forward items unchanged | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; OneDrive backup S-11 unchanged from R3.10 (no nightly run between R3.10 and R3.11; no third `failed` entry yet); DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse deferred. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.10.** No state change. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.10 (auto-detected 2026-05-02 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| NEW addendum DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md in DOC23 Addenda subfolder | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 00:31, size 22,818 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Red Line — Sequential Re-Prompt System", date 2026-05-01, status "Draft addendum for compilation into DOC23 R3.2." Affects DOC23 §3.2.1 (step.agent_task), §3.2.8 (step.coding), §6.5.2 (agent task execution), §6.5.8 (coding execution), §4.5 (output popups), §4.8 (validation). New row A-46 added in §4.A6. | **NEW in R3.10.** Action needed: human classification + disposition. Note: A-46 targets DOC23 R3.2 compilation revision while A-45 (also DOC23-related) targets DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 — implies parallel-track evolution of operative DOC23 spec alongside its addenda. |
| NEW mockup variant Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx | `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx` (mtime 2026-05-01 21:54, size 180,080 bytes — ~22% larger than V11.0's 147,393 bytes). The "ALT_A" suffix suggests parallel A/B variant rather than supersession; both V11.0 and V11_ALT_A coexist. Likely tied to the DOC23 addendum cluster shipping in same window. Not formally tracked in master spec list §3-§7 (mockups live in design folder); SPEC_STATE.md Build Surface section updated. | **NEW in R3.10 (informational only).** Action needed: human-confirm the "ALT_A" naming convention is intentional (parallel variant) vs supersession-with-typo, and whether this mockup should be promoted to the canonical DOC23 mockup or held as exploration. |
| R3.9 versioned snapshot was missing | The R3.9 alias bump (2026-05-01 ~23:14) registered version revision in alias content but did NOT save a versioned snapshot file. R3.10 sync backfills the snapshot as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.9.md` from the pre-bump alias content. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (acknowledged carry-forward from R3.7 — preserved only as narrative within R3.6.md). | **RESOLVED in R3.10 for R3.9 (backfilled).** Carry-forward unchanged for R3.5 (still missing). Pattern carries forward: alias bumps occasionally fail to save versioned snapshots; nightly sync's backfill behavior catches them on the next run. |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11) | Auto-task neighbours touched all four state-tracker files: `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) → 2026-05-01 11:17 (second `failed` entry); `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) → 2026-05-01 10:42 (additional release-alignment entry); `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) → 2026-05-01 11:00 (third auto-refresh tick); `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) → 2026-05-01 11:04. All informational; status fields preserved. | **Mtime/Notes refreshed in §7 R3.10 sync.** No human action required. **Carry-forward:** OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox — count of consecutive failures now 2; Will needs to add OneDrive Personal folder to Cowork's connected directories. |
| State-tracker backfill of R3.9 changes | The R3.9 alias bump (2026-05-01 ~23:14) registered DOC23 archive moves + new subfolder + new addendum in alias content but did NOT flow them through to SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md trackers (state files mtime 2026-05-01 10:09 / 10:11 — predate R3.9 alias bump). R3.10 sync corrects: ADDENDA_STATE.md rows A-38/A-39/A-40/A-41 annotated as file-moved-to-archive; A-42 annotated as relocated to new DOC23 Addenda subfolder; new §A.6 DOC23 Addenda subsection added with rows A-43 + A-44 (state-file numbering). SPEC_STATE.md Master Spec List row updated to R3.10; S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 mtime/Notes updated; Build Surface section updated for new V11_ALT_A mockup. | **RESOLVED in R3.10 (backfilled).** Pattern of "alias bump misses tracker flow-through" recurs from R3.5/R3.6 → R3.7 backfill; R3.9 → R3.10 backfill is the same shape. Recommendation: human-investigate whether the alias-bump pathway can be modified to include tracker flow-through automatically. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.9 (auto-detected 2026-05-01 ~10:30 by nightly sync — fourth pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Four DOC23 Task Optimization files moved en masse to archive | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` (A-40, mtime 2026-04-30 13:43, 61,420 bytes), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` (A-41, mtime 2026-04-30 16:40, 24,266 bytes), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (A-42, mtime 2026-04-30 17:57, 108,578 bytes), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` (A-43, mtime 2026-04-30 22:50, 52,949 bytes) all moved from active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. R3.7-R3.8 had flagged all four for likely archival (especially R3.8 changelog "Things this auto pass deferred for human review: Disposition / archival decisions on A-40/A-41/A-43 supersession chain"). Note: A-42, A-43 mtimes appear slightly older than R3.7's recorded values — possibly filesystem-touch artifacts during move OR R3.7's mtime read was inaccurate. Rows A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 in §4.A1 annotated with file-moved markers. | **NEW in R3.9 (deferred-disposition-now-executed from R3.7).** Action needed: human-confirm archival was intentional; if so, the registry can collapse the four annotated rows into a single "DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0/Running-Additions superseded by A-44 R4.0 (1)" pointer in next manual sweep. |
| NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder created with relocated A-44 + new A-45 | New subfolder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/` (folder mtime 2026-05-01 10:27). Contains 2 files: (1) `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` — same file registered as A-44 in R3.7 at the addenda root, now relocated here (mtime preserved 2026-04-30 23:44, size unchanged 41,659 bytes); (2) `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_CONTEXT_MANAGEMENT_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 10:26, size 53,884 bytes — entirely new file) — Judge Context Management Proposal V1 by Claude Opus 4.7, target compilation revision DOC23 Addenda A R4.1, closes per-dimension context-duplication gap flagged by two same-day red team reviews (40 + 34 findings). New §4.A6 subsection added; A-44 row in §A1 annotated with file-moved-to-§A6 marker; new row A-45 added in §A6 for the context management proposal. Subfolder is structurally analogous to existing DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda subfolders. | **NEW in R3.9.** Action needed: (1) human-classify A-45 (likely PROPOSED ADDENDUM final disposition); (2) confirm A-44 (kept active and relocated) is canonical R4.0 vs A-43 (no-suffix file, archived) — the move pattern strongly implies A-44 is canonical; (3) update nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include the new `DOC23 Addenda/` path (this gap also persists for the DOC73 Addenda subfolder added in R2.9). |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime + size refresh; second consecutive failure | mtime advanced 2026-04-30 04:16 → 2026-05-01 04:17; size grew 1,159 → 2,366 bytes (~2x). Second consecutive `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` entry written at 2026-05-01 11:16 (UTC) with same root cause as 2026-04-30 entry. Per the 2026-05-01 entry's notes: `mkdir -p` on `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` failed with "Permission denied" when trying to create `/Users`; mount only exposes `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`; per task spec constraint #4 did NOT fall back to local-only paths. Will needs to add the OneDrive Personal folder (or parent `~/Library/CloudStorage/`) to Cowork's connected directories. Row S-11 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status preserved. | **NEW in R3.9 (informational).** Action needed: Will to resolve sandbox/permissions issue OR adjust backup task to use a sandbox-visible destination path; until then daily backup task will continue to no-op with `failed` entries on every run. Carry-forward from R3.6 with the failure now confirmed as a persistent (not transient) condition. |
| Carry-forward DOC11 R15 R1/R2 active-folder coexistence | Unchanged from R3.8 — A-1 (R1) and A-36 (R2) both still present in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.5.** Action needed: human-archival decision. |
| Carry-forward OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy | Unchanged from R3.8 — still two copies. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.5 (informational).** |
| Carry-forward DOC73 Addenda subfolder not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list | Unchanged from R3.8; now joined by the NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder which has the same gap. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R2.9.** Both subfolders (`DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` and `DOC23 Addenda/`) are treated as in-scope by recent auto passes but neither is formally listed in the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list. |
| Carry-forward DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path | Unchanged from R3.8. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R2.8.** |
| Carry-forward versioned-snapshot R3.5 still missing | Unchanged from R3.8 — `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.5.md` still does not exist as a discrete versioned snapshot file. Narrated only via R3.6.md / R3.7.md / R3.8.md / R3.9.md (this file's predecessor) narrative sections. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.7.** Action needed: human-decide whether R3.5 needs reconstruction or the gap is acceptable. |
| Carry-forward versioned-snapshot R3.8.md vs alias content | The R3.8 versioned snapshot file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.8.md` was saved when R3.8 was generated (matches alias content at R3.8 generation time, both at 178,030 bytes). R3.9 sync does NOT save a new R3.9 snapshot (per task spec which writes only to the canonical alias file `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md`); R3.9 versioned snapshot can be backfilled by next sync run if Will wants discrete per-revision archive files. | **NEW in R3.9 (informational).** Action needed: human-decide whether to backfill `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.9.md` from current alias content before R3.10 generation. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.7 (auto-detected 2026-05-01 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` newly present | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 23:40, size 24,266 bytes — ~60% smaller than R2.0). Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) per filename pattern. New row A-41 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.7.** Action needed: human-classify A-41; decide whether A-40 (R2.0) should be moved to archive (mirroring DOC72 CSA R1 → R2 pattern). Note R4.0 (A-43) shipped within hours — A-41 likely already superseded. |
| `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` newly present | New large staging file (mtime 2026-05-01 00:57, size 108,578 bytes) appeared in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Per file header: "Running Additions for R3.0 — Staging document for changes to compile into the next revision of DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization)." Pattern: items added during iterative discussion and compiled in batch into next addendum revision. New row A-42 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.7.** Action needed: human-classify A-42; consider promoting to STAGING / SUPPORT classification rather than PROPOSED ADDENDUM since file is explicitly a staging buffer rather than a proposed amendment. Also: header references "for R3.0" but R4.0 already shipped — file may need re-targeting. |
| `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` newly present | New file (mtime 2026-05-01 05:50, size 52,949 bytes). Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) and A-41 (R3.0) per filename pattern. New row A-43 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.7.** Action needed: human-classify A-43 as the latest DOC23 Task Optimization revision; decide archival of A-40/A-41 (mirrors DOC11 R15 R1/R2 and DOC72 CSA R1/R2 supersession patterns). Three revisions in <16 hours suggests rapid iteration cycle — Will may want to consolidate/freeze before further bumps. |
| `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` newly present | New file (mtime 2026-05-01 06:44, size 41,659 bytes — DIFFERENT from A-43's 52,949 bytes). Filename "(1)" suffix is the macOS download-collision pattern. `diff -q` confirms files DIFFER. Both coexist in active folder. New row A-44 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.7.** Action needed: human-decide which file is canonical R4.0 — A-43 (no suffix, 52,949 bytes, mtime 05:50) or A-44 (suffix, 41,659 bytes, mtime 06:44). The newer-mtime / smaller-size file (A-44) could be a tighter rewrite OR the older-mtime / larger file (A-43) could be the more complete one — content inspection needed. Sync did NOT delete or rename either file per task constraint #1. |
| State-tracker backfill: A-38, S-9, S-10, S-11 missing from SPEC_STATE/ADDENDA_STATE | Prior R3.5 / R3.6 alias bumps registered S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG, S-11 BACKUP_LOG, and A-38 DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 in the master spec list alias content but did NOT flow them through to SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md trackers. R3.7 sync corrects: SPEC_STATE.md adds rows for S-9/S-10/S-11; ADDENDA_STATE.md adds row for A-38 (and contemporaneously adds A-39/A-40/A-41/A-42 for today's drift). | **RESOLVED in R3.7 (mechanical backfill).** Action needed: verify SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md row contents on next human review pass. |
| Versioned-snapshot backfill: R3.5 / R3.6 master spec list snapshots missing | Prior R3.5 / R3.6 alias bumps registered version revisions in alias content but did NOT save versioned snapshot files. R3.7 sync saves the pre-bump alias content (which represented R3.6 state) as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.6.md`. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (only narrated within R3.6.md "R3.5 vs R3.4" section). | **PARTIALLY RESOLVED in R3.7.** Action needed: human-decide whether R3.5 needs reconstruction. Recommend acceptance of the gap given R3.5 → R3.6 → R3.7 changes are all narrated in subsequent versioned files. |
| Carry-forward DOC11 R15 R1/R2 active-folder coexistence | Unchanged from R3.6 — A-1 (R1) and A-36 (R2) both still present. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.5.** Action needed: human-archival decision. |
| Carry-forward OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy | Unchanged from R3.6. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.5 (informational).** |
| Carry-forward DOC73 Addenda subfolder not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list | Unchanged from R3.6. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R2.9.** |
| Carry-forward DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path | Unchanged from R3.6. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R2.8.** |
| Carry-forward OneDrive backup destination unreachable from sandbox | Unchanged from R3.6 — BACKUP_LOG.md continues to record `failed` entries on each scheduled backup attempt because OneDrive Personal cloud path is not visible to the bash sandbox. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.6.** Action needed: resolve sandbox/permissions issue OR adjust backup task to use a sandbox-visible destination path. Until then daily backup task continues to fail. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.6 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 by nightly sync — third pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` newly present in active addenda folder | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 13:43, size 61,420 bytes) appeared in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root folder. Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization: Experiments, Judges, and Prompt Optimization", R2.0 (Draft), dated 2026-04-02, parent document DOC23 R3.1, companion to Prop-A R6.3. Status header notes "not yet compiled into DOC23." Defines `system.experiment`, `step.judge`, and DSPy prompt optimization as DOC23 modules. New row A-40 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.6.** Action needed: human-classify A-40; decide whether this targets DOC23 R3.1 (the active R3.1 file referenced in the addendum's parent-doc field) or row 39b's pending re-classification target; coordinate with row 39b's eventual promotion if A-40 is to be compiled into DOC23 prior to R3.1's adoption. |
| `BACKUP_LOG.md` newly present in active `Operations Docs/` | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 04:16, size 1,159 bytes — small) appeared in active `Operations Docs/`. Append-only log of automated daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task. First entry 2026-04-30 11:16 (UTC) recorded `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` — `mkdir -p` on `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` failed with permission denied because the OneDrive Personal cloud path is not visible to the bash sandbox in this run; per task spec no fallback write to local-only paths was performed; source folder unchanged; retry on next scheduled run. New row S-11 added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.6.** Action needed: human-classify S-11 (treat as state-tracking artifact in same cluster as S-3/S-4/S-5/S-9/S-10); resolve the underlying sandbox/permissions issue so the OneDrive folder is reachable, OR adjust task to use a different destination path that is visible to the bash sandbox; until then the daily backup task will continue to fail and accumulate `failed` entries in this log. |
| Carry-forward DOC11 R15 R1/R2 active-folder coexistence | Unchanged from R3.5 — A-1 (`DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL.md`, R1) and A-36 (R2) both still present in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.5.** Action needed: human-decide whether A-1 should be moved to archive (mirroring A-8 PACER and A-25 DOC72 CSA R1 patterns). |
| Carry-forward OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy | Unchanged from R3.5 — two copies of same-size file (30,479 bytes each) remain in two locations. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.5 (informational).** Action needed: human-decide whether the addenda-folder copy is a duplicate or a divergent companion. Not blocking. |
| Carry-forward DOC73 Addenda subfolder not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list | Unchanged from R2.9 — subfolder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` was created 2026-04-27 22:50 and is treated as in-scope by recent auto passes (R2.9 onward, including R3.6) but is not formally listed in the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R2.9.** Action needed: human-update task SKILL.md to formally include the DOC73 subfolder. |
| Carry-forward DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path | Unchanged from R2.8 — registry row 27 + multiple §8 reading packs reference the old active-folder path; file is in `Subsumed Specs/`. | **CARRY-FORWARD from R2.8.** Action needed: human-retire row 27 and strip the file from §8 reading packs. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.5 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` newly present in active `Operations Docs/` | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 03:42, size 1,013 bytes — small) appeared in active `Operations Docs/`. Append-only log of nightly OpenClaw release-alignment checks. First entry 2026-04-30 10:42 (UTC) recorded gap status BEHIND by one release (covered through 2026.4.26 per DOC11 R15 R2 proposal A-36 vs latest stable 2026.4.27). New row S-9 added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.5.** Action needed: human-classify S-9; coordinate with A-1/A-36 (DOC11 R15 amendment proposals) — when R2 is promoted to include 2026.4.27 ("watch / conditional include" → include-now), this log should record that disposition. |
| `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` newly present in active `Operations Docs/` | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 04:04, size 1,947 bytes — small) appeared in active `Operations Docs/`. Append-only log accompanying RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md refreshes. First auto-refresh entry 2026-04-30 10:55 (UTC) records 13 per-doc updates including DOC11 R15 R2 promotion, DOC73 V1.6 RT prep cycle activation, DOC24 R3 RT Adjudication Card V1.1, Master Spec List R3.4, and S-9 OpenClaw Release Tracker Log first entry. New row S-10 added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.5.** Action needed: human-classify S-10; treat as state-tracking artifact in the same cluster as SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md / OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (all are auto-refresh tracker logs). |
| S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime + size refresh | File mtime advanced from 2026-04-29 19:05 to 2026-04-30 04:01; size grew from 15,496 bytes to 18,228 bytes (~18%). Per new companion log S-10, this file was promoted from manual-only to nightly-auto-refresh in this pass. Row S-8 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status preserved (`SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human classification). | **NEW in R3.5 (informational).** Action needed: none structural — content delta tracked in S-10 log. |
| State tracker files refreshed | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) mtime 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-04-30 03:08; size 19,169 → 21,993 bytes. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) mtime 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-04-30 03:09; size 14,478 → 20,040 bytes. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) mtime 2026-04-29 03:23 → 2026-04-30 03:20; size 29,727 → 40,253 bytes. All three are auto-refresh tracker files updated by this same nightly sync run. | **NEW in R3.5 (informational).** Action needed: none — mtime/size refreshes only; no row content changes. |
| Carry-forward DOC11 R15 R1/R2 active-folder coexistence | A-1 (`DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL.md`, R1) and A-36 (`DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md`) both still present in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Per S-9 OpenClaw Release Tracker Log first entry, R2 is the operative amendment proposal (covers through 2026.4.26 vs unversioned R1's earlier scope). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.4.** Action needed: human-decide whether A-1 should be moved to archive (mirroring A-8 PACER and A-25 DOC72 CSA R1 patterns). |
| Carry-forward OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy | Two copies of same-size file (30,479 bytes each) remain in two locations: `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (mtime 2026-04-13 19:57) and `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (mtime 2026-04-29 19:21 — touched in same window as A-36 R2 proposal). | **CARRY-FORWARD from R3.4 (informational).** Action needed: human-decide whether the addenda-folder copy is a duplicate or a divergent companion. Not blocking. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.4 (auto-detected 2026-04-30 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md` newly present | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 00:45, size 77,777 bytes — ~52% larger than R1's 51,307 bytes) appeared in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Supersedes A-1 (original DOC11 R15 amendment proposal). Both files remain in active folder. New row A-36 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.4.** Action needed: human-classify A-36; decide whether A-1 should be moved to archive (mirroring A-8 PACER pattern). |
| `DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R2.md` newly present; R1 moved to archive | New file (mtime 2026-04-29 18:28, size 83,554 bytes — ~71% larger than R1's 48,797 bytes) in active `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolder. Predecessor R1 file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. New row A-37 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder; A-25 (R1) annotated for file-moved. | **NEW in R3.4.** Action needed: human-classify A-37 (likely supersedes A-25 R1; CSA R2 is referenced as the origin context for the DOC73 §6.4 Mechanism 4 Rollup proposal A-38). |
| `DOC73_PROPOSAL_SECTION_6_4_MECHANISM_4_ROLLUP_V1.md` newly present | New file (mtime 2026-04-29 18:31, size 26,669 bytes) in active `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolder. Per file header: standalone handoff document targeting DOC73 V1.5.1 §6.4 Mechanism 4 (currently named but undefined). Origin: identified as a gap during CSA R2 (A-37) drafting. New row A-38 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.4.** Action needed: human-classify A-38; coordinate with A-37 (companion proposal). |
| `DOC73_V1_6_ADJUDICATION_CARD_ARCHITECT_NOTES_V1 (1).md` newly present | New file (mtime 2026-04-30 04:14, size 6,441 bytes — small file, 73 lines) in active `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` subfolder. Filename includes "(1)" suffix suggesting Will may have copied from Downloads. Likely architect notes / adjudication card for the upcoming DOC73 V1.5.1 → V1.6 red-team round. New row A-39 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.4.** Action needed: human-classify A-39 (likely a working note rather than a normative proposal). |
| `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` newly present in active `Operations Docs/` | New file (mtime 2026-04-29 19:05, size 15,496 bytes) in active `Operations Docs/`. Likely a Will-authored summary of recent work (2026-04-29 evening session). Not a tracker file. New row S-8 added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.4.** Action needed: human-classify S-8. |
| Carry-forward DOC16 anomalies #2 and #3 RESOLVED | `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` (anomaly #2) and `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` (anomaly #3) — both files no longer in active folder (moved to `Subsumed Specs/`). SPEC_STATE.md rows for these files REMOVED per task spec. Anomaly #1 (DOC16_R5_4 missing) was likely stale — the R5.4 file IS present in active folder (mtime 2026-04-09 22:47, size 245,927 bytes, hardlink count 2). | **RESOLVED in R3.4** for anomalies #2 and #3. Anomaly #1 status: file IS present; SPEC_STATE.md row mtime + Notes updated mechanically; master spec list row 30 judgment fields preserved — needs human review of R5.4 status (currently FUTURE / PLANNING DRAFT; file is present and active). |
| `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` mtime change | File in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (mtime 2026-04-29 19:21, size 30,479 bytes — same size as the operative-folder copy at 2026-04-13 19:57). Two copies of same-size file in two locations: one in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (untouched at Apr 13) and one in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` (mtime refreshed to Apr 29). Hardlink check inconclusive in this run. | **NEW in R3.4 (informational).** Action needed: human-decide whether the addenda-folder copy is a duplicate that should be removed, or whether it represents a divergent companion. Not blocking. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.2 (auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md` newly present | New file appeared in active folder 2026-04-29 04:36 (size 663,684 bytes — ~187 KB / ~39% larger than V1.4.1's 476 KB). Predecessor `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` (formerly registry row 43) moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. Placeholder row 43b created pending human reclassification. Substantive content delta from V1.4.1 not analyzed by auto pass. | **NEW in R3.2.** Action needed: human-classify V1.5.1 (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER given V1.4.1 was operative per architect 2026-04-26); retire row 43 (V1.4.1 → archived); update front-door pack item 17 (currently "DOC73 V1.4.1" — should be "DOC73 V1.5.1"); update reading packs that mention DOC73 V1.4.1; verify whether V1.5.1 dereferences `DOC25_IngestionResult` per CLAUDE.md note. |
| OP-A V3.7 newly present; V3.6 + entire V3.x cohort moved to archive | New file `DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_7.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 05:15, size 244,079 bytes). Active `Operations Docs/` now contains only V3.7. Files V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5, V3.6 all moved to `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` alongside V2. Companion patch document `OP_A_V3_6_TO_V3_7_PATCH_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 04:58, 83,154 bytes) sits in archive subfolder. | **NEW in R3.2.** Action needed: human-classify V3.7 (likely ACTIVE OPERATIONS FILE); update §7 row S-1 path (V2 → archive subfolder), supersede S-2 (V3.6) by S-2b (V3.7); decide whether the patch document warrants its own §7 row or remains a versioning artifact. |
| `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (no `_PROPOSAL_V*` suffix) newly present | New file (mtime 2026-04-29 08:32, size 193,966 bytes) appeared in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Filename drops `_PROPOSAL_V1` suffix → likely the post-RT consolidated R2.2. New row A-35 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.2.** Action needed: human-classify A-35; verify whether it consolidates A-2 (V1)/V2/V3, A-3 (Semantic Skills R2.1), and A-12 (Live Recording Upgrades) — all four rows show file-moved-to-archive in this pass. May warrant promotion to a numbered DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 final-spec status if Will treats this as the integration target rather than another proposal. |
| Five active-folder files moved to archive en masse | `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (A-2), `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_SEMANTIC SKILLS R2_1.md` (A-3), `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (A-12 — already in archive at R3.0; reaffirmed in R3.2), `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (A-31), `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md` (A-33) all now in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. A V3 of the DOC3 R11.3 R2.2 proposal (briefly present) is also archived. All affected rows annotated with file-moved markers. | **NEW in R3.2.** Action needed: retire annotated rows in next manual sweep; verify each file-moved annotation matches Will's archival intent; collapse A-2/A-3/A-12/A-33 into the A-35 entry once consolidation is confirmed. |
| `Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_0.jsx` newly present | New mockup (mtime 2026-04-28 04:16) appeared in `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/`. Likely the DOC23 R3.1 companion mockup (R3.1 mtime 2026-04-28 03:43 — same window). V10.4, V10.5, V10.8, V10.9 all remain alongside. SPEC_STATE.md Build Surface row updated. | **NEW in R3.2.** Action needed: human-confirm V11.0 supersedes V10.9; archive older mockup versions per project hygiene. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.1 (auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync — third pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Two `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL` versions in active folder | V1 (mtime 2026-04-28 13:57, size 33,664 bytes) and V1.1 (mtime 2026-04-28 15:48, size 38,285 bytes) both present in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. V1.1 explicitly supersedes V1 per its `Supersedes:` header field. New rows A-31 (V1) and A-32 (V1.1) added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. | **NEW in R3.1.** Action needed: human-classify both rows; decide whether V1 should be moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` (mirroring the A-8 PACER V1.0 pattern) or remain in active folder. |
| Two `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL` versions in active folder | V1 (A-2, mtime 2026-04-15) and V2 (mtime 2026-04-28 11:43, size 49,607 bytes) both present in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. V2 header indicates "Patch A applied" per 18-item red team adjudication. New row A-33 (V2) added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder; A-2 (V1) annotated for likely supersession. | **NEW in R3.1.** Action needed: human-classify A-33; decide whether V1 should be moved to archive or remain pending Addenda A R2.2 incorporation. |
| `ELNOR_SEARCH_ARCHITECTURE_REFERENCE_R1.md` newly present in active addenda folder | New file (mtime 2026-04-28 15:27, size 23,818 bytes) appeared in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Per its own header it is a **non-normative reference document** ("Reference document, not an operative spec. Synthesizes existing specs into one place for navigation."). It modifies nothing and explicitly disclaims operative status. New row A-34 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder, annotated for likely reclassification. | **NEW in R3.1.** Action needed: human-classify A-34 — likely should be `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` with owner type `SUPPORT / AUDIT` or a new `REFERENCE / NAVIGATION` category, NOT a proposed addendum. May warrant relocation out of `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` into a top-level `Reference/` or `Navigation/` folder. |

### New anomalies detected in R3.0 (auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync — second pass of the day)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (A-12) no longer in active folder | File moved to `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-14 02:58 in archive). The R2.9 auto pass did not detect this move; the parent archived folder mtime (2026-04-27 18:50) confirms the move occurred at the same archival pass that took A-8 PACER V1.0. Row A-12 annotated for file-moved (mirroring A-8 pattern). | **NEW in R3.0 (deferred-detect from R2.9).** Action needed: human-reclassify A-12 (likely supersession by A-2 DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 Proposal V1, which incorporates Live Action Feed and conversational capture per its description). |
| OP-A V2 (S-1) and V3 / V3.2 / V3.3 no longer in active `Operations Docs/` folder | `DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V2.md`, `_V3.md`, `_V3_2.md`, `_V3_3.md` are all in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`. Active `Operations Docs/` folder contains only V3.4 (mtime 2026-04-26 22:33), V3.5 (mtime 2026-04-26 22:53), V3.6 (mtime 2026-04-26 23:25). Per V5 carryover and `SPEC_STATE.md`, V3 series is operative; V3.6 is the latest. | **NEW in R3.0 (deferred-detect from R2.8/R2.9).** R2.8 auto pass did NOT modify §7 (judgment field preserved). R3.0 auto pass adds placeholder rows S-2 (V3.6) for the latest active version, preserves S-1 (V2) row with file-moved annotation. Action needed: human-reclassify the OP-A version cluster (likely supersession of S-1 → S-2). |
| `DRIFT_LOG.md` newly present in active `Operations Docs/` | New file `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:17, size 19,385 bytes) appeared in active `Operations Docs/` after R2.9 was generated (R2.9 timestamp 03:13). Likely paired with `SPEC_STATE.md` and `ADDENDA_STATE.md` as nightly sync state artifacts. New row S-5 added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder status. | **NEW in R3.0.** Action needed: human-classify the three state files (`SPEC_STATE.md`, `ADDENDA_STATE.md`, `DRIFT_LOG.md`) as a coherent state-tracking cluster — likely a new sub-section of §7 dedicated to nightly sync artifacts. |
| `SPEC_STATE.md` and `ADDENDA_STATE.md` in active `Operations Docs/` but unregistered until R3.0 | `SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:09, size 19,169 bytes) and `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:10, size 14,478 bytes) were referenced in the R2.8 and R2.9 changelogs as "state file updated" but never formally registered in §7. R3.0 adds placeholder rows S-3 and S-4. | **NEW in R3.0 (deferred-register from R2.8/R2.9).** Action needed: see action above for the state-tracking cluster. |
| OP-A consolidation session reports unregistered until R3.0 | `OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-26_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-26 17:32) and `OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-27_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-27, V1) were noted as anomalies in R2.8 but never formally registered. R3.0 adds placeholder rows S-6 and S-7. | **NEW in R3.0 (deferred-register from R2.8).** Action needed: human-classify whether these session reports remain operative documentation or should be treated as historical (move to `Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`). |

### New anomalies detected in R2.9 (auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_1.md` newly present | New R3.1 file appeared in active folder 2026-04-28 03:43 (size 482,004 bytes). R3.0 file (formerly registry row 39) moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. Placeholder row 39b created pending human reclassification. | **NEW in R2.9.** Action needed: human-classify R3.1 (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER), retire row 39 in next manual sweep, update front-door pack item 13, update reading-pack references (task system pack). |
| New subfolder `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` | Subfolder was created 2026-04-27 22:50 inside `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Contains one file: `DOC73_CORPUS_SOURCE_BINDINGS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-27 22:50). Subfolder is structurally analogous to existing `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/` but is NOT in the in-scope folder list in the nightly sync task SKILL.md. | **NEW in R2.9.** Action needed: update the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`. The auto pass treated the file as in-scope and added new §4.A5 subsection + row A-30 with placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM status. |
| `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md` no longer in active folder | File moved to `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md`. Superseded by `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC_V1.1.md` (new row A-28). Registry row A-8 still references the old active-folder path. | **NEW in R2.9.** Action needed: retire row A-8 (replace with archived-pointer note pointing at A-28). |
| Three new top-level addenda detected | `EC_CORE_ADDENDUM_A_INTAKE_ROUTING_FOR_CORPUS_BINDINGS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (2026-04-27), `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC_V1.1.md` (2026-04-27), `CROSS_SPEC_ISSUES_PUNCH_LIST_V1.md` (2026-04-28). All registered with placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM status (rows A-27, A-28, A-29). | **NEW in R2.9.** Action needed: human-classify each addendum's parent-spec set, disposition, and disposition target. |

### New anomalies detected in R2.8 (auto-detected 2026-04-27 by nightly sync)

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md` newly present | New R3 file appeared in active folder 2026-04-27. R2.5 file (formerly registry row 40) moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. Placeholder row 40b created pending human reclassification. | **NEW in R2.8.** Action needed: human-classify R3 (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER), retire row 40 in next manual sweep, update front-door pack item 14, update reading-pack references (J. task system pack, J. knowledge/capability/intelligence pack, document-intelligence pack). |
| `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` no longer in active folder | Archived to `Subsumed Specs/DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft_ARCHIVED_2026-04-26.md` per V5 carryover note. Registry row 27 + multiple §8 reading packs (CIL/learning, retrieval/search, cross-document delta) still reference the old active-folder path. | **NEW in R2.8.** Action needed: retire row 27 (replace with archived-pointer note), strip the file from §8 reading packs, update front-door pack item 10's must-read-with reference. |
| OP-A version drift in §7 | Registry row S-1 references `DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V2.md` (V2). Folder now contains V2, V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5, V3.6 — all in `Operations Docs/` with mtime 2026-04-27. V3 series is operative per V5 carryover prompt and SPEC_STATE.md. | **NEW in R2.8.** Action needed: bump §7 row S-1 to V3.6 (or whichever version the architect deems operative); add a "superseded versions" pointer for V2. |
| Two new OP-A consolidation session reports | `Operations Docs/OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-26_V1.md` and `Operations Docs/OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-27_V1.md` are new in `Operations Docs/`. Not yet registered. | **NEW in R2.8.** Action needed: register in §7 (or new §7 sub-row) as session reports accompanying OP-A V3.x bumps. |

### Carry-forward anomalies from R2.4–R2.7

| Anomaly | Detail | Status |
|---|---|---|
| `DOC20_R4_3.md` not found in active folder | R2.4–R2.6 scans reported this file missing. **R2.7 scan confirms it IS present** (size 473,759 bytes; mtime 2026-04-09). | **RESOLVED in R2.7.** |
| `DOC16_R5_4.md` not found in active folder | Registry entry #30 references this file as the operative R5.4 revision, but only `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` (the R5.3 predecessor) is present in the folder. Either the R5.4 file was never saved to this folder, or it exists under a different name. | **CARRIED from R2.4–R2.6.** Action needed: locate or create `DOC16_R5_4.md` and move R5.3 to Subsumed Specs. |
| `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` still present | Designated as removed in R2.4 (superseded by R5.4) but remains in the active folder. | **CARRIED from R2.4–R2.6.** Action needed: move to Subsumed Specs once R5.4 is confirmed present. |
| `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` still present | Superseded by R2.1 in R2.6 and should be moved to Subsumed Specs. | **CARRIED from R2.6.** Action needed: move to Subsumed Specs. |
| `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_6.md` not found in active folder | R2.6 registered the file as R5_6; the folder contains only `R5_73` (dated 2026-04-26) and the prior R5_6 file is absent. | **RESOLVED in R2.7.** Registry slot updated to R5.73. |
| `DOC73` not previously registered | `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` (V1.4.1, 2026-04-26) is present in the active folder but had no registry slot in R2.6. | **RESOLVED in R2.7.** New registry slot created (row 43). Status flagged as CONCEPT DRAFT (not operative). |
| `DOC25` operative file location | Three DOC25-family files exist: `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md` (V2.0, primary folder, 2026-04-26 — operative); `Integrated Addenda/DOC25_DOC INTELLIGENCE_SPEC.md` (V1.0, 2026-04-11 — superseded); `Integrated Addenda/DOC25_PLANNING_NOTES_V2.md` (planning notes, 2026-04-23 — superseded). | **RESOLVED in R2.7.** V2.0 registered as operative (row 41); V1.0, planning notes, and `DOC_INTELLIGENCE_EXTRACTION_PIPELINE_PROPOSAL_R1.md` registered in §5 as INTEGRATED. |
| `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL.md` not previously registered | Active proposal in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` since 2026-04-13 but had no registry entry in R2.6. | **RESOLVED in R2.7.** Registered in §4 (row A-1). |

---

## 11. Counts

> **⚠️ R3.61 AUTHORITATIVE RECONCILED TOTALS (read this first).** The cumulative-annotation tables below were **frozen at R3.58 values** — they were never updated through R3.59/R3.60 (the "By status" PROPOSED ADDENDUM cell still reads 81 and Grand total 151; the "By section" Grand total still reads 141). R3.61's filesystem-grounded reconciliation supersedes them. **Authoritative counts (files actually on disk, in scope, at R3.61):**
>
> | Bucket | R3.61 authoritative | Note |
> |---|---:|---|
> | §3 Core Specifications | 56 | unchanged since R3.59 |
> | §A3 DOC24 Addenda | 11 | R3.60 claimed 10; +1 = never-counted `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` (A-81), now rowed |
> | §A8 DOC 80 DAMS | 6 | V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4/V4.1 — all 6 rows now present (V3/V3(1) were phantom-claimed at R3.59) |
> | §4 Active Addenda | 86 | R3.60 = 83 (incl. 3 phantom-claimed rows); +1 KDA v0.3.1; +2 DAMS V4/V4.1 |
> | §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM | 87 | = §4 active (86) + reclassification deltas absorbed; all DAMS/BDSM/KDA drafts are PROPOSED ADDENDUM |
> | §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | 28 | unchanged since R3.59 |
> | §11 INTEGRATED ADDENDUM | 5 | unchanged |
> | §11 Cross-Document References | 2 | unchanged |
> | §11 Operations Files | 12 | unchanged since R3.6 |
> | **§11 Grand total (all sections)** | **159** | R3.60 = 156; +1 KDA v0.3.1 + 2 DAMS V4/V4.1 |
>
> **Reconciliation findings flagged for human review:** (a) R3.59 changelog claimed table rows A-80/A-82/A-83 that were never written — narrative-vs-execution divergence (same family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.55); (b) `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` was on disk since 2026-05-20 but escaped all of R3.58/R3.59/R3.60 detection; (c) the §11 tables below were never advanced past R3.58. The SKILL.md tightening recommendation (post-write `stat`/grep verification of claimed table edits) is now **thirty-six cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.61); items (a)–(c) are the strongest evidence to date for adopting it. The cumulative-annotation tables below are retained verbatim for historical traceability only — **use the table above as authoritative.**

### By status

| Status | Count |
|---|---:|
| CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT | 29 (was 28 from R3.0–R3.46; +1 in R3.47 for DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch — placeholder row, needs human re-classification re whether R3.1.1 supersedes R3 or stacks alongside it) |
| ACTIVE COMPANION DRAFT | 5 |
| ACTIVE BUILD / IMPLEMENTATION DRAFT | 4 |
| SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT | 24 (was 23 in R3.53/R3.54; +1 in R3.55 for OPA V3.16 placeholder Support/Operations row continuing placement-irregular active-root pattern; was 22 in R3.52; +1 in R3.53 for OPA V3.15 placeholder Support/Operations row continuing placement-irregular active-root pattern with V3.14 skipped; was 21 in R3.50/R3.51; +1 in R3.52 for OPA V3.13 placeholder Support/Operations row; was 19 in R3.47-R3.49; +2 in R3.50 for OPA V3.11 in proper Operations Docs/ location + OPA V3.12 in active root; was 18 from R3.6–R3.46; +1 in R3.47 for OPA V3.9 placement-irregular Support/Operations row) |
| FUTURE / PLANNING DRAFT | 1 |
| CONCEPT DRAFT | 1 |
| **Core registry total (rows 1–43 + R2.8 row 40b + R2.9 row 39b + R3.2 row 43b + R3.47 row 44c DOC24 R3.1.1 + R3.47 row 44d OPA V3.9 + R3.50 row 44e OPA V3.11 + R3.50 row 44f OPA V3.12 + R3.52 row 44g OPA V3.13 + R3.53 row 44h OPA V3.15 + R3.55 row 44i OPA V3.16 placeholders)** | **54 (incl. row 44 placeholder; +1 in R3.55 for OPA V3.16 placeholder row 44i; was 53 in R3.53/R3.54 after +1 for V3.15 row 44h; was 52 in R3.52 after +1 for V3.13; was 51 in R3.50/R3.51 after +2 for V3.11 + V3.12; was 49 in R3.47-R3.49)** (was 47 from R3.0–R3.46; +2 in R3.47 for two new placeholder rows pending human classification)** |
| PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda) | 81 (was 76 in R3.55–R3.57; +5 net in R3.58 for A-75 DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3 NEW in §A3 + A-76 DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.3 NEW in §A3 + A-77 Unified Workspace R0.3 NEW in §A7 with explicit `Supersedes:` of R0.2 + A-78 DAMS V1 NEW in brand-new §A8 + A-79 DAMS V2 NEW in §A8 same-day successor to V1; A-72 BDSM v0.2 + A-73 KDA v0.2 + A-58 R0.2 all get natural-progression-supersession annotations pending finalization/archival; was 72 in R3.53/R3.54; +4 net in R3.55 for A-71 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED NEW in §A1 + A-72 DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 NEW in §A3 + A-73 DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 NEW in §A3 + A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 NEW in §A6 — A-67 V5.1 + A-19 KDA R2 + A-22 BDSM V6.4 all get natural-progression-supersession annotations pending finalization/archival; was 68 in R3.52; +4 net in R3.53 for A-67 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1 NEW in §A1 + A-68 DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal NEW in §A1 + A-69 R3 Coverage Audit NEW in §A1 + A-70 RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3 NEW in §A1 — all four NEW top-level addenda in `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/` subfolder or root, with R2 predecessors moved to NEW intra-subfolder archive `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` and A-5 ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 row getting natural-progression-supersession annotation; was 66 in R3.50/R3.51; +2 net in R3.52 for A-67 DOC23 ADDB Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3.3 NEW in §A6 sub-sub-folder + A-68 DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 NEW in §A6 sub-sub-folder; was 65 in R3.49; +1 net in R3.50 for A-66 R4.1 V6 NEW in §A6 DOC23 Addenda — successor in V2 → V6 chain since A-47 V2 last formally tracked in R3.12; intermediate V3/V4/V5 never materialized at sync windows. Was 59 in R3.47/R3.48; +6 net in R3.49 for A-60 V3.2 NEW + A-61 R0.7 Core NEW + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW + A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW + A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW — major architectural decomposition of DOC23 Addenda B work into Core + V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts family topology in brand-new sub-sub-folder `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/`; A-59 V3.1 retained ACTIVE pending archival per V3.2 supersession; A-53 R0.6.4 retained ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 Core supersession; A-54 R0.6.5 retained ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 absorption of base material; A-65 Common Contracts V1 counted as PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholder pending human reclassification as SUPPORT / SIBLING SPEC; was 58 in R3.44/R3.45/R3.46; +1 net in R3.47 for A-59 V3.1 NEW in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain — natural-progression successor to A-57 V3 + A-55 V2 + A-54 V1; V3 file MOVED to local intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` along with V2 + older predecessor files; V3/V2 rows retained in §A6 with intra-subfolder-archive annotations per auto pass no-removal policy; prior R3.41/R3.42/R3.43 56-count baseline +2 net in R3.44 for A-57 V3 NEW in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain + A-58 R0.2 NEW in §A7 Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder; A-55 V2 + A-54 V1 + A-56 R0.1 stacked-then-superseded pattern from R3.33/R3.39/R3.41/R3.44 preserved; A-52 row preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation per the audit-cleanup rule, mirroring A-50/A-51 archival pattern) |
| INTEGRATED ADDENDUM | 5 |
| Cross-Document References | 2 |
| Operations Files | 12 (unchanged from R3.6) |
| **Grand total (all sections)** | **151** (was 146 in R3.55–R3.57; +5 in R3.58 for A-75 DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3 + A-76 DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.3 + A-77 Unified Workspace R0.3 + A-78 DAMS V1 + A-79 DAMS V2 — first new §A8 subfolder DOC 80 DAMS; was 141 in R3.53/R3.54; +5 in R3.55 for OPA V3.16 placeholder Support/Operations row + A-71 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED NEW + A-72 DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 NEW + A-73 DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 NEW + A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 NEW. Was 136 in R3.52; +5 in R3.53 for OPA V3.15 placeholder Support/Operations row + A-67 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1 NEW + A-68 DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal NEW + A-69 R3 Coverage Audit NEW + A-70 RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3 NEW in §A1. Was 133 in R3.50/R3.51; +3 in R3.52 for OPA V3.13 placeholder Support/Operations row + A-67 DOC23 ADDB V3.3 NEW + A-68 DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 NEW in §A6. Was 130 in R3.49; +3 in R3.50 for OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 placeholder Support/Operations rows + A-66 R4.1 V6 NEW in §A6. Was 124 in R3.47/R3.48; +6 in R3.49 for A-60 V3.2 NEW + A-61 R0.7 Core NEW + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW + A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW + A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW; was 123 in R3.44–R3.46; +1 in R3.47 for A-59 V3.1 NEW; was 121 in R3.41–R3.43; +2 active addenda in R3.44 for A-57 V3 NEW + A-58 R0.2 NEW; was 120 in R3.39/R3.40; +1 in R3.41 for A-56; was 119 in R3.33–R3.38; +1 in R3.39 for A-55 V2 supersession of A-54 V1 with V1 retained pending archival; was 118 in R3.18–R3.32; +1 in R3.33 for A-54 R0.6.5; was 117 in R3.13–R3.17; +1 in R3.18 for A-53) |

### By section

| Section | Count |
|---|---:|
| §3 Core Specifications (rows 1–43 + R2.8 row 40b + R2.9 row 39b + R3.2 row 43b + R3.47 row 44c + R3.47 row 44d + R3.50 row 44e + R3.50 row 44f + R3.52 row 44g + R3.53 row 44h + R3.55 row 44i) | 53 (was 52 in R3.53/R3.54; +1 in R3.55 for OPA V3.16 placeholder row 44i; was 51 in R3.52; +1 in R3.53 for OPA V3.15 placeholder row 44h; was 50 in R3.50/R3.51; +1 in R3.52 for OPA V3.13 placeholder row 44g; was 48 in R3.47-R3.49; +2 in R3.50 for OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 placeholder rows) |
| §4 Active Addenda | 80 (was 75 in R3.55–R3.57; +5 in R3.58 — A3: 9 (+2 for A-75 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3 + A-76 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.3, second consecutive multi-DOC24-draft sync window); A7: 3 (+1 for A-77 R0.3 explicit Supersedes of A-58 R0.2); **A8: 2 NEW SUBSECTION (DOC 80 DAMS subfolder NEW in R3.58 with A-78 V1 + A-79 V2 same-day pair)**; was 71 in R3.53/R3.54; +4 in R3.55 for A-71 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED in §A1 + A-72 DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 in §A3 + A-73 DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 in §A3 + A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 in §A6; was 67 in R3.52; +4 in R3.53 for A-67 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1 + A-68 DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal + A-69 R3 Coverage Audit + A-70 RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3 — all in §A1; was 65 in R3.50/R3.51; +2 in R3.52 for A-67 DOC23 ADDB V3.3 + A-68 DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 in §A6 sub-sub-folder; was 64 in R3.49; +1 in R3.50 for A-66 R4.1 V6 in §A6. Was 58 in R3.47/R3.48; +6 in R3.49 for A-60 V3.2 + A-61 R0.7 Core + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 + A-65 Common Contracts V1; A1: 33 — was 32 in R3.53/R3.54, +1 in R3.55 for ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.2 AUDITED; was 28 in R3.52, +4 in R3.53 for ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.1 + DOC11 R3 + R3 Coverage Audit + RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3; A2: 4; A3: 7 — was 5 in R3.0–R3.54, +2 in R3.55 for A-72 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 + A-73 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 (first multi-DOC24-draft drift in single sync window); A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 19 — was 18 in R3.49–R3.54, +1 in R3.55 for A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 (first family-coherence reference map for the DOC23 family); was 13 in R3.47, was 12 in R3.44–R3.46, was 11 in R3.39–R3.43; A-45 from R3.9 + A-46 from R3.10 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 from R3.12 + A-50 alias from R3.13 (R3.15 archived to intra-subfolder) + A-51 alias from R3.15 (R3.16 archived to intra-subfolder) + A-52 alias from R3.16 (R3.18 archived to intra-subfolder) + A-53 NEW in R3.18 (R0.6.4 — ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 supersession) + A-54 NEW in R3.33 (R0.6.5 stacked proposal — ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 absorption) + A-55 NEW in R3.39 (V2; intra-subfolder archived R3.47) + **A-57 NEW in R3.44 (V3; intra-subfolder archived R3.47)** + **A-59 NEW in R3.47 (V3.1 — ACTIVE pending archival per V3.2 supersession)** + **A-60 NEW in R3.49 (V3.2 — surgical patch incorporating coordination V3 FINAL)** + **A-61 NEW in R3.49 (R0.7 Core supersession of R0.6.4 via family-topology reorganization; in `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder)** + **A-62 NEW in R3.49 (Feedback Delivery V1 sub-addendum; in rework sub-sub-folder)** + **A-63 NEW in R3.49 (Source Workspace V1 sub-addendum; in rework sub-sub-folder)** + **A-64 NEW in R3.49 (Task Forum + Run Board V1 sub-addendum; in rework sub-sub-folder)** + **A-65 NEW in R3.49 (Common Contracts V1 joint-ownership sibling spec; in rework sub-sub-folder)**; **A7: 2 — A-56 NEW in R3.41 + A-58 NEW in R3.44 (R0.2 explicit Supersedes of A-56 R0.1 per R0.2 file header; scope refined to demote DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status and drop Output Routing/Task Scope/Working Set in favor of consolidated Resume Work surface)**; A-44 is an alias pointer to the §A1 row of the same file and is not counted again — its file remains archived to global archive per R3.12) | was 13 in R3.47, was 12 in R3.44–R3.46, was 11 in R3.39–R3.43; A-45 from R3.9 + A-46 from R3.10 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 from R3.12 + A-50 alias from R3.13 (R3.15 archived to intra-subfolder) + A-51 alias from R3.15 (R3.16 archived to intra-subfolder) + A-52 alias from R3.16 (R3.18 archived to intra-subfolder) + A-53 NEW in R3.18 (R0.6.4 — ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 supersession) + A-54 NEW in R3.33 (R0.6.5 stacked proposal — ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7 absorption) + A-55 NEW in R3.39 (V2; intra-subfolder archived R3.47) + **A-57 NEW in R3.44 (V3; intra-subfolder archived R3.47)** + **A-59 NEW in R3.47 (V3.1 — ACTIVE pending archival per V3.2 supersession)** + **A-60 NEW in R3.49 (V3.2 — surgical patch incorporating coordination V3 FINAL)** + **A-61 NEW in R3.49 (R0.7 Core supersession of R0.6.4 via family-topology reorganization; in `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder)** + **A-62 NEW in R3.49 (Feedback Delivery V1 sub-addendum; in rework sub-sub-folder)** + **A-63 NEW in R3.49 (Source Workspace V1 sub-addendum; in rework sub-sub-folder)** + **A-64 NEW in R3.49 (Task Forum + Run Board V1 sub-addendum; in rework sub-sub-folder)** + **A-65 NEW in R3.49 (Common Contracts V1 joint-ownership sibling spec; in rework sub-sub-folder)**; **A7: 2 — A-56 NEW in R3.41 + A-58 NEW in R3.44 (R0.2 explicit Supersedes of A-56 R0.1 per R0.2 file header; scope refined to demote DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status and drop Output Routing/Task Scope/Working Set in favor of consolidated Resume Work surface)**; A-44 is an alias pointer to the §A1 row of the same file and is not counted again — its file remains archived to global archive per R3.12) |
| §5 Integrated Addenda | 5 |
| §6 Cross-Document References | 2 |
| §7 Supporting Documents (Operations) | 12 (unchanged from R3.6) |
| **Grand total** | **141** |

> Note: The header total ("130") reflects R3.49 additions (+6 net in §A6: A-60 V3.2 NEW + A-61 R0.7 Core NEW + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW + A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW + A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW; cumulative since R3.44: +2 in R3.44, +1 in R3.47, +6 in R3.49 = +9 net since R3.43 baseline). Small differences across header/§3/§11 are caused by including/excluding the placeholder row 44 (in §3 — DOC11 R14 cross-reference) and by counting the §A6 alias pointers vs primary rows. §A6 active rows at R3.49: 18 (was 13 at R3.47, was 12 at R3.44–R3.46, was 11 from R3.39–R3.43): A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 + A-50 alias + A-51 alias + A-52 alias + A-53 + A-54 + A-55 (intra-subfolder archive R3.47) + A-57 (intra-subfolder archive R3.47) + A-59 V3.1 + **A-60 V3.2 NEW** + **A-61 R0.7 Core NEW** + **A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW** + **A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW** + **A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW** + **A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW** — A-50/A-51/A-52 aliases are file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive pointers; A-44 is an alias pointer to the §A1 row of the same file (file in global archive per R3.12); A-55 and A-57 are intra-subfolder-archive pointers added R3.47; A-53/A-54/A-59 ACTIVE pending archival per R0.7/R0.7-absorption/V3.2 supersession respectively; A-60 through A-65 all NEW in R3.49 representing major architectural decomposition of DOC23 Addenda B work into Core + Addendum + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts family topology in brand-new `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder. §A7 active rows at R3.49 unchanged from R3.44: 2 (A-56 + A-58) — A-56 ACTIVE pending archival per R0.2 supersession. Use §11 grand totals as authoritative.

---

## 12. Changelog

### R3.62 — 2026-05-24 (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **TWO-DAY-GAP-CATCHUP bump** backfilling R3.61 substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping + capturing post-R3.61 in-scope archival events. **R3.61** was bumped 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local as a SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump + RECONCILIATION PASS that added 2 NEW DAMS files (V4 + V4.1) + 6 backfilled rows (A-80 BDSM v0.3.1 / A-81 KDA v0.3.1 / A-82 DAMS V3 / A-83 DAMS V3(1) / A-84 DAMS V4 / A-85 DAMS V4.1) into MSL §4 — but never updated SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md / dashboard.html / carryover prompt on its own window. **FIRST EVER substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping observation** — prior alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping family (R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41/R3.49/R3.51/R3.54/R3.55/R3.57/R3.60) all involved ALIAS-ONLY firings; R3.61 introduces a new variant where a SUBSTANTIVE structural bump skips housekeeping. Plus **2026-05-23 had ZERO sync firing observed** — FIRST EVER silent calendar day in this scheduled-task run history (no DRIFT_LOG entry, no MSL bump, no expected daily-cadence operations-state ledger firing; likely missed-firing rather than zero-drift run-marker since no run-marker entry was appended). **In-scope filesystem scan since R3.61 alias write 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.61.md` returned 7 hits — 0 in-scope NEW spec files + 6 `Operations Docs/` ledgers (operations-state, not spec content) + 1 sub-sub-folder cleanup patch pack (out-of-scope per SKILL.md scope-list — DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework sub-sub-folder still NOT formally listed; backlog item carry-forward). **In-scope archival events captured today:** 5 DAMS files MOVED from `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/` → `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` between R3.61 and today: DAMS V1 (mtime 2026-05-20 11:32 preserved), V2 (mtime 2026-05-20 13:42 preserved), V3 (mtime 2026-05-21 05:56 preserved), V3 (1) (mtime 2026-05-21 05:59 preserved), V4 (mtime 2026-05-22 04:19 preserved). DAMS V4.1 modified 2026-05-22 04:27 local — **sole remaining active file in §A8 DOC 80 DAMS subfolder** post-Will-side archival decision. §A8 effective active count = 1 (V4.1 only); preserved-for-traceability rows = 5 (V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4 all moved to global addenda archive — auto-pass no-removal policy retains rows with FILE MOVED TO GLOBAL ARCHIVE annotation; consistent with §A.1 A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 / A-2 DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 PROPOSAL_V1 / A-3 / A-12 / etc. handling pattern). **State-file backfill executed today:** SPEC_STATE Master Spec List row Rev field advanced R3.60 → R3.62 with R3.61/R3.62 narrative folded into Notes; Spec State + Addenda State rows' Last Modified advanced 2026-05-22 → 2026-05-24. ADDENDA_STATE.md header Last touched advanced 2026-05-22 → 2026-05-24 with R3.62 narrative. **NEW ADDENDA_STATE rows added today via R3.62 catchup:** A-80 `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` in §A.3 (materializes R3.61 reconciliation finding (b) for ADDENDA_STATE which never had this row; ADDENDA_STATE uses A-80, MSL §4 uses A-81 — divergence-by-one pattern); A-83 `DOC 80 DAMS/Archived (now in global addenda archive)/DAMS_V4_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` in §A.8 (ADDENDA_STATE uses A-83, MSL §4 uses A-84); A-84 `DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_1_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` in §A.8 (ADDENDA_STATE uses A-84, MSL §4 uses A-85). §A.8 existing rows A-78/A-79/A-81/A-82 (V1/V2/V3/V3(1)) get FILE MOVED TO GLOBAL ARCHIVE annotations. **Dashboard regenerated** with R3.62 narrative; `lastRefresh` advanced 2026-05-22 → 2026-05-24; `generatedAt` advanced 2026-05-22 → 2026-05-24. **Carryover bumped V22 → V23** — substantive structural drift warrants refresh (DAMS subfolder reorganization + R3.61 backfill content); V22 retained in `Prompts/` per task spec versioned-coexistence rule. **R3.61 versioned file moved → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.61.md`** per audit-cleanup pass; active folder retains R3.62 alias + R3.62 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant intact. **Counts post-R3.62 (preserving R3.61 reconciled totals; archival adjustments noted parenthetically per auto-pass row-preservation policy):** §3 Core Specs = 56 (unchanged); §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 11 (unchanged from R3.61); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 6 rows total (1 effective active V4.1 + 5 preserved-for-traceability archived V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4); §4 Active Addenda = 86 row-count (unchanged from R3.61); effective active addenda excluding archived V1-V4 ≈ 81; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 87 (R3.61); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28 (R3.61); §11 Grand total = 159 (R3.61). **Critical cross-doc finding carry-forward unchanged:** DAMS V2/V3's DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) flagged R3.58/R3.59, further evidenced by R3.61 §12 DAMS V4 "central reframe of DAMS as one demoted substrate inside a larger memory architecture" narrative — DAMS is no longer standalone proposal but memory-architecture-component proposal touching DOC1/DOC8 substantially; still pending human review. DOC 80 DAMS still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in SKILL.md scope-list backlog (unchanged). **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-EIGHT cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.62) — today reinforces (a) item #5 post-edit `stat`/grep verification on claimed-edited files (R3.61 should have stat-checked SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard / carryover after its narrative-write to detect skipped-housekeeping at write time), and (b) NEW recommendation: substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping detection warrants its own SKILL.md item separating it from the alias-only family since detection signals differ (substantive bumps inject false drift signal into MSL §12 while skipping downstream state-file housekeeping that materializes the claimed changes). **NEW ANOMALY** flagged today: 2026-05-23 silent calendar day — first observed silent calendar day in scheduled-task run history; needs human verification of whether task fired silently or failed to fire. **Tracker numbering note:** R3.62 uses A-80 KDA v0.3.1 / A-83 DAMS V4 / A-84 DAMS V4.1 in ADDENDA_STATE numbering (vs MSL §4 A-81/A-84/A-85) — divergence-by-one-or-two pattern extends to eleventh+ NEW-row cycle.)

### R3.61 — 2026-05-22 (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump + RECONCILIATION PASS**. **2 NEW spec files** since R3.60 alias write 2026-05-21 16:11 local: (1) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-21 21:19 local; 62,380 bytes; -15,682 bytes / -20.1% under primary V3) — new row A-84 in §A8; central reframe: DAMS is *one demoted substrate* inside a larger memory architecture (memory-as-control-problem; Premise Families base object; Context Compiler emitting warranted packets; recompile-on-resume + cognitive diff; thick-floor/thin-swappable-judgment invariant; domain-packs; Knowledge Topic primitive); lineage V2 → meta-review → V3.1 → V4. (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V4_1_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-21 21:27 local; 64,604 bytes; +2,224 bytes / +3.6% over V4) — new row A-85 in §A8; per file header, two content additions vs V4 (§B.8 worked three-Topics walkthrough establishing the multi-parent acyclic DAG; §C.1 sharpened "the merge is itself the audit" epistemics), no structural change. **SECOND-EVER same-day intra-window successor pair** (V4 21:19 → V4.1 21:27, ~8min apart) — tighter than the R3.59 OPA V3.17→V3.18 ~17min pair. **Filesystem scan since R3.60:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 8 hits — 2 in-scope new spec files (above) + 5 `Operations Docs/` ledgers (ADDENDA_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md, OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, SPEC_STATE.md — operations-state, not spec content) + the R3.60 versioned snapshot (self). **MAJOR RECONCILIATION PASS (three findings, flagged for human review):** (a) the R3.59 changelog claimed it added rows A-80 (BDSM v0.3.1, §A3), A-82 (DAMS V3, §A8), and A-83 (DAMS V3(1), §A8), and the R3.59/R3.60 counts include those files, **but none of those rows were ever written into the tables** — a narrative-vs-execution divergence of the same family the changelog has repeatedly flagged (R3.13/R3.16/R3.55 phantom-claim pattern). R3.61 back-fills all three from the R3.59 changelog source data. (b) `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 16:14 local; 129,645 bytes) **existed on disk since the R3.58 era but was never counted or rowed by any prior revision** — the R3.60 §A3 count of 10 undercounted the 11 actual DOC24-Addenda files by exactly this file; R3.61 tracks it as A-81 (closing the long-standing A-81 numbering gap chronologically — both v0.3.1 files predate the DAMS V3 files). Both v0.3.1 files carry a filename-vs-internal-version discrepancy (filename `_v0_3_1`, internal H1 still "v0.3") flagged for human classification. (c) the **§11 Counts tables were frozen at R3.58 values** (PROPOSED ADDENDUM still 81, Grand totals still 151/141) — never advanced through R3.59/R3.60; R3.61 adds an authoritative reconciled-totals table at the head of §11 and retains the cumulative-annotation tables verbatim for historical traceability only. **Authoritative reconciled counts at R3.61:** §3 Core Specs = 56; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 11; §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 6; §4 Active Addenda = 86; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 87; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 159. **Audit-cleanup pass** moved R3.60 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (parent `ECQ Development/`); R3.61 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved. **Carry-forward (unchanged, pending human review):** DAMS DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is a 730-line friction engine with no learning-engine capabilities) persists from R3.58; DOC 80 DAMS still the eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in the SKILL.md scope-list backlog. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-six cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.61) — findings (a)/(b)/(c) today are the strongest evidence yet for adopting post-write `stat`/grep verification of claimed table edits; had R3.59 grep-verified its claimed A-80/A-82/A-83 rows, all three phantoms would have been caught at write time. **Tracker numbering note:** R3.61 uses A-80 (BDSM v0.3.1) / A-81 (KDA v0.3.1) / A-82 (DAMS V3) / A-83 (DAMS V3(1)) / A-84 (DAMS V4) / A-85 (DAMS V4.1) — the A-81 slot, skipped in the prior divergence pattern, is now filled chronologically by KDA v0.3.1.)

### R3.60 — 2026-05-21 (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing**; zero new spec files detected since R3.59 alias write 2026-05-21 03:15 local (+~1h17m at firing 2026-05-21 ~04:31 local). **Filesystem scan since R3.59:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 5 hits, ALL in `Operations Docs/` (operations-state ledgers, not spec content) — DRIFT_LOG.md (+04m post-R3.59) + OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (+30m post-R3.59) + BACKUP_LOG.md (+1h05m post-R3.59) + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (+1h10m post-R3.59) + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (+1h16m post-R3.59). Spec corpus content (DOC1–DOC25, DOC72, DOC73 family, EC_Core_Specs, OPA V3.11–V3.18 with 9-of-10 active-root placement-irregularity backlog, Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC, addenda subfolder topology including §A8 DOC 80 DAMS at 4 files, integrated-vs-active status, BDSM v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/v0.3.1 working-draft series) all stable from R3.59 snapshot — no diff. Per SKILL.md Step 5 ALIAS-ONLY canonical path (mirrors prior R3.57 + R3.54 firing patterns). R3.59→R3.60 represents the lightest possible alias bump — versioning continuity preserved for downstream consumers without injecting false drift signal. **Counts:** all unchanged from R3.59 (§3 Core Specs = 56; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 10; §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 4; §4 Active Addenda = 83; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 84; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 156). **Audit-cleanup pass** moved R3.59 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure; R3.60 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.60 alias + R3.60 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved. **R3.59 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** (a) DAMS V2/V3 DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) flagged in R3.58/R3.59 still pending human review; (b) A-75 BDSM v0.3 + A-78 V1 + A-79 V2 DAMS rows all retain natural-progression-supersession annotations; (c) same-day intra-window OPA pair pattern (V3.17 → V3.18 ~17min apart) carried forward as architecturally-significant emergence; (d) same-day intra-folder duplicate-exceeding-primary pattern (DAMS V3 (1) > primary V3 by +20.7%) carried forward as workflow-signal mystery pending human classification; (e) fourth-decimal-place patch suffix in BDSM chain (`_v0_3_1`) carried forward as architecturally-significant intra-version patch granularity pattern; (f) DOC 80 DAMS subfolder still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in scope-list backlog (accumulated 4 files in <24h from R3.58 + R3.59). **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-five cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.60). **Tracker numbering divergence** between MSL §4 (A-80/A-82/A-83) and ADDENDA_STATE (A-79/A-81/A-82) extends to tenth+ NEW-row cycle pending ADDENDA_STATE backfill.)

### R3.59 — 2026-05-21 (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW files** since R3.58 alias write 2026-05-20 23:15 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.58:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 5 hits in scope: 2 spec files in active root (OPA V3.17 + OPA V3.18) + 3 addenda files in subfolders (BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3.1 + DAMS V3 + DAMS V3 (1)). **New files:** (1) `OPA_V3_17.md` active root (mtime 2026-05-21 01:30 local; size 760,219 bytes; +41,168 bytes / +5.7% over V3.16) — eighth active-root placement-irregular OPA instance. (2) `OPA_V3_18.md` active root (mtime 2026-05-21 01:47 local; size 767,081 bytes; +6,862 bytes / +0.9% over V3.17) — **FIRST EVER same-day intra-window OPA successor pair** ~17min apart; ninth placement-irregular instance; small +0.9% growth suggests minor corrective patch over V3.17. (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 23:15 local) — **FIRST EVER fourth-decimal-place patch suffix** `_v0_3_1` in BDSM chain extending v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL working-draft series with intra-version patch granularity (analogous to DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 → V3.1 → V3.2 minor-revision pattern from R3.47/R3.49). New row A-80 in §A3 DOC24 Addenda; A-75 v0.3 row gets natural-progression-intra-version-patch-successor annotation pending finalization. (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-21 05:56 local; size 78,062 bytes; -3,210 bytes / -4% under V2) — consolidated successor to A-78/A-79 V1+V2 same-day pair from R3.58; filename change `DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2` → `DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL` signals consolidation from proposal-iteration mode to architecture-baseline mode; modest size reduction (-4%) consistent with consolidation tightening. New row A-82 in §A8 DOC 80 DAMS; A-78/A-79 V1+V2 rows get natural-progression-consolidated-successor annotations. (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-21 05:59 local; size 94,239 bytes; +16,177 bytes / +20.7% over primary V3) — **(1)-suffix duplicate variant** of primary V3 written ~3min after primary; **FIRST EVER same-day intra-folder duplicate pair where duplicate EXCEEDS primary in size** (unlike prior (1)-suffix downloads-copy pattern observed across DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card and DOC23 REPROMPT duplicates where duplicate matched primary); workflow-signal mystery pending human classification. New row A-83 in §A8. **Architecturally significant developments today:** (a) FIRST EVER same-day intra-window OPA successor pair (V3.17 → V3.18 ~17min apart) — tighter than R3.58 DAMS V1→V2 ~2h pair; (b) FIRST EVER fourth-decimal-place patch suffix `_v0_3_1` in BDSM chain extends draft-series pattern with intra-version patch granularity; (c) FIRST EVER (1)-duplicate exceeding primary in size — first deviation from downloads-copy-matching-primary pattern; (d) DOC 80 DAMS subfolder now has 4 files (V1+V2 from R3.58 + V3+V3 (1) from R3.59) — first not-formally-listed subfolder to accumulate 4 files in single MSL bump-cycle since formation. **Counts updates in R3.59:** §3 Core Specs 54 → 56 (+2 for OPA V3.17 + V3.18); §A3 DOC24 Addenda 9 → 10 (+1 for BDSM v0.3.1); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS 2 → 4 (+2 for V3 + V3 (1)); §4 Active Addenda 80 → 83 (+3); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 81 → 84 (+3); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER 26 → 28 (+2); Grand total 151 → 156 (+5). **Audit-cleanup pass** moves R3.58 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`; R3.59 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.59 alias + R3.59 versioned snapshot only. **Critical cross-doc finding carry-forward:** DAMS V2's DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) flagged in R3.58 still pending human review. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-four cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.59). DOC 80 DAMS subfolder still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in scope-list backlog (now accumulated 4 files in <24h). Tracker numbering divergence between MSL §4 (A-80/A-82/A-83) and ADDENDA_STATE (A-79/A-81/A-82) extends to ninth+ NEW-row cycle.)

### R3.58 — 2026-05-20 (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing **5 NEW spec files + 1 NEW Addenda subfolder** since R3.57 alias write 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.57:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 7 hits — 5 spec/addendum files in scope + 2 out-of-scope Operations Docs ledgers (BACKUP_LOG.md +9m post-R3.57 + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md +4m post-R3.57; both attributable as late-coordinated R3.57 post-write housekeeping). **New files:** (1) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_Project_Proposal_R0_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 10:47:42 local; size 89,032 bytes; +741 bytes / +0.8% over R0.2 = A-58) — explicit `Supersedes:` declaration of R0.2; title evolution: "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal R0.2" → "Workspace / Library / Project Mode / Output Routing / Memory Continuity Proposal R0.3"; **introduces explicit project mode as primary primitive** collapsing R0.2's eleven user-facing concepts after red-team review; second consecutive explicit-supersession-declaration in this §A7 multi-parent track (R0.1 → R0.2 → R0.3); references in-flight DOC72 Entity Attenuator Addendum as canonical. New row A-77 in §A7. (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 11:32:26 local; size 131,064 bytes) — **first ever DAMS (Dynamic Attenuator Memory System) proposal**; placeholder DOC80 (core primitive) + DOC81 (consumer integration map) numbering; companion to A-77 R0.3 (R0.3 explicitly references DAMS attenuator primitive as canonical for projects' DOC72 `world_entity` node). New row A-78 in **brand-new §A8 DOC 80 DAMS subfolder**. (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_PROPOSAL_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 13:42:32 local; size 81,272 bytes; -49,792 bytes / -38% under V1) — **first ever same-day V1→V2 pair in any addenda subfolder**; V2 substantively re-frames V1 (build-it-all-at-once posture, DOC72 size constraint, **DOC8 phantom finding** — the document named DOC8 is a 730-line friction engine containing no learning engine capabilities that DOC24/DOC72/DOC73/DOC23/BDSM reference; naming "Attenuator" vs "Attenuated"; Control Surface §16). New row A-79 in §A8. (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 11:27:03 local; size 170,708 bytes; +19,040 bytes / +12.6% over v0.2 = A-72) — v0.3 corrective-patch over v0.2 BDSM V6.5 draft; per file: "applies the v0.3 corrective patch plan over the v0.2 BDSM V6.5 draft and replaces BDSM v6.4 for the V6.5+ revision lane." New row A-75 in §A3; A-72 v0.2 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending finalization. (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-20 12:23:19 local; size 128,723 bytes; +34,891 bytes / +37.2% over v0.2 = A-73) — v0.3 mechanical preservation-patch over v0.2 KDA R3 draft; per file: "v0.3 is a mechanical preservation patch over v0.2, closing the ten KDA R2 preservation gaps enumerated in the v0.3 patch plan." New row A-76 in §A3; A-73 v0.2 row gets natural-progression-supersession annotation pending finalization. **NEW SUBFOLDER §A8 DOC 80 DAMS** — first addenda subfolder pattern keyed to a placeholder DOC number not yet in core spec list (DOC80/DOC81 placeholder numbers); structurally analogous to existing single-parent subfolders (DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73/DOC23/DOC11 Addenda) BUT first ever pattern where parent spec numbers do not exist yet (proposed/placeholder docs materializing if DAMS proposal accepted). SKILL.md scope list does not formally include DOC 80 DAMS path (eighth not-formally-listed subfolder added since SKILL.md tightening recommendation began at R3.26). **Multi-revision DOC24 cluster again** (v0.3 BDSM + v0.3 KDA within ~1h window) — second consecutive multi-DOC24-draft sync window (R3.55 captured v0.2 pair; R3.58 captures v0.3 pair); confirms coordinated DOC24 family redrafting cadence. **Counts updates in R3.58:** §A3 DOC24 Addenda 7 → 9 (+2 for A-75 BDSM v0.3 + A-76 KDA v0.3); §A7 Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj 2 → 3 (+1 for A-77 R0.3); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS 0 → 2 (+2 for A-78 V1 + A-79 V2; new subsection); §4 Active Addenda 75 → 80 (+5); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 76 → 81 (+5); §11 Grand total 146 → 151 (+5). **Audit-cleanup pass** moves R3.57 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure; R3.58 versioned snapshot saved alongside alias write. Active folder retains R3.58 alias + R3.58 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved. **Critical cross-doc finding flagged:** DAMS V2's DOC8 phantom finding (DOC8 R3 is a 730-line friction engine with no learning engine capabilities) implies §3 DOC8 row may need substantial respec or replacement — flagged here for human review as a possible §10 file-system anomaly entry in future R-revisions. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-three cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.58). Tracker numbering divergence between MSL §4 (A-75/A-76/A-77/A-78/A-79) and ADDENDA_STATE (likely A-74/A-75/A-76/A-77/A-78) extends to ninth+ NEW-row cycle pending ADDENDA_STATE backfill.)

---

### R3.57 — 2026-05-20 (autonomous `spec-registry-update` scheduled-task firing — **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing**; zero new spec files detected since R3.56 alias write 2026-05-20 ~03:15 local (+~0h52m at firing 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local). **Filesystem scan since R3.56:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` returned 3 hits, ALL in Operations Docs/ (operations-state ledgers, not spec content) — DRIFT_LOG.md (+6m post-R3.56) + OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (+28m post-R3.56) + RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (+49m post-R3.56). Spec corpus content all stable from R3.56 snapshot — no diff. Per SKILL.md Step 5 ALIAS-ONLY canonical path (mirrors prior R3.54 firing pattern). Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.56 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retained R3.57 alias + R3.57 versioned snapshot only. **Counts:** all unchanged from R3.56. **Changelog backfill in R3.58:** R3.57 §12 changelog entry not added at R3.57 firing — backfilled here in R3.58 for traceability completeness (mirrors R3.50/R3.51/R3.52 pattern where alias-only firings sometimes skipped changelog entry).)

---

### R3.56 — 2026-05-20 (nightly sync auto-bump — **STATE-FILES-CATCHUP bump** with zero new spec files detected since R3.55 alias write 2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC (+~11h at firing), but backfilling R3.55's MSL-captured-but-state-files-missed structural drift. **R3.55 had captured 5 NEW files in MSL §3/§4** (OPA V3.16 + ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.2 AUDITED + DOC24 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 + DOC24 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 + DOC23 FAMILY COHERENCE V1) **but FAILED to update SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md / dashboard.html / carryover prompt** — R3.55 §12 changelog narrative claimed "Carryover prompt bumped V20 → V21" but NO V21 FILE EXISTED in `Prompts/` until today (V20 dated 2026-05-19 10:23 was still the latest V2x file). **Same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping anomaly family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41 phantom-V17 + R3.49 phantom-V19 narrative-vs-execution divergences.** R3.56 today: (a) Backfills SPEC_STATE.md with 1 NEW Core Specs row OPA V3.16 (placement-irregular active-root successor, +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15, seventh active-root placement instance vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed); (b) Backfills ADDENDA_STATE.md with 4 NEW rows — A-70 V5.2 AUDITED in §A.1 (top-level natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-66 V5.1; first observed `_AUDITED` suffix in any subagent chain), A-71 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 in §A.3 (DRAFT successor to A-22 V6.4 operative; first observation of `v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL` working-draft-series pattern in BDSM chain), A-72 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 in §A.3 (DRAFT successor to A-19 R2 via filename canonicalization long-form → short-form pattern, third instance after ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 and DOC23 ADDB V2 → V3), A-74 DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 in §A.6 (NEW cross-cutting reference map V1 spanning Addenda A R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1.1; likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP / NON-OWNER DRAFT); ADDENDA_STATE uses A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74 (skips A-73 to preserve historical row-bound divergence pattern); master spec list §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74; cumulative divergence-by-one pattern extends to EIGHT+ NEW-row cycles. (c) Carryover prompt actually bumped V20 → V21 today (materializing R3.55's phantom claim). V21 captures: (i) OPA V3.15 → V3.16 placement-irregular continuation; (ii) ELNOR_SUBAGENT V5.1 → V5.2 AUDITED audit-suffix variant (first in any subagent chain); (iii) DOC24 BDSM V6.4 → V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 multi-draft pattern emergence; (iv) DOC24 KDA R2 → R3 DRAFT v0.2 with filename canonicalization; (v) DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 cross-cutting reference emergence; (vi) R3.55 phantom V21-claim recovery via today's actual V21 creation. (d) Dashboard regenerated with R3.56 narrative; `lastRefresh` advanced 2026-05-19 → 2026-05-20; new SPECS row for OPA V3.16; new ADDENDA rows for A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74. (e) DRIFT_LOG.md appended with today's catchup entry recording the R3.54 alias-only firing + R3.55 substantive structural drift + today's state-file catchup. **Filesystem scan since R3.55 alias write:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.55.md` returned ZERO hits in active scan folders — no new substantive content drift today; today's R3.56 is purely a state-files-catchup bump recording R3.54 + R3.55 drift in the §12 audit trail (since R3.54 and R3.55 §12 entries did not include the V21 phantom-claim documentation that the operations team needs to track). **Counts:** all unchanged from R3.55 (§3 Core Specifications = 53; §A1 Top-level addenda = 33; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 7; §A6 DOC23 Addenda = 19; §4 Active Addenda = 75; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 76; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER DRAFT = 24; §11 Core total = 54; §11 Grand total = 146). **Audit-cleanup pass** moved R3.55 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`; R3.56 versioned snapshot saved alongside alias write. Active folder retains R3.56 alias + R3.56 versioned only. **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-one cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.56) — today's R3.55-phantom-V21-claim recovery reinforces item #5 (post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files); `stat`-checking `Prompts/V21` after R3.55's narrative write would have caught the divergence at write time. **All R3.55 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-67 V5.1 + A-22 V6.4 + A-19 R2 all retain natural-progression-supersession annotations; OPA placement-irregularity backlog at 7-of-8 (V3.11 lone correctly-placed); two-intra-day-DOC24-redrafting-cluster pattern (BDSM V6.5 + KDA R3 within ~2h window) carried forward as architecturally-significant pattern emergence; cross-cutting DOC23 FAMILY map emergence as new cross-doc consistency artifact; multi-DOC24-draft same-day drift correlation with DOC23 FAMILY map carried forward. **Tracker numbering divergence:** master spec list §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74; ADDENDA_STATE uses A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74; cumulative divergence-by-one pattern intact at A-70/A-71/A-72 with coincidental alignment at A-74. **S-11 BACKUP_LOG carry-forward note:** No new firing observed today; S-11 last fired 2026-05-19 04:17 UTC. Eleven calendar days now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success (5/10 → 5/20). Three urgent Will actions persist unchanged. **S-9 OpenClaw release-alignment carry-forward note:** No new firing today; gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12; cadence lag advances to **twenty-four consecutive days**. **DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal (A-67 in ADDENDA_STATE / A-68 in MSL) authored 2026-05-19 03:06 may begin closing the gap** once integrated.)

### R3.55 — 2026-05-19 (nightly sync auto-bump — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing 5 NEW files since R3.54 alias write 2026-05-19 04:09:42 local, ~9h45m earlier. Second substantive bump today after R3.54 alias-only firing earlier this morning. **New files:** (1) `OPA_V3_16.md` active root, mtime 2026-05-19 10:17:42, size 719,051 bytes, +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15; placement-irregular active-root successor; placement-irregularity backlog extends to 7 instances V3.8/V3.9/V3.10 implicit/V3.12/V3.13/V3.15/V3.16 vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy. (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED.md` top-level, mtime 2026-05-19 09:18:57, size 95,218 bytes; natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-67 V5.1 (R3.53 NEW); +34,080 bytes / +55.7% growth consistent with audit-driven red-team incorporation pattern (analogous to DOC10 R10 → R11 Consolidated expansion via R10/R8 red-team incorporation matrix); first observed `_AUDITED` suffix in any subagent chain. (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_2.md`, mtime 2026-05-19 13:50:39, size 151,668 bytes (+7.5% over A-22 V6.4); v6.5 DRAFT v0.2 successor in BDSM Operative Spec chain; `_DRAFT_v0_2` filename suffix indicates working-draft variant likely first of a v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL series before A-22 supersession. (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2.md`, mtime 2026-05-19 11:54:51, size 93,832 bytes (+28% over A-19 R2); R3 DRAFT v0.2 successor in DOC24 KDA chain with filename canonicalization (long-form `DOC24_ADDENDUM-B [KDA] KNOWLEDGE_DELIVERY_SHARED_CONTRACTS_R2` → short-form `DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2`, analogous to ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 + DOC23 ADDB V2 → V3 canonicalization patterns); +28% size growth suggests substantive R3 expansion likely incorporating cross-references with new A-74 DOC23 family coherence map. (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1.md`, mtime 2026-05-19 12:43:05, size 53,808 bytes; NEW DOC23 family coherence map V1, no prior version; cross-cutting reference document mapping self-learning coherence across DOC23 family addenda (Addenda A R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1.1); likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP / NON-OWNER DRAFT analogous to A-49 Card Integration Map V2 and A-32 ELNOR Search Reference R1. **Two intra-day DOC24 successor drafts within ~2h window** (BDSM V6.5 + KDA R3) — first multi-DOC24-draft drift in single sync window; suggests coordinated DOC24 family redrafting pass possibly triggered by DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1 introduction earlier same day. **Operations-state firings captured pre-scan:** S-11 BACKUP_LOG (+8m post-R3.54) + S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG (+0m alias-write coupled) — both late-coordinated R3.54 post-write housekeeping. **Counts:** §3 Core Specifications 52 → 53 (+1 for OPA V3.16); §A1 Top-level addenda 32 → 33 (+1 for A-71 V5.2 AUDITED); §A3 DOC24 Addenda 5 → 7 (+2 for A-72 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT + A-73 KDA R3 DRAFT); §A6 DOC23 Addenda 18 → 19 (+1 for A-74 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1); §4 Active Addenda 71 → 75 (+4); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 72 → 76 (+4); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER DRAFT 23 → 24 (+1 for OPA V3.16); §11 Core total 53 → 54; §11 Grand total 141 → 146 (+5). **Audit-cleanup pass** moved R3.54 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`; R3.55 versioned snapshot saved alongside alias write. Active folder retains R3.55 alias + R3.55 versioned only. **Carryover prompt bumped V20 → V21** — five new files including DOC24 family redrafting cluster warrant refresh. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.55). Tracker numbering divergence extends to eighth+ NEW-row cycle. A-67 V5.1 + A-22 BDSM V6.4 + A-19 KDA R2 all get natural-progression-supersession annotations pending finalization/archival.)

### R3.54 — 2026-05-19 (nightly sync auto-bump — **ALIAS-ONLY operations-state-only firing**; zero new spec files detected since R3.53 alias write 2026-05-19 03:19:50 local (+0h47m at firing). No new spec content, addenda, or proposals in scanned scope. Only operations-state ledger updates detected: (1) `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:28:29 local; +8m39s post-R3.53; size 227,773 bytes) — late-coordinated R3.53 post-write housekeeping firing; (2) `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 03:46:52 local; +27m02s post-R3.53; size 98,280 bytes) — independent post-R3.53 firing; (3) `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-05-19 04:02:40 local; +42m50s post-R3.53; size 44,930 bytes) — independent post-R3.53 firing. Spec corpus content (DOC1–DOC25, DOC72, DOC73 family, EC_Core_Specs, OPA_V3_15, Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC, addenda subfolder topology, integrated-vs-active status, placement-irregularity backlog of 6 OPA instances) all stable from R3.53 snapshot — no diff. R3.53→R3.54 represents the lightest possible alias bump — versioning continuity preserved for downstream consumers without injecting false drift signal. **Counts:** all unchanged from R3.53. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.53 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure. Active folder retained R3.54 alias + R3.54 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved.)

### R3.53 — 2026-05-19 (nightly sync auto-bump — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing 5 NEW files since R3.52 alias write 2026-05-18 23:08 UTC, ~11h earlier. First R3.x firing today after yesterday's three-bump trail R3.50 + R3.51 + R3.52. **New files:** (1) `OPA_V3_15.md` active root, mtime 2026-05-19 05:36, size 675,447 bytes, +138,064 bytes / +25.7% over V3.13; placement-irregular successor with V3.14 skipped (briefly-extant pattern); placement-irregularity backlog extends to 6 instances vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy. (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1.md` top-level, mtime 2026-05-18 23:55, size 61,138 bytes; natural-progression successor to A-5 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4 via filename canonicalization V4 PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES → V5.1 ARCHITECTURE (analogous to V2 → V3 OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION → OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR pattern in DOC23 Addenda B chain); V5 briefly-extant or skipped; V5.1 is smaller than V4 (~76%) suggesting tighter rewrite or partial-scope spec. (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3.md`, mtime 2026-05-19 03:06, size 76,467 bytes (~98% of R2); DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R3 successor to A-34 R2. **NEW intra-subfolder archive `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/`** created today (folder mtime 2026-05-19 03:09) — first intra-subfolder archive in this subfolder, mirrors `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` pattern from R3.47; populated with R2 amendment proposal + RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 + R2 ADD REVIEW variant. Partial-resolution of long-standing "DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder not formally listed in SKILL.md scope list" backlog item. (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3_COVERAGE_AUDIT.md`, mtime 2026-05-19 03:07, size 3,516 bytes; short coverage-audit companion document attached to R3 amendment proposal — likely `SUPPORT/AUDIT` classification per A-32/A-47 reclassification pattern. (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3.md`, mtime 2026-05-19 03:07, size 19,278 bytes (-37% vs R2); R3 successor to R2 (previously tracked in SPEC_STATE Cross-Cutting/Support as `OpenClaw Release Align`). **No operations-state firings** observed since R3.52 captured them at 2026-05-18 ~17:50 UTC (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 all preserved at R3.52 mtimes; today's R3.53 sync write itself will touch S-3/S-4/S-5 as coordinated post-write housekeeping). **Counts:** §3 Core Specifications 51 → 52 (+1 for OPA V3.15); §4 Active Addenda 67 → 71 (+4 in §A1 for A-67/A-68/A-69/A-70); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 68 → 72 (+4); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER DRAFT 22 → 23 (+1 for OPA V3.15); §11 Core total 52 → 53; §11 Grand total 136 → 141 (+5). **Audit-cleanup pass** moved R3.52 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`; R3.53 versioned snapshot saved alongside alias write. Active folder retains R3.53 alias + R3.53 versioned only. **Carryover prompt bumped V19 → V20** — five new files including major subfolder reorganization warrant refresh. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-nine cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.53). Tracker numbering divergence extends to seventh+ NEW-row cycle.)

### R3.52 — 2026-05-18 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day THIRD-firing **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** after R3.50 substantive + R3.51 operations-state-only fires earlier today. **3 NEW files detected** since R3.51 alias write 2026-05-18 ~04:08 local: (1) `OPA_V3_13.md` in active root (mtime 2026-05-18 10:42; size 537,383 bytes; +9,897 bytes over V3.12 — continues placement-irregular active-root pattern, now 5 placement-irregular instances vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy); (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18; size 474,162 bytes — successor in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain V3.2 → V3.3, first sub-sub-folder-resident successor since R3.49 family-topology decomposition); (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18; size 52,068 bytes — first revision to A-65 Common Contracts V1 since R3.49 introduction; V1 → V1.1 semantic-version increment). Two operations-state firings also captured — S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (+05m19s post-R3.51) attributable as late-coordinated R3.51 post-write housekeeping + S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (+08m49s post-R3.51) INDEPENDENT firing with tenth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF + defensive-pre-check applied — **ends R3.51's "ninth-day silence" characterization**, recharacterizes as tenth-strike confirmed failure. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.51 versioned file from active root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`; R3.52 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write.)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-18 ~17:50 UTC (~10:50 local), ~6.8h after R3.51's alias write at 2026-05-18 ~11:00 UTC. This is the THIRD R3.x firing today.

- **Filesystem deltas since R3.51:** Three NEW files in active scan folders (OPA V3.13 in active root + DOC23 ADDB V3.3 in doc23 add b rework/ sub-sub-folder + DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 in doc23 add b rework/ sub-sub-folder); plus two operations-state firings (S-10 + S-11) and one `(1)`-suffix duplicate of Common Contracts V1.1 in `Archived DOC23 addenda/` (Downloads-copy artifact pending human canonicalization).
- **Spec corpus changes since R3.51:** §3 row counts +1 (OPA V3.13 row 44g). §A6 row counts +2 (A-67 V3.3 + A-68 Common Contracts V1.1 — A-67/A-68 are master spec list numbering; ADDENDA_STATE.md continues divergence-by-two pattern at A-65/A-66 pending sync).
- **(NEW §3 row 44g — OPA V3.13 placement-irregular successor):** `OPA_V3_13.md` in active root (mtime 2026-05-18 10:42, size 537,383 bytes; +9,897 bytes over V3.12 from R3.50). Continues active-root placement-irregular pattern — no return to proper `Operations Docs/` location after V3.11's lone exception. Placement-irregularity backlog now 5 instances (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 implicit + V3.12 + V3.13). Successor to V3.12. Full file-header inspection deferred. Per file size growth of ~10KB suggests incremental patch/audit-closure content rather than major architectural addition. Placement-pattern-alternation theory (R3.50) downgraded — V3.13 is the third consecutive placement-irregular file in the V3.12/V3.13 sequence.
- **(NEW §A6 row A-67 — DOC23 Addenda B Addendum Outcome Evaluator/Revisor V3.3 sub-sub-folder successor):** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_3.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18, size 474,162 bytes; +12,914 bytes over V3.2 from R3.49). DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain progression now V2 → V3 → V3.1 → V3.2 → V3.3. First successor file materializing in the sub-sub-folder `doc23 add b rework/` since R3.49 introduced that pattern. Expected per V3.2's "Pending red-team review per §25" status — V3.3 likely incorporates red-team findings or further architectural refinement.
- **(NEW §A6 row A-68 — DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 sub-sub-folder first revision):** `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-18 10:18, size 52,068 bytes; +5,490 bytes over V1 from R3.49). First revision to A-65 Common Contracts V1. V1.1 semantic-version increment pattern (vs V2 step). Co-arrival with V3.3 Addendum (16s apart, both 10:18) suggests coordinated edit pass — V3.3 architectural refinement likely drove Common Contracts V1.1 schema revision.
- **Operations-state firings since R3.51:** S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md fired at 04:13:40 local (+05m19s post-R3.51 — late-coordinated R3.51 post-write housekeeping); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md fired at 04:17:10 local (+08m49s post-R3.51 — INDEPENDENT firing with tenth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF + DEFENSIVE-PRE-CHECK-APPLIED). S-11 firing ends R3.51's "ninth-day silence" characterization — silence-vs-failure-with-proof ambiguity from R3.51 resolved to failure-with-proof. BACKUP_LOG content confirms ninth consecutive failure (5/10 through 5/18); `mountpoint /sessions/busy-optimistic-dijkstra/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned "No such file or directory"; `/proc/mounts` confirms `OpenClaw-Shared` absent. Source corpus has grown 22→27 MB in 24 hours per BACKUP_LOG narrative — backup gap more significant each day.
- **Silences confirmed:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md, S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md all preserved at R3.51-window mtimes (no further firings between R3.51 and R3.52).
- **Counts updates in R3.52:** §3 Core Specifications 50 → 51 (+1 for OPA V3.13 placeholder row 44g); §4 Active Addenda 65 → 67 (+2 in §A6 for A-67 V3.3 + A-68 Common Contracts V1.1); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 66 → 68 (+2 net for A-67 + A-68); §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 21 → 22 (+1 for OPA V3.13 placeholder row); §11 Core registry total 51 → 52 (+1); §11 Grand total 133 → 136 (+3).
- **Audit-cleanup pass:** R3.51 versioned snapshot moved from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.51.md` per standard bump procedure; R3.52 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.52.md`. Active folder retains R3.52 alias + R3.52 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.
- **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence:** 28 cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.52). `mountpoint -q` pre-flight remains highest-urgency given S-11 tenth-strike confirmed-failure pattern. Five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog + sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement (R3.49) + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder INCLUDE-list decision all unresolved.
- **Carryover prompt bumped V19 → V20** — three new files + R3.51 → R3.52 substantive drift + S-11 firing-with-proof recharacterization warrant the carryover refresh. V20 captures: (a) OPA V3.12 → V3.13 placement-irregular continuation; (b) DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.2 → V3.3 sub-sub-folder chain advance (first since R3.49 family decomposition); (c) Common Contracts V1 → V1.1 first revision; (d) S-11 silence-mode end + tenth-strike with-proof recharacterization.
- **Recharacterization of R3.51 narrative:** R3.51 was written claiming "S-10 silent + S-11 silent + ninth-day silence-mode" but S-10 fired at +05m19s post-R3.51 alias write and S-11 fired at +08m49s post-R3.51 — both firings occurred AFTER R3.51 alias write at 04:08, so R3.51 narrative was correct as of its write moment but the actual state diverged within ~10 minutes. R3.52 attributes S-10 as late-coordinated R3.51 post-write housekeeping (similar to R3.50 post-write S-3/S-4/S-5 cluster) and S-11 as INDEPENDENT firing with full bind-mount failure proof + defensive-pre-check applied — the second consecutive observed defensive-pre-check run after R3.49's first.
- **All R3.51 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 active-folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; A-53 through A-66 + **A-67 V3.3 NEW** + **A-68 Common Contracts V1.1 NEW** all ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate + R4.1 V6 (1) duplicate + Common Contracts V1.1 (1) duplicate all awaiting deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence MSL §4 vs ADDENDA_STATE.md extends to nine-row cumulative pattern; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window ~488+ hours / 24-day cadence lag; DOC24 R3.1.1 + OPA V3.9 + OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 + OPA V3.13 + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1/V3.2/V3.3 + DOC23 Addenda B family decomposition + DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 V6 chain all carry forward.

---

### R3.51 — 2026-05-18 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day SECOND-firing **operations-state-only bump** after R3.50; zero spec/addenda drift in ~45-min window since R3.50 alias write; four operations-state firings captured — S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG (late-coordinated R3.50 post-write housekeeping at +17m05s / +18m12s / +24m04s) + S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG (independent post-R3.50 firing at +22m05s = canonical daily morning OpenClaw-alignment cadence ~03:39-03:46 local); S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG / S-11 BACKUP_LOG silent this firing; S-11 silence extends URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-TASK-SILENCE to ninth-calendar-day since 2026-05-09 last claimed success.)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-18 ~11:00 UTC (~04:00 local), ~45min after R3.50's alias write at 2026-05-18 ~10:17 UTC (~03:17 local). This is the SECOND R3.x firing today.

- **Filesystem deltas since R3.50:** zero new spec/addenda files in any active scan folder (CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root, all Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolders including DOC23/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj + Connectors and Integrations Addenda + DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs + Integrated Addenda + CD Cross Docs + DOC20 Addenda); zero supersession-chain advances; zero Integrated-Addenda relocations; zero Subsumed Specs/ relocations (other than the audit-cleanup R3.50 versioned-file move detailed below).
- **Operations-state mtime/size deltas (late-coordinated post-R3.50 — attributed to R3.50):** `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` 03:34:40 local (+17m05s post-R3.50 alias write); `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` 03:35:47 local (+18m12s); `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` 03:41:39 local (+24m04s — R3.50 substantive structural-drift narrative entry appended at top documenting OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 + implicit V3.10 archival transit + A-66 R4.1 V6 detections). Coordination window wider than R3.47/R3.48's seconds-to-minutes window because R3.50 substantive drift required additional row writes; cluster tightness (7-min spread) + R3.50-content-only narrative supports R3.50 attribution rather than independent R3.51 firing classification.
- **Operations-state mtime/size deltas (independent post-R3.50):** `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` 2026-05-18 03:39:40 local / 10:39:40 UTC, +22m05s post-R3.50 alias write — daily OpenClaw release-alignment check at canonical morning cadence (~03:39-03:46 local window observed across R3.x history). No other independent firings. Auto pass does not inspect new log content for this cycle; deferred to next manual review pass or next substantive-drift bump.
- **Silences confirmed:** S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime preserved at R3.50 capture value (no firing today's morning cycle); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md preserved (no firing today's morning cycle); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md preserved (no firing today; **ninth-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-TASK-SILENCE** since 2026-05-09 last claimed success; silence-vs-failure-with-proof ambiguity continues; no defensive-pre-check applied this cycle since task did not fire). S-11 backlog: 5/10 fail, 5/11 fail, 5/12 implied-silence, 5/13 fail, 5/14 fail, 5/15 fail (bind-mount-proof), 5/16 silent, 5/17 fail (defensive-pre-check applied), 5/18 silent (this cycle).
- **§11 totals unchanged from R3.50:** Grand total 133; PROPOSED ADDENDUM 66; SUPPORT/NON-OWNER DRAFT 21; CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT 29; Core registry total 51; §A6 active rows 13; §A7 active rows 2; §7 row count 12.
- **S-9 narrative summary:** S-9 fired at canonical morning cadence (+22m05s post-R3.50); content delta from R3.50 capture not inspected this auto-pass cycle. Carry-forward: stable holds at 2026.5.12 from R3.48 capture (T+4 days old if no new stable today); gap composition assumed UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10; cadence lag advances to 22 consecutive days (was 21 at R3.48; +4 days through R3.49/R3.50/R3.51); v2026.5.14-beta.2 prerelease watch + #82069 Codex OAuth refresh regression carry-forward. Beta dist-tag activity from R3.48 (5.14-beta.2 → 5.16-beta.1 → 5.16-beta.3) may have advanced further; deferred to next substantive-drift bump for content review.
- **DRIFT_LOG entry to append this cycle:** R3.51 operations-state-only bump narrative + S-11 ninth-day silence-mode milestone + R3.50 late-coordinated post-write attribution observation.
- **Audit-cleanup pass:** R3.50 versioned snapshot moved from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.50.md` (1,009,733 bytes, mtime 03:17:28 local preserved through move); R3.51 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.51.md`. Active folder retains R3.51 alias + R3.51 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.
- **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence:** 27 cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.51). `mountpoint -q` pre-flight remains highest-urgency item given continued S-11 silence/failure pattern (ninth-calendar-day milestone). Five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog + sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement (R3.49) + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder INCLUDE-list decision all unresolved.
- **Carryover prompt remains V19** — no spec-folder structural drift since R3.50; V19 still captures all R3.49 + R3.50 narrative (sub-sub-folder pattern, family-topology decomposition, OPA V3.11/V3.12 placement-pattern alternation, R4.1 V6 chain advance, implicit V3.10 archival transit).
- **All R3.50 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 active-folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; A-53 through A-66 all ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate + R4.1 V6 (1) duplicate awaiting deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence MSL §4 vs ADDENDA_STATE.md preserved (seven-row cumulative divergence pattern); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window ~480+ hours / 24-day cadence lag; DOC24 R3.1.1 + OPA V3.9 + OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1/V3.2 + DOC23 Addenda B family decomposition + DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 V6 chain all carry forward.

---

### R3.50 — 2026-05-18 (nightly sync auto-bump — daily morning firing capturing **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** since R3.49 alias write 2026-05-17 23:10 UTC. Three NEW files detected: (1) `Operations Docs/OPA_V3_11.md` materialized in proper Operations Docs/ location (mtime 2026-05-17 23:45; size 509,424 bytes — first OPA version since V3.7 in proper location, ending V3.8/V3.9 active-root placement-irregularity pattern); (2) `OPA_V3_12.md` materialized in active root (mtime 2026-05-18 07:05; size 527,486 bytes; +18,062 bytes over V3.11 — reverts to placement-irregular active-root pattern); (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-18 06:05; size 405,498 bytes — V6 successor in DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 chain; A-47 R4.1 V2 was last formally tracked predecessor in R3.12 — chain advanced through V3/V4/V5/V6 with intermediate revisions never materialized at sync windows; (1)-suffix filename Downloads-copy pattern). One implicit transit: OPA_V3_10.md now in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` — appeared and was archived between R3.49 and R3.50; never given an active-tracker row analogous to brief-extant R4.1 V1 pattern from R3.12. Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.48 versioned file from active folder → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (was leftover from R3.49 sync per its own narrative); R3.49 versioned file also moved to archive per standard bump procedure; R3.50 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.50 + alias only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant restored).)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-18 ~10:13 UTC (~03:13 local), ~11h after R3.49's alias write at 2026-05-17 ~23:10 UTC.

**Filesystem scan since R3.49:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.49.md` returned three primary file hits in active scan folders plus the implicit OPA V3.10 archival transit:

*(NEW §3 row 44e — OPA V3.11 in proper Operations Docs/ location)*
- **`Operations Docs/OPA_V3_11.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 23:45, size 509,424 bytes). FIRST OPA version since V3.7 to live in proper `Operations Docs/` location, ending V3.8/V3.9 active-root placement-irregularity pattern. V3.11 size +71,278 bytes over V3.9 (438,146 → 509,424) — suggests substantial content expansion likely incorporating DOC24 R3.1.1 follow-on adjudication closure rows or DOC23 Addenda B family-topology absorption rows. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. Successor to OPA V3.9 (active root) and the transit OPA V3.10 (now archived).

*(NEW §3 row 44f — OPA V3.12 placement-irregular successor)*
- **`OPA_V3_12.md`** (active root; mtime 2026-05-18 07:05, size 527,486 bytes; +18,062 bytes over V3.11). Reverts to placement-irregular active-root pattern after V3.11's brief return-to-proper-location. Successor to V3.11. Pattern alternation between proper-location and placement-irregular may suggest Will-side workflow tension between "tidy archival in Operations Docs/" vs "visibility-priority active-root copy." Placement-irregularity backlog now stretches across V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 implicit + V3.12 (four placement-irregular instances) with V3.11 the lone correctly-placed copy. Human classification + path canonicalization needed.

*(NEW §A6 row A-66 — DOC23 Addenda A Task Optimization R4.1 V6 successor)*
- **`Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md`** (mtime 2026-05-18 06:05, size 405,498 bytes). V6 successor in DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 chain. A-47 R4.1 V2 was last formally-tracked predecessor in R3.12; chain advanced V2 → V3 → V4 → V5 → V6 with intermediate revisions never materialized at sync windows (same briefly-extant pattern observed previously for R4.1 V1). V6 size 405,498 bytes ≈ 2.6× A-47 V2's 154,930 bytes — substantial growth across intermediate revisions. Per coordination V3 FINAL outputs noted in R3.49 (A-65 Common Contracts V1 lists "DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3" as consumer), the A-track has been at V3 since coordination V3 work; V6 likely incorporates coordination V3 FINAL outputs plus further audit closure passes. Filename has "(1)" suffix suggesting Will copied from another location (Downloads-copy pattern observed in DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card and DOC23 REPROMPT duplicates).

*(IMPLICIT transit — OPA V3.10 brief-extant archival)*
- **`Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/OPA_V3_10.md`** appeared between R3.49 alias write and this run. V3.10 was never given an active-tracker row (brief-extant pattern). Auto pass records the archival transit but does not create or remove rows since V3.10 was never tracked.

**Operations-state file deltas since R3.49:** SPEC_STATE.md, ADDENDA_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md preserved at R3.49 mtimes pending this run's coordinated post-write touches. S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md, S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtimes carried forward from R3.49 capture (no new firings observed in the ~11h R3.49→R3.50 window).

**Spec corpus changes since R3.49:** Three NEW files as listed above. §3 row counts +2 (OPA V3.11 row 44e + OPA V3.12 row 44f). §A6 row counts +1 (A-66 R4.1 V6 — A-66 is master spec list numbering; ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-65 preserving cumulative divergence-by-one pattern).

**Counts updates in R3.50:** §3 Core Specifications 48 → 50 (+2 for OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 placeholder rows); §4 Active Addenda 64 → 65 (+1 in §A6 for A-66 R4.1 V6); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 65 → 66 (+1 net for A-66); §11 SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 19 → 21 (+2 for OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 placeholder rows); §11 Core registry total 49 → 51 (+2); §11 Grand total 130 → 133 (+3 net).

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.48 versioned file moved from active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.48.md` (was leftover from R3.49 sync per its own deferred-archival narrative — today executes the move). R3.49 versioned file also moved to archive per standard bump procedure. R3.50 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.50 + alias only.

**Carryover prompt bumped V18 → V19** — three new files + R3.49 phantom-V19 backlog of structural drift (sub-sub-folder pattern, family-topology reorganization, six new addenda rows) warrant the carryover refresh that R3.49 narrative claimed but never materialized. V19 captures: (a) the R3.49 sub-sub-folder + family-topology decomposition; (b) DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 V6 advance; (c) OPA V3.11 → V3.12 placement-pattern alternation; (d) implicit V3.10 archival transit. Same phantom-bump family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41/R3.45 alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping precedents.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — three NEW files + R3.48 audit-cleanup-deferral resolution + V19 phantom-materialization makes today's run substantive structural drift even though the R3.49 → R3.50 delta is smaller than R3.48 → R3.49's six-row addition.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-six cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.50). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.49 list with no new items added: five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog + sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement from R3.49 both unresolved.

**All R3.49 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog (DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE, DOC23 Addenda, EC Core Addenda, Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj, DOC73 Addenda and Proposals); sub-sub-folder traversal mode for DOC23 Addenda; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + A-59 V3.1 + A-60 V3.2 + A-61 R0.7 + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 + A-65 Common Contracts V1 + **A-66 R4.1 V6 NEW** all still ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate + R4.1 V6 (1) duplicate both await deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 preserved verbatim (extends to seven-row cumulative divergence pattern); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~456+ hours / 23-day cadence lag**; DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch + OPA V3.9 patch session + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1 successor + DOC23 Addenda B family decomposition (R3.47 + R3.49) all carry forward unchanged in R3.50.

**Tracker numbering divergence carried forward:** MSL §4 uses A-66 for R4.1 V6; ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-65 — preserves R3.33+R3.39+R3.41+R3.44+R3.47+R3.49 cumulative divergence-by-one pattern. Cumulative divergence now extends to SIX NEW-row cycles (six numbered increments diverged from ADDENDA_STATE numbering).

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.50 alias write accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.50.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.49 pattern. R3.49 versioned snapshot moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` in same audit-cleanup pass; R3.48 versioned snapshot also moved this run from R3.49 deferred-archival backlog.

---

### R3.49 — 2026-05-17 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day THIRD-firing **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** after R3.47 substantive + R3.48 operations-state-only fires; **7 NEW addendum files** since R3.48 in DOC23 Addenda subfolder split across the root (1 file — V3.2) and a brand-new sub-sub-folder `doc23 add b rework/` (6 .md files — Core R0.7 supersession of R0.6.4 + Feedback Delivery V1 + Source Workspace V1 + Task Forum + Run Board V1 + Common Contracts V1 + duplicate V3.2 + files.zip packaging); first ever sub-sub-folder pattern at this depth in any tracked top-level Addenda subfolder; represents major architectural decomposition of DOC23 Addenda B work from singular unified draft into Core + V3.2 Addendum + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts family topology; plus 1 independent S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing — eighth consecutive failure but FIRST WITH DEFENSIVE PRE-CHECK applied this run.)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-17 ~23:10 UTC (~16:10 local), ~12h after R3.48's alias write at 2026-05-17 ~11:04 UTC (~04:04 local). This is the THIRD R3.x firing today (R3.47 substantive structural drift at ~10:11 UTC; R3.48 operations-state-only at ~11:04 UTC; R3.49 substantive structural drift at ~23:10 UTC).

**Filesystem scan since R3.48:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.48.md` returned **eight file hits** (seven NEW addendum files in active scan folders + one S-11 operations-state firing):

*(NEW addendum — DOC23 Addenda root)*
- **`Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_2.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:14:43 local = 22:14:43 UTC, size 461,248 bytes — ~5.5% larger than V3.1's 437,051 bytes). Natural-progression successor to A-59 V3.1 in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain (V1 → V2 → V3 → V3.1 → V3.2). Per V3.2 file header: **Status** "V3.2 specification (surgical patch over V3.1 incorporating Addenda A/B coordination V3 FINAL outputs)"; **Version** "3.2"; **Prepared** "2026-05-15 (V3); revised 2026-05-16 (V3.1 audit-complete); revised 2026-05-17 (V3.2 coordination patch)". **Surgical patch nature:** V3.2 is positioned as a patch over V3.1 incorporating Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL outputs (companion to A-65 Common Contracts V1 + A-61 R0.7 Core). **New V3.2 architectural primitive beyond V3/V3.1:** `claims_in` port contract (V3 had only `revision_in`; V3.2 adds `claims_in` as input port for claim-extractor-pipeline integration per coordination V3 FINAL); plus updates to `revision_in` port contract; plus pattern-learning configuration; plus learning-mode configuration. Identical duplicate file exists in the new `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder (byte-identical, 461,248 bytes; auto pass treats as single file at primary location).

*(NEW sub-sub-folder + 5 NEW addendum files within it)*
- **NEW sub-sub-folder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/`** (folder mtime 2026-05-17 15:53). **First ever sub-sub-folder at this depth in any tracked top-level Addenda subfolder** — distinct from intra-subfolder archive pattern (`Archived DOC23 addenda/` introduced in R3.15) and distinct from the top-level Addenda subfolder pattern. Contains 6 NEW .md files + 1 files.zip packaging file representing major architectural decomposition of DOC23 Addenda B work.
- **`doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_CORE_R0_7.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:46 local, size 370,034 bytes). DOC23 Addenda B Core R0.7 supersession of R0.6.4 (= A-53) via family-topology reorganization. Per file header **Revision** "R0.7 Core — supersedes R0.6.4; family-topology reorganization plus Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL absorption"; **Status** "Build-ready Core specification. R0.7 is the family-core for Addenda B's Task Design domain. Outcome Evaluator/Revisor lives in the V3.2 sub-addendum. Source Workspace, Task Forum + Run Board, and Feedback Delivery live in their own sub-addenda. Shared evaluation primitives live in DOC23 Evaluation Common Contracts (sibling to the parent doc)". Four substantive change classes per R0.7 change log: Class 1 family-topology reorganization; Class 2 R0.6.5 base material absorption; Class 3 Addenda A ↔ Addenda B coordination V3 FINAL integration; Class 4 several R0.6.4 §26 open questions resolved.
- **`doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_FEEDBACK_DELIVERY_V1.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:53 local, size 38,711 bytes). Topical sub-addendum to A-61 R0.7 Core. Per file header: "Specification for in-run feedback delivery from evaluators (V3.2 Outcome Evaluator, Addenda A Judge, agent review gates) to downstream consumers (modules, sub-agents, Task Agent, user). Defines the EvaluationFeedbackBundle, defeasible findings, Run Guidance, Repair Instructions, Feedback Routing Policy, four delivery channels, and Feedback Consumption Receipts." Absorbs R0.6.5 §§8-15.
- **`doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_V1.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:50 local, size 33,326 bytes). Topical sub-addendum to A-61 R0.7 Core for Task Source Workspace + Source Research/Gathering module + user-facing UI. Absorbs R0.6.5 §§16-18 + §28. Integrates with V3.2 §12 narrow workspace coverage.
- **`doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_SUBSYS_TASK_FORUM_RUN_BOARD_V1.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:56 local, size 36,139 bytes). Topical sub-addendum to A-61 R0.7 Core for passive Task Run Board + active Task Forum module (`system.task_forum`) + Module Assistance Requests + Board Digests + TaskRunContextPacket + moderator modes + user-facing UI surfaces. Absorbs R0.6.5 §§19-22, §27, §31. Integrates with V3.2 §14.9 plan review forum.
- **`doc23 add b rework/DOC23_EVALUATION_COMMON_CONTRACTS_V1.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 15:53:42 local, size 46,578 bytes). Sibling specification to DOC23 R3.1 hosting shared evaluation primitives until DOC23 R3.2 absorbs them at the parent level. Per file header: **Owner** "Joint between Addenda A chat and Addenda B chat per coordination V3 §3.2; conflicts adjudicated by Will" — **first ever explicitly-joint-ownership sibling spec registered in the master spec list**. Per file §0.1 rationale: "Hosting these primitives in one of the addenda would create fragile cross-addendum references and bury shared types inside one addendum's narrative. Per coordination V3 §3.2, the resolution is a sibling document hosting these primitives. Both addenda reference this document. When DOC23 R3.2 compiles, the primitives migrate to the parent doc and this document retires (§11)." Hosts: EvaluationResultEnvelope, EvaluationLearningSignalEnvelope, Criterion, ArtifactScopeRef, TextAnchor, StructuredAnchor.
- *(duplicate file — not tracked as separate row)* `doc23 add b rework/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_2.md` (mtime 15:53:07 local, size 461,248 bytes — byte-identical to root V3.2 = A-60 row).
- *(packaging artifact — not tracked as separate row)* `doc23 add b rework/files.zip` (160,315 bytes, mtime 2026-05-17 15:54:00) — likely the export bundle from the authoring environment.

*(NEW operations-state firing — independent post-R3.48)*
- **S-11 `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md`** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-17 04:17:30 local = 11:17:30 UTC, size 34,099 bytes — +4,080 bytes from R3.46 capture 30,019 bytes; +13m26s post-R3.48 alias write at 04:04 local — clearly outside coordinated post-write window, classified as independent post-R3.48 firing).

**S-11 narrative:** OneDrive backup task's 2026-05-17 11:16 UTC run was the **EIGHTH consecutive failure but FIRST WITH DEFENSIVE PRE-CHECK** applied this run. Unlike runs 5/15 and 5/16, the directory-existence check was performed BEFORE the `mkdir -p` step, so no sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/` scaffolding was created and no bogus tarball was written and then deleted. This is the manual application of the hardening recommendation that has been pending for three runs. Workspace state at end of run matches what was visible at session start. Bind-mount verification: `mountpoint /sessions/nice-zen-shannon/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned `No such file or directory`; `mountpoint /sessions/nice-zen-shannon/mnt/ECQ Development` returned `is a mountpoint`. Ends two-consecutive-day silence (5/15-5/16 silent) by returning to firing, but is the eighth-consecutive-failure overall since 2026-05-09 last claimed success. Eight calendar days now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup. The 2026-05-17 log entry includes a concrete patch suggestion for SKILL.md Step 1: `mountpoint -q "$WORKSPACE_MNT/OpenClaw-Shared" 2>/dev/null || { echo "ERROR: OneDrive folder not bind-mounted — needs reconnect" >&2; exit 1; }` — placed BEFORE the existing `mkdir -p "$DEST"` line. Will-side three-pronged action from R3.42/R3.43/R3.47/R3.48 remains the priority: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button (eight consecutive runs pending; folder was last successfully connected per task spec on 2026-05-02; something disconnected it on or before 2026-05-10); (2) independently verify on host whether prior tarballs accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` (per 5/15 bind-mount finding, the 5/04 through 5/09 "successful" runs may have been writing to ephemeral sandbox paths the whole time); (3) implement `mountpoint -q` pre-flight in S-11 task SKILL.md (now manually applied this run as a defensive pattern — not yet automated in SKILL.md; today's manual application demonstrates the patch works as intended).

**S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 unchanged from R3.48 capture:** SPEC_STATE.md (03:12:54 / 79,730 bytes), ADDENDA_STATE.md (03:12:54 / 77,643 bytes), DRIFT_LOG.md (03:15:59 / 206,442 bytes), RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (preserved from R3.45 capture 2026-05-16 04:03:04 / 58,531 bytes), OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (preserved from R3.48 capture 03:46:24 / 84,689 bytes), RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (preserved from R3.46 capture 2026-05-16 04:09:03 / 84,829 bytes). No new ticks on any of these between R3.48 and R3.49.

**Spec corpus changes since R3.48:** SEVEN new addendum files as listed above. §A6 row counts +6 (A-60 V3.2 + A-61 R0.7 + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 + A-63 Source Workspace V1 + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 + A-65 Common Contracts V1). §A6 active row count: 12 → 18 (was 12 in R3.48 inherited from R3.47 with intra-subfolder-archive annotations on V3 + V2 rows; +6 in R3.49). §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM count: 59 → 65. §11 Grand total: 124 → 130. No core spec changes. No `Subsumed Specs/` reclassifications. No `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/` changes.

**Counts updates in R3.49:** §3 Core Specifications 48 — unchanged from R3.47; §4 Active Addenda 58 → 64 (+6 in §A6 for A-60 through A-65); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 59 → 65; §11 Grand total 124 → 130.

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.47 versioned file already moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule in R3.48 sync; R3.48 versioned file preserved in active folder pending audit-cleanup move next sync; R3.49 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.49.md`. Per the audit-cleanup rule, active folder retains R3.49 alias + R3.48 versioned snapshot + R3.49 versioned snapshot only (R3.48 to be archived next sync). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**Carryover prompt bumped V18 → V19** — 6 new addendum files in a brand-new sub-sub-folder pattern representing major architectural decomposition is the largest single-revision structural drift since R3.13's first DOC23 Addenda B entry, warranting carryover refresh. V19 captures: (a) the new sub-sub-folder traversal convention for DOC23 Addenda subfolder; (b) the family-topology reorganization model (Core + Addendum + sub-addenda + sibling Common Contracts); (c) the explicit R0.6.4 → R0.7 supersession; (d) the V3.1 → V3.2 surgical-patch supersession; (e) the joint-ownership sibling-spec pattern for A-65 Common Contracts.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — major architectural decomposition (DOC23 Addenda B singular unified draft → Core + V3.2 + 3 sub-addenda + Common Contracts family) + first ever sub-sub-folder pattern at this depth + 6 NEW addendum files in one window = substantive structural drift event of largest scale in this scheduled task's history.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-five cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.49). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.48 list with one expansion: item (4) now explicitly includes the sub-sub-folder traversal mode for DOC23 Addenda subfolder + decision rule for whether the `doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder is staging area (collapses upward into DOC23 Addenda root when V1 → V2 / Core R0.7 → R0.8 / V3.2 → V4 cycles converge) or permanent organizational pattern (warrants its own §A8 section in future master spec list revision); item (7) `mountpoint -q` pre-flight check is now confirmed working as a manual defensive pattern (today's run applied it manually) but still pending automation in SKILL.md.

**All R3.48 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five-subfolders backlog + NEW sub-sub-folder traversal mode requirement); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + A-59 V3.1 + **A-60 V3.2 NEW + A-61 R0.7 NEW + A-62 Feedback Delivery V1 NEW + A-63 Source Workspace V1 NEW + A-64 Task Forum + Run Board V1 NEW + A-65 Common Contracts V1 NEW** all still ACTIVE pending human archival/classification decisions; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 preserved verbatim (now extends to seven-row cumulative divergence pattern after R3.49 adds six new rows — divergence-by-one carries through A-60/A-61/A-62/A-63/A-64/A-65 to give six additional offset rows; ADDENDA_STATE.md A-59 ↔ MSL A-60, etc.); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~432+ hours / 22-day cadence lag**; DOC24 R3.1.1 audit closure patch + OPA V3.9 patch session + DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3.1 successor all carry forward unchanged in R3.49.

**Tracker numbering divergence carried forward:** MSL §4 uses A-60 for V3.2, A-61 for R0.7, A-62 for Feedback Delivery V1, A-63 for Source Workspace V1, A-64 for Task Forum + Run Board V1, A-65 for Common Contracts V1; ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-59 for V3.2, A-60 for R0.7, A-61 for Feedback Delivery V1, A-62 for Source Workspace V1, A-63 for Task Forum + Run Board V1, A-64 for Common Contracts V1 — preserves R3.33+R3.39+R3.41+R3.44+R3.47 cumulative divergence-by-one pattern, now extending to SIX additional NEW-row offsets in single cycle. Cumulative divergence stretches to **eleven NEW-row cycles** (R3.33 + R3.39 + R3.41 + R3.44 + R3.47 + R3.49 — last cycle alone adds six divergent offsets).

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.49 alias write accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.49.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.48 pattern. R3.48 versioned snapshot to be moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` next sync (audit-cleanup step).

---

### R3.48 — 2026-05-17 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day FOLLOW-UP operations-state-only bump after R3.47; zero spec/addenda drift in ~53-min window since R3.47 alias write; exactly one independent post-R3.47 operations-state firing captured — S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG at 10:46:24 UTC — plus three coordinated R3.47 post-write touches on S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG; S-9 logs latest stable holds at 2026.5.12 for third consecutive quiet stable day (T+3 days old), gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10, twenty-one-day cadence-lag milestone reached, beta dist-tag rolled 5.14-beta.2 → 5.16-beta.1 → 5.16-beta.3 abandoning yesterday's 5.14-beta.2 watch row; S-11 BACKUP_LOG SILENT for second consecutive day, eighth-calendar-day cloud-recoverability gap since 2026-05-09 success.)

- **Filesystem deltas since R3.47:** zero new spec/addenda files in any active scan folder; zero supersession-chain advances; zero Integrated-Addenda relocations; zero Subsumed Specs/ relocations.
- **Operations-state mtime/size deltas (independent post-R3.47):** `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` 2026-05-17 03:46:24 local / 10:46:24 UTC, 84,689 bytes — entry-header firing time 10:44 UTC, +35min13s post-R3.47 alias write at 03:11:11 local. No other independent firings.
- **Operations-state mtime/size deltas (coordinated post-R3.47 — attributed to R3.47):** `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` 03:12:54 (79,730 bytes, +85s); `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` 03:12:54 (77,643 bytes, +85s); `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` 03:15:59 (206,442 bytes, +4m48s — R3.47's SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL DRIFT append).
- **Silences confirmed:** S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-16 04:03:04 (no firing today); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md preserved at 2026-05-16 04:09:03 (no firing today); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md preserved at 2026-05-16 04:18:03 (no firing today; second consecutive silent day; eighth-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-TASK-SILENCE).
- **§11 totals unchanged from R3.47:** grand total 124; PROPOSED ADDENDUM count 59; §A6 active rows 12; §A7 active rows 2; §7 row count 12.
- **S-9 narrative summary:** stable holds at 2026.5.12 for T+3 days (third quiet day); gap UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10; cadence lag advances to 21 consecutive days (was 20 at R3.45); beta dist-tag jumped 5.14-beta.2 → 5.16-beta.1 → 5.16-beta.3 (yesterday's 24-72h watch for 5.14-beta.2 → stable did NOT materialize; next stable cut likely folds two beta lineages). Issue #82069 Codex OAuth refresh regression carry-forward.
- **DRIFT_LOG entry to append this cycle:** S-9 21-day cadence lag milestone + beta dist-tag 5.14-beta.2 → 5.16 jump (yesterday's watch row abandoned) — narrative-significant.
- **Audit-cleanup pass:** R3.47 versioned snapshot preserved at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.47.md` (911,793 bytes, 03:11:11 local); R3.48 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write at `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.48.md`. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.
- **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence:** 24 cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.48). `mountpoint -q` pre-flight remains highest-urgency item given second consecutive S-11 silence.
- **Carryover prompt remains V17** — no spec-folder structural drift.

### R3.47 — 2026-05-17 (nightly sync auto-bump — **SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump** capturing 3 NEW files since R3.46; first substantive structural drift since R3.44 on 2026-05-16; ends two-revision window R3.45/R3.46 of operations-state-only / fire-only bumps; first ever R3.47-window appearance of three NEW files in three distinct categories: core-spec patch successor, OP-A version successor, addendum chain V3.1 successor; intra-subfolder archival event for V3+V2+older DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain predecessors)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-17 ~10:08 UTC (~03:08 local), ~22.5 hours after R3.46's alias write at 2026-05-16 11:30 UTC. This is the FIRST R3.x firing today.

**Filesystem scan since R3.46:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.46.md` returned exactly three file hits in active scan folders plus one Subsumed Specs reclassification event:

*(NEW core spec — active root)*
- **`DOC24_R3_1_1.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 03:58:00 local = 10:58 UTC, size 292,034 bytes) — R3.1.1 audit closure patch successor to R3.1. Per R3.1.1 file header: "Version R3.1.1; Status Consolidated (§0 through §38 + Appendices A–D; 7 audit-identified gaps closed per audit report 2026-05-17; ready for fresh-window reviewer prompts); Lineage R3 + V1 (136 adjudication cards) + V1.1 (cross-card normalization) + V1.2 (citation hygiene) + V1.3 (HH preflight closure) + V1.4 (II missed R3 field restorations + lint citations) + R3.1 audit closure." Seven gaps closed: (1) HH.4.10 `applyMatrixConfidenceAdjustmentSafe` body added to §13.4B.2 with `BETA_EPSILON`/`EFFECTIVE_BETA_TOTAL_CAP` constants; (2) HH.12 `ExtractionPromptSectionId` A–I enum + `DEFAULT`/`LONG_CHUNK` orderings + `LongChunkMitigation` added as new §38.19 (dangling §38.X reference fixed); (3) HH.15.8 token-count write-time rule + `TokenizerDriftCheckPolicy`/`TokenizerDriftObservation` added to §38.11.5; (4) Y.14 `WatchpointRef` discriminated union added as §5.4.1.Z; (5) Y.15 `ObservedActionRef` added as §5.4.1.AA; (6) Y.23 `SessionInjectionManifest` added as §5.4.1.BB with `reconciliation_overlay` variant renamed to `reconciliation_event` per HH.3 event model; (7) II.4.2 `walkPacketDecisionGraph` paste-ready body added to §38.10.1. Per file header: "No directional changes — all patches are pure-add from V1.x canonical sources." Addendum table reaffirms BDSM V6.5+ + KDA R3+ as referenced companions.

*(NEW Support/Operations file — active root, placement-irregular)*
- **`OPA_V3_9.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 07:15:26 local = 14:15 UTC, size 438,146 bytes) — successor to OPA V3.8. Per file header: "OP-A V3.9 — Generated by V3.9 patch session per V4 §0.3 (DOC24 R3.1.1 V1.x adjudication closure landing)"; "Version: V3.8" (header still shows V3.8 in version field — likely a header-not-yet-updated transient; filename and explicit title both V3.9); "Folder: `ECQ Development/DOC73 R1.6 Build/` (working folder for V1.6 wave); to be promoted to `Current Specs/Operations Docs/` once V1.6 wave settles." Placement irregularity continues from V3.8: official location is `DOC73 R1.6 Build/` but active-root copy maintained for visibility. Likely byte-identical to a `DOC73 R1.6 Build/OPA_V3_9.md` companion (same pattern as V3.8 in R3.18 sync) — auto pass does not verify the companion exists, only records the active-root copy. Supersedes OPA V3.8 in active root + DOC73 R1.6 Build/. Both V3.8 + V3.9 retained in active root pending human classification + path canonicalization.

*(NEW addendum — DOC23 Addenda subfolder)*
- **`Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3_1.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 03:28:00 local = 10:28 UTC, size 437,051 bytes — ~21% larger than V3's 360,081 bytes). Natural-progression successor to A-57 V3 in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain (V1 → V2 → V3 → V3.1). Filename pattern V3 → V3_1 indicates post-V3 patch/revision (analogous to DOC73 V1.4 → V1.4.1 patch pattern). Auto pass treats as natural-progression successor; full content delta from V3 not captured by auto pass (file header read not performed for this auto-detection cycle — Will to annotate or red-team). V3 file MOVED to local archive (see subfolder reorganization below) — A-57 V3 row in §A6 retained with intra-subfolder-archive annotation per auto pass no-removal policy. Detection sequence: V3.1 created ~03:28; V3 moved to archive ~04:15 (likely human reorganization after V3.1 creation, manually cleaning up the chain).

*(Subsumed Specs reclassification — global archive)*
- **`Subsumed Specs/DOC24_R3_1_CONSOLIDATED.md`** (mtime 2026-05-17 03:58:00 local = 10:58 UTC, size 279,846 bytes). Was the R3.1 consolidated working draft (predecessor to R3.1.1). Moved to `Subsumed Specs/` in same 03:58 window as DOC24_R3_1_1.md creation — atomic supersession-and-archive operation. R3.1 file was never tracked by SPEC_STATE.md or master spec list (it lived briefly between R3 = DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md and R3.1.1 = DOC24_R3_1_1.md). Per R3.1.1 file header lineage: "R3 + V1 (136 adjudication cards) + V1.1 + V1.2 + V1.3 + V1.4 + R3.1 audit closure" — R3.1 consolidation was the V1.4 product that R3.1.1 then patched. Auto pass records the Subsumed reclassification but does NOT add or remove rows since R3.1 was never tracked.

*(Subfolder reorganization — local intra-subfolder archive)*
- **NEW subfolder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`** (folder mtime 2026-05-17 04:15). Populated with files moved from DOC23 Addenda root: `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3.md` (= A-57 row), `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md` (= A-55 row), and several older predecessor files (`DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_CONTEXT_MANAGEMENT_PROPOSAL_V1.md`, `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_R0_5_AUDIT_COMPLETE_MERGE_PACK_TASK_INVOCATION_TA_PROMPT_EVAL.md`, `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md`, `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md`, `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_3_SURFACE_CONTEXT_PATCHED.md`, `DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md`). This is LOCAL intra-subfolder archival — distinct from global `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archive at the `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root level. Pattern is analogous to how core-spec authors sometimes create per-author working-folder archives. Auto pass treats the local archive as out-of-scope for active addenda tracking (parallel to global archive treatment) and annotates affected §A6 rows accordingly.

**Operations state files unchanged from R3.46 capture:** S-3 SPEC_STATE.md, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md, S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, S-10 BACKUP_LOG.md, S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtimes/sizes preserved at R3.46 values until this run's writes. R3.47 sync run will then advance S-3/S-4/S-5 (the three state files this job maintains: SPEC_STATE, ADDENDA_STATE, DRIFT_LOG) plus dashboard.html.

**S-11 BACKUP_LOG silence note:** No new firing observed today; consistent with the silence-vs-failure-with-proof pattern flagged in R3.45. **Eight calendar days now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success** (5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15, 5/16, 5/17). Three urgent Will actions persist unchanged from R3.45/R3.46.

**S-9 OpenClaw release-alignment unchanged:** No new firing; gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12; twenty-one-day cadence lag.

**Spec corpus changes since R3.46:** THREE new files as listed above. §3 row counts +2 (DOC24 R3.1.1 + OPA V3.9 placeholders). §4 row counts +1 (V3.1). §A6 active row count: 12 → 13 with intra-subfolder-archive annotations on V3 + V2 rows. §11 Grand total: 123 → 124.

**Counts updates in R3.47:** §3 Core Specifications 46 → 48; §4 Active Addenda 57 → 58; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 58 → 59; §11 Grand total 123 → 124; §11 Core registry total 47 → 49; §11 CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT 28 → 29 (DOC24 R3.1.1 placeholder); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER DRAFT 18 → 19 (OPA V3.9 placeholder).

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.46 versioned file will be moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.47 alias + R3.47 versioned snapshot only. Per the same rule, only the current N + N-1 versioned snapshots are retained outside the archive; older snapshots (R3.0–R3.45, and R3.46 once this run completes) live under archive for traceability.

**Carryover prompt bumped V17 → V18** — substantive structural drift (3 new files in 3 distinct categories) warrants a bump. V18 captures the R3.47 sync events.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — three new file events + one Subsumed reclassification + one intra-subfolder reorganization.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-three cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.47). Recommendations carried forward unchanged.

**All R3.46 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending human archival decision; A-2 DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 PROPOSAL_V1 still preserved; S-9 OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (twenty-one-day cadence lag); v2026.5.14-beta.2 prerelease watch + #82069 Codex OAuth refresh regression carry-forward all preserved.

**Tracker numbering divergence carried forward:** MSL §4 uses A-59 for V3.1; ADDENDA_STATE.md uses A-58 — preserves R3.33+R3.39+R3.41+R3.44 cumulative divergence-by-one pattern. Cumulative divergence now extends to FIVE NEW-row cycles (R3.33 + R3.39 + R3.41 + R3.44 + R3.47).

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.47 alias write accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.47.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.46 pattern. R3.46 versioned snapshot will be moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (audit-cleanup step described above).

---

### R3.46 — 2026-05-16 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day THIRD-firing operations-state-only bump after R3.45; zero spec/addenda drift in ~11-min window since R3.45 alias write; exactly one independent operations-state firing captured — S-11 BACKUP_LOG at 11:18 UTC — plus one coordinated-completion R3.45 post-write touch on S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md; SECOND-day-running BACKUP_LOG bind-mount-failure confirmation; tenth-strike consecutive disconnected run; seven-calendar-day cloud-recoverability gap since 2026-05-09 success.)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-16 ~11:30 UTC (~04:30 local), ~23 minutes after R3.45's alias write at 11:07:10 UTC. This is the THIRD R3.x firing today (R3.44 substantive at ~10:13 UTC; R3.45 operations-state-only at ~11:07 UTC; R3.46 operations-state-only at ~11:30 UTC).

**Filesystem scan since R3.45:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.45.md` returned exactly two operations-state file hits, categorized per the established R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40/R3.42/R3.44/R3.45 attribution pattern:

*(coordinated R3.45 post-write touch, attributed to R3.45 — nightly-summary task completion finalize)*
- `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 04:09:03 local = 11:09:03 UTC, size 84,829 bytes — +1m53s after R3.45 alias write; the LOG entry header timestamps the run at 10:55 UTC and documents the R3.44-window state — not new R3.46-window state — so attribution to R3.45's nightly-summary task is correct.)

*(independent post-R3.45 firing — R3.46's actual delta)*
- **S-11 `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md`** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-16 04:18:03 local = 11:18:03 UTC, size advanced 26,301 → 30,019 bytes / +14.1% / +3,718 bytes; +10m53s after R3.45 alias write — clearly outside the coordinated ~2-min post-write window, classified as an independent scheduled-task firing.)

**S-11 narrative:** OneDrive backup task's 2026-05-16 11:18 UTC run was the **SECOND CONSECUTIVE day** with bind-mount-verification pre-flight enabled, and the result is identical to 5/15's finding: `mountpoint /sessions/adoring-dazzling-galileo/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned 'is not a mountpoint' while `mountpoint /sessions/adoring-dazzling-galileo/mnt/ECQ Development` returned 'is a mountpoint'. A 5.81 MB tarball (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-16_111641.tgz`) was written to the sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/` scaffold and then deleted per task constraint #4 (never fall back to writing to local paths that won't sync), and the scaffold itself was `rmdir`-ed to restore session-start state. This is the **tenth consecutive disconnected backup run** (5/10, 5/11, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15, 5/16 — 5/12 had no log entry / suggesting failed-before-log; earlier 5/04-5/09 'successful' runs are now retroactively suspect per the 5/15 bind-mount finding which empirically proved the ephemeral-mount masking failure mode that may have masked all pre-5/15 'successes'). **Seven calendar days have now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success.** Three urgent Will actions persist unchanged from 5/15: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder to Cowork via the chat-box '+' button; (2) independently verify on the host whether `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` contains any tarballs at all; (3) harden the backup task script with an explicit `mountpoint -q "$(dirname "$DEST")" || exit` pre-flight BEFORE the `mkdir -p` in Step 1, failing closed when the parent is not a real mount.

**S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md / S-9 / S-10 unchanged from R3.45**: SPEC_STATE.md (03:14:25 / 77,145 bytes), ADDENDA_STATE.md (03:15:54 / 72,618 bytes), DRIFT_LOG.md (03:19:43 / 194,752 bytes), RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (04:03:04 / 58,531 bytes), OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (03:44:22 / 76,704 bytes). No new ticks on any of these between R3.45 and R3.46.

**Spec corpus changes since R3.45:** NONE. No new addendum files in any tracked Addenda subfolder. No core spec changes. No `Subsumed Specs/` reclassifications. No `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/` changes. Section counts unchanged.

**Counts updates in R3.46:** §3 and §4 row counts unchanged from R3.45. §11 counts unchanged. §7 row mtime / size fields updated for S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md only (all other operations-state rows unchanged).

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.45 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.46 alias + R3.46 versioned snapshot only. Per the same rule, only the current N + N-1 versioned snapshots are retained outside the archive; older snapshots (R3.0-R3.43, and now R3.44 once R3.45 is archived) live under `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` for traceability.

**Carryover prompt V17 unchanged** — no new spec corpus drift requires a bump beyond V17 from R3.44.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — single S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing event noted; bind-mount-failure confirmation for second consecutive day; spec corpus drift NONE.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-two cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.46). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.45.

**All R3.45 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending human archival decision; A-2 DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 PROPOSAL_V1 still preserved; S-9 OpenClaw release-alignment gap unchanged at BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (twenty-day cadence lag); v2026.5.14-beta.2 prerelease watch + #82069 Codex OAuth refresh regression carry-forward all preserved.

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.46 alias write accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.46.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.45 pattern. R3.45 versioned snapshot will be moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` (audit-cleanup step described above).

---

### R3.45 — 2026-05-16 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump after R3.44; zero spec/addenda drift in 57-min window since R3.44 alias write; two independent operations-state file firings captured (S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER at 10:43 UTC + S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY at ~11:03 UTC); S-9 logs latest-stable holds at 2026.5.12 for second consecutive quiet stable day (T+2 days old), gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10, twenty-day cadence-lag milestone reached, NEW v2026.5.14-beta.2 prerelease watch row plus #82069 Codex OAuth refresh regression carry-forward; S-11 BACKUP_LOG SILENCE today after R3.43 ninth-strike bind-mount-proof — seven calendar days now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup since 2026-05-09 success; provisional tenth-strike characterization is SILENCE rather than failure-with-proof)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-16 ~11:10 UTC (~04:10 local), ~57 minutes after R3.44's write at 2026-05-16 ~10:13 UTC (~03:13 local). Triggered by `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.44.md` returning exactly two independent operations-state file hits (S-9 + S-8) since R3.44 alias write, plus three coordinated R3.44 post-write touches attributable to R3.44 itself per the established attribution pattern.

**Filesystem scan since R3.44:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.44.md` returned two categories of hits:

*(coordinated R3.44 post-write touches, attributed to R3.44 per established R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40/R3.42 pattern — within ~10 minutes of R3.44 alias write at 03:13:14 local)*
- `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 03:14:25 local = 10:14:25 UTC, size 77,145 bytes — +71s after R3.44 alias write; R3.44's own SPEC_STATE update touch)
- `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 03:15:54 = 10:15:54 UTC, size 72,618 bytes — +2m40s; R3.44's own ADDENDA_STATE update touch capturing A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 new rows)
- `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 03:19:43 = 10:19:43 UTC, size 194,752 bytes — +6m29s; R3.44's own DRIFT_LOG append documented in R3.44 narrative)

*(independent post-R3.44 firings — R3.45's actual delta)*
- **S-9 `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md`** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-16 03:44:22 local = 10:44:22 UTC, size 76,704 bytes; entry-header firing time 2026-05-16 10:43 UTC; +30 minutes post-R3.44 alias write)
- **S-8 `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md`** (mtime advanced to 2026-05-16 04:03:04 local = 11:03:04 UTC, size 58,531 bytes; +50 minutes post-R3.44 alias write)

**No other firings:** S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 04:17:55 from R3.43 capture (no firing today; SILENCE after yesterday's bind-mount-proof event); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 04:10:31 from R3.42 capture (no firing today); S-3/S-4/S-5/S-7 unchanged from R3.44 capture. No new files in any active spec folder, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations.

**S-9 narrative:** OpenClaw release-tracker 2026-05-16 10:43 UTC nightly check logs latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14 18:28 UTC) for **second consecutive quiet stable day** since the 5/14 cut ended the 7-day stable pause. 2026.5.12 now T+2 days old; well within normal post-architectural-release patch-window cadence (typical pattern: large stable release → 1-3 day pause → patch or watch-pause-extension). Gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-10 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7, 2026.5.12; version-number sequence skips 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 / 2026.5.8 / 2026.5.9 / 2026.5.10 / 2026.5.11 / 2026.5.13 entirely — 5.9/5.10/5.14 exist only as betas, others not at all). Single-release roll-forwards now lagged **twenty consecutive days** — R3.45 captures the twenty-day cadence-lag milestone (was nineteen per R3.42 5/15 capture, was seventeen per R3.40 5/14 capture; +1 each day since pause halts gap growth, does not narrow it; 8→9→10 jump from 5/14 stable cut now held at 10 for second day). **NEW beta observation in this entry:** `v2026.5.14-beta.2` prerelease tag dated 2026-05-15 11:11 UTC (per WebSearch — additions to Channels/SDK for normalized command turn facts to channel turn construction, command-turn helpers for plugin inbound contexts, dependency refreshes, Canvas updates, UI/i18n touches, Telegram support changes, and assorted agent functionality improvements; details not yet inspected line-by-line) on the beta dist-tag, following the previously-tracked `v2026.5.14-beta.1` (2026-05-14/15 — first 5.14-beta line cut after 5.12 stable). **GitHub issue #82069** documents `v2026.5.14-beta.1` Codex OAuth refresh `401 token_expired` regression report post-#80738 fix; beta.2 ships subsequently but #82069 may reopen the Codex-route saga (closed in R3.42 as safe three-act: 5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). Beta dist-tag only — does not promote into stable alignment basis until cut on latest dist-tag. Version-number sequence continues to skip `v2026.5.13` entirely (5.12 → 5.14-beta.1 → 5.14-beta.2, no 5.13 of any form observed). Dashboard updates from this S-9 firing: `lastChecked` → '2026-05-16'; `recommendation` rewritten to reflect today's no-new-stable finding, T+2-day-old 5.12 stable, 20-day cadence lag, new v2026.5.14-beta.2 beta watch row plus open #82069 Codex OAuth refresh issue, and watch trigger for if/when 5.14-beta.2 promotes to stable; `releasesSinceLastCovered` / `latestReleaseChecked` / `latestReleaseCheckedDate` / `gapStatus` all preserved (unchanged); alignment-doc fields preserved per task constraints (alignment docs themselves not modified). Standing strong recommendation to actually start drafting DOC11 R15 R3 consolidated amendment continues to compound — R3 should fold all ten backlog releases in one consolidated pass, with Codex-route saga folded as a single closed three-act item rather than three separate rows; companion next-R of running list carries same logic. **WATCH:** if v2026.5.14-beta.2 promotes to stable (most likely as v2026.5.13 or v2026.5.14 within next 24-72h based on 5.12 beta lineage cadence of beta.1 → beta.4 → beta.5 → beta.6 → stable taking ~5 days), backlog jumps to 11 and the R3 pass becomes more time-sensitive; also worth tracking whether #82069 reopens the Codex-route saga in stable form before R3 lands.

**S-8 narrative:** RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md refreshed at 2026-05-16 11:03 UTC (mtime 04:03 local). Refresh captures: Section 1 NEW V3 spec + R0.2 proposal entries (5/16 NEW addendum file pair documented in R3.44 — DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 360 KB / 8,555 lines + Unified Workspace/Library/Work Context Proposal R0.2 88 KB / 3,220 lines); Section 2 supersession-status updates (V2 → V3 / R0.1 → R0.2 chains; V2 + V1 + R0.1 predecessor files retained ACTIVE pending archival decisions); §"Suggested next actions" priority reshuffling that promotes **DOC24 R3 → R3.1 spec compilation (gated on V1.3 Adjudication Card 5/16)** to #1 priority (highest-leverage single move; closes longest-running RT adjudication chain V1 → V1.1 → V1.2 → V1.3; unblocks DOC73 V1.6 capability registry / reason-code namespace dependency per V1.6 README §5) and **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 architect review + post-RT corrective pass (if needed)** to #2 priority (V3 SPEC is post-adjudication tightening of V2 absorbing Card V3.1 + Canonicalization Patch V2; ChatGPT V3.1 review 5/16 graded card A-/B+ but flagged second-order integration bugs; may need V3.1 corrective spec). **DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R3 (consolidated TEN-release pass)** is now demoted to #3 priority with explicit note of ~336+ hour drafting window and 20-day cadence lag; **OneDrive backup chain URGENT OPERATIONAL ACTION** is #4 with three-pronged Will-action item; **Unified Workspace / Library / Resume Work Proposal R0.2 — architect review** is #5 (explicit Supersedes of R0.1; DOC23 demoted to integration-boundary-only; new Library source status model Linked/Indexed/Learned; will-side scope-refinement decision pending). Refresh adds 5/16 NEW entries for **DOC24 R3 Adjudication Card V1.3** (Part HH preflight closure; paste-ready for R3.1 drafting), **DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V2 Combined Adjudication Card V1** (consolidated multi-reviewer round; ~180 findings; 6 convergent CRITICAL), **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Adjudication Card V3** and **V3.1 STANDALONE** (172,642 bytes; inlines all referenced content), and reviewer cards for the V3 / V3.1 adjudication round. Refresh also documents the **DOC23 Addenda B chain at R3.44** (R0.1 global archive → R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4 ACTIVE + Addendum V1 → V2 → V3 chain).

**S-11 narrative:** **NO BACKUP_LOG firing today** — first day in this scheduled task's history that the bind-mount-verification capability has been silent rather than failing-with-proof. BACKUP_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 04:17:55 (yesterday's R3.43 ninth-strike bind-mount-proof entry). **Seven consecutive calendar days now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup** (last successful tarball remains `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` from 2026-05-09; intervening days 5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15 all failed or absent; today 5/16 silent at R3.45 sync time). **Pattern recharacterizes from R3.43's NINTH-STRIKE six-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF to provisional TENTH-STRIKE-SILENCE seven-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-TASK-SILENCE** — **caveat:** task may still fire later today (typical firing times have been 03:00–05:00 local / 10:00–12:00 UTC; today's nominal window has passed without a firing as of R3.45 sync time at ~11:10 UTC, but this is observation-only, not a guarantee of silence for the rest of the day). Per task constraint #4 (no local-only fallback), even if a later firing produces a tarball, that tarball would only be confirmed real if a `mountpoint` pre-flight check passes (the SKILL.md tightening item #7 carry-forward from R3.43 remains un-implemented as of R3.45). Will-side three-pronged action from R3.42/R3.43 remains the priority: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button; (2) verify on host whether prior tarballs actually accumulated (R3.43 bind-mount proof strongly suggests 5/04–5/09 "successful" runs may not have); (3) implement `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || { log "OneDrive not bind-mounted — exiting"; exit; }` pre-flight in S-11 task SKILL.md before next firing.

**Spec corpus changes since R3.44:** NONE. No new addendum files in any tracked Addenda subfolder. No new operative spec files in active root. No movement of any operative spec to or from any archive subfolder. The 57-minute window since R3.44 alias write contains only the two independent operations-state firings (S-9 + S-8) plus R3.44's own coordinated post-write touches (S-3 SPEC_STATE + S-4 ADDENDA_STATE + S-5 DRIFT_LOG). The §A6 row A-57 V3 file + §A7 row A-58 R0.2 file added in R3.44 carry forward unchanged; their predecessor files (A-55 V2 + A-54 V1 in §A6; A-56 R0.1 in §A7) remain ACTIVE pending human archival decisions per auto-pass no-relocation policy.

**Counts updates in R3.45:** §3 and §4 row counts unchanged from R3.44. §7 row mtime / size fields updated for S-9 + S-8 only (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-10/S-11 unchanged from R3.44 capture or earlier). Grand total preserved at **123** (no addendum churn since R3.44; A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 carry forward).

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.44 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.45 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**Carryover prompt remains V17** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V18 bump (same-day operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). V17 from R3.44 still captures the two parallel supersession events (V3 succession of V2 in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain; R0.2 succession of R0.1 in §A7 multi-parent track).

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — S-9 twenty-day cadence-lag milestone + new v2026.5.14-beta.2 watch row + #82069 Codex OAuth refresh issue carry-forward is narrative-significant; S-11 silence-pattern recharacterization (failure-with-proof → silence) is narrative-significant as a new sub-mode of the persistent backup failure. This is NOT a fire-only mechanical bump — narrative-significant content present.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-one cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.45). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.44 list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj + DOC73 Addenda and Proposals subfolders formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md (five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog); (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window — R3.45 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about S-9 + S-8 firings that have already occurred, and explicit "no firing today as of R3.45 sync time" past-tense framing for S-11 silence with explicit caveat that task may still fire later); (7) **`mountpoint -q` pre-flight check** before `mkdir -p` in S-11 BACKUP_LOG task — promoted from R3.43 narrative to formal tightening list item; today's S-11 silence makes implementation more urgent should the task fire again.

**All R3.44 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five not-formally-listed subfolders backlog); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track + Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunities; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + A-57 V3 + A-58 R0.2 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (uses A-56 for V3 / A-57 for R0.2) and master spec list §4 (uses A-57 for V3 / A-58 for R0.2) preserved verbatim; A-54 V1 + A-55 V2 stacked-then-superseded chain in §A6 + A-56 R0.1 in §A7 all still ACTIVE pending human archival decisions; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window stretches to **~336+ hours / 20-day cadence lag** (demoted to priority #3 per today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh, behind DOC24 R3 → R3.1 #1 and DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 architect review #2).

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.45 alias write accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.45.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.44 pattern. R3.5 versioned snapshot gap remains in carry-forward.

---

### R3.44 — 2026-05-16 (nightly sync auto-bump — substantive structural-drift bump capturing 2 NEW addendum files; first substantive structural drift since R3.41 on 2026-05-14; ends two-revision window R3.42/R3.43 of operations-state-only / fire-only bumps; extends supersession chain in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain via V3 succession of V2 + restores supersession pattern in §A7 multi-parent track via R0.2 explicit Supersedes of R0.1)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-16 ~10:10 UTC (~03:10 local), ~17h after R3.43's write at 2026-05-15 ~17:00 UTC. Triggered by autonomous filesystem scan returning two NEW addendum file hits since R3.43.

**Filesystem scan since R3.43:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.43.md` returned exactly **two file hits** in active scan folders, both NEW addendum files:
- `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 02:44 UTC = 2026-05-15 19:44 local; size 360,081 bytes; 8,555 lines)
- `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 00:04 UTC = 2026-05-15 17:04 local; size 88,291 bytes; 3,220 lines)
- (Plus the master spec list file itself from R3.43's alias write.)

**No operations-state file firings** (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 unchanged from R3.43's capture). No operative spec mutations. No other addenda churn. The 17-hour window since R3.43 alias write at 2026-05-15 17:00 UTC contains exactly the two new addendum files and nothing else.

**Substantive structural drift event #1 — §A6 row A-57 V3 succession of V2:** new file V3 is the natural-progression successor to V2 (= A-55 row) and V1 (= A-54 row) in the DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain. **Filename canonicalization:** V3 uses simpler base name `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR` ("Evaluator and Revisor") whereas V2 used `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION` ("Eval Revision") — shift toward more formal/canonical vocabulary. Per V3 file header: `# DOC23 Addenda B Addendum — Outcome Evaluator and Revisor V3`; **Status:** `V3 specification` (not "proposal" or "draft" as in V2); **Version:** `3.0`; **Prepared:** `2026-05-15`. **Source documents per V3 header:** DOC23 Task System Modular Architecture R3.1; DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization) R4.1 V2; DOC23 Addenda B (Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability) R0.6.4; **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Adjudication Card V3.1**; **DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Canonicalization Patch V2** — V3 is therefore the post-adjudication revision incorporating Card V3.1 decisions + Canonicalization Patch V2 normalizations. Cross-references in V3 use `[X]` format for items in the Adjudication Card V3.1 and `[P-N]` format for patches in the Canonicalization Patch V2 — establishing V3 as a normative spec rather than V2's proposal/draft status. **Cross-doc dependency expansion:** V3 explicitly enumerates 13 cross-doc dependencies in file header (DOC11 ACP/runtime, DOC12 plan review forum, DOC15 CIL authority + context packets, DOC20 UI surfaces for Evaluation/Revision Result Cards + Teach-from-feedback, DOC24 capability registry + runtime injection, DOC25 IngestionResult + source verification, DOC72 Pattern primitive + goal context, DOC73 receipt envelope + PBEOperationReceiptLite, EC Core sole durable writer + retention rows + PolicyDecision gate, BDSM/DOC8 utility learning signals, DOC23 Addenda A Judge module + Claim Extractor + prompt optimization). V2 listed companions; V3 elevates them to dependencies with specific contract ownership. **NEW V3 architectural primitives beyond V2:** Outcome Compiler (compiles outcome specs from natural-language input + skill graph patterns); Revision Compiler (compiles revision plans into dispatchable units); Revision Dispatcher (per-module dispatch runtime evolving V2's Revision Bus); Candidate artifact versions with `CandidateArtifactVersion` inside SourceWorkspace; Plan assurance policy (formal verification before execution); Taint and policy model (provenance + policy gating on iterative revisions); Pattern learning (skill-graph integration formalized as §22); Feedback pipeline (V2's four channels become an end-to-end pipeline). **V3 §0.2 phasing:** Phase 1 (this spec) covers full Evaluator/Revisor/Dispatcher pipeline, candidate versions, taint model, pattern capture, quality programs with metric denominators, sub-agent reputation scoring, dry-run mode, hardware-aware degradation, four-domain eval suite plus domain-neutral smoke set, cross-doc obligations registered in OP-A. **V3 §0.3 Canonical Naming Table** and **§0.4 Canonical Enum Inventory** are normative (implementations MAY NOT introduce new values or substitute alternates without spec amendment). **V3 §0A Implementation Discipline Preamble** governs how V3 is implemented and explicitly binds coding agents to its rules. **V3 §26 Drift Manifest** records every TODO/placeholder/deferred behavior. **V3 §24/§25 stress test fixtures** with four-domain eval suite. **V3 is materially more rigorous than V2** — V2 was an architectural revision over V1; V3 is the post-adjudication tightening that elevates V2 from proposal to spec status with explicit normative discipline. **No explicit "Supersedes:" header in V3** (unlike V2 which explicitly superseded V1) — V3 positions itself as the V3 spec for the same subsystem rather than as a strict supersession of V2 by header declaration; auto pass treats this as a natural-progression supersession (V2 → V3) per the established DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain pattern. V2 file (= A-55 row) remains in active folder pending human archival decision. V1 file (= A-54 row) also still in active folder pending the same disposition decision. **DOC23 Addenda B chain at R3.44:** R0.1 (global archive) → R0.3 (= A-50, intra-subfolder archive R3.15) → R0.5 (briefly-extant, intra-subfolder archive) → R0.6.1 (= A-51, intra-subfolder archive R3.16) → R0.6.3 (= A-52, intra-subfolder archive R3.18) → **R0.6.4 (= A-53, ACTIVE — current unified Addenda B draft)** + Addendum chain **V1 (= A-54, ACTIVE pending archival per V2 supersession) → V2 (= A-55, ACTIVE pending archival per V3 succession) → V3 (= A-57 NEW, ACTIVE)**. Three Addendum revisions now coexist; collapse-opportunity-by-archival deepens further.

**Substantive structural drift event #2 — §A7 row A-58 R0.2 supersession of R0.1:** new file R0.2 is the natural-progression successor to R0.1 (= A-56 row) in the §A7 Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder track. **Explicit supersession declaration**: per R0.2 file header `**Supersedes:** Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md for current discussion purposes.` — first explicit supersession in this §A7 multi-parent track. Per R0.2 file header: `# Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal R0.2`; **Status:** `Draft proposal for architect review and iterative refinement.`; **Date:** `2026-05-15.`. **Title evolution from R0.1:** R0.1 title was "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Task Scope / Working Set / Continuity Proposal"; R0.2 title is "Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Resume Work / Continuity Proposal" — **drops "Output Routing", "Task Scope", "Working Set"; adds "Resume Work"** — significant scope refinement consolidating around the resume-work surface as the primary user-facing affordance over the more granular scope envelope vocabulary. **R0.2 scope refinement vs R0.1:** R0.2 scope says "Integration proposal across DOC20, DOC7, DOC25, DOC72, DOC73, DOC24, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC1, EC Core, and CSA/continuity. DOC23 is included only as an integration boundary, not as an owner target for task-run context design." — **explicitly excludes DOC23 from owner targets** (R0.1 included DOC23 as a co-owner; R0.2 demotes DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status, reflecting architect judgment that the Unified Workspace proposal should not co-own task-run context with DOC23's existing task system). **Design posture strengthened:** R0.2 design-posture line adds explicit promise to "give enough schema detail to reason about seams" (R0.1 said only "names product objects, clarifies seams"); R0.2 is therefore more specification-flavored than R0.1's purely-product-model framing. **NEW R0.2 architectural primitive — Library source status model** with three additive statuses (NOT separate memory systems): **Linked**, **Indexed**, **Learned** — clarifies R0.1's vague "availability vs cataloging vs learning" distinction. **Retired R0.1 concepts** per R0.2's explicit retirement table: **Available** (retired as Library level/status because all Linked/Indexed/Learned sources are available); **Cataloged** (retired as Library status because too vague — "Indexed" better communicates the document-intelligence delta). **NEW R0.2 Co-Work-like behavior in Output Location**: if user opens or uploads a source document from a folder and asks Elnor to revise it, Elnor should often save a new sibling version near the source — formalizes source-folder affinity as a default Output Location heuristic. **R0.2 retains R0.1 core product model** with scope-envelope terms (Session Working Set + Work Stream) consolidated into the Resume Work surface: Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant, Task, Continuity Card. **R0.2 retains R0.1 core philosophy** axioms verbatim per §2: "Everything is optional"; "One substrate, visible lenses"; "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different"; "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane". R0.1 file (= A-56 row) remains in active folder pending human archival decision per auto pass's no-relocation policy. **R0.2's explicit DOC23 demotion provides Will-side signal** pointing toward disposition option (b) for the multi-parent proposal (elevate one parent as primary with the rest as companions; DOC23 would become a companion/integration-boundary rather than an owner).

**Counts updates in R3.44:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 56 → 58 (+2 net for A-57 V3 NEW in §A6 + A-58 R0.2 NEW in §A7; A-55 V2 + A-54 V1 + A-56 R0.1 all retained ACTIVE pending archival decisions); §4 Active Addenda 56 → 58; §A6 active rows 11 → 12; §A7 active rows 1 → 2; Grand total 121 → 123.

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.43 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.44 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**Carryover prompt bumped V16 → V17** — two new addendum files representing two parallel supersession events (V3 succession of V2 in §A6 DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain; R0.2 supersession of R0.1 in §A7 multi-parent track) is substantive structural drift warranting carryover refresh. V17 records: (a) V3 is the post-adjudication tightening of V2 with Adjudication Card V3.1 + Canonicalization Patch V2 absorbed; (b) R0.2 is the scope-refined successor of R0.1 demoting DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status and consolidating scope-envelope terms into Resume Work surface.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — two NEW addendum files + two parallel supersession events is substantive structural drift (not a fire-only mechanical bump or operations-state-only).

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.44), but R3.44 is itself a substantive-drift run rather than a same-day fire-only mechanical bump, so the tightening backlog is for next-cycle attention rather than today's structural focus. Tightening list carries forward unchanged from R3.43: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md (five-subfolders-still-not-formally-listed backlog); (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks; (7) NEW from R3.43: `mountpoint -q` pre-flight check before `mkdir -p` in S-11 BACKUP_LOG task to fail-closed when OneDrive destination is not a real bind mount.

**All R3.43 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (uses A-56 for V3 / A-57 for R0.2) and master spec list §4 (uses A-57 for V3 / A-58 for R0.2) preserved verbatim (divergence-by-one pattern extends to two new rows in R3.44); A-54 V1 + A-55 V2 stacked-then-superseded chain in §A6 + A-56 R0.1 in §A7 all still ACTIVE pending human archival decisions; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-10 since 2026.5.12 (2026-05-14); BACKUP_LOG nine-day cloud-recoverability gap from R3.43 bind-mount proof carry-forward — no new S-11 firing observed today; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen.

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.44 alias write accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.44.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.43 pattern. R3.5 versioned snapshot gap remains in carry-forward.

---

### R3.43 — 2026-05-15 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump after R3.42; zero spec/addenda drift; sole filesystem delta is S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md ninth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF escalation; first bind-mount verification in this scheduled task's history CONFIRMS the silent-ephemeral-mount hypothesis from R3.42's 2026-05-14 narrative; retroactive doubt cast on 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 "successful" runs)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-15 ~17:00 UTC (~10:00 local), ~6h after R3.42's write at 2026-05-15 ~11:00 UTC. Triggered by S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md being appended by the scheduled backup task at 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC (firing ~6h15m after R3.42's alias write).

**Filesystem scan since R3.42:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.42.md` returned exactly **one operations-state file hit** in active scan folders:
- `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 04:17:55, size 22,602 → 26,301 bytes / +16.4% / +3,699 bytes; entry-header firing time 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC; session ID `jolly-cool-albattani`)
- (Plus the master spec list file itself from R3.42's alias write.)

**S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 unchanged from R3.42**: SPEC_STATE.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-15 03:09; ADDENDA_STATE.md at 2026-05-15 03:10; DRIFT_LOG.md at 2026-05-15 03:13; RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md at 2026-05-15 04:04; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md at 2026-05-15 03:49 (R3.42's 2026.5.12 detection capture); RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md at 2026-05-14 04:25 (R3.41 coordinated post-write touch). No other new files in any active scan folder.

**Substantive BACKUP_LOG ninth-strike + bind-mount-proof event:** today's 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC run was the FIRST in this scheduled task's history to execute an explicit `mountpoint` verification on the destination. Result: `mountpoint /sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared` returned "is not a mountpoint", while `mountpoint /sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/ECQ Development` returned "is a mountpoint" — **definitive proof** that the OneDrive destination is NOT a bind mount in this session; instead, Step 1's `mkdir -p` silently created a sandbox-local `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` directory under `/sessions/jolly-cool-albattani/mnt/` and wrote a 5.80 MB tarball (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-15_111640.tgz`) to it. This is exactly the silent ephemeral-mount failure mode hypothesized in the 5/14 R3.42 entry. Per task constraint #4 (no local-only fallback), the bogus tarball was deleted and the sandbox-local scaffolding was `rmdir`-ed; workspace state matches session start. **Six calendar days have now elapsed with no confirmed cloud backup** (5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, 5/14, 5/15). **Retroactive doubt cast on the 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 "successful" runs** — none performed the bind-mount check, so they may also have written to ephemeral sandbox paths that never synced to OneDrive. **Escalation:** R3.35 sixth-strike → R3.36 seventh-strike → R3.42 eighth-strike → **R3.43 NINTH-STRIKE six-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT-WITH-BIND-MOUNT-PROOF**. The 5/15 entry strengthens the 5/14 R3.42 hardening recommendation to a concrete `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || { log "OneDrive not bind-mounted — exiting"; exit; }` pre-flight before the `mkdir -p` in Step 1 of the SKILL.md.

**Spec corpus changes since R3.42:** NONE. No new addendum files in any tracked Addenda subfolder. No new operative spec files in active root. No movement of any operative spec to or from any archive subfolder. The `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/` subfolder added in R3.41 remains a one-file subfolder containing only A-56 R0.1.

**Counts updates in R3.43:** §3 and §4 row counts unchanged from R3.42. §7 row mtime / size fields updated for S-11 only (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 unchanged from R3.42's capture; S-10 unchanged from R3.41's coordinated touch). Grand total preserved at **121** (no addendum churn since R3.41).

**Recommendation for next manual review pass:** the three-pronged Will action from R3.42 (reconnect + Finder-verify + harden) becomes increasingly urgent given today's bind-mount proof. The hardening item now has a concrete code-level remediation: add `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || { log "OneDrive not bind-mounted — exiting"; exit; }` pre-flight BEFORE the `mkdir -p` in Step 1 of the SKILL.md — this would catch silent ephemeral-mount failures earlier and prevent producing misleading "SUCCESS" entries in the BACKUP_LOG when host-side files may not actually be persisting. Five not-formally-listed Addenda subfolders backlog (DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj) continues to compound — SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence now nineteen cycles un-implemented.

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.43 alias write should be accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.43.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.42 pattern. R3.5 versioned snapshot gap remains in carry-forward.

---

### R3.42 — 2026-05-15 (nightly sync auto-bump — overnight operations-state-only bump after R3.41; no spec or addenda drift; substantive OpenClaw 2026.5.12 stable release ends 7-day stable pause; BACKUP_LOG eighth-strike five-calendar-day URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT escalation)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-15 ~04:00 local (~11:00 UTC), ~11h40m after R3.41's write at 2026-05-14 ~23:10 UTC (~16:10 local). Triggered by `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.41.md` returning Operations Docs state-tracker files only (no spec or addenda corpus drift).

**Filesystem scan since R3.41:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.41.md` returned exactly six hits in active scan folders (all Operations Docs state-tracker files):
- `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:09:37, size 70,245 bytes)
- `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:10:40, size 58,311 bytes)
- `Operations Docs/DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:13:42, size 178,697 bytes)
- `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 03:49:09, size 70,092 bytes — large jump from R3.28 baseline of 34,357 bytes; today's 03:49 entry captures 2026.5.12 stable detection)
- `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-05-15 04:04:29, size 65,326 bytes)
- (Plus the master spec list file itself from R3.41's alias write.)

**S-10 + S-11 unchanged from R3.41**: S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-14 04:25 (captured by R3.41 as coordinated post-write touch). S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime preserved at 2026-05-14 04:16 (last firing recorded). No other new files in any active scan folder.

**Substantive OpenClaw release event:** S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-15 03:49 entry captures detection of **2026.5.12 (released 2026-05-14 18:28 UTC by github-actions, tag signed by steipete)** — ends the 7-day stable pause that ran 2026-05-08 → 2026-05-14. Gap status widens BEHIND-by-9 → BEHIND-by-10. **2026.5.12 is the most architecturally consequential stable since 2026.5.3.** Eight architectural anchors detailed in §10 R3.42 anomalies row (leaner-installs plugin-externalization extension; NEW `acp.fallbacks` ACP runtime-backend fallback; explicit browser device pairing + Control UI pairing before proxy-scoped access; Claude CLI fresh-session bounded transcript retry; in-process agent dispatcher for same-process subagent handoffs; Control UI/WebChat persisted auto-scroll mode selector; Telegram polling isolation + durable local spool + HTML formatting preservation; `agents.defaults.subagents.model` applied before target agent primary models during `sessions_spawn`). Codex OAuth route saga remains closed in safe three-act form (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). Recommendation strengthened: DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal should now fold **all ten** un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 + 2026.5.7 + **2026.5.12**) in one consolidated pass. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for **eighteen consecutive days**.

**Substantive BACKUP_LOG escalation event:** S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md 2026-05-14 04:16 / 11:16 UTC entry records **fourth logged consecutive disconnected run** (after 2026-05-10, 2026-05-11, and 2026-05-13; 2026-05-12 has no log entry suggesting task did not run or failed before logging step). Workspace mount lacks `OpenClaw-Shared`. Last successful tarball was 2026-05-09. **Five calendar days have now elapsed with no new cloud backup.** Escalation: R3.35 sixth-strike → R3.36 seventh-strike → **R3.42 eighth-strike URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-PERSISTENT**. The 2026-05-14 entry adds a third Will-action item (hardening pass with explicit pre-flight mount-vs-directory check before declaring runs successful — would catch silent ephemeral-mount failures earlier).

**Spec corpus changes since R3.41:** NONE. No new addendum files in any tracked Addenda subfolder. No new operative spec files in active root. No movement of any operative spec to or from any archive subfolder. The `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/` subfolder added in R3.41 remains a one-file subfolder containing only A-56 R0.1.

**Counts updates in R3.42:** §3 and §4 row counts unchanged from R3.41. §7 row mtime / size fields updated for S-3, S-4, S-5, S-8, S-9, S-11. Grand total preserved at **121** (no addendum churn since R3.41).

**Recommendation for next manual review pass:** human-author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing all ten un-folded OpenClaw releases through 2026.5.12 + reconnect-and-harden the OneDrive backup task (three-pronged action). Five not-formally-listed Addenda subfolders backlog (DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj) continues to compound — SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence now eighteen cycles un-implemented.

**Versioned snapshot:** R3.42 alias write should be accompanied by `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.42.md` versioned snapshot per established R3.0–R3.41 pattern. R3.5 versioned snapshot gap remains in carry-forward.

---

### R3.41 — 2026-05-14 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day THIRD-firing SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump; 1 NEW addendum file + 1 NEW subfolder; first ever §A7 "Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj" subfolder added; first ever multi-parent cross-doc proposal registered in master spec list; second substantive structural drift in the R3.39 → R3.41 window; first same-day TRIPLE-fire in this scheduled task's history that ended in substantive drift rather than fire-only / operations-only bump)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-14 ~23:10 UTC (~16:10 local), ~11h10m after R3.40's write at 2026-05-14 ~12:00 UTC. Triggered by 1 substantive NEW addendum file detected in a brand-NEW subfolder under `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`.

**Filesystem scan since R3.40:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.40.md` returned exactly two hits in active scan folders:
- **NEW SUBSTANTIVE DRIFT:** `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:21 PDT = 16:18 UTC; size 63,741 bytes; +~5h after R3.40 alias write). Folder `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/` itself NEW (folder mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:54 PDT = 16:18 UTC; +33 seconds after file).
- **OPERATIONS-STATE COORDINATED TOUCH:** `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 04:25:37 PDT = 11:25:37 UTC; +3m37s after R3.40 alias write at 11:22 UTC; size advanced into the 67,229-byte range). Inferred as R3.40's own coordinated post-write touch rather than independent S-10 firing — mirrors R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40 same-pattern attributions of operations-state-file mtimes within ~10 minutes of own alias write to the alias-writing run rather than a fresh firing.

No other new files in active spec folders, no other addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-7/S-8/S-9/S-11 firings since R3.40 captured them.

**File header excerpt (A-56 R0.1 Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context Proposal):**
- Title: "Unified Workspace / Library / Work Context / Work Product / Output Routing / Task Scope / Working Set / Continuity Proposal R0.1"
- Status: "Draft proposal for architect review and iterative refinement"
- Date: "2026-05-10"
- Scope: "Integration proposal across DOC20, DOC7, DOC25, DOC72, DOC73, DOC24, DOC23, DOC11/OpenClaw, DOC1, EC Core, and continuity/CSA"
- Design posture: "Seam-focused. This proposal does NOT rewrite DOC72, DOC73, DOC23, or DOC24. It names product objects, clarifies seams, and defines cross-doc owner obligations where the current system has useful pieces that are not yet exposed as one coherent user model."

**Proposal substance:**
- §1 Core product model defines eleven domain-neutral product objects — Workspace, Work Context, Library, Folder Binding, Work Product, Output Location, Assistant, Task, Session Working Set, Work Stream, Continuity Card — explicitly as lenses/bindings/profiles/views over the same governed substrate.
- §2 Core philosophy enumerates four governing axioms: "Everything is optional"; "One substrate, visible lenses"; "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different"; "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane" (still governed by DOC72 intake / significance / extraction / Write Gate pipeline).
- Proposal does NOT introduce new memory truth systems, new graph stores, or new brains — explicitly positions these eleven primitives as lenses over the existing DOC72/DOC24/DOC23/DOC1/EC Core substrate.

**Multi-parent classification (FIRST in master spec registry):** A-56 explicitly touches ten parent specs / addenda chains simultaneously rather than naming a single primary parent. This is the **first multi-parent cross-doc proposal** registered in this master spec list — all prior proposals named a primary parent + companions. The new §A7 subsection was created to track this proposal and any future multi-parent proposals that may follow this pattern.

**New §A7 subfolder (FIRST multi-parent subfolder):**
- Subfolder name: `Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/`
- Folder mtime: 2026-05-14 09:18:54 PDT = 16:18 UTC
- Structurally analogous to existing single-parent-doc subfolders (DOC20 Addenda, DOC24 Addenda, DOC72 Addenda and Proposals, DOC73 Addenda and Proposals, DOC23 Addenda) but explicitly multi-parent.
- Initial content at R3.41 detection: 1 file (the R0.1 proposal).
- Subfolder name uses "Brain Bucket Lib" colloquial shorthand rather than the file's formal terms "Workspace / Library / Work Context" — may warrant renaming to a more conventional convention (e.g., "Unified Workspace Architecture Addenda and Proposals") if the proposal is retained as an active multi-parent track.

**Disposition options for A-56 R0.1 pending human review:**
1. Keep multi-parent as-is and fold incrementally into each named parent's next revision wave under owner-specific subsections of the proposal.
2. Elevate one parent (likely DOC72 as substrate owner, or DOC24 as routing/capability owner, or a new "DOC??" Workspace Architecture parent doc) as primary with the rest as companions.
3. Split the proposal into per-parent addenda files placed under existing single-parent subfolders.
4. Some other disposition.

Auto pass leaves the file ACTIVE in the new §A7 subfolder pending decision.

**Counts updated:**
- §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 55 → 56 (+1 for A-56)
- §4 Active Addenda 54 → 55 (+1 for A-56)
- §A7 NEW with 1 active row (A-56)
- Grand total 120 → 121

**Carryover prompt bumped V16 → V17** to add the new §A7 subfolder to nightly sync scope and to document the multi-parent proposal classification convention. R3.41 is the first revision since R3.39 to warrant a carryover prompt bump (R3.40 left V16 unchanged since it was fire-only / ops-only).

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.40 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.41 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — new subfolder creation + new multi-parent proposal addendum is substantive structural drift, not a fire-only mechanical bump.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to seventeen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.41). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.40 list, plus one addition: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + **NEW Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj** subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md; (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window — R3.41 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about the one new file and the one new subfolder).

**All carry-forward items from R3.40 preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + **NEW Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj** subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (A-54 for V2) and master spec list §4 (A-55 for V2) preserved verbatim, and now extends to A-56 in master spec list (= likely A-55 or A-56 in ADDENDA_STATE going forward — first multi-parent proposal may need its own row taxonomy in ADDENDA_STATE.md); A-54 V1 stacked proposal still ACTIVE pending human archival decision after V2 supersession declared in R3.39; OneDrive backup chain at TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE per R3.40 capture (no S-11 firing since); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-9 since 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07) per R3.40 capture (no S-9 firing since); single-release roll-forward standstill stretches to seventeen days; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen.

---

### R3.40 — 2026-05-14 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump capturing two post-R3.39 scheduled-task firings (S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER at 10:42 UTC + S-11 BACKUP_LOG at 11:16 UTC); S-11 escalates from R3.39 ninth-strike to TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE; S-9 adds NEW beta v2026.5.12-beta.6 watch row and stretches single-release roll-forward standstill to seventeen consecutive days; first same-day double-fire since R3.37→R3.38 on 5/13)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-14 ~12:00 UTC, ~1h47m after R3.39's write at 2026-05-14 ~10:13 UTC. Triggered by two post-R3.39 operations-state firings (S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG at 10:42 UTC, +29min post-R3.39; S-11 BACKUP_LOG at 11:16 UTC, +63min post-R3.39).

**Filesystem scan since R3.39:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.39.md` returned exactly **two operations-state file hits** in active scan folders:
- **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md** — mtime 2026-05-14 03:43 local = 10:43 UTC; size 59,797 → 61,931 bytes (+3.6% / +2,134 bytes); entry-header firing time 2026-05-14 10:42 UTC; +29min after R3.39 alias write.
- **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md** — mtime 2026-05-14 04:16 local = 11:16 UTC; size 20,045 → 22,602 bytes (+12.8% / +2,557 bytes); entry-header firing time 2026-05-14 11:16 UTC; +63min after R3.39 alias write.

Plus **S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md** mtime 2026-05-14 03:17 UTC inferred as R3.39's own coordinated append per R3.39 narrative ("DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle") rather than independent task firing — not counted as new drift. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-7/S-8/S-10 firings since R3.39 captured them.

**S-9 OpenClaw release-tracker narrative (2026-05-14 10:42 UTC entry):**
- Latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC) — **seventh consecutive quiet stable day**. Prior 2026.4.27 → 2026.5.7 daily-cadence streak now paused 7 days.
- Gap composition UNCHANGED at BEHIND-by-9 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 / 2026.5.8 / 2026.5.11 not published as stable).
- Single-release roll-forwards have now lagged **seventeen consecutive days** (was sixteen per R3.37 5/13 capture; +1 since pause halts growth, does not narrow it).
- **NEW beta observation:** `v2026.5.12-beta.6` prerelease tag dated 2026-05-13 — iMessage native image send hygiene fix that stops emitting visible `<media:image>` placeholder text for media-only sends while preserving internal echo key that prevents self-echo duplicate replies. Joins prior beta watch list: `v2026.5.9-beta.1` (2026-05-09 — `/think default` + `/fast default` chat-command additions + POSIX `openclaw.json` 0600 chmod restoration), `v2026.5.10-beta.6` (2026-05-11), `v2026.5.12-beta.4` (2026-05-13 05:17 UTC — Codex private-runtime-SDK helper exposure fix for `@openclaw/codex` MODULE_NOT_FOUND errors). Beta dist-tag only — none promote into stable alignment basis until cut on latest dist-tag. Beta sequence: 5.9-beta.1 → 5.10-beta.6 → 5.12-beta.4 → 5.12-beta.6. 5.12-beta.6 contents are only iMessage visible-text hygiene — no new architectural surfaces, beta cadence not yet alignment-basis material; if stabilizes, touches DOC11/DOC10 channel projection (visible-reply enforcement vs internal echo key separation — quiet contract for any spec that pins iMessage visible-reply truth).
- **Recommendation unchanged:** DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen — fold all 9 stable releases in consolidated pass with Codex OAuth route saga as single closed three-act item (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover).

**S-11 BACKUP_LOG narrative (2026-05-14 11:16 UTC entry):**
- Status: **failed (OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect)**. Archive not created. Source mounted and accessible. Destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` NOT mounted in this session.
- Session ID: `great-sharp-clarke`. Workspace sandbox mount `/sessions/great-sharp-clarke/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, plus hidden `.claude` and `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` absent.
- No stray `mkdir -p` artifact created (OpenClaw-Shared parent doesn't exist, mkdir attempt failed and bailed out before creating stub).
- **Fourth logged consecutive disconnected/failed run** (after 5/10, 5/11, 5/13; 5/12 has no log entry suggesting task did not run or failed before reaching logging step).
- **Five calendar days now elapsed with no new cloud backup** (5/10, 5/11, 5/12 implied gap, 5/13, 5/14). Escalation from R3.38/R3.39's four-consecutive-failed-day characterization. Last successful tarball remains `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` from 2026-05-09; cloud-resident-recoverability state is now five days stale.
- **NEW hardening recommendation appears in this 5/14 entry (item #3, not present in any prior entry):** "consider whether the scheduled task itself needs a hardening pass: an explicit pre-flight check that asserts the destination is a real OneDrive bind mount (not just a writable directory under the sandbox) before declaring a run successful. This would catch silent ephemeral-mount failures earlier."
- Prior Will-side urgent actions carried forward: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via chat-box "+" button so scheduled runs can resume cloud writes; (2) independently verify on host whether prior tarballs (5/4–5/9 "successful" runs) actually accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — open hypothesis about per-session ephemeral mount semantics remains untested.
- **Pattern recharacterizes from R3.39's NINTH-STRIKE four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE to TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE** with five-calendar-day-elapsed cloud-recoverability gap.

**No spec/addenda churn in this 1h47m window:** no new spec files in active spec folders; no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations.

**§7 row narratives NOT individually rewritten** in this bump per established same-day fire pattern — S-9 + S-11 mtime/size advances captured in narrative form in this changelog entry and the Last Updated header block.

**Counts unchanged from R3.39:** §11 grand total 120; §7 row count 12; §A6 active rows 11; PROPOSED ADDENDUM 55; Operations files 12.

**Carryover prompt remains V16** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V17 bump (same-day operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet).

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — S-11 fifth-elapsed-calendar-day cloud-recoverability gap is narrative-significant (escalation from R3.39 ninth-strike to tenth-strike); S-9 new beta `v2026.5.12-beta.6` watch row plus seventeen-day cadence-lag milestone are informational but worth recording. This is NOT a fire-only mechanical bump — narrative-significant content present.

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** R3.39 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.40 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to sixteen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.40). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.39 list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md; (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window — R3.40 honors this discipline (only past-tense observations about S-9 and S-11 firings that have already occurred).

**All carry-forward items from R3.39 preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (A-54 for V2) and master spec list §4 (A-55 for V2) preserved verbatim; A-54 V1 stacked proposal still ACTIVE pending human archival decision after V2 supersession declared in R3.39; OneDrive backup chain at TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE (escalated from R3.39 ninth-strike); OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-9 since 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07); single-release roll-forward standstill stretches to seventeen days; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen.

---

### R3.39 — 2026-05-14 (nightly sync auto-bump — SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump; 1 NEW addendum file in DOC23 Addenda subfolder explicitly superseding A-54 R0.6.5 V1 stacked proposal; supersession-and-replace pattern restored after R3.33 stacked-proposal one-off; first substantive structural drift since R3.33 on 2026-05-10; ends six-revision window of operations-state-only / fire-only / no-drift bumps R3.34–R3.38)

**Origin:** Auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-14 ~10:10 UTC, ~11h00m after R3.38's write at 2026-05-13 ~23:10 UTC. Triggered by 1 substantive new addendum file in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/`.

**Filesystem scan since R3.38:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.38.md` returned exactly **one new file hit** in active scan folders: `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 03:32 UTC, size 133,682 bytes, 2,740 lines).

**File header excerpt:** "DOC23 Task System — Addenda B ADDENDUM: Outcome Evaluation and Revision Architecture, V2". Document hierarchy: "DOC23 (R3.1) → Addenda B (R0.6.4) → Addendum (this doc, V2)". Status: "Proposal — pending red-team review per §25. Not yet folded into Addenda B main." Author: "Will Brody (architecture) + Claude (drafting)." **Explicit supersession declaration**: "Supersedes: `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL_ADDITION_FOR_R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (V1)" — this V1 is the existing A-54 R0.6.5 stacked proposal detected by R3.33 (= ADDENDA_STATE.md A-53). NB: V2 header references V1 filename with underscores; filesystem filename has spaces; same file.

**Change log from V1 (per V2 §0.1):** V2 is "a substantial architectural revision, not an incremental edit." V1's primitives RETAINED: OutcomeSpec, OutcomeEvaluatorConfig, OutcomeGate, EvaluationFeedbackBundle, defeasible findings lifecycle, Run Guidance Items, Repair Instructions, four feedback delivery channels, FeedbackConsumptionReceipts, TaskSourceWorkspace, TaskProcessGapSignal. **V2 closes 11 specification gaps V1 lacked:**
1. How a user creates an outcome without filling out a 15-field form (V1 was builder-facing; user experience was undesigned)
2. A plan-and-execute layer (V1 had Repair Instructions but no module that produced or dispatched them)
3. Targeted evaluation mode (V1's Evaluator only ran in "evaluate everything" mode)
4. Per-outcome progress signals beyond pass/fail (no fixed-this-iteration / still-failing / regressed states)
5. Cascading revalidation via declared dependencies (no mechanism for "when X changes, re-check Y")
6. Two-budget iteration model (V1 had a single iteration cap)
7. Formal Revision Bus / dispatch runtime
8. Per-module `revision_in` port contract
9. Plan review forum semantics distinct from runtime orchestration
10. Text-to-outcome inference pipeline (V1 had no mechanism for converting natural-language outcome descriptions into configured outcomes)
11. Skill-graph integration for learned patterns (V1 had Outcome Presets but no automatic retrieval/learning loop)

**New V2 architectural primitives:**
- `step.revisor` module (§6)
- `RevisionPlan` schema (§7)
- Revision Bus runtime (§8)
- `revision_in` port contract (§9)
- `target_outcomes` input port on Evaluator (§5.1)
- `iteration_history` input port on Evaluator (§5.1)
- `plan_step_context` input port on Evaluator (§5.1)

**Supersession-and-replace pattern RESTORED:** R3.33's stacked-proposal pattern was a one-off — V2's explicit "Supersedes:" header returns the DOC23 Addenda B chain to the supersession-and-replace convention familiar from R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4. Naming convention also evolves: V1 used the R0.x version numbering ("R0.6.5"); V2 uses simple "V2" semantic version + new "ADDB" filename abbreviation ("Addenda B") — first time this naming is used in the chain. Whether V2's naming convention persists for future revisions or returns to R0.x numbering is an open question for the next revision.

**V1 file disposition pending:** V1 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (= existing A-54 row) remains in active folder per auto pass's no-relocation policy. **Disposition options for human review:** (a) move V1 file to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` following the supersession-and-archive pattern; (b) keep V1 file in active folder for traceability (atypical). Auto pass leaves both ACTIVE pending decision.

**Conspicuous absences this window:**
- **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md** unchanged from R3.38's 2026-05-13 11:16 UTC capture; no new firing observed at sync time. Pattern remains in ninth-strike four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE state per R3.38; whether today's scheduled firing window has passed or has not yet occurred is uncertain at sync time (~10:10 UTC). Per the SKILL.md tightening recommendation that emerged from R3.37/R3.38 narrative-vs-reality divergence: this R3.39 entry makes NO future-tense claim about whether today's S-11 firing will happen.
- **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md** unchanged from R3.37's 2026-05-13 10:43 UTC capture; the daily 03:44 PDT / 10:44 UTC firing window has not yet closed at sync time (~10:10 UTC, ~34 minutes before window).
- **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md / S-3 SPEC_STATE.md / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md** unchanged from R3.38 capture.

**Audit-cleanup pass executed this run:** Three versioned files accumulated in active folder from yesterday's R3.37/R3.38 same-day double-bump (R3.36 + R3.37 + R3.38). All three moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. Archive folder now contains R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.38 (42 files). R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. Active folder retains R3.39 + alias only.

**Carryover prompt:** bumped V15 → V16 to capture V2 supersession of V1 + new V2 architectural primitives + naming-convention evolution from R0.x to V-series. V15 retained alongside V14/V13/V12 per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule.

**DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle** — narrative-significant substantive drift. Entry also backfills R3.37 + R3.38 narrative since neither prior bump appended its own DRIFT_LOG entry.

**§11 counts updated:** PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 54 → 55 (+1 for A-55 V2; A-54 V1 retained ACTIVE pending archival decision). §4 Active Addenda count: 54 → 55 (A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 10 → 11 — added A-55 V2 alongside A-54 V1; A-50/A-51/A-52 aliases preserved as file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive pointers). Grand total (all sections): 119 → 120 (+1 for A-55 V2). Operations files: 12 (unchanged).

**SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to fifteen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.39). Recommendations carried forward unchanged from R3.37's list: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md; (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files; (6) NEW from R3.38 reflection: avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks within the same firing window (today's R3.39 entry honors this discipline).

**All carry-forward items from R3.38 preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (A-54 for V2) and master spec list §4 (A-55 for V2) preserved verbatim; OneDrive backup chain at ninth-strike four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE per R3.38; OpenClaw release-alignment gap BEHIND-by-9 since 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07); twelve-day single-release roll-forward standstill continues to widen the DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window.

---

### R3.38 — 2026-05-13 (same-day SECOND-firing fire-only mechanical bump — single S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md firing at 11:16 UTC since R3.37; refutes R3.37's "EIGHTH-STRIKE three-consecutive-day-silence" claim (5/13 DID fire) but cadence remains FAILING — fourth consecutive failed/disconnected day; recharacterized as NINTH-STRIKE four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-13 ~16:10 UTC, ~5h00m after R3.37's write at 2026-05-13 ~11:09 UTC. R3.37 (written at 11:09 UTC) made a future-state claim about the BACKUP_LOG task ("produced no firing on 2026-05-13") that was refuted ~7 minutes later when the BACKUP_LOG task fired at 11:16 UTC — see SKILL.md tightening observation in this entry's narrative section. This is the first same-day double-fire since the 5/10 quadruple-fire window (R3.32→R3.33→R3.34→R3.35).

**Filesystem scan since R3.37:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.37.md` returned exactly **one operations-state file hit** in active scan folders:

| File | Prior mtime | New mtime | Prior size | New size | Δ size | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md** | 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC | 2026-05-13 11:16 UTC | 17,777 | 20,045 | +12.8% / +2,268 bytes | **SIGNIFICANT — partial refutation of R3.37's eighth-strike silence escalation; recharacterized as ninth-strike four-consecutive-failed-day-failing-cadence** |

No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-7 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 firings since R3.37 captured them ~5h00m ago at 11:09 UTC.

**S-11 narrative (SIGNIFICANT — silence refuted, failure entrenched):**

The autonomous `elnor-onedrive-backup` task fired at 2026-05-13 11:16 UTC (~6 minutes later than the expected 11:10 cadence), appending a new entry to BACKUP_LOG.md. The new entry refutes R3.37's headline claim — the task DID fire on 5/13 — but confirms the underlying failure trajectory continues:

- **Status:** failed (OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect via chat-box "+" button)
- **Archive:** not created
- **Source size:** n/a (skipped before tarball)
- **Destination:** `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` (NOT mounted in this session)
- **Rotation:** not run
- **Backups remaining:** unknown (destination unreachable)
- **Session ID:** `stoic-wonderful-babbage`

The 5/13 BACKUP_LOG entry calls this the **third consecutive disconnected run** (after 2026-05-10 and 2026-05-11) and notes that 5/12 has **no entry in the log at all** — suggesting the 5/12 task either did not run or failed before reaching the logging step. Counting calendar days, 5/13 is the **fourth consecutive day with a failed/disconnected/missing-firing outcome** (5/10 disconnected, 5/11 disconnected, 5/12 silent, 5/13 disconnected) and the **fifth consecutive day with no new cloud tarball written** (5/9 success → 5/10 failed → 5/11 failed → 5/12 silent → 5/13 failed).

The new entry confirms mountpoint absence: `mountpoint` verification shows only `ECQ Development` and `outputs` resolve as mountpoints under `/sessions/stoic-wonderful-babbage/mnt/`; `OpenClaw-Shared` returned "No such file or directory" (no stub or stray `mkdir -p` artifact was created this run, distinguishing from some prior failed-run patterns). Visible workspace entries this session: `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, plus hidden `.claude` / `.remote-plugins`.

**Pattern recharacterization** — R3.36 introduced "seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs"; R3.37 escalated to "eighth-strike three-consecutive-day-silence-FAILING-CADENCE" claiming the task had stopped firing entirely; R3.38 refutes the silence dimension (task DID fire on 5/13) but the failure dimension is unchanged or worse — so the pattern recharacterizes to **ninth-strike four-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE**. The hypothesis from R3.37 that the task was "silently disabled or quietly retrying-and-erroring without writing to BACKUP_LOG" is partially refuted: the task IS still writing to BACKUP_LOG when it fires; the 5/12 missing-entry remains the only gap to explain. The mount-loss state remains entrenched and the cloud-resident-recoverability goal continues to be met for zero consecutive days.

**Urgent suggested Will action (carried forward from 5/13 BACKUP_LOG entry, fourth consecutive cycle):**

1. **Re-add the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via the chat-box "+" button** to mount it into future Cowork sessions so the scheduled backup task can resume writing cloud-resident tarballs.
2. **Separately, verify on the host** whether prior "successful" tarballs (the 5/4 through 5/9 runs that reported SUCCESS) actually accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. The open hypothesis about per-session ephemeral mount semantics remains untested — if the host folder is empty, the cloud-resident-recoverability goal of this task has **never** been met during this scheduled task's history, not just during the current 5/10+ failure window.

**No spec / addenda churn:** No new spec files in active spec folders; no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations. §11 grand total unchanged at 119; §7 row count unchanged at 12; PROPOSED ADDENDUM count unchanged at 54; §A6 active rows unchanged at 10. R3.38 is a pure operations-state single-row bump.

**S-9 narrative continues (carried forward — not refreshed in this 5h00m window):** Latest stable OpenClaw release remains 2026.5.7 (published 2026-05-07 20:57 UTC) — UNCHANGED for the sixth consecutive day. Gap status, prerelease watch rows (`v2026.5.9-beta.1`, `v2026.5.10-beta.6`, `v2026.5.12-beta.4`), and DOC11 R15 R3 amendment URGENT-and-unauthored status all unchanged since R3.37; will be refreshed at the next nightly sync that captures the next S-9 firing.

**Per established pattern**, §7 row narratives are NOT individually rewritten in this bump — the S-11 mtime/size advance is captured in narrative form in this changelog entry's tables and prose, and detailed per-row §7 backfill is deferred to the next substantive-drift run that touches §7 rows directly.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendations carried forward (fourteen cycles persistent):** (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires to prevent rapid-fire mechanical bumps; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard so that pure operations-state mtime advances don't produce R3.x revisions on their own; (3) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files to catch narrative-vs-execution divergence.

**NEW SKILL.md tightening observation introduced in R3.38 — "narrative-precedes-reality" / future-tense claims defect:**

R3.37 was written at 2026-05-13 ~11:09 UTC and asserted in its headline narrative that the BACKUP_LOG task "produced no firing on 2026-05-13 despite expected daily firings at ~04:17 local / ~11:17 UTC cadence". That claim was framed as a present-tense observation about the entire 5/13 day, but the daily cadence window (~11:10–11:20 UTC) had not yet closed at write time; the task actually fired at 11:16 UTC, ~7 minutes after R3.37's write, refuting the R3.37 claim within 10 minutes of its publication. This is a structurally identical defect to the R3.36 ADDENDA_STATE.md narrative-vs-execution divergence (which R3.37 itself flagged): the spec-registry-update task wrote narrative content that was not validated against reality.

**Proposed mitigation for SKILL.md:** when the registry update task asserts an absence-of-firing claim for a still-open daily cadence window, it should either (a) defer such claims until past 14:00 UTC if the daily task fires ~11:00–11:20 UTC, or (b) frame such claims with explicit as-of timestamps and acknowledge the open window ("as of 11:09 UTC today's firing has not yet occurred; the cadence window typically extends to ~11:20 UTC"). The defensive framing (b) would prevent same-day refutation events like the one captured in R3.38.

**R3.38's own self-discipline:** This entry makes no future-tense claims about un-fired tasks — only past-tense observations about the 5/13 11:16 BACKUP_LOG firing and its already-written contents. Future S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 firings later today or overnight are not predicted in this entry; they will be captured by the next nightly-sync auto-bump if and when they occur.

---

### R3.37 — 2026-05-13 (nightly sync auto-bump — multi-firing operations-state-only bump capturing six tracker-log/state-file refreshes across the 5/12 + 5/13 sync window; S-11 BACKUP_LOG EIGHTH-STRIKE three-consecutive-day-silence-FAILING-CADENCE escalation; first multi-firing run since R3.35's same-day quadruple-fire on 5/10)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-13 ~11:00 UTC, ~44½ hours after R3.36's write at 2026-05-11 ~14:50 UTC. The 5/12 ~14:11 UTC nightly sync was a pure no-drift no-bump pass (per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY narrative); today's 5/13 ~10:08 UTC nightly sync is also a no-drift pass in the spec/addenda dimension but bumps R3.x because six operations-state tracker artifacts have accumulated refreshes since R3.36. The autonomous task continues to fire without supervision; **SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirteen cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32 → R3.33 → R3.34 → R3.35 → R3.36 → 5/12 no-drift pass → R3.37). NEW SKILL.md tightening line item from tonight: require post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files (yesterday's ADDENDA_STATE narrative-vs-execution divergence documented in RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY tonight).

**Filesystem scan since R3.36:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.36.md` returned exactly **six operations-state file hits** in active scan folders, plus the conspicuous absence of S-11:

| File | Prior mtime | New mtime | Prior size | New size | Δ size | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **S-3 SPEC_STATE.md** | 2026-05-11 03:09 UTC | 2026-05-13 03:07 UTC | ~46K | 53,223 | ~+15% | No-drift run-marker write across 5/12 + 5/13 nightly syncs |
| **S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md** | 2026-05-11 03:09 UTC | 2026-05-13 03:07 UTC | ~39K | 46,360 | ~+18% | Header `Last touched` line advanced 5/10 → 5/13 (5/12 advance was narrated but not actually executed — divergence corrected tonight) |
| **S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md** | 2026-05-11 03:08 UTC | 2026-05-13 03:09 UTC | ~124K | 150,713 | ~+21% | 5/12 backfill narrative + 5/13 no-drift narrative appended at top |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md** | 2026-05-10 11:13 UTC | 2026-05-13 04:01 PDT / 11:01 UTC | 41,222 | 54,107 | ~+31% | 5/11 + 5/12 daily refreshes were silent (missing firings); 5/13 resumed |
| **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md** | 2026-05-08 03:44 UTC | 2026-05-13 03:43 UTC | 34,357 | 55,301 | ~+61% | Four new daily entries 5/9 / 5/10 / 5/12 / 5/13 added; 5/11 entry was silent / missed firing; latest stable still 2026.5.7 |
| **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md** | 2026-05-08 04:21 UTC | 2026-05-13 04:06 PDT / 11:06 UTC | 35,320 | 59,665 | ~+69% | 5/11 silent (companion to S-8 silence); 5/12 + 5/13 appended |

**Conspicuous absence — S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED since R3.36:** mtime preserved at 2026-05-11 07:45 PDT / 14:45 UTC, size unchanged 17,777 bytes. The scheduled OneDrive backup task produced **no firing on 2026-05-12 or 2026-05-13** despite the expected daily ~04:17 local / ~11:17 UTC cadence. Pattern escalation: R3.36's seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING → R3.37's **EIGHTH-STRIKE three-consecutive-day-silence-FAILING-CADENCE**. Per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY S-11 narrative tonight: "a degenerate failure mode where the task may be silently disabled or quietly retrying-and-erroring without writing to BACKUP_LOG." Last successful tarball was 2026-05-09 (`ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz`); four consecutive days have now produced no new cloud backup. The cloud-resident-recoverability goal of this scheduled task is being met for zero consecutive days. **Two-pronged Will action remains URGENT and operationally blocking** (carried verbatim from R3.36 + extended): (1) re-add the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via the chat-box "+" button so the scheduled task can resume; (2) verify on the host whether prior tarballs actually accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`; **NEW (3)**: investigate whether the scheduled task is silently disabled or stuck (two missed expected firings 5/12 + 5/13 with no BACKUP_LOG entry suggest the task may not be running anymore) — re-trigger from scheduled-task UI to confirm it can fire at all.

**S-9 narrative (sixth consecutive quiet day at 2026.5.7):** Latest stable OpenClaw release remains 2026.5.7 (published 2026-05-07 20:57 UTC) — UNCHANGED for the sixth consecutive day. The 2026.4.27 → 2026.5.7 daily-cadence streak has paused six days. Gap status BEHIND by 9 releases (composition unchanged: 2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7). Beta channel activity widened: previously-tracked `v2026.5.9-beta.1` (2026-05-09 — `/think default` + `/fast default` chat commands; POSIX `openclaw.json` 0600 chmod restoration) and `v2026.5.10-beta.6` (2026-05-11) are now joined by NEW `v2026.5.12-beta.4` (2026-05-13 05:17 UTC — Codex runtime fix allowing the official installed `@openclaw/codex` package to use its private task-runtime SDK helper, addressing `MODULE_NOT_FOUND` errors during migrated OpenAI/Codex beta runs). Version-number sequence now skipping both `v2026.5.8` and `v2026.5.11` entirely. **Single-release roll-forwards lagging release cadence ~16 consecutive days**; six-day pause halts growth but does not narrow the gap. **DOC11 R15 R3 consolidated nine-release amendment remains URGENT and unauthored** — six consecutive quiet days have been an extended drafting window that no one used. Codex OAuth route saga remains closed in safe three-act PRESERVE/RECOVER form (canonize the 5.7 form, NOT the 5.5 REWRITE form).

**S-3 / S-4 narrative:** Both files refreshed twice in the window (5/12 backfill + 5/13 no-drift run-markers). NEW informational anomaly noted in S-4 path tonight: yesterday's R3.36-backfill DRIFT_LOG narrative had claimed ADDENDA_STATE.md header `Last touched` line was advanced 2026-05-10 → 2026-05-12, but verification showed the filesystem mtime remained at 2026-05-10 10:14 UTC and the header line still read 2026-05-10 — **the edit was not actually applied to file content despite the narrative claim**. Same narrative-vs-execution divergence as R3.24/R3.25 documented in R3.26 backfill. Tonight's pass executes the advance properly to 2026-05-13.

**S-5 narrative:** Two narrative entries appended at top across the window — 5/12 R3.34/R3.35/R3.36 backfill (closing the gap left by the 5/10 same-day-quadruple-fire that had skipped the per-bump DRIFT_LOG appends per fire-only-mechanical-bump-no-DRIFT-entry pattern) + 5/13 no-drift entry.

**S-8 / S-10 narrative (silent-and-resumed pattern):** RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY and its refresh log were both silent on 5/11 (S-8) and 5/11 + 5/12 (S-8 daily refresh); appears the scheduled daily-refresh task did not fire on those dates, similar pattern to the S-11 BACKUP_LOG silence. The scheduled-task-silence pattern is widening across multiple distinct scheduled tasks (S-8 / S-9 / S-11), suggesting either the scheduled-task infrastructure itself is intermittently unreliable when sandbox mounts are missing, or the tasks are quietly retrying without writing to their logs. Both files resumed firing today (5/13).

**No spec / addenda churn in this window:** no new spec files in active spec folders; no addenda churn; no operative spec mutations. §11 grand total unchanged at 119; §7 row count unchanged at 12; PROPOSED ADDENDUM count unchanged at 54; §A6 active rows unchanged at 10. R3.37 is a pure operations-state-tracker bump bringing the registry's header narrative into alignment with the 2026-05-13 filesystem reality.

**Per established pattern**, §7 row narratives are NOT individually rewritten in this bump — their accumulated mtime/size advances are captured in narrative form in the §7-prefix lines above and in this changelog entry. Detailed per-row §7 backfill is deferred to the next substantive-drift run that touches §7 rows directly. This matches the R3.34 / R3.35 fire-only-mechanical-bump convention (and the gap-closing backfill that followed). Per the recurring SKILL.md tightening recommendation: a future cooldown-gate / no-drift-no-bump / per-row §7 freshness check would have absorbed today's six operations-state advances into the next substantive-drift run rather than producing R3.37 today.

**SKILL.md tightening recommendations carried forward (thirteen cycles persistent):** (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires to prevent rapid-fire mechanical bumps; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard so that pure operations-state mtime advances don't produce R3.x revisions on their own; (3) per-row §7 freshness check that updates row mtime fields in-place rather than relying on header narrative; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda subfolder formal scope addition to nightly sync SKILL.md; (5) NEW from R3.37: post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files (yesterday's narrative-vs-execution divergence on ADDENDA_STATE header advance).

---

### R3.36 — 2026-05-11 (nightly sync auto-bump — single-firing operations-state-only bump capturing post-R3.35 S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing; S-11 SEVENTH-STRIKE two-consecutive-failed-runs ESCALATION; first single-fire run since R3.30)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-11 ~14:50 UTC (~07:50 PDT), ~27½ hours after R3.35's alias write at 2026-05-10 ~11:25 UTC. After yesterday's first same-day QUADRUPLE-fire (R3.32→R3.33→R3.34→R3.35 within ~13 hours), today's run reverts to a single-fire cadence — first single-fire run since R3.30. The autonomous task continues to fire without supervision; SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to **eleven cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32 → R3.33 → R3.34 → R3.35 → R3.36), though the same-day-multi-fire escalation pattern that motivated R3.35's cooldown-gate recommendation does not directly compound today.

**Filesystem scan since R3.35:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.35.md` returned exactly one operations-state file hit in active scan folders:

| File | Prior mtime | New mtime | Prior size | New size | Δ size | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md** | 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC | 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC | 16,078 | 17,777 | +11% | **SIGNIFICANT — seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs ESCALATION** |

No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-3/S-4/S-5/S-7/S-8/S-9/S-10 firings since R3.35 captured them yesterday.

**S-11 narrative (SIGNIFICANT — pattern escalation continues):**

Today's 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC scheduled backup run logged FAILED with status "OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect" — second consecutive day with the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder absent from the workspace sandbox mount. Per the new BACKUP_LOG entry, the workspace sandbox mount at `/sessions/jolly-cool-heisenberg/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, and `.remote-plugins` — no `OpenClaw-Shared`. A stray empty `OpenClaw-Shared/` directory created by an early `mkdir -p` call in Step 1 was cleaned up — no orphan dirs remain in the sandbox. No source files were modified. No tarball was written to a local-only path (per task constraint #4 — OneDrive-resident backups only).

**Pattern escalation:** R3.35's sixth-strike total-mount-loss event (single failed run) has now extended to a **seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs** pattern. The prior strikes (R3.18 / R3.21 / R3.23-recurrence / R3.25 / R3.28 / R3.30 entrenched / R3.35 sixth-strike) traced an arc from intermittent-failure → entrenched-empty-start → single-day-total-mount-loss; R3.36 now establishes that the mount-loss pattern itself is recurring, not a one-off. The cloud backup chain has now produced no new tarball for two consecutive days (last successful tarball reported by this scheduled task was **2026-05-09** `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz`; both 2026-05-10 and 2026-05-11 failed with mount-not-connected). The R3.30→R3.35 escalating recommendation to PAUSE the scheduled task pending Will-side mount-semantics investigation is now further reinforced — **URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING**.

**Suggested Will action (two-pronged, per today's BACKUP_LOG entry):**
1. Re-add the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via the chat-box "+" button so the scheduled task can resume.
2. Separately, verify on the host whether prior tarballs actually accumulated in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — the open hypothesis from the 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 runs about per-session ephemeral mount semantics remains untested.

**Changes from R3.35:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **S-11 seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs escalation** | OneDrive backup mount-loss pattern: sixth-strike total-mount-loss URGENT-FAILURE-MODE (R3.35 — single failed run) → seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING (R3.36). New BACKUP_LOG entry at 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC with status FAILED — OneDrive folder not connected this session for the second consecutive day. §7 row S-11 mtime/size + Notes refreshed; status field preserved (`SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT`). Narrative tail of §7 row S-11 description replaced with the seventh-strike escalation summary; long-form historical narrative (R3.6–R3.35) preserved in R3.35 versioned snapshot. |
| **Other operations-state files unchanged from R3.35-recorded mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-10 03:14 PDT — R3.33 coordinated post-write touch); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-10 03:14 PDT — R3.33 coordinated post-write touch); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-10 03:20 PDT — R3.33 narrative entry append); S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-10 04:13 PDT — R3.35 captured); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-10 03:43 PDT — R3.34 captured the 10:42 UTC nightly check; **third consecutive quiet day** for OpenClaw releases — no new firing since); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-10 04:19 PDT — R3.35 captured). |
| **No structural drift in any active spec folder** | Active root unchanged from R3.35 (still OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.36 versioned snapshot saved + R3.35 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder). No new files in active root, in CD Cross Docs, in DOC20 Addenda, in DOC23 Addenda (still 7 active files: A-46/A-47/A-48/A-49/A-53/A-54 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate), in DOC24 Addenda, in DOC72 Addenda and Proposals, in DOC73 Addenda and Proposals, in EC Core Addenda, in DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs, in Connectors and Integrations Addenda, in Integrated Addenda, or in DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda subfolder. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 54 (unchanged). §4 Active Addenda count: 54 (unchanged; A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 10). Grand total (all sections): 119 (unchanged). Operations files: 12 (unchanged). |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry should be appended this cycle** | Second consecutive narrative-significant DRIFT_LOG-eligible cycle (R3.35 sixth-strike + R3.36 seventh-strike). S-11 seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs escalation is qualitative pattern change worth an entry. (Auto pass cannot reliably append to DRIFT_LOG.md — `find -newer` did not return DRIFT_LOG in this scan, so the file is at R3.33 entry append state. R3.37 or later pass should backfill if not done sooner.) |
| **Carryover prompt remains V15** | No spec-folder structural drift to warrant V16 bump (operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). V15 was authored by R3.33 to capture A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal addition. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.36.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.35 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.36 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **All R3.35 carry-forward items preserved unchanged plus one escalation** | OneDrive backup mount-loss anomaly **ESCALATES** from sixth-strike total-mount-loss URGENT-FAILURE-MODE (single failed run) to **seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING**; all other carry-forward items unchanged. A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; R0.6.5-stacked-on-R0.6.4 disposition decision (fold vs keep parallel) pending human review; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation (now URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING with seventh-strike escalation); OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation BEHIND-by-9 with **third-consecutive-quiet-day drafting window** (no S-9 firing since R3.34 captured the 2026-05-10 10:42 UTC nightly check; pause assumed continuing). |
| **NEW carry-forward in R3.36 (informational)** | Single-fire cadence (first since R3.30 yesterday) breaks the recent same-day-multi-fire escalation pattern (R3.32 first triple-fire; R3.35 first quadruple-fire). The same-day-firing cooldown gate recommendation that R3.35 strengthened is not directly compounded by today's pass, but the underlying SKILL.md tightening recommendation persists at 11 un-implemented cycles. The third consecutive quiet day for OpenClaw releases (no S-9 firing change since R3.34) extends the drafting window for the deferred DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal that should fold all 9 un-folded releases plus the Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative. |
| **§7 row mtime backfill — only S-11 this pass** | R3.35 carry-forward gap of stale §7 row mtimes for S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-9 (four rows still carrying R3.34-era mtimes) is NOT closed this pass since none of those files fired since R3.35. Only S-11 row is refreshed to 2026-05-11 mtime (the one file that fired this cycle). S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-9 / S-8 / S-10 rows still carry R3.35-era mtimes (S-3/S-4 still 2026-05-10 03:14 PDT; S-5 still 2026-05-10 03:20 PDT; S-8 still 2026-05-10 04:13 PDT; S-9 still 2026-05-10 03:43 PDT; S-10 still 2026-05-10 04:19 PDT). These six remaining stale rows are R3.33/R3.34/R3.35-era products and are inferred-current; full backfill deferred to next pass. |

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**

- **PRIMARY:** S-11 seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs escalation. The OneDrive backup task has now produced NO TARBALLS for two consecutive days (2026-05-10 + 2026-05-11). Recommendation: pause the scheduled `elnor-onedrive-backup` task at the Will side until the mount-semantics issue is investigated and the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder is reliably re-mounted. The pause window also enables Finder-side host inspection of `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` to confirm prior tarballs (2026-05-04 / 2026-05-06 / 2026-05-07 / 2026-05-08 / 2026-05-09) are or are not landing on the host (which is the underlying R3.30 fifth-strike question that has never been answered).
- All other R3.35 deferred items preserved unchanged: A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal disposition decision; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE classifications; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal authoring (third-consecutive-quiet-day drafting window now open); §7 row backfill for S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 (six remaining stale rows).

---

### R3.35 — 2026-05-10 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day THIRD-firing operations-state-only bump capturing post-R3.34 S-11 BACKUP_LOG mount-loss firing + S-8 daily summary refresh + S-10 refresh-log; FIRST same-day QUADRUPLE-fire observed; S-11 SIXTH-STRIKE total-mount-loss ESCALATION)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-10 ~11:25 UTC (~04:25 PDT), ~14 minutes after R3.34's alias write at 2026-05-10 ~11:11 UTC (~04:11 PDT). Today's R3.33 (~10:13 UTC) → R3.34 (~11:11 UTC) → R3.35 (~11:25 UTC) interval establishes today as the **first same-day QUADRUPLE-fire** in this scheduled task's run history — yesterday's R3.30/R3.31/R3.32 triple-fire is now exceeded. The autonomous task continues to fire without supervision; SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence now stretches to **ten cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32 → R3.33 → R3.34 → R3.35) and is now further reinforced by today's quadruple-fire pattern.

**Filesystem scan since R3.34:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.34.md` returned exactly three operations-state file hits in active scan folders:

| File | Prior mtime | New mtime | Prior size | New size | Δ size | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md** | 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC | 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC | 15,163 | 16,078 | +6% | **SIGNIFICANT — sixth-strike total-mount-loss ESCALATION** |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md** | 2026-05-09 09:36 | 2026-05-10 04:13 PDT (~10:56 UTC per file head) | 42,106 | 53,499 | +27% | Significant — daily refresh task finally fired after multi-day miss |
| **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md** | 2026-05-09 09:53 | 2026-05-10 04:19 PDT (~11:19 UTC) | 46,014 | 52,395 | +14% | Companion refresh-log entry |

No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER firing since R3.34 captured it ~42 minutes ago.

**S-11 narrative (SIGNIFICANT — pattern escalation, first since R3.30's fifth-strike classification):**

Today's 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC scheduled backup run logged FAILED with status "OneDrive folder not connected — needs reconnect". Per BACKUP_LOG entry, verified via `mountpoint` that `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT a real bind mount this session (only `ECQ Development` is). Action note quoted verbatim from BACKUP_LOG: "Will needs to re-add the OneDrive folder OpenClaw-Shared via the chat-box '+' button so it gets mounted into future Cowork sessions. No source files were modified. No tarball was written to a local-only path (per task constraint #4 — OneDrive-resident backups only)."

**Pattern escalation:** The prior fifth-strike entrenched-pattern empty-start anomaly (R3.30 classification — "destination empty at start of run but new tarball created in spite of 48-hour gate being defeated") has now ESCALATED to **sixth-strike total-mount-loss** ("destination unreachable, no tarball created, task no-op"). This is a qualitative pattern change, not merely a continuation. The prior strikes (R3.18 / R3.21 / R3.23-recurrence / R3.30 entrenched) all produced tarballs despite the empty-start anomaly — the rotation logic was silently violated but backups were at least being attempted. R3.35's sixth-strike firing produces NO tarball; the scheduled task is no longer fulfilling its primary objective. **R3.30-strengthened recommendation to PAUSE the scheduled task pending Will-side mount-semantics investigation is now further reinforced — URGENT-FAILURE-MODE.**

**S-8 narrative:**

The daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task that R3.31 / R3.32 narratives had flagged as MISSED (for the second time this week — first miss documented in R3.27 / R3.28) finally fired today at 04:13 PDT (~10:56 UTC per file head). This is the first successful firing since the absence-window opened. File grew 27% (42,106 → 53,499 bytes) to capture:

- R3.33 substantive structural-drift narrative (first NEW addendum since A-53 R0.6.4 detection on 2026-05-04)
- NEW DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5 stacked-proposal Section 1 entry (file `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md`)
- OpenClaw release-tracker second-consecutive-quiet-day narrative + `v2026.5.9-beta.1` WATCH-ONLY beta-prerelease row
- New chat context sync 5/10 bundle rotation R3.26 → R3.33 + carryover V15 + ROADMAP source-of-truth divergence flag

Per S-8 file head: "Generated: 2026-05-10 (nightly auto-refresh)", Window 2026-05-03 → 2026-05-10 (7 days). Outstanding count: 20 prioritized actions (top: R0.6.5 disposition decision; #2 OneDrive backup pause-pending-investigation; #3 DOC11 R15 R3 amendment in extended drafting window).

**S-10 narrative:**

Companion refresh-log entry recording the 2026-05-10 10:56 refresh. File grew ~14% (46,014 → 52,395 bytes) with the new top-of-log entry. Tracks 16 documents updated (4 active in window, 12 active no surface, 0 quiescent), 5 sessions read, ROADMAP source-of-truth divergence flag, and dashboard.html `RECENT_WORK` block coordinated update.

**Changes from R3.34:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **S-11 sixth-strike total-mount-loss escalation** | OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly status changes: fifth-strike entrenched-pattern (R3.30) → sixth-strike total-mount-loss (R3.35). New BACKUP_LOG entry at 2026-05-10 11:17 UTC with status FAILED — OneDrive folder not connected this session. §7 row S-11 mtime/size + Notes refreshed; status field preserved (`SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT`). Narrative tail of §7 row S-11 description replaced with the sixth-strike escalation summary; long-form historical narrative (R3.6–R3.30) preserved in R3.34 versioned snapshot. |
| **S-8 daily-04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task fired** | First successful firing since R3.27 / R3.28 / R3.31 / R3.32 flagged the daily-04:02 refresh task as missed. mtime 2026-05-09 09:36 → 2026-05-10 04:13 PDT; size 42,106 → 53,499 bytes (+27%). §7 row S-8 mtime refreshed; row narrative preserved (the anomaly-history entries from R3.5 / R3.11 / R3.14 / R3.18 / R3.20 / R3.22 / R3.24 / R3.28 carry forward unchanged). |
| **S-10 companion refresh-log fired** | mtime 2026-05-09 09:53 → 2026-05-10 04:19 PDT; size 46,014 → 52,395 bytes (+14%). §7 row S-10 mtime refreshed; row narrative preserved. |
| **Other operations-state files unchanged from R3.34-recorded mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-10 03:14 PDT — R3.33 coordinated post-write touch); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-10 03:14 PDT — R3.33 coordinated post-write touch); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-10 03:20 PDT — R3.33 narrative entry append); S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged; S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-10 03:43 PDT — R3.34 captured the 10:42 UTC nightly check; no new firing since). |
| **No structural drift in any active spec folder** | Active root unchanged from R3.34 (still OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.35 versioned snapshot saved + R3.34 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder). No new files in active root, in CD Cross Docs, in DOC20 Addenda, in DOC23 Addenda (still 7 active files: A-46/A-47/A-48/A-49/A-53/A-54 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate), in DOC24 Addenda, in DOC72 Addenda and Proposals, in DOC73 Addenda and Proposals, in EC Core Addenda, in DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs, in Connectors and Integrations Addenda, in Integrated Addenda, or in DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda subfolder. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 54 (unchanged). §4 Active Addenda count: 54 (unchanged; A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 10). Grand total (all sections): 119 (unchanged). Operations files: 12 (unchanged). |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry should be appended this cycle** | First narrative-significant DRIFT_LOG-eligible cycle since R3.33. S-11 sixth-strike total-mount-loss escalation is qualitative pattern change worth an entry. (Auto pass cannot reliably append to DRIFT_LOG.md — `find -newer` did not return DRIFT_LOG in this scan, so the file is at R3.33 entry append state. R3.36 or later pass should backfill if not done sooner.) |
| **Carryover prompt remains V15** | No spec-folder structural drift to warrant V16 bump (operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). V15 was authored by R3.33 to capture A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal addition. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.35.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.34 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.35 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **All R3.34 carry-forward items preserved unchanged plus one escalation** | OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly **ESCALATES** from fifth-strike entrenched-pattern to **sixth-strike total-mount-loss URGENT-FAILURE-MODE**; all other carry-forward items unchanged. A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; R0.6.5-stacked-on-R0.6.4 disposition decision (fold vs keep parallel) pending human review; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation (now URGENT-FAILURE-MODE with sixth-strike escalation); OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation BEHIND-by-9 with second-consecutive-quiet-day drafting window. |
| **NEW carry-forward in R3.35 (informational)** | First same-day QUADRUPLE-fire observed in this scheduled task's run history. Yesterday's R3.30/R3.31/R3.32 triple-fire is now exceeded. SKILL.md tightening recommendation to add same-day-firing cooldown gate now stretches to **ten cycles** un-implemented. The intra-day firing cadence appears to be accelerating (yesterday: 3 fires; today: 4 fires by 11:25 UTC and the day is still young). |
| **§7 row mtime backfill — partial (S-8/S-10/S-11 only)** | R3.34 carry-forward gap of stale §7 row mtimes for S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 / S-11 is partially closed this pass: S-8 / S-10 / S-11 rows are now refreshed to 2026-05-10 mtimes (the three files that fired this cycle). S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-9 rows still carry R3.34-era mtimes (S-3/S-4 still 2026-05-10 03:14 PDT; S-5 still 2026-05-10 03:20 PDT; S-9 still 2026-05-10 03:43 PDT). These four remaining stale rows are R3.33/R3.34 coordinated post-write touch products and are inferred-current; full backfill deferred to next pass. |

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**

- **PRIMARY:** S-11 sixth-strike total-mount-loss escalation. The OneDrive backup task is now NO LONGER PRODUCING TARBALLS. Recommendation: pause the scheduled `elnor-onedrive-backup` task at the Will side until the mount-semantics issue is investigated and the OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder is reliably re-mounted. The pause window also enables Finder-side host inspection of `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` to confirm prior tarballs are or are not landing on the host (which is the underlying R3.30 fifth-strike question that has never been answered).
- Same-day QUADRUPLE-fire is the new escalation pattern. SKILL.md tightening to add a same-day-firing cooldown gate (e.g., suppress alias write if `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_<prev>.md` returns only operations-state files attributable to the prior run's coordinated post-write touches OR if last alias write was within the past hour) now persisted ten cycles un-implemented. Will-side procedural action remains warranted to break the pattern.
- All other R3.34 deferred items preserved unchanged: A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal disposition decision; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE classifications; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate canonicalization; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal authoring (second-consecutive-quiet-day drafting window remains open); §7 row backfill for S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-9 (four remaining stale rows).

---

### R3.34 — 2026-05-10 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day second-firing operations-state-only bump capturing post-R3.33 S-9 OpenClaw release-tracker firing; second consecutive quiet day for OpenClaw releases)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-10 ~11:08 UTC (~04:08 PDT), ~55 minutes after R3.33's alias write at 2026-05-10 ~10:13 UTC (~03:13 PDT). **Filesystem scan since R3.33:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.33.md` returned exactly one substantive hit in active scan folders — `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9, mtime 2026-05-10 03:43 PDT / 10:43 UTC, size 37,739 → 42,770 bytes; ~13% growth). Three other operations-state files touched within ~7 minutes of R3.33's alias write — S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (mtime 03:14 PDT, +1m after R3.33 alias write), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (03:14 PDT, +1m), S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (03:20 PDT, +7m) — are inferred to be R3.33's own coordinated post-write touches rather than independent task firings, mirroring the same attribution pattern R3.31/R3.32 applied to R3.30's coordinated post-write touches. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing since R3.30 captured it at 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC (the OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly remains at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification with no new firing to advance or downgrade the status). R3.34 is an **operations-state-only bump** materializing the substantive content of today's S-9 firing into the §7 row + §10 narrative + this §12 changelog entry.

**S-9 narrative (2026-05-10 10:42 UTC nightly check):**

| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Latest stable release | **2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC) — UNCHANGED from yesterday and the day before. Second consecutive quiet day.** |
| Gap status | BEHIND-by-9 (composition unchanged from 2026-05-08 / 2026-05-09 entries) |
| New stable releases since prior check | NONE (second consecutive quiet day; 2026.4.27 → 2026.5.7 daily-cadence streak has now paused for 48+ hours) |
| Prerelease activity (WATCH-ONLY) | `v2026.5.9-beta.1` published 2026-05-09 with two contract-touching items: (1) chat-command additions `/think default` and `/fast default` that clear session overrides and inherit configured/provider defaults; (2) gateway/recovery hardening — chmod restored `openclaw.json` back to owner-only `0600` on POSIX hosts after suspicious-read backup recovery (so a previously world-readable config mode cannot persist into a freshly restored credential-bearing config). Beta dist-tag only — does NOT promote into the stable alignment basis until cut as `v2026.5.9` (or higher) on the latest dist-tag. |
| Version sequence skip | No `v2026.5.8` tag exists in any form (stable or beta) — the version-number sequence appears to be skipping 5.8 the way it skipped 4.28 / 4.30 / 5.0 / 5.1. |
| Recommendation | DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal recommendation HOLDS at BEHIND-by-9 with all 9 un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 + 2026.5.7) — today's pause halts gap growth at 9 but does not narrow it. Two consecutive quiet days create a useful drafting window; the daily-cadence streak pause may signal a release-cadence inflection point worth monitoring. |

**Changes from R3.33:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md mtime/size/content tick** | mtime 2026-05-09 12:00 UTC → 2026-05-10 10:43 UTC; size 37,739 → 42,770 bytes (~+13%). New nightly-check entry at top of file recording 2026-05-10 10:42 UTC narrative summarized above. Row S-9 in §7 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved; `lastChecked` advanced to 2026-05-10. |
| **Operations-state files unchanged from R3.33-recorded mtimes (other than S-9 + R3.33 coordinated post-write touches)** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-10 03:14 PDT / 45,643 bytes — R3.33 coordinated post-write touch at +1m); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-10 03:14 PDT / 49,447 bytes — R3.33 coordinated post-write touch at +1m); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-10 03:20 PDT / 124,310 bytes — R3.33 narrative entry append at +7m); S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-09 16:48 / 42,106 bytes — unchanged from R3.32-recorded coordinated touch); S-9 — see above; S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-09 16:53 / 46,014 bytes — unchanged from R3.32-recorded coordinated touch); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-09 16:29 UTC / 15,163 bytes — unchanged since R3.30 captured it; fifth-strike entrenched-pattern empty-start anomaly carries forward URGENT). |
| **No structural drift in any active spec folder** | Active root unchanged from R3.33 (still OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.34 versioned snapshot saved + R3.33 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder). No new files in active root, in CD Cross Docs, in DOC20 Addenda, in DOC23 Addenda (still 7 active files: A-46/A-47/A-48/A-49/A-53/A-54 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate), in DOC24 Addenda, in DOC72 Addenda and Proposals, in DOC73 Addenda and Proposals, in EC Core Addenda, in DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs, in Connectors and Integrations Addenda, in Integrated Addenda, or in DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda subfolder. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 54 (unchanged). §4 Active Addenda count: 54 (unchanged; A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 10). Grand total (all sections): 119 (unchanged). Operations files: 12 (unchanged). |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle** | Matching R3.27/R3.28/R3.29/R3.31/R3.32 pattern: same-day operations-state-only bumps with no NEW filesystem drift in active spec folders do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries; only narrative-significant cycles (e.g., R3.30 S-11 entrenched-pattern + S-9 first-quiet-day) or active-spec-folder drift cycles (e.g., R3.33 A-54 R0.6.5 NEW) append. R3.33 was the most recent DRIFT_LOG entry; R3.34's S-9 second-quiet-day continuation is mtime-significant but not narrative-significant in the same way R3.30's first-quiet-day was. |
| **Carryover prompt remains V15** | No spec-folder structural drift to warrant V16 bump (operations-state-only run; spec folders quiet). V15 was authored by R3.33 to capture A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal addition + the new "merge proposal not yet folded" pattern. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.34.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.33 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.34 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **All R3.33 carry-forward items preserved unchanged** | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; R0.6.5-stacked-on-R0.6.4 disposition decision (fold vs keep parallel) pending human review; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification (URGENT-PRE-RESUMPTION); OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to **nine cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32 → R3.33 → R3.34). |
| **NEW carry-forward in R3.34 (informational)** | The OpenClaw release-cadence pause has now stretched to **two consecutive quiet days** (2026-05-08 first quiet day, 2026-05-09 second quiet day, 2026-05-10 check confirms). The 2026.4.27 → 2026.5.7 daily-cadence streak that ran for ~10 consecutive release-days has now paused for 48+ hours. Whether this is a temporary lull or a release-cadence inflection point is worth monitoring at next nightly check. The two-quiet-day window also creates a useful drafting opportunity for the deferred DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal that should fold all 9 un-folded releases plus the Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative. |

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Same-day second-firing pattern continues (R3.30/R3.31/R3.32 yesterday triple-fire; R3.33/R3.34 today double-fire). SKILL.md tightening recommendation now persisted nine cycles un-implemented. Will-side procedural action remains warranted to break the pattern; the autonomous task continues to fire without supervision and produce same-day operations-state-only or fire-only-mechanical bumps regardless of underlying drift levels.
- All other R3.33 deferred items preserved unchanged: A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal disposition decision (fold into R0.6.4 producing R0.6.5-merged unified draft following prior supersession pattern, OR keep parallel as stacked proposals with R0.6.4 base + R0.6.5 additive layer, OR other disposition); A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE classifications; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate canonicalization; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly fifth-strike investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal authoring (now also has two-quiet-day drafting window).

---

### R3.33 — 2026-05-10 (nightly sync auto-bump — structural drift detected; 1 NEW addendum file in DOC23 Addenda; first NEW addendum since A-53 R0.6.4 detection on 2026-05-04 R3.18; ends fourteen-revision window of operations-state-only or fire-only-mechanical bumps)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job firing 2026-05-10 ~10:07 UTC. **Substantial structural drift detected since R3.32** — 1 NEW addendum file in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder. **Filesystem scan since R3.32:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.32.md` returned exactly one hit in active spec folders: `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-10 00:14:54 UTC, size 74,733 bytes). No other filesystem drift detected: all operations-state files (S-3 SPEC_STATE, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE, S-5 DRIFT_LOG, S-7 OP-A V3.7, S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY, S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG, S-11 BACKUP_LOG) unchanged from R3.32-recorded mtimes; no new files in any other tracked subfolders.

**Changes from R3.32:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **NEW: A-54 DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5 — Outcome Evaluation, Source Workspace, Task Forum, and Evaluator Feedback Proposal** | Filename `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (typo "PROPSAL" preserved verbatim from filesystem). mtime 2026-05-10 00:14:54 UTC, size 74,733 bytes. Per file header: date 2026-05-10, status **"Initial merge proposal for review. Not yet folded into the R0.6.4 unified Addenda B draft."** Target: DOC23 Addenda B (same end-state architectural draft track as A-53 R0.6.4). Companion documents per file header: DOC23 R3.1, DOC23 Addenda A R4.1/R5-R6 deferral list (= A-47/A-48), DOC20 R4.3, DOC24 R3, DOC24 KDA R2 (= A-19), DOC25 V2.0, DOC72 R5.73, DOC73 V1.5, DOC17 R4.2, DOC8 v1.11.4, BDSM v6.4 (= A-22), DOC11/OpenClaw R15 amendment proposal (= A-1/A-34), DOC12 forum/panel architecture, EC Core Addendum A (= A-4), PropA R6.3 (= A-7). Per §0 Executive Summary: "Add a graph-native quality-improvement architecture for complex DOC23 tasks, without turning tasks into hidden agent rooms or making simple tasks heavy." Eight new architectural primitives: Outcome Specs / Outcome Evaluators / Outcome Gates / Evaluator Feedback Bundles / Task Source Workspace / Task Run Board / Task Forum Module / Task Agent role retained. Per §1 Governing Principles: graph primacy preserved (DOC23 graph remains source of process truth); forum non-necessity (Task Run Board/Forum never required); domain-agnostic in core primitives + legally powerful through saved configurations. New row A-54 added in §4.A6 (DOC23 Addenda subfolder) as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. |
| **NEW pattern: stacked proposal (distinct from B-track supersession-and-archive pattern)** | A-54 R0.6.5 is positioned as ADDITIONAL stacked proposal on top of A-53 R0.6.4 rather than a strict supersession — file header explicitly states "Not yet folded into the R0.6.4 unified Addenda B draft." This is a NEW pattern in the DOC23 Addenda B chain, distinct from the prior B-track supersession-and-archive pattern (R0.3 → R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4). Both A-53 R0.6.4 and A-54 R0.6.5 coexist as ACTIVE in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder pending human classification + folder disposition. **Disposition options for human review:** (a) fold R0.6.5 into R0.6.4 producing R0.6.5-merged unified draft following the prior supersession pattern; (b) keep them parallel as stacked proposals with R0.6.4 as base + R0.6.5 as additive layer; (c) some other disposition. Auto pass leaves both ACTIVE pending decision. |
| **Operations-state files unchanged from R3.32-recorded mtimes** | All operations-state files unchanged: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-09 16:35 / 45,897 bytes — to be touched by tonight's R3.33 backfill); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-09 16:35 / 41,484 bytes — to be touched by tonight's R3.33 backfill); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-09 16:36 / 111,976 bytes — to be appended by tonight's R3.33 entry); S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-09 16:48 / 42,106 bytes — unchanged from R3.32-recorded coordinated touch); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-09 12:00 UTC / 37,739 bytes — unchanged since R3.30 captured it; no new release published since 2026.5.7 from 2026-05-07; thirteen-day single-release roll-forward standstill continues); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-09 16:53 / 46,014 bytes — unchanged from R3.32-recorded coordinated touch); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-09 16:29 UTC / 15,163 bytes — unchanged since R3.30 captured it; fifth-strike entrenched-pattern empty-start anomaly carries forward URGENT). |
| **No structural drift in active root or other tracked subfolders** | Folder counts unchanged from R3.32 except `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/`: active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root .md set unchanged (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.33 versioned snapshot saved + R3.32 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active root, in CD Cross Docs, in DOC20 Addenda, in DOC24 Addenda, in DOC72 Addenda and Proposals, in DOC73 Addenda and Proposals, in EC Core Addenda, in DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs, in Connectors and Integrations Addenda, in Integrated Addenda, or in DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda subfolder. |
| **§11 counts updated** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 53 → 54 (+1 for A-54 R0.6.5 NEW; A-53 R0.6.4 preserved as ACTIVE alongside A-54). §4 Active Addenda count: 53 → 54 (A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 9 → 10 — added A-54 R0.6.5 NEW alongside A-53 R0.6.4; A-50/A-51/A-52 aliases preserved as file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive pointers). Grand total (all sections): 118 → 119 (+1 for A-54 R0.6.5). Operations files: 12 (unchanged). |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry appended** | Tonight's run produces a substantive DRIFT_LOG entry (first NEW addendum in active folder since A-53 R0.6.4 detection on 2026-05-04 R3.18; ends the R3.18 → R3.32 fourteen-revision window of operations-state-only or fire-only-mechanical bumps that produced either no DRIFT_LOG entry or only narrative-significant operations-state ticks). |
| **Carryover prompt bumped V14 → V15** | Bumped to capture A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal addition to the DOC23 Addenda B track + the new "merge proposal not yet folded" pattern (distinct from prior B-track supersession-and-archive pattern). V15 inherits all V14 invariants (workstreams A through K with Capability Registry Sweep added 2026-04-27; volatile-state-on-dashboard pointer; ROADMAP.md project-internal-infrastructure note). V14 retained alongside V13 + V12 per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.33.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.32 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.33 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **Carry-forward items preserved unchanged from R3.32** | A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (R3.33 emphasizes: today's R3.33 detection happened BECAUSE auto pass scans `DOC23 Addenda/` by precedent — SKILL.md update remains pending); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly remains at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification (URGENT-PRE-RESUMPTION); OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation BEHIND-by-9 with thirteen-day single-release roll-forward standstill. |
| **NEW carry-forward in R3.33 (informational)** | The "stacked proposal not folded into prior unified draft" pattern is a NEW DOC23 Addenda B track convention, distinct from the prior supersession-and-archive pattern. Future R3.34+ runs will need to track whether R0.6.5 gets folded into a R0.6.6 unified draft (returning to the supersession pattern) or whether the stacked-proposal pattern becomes the new convention. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to **eight cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32 → R3.33). |

---

### R3.32 — 2026-05-09 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day THIRD-firing fire-only mechanical bump; zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.31; first same-day TRIPLE-fire observed)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-09 ~23:06 UTC (~16:06 PDT), ~6h23m after R3.31's alias write at 09:43:57 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.31:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.31.md` returned exactly two operations-state files — S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (mtime 09:48:06 local; +4m9s after R3.31 alias write) and S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (mtime 09:53:13 local; +9m16s after R3.31 alias write) — both within ~10 minutes of R3.31's alias write at 09:43:57 and inferred to be R3.31's own coordinated post-write touches rather than independent task firings. This mirrors the same attribution pattern R3.31 itself applied to the four operations-state files (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8) that R3.30 had touched within ~3 minutes of R3.30's alias write. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no S-9 / S-11 firings since R3.30 captured them at 12:00 UTC / 16:29 UTC respectively.

**First same-day TRIPLE-fire observed in this scheduled task's run history:** Today's R3.30 (09:33 local) → R3.31 (09:43 local, +~10min) → R3.32 (16:06 local, +~6h23m) interval establishes today as the FIRST same-day TRIPLE-fire in this scheduled task's run history. Same-day double-fires were already well-established across multiple weeks (historical clusters R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24+R3.25; this week's clusters R3.26/R3.27/R3.28 + R3.29/R3.30/R3.31). R3.32 escalates the cadence pattern from double to triple. The autonomous task is firing without supervision and continues to produce same-day-mechanical-bump revisions on cadence regardless of underlying drift levels — SKILL.md tightening recommendation now persisted **seven cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31 → R3.32). Will-side procedural action increasingly warranted to break the pattern; the same-day triple-fire is a new escalation worth flagging.

**Daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task continues to be missed:** R3.31 narrative flagged today's daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh as having missed its scheduled firing for the second time this week (first miss documented in R3.27/R3.28). R3.32 confirms the absence-window has now extended from "missed at 09:38" to "missed for ~12 additional hours through 16:06" — no 04:02 firing has occurred between R3.31's 09:43 generation and R3.32's 16:06 generation. Today's 09:48 / 09:53 mtimes on S-8 / S-10 are R3.31 sync coordinated touches, NOT today's daily refresh. The daily-04:02 task gap continues to widen and remains a next-sync scrutiny item rather than fresh drift.

**§7 row backfill deferred to next pass per established pattern:** R3.31 inherited unfilled §7 row mtimes for S-3 (still `mtime 2026-05-07 03:09`) / S-4 (still `mtime 2026-05-07 03:09`) / S-5 (still `mtime 2026-05-07 03:10`) / S-8 (still `mtime 2026-05-08 04:02`) / S-9 (still `mtime 2026-05-08 03:44`) / S-11 (still `mtime 2026-05-08 04:21`) despite their filesystem mtimes advancing during the R3.30/R3.31 cycle. R3.32 inherits the same row-backfill gap unchanged AND adds two more deferred rows (S-8 09:48 / S-10 09:53 from the R3.31 coordinated post-write touches). This continues the alias-bump-skipped-§7-row-update pattern documented across R3.27 (skipped) → R3.28 (backfilled) → R3.29 (zero drift) → R3.30 (skipped) → R3.31 (skipped, fire-only) → R3.32 (skipped, fire-only). Row backfill deferred to next narrative-significant or backfill pass.

**Counts unchanged:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §A6 active rows 9; Operations files 12; Grand total 118.

**Carryover prompt remains V14** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V15 bump (same-day fire-only run; spec folders quiet).

**Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup:** `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.32.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.31 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.32 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle** (matching R3.27/R3.28/R3.29/R3.31 pattern: same-day fire-only mechanical bumps with zero NEW filesystem drift do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries; only narrative-significant or filesystem-drift cycles append; R3.30 was the most recent narrative-significant entry).

**All R3.31 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly remains at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification** with R3.30 strengthened recommendation to pause the scheduled task pending Will-side mount-semantics investigation (carries forward URGENT — no S-11 firing has occurred since R3.30 captured it at 16:29 UTC, so empty-start status is unchanged but still URGENT); OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation BEHIND-by-9 with Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required, twelve-day single-release roll-forward standstill (no S-9 firing has occurred since R3.30 captured it at 12:00 UTC, so release-tracker status is unchanged from R3.30/R3.31 narrative).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Same-day TRIPLE-fire pattern is new — first observation in this scheduled task's run history. Recommend SKILL.md tightening to add a same-day-firing cooldown gate (e.g., suppress alias write if `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_<prev>.md` returns only operations-state files attributable to the prior run's coordinated post-write touches). This recommendation now persisted seven cycles un-implemented.
- §7 row mtime backfill outstanding for S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 / S-11 — six rows now have stale §7 mtimes vs. filesystem reality. Backfill should occur at next narrative-significant cycle.
- All other R3.31 deferred items preserved unchanged.

---

### R3.31 — 2026-05-09 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day second-firing fire-only mechanical bump; zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.30)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-09 ~16:38 UTC (~09:38 PDT), ~5 minutes after R3.30's alias write at 09:33:44 local. **Filesystem scan since R3.30:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.30.md` returned only operations-state files touched as part of the R3.30 sync run itself — S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (mtime 09:35:13), S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (09:35:22), S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (09:36:15), S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (09:36:56) — all within ~3 minutes of R3.30's alias write at 09:33:44 and inferred to be R3.30's own post-write touches rather than independent task firings. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no new S-9/S-11 firings since R3.30 captured them at 12:00 UTC / 16:29 UTC respectively.

**Same-day double-fire pattern continues:** Today's R3.30 (09:30 local) → R3.31 (09:38 local) interval of ~8 minutes is the tightest same-day interval observed in this scheduled task's run history (prior tightest: R3.13/R3.14 at ~46 min; R3.26/R3.27 at ~76 min; R3.27/R3.28 at ~12 min). Same-day double-fires are now well-established (historical clusters R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24+R3.25; this week's clusters R3.26/R3.27/R3.28 + R3.29/R3.30/R3.31). The autonomous task is firing without supervision and continues to produce same-day-mechanical-bump revisions on cadence regardless of underlying drift levels — SKILL.md tightening recommendation now persisted **six cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30 → R3.31).

**Notable narrative-inaccuracy carry-forward observed from R3.30 (NOT recharged as new drift):** R3.30 narrative + R3.30 §7 SPEC_STATE row note both claimed `S-7/S-8/S-10 unchanged from R3.28/R3.27 (no firing of those tasks since R3.29)`, but filesystem shows S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime advanced 2026-05-08 04:02 → 2026-05-09 09:36 (size 41,222 → 41,735 bytes; +0.5%). R3.31 attributes this to a coordinated touch by R3.30's own sync write rather than the daily 04:02 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task firing, which has not fired today at sync time of 09:38; today's daily 04:02 firing missed for the second time this week per cadence-monitor signal — first miss documented in R3.27/R3.28. R3.31 flags this as next-sync scrutiny item rather than re-classifying as fresh drift.

**§7 row backfill deferred to next pass per established pattern:** R3.30's narrative captured S-9 (mtime 2026-05-09 12:00 UTC, 34,357 → 37,739 bytes) + S-11 (mtime 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC, 12,994 → 15,163 bytes) substantive ticks but did NOT update the §7 row mtimes (S-9 row still reads `mtime 2026-05-08 03:44`; S-11 row still reads `mtime 2026-05-08 04:21`). R3.30 also did not update §7 rows S-3 (still `mtime 2026-05-07 03:09`) / S-4 (still `mtime 2026-05-07 03:09`) / S-5 (still `mtime 2026-05-07 03:10`) / S-8 (still `mtime 2026-05-08 04:02`) despite their filesystem mtimes advancing today. This is the alias-bump-skipped-§7-row-update pattern documented across R3.27 (skipped S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 row updates) → R3.28 (backfilled them) → R3.29 (zero drift, nothing to skip) → R3.30 (skipped S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-11 row updates) → R3.31 (this fire-only pass; row backfill deferred to next narrative-significant or backfill pass).

**Counts unchanged:** §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §A6 active rows 9; Operations files 12; Grand total 118.

**Carryover prompt remains V14** — no spec-folder structural drift to warrant V15 bump (same-day fire-only run; spec folders quiet).

**Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup:** `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.31.md` saved alongside alias write; R3.30 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.31 + alias only per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series.

**DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle** (matching R3.27/R3.28/R3.29 pattern: same-day fire-only mechanical bumps with zero NEW filesystem drift do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries; only narrative-significant or filesystem-drift cycles append; R3.30 was the most recent narrative-significant entry).

**All R3.30 carry-forward items preserved unchanged:** A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows; DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows; A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification; (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization; **OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly remains at fifth-strike entrenched-pattern classification** with R3.30 strengthened recommendation to pause the scheduled task pending Will-side mount-semantics investigation (carries forward URGENT); OneDrive connection persistence problem still pending Will-side investigation; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal recommendation BEHIND-by-9 with Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required, twelve-day single-release roll-forward standstill (today's pause halts gap growth at 9 but does not narrow it).

---

### R3.30 — 2026-05-09 (nightly sync auto-bump — operations-state-only bump capturing same-day S-9 + S-11 firings)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing on 2026-05-09 ~16:30 UTC, after R3.29's 2026-05-08 ~18:50 local generation. **Filesystem scan since R3.29:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.29.md` against in-scope folders returned exactly two hits — both in `Operations Docs/`: S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md and S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md. No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations, no other operations-log ticks. R3.30 is an operations-state-only bump materializing the substantive content of today's S-9 + S-11 firings into §7 rows + §10 narrative subsection + DRIFT_LOG entry. R3.29 (yesterday's same-day fourth fire-only mechanical bump) had zero filesystem drift to record; R3.30 is its narrative-significant counterpart capturing the firings R3.29 anticipated as "next fire tomorrow morning."

**Changes from R3.29:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **NEW: S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER 2026-05-09 11:59 entry — first day in nearly two weeks without a new release** | mtime 2026-05-08 03:44 → 2026-05-09 12:00 UTC; size 34,357 → 37,739 bytes (~10% growth). Latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC); no v2026.5.8 published yet. **Daily-cadence streak from 2026.4.27 through 2026.5.7 has paused.** Gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-9 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7); 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 were not published as stable. Today's pause halts gap growth but does not narrow it. Twelve-day standstill on single-release roll-forwards continues. **Recommendation unchanged:** an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold all nine un-folded releases in one consolidated pass — with the Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). The pause window is a useful drafting opportunity rather than a deadline relief. Row S-9 §7 mtime + Notes refreshed. |
| **NEW: S-11 BACKUP_LOG 2026-05-09 16:18 entry — fifth consecutive empty-start strike, recommend pausing the task** | mtime 2026-05-08 04:21 → 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC; size 12,994 → 15,163 bytes (~17% growth). Fifth SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run at 2026-05-09 16:18 UTC (09:18 local). Archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` (5.40 MB compressed from 19 MB / 19,216,816 bytes uncompressed source). Mount path this run: `/sessions/fervent-sweet-galileo/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Five of seven autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success, 5/8 success, 5/9 success — 5-of-7 = 71% success rate). **CRITICAL: destination empty at start of run for the FIFTH CONSECUTIVE TIME** (2026-05-04, 2026-05-06, 2026-05-07, 2026-05-08, 2026-05-09). Pattern is now entrenched — no longer a one-off anomaly. The 48-hour gate is permanently defeated because each session opens with zero pre-existing tarballs; rotation logic will never fire because each run sees an empty destination, so the cap-of-3 invariant is silently violated. **Entry recommendation strengthens to "recommend pausing the scheduled task and investigating the mount semantics before the next run."** Empty-start anomaly graduated from third-strike (R3.25) → fourth-strike (R3.28) → **fifth-strike entrenched-pattern (R3.30)**. Row S-11 §7 mtime + Notes refreshed; status holds RESOLVED across five consecutive autonomous successes — but the persistence question is now URGENT, not informational. |
| **Operations-state files unchanged from R3.29-recorded mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 / 39,045 bytes — to be touched by tonight's R3.30 backfill); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 / 41,338 bytes — to be touched by tonight's R3.30 backfill); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-08 03:15 / 102,215 bytes — to be appended by tonight's R3.30 entry); S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md unchanged from R3.28 (2026-05-08 04:02 / 41,222 bytes); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md unchanged from R3.27 (2026-05-08 04:24 / 41,701 bytes — today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh has not yet fired at R3.30 sync time of ~16:30 UTC). |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder counts unchanged from R3.29: active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root .md set unchanged (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.30 versioned snapshot saved + R3.29 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18–R3.29. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12. Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered tonight; operations-state-only run with no structural spec-folder drift does not warrant V15 bump under any rule. V14 honors all carryover invariants (workstream A through K with Capability Registry Sweep added 2026-04-27; volatile-state-on-dashboard pointer; ROADMAP.md project-internal-infrastructure note). |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.30.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.29 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.30 only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry appended** | R3.30 entry summarizes the OpenClaw 2026.5.7 unchanged + first-day-without-release detection + S-11 fifth-strike entrenched empty-start pattern (URGENT carry-forward, recommend pausing task) + carry-forward inventory. **R3.30 breaks the R3.28/R3.29 fire-only-mechanical-bump pattern** (which had skipped DRIFT_LOG entries) because both S-9 and S-11 contain narrative-significant updates. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.30 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-9 / S-11 mtime + Notes refresh; S-3 / S-4 / S-5 will be advanced to 2026-05-09 mtimes by tonight's backfill but row content preserved; S-7 / S-8 / S-10 row content preserved (S-8 / S-10 unchanged since R3.28 / R3.27 respectively).
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.30 sub-section under §10 documents S-11 fifth-strike entrenched-pattern + S-9 first-day-without-release.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.29 except where strengthened (S-11 fifth strike, recommend pausing task) or held (OpenClaw BEHIND-by-9 unchanged).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder pending archival decision (now superseded by A-34 R2).
- DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list.
- DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows.
- DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate all still pending human classification.
- OneDrive backup connection persistence — **URGENT, recommend pausing scheduled task pending Will-side investigation of mount semantics**.
- DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal — recommendation stands at strengthened-per-R3.28 status (BEHIND-by-9, Codex OAuth route saga three-act closure narrative-required).
- SKILL.md tightening recommendation — now persisted **five cycles** un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.27 → R3.28 → R3.29 → R3.30); Will-side procedural action increasingly warranted to break the pattern.

---

### R3.29 — 2026-05-08 (nightly sync auto-bump — same-day fourth sync, fire-only mechanical bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing a fourth time on 2026-05-08 ~18:50 local, after R3.28's ~04:35 same-day-third pass. **Zero NEW filesystem drift in active spec folders since R3.28.** Operations-state files all unchanged from R3.28-recorded mtimes (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-7/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 all preserved). Same-day cycle today extended R3.26 ~03:10 → R3.27 ~04:23 → R3.28 ~04:35 → R3.29 ~18:50, with the ~14-hour gap between R3.28 and R3.29 corresponding to the Friday daytime work window. First same-day evening-slot firing observed in this scheduled task's run history.

**Changes from R3.28:** Header revision R3.28 → R3.29; counts unchanged; carryover unchanged at V14; versioned snapshot saved; R3.28 versioned file archived; DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended (matching the R3.28/R3.25 pattern: fire-only mechanical bumps with zero substantive content do not produce DRIFT_LOG entries). NEW carry-forward (informational): SKILL.md procedure has now persisted four cycles without recommended tightening — Will-side procedural action increasingly warranted.

---

### R3.28 — 2026-05-08 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day, two-axis backfill pass)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing a third time on 2026-05-08, after R3.27's ~04:23 same-day-second mechanical bump. **Zero NEW filesystem drift in active spec folders since R3.27** (filesystem scan returned zero hits in `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root or any tracked subfolder, or active `Operations Docs/`). Tonight's R3.28 sync is a **two-axis backfill pass** capturing (a) operations-state drift R3.27 narrative-acknowledged but failed to materialize into §7 rows + (b) post-R3.27 operations-state firings R3.27 missed entirely. Same alias-bump-skipped-§7-rows pattern as the R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 §12-changelog skipped + R3.24/R3.25 §7-row-mtime skipped backfill cycles documented in earlier runs — this is now the third instance of the pattern within the past 30 days and may merit Will-side procedural action on the SKILL.md.

**Changes from R3.27:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **Backfill: S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER content delta materialized** | R3.27 narrative noted S-9 mtime advance to 2026-05-08 03:44 but did NOT capture the substantive content delta. R3.28 backfills: 2026.5.7 detected as new stable (gap widened BEHIND-by-8 → BEHIND-by-9). 2026.5.7 closes the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 → 2026.5.7 Codex OAuth route saga as a three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). DOC11 R15 R3 may now treat the rule as stable precedent for capability-bound default-runtime resolution but should fold the saga as a single closed three-act narrative rather than three separate rows. Other 2026.5.7 quiet contract changes worth tracking: Active Memory admin-scope (#78863); Channels CLI restructured (#78456); Cron CLI status field (#78701); Native commands owner enforcement (#78864); Auto-reply before-tool-call hooks (#78517); Codex approvals dropping pre-guardian PermissionRequest hook + remembering allow-always within session; Discord voice permission auditing + post-speech silence grace 2.5s. **Recommendation strengthened:** an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold all nine un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 + **2026.5.7 NEW**) in one consolidated pass with the Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative — REPLACES R3.24's "must-explicitly-not-canonize" note. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence ~12 consecutive days. Row S-9 §7 mtime + Notes refreshed (R3.27 §7-row-gap closed). |
| **Backfill: S-11 BACKUP_LOG fourth autonomous-success-path run + FOURTH consecutive empty-start strike** | R3.27 INCORRECTLY narrated S-11 as "(2026-05-07 04:17, 11,038 bytes) unchanged from R3.26 baseline since today's daily 04:08/04:17 firings have not yet occurred at R3.27 sync time of ~04:23 local" — factually incorrect; today's S-11 firing actually occurred at 2026-05-08 04:21:45 local (~2 minutes BEFORE R3.27 generation time of ~04:23). R3.28 backfills: mtime advanced 2026-05-07 04:17 → 2026-05-08 04:21, size grew 11,038 → 12,994 bytes (~18%) recording fourth SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run at 2026-05-08 11:21 UTC. Archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-08_112116.tgz` (5.38 MB compressed from 19 MB). Mount path `/sessions/upbeat-gifted-thompson/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Four of six autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success, 5/8 success — 4-of-6 = 67% success rate). **CRITICAL: destination empty at start of run for the FOURTH CONSECUTIVE TIME** (rotation logic in this script will never run because destination always looks empty — meaning script is NOT actually capping at 3 backups across runs). Row S-11 §7 mtime + Notes refreshed; status holds RESOLVED across four consecutive autonomous successes. |
| **Backfill: S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY mtime + size with second size-decrease anomaly** | R3.27 narrative noted S-8 mtime advance to 2026-05-08 04:02 but did NOT capture size delta or update §7 row. R3.28 backfills: mtime advanced 2026-05-07 04:03 → 2026-05-08 04:02, size shrank 43,864 → 41,222 bytes (-6.0%). Second size-decrease across the auto-refresh series (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 → R3.22 40,104 → R3.24 43,864 → R3.28 41,222). Today's value below R3.24 peak by ~6% and essentially equal to R3.18 prior peak. Per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md head: Window 2026-05-01 → 2026-05-08 (7-day rolling window) may explain oscillation. R3.24 noted FULLY RESOLVED of R3.20 anomaly; R3.28 reopens in milder form. Row S-8 §7 mtime + Notes refreshed (R3.27 §7-row-gap closed). |
| **Operations-state files unchanged from R3.27 mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 / 37,092 bytes preserved); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-08 03:12 / 41,199 bytes preserved); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-08 03:15 / 93,077 bytes preserved); S-7 OP-A V3.7 unchanged; S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md unchanged from R3.25 (2026-05-07 04:08 / 35,320 bytes — today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh did not produce a corresponding log append, possibly because today's refresh ran in a mode that bypasses the log). |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder counts unchanged from R3.27: active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root .md set unchanged (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.28 versioned snapshot transient — to be archived by next sync's audit-cleanup pass + R3.27 versioned snapshot archived this run + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs other than the R3.27 versioned snapshot move described below. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18–R3.27. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12. Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered tonight; pure operations-state-only run with no structural spec-folder drift does not warrant V15 bump under any rule. V14 honors all carryover invariants. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.28.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.27 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains R3.28 only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry appended** | R3.28 entry summarizes the OpenClaw 2026.5.7 detection (BEHIND-by-9 + Codex saga three-act closure) + S-11 fourth empty-start strike (URGENT carry-forward strengthened, rotation logic confirmed never firing) + S-8 second size-decrease anomaly + R3.27 §7-row-gap backfill + carry-forward inventory. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.28 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-8 / S-9 / S-11 mtime + Notes refresh; S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-7 / S-10 row content preserved (S-3/S-4/S-5 were already updated to 2026-05-08 mtimes by R3.26 backfill; S-10 unchanged from R3.25).
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.28 sub-section under §10 documents OpenClaw 2026.5.7 detection + S-11 fourth strike + S-8 reopen + R3.27 §7-row-gap procedural anomaly.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.27 except where strengthened (S-11 fourth strike), reopened (S-8), or progressed (OpenClaw BEHIND-by-9).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **Carry-forward (R3.25 strengthened to R3.28 STRENGTHENED FURTHER, urgent):** OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — four consecutive occurrences. Rotation logic confirmed never firing across runs. Will to manually inspect actual OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents in Finder to confirm whether prior tarballs are persisting in cloud storage.
- **Carry-forward (R3.24 progressed to R3.28 BEHIND-by-9):** OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal needed; gap is now 9 unfolded releases. The DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal should fold the Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover) — REPLACES R3.24's "must-explicitly-not-canonize" note since 5.7's safe-form rule is back in stable.
- **Carry-forward (R3.21):** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence.
- **Carry-forward (R3.18):** Final classification of A-53 R0.6.4 placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- **NEW carry-forward (R3.28, procedural):** R3.27 §7-row-gap is the third instance of the alias-bump-skipped-§7-row pattern within the past 30 days (R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 missed §12 changelog entries; R3.24/R3.25 missed §7 row mtimes; R3.27 missed §7 row mtimes AND mis-narrated S-11 mtime AND missed S-9 content delta). The R3.26 narrative's recommendation that the SKILL.md procedure should be tightened to actually execute audit-cleanup + §12 append + §7 row updates at bump time has not been implemented and may be worth Will-side procedural action.

**§7 row updates NOT performed by R3.28 because preserved-from-R3.27 was correct:**
- S-3 / S-4 / S-5 mtimes (preserved at 2026-05-08 03:12 / 03:12 / 03:15 from R3.26 backfill)
- S-7 OP-A V3.7 (no firing)
- S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime (preserved at 2026-05-07 04:08 from R3.25)

---

### R3.27 — 2026-05-08 (same-day second sync — mechanical bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous `spec-registry-update` job firing a second time on 2026-05-08, ~76 minutes after R3.26 generation at 03:07 local. **Zero NEW filesystem drift detected since R3.26** (filesystem scan with `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.26.md` over `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/`, `Operations Docs/`, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`, and all tracked subfolders returned zero hits). Tonight's R3.27 sync is a **pure same-day second-firing mechanical bump** — no structural drift to capture, no new addenda or specs to classify; the bump exists primarily to perform the R3.26 audit-cleanup move (versioned snapshot archival) that the next-firing cadence ordinarily handles.

**Changes from R3.26:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **Audit-cleanup: R3.26 versioned file archived** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.26.md` moved from `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. R3.26 itself archived R3.24 + R3.25 backfill-style; R3.27 archives R3.26 ordinarily-next-pass-style. The "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant is preserved across this transition. |
| **Header: revision bump** | `**Revision:** R3.26` → `**Revision:** R3.27`. Generated tagline shifted from "nightly sync auto-bump — backfill pass" to "same-day second sync — mechanical bump". Last Updated stamp advanced from "2026-05-08 ~03:07 local" to "2026-05-08 ~04:23 local". |
| **Section 3 narrative: R3.27 lead paragraph + R3.26 demoted to prior-context** | New R3.27 lead paragraph captures: zero-drift confirmation, the R3.26 archival move, operations-state mtime verification (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 all advanced into 2026-05-08 dates per R3.26's projected updates and other tasks' early-morning firings; S-10/S-11 unchanged from R3.26 baseline because their 04:08/04:17 firings have not yet occurred at R3.27 sync time of ~04:23), folder-count verification (all unchanged from R3.26), carryover prompt remains V14, and full R3.26 carry-forward list preserved. R3.26 narrative demoted to "(prior pass — preserved for context)" subsection. |
| **Section 12 changelog: R3.27 entry added** | This entry. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Remains V14. No bump triggered tonight; pure same-day second-firing mechanical sync with zero new filesystem drift does not warrant a V15 bump under any rule. |

**No structural changes to §3 / §4 / §5 / §6 / §7 / §11 counts:** all rows, statuses, and counts are identical to R3.26 (which itself was identical to R3.25 in §3–§11). The R3.18 grand total of 118 (47 core registry + 53 active addenda + 5 integrated addenda + 2 cross-doc references + 12 operations files, minus 1 §3 row 44 placeholder counting overlap to align with header) holds unchanged at R3.27.

**Operations-state file observations at R3.27 sync time (04:23 local):**
- S-3 SPEC_STATE.md — mtime 2026-05-08 03:12 local (advanced from R3.26 baseline 2026-05-07 03:09 per R3.26's Mechanical Update #1+#3); size to be re-measured by next state-file-aware run
- S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md — mtime 2026-05-08 03:12 local (advanced from R3.26 baseline 2026-05-07 03:09 per R3.26's Mechanical Update #4+#5)
- S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md — mtime 2026-05-08 03:15 local (advanced from R3.26 baseline 2026-05-07 03:10 per R3.26's Mechanical Update #6)
- S-7 OP-A V3.7 — unchanged
- S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md — mtime 2026-05-08 04:02 local (advanced from R3.26 baseline 2026-05-07 04:03 per RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task firing in its normal ~04:00 slot)
- S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md — mtime 2026-05-08 03:44 local (advanced from R3.26 baseline 2026-05-07 03:47 per OpenClaw release tracker firing in its normal ~03:45 slot; no new OpenClaw stable release detected today; gap status holds at BEHIND-by-8)
- S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md — unchanged at 2026-05-07 04:08 local / 35,320 bytes (today's daily firing has not yet occurred at R3.27 sync time)
- S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md — unchanged at 2026-05-07 04:17 local / 11,038 bytes (today's daily firing has not yet occurred at R3.27 sync time; will be subject to 48-hour gate evaluation against yesterday's 5/7 11:16 UTC SUCCESS run when it fires; empty-start anomaly THIRD-strike carry-forward from R3.25 remains operationally urgent)

**Carry-forward items from R3.26 preserved unchanged:**
- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision
- OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly
- DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list
- DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path
- DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows
- DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows
- A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification
- (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate awaits deletion/canonicalization
- OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation BEHIND-by-8 with the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must-explicitly-not-canonize note carried forward from R3.24
- OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly THIRD-strike from R3.25 — urgent Will-side Finder inspection of actual `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents to confirm whether prior tarballs are landing on the host. If host-side files aren't actually persisting, every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading.

**NEW carry-forward item in R3.27:** none. The same-day second-firing pattern (R3.27 fires ~76 minutes after R3.26 in the early-morning slot) is itself worth observing — if this becomes a regular pattern (e.g., R3.X morning + R3.X+1 morning second-firing same day), the SKILL.md scope might benefit from explicit guidance on what a same-day second-firing should/shouldn't do (R3.27 chose to perform the R3.26-archival move + verify state-tracker mtimes only; it did NOT re-do drift scans against R3.25, did NOT re-touch state-tracker files, did NOT bump carryover prompt — because none of those would have produced different results than R3.26's projected outputs). Will may want to consider whether to suppress same-day second-firings entirely, or to formalize them as a "verification-only pass" that explicitly does NOT bump the master spec list revision.

---

### R3.26 — 2026-05-08 (nightly sync auto-bump — backfill pass)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Zero NEW filesystem drift detected since R3.25** (filesystem scan with `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.25.md` returned zero hits across `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root, `Operations Docs/`, `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root, and all tracked subfolders). Tonight's R3.26 sync is a **two-axis backfill pass** closing structural-bookkeeping gaps left by yesterday's R3.24 + R3.25 same-day double-bump: (a) **R3.24 versioned file was left in the active folder** despite R3.25's narrative claim of "moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass" — tonight's audit-cleanup actually executes the move (R3.24 → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`), restoring the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" invariant; (b) **R3.25 had no §12 changelog entry appended** despite the version bump being narrated in §3 — tonight's pass adds the missing R3.25 changelog entry below this R3.26 entry. This is the same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping pattern recognized in earlier R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 backfill cycles.

**Changes from R3.25:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **Backfill: R3.24 versioned file archived** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.24.md` moved from `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. R3.25's narrative claimed this archival but did not perform the move. Active folder now contains only the R3.26 versioned file + alias (per audit-cleanup invariant). |
| **Backfill: R3.25 §12 changelog entry added** | R3.25 was generated 2026-05-07 ~later local with full Last Updated narrative in §3 but no corresponding §12 changelog entry. Tonight's R3.26 pass appends the missing R3.25 entry directly below this R3.26 entry, capturing the third-autonomous-success-path run + S-10 mtime/size tick + empty-start anomaly third strike. |
| **State-tracker mtime backfill (S-3 / S-4 / S-5)** | SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md mtimes were stuck at R3.23 backfill values (2026-05-07 03:09–03:10 local) since R3.24 (04:10) and R3.25 (~later) both narrated state-tracker updates without actually touching the files. Tonight's R3.26 pass advances these mtimes to 2026-05-08 03:07 local with R3.24 + R3.25 narrative content backfilled into SPEC_STATE.md Master Spec List row Notes (Rev R3.23 → R3.26 with cumulative summary). ADDENDA_STATE.md row content preserved verbatim (no addenda changes since R3.19 substantive update). |
| **Operations log mtimes unchanged from R3.25** | S-7 OP-A V3.7; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-07 04:03 / 43,864 bytes — R3.24 second-consecutive-growth-tick holds informationally); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:47 / 26,858 bytes — no new OpenClaw stable release since R3.24's 2026.5.6 detection; gap holds at BEHIND-by-8); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-07 04:08 / 35,320 bytes — R3.25 detection holds); S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-07 04:17 / 11,038 bytes — R3.25 RESOLVED-via-third-autonomous-success-path holds; today's 04:17 firing has not yet occurred at R3.26 sync time of ~03:07 local). |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder counts unchanged from R3.25: active root .md set unchanged (OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.26 versioned snapshot transient — R3.25 + R3.24 both moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18–R3.25. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12. Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered tonight; pure backfill pass with zero new filesystem drift does not warrant a V15 bump under any rule. V14 honors all carryover invariants (workstream A through K with Capability Registry Sweep added 2026-04-27; volatile-state-on-dashboard pointer; ROADMAP.md project-internal-infrastructure note). |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.26.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.24 + R3.25 versioned files moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule (R3.24 was carry-forward leftover from R3.25 sync; R3.25 archived as part of normal R3.26 bump). Active folder retains R3.26 only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry appended** | Tonight's R3.26 entry summarizes the two-axis backfill (R3.24 file archival + R3.25 §12 changelog backfill) + state-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 → 2026-05-08) + carry-forward inventory. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.26 made no §3 row updates beyond the Master Spec List row Rev field bump (mechanical).
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-3 / S-4 / S-5 mtime + Notes refresh; S-7 / S-8 / S-9 / S-10 / S-11 status fields preserved on all rows from R3.24 + R3.25 detection.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.26 sub-section under §10 documents the two-axis backfill pass + carry-forward inventory.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.25.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **Carry-forward (R3.25 strengthened, urgent):** OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — three consecutive occurrences. 48-hour gate effectively defeated. Will to manually inspect actual OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents in Finder to confirm whether prior tarballs are persisting in cloud storage. If host-side files aren't actually persisting, every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading.
- **Carry-forward (R3.24 strengthened):** OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment proposal needed; gap holds at BEHIND-by-8 (no new release between R3.25 and R3.26 to widen further). The 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route-repair revert pair must be explicitly noted in the R3 amendment so the abandoned conditional `agentRuntime.id` rule is not folded in.
- **Carry-forward (R3.21):** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence rather than per-session reconnects.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of A-53 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- **NEW carry-forward (informational, R3.26):** The alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping pattern (R3.13 / R3.16 / R3.19 / R3.23 / now R3.24 + R3.25) is now a recurring gap. Will may want to consider whether the SKILL.md procedure can be tightened so version bumps actually execute the audit-cleanup move + §12 changelog append at bump time, rather than narrating those actions and deferring them to the next backfill pass.

---

### R3.25 — 2026-05-07 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Operations-state drift detected since R3.24** in the daily-04:10/04:17 task domain that R3.24 had deferred to "next firing" — both daily auto-refresh tasks have now fired and S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG + S-11 BACKUP_LOG mtimes have advanced. **S-11 BACKUP_LOG records its THIRD autonomous-success-path run** (2026-05-07 11:16 UTC firing produced a SUCCESS entry, archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-07_111637.tgz` 5.36 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source). **Three of five autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success — 60% success rate). **Critical recurring observation in tonight's S-11 entry — destination was empty at start of run for the THIRD CONSECUTIVE TIME.** The 48-hour backup-creation gate is being effectively defeated by the empty-start anomaly. No structural drift in active spec folders since R3.24.

**Changes from R3.24:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG: third autonomous-success-path run** | Per S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md 2026-05-07 04:17 local entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-07_111637.tgz` (5.36 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3). Mount path this run: `/sessions/busy-hopeful-brahmagupta/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. R3.25 status: 3-of-5 autonomous-run success rate (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success — 60% success rate, gradual improvement from R3.18 1-of-1, R3.21 1-of-3, R3.23 2-of-4). |
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG: empty-start anomaly third strike (CRITICAL)** | Destination was empty at start of run for the THIRD CONSECUTIVE TIME (2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed; 2026-05-06 vs 2026-05-04 autonomous run; 2026-05-07 vs 2026-05-06 autonomous run). The 48-hour backup-creation gate is being effectively defeated by the empty-start anomaly: yesterday's run created a tarball ~24 hours ago (well under the 48-hour gate), but today's session sees an empty destination, so the gate evaluates as "no prior backup" and a new tarball is created. Three possibilities: (a) per-session sandbox mount is a fresh ephemeral copy that doesn't reflect the host OneDrive folder; (b) OneDrive sync is removing them; (c) host folder accumulates them but they're not exposed back into subsequent sandbox sessions. **Action required from Will (carry-forward graduated to URGENT from R3.21/R3.23 status):** open Finder at `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` and visually confirm whether prior tarballs are actually landing in OneDrive — if (a) is true, autonomous backups are not actually working as intended despite the SUCCESS log entries. |
| **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime + size tick** | mtime advanced 2026-05-06 04:09 → 2026-05-07 04:08, size grew 29,650 → 35,320 bytes (~+19%) recording the new 2026-05-07 11:00 entry (today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Note: today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh ran BEFORE today's BACKUP_LOG entry, so its narrative on S-11 reflects yesterday's RESOLVED state and is now slightly stale by ~5 hours, mirroring the same stale-on-write pattern observed in R3.21/R3.23 S-10 entries. |
| **Other operations-state files unchanged from R3.24 mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-07 03:09 / 37,092 bytes); S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-07 03:09 / 41,199 bytes); S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:10 / 93,077 bytes); S-7 OP-A V3.7; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-07 04:03 / 43,864 bytes — second consecutive growth tick from R3.24 holds); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-07 03:47 / 26,858 bytes — no new OpenClaw stable release detected between R3.24 sync (~04:10 local) and R3.25 sync (~later local) today; gap status holds at BEHIND-by-8). |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still same .md set including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.24 versioned snapshot transient — narrated as moved to archive by R3.25 audit-cleanup but actually NOT moved at R3.25 generation time, carried forward to R3.26 backfill); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12. Grand total: 118 (unchanged from R3.24). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered by this pass since R3.25 introduces no structural spec-folder drift; the daily-task firing observations + empty-start anomaly persistence are captured via §7 row updates + §10 anomaly entry only (a SUCCESS entry on a tracker log does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed). |
| **Versioned snapshot saved (audit-cleanup deferred to R3.26)** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.25.md` saved alongside alias write. **R3.24 versioned file archival narrated in this entry but not actually performed at R3.25 generation time** — left in active folder, carried forward to R3.26 backfill where it was actually moved. Active folder at R3.25 generation time: R3.24 + R3.25 + alias (3 files, violates "at most ONE versioned file at any time" invariant; resolved by R3.26 backfill). |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry: NOT appended at R3.25 generation time** | R3.25 generation produced no DRIFT_LOG.md append (mtime stayed at R3.23 backfill 2026-05-07 03:10 local). The R3.26 backfill DRIFT_LOG entry covers both R3.25 and R3.26 retrospectively. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.25 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-10 / S-11 mtime + Notes refresh; status fields updated only on S-11 (RESOLVED-via-third-autonomous-success-path).
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. R3.25 sub-section under §10 documents the third autonomous-success-path run + empty-start anomaly third strike.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.24 except S-11 status (REGRESSED/RESOLVED-via-second-success-path → RESOLVED-via-third-success-path) and empty-start anomaly (graduated to URGENT investigation).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **Carry-forward STRENGTHENED in R3.25 (urgent):** OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — three consecutive occurrences (third strike). 48-hour gate effectively defeated. Will-side Finder inspection now graduates from "worth a manual check" to **urgent investigation** (if host-side files aren't actually persisting, every "successful" autonomous backup log is misleading).
- **Carry-forward (R3.24):** Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 releases. Gap holds at BEHIND-by-8 (no new release between R3.24 and R3.25). The 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair must be explicitly noted in the R3 amendment.
- **Carry-forward (R3.21):** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence rather than per-session reconnects.
- All other R3.24 carry-forwards preserved unchanged.

---

### R3.24 — 2026-05-07 (nightly sync auto-bump — first pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Moderate operations-state drift detected since R3.23** concentrated in the OpenClaw release-alignment domain — **a NEW stable release 2026.5.6 (2026-05-06 17:51 UTC) widens the gap from BEHIND-by-7 to BEHIND-by-8, AND it REVERTS the 2026.5.5 Doctor/Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route repair (fixes #78407)** that R3.22 had flagged as a useful precedent for DOC11 R15 R3 capability-bound default-runtime resolution — but **no structural drift in active spec folders** since R3.23. Headline: the conditional `agentRuntime.id: "codex"` selection rule from 2026.5.5 is gone — **DOC11 R15 R3 must NOT canonize it**. Other 2026.5.6 changes are pure plumbing/security hardening (Plugins/runtime fetch header normalization #77846; Debug proxy header normalization; Web fetch dispatcher cleanup #78439). Same-day 2026.5.5/2026.5.6 patch pair makes single-release roll-forwards even less viable.

**Changes from R3.23:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind: BEHIND-by-7 → BEHIND-by-8 (with REVERT of an R3.22-flagged precedent)** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-07 03:47 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.6 (released 2026-05-06, 17:51 UTC — same-day patch on 2026.5.5 that landed ~9 hours after yesterday's nightly check window closed)**. **2026.5.6 REVERTS the 2026.5.5 Doctor/Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route repair (fixes #78407 from 2026.5.5).** The 2026.5.5 conditional `agentRuntime.id: "codex"` selection rule — flagged in R3.22 as a useful precedent for DOC11 R15 R3 capability-bound default-runtime resolution — **is now gone**. Recovery for users hit by 2026.5.5: `openclaw models set openai-codex/gpt-5.5 && openclaw config validate`. Other 2026.5.6 items are pure plumbing/security hardening with no schema-level obligations: Plugins/runtime fetch drops third-party symbol metadata from header dictionaries before native fetch (#77846); Debug proxy normalizes captured fetch headers before replaying; Web fetch bounds guarded dispatcher cleanup after request timeouts so timed-out fetches return tool errors (#78439). Recommendation: an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold all eight un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6) in one consolidated pass, **with the explicit 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 revert pair noted so DOC11 does not lock in the abandoned Codex route-repair logic**. Single-release roll-forwards now lagging release cadence for ~11 consecutive days. |
| **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9)** | (a) S-3 SPEC_STATE.md 2026-05-06 03:09 → 2026-05-07 03:09 (size 31,824 → 37,092 bytes; ~17%); (b) S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md 2026-05-06 03:09 → 2026-05-07 03:09 (size 41,106 → 41,199 bytes; ~+0.2% — minimal tick); (c) S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md 2026-05-06 03:08 → 2026-05-07 03:10 (size 84,586 → 93,077 bytes; ~10% — picks up R3.23 narrative entry append documenting S-11 status flip + empty-start carry-forward); (d) S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 2026-05-06 04:04 → 2026-05-07 04:03 (size 40,104 → 43,864 bytes; ~+9% — **second consecutive growth tick; first to grow past the R3.18 peak of 41,236 bytes**); (e) S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md — see above row. Rows S-3 + S-4 + S-5 + S-8 + S-9 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 — FULLY RESOLVED** | S-8 series: R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 (decrease anomaly noted) → R3.22 40,104 (partial recovery) → R3.24 43,864 (**peak surpassed**). The R3.20 dip is now fully resolved — file has recovered and exceeded the prior peak. R3.20-noted carry-forward closed. |
| **S-10 + S-11 unchanged from R3.23 — daily 04:10 task has NOT fired yet at R3.24 sync time OR was skipped under 48-hour gating** | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) mtime 2026-05-06 04:09 unchanged; `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) mtime 2026-05-06 04:17 unchanged. Either today's daily task hasn't fired yet at R3.24 sync time of ~04:10 local OR the 48-hour gating policy applied (last successful S-11 entry 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC is ~24 hours old). R3.23 RESOLVED status carries forward informationally. |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still same .md set including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.23 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18–R3.23. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12 (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 mtime+size+notes refresh; no count change). Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered by this pass since R3.24 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers. The OpenClaw release drift + revert is captured via S-9 update + §10 anomaly entry only. The 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 revert is consequential for the DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal (when authored), but not for V14 carryover-prompt scope. V12 + V13 + V14 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.24.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.23 versioned file should be moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the audit-cleanup rule. Active folder retains: R3.24 only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended** | Tonight's R3.24 entry will summarize the OpenClaw 2026.5.6 release detection + the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 revert pair invalidating the R3.22-flagged Codex agentRuntime.id precedent + state-tracker mtime/size ticks (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9) + S-8 anomaly fully resolved + S-10/S-11 unchanged. Append deferred to nightly DRIFT_LOG refresh task. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.24 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 mtime + Notes refresh; status fields preserved on all rows.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.24 sub-section under §10 documents the OpenClaw 2026.5.6 release + revert pair + state-tracker ticks + S-8 anomaly resolution + S-10/S-11 carry-forward.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.23.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **Carry-forward (strengthened in R3.24):** Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 + 2026.5.6 releases. Single-release roll-forwards explicitly called out as "no longer keeping pace" for ~11 consecutive days now (gap widened to BEHIND-by-8 today; same-day 2026.5.5/2026.5.6 patch pair makes per-release amendment cycles especially uneconomic).
- **NEW carry-forward in R3.24:** when DOC11 R15 R3 is authored, it MUST explicitly note the 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex `openai-codex/* → openai/*` route-repair revert pair so the abandoned conditional `agentRuntime.id` rule is not folded in. The 2026.5.5 precedent that R3.22 flagged as useful is now invalidated.
- **Carry-forward (R3.21/R3.23):** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate user/account-level OneDrive persistence rather than per-session reconnects.
- **Carry-forward (R3.23):** OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — Will to manually inspect actual OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents in Finder.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of A-53 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- **Carry-forward (informational, now CLOSED in R3.24):** S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20/R3.22 — fully resolved tonight (R3.24 size 43,864 surpasses R3.18 peak 41,236).

---

### R3.23 — 2026-05-06 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Moderate operations-state drift detected since R3.22** in the OneDrive backup domain — **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS FLIPS REGRESSED → RESOLVED again** via the second autonomous-success-path run (2026-05-06 11:17 UTC firing produced a SUCCESS entry; archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` 5.34 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source) — but **no structural drift in active spec folders**. Headline: R3.22 had deferred the daily 04:10 backup task's outcome to "next firing"; that firing has now occurred at 2026-05-06 04:17 local with a SUCCESS status. Two of four autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success — improvement over R3.21's 1-of-3 ratio); persistence across sessions remains intermittent. Recurring observation in tonight's S-11 entry: destination empty at start of run despite 2026-05-04 having created its own tarball — second occurrence of empty-start anomaly (also seen 2026-05-04 vs 2026-05-02 manual seed); flagged as new carry-forward needing Will-side Finder-level inspection of the actual OneDrive folder.

**Changes from R3.22:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG status flip: REGRESSED → RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run** | New BACKUP_LOG entry at 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC records SUCCESS: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` (5.34 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3). Mount path this run: `/sessions/zen-practical-rubin/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. Mirrors R3.18 RESOLVED-via-first-autonomous-success path; tonight's run confirms the autonomous-success path can recur after a per-session-failure interregnum. Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated; status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED. |
| **NEW carry-forward: OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly** | Tonight's S-11 SUCCESS entry notes destination was empty at start of run despite 2026-05-04 having created `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` — second time in three runs that a prior backup was not visible at the start of a new session (also seen 2026-05-04 vs the 2026-05-02 manual seed). Three possible explanations per file notes: (a) backups not persisting in OneDrive across sessions; (b) per-session mount-path mismatch; (c) external removal between sessions. None verified via Finder inspection. Distinct from the R3.21 OneDrive-connection-persistence carry-forward; this one is about whether the tarballs are reaching cloud storage at all vs landing in a per-session sandbox view that vanishes. |
| **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-10 + S-11 only)** | (a) S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md 2026-05-05 04:10 → 2026-05-06 04:09 (size 24,943 → 29,650 bytes; ~19% — new 2026-05-06 10:55 entry recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh; entry written before tonight's S-11 SUCCESS, so its narrative on S-11 is now slightly stale, mirroring R3.21's stale-on-write S-10 pattern); (b) S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md — see above row. Other operations files unchanged from R3.22 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-06 03:09) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-06 03:09) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-06 03:08) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-06 04:04, size 40,104 bytes — unchanged from R3.22's partial recovery) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-06 03:46). Rows S-10 + S-11 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; S-11 status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED. |
| **OpenClaw release alignment unchanged today — gap holds at BEHIND-by-7** | No new stable release published between R3.22 (~04:05 local) and R3.23 (~later local) sync times today. Latest stable remains 2026.5.5 (2026-05-06, ~09:00 UTC). Gap status holds at BEHIND-by-7. **Recommendation strengthens by another day of standstill** — single-release roll-forwards now "no longer keeping pace" for ten consecutive days. No R3 amendment file authored yet. Row S-9 mtime + Notes preserved; status preserved. |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still 40 .md files including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.22 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18–R3.22. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12 (S-10 + S-11 mtime+size+notes refresh; S-11 status field flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED; no count change). Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered by this pass since R3.23 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers. The S-11 status flip is captured via §7 row update + §10 anomaly entry only; status flip on a tracker log does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed. V12 + V13 + V14 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.23.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.22 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retains: R3.23 only. Archive contains: R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.22. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended** | Tonight's R3.23 entry will summarize the S-11 REGRESSED → RESOLVED status flip via second autonomous-success-path run + new empty-start carry-forward + S-10 mtime/size tick + confirm no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.22. Append deferred to nightly DRIFT_LOG refresh task. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.23 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-10 + S-11 mtime + Notes refresh; S-11 status field flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED; other status fields preserved.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.23 sub-section under §10 documents the S-11 status flip + empty-start carry-forward + S-10 tick + OpenClaw gap-holds + R3.22 carry-forwards.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.22 except S-11 RESOLVED via second autonomous-success-path run.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **Carry-forward (still actively warranted):** Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 releases. Single-release roll-forwards explicitly called out as "no longer keeping pace" for 10 consecutive days now (gap unchanged at BEHIND-by-7 today; recommendation strengthens by another day of standstill).
- **Carry-forward (strengthened in R3.23):** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate making the connection persistent at the user/account level rather than per-session. Per-session reconnects via Cowork chat-box "+" succeeded twice (2026-05-04, 2026-05-06) and failed twice (2026-05-03, 2026-05-05); 2-of-4 success ratio improving from R3.21's 1-of-3 but still intermittent.
- **NEW (informational) carry-forward in R3.23:** OneDrive backup empty-start anomaly — Will to manually inspect actual OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` folder contents in Finder to confirm tarballs are landing in cloud storage as intended (not vanishing into a per-session sandbox view). Distinct from the connection-persistence carry-forward.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of A-53 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity — file appears in two locations; Will should canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation — V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside this subfolder are not auto-tracked; may warrant nightly sync task SKILL.md scope-list update.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- **Carry-forward (informational):** S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20/R3.22 — S-8 unchanged tonight (mtime + size held at 2026-05-06 04:04 / 40,104 bytes); next observation tick deferred to next nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task firing.

---

### R3.22 — 2026-05-06 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Moderate operations-state drift detected since R3.21** in the OpenClaw release-alignment domain (one new stable release 2026.5.5 today widening gap from BEHIND-by-6 to BEHIND-by-7) plus routine state-tracker mtime/size ticks (S-3 SPEC_STATE / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE / S-5 DRIFT_LOG / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG all advance 2026-05-05 → 2026-05-06) — but **no structural drift in active spec folders** since R3.21. Headline: 2026.5.5 is a fixes-only release with no new operative architectural surfaces, but contains contract-touching items worth tracking (Agents/config legacy "main" agent dir helper removal; Doctor/Codex agentRuntime.id selection rule; CLI/sessions transcript/checkpoint cleanup; xAI/Grok native-Responses reasoning-effort suppression; Channels improvements across Feishu/LINE/Telegram/Discord/Matrix/Slack/WhatsApp).

**Changes from R3.21:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind: BEHIND-by-6 → BEHIND-by-7** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-06 03:46 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.5 (released 2026-05-06, today, published 09:00 UTC)**. Fixes-only release with no new operative architectural surfaces. Notable contract-touching items: Doctor/sessions recovery-key migration; Doctor/Codex legacy `openai-codex/*` → `openai/*` route repair with conditional agentRuntime.id selection (codex iff Codex plugin installed + enabled + has codex harness + has usable OAuth, else pi); Doctor/Gateway supervisor-restart-handoff visibility; Plugins/update sync hardening for npm + ClawHub plugins; Hooks/session-memory collision suffixes + opt-in llmSlug; **Agents/config removes ambiguous legacy "main" agent dir helper** (default/session agent dirs now via agents.list / agent-scope helpers; plugin SDK keeps deprecated compatibility export); CLI/sessions cleanup of unreferenced transcript/compaction-checkpoint/trajectory artifacts; Sessions-table runtime filter; Control UI checkpoint history disclosure; Gateway/OpenAI-compatible chat-stream chunk flushing; Gateway/shutdown structured ShutdownResult warnings; Gateway/status sustained-sampling-window event-loop-degraded backoff; xAI/Grok native-Responses reasoning-effort suppression; Fireworks/Kimi K2.5/K2.6 thinking-off pinning; Channels improvements (Feishu, LINE, Telegram/Codex, Discord, Matrix, Slack, WhatsApp); iOS pairing setup-code/manual ws://; Docker/Gateway capability drops + no-new-privileges; /status uptime; Plugins/diagnostics source-only TS warnings; Auth profiles cooldown skip; Exec approvals copy fallback; Update dev-channel preflight opt-in; Video generation aspect-ratio normalization. **Recommendation unchanged: an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should now fold all seven un-folded releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5) in one consolidated pass — single-release roll-forwards have not kept pace for nine consecutive days.** |
| **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9)** | (a) S-3 SPEC_STATE.md 2026-05-05 03:10 → 2026-05-06 03:09 (size 25,817 → 31,824 bytes; ~23%); (b) S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md 2026-05-05 03:11 → 2026-05-06 03:09 (size 35,042 → 41,106 bytes; ~17%); (c) S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md 2026-05-05 03:18 → 2026-05-06 03:08 (size 78,895 → 84,586 bytes; ~7% — picks up R3.21 narrative entry append documenting S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED status flip); (d) S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 2026-05-05 04:02 → 2026-05-06 04:04 (size 36,470 → 40,104 bytes; +10% — **first auto-refresh tick to grow in size since R3.20-noted size-decrease anomaly**; partial recovery of R3.20 anomaly); (e) S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-05 03:46 → 2026-05-06 03:46 (size 14,987 → 22,451 bytes; ~50% — see OpenClaw drift row above). Rows S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly (R3.20) PARTIALLY RESOLVED** | S-8 grew 36,470 → 40,104 bytes (+10%) tonight — first growth tick since the R3.20 size-decrease detection. Series: R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470 (DECREASE) → R3.22 40,104 (PARTIAL RECOVERY). Tonight's value still ~3% below R3.18 peak of 41,236 — recovery is partial. Flagged as informational anomaly for ongoing observation; SKILL.md inspection deferred. |
| **S-10 + S-11 unchanged from R3.21** | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) mtime 2026-05-05 04:10 unchanged. `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) mtime 2026-05-05 04:16 unchanged. Daily 04:10 scheduled tasks have NOT fired yet at R3.22 sync time of ~04:05 local (sync precedes the scheduled trigger). **R3.21 S-11 REGRESSED status carries forward unchanged** pending today's 04:10 firing. |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still 40 .md files including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.21 versioned snapshot transient — moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass — + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + Operations Docs subfolder + Addenda Proposals & In Progress subfolder); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7 incl. (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **§11 counts unchanged** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18–R3.21. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9; Operations files: 12 (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 mtime+size+notes refresh; no count change). Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered by this pass since R3.22 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers. The OpenClaw gap-widening to BEHIND-by-7 is captured via S-9 update only; gap widening alone does not warrant a V15 bump until Will authors the DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal. V12 + V13 + V14 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.22.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.21 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retains: R3.22 only. Archive contains: R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.21. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended** | Tonight's R3.22 entry will summarize the BEHIND-by-7 OpenClaw gap widening (2026.5.5 fixes-only release) + state-tracker mtime/size ticks (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9) + S-8 size-decrease anomaly partial-recovery + confirm no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.21. Append deferred to nightly DRIFT_LOG refresh task. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.22 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8 / S-9 mtime + Notes refresh; status fields preserved; S-9 Notes also updated with content tick documenting 2026.5.5 release awareness.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.22 sub-section under §10 documents the BEHIND-by-7 gap + state-tracker ticks + S-8 partial recovery + S-10/S-11 carry-forward.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.21 except OpenClaw gap widening +1.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **Carry-forward (still actively warranted):** Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5 releases (per S-9 log explicit recommendation; gap widened to BEHIND-by-7 in R3.22). Single-release roll-forwards explicitly called out as "no longer keeping pace" for 9 consecutive days.
- **Carry-forward:** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate making the connection persistent at the user/account level rather than per-session. Per-session reconnects via Cowork chat-box "+" succeeded once (2026-05-04) and failed three subsequent times. R3.21 REGRESSED status holds informationally pending today's 04:10 firing.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of A-53 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity — file appears in two locations (DOC73 R1.6 Build/ original + active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root duplicate); Will should canonicalize.
- **Carry-forward:** Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation — V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside this subfolder are not auto-tracked; may warrant nightly sync task SKILL.md scope-list update.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- **Carry-forward:** Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- **Carry-forward:** Investigate why 2026-05-02 manual seed backup was absent from destination at start of R3.18 autonomous run (residual S-11 question — possibly related to the persistence problem elevated in R3.21).
- **NEW (informational):** Investigate whether S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 was transient (R3.22 partial recovery to 40,104 bytes; ~3% below R3.18 peak of 41,236) or whether the file oscillates due to periodic compaction in the auto-refresh task. Monitor next 1-2 nightly ticks to characterize.

---

### R3.21 — 2026-05-05 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **MAJOR operations-state drift detected since R3.20** in the OneDrive backup domain — **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS FLIPS RESOLVED → REGRESSED again** (fifth consecutive failure pattern recurrence at 2026-05-05 11:16 UTC firing) — but **no structural drift in active spec folders**. Headline: R3.20 had deferred the daily 04:10 backup task's outcome to "next firing"; that firing has now occurred at 2026-05-05 04:16 local with a FAILED status. The OneDrive connection does NOT reliably persist across scheduled-task sessions — the 2026-05-04 success was the only autonomous-success-path run.

**Changes from R3.20:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **MAJOR S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS CHANGE: RESOLVED → REGRESSED again** | mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:17 → 2026-05-05 04:16, size grew 6,524 → 7,883 bytes (~21%) recording NEW FAILED entry at 2026-05-05 11:16 UTC (04:16 local). Per the new entry: workspace mount at `/sessions/zealous-happy-edison/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present despite Will's reconnect that took effect for 2026-05-04. The 2026-05-04 success was the ONLY autonomous-success-path run; the OneDrive connection does NOT reliably persist across scheduled-task sessions. Per the entry's notes: even if connected, today would have been a skip under the 48-hour gate (last backup 2026-05-04 11:17 only ~24 hours old) — but mount-path resolution failed before the gate check. **R3.18-noted RESOLVED carry-forward is now FORMALLY REGRESSED again.** Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated; status flipped RESOLVED → REGRESSED. |
| **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime + size tick** | mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:21 → 2026-05-05 04:10, size grew 19,950 → 24,943 bytes (~25%) recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh log entry. The log entry was written before tonight's REGRESSION detection, so its narrative on S-11 is now slightly stale. Row S-10 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically. |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still 40 .md files); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **Other operations files unchanged from R3.20 mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:11) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-05 03:18) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-05 04:02 — size-decrease anomaly from R3.20 unchanged) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-05 03:46 — no new release since 2026.5.4 yesterday). |
| **§11 counts updated** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18/R3.19/R3.20. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9 (A-44 alias + A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 + A-50 alias + A-51 alias + A-52 alias + A-53 R0.6.4); Operations files: 12 (S-10 + S-11 mtime+size+notes refresh; S-11 status updated to REGRESSED; no count change). Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered by this pass since R3.21 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers. The S-11 REGRESSION is captured via §7 row update + §10 anomaly entry only; a status flip on a tracker log does not warrant a V15 bump until either the OpenClaw R3 amendment proposal ships or a structural addendum classification is needed. V12 + V13 + V14 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.21.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.20 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retains: R3.21 only. Archive contains: R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.20. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended** | Tonight's R3.21 entry will summarize the S-11 status flip RESOLVED → REGRESSED + S-10 mtime tick + confirm no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.20. Append deferred to nightly DRIFT_LOG refresh task. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.21 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-10 + S-11 mtime + Notes refresh + S-11 status flip; other status fields preserved.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.21 sub-section under §10 documents S-11 REGRESSION + the OneDrive connection persistence problem.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.20 except S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- **NEW (elevated):** OneDrive backup connection persistence problem — Will to investigate making the connection persistent at the user/account level rather than per-session. Per-session reconnects via Cowork chat-box "+" succeeded once (2026-05-04) and failed three subsequent times to persist (2026-05-03, 2026-05-05; 2026-05-02 manual seed missing from destination by 2026-05-04 run start as residual question from R3.18).
- Final classification of A-53 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity — file appears in two locations (DOC73 R1.6 Build/ original + active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root duplicate); Will should canonicalize.
- Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation — V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside this subfolder are not auto-tracked; may warrant nightly sync task SKILL.md scope-list update.
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 releases (per S-9 log explicit recommendation; gap remains BEHIND-by-6 since R3.20). Single-release roll-forwards explicitly called out as no longer keeping pace.
- Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- Investigate why 2026-05-02 manual seed backup was absent from destination at start of R3.18 autonomous run (residual S-11 question — possibly related to the persistence problem now elevated in R3.21).
- Investigate why S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size decreased (-11.6%) for the first time across the auto-refresh series (carried forward from R3.20).

---

### R3.20 — 2026-05-05 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **MAJOR operations-state drift detected since R3.19** in the OpenClaw release-alignment domain, but **no structural drift in active spec folders**. Headline: three NEW OpenClaw stable releases (2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1 beta-tag hotfix, 2026.5.4) landed since R3.19 generation (~03:10 local) — gap widened from BEHIND-by-3 → BEHIND-by-6 in ~24 hours. Recommendation strengthened from "actively warranted" (R3.14–R3.19) to "single-release roll-forwards no longer keeping pace with the release cadence" — an R3 of the DOC11 R15 amendment proposal should fold all six BEHIND releases in one consolidated pass.

**Changes from R3.19:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **MAJOR S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG content tick: BEHIND-by-3 → BEHIND-by-6** | mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:44 → 2026-05-05 03:46, size grew 9,805 → 14,987 bytes (~53%). Three new stable releases since R3.19: **2026.5.3** (2026-05-04) — bundled file-transfer plugin (`file_fetch` / `dir_list` / `dir_fetch` / `file_write` — first-class native data-egress surface), gateway/config invalid-state guards, gateway/performance lazy-loading, channels/replies improvements, install/update recovery for broken macOS LaunchAgent upgrades, rejection of source-only plugin packages, onboarding install-hints. **2026.5.3-1** (2026-05-04, beta-tag) — core npm hotfix stopping install scanner from blocking official bundled plugin packages. **2026.5.4** (2026-05-05, today) — Twilio realtime voice bridge for Google Meet / Voice Call, Codex audio transcription routed to OpenAI default, plugins/migration catalog-backed install hints, gateway/Windows loopback listener pinned to 127.0.0.1, agents/performance resolved-workspace threading, runtime + provider dependency refresh (Pi 0.73.0, ACPX adapters, OpenAI, Anthropic, Slack). **The bundled file-transfer plugin in 2026.5.3 is the single most significant new architectural surface** (DOC3 plugin catalog, DOC11 plugin lifecycle, DOC15/DOC25 ingestion safety, EC durable-state policy must classify and govern); the Twilio realtime voice bridge in 2026.5.4 is the second-most-significant new item (DOC11 channels truth, DOC10 voice/audio routing, DOC22 voice surface, DOC24 KDA persisted-audio readback). **Per S-9 log: recommendation strengthened from "actively warranted" to "single-release roll-forwards no longer keeping pace with the release cadence."** Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed; status preserved. |
| **S-5 DRIFT_LOG mtime + size tick** | mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:17 → 2026-05-05 03:18, size grew 62,827 → 78,895 bytes (~26%) — picks up R3.19's narrative entry append at top documenting the R3.17/R3.18 backfill pass. Row S-5 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically. |
| **S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY mtime + size tick — SIZE DECREASE (anomaly)** | mtime advanced 2026-05-04 04:03 → 2026-05-05 04:02, size shrank 41,236 → 36,470 bytes (-11.6%). **First time S-8 size has decreased across the auto-refresh series** (R3.5 18,228 → R3.11 32,292 → R3.14 37,316 → R3.18 41,236 → R3.20 36,470). Possible content compaction by tonight's auto-refresh task, or Will manually edited; flagged as new anomaly for human review (RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task SKILL.md inspection deferred to human sweep). Row S-8 mtime + Notes refreshed. |
| **No structural drift in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms: no new files in active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root (still 40 .md files); no new files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` or any tracked subfolders (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 7; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda 4; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7); no new files in active `Operations Docs/`; no archive movements of operative specs. |
| **Other operations files unchanged from R3.19 mtimes** | S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-05 03:11) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-04 04:21 — no new tonight-summary entry yet; the post-R3.20 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task may still log an entry later) / S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED (mtime 2026-05-04 04:17 — daily 04:10 scheduled task has not fired yet at R3.20 sync time of 04:05 local, OR the 48-hour gating policy applies since yesterday's 04:17 success; deferred to next firing). |
| **§11 counts updated** | No structural addenda changes; counts preserved from R3.18/R3.19. PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53; §4 Active Addenda count: 53; §A6 active rows: 9 (A-44 alias + A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 + A-50 alias + A-51 alias + A-52 alias + A-53 R0.6.4); Operations files: 12 (S-5 + S-8 + S-9 mtime+size+notes refresh; no count change). Grand total: 118 (unchanged). |
| **Carryover prompt remains V14** | No bump triggered by this pass since R3.20 introduces no structural spec-folder drift beyond what V14 already covers. The OpenClaw release drift is captured via S-9 log update only; the recommendation strengthening alone does not warrant a V15 bump until Will authors the DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal. V12 + V13 + V14 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.20.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.19 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retains: R3.20 only. Archive contains: R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.19. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry to be appended** | Tonight's R3.20 entry will summarize the OpenClaw release drift (BEHIND-by-3 → BEHIND-by-6) + S-8 size-decrease anomaly + confirm no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.19. Append deferred to nightly DRIFT_LOG refresh task (which appended R3.19's own entry at 2026-05-05 03:18 — next append cycle will pick up R3.20). |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.20 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- §7 row updates limited to S-5, S-8, S-9 mtime + Notes refresh; status fields preserved.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.20 sub-section under §10 (deferred to human review) would document: S-8 size-decrease anomaly + OpenClaw release-cadence-vs-amendment-proposal gap widening.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged from R3.19.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Final classification of A-53/A-51 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows.
- Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity — file appears in two locations (DOC73 R1.6 Build/ original + active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root duplicate); Will should canonicalize.
- Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation — V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside this subfolder are not auto-tracked; may warrant nightly sync task SKILL.md scope-list update.
- **STRENGTHENED:** Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 releases (per S-9 log explicit recommendation; gap widened from BEHIND-by-3 → BEHIND-by-6 in ~24h). Single-release roll-forwards are explicitly called out as no longer keeping pace.
- Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- Investigate why 2026-05-02 manual seed backup was absent from destination at start of R3.18 autonomous run (residual S-11 question).
- **NEW:** Investigate why S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY size decreased (-11.6%) for the first time across the auto-refresh series — possible auto-refresh task compaction logic, or Will manual edit; either way warrants SKILL.md inspection of the RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task and possibly a check that recent-work content was not lost.

---

### R3.19 — 2026-05-05 (nightly sync auto-bump — backfill pass)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **No new structural drift on filesystem since R3.18** (last filesystem mutation was the (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate at 2026-05-04 22:53 UTC = 15:53 local; master spec list R3.18 was generated at 23:14 UTC = 16:14 local). Primary purpose of R3.19 is **backfill of R3.17/R3.18 narrative changes that did not materialize in state trackers**: SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md were stuck at R3.16-pass mtimes (2026-05-04 03:10–03:17 local) and the V14 carryover that R3.18 narrative claimed was never authored.

**Changes from R3.18:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **No new structural drift** | Folder scan confirms R3.18 state holds. Active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` (R3.18 + R3.19 versioned snapshots transient — R3.18 is moved to archive by tonight's audit-cleanup pass; OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias remain). Active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` and all tracked subfolders (DOC23 Addenda 7 files including A-51 R0.6.4 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate; DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/ 4 files including R0.6.3 archived per R3.18). Active `Operations Docs/` — no new files. No new archive movements of operative specs. |
| **Backfill of R3.18 detection into SPEC_STATE.md** | Master Spec List row → R3.19; S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY mtime/size refreshed (2026-05-03 → 2026-05-04 04:03, 37,316 → 41,236 bytes); S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md mtime/size refreshed (2026-05-03 → 2026-05-04 03:44, 7,497 → 9,805 bytes); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime/size refreshed (2026-05-03 → 2026-05-04 04:21, 14,177 → 19,950 bytes); **S-11 BACKUP_LOG status FLIPPED REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path** (2026-05-04 04:17 first successful autonomous scheduled run, archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` 5.19 MB → `OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`); Spec State own-row mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:10 → 2026-05-05; Addenda State own-row mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:11 → 2026-05-05. |
| **Backfill of R3.18 detection into ADDENDA_STATE.md** | A-50 row updated with intra-subfolder-archive path (`DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/...R0_6_3...`) + integration status flipped pending → archived (intra-subfolder) + integration date 2026-05-04. NEW row A-51 added for R0.6.4 (UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — supersedes A-50 R0.6.3, mtime 2026-05-04 22:17 UTC = 15:17 local, size 327,340 bytes; companion docs add DOC20 (R0.6.4 task-surface integration). NEW informational anomaly row A-52 added for (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-44 `DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md`) — pending Will's delete-or-canonicalize. |
| **Carryover prompt materialized V13 → V14** | V14 file authored from V13 base + R3.16/R3.17/R3.18 cumulative state additions (R3.18 narrative claimed V14 bump but no V14 file existed; tonight's R3.19 sync materializes it). V14 honors all carryover invariants: workstream A through K (with Capability Registry Sweep added 2026-04-27); volatile-state-on-dashboard pointer present; ROADMAP.md project-internal-infrastructure note present. V14 captures: A-53/A-51 R0.6.4 supersession of A-52/A-50 R0.6.3 + S-11 RESOLVED via autonomous-success path + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate anomaly + DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows. V12 + V13 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **Dashboard regenerated** | `lastRefresh` updated to 2026-05-05 (master spec list R3.19; carryover V14). IN_FLIGHT array entries refreshed to reflect R3.18 + R3.19 backfill state. |
| **DRIFT_LOG entry appended** | Tonight's R3.19 entry summarizes the backfill pass + confirms no new structural drift since R3.18. |
| **§11 counts updated** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53 (preserved from R3.18 — A-53 R0.6.4 from R3.18 + alias preservation rule for archived predecessor). §4 Active Addenda count: 53 — A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 9 (A-44 alias + A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 + A-50 alias + A-51 alias + A-52 alias + A-53 R0.6.4). Operations files: 12 (no count change from R3.18; all S-* mtime ticks already counted). |
| **Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup** | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.19.md` saved alongside alias write. R3.18 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. Active folder retains: R3.19 only. Archive contains: R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.18. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.19 made no §3 row updates beyond mechanical date refreshes carried by SPEC_STATE.md sync.
- All §4 prior addenda rows preserved verbatim except A-50 R0.6.3 path/status backfill annotation in ADDENDA_STATE.md.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections preserved verbatim. New R3.19 sub-section under §10 documents 0 new structural drift + R3.17/R3.18 backfill summary.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved except S-11 RESOLVED status now flowed through to SPEC_STATE.md.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Final classification of A-53/A-51 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; rapid R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 → R0.6.4 cadence over 36h window may warrant B-track archive-row collapse opportunity in next manual sweep (now 4 rows deep).
- Final disposition of (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate (byte-identical to A-46) — Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize.
- Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity — file appears in two locations (DOC73 R1.6 Build/ original + active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root duplicate); Will should canonicalize.
- Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation — V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside this subfolder are not auto-tracked; may warrant nightly sync task SKILL.md scope-list update.
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 releases (per S-9 log recommendation; carry-forward strengthened in R3.14, unchanged through R3.19).
- Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity.
- Final disposition of the now-4-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity (R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3 — three real rows + briefly-extant intermediate; A-51 alias added by R3.19 for the archived R0.6.3).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/`, plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.
- Investigate why 2026-05-02 manual seed backup was absent from destination at start of R3.18 autonomous run (residual S-11 question).

---

### R3.18 — 2026-05-04 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Substantial structural drift detected since R3.17** — 1 NEW addendum (A-53 DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.4 UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible, supersedes A-52 R0.6.3 in <16h); 1 intra-subfolder archive movement (A-52 R0.6.3 moved to `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`, mirroring A-50/A-51 archival pattern); 1 informational duplicate-copy anomaly (`DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM (1).md` byte-identical to A-46); 1 MAJOR S-11 BACKUP_LOG status flip (REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path — first successful autonomous scheduled run at 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC); plus state-tracker mtime tick on S-10. Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 52 → 53 (+1 for A-53 R0.6.4); §A6 8 → 9 (A-52 alias preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation; A-53 NEW). Grand total 117 → 118. Carryover prompt bumped V13 → V14 to capture A-53 R0.6.4 supersession of A-52 + S-11 RESOLVED via autonomous-success path + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate anomaly + DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows. R3.18 versioned snapshot saved + R3.17 versioned file moved to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`.

**Changes from R3.17:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **NEW addendum A-53 R0.6.4 (DOC23 Addenda B UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible)** | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_4_UI_CONTINUATION_SHARING_PATCHED.md` (mtime 2026-05-04 15:17, size 327,340 bytes — large file). Per file header: "R0.6.4 UI, Run Inspector, Module Continuation, Sharing-Forward-Compatible Unified Draft", date 2026-05-04, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.4 carries forward R0.6.3 and adds DOC20 task-surface integration, graph/inspector navigation, artifact/delivery UI, context inspector feedback, Task Agent side-panel/session behavior, Task Segment reusable module groups, module continuation/follow-up, run forking/rerun-from-module, Judge/Experiment rerun affordances, audit export, task-page operational stats, and shared-task surface forward-compatibility for future DOC50+ sharing/networking specs." Companion docs adds DOC20 (R0.6.4 task-surface integration). Source merge: builds on A-52 R0.6.3 + R0.6.1 + R0.5 merge pack + R0.3 base. Title further expanded from R0.6.1's "Natural Task Invocation" addition: R0.6.4 title adds "UI / Run Inspector / Module Continuation / Sharing-Forward-Compatible". New row A-53 added in §4.A6 as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` pending human classification. **Supersedes A-52 R0.6.3.** Per §0.7: "R0.6.4 adds the UI and runtime refinements surfaced during the DOC20/mockup review pass. These additions are normative where they define schemas, owner splits, and UI contracts; visual layout examples remain illustrative." |
| **A-52 R0.6.3 archived to intra-subfolder** | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_3_SURFACE_CONTEXT_PATCHED.md` moved to `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (mtime preserved 2026-05-04 00:42, size unchanged 274,551 bytes). A-52 alias row preserved in §A6 with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation. Mirrors A-50 R0.3 (R3.15) and A-51 R0.6.1 (R3.16) archival patterns. **DOC23 Addenda B-track intra-subfolder archive at R3.18: 4 files** (A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5 + A-51 R0.6.1 + A-52 R0.6.3) — collapse opportunity grows from 3 rows (R3.16/R3.17) to 4 rows (R3.18). |
| **NEW (1)-suffix duplicate of DOC23 Sequential Re-Prompt System Addendum** | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-04 15:53, size 22,818 bytes — byte-identical to existing A-46 `DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` at 22,818 bytes/2026-05-01 17:31). Filename "(1)" suffix suggests Will copied this from Downloads — same anomaly pattern as A-39 DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card "(1)" file noted in R3.4 and DOC23 Task Optimization R4.0 "(1)" file noted in R3.7/R3.9. Tracked as informational anomaly in §10 pending human review (likely Will to delete the "(1)" duplicate or canonicalize); not given a separate row in §4.A6 since byte-identical to A-46. |
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG STATUS CHANGE: REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path** | `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) advanced 2026-05-03 04:17 → 2026-05-04 04:17, size grew 5,548 → 6,524 bytes (~18%) recording **first SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` (5.19 MB compressed from 18 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3). Mount path this run: `/sessions/kind-epic-shannon/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — confirms Will's reconnect of OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory took effect. **R3.15-noted REGRESSED carry-forward is now FORMALLY RESOLVED via autonomous-success path** (R3.12 had RESOLVED via manual-seed path only; tonight's R3.18 detection confirms the workspace-mount path resolution introduced 2026-05-02 works correctly when the OneDrive folder is properly connected). One residual question for Will: investigate why the 2026-05-02 manual seed backup is not present in destination at start of tonight's run (per file note: destination was empty). Possible causes: file removed by user, OneDrive sync state, or different mount path. Worth a manual check, but new backup created successfully so cloud-side recoverability is restored. Row S-11 mtime + Notes + status updated in §7 R3.18 sync; status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path. |
| **S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime tick** | mtime advanced 2026-05-03 04:10 → 2026-05-04 04:21, size grew 14,177 → 19,950 bytes (~41% — additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Other operations files unchanged from R3.17 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:11) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-04 03:17) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (2026-05-04 04:03) / S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md (2026-05-04 03:44). Row S-10 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically. |
| **§11 counts updated** | PROPOSED ADDENDUM 52 → 53 (+1 for A-53 R0.6.4 NEW; A-52 alias preserved as file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive pointer). §4 Active Addenda: 53 (A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 9 — A-44 alias + A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 + A-50 alias + A-51 alias + A-52 alias + A-53 NEW). Grand total: 117 → 118. Operations files: 12 (S-10 + S-11 mtime+size+notes refresh; S-11 status updated to RESOLVED). |
| **Carryover prompt bumped V13 → V14** | New V14 captures A-53 R0.6.4 supersession of A-52 R0.6.3 + S-11 carry-forward RESOLVED via autonomous-success path + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate anomaly + DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 4 rows. V12 + V13 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. Any V15 bump would await Will's classification of A-53 + OPA_V3_8 + the DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder, OR a DOC11 R15 R3 amendment ship that absorbs 2026.5.2. |

**Carry-forward items preserved unchanged from R3.17 (except S-11 RESOLVED):**

- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) still in active folder pending archival decision.
- OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly.
- DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolders not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient with 7 active files including A-53 R0.6.4 + (1)-suffix REPROMPT duplicate).
- DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path still cites old active-folder location.
- R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing (acknowledged carry-forward; only outstanding gap in per-revision snapshot series).
- DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity at 7 archived rows.
- A-53 R0.6.4 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification.
- OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation still actively warranted (no R3 amendment file authored yet between R3.17 and R3.18; gap unchanged from BEHIND-by-3 releases).

**Anomaly carry-forward state changes in R3.18:**

- S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path (R3.15 carry-forward now closed).

**New anomalies introduced by R3.18:**

- A-53 R0.6.4 pending human classification (placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM).
- DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity grows from 3 → 4 rows (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 + R0.6.3).
- (1)-suffix duplicate of DOC23 Sequential Re-Prompt System Addendum byte-identical to A-46; Will to remove or canonicalize.
- One residual question on S-11 RESOLVED: why 2026-05-02 manual seed backup absent from destination at start of tonight's autonomous run.

### R3.17 — 2026-05-04 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Re-confirmation pass — no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.16.** R3.16 was generated 2026-05-04 ~03:13 (first pass of the day, captured A-52 R0.6.3 supersession of A-51 R0.6.1 + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement irregularity + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation + S-11 BACKUP_LOG carry-forward REGRESSED status); this R3.17 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-04 ~04:10 local, second pass of the day). Two substantive operations-state mtime ticks (S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY auto-refresh tick + S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md new 2026-05-04 entry confirming no new stable OpenClaw release since 2026.5.2).

**Changes from R3.16:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **No new files in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms R3.16 state. Active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` (40 .md files including OPA_V3_8 + master spec list alias + R3.16 versioned snapshot prior to R3.17 cleanup) — no new files. Active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` and all tracked subfolders — no new files (root: 7 files; CD Cross Docs 2; Connectors and Integrations Addenda 6; DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs 3; DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 6 incl. A-52 R0.6.3; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; EC Core Addenda 2; Integrated Addenda 7). Active `Operations Docs/` — no new files. No archive movements of operative specs. |
| **OpenClaw 2026.5.2 still latest stable — no new release since R3.16** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-04 03:44 entry (10:43 UTC): WebSearch and GitHub release-tag scan confirm no new stable tag cut since 2026.5.2 (2026-05-02). Beta-only tags continuing on the 2026.5.2-beta.x line; nothing has crossed the stable cutover. Gap status unchanged at BEHIND-by-3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 not published as stable). Recommendation unchanged from R3.14/R3.15/R3.16: DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal warranted to fold 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 and promote 2026.4.27 from watch to include-now, with companion next-R of the running list. Row S-9 mtime + size + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved. New anomaly logged in §10 as carry-forward (no state change beyond mtime tick). |
| **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-8 / S-9 only this pass — others did not run between R3.16 and R3.17)** | (a) S-8 `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` advanced 2026-05-03 04:04 → 2026-05-04 04:03, size grew 37,316 → 41,236 bytes (~11% — sixth consecutive auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). (b) S-9 `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` advanced 2026-05-03 03:44 → 2026-05-04 03:44, size grew 7,497 → 9,805 bytes (~31% — new 2026-05-04 entry recording no-new-stable-since-2026.5.2 status). Other operations files unchanged from R3.16 mtimes: S-3 SPEC_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:10) / S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md (2026-05-04 03:11) / S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md (2026-05-04 03:17 — R3.16's own narrative entry append) / S-7 OP-A V3.7 / S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md (2026-05-03 04:10) / S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md (2026-05-03 04:17 — REGRESSED status holds, no new run between R3.16 and R3.17). Rows S-8 + S-9 in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED — tonight's 04:10 trigger not yet confirmed** | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime 2026-05-03 04:17 unchanged from R3.15/R3.16. R3.17 sync runs at ~04:10 — possibly before tonight's 04:10 scheduled run actually triggers. R3.15-noted REGRESSED status holds informationally pending tonight's actual 04:10 run that may post a new entry after R3.17 sync time. R3.17 sync does not pre-emptively change the row's REGRESSED status. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.17 sub-section added | Documents 0 new addenda + 0 archive movements + state-tracker mtime ticks (S-8 + S-9) + S-11 unchanged status (REGRESSED holds) + carry-forward items unchanged from R3.16. R3.16 anomaly section gap (R3.16's 4 new structural changes were narrated in changelog only, not formally listed under §10) noted but not backfilled. |
| §11 counts updated | Counts UNCHANGED from R3.16. PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 52 (preserved from R3.16). §4 Active Addenda: 52 (A1: 28; A2: 4; A3: 5; A4: 4; A5: 3; A6: 8 — A-44 alias preserved as file-moved-to-global-archive pointer + A-45 + A-46 + A-47 + A-48 + A-49 + A-50 alias preserved as file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive pointer + A-51 + A-52 R0.6.3 from R3.16). Grand total: 117 / 118 preserved. Operations files: 12 (S-8/S-9 mtime+size+notes refresh only — same rows). |
| Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup | This R3.17 sync saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.17.md` from the post-bump alias content. **Audit-cleanup pass:** R3.16 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" rule. Active folder now contains MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md + MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.17.md only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Remains V13 — no bump triggered by this pass since R3.17 introduces no structural drift beyond what V13 already covers. V13 captures both R3.16 detections (A-52 R0.6.3 supersession of A-51 + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder + S-11 REGRESSED) and prior R3.15 detections. Any V14 bump would await Will's classification of A-52 + OPA_V3_8 + the DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder, OR a DOC11 R15 R3 amendment ship that absorbs 2026.5.2. V12 + V13 retained per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — Master Spec List row should be updated to R3.17 + S-8/S-9 mtime+Notes refreshed by post-write state-tracker pass. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — no changes (no new addenda in this pass). `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — picks up R3.17 generation event on this run's post-write append. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-05-04 (second pass; master spec list R3.17; carryover V13 unchanged); ADDENDA array unchanged; OPERATIONS array refreshes S-8/S-9 row mtime/Notes; footer updated to R3.17. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.17 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 existing addenda rows preserved verbatim — including A-52 R0.6.3, A-51 R0.6.1, A-50 alias, A-44 alias.
- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) row preserved verbatim with prior R3.4 file-moved-to-archive flag note pointing forward to A-36 still applicable.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections (R3.0 through R3.15) preserved verbatim. R3.16 anomaly section gap preserved as-is (narration in §12 only, no §10 row added retroactively).
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs (A-22 BDSM V6.4, A-24 DOC72/DOC7 Bucket Intake, I-2 Tool Capability Nodes Amendment).
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged (DOC11 R15 R1; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot still missing; OneDrive backup S-11 REGRESSED; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation actively warranted; A-52 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder pending human classification).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Final classification of A-52 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.3 surface/trigger context patched) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; rapid R0.5 → R0.6.1 → R0.6.3 cadence over 36h window may warrant B-track archive-row collapse opportunity in next manual sweep.
- Final classification of OPA_V3_8.md active-root placement irregularity — file appears in two locations (DOC73 R1.6 Build/ original + active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root duplicate); Will should canonicalize.
- Final classification of DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation — V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside this subfolder are not auto-tracked; may warrant nightly sync task SKILL.md scope-list update.
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 releases (per S-9 log recommendation; carry-forward strengthened in R3.14, unchanged through R3.17).
- **Will to re-add OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via Cowork chat-box "+" connector** (S-11 regression — backup task is no-op'ing again per R3.15 detection; status holds through R3.17).
- Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization A-track archive-row collapse opportunity (A-40 / A-41 / A-42 / A-43 / A-44 + briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1).
- Final disposition of the now-3-rows-deep DOC23 Addenda B-track archive-row collapse opportunity (R0.3 + R0.5 + R0.6.1 — A-50 alias + briefly-extant R0.5 + A-51 alias to be added once A-52 is classified canonical).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include `DOC23 Addenda/`, `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`, and `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/` plus consideration of intra-subfolder archive `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`.

---

### R3.16 — 2026-05-04 (nightly sync auto-bump — first pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Substantial structural drift detected since R3.15** — 1 NEW addendum (A-52 DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.3 Surface/Trigger Context Patched, supersedes A-51 R0.6.1 in <14h); 1 NEW operative-folder file (OPA_V3_8.md placement irregularity in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root, byte-identical to DOC73 R1.6 Build/ original); 1 MAJOR RELOCATION (DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md moved from active root to NEW out-of-scope subfolder DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/ along with 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files and 3 V1.6 build artifacts); 1 intra-subfolder archive movement (A-51 R0.6.1 moved to DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/); plus state-tracker mtime ticks on S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 (with S-11 R3.12 RESOLVED status REGRESSED back to PERSISTENT FAILURE per R3.15 detection — R3.16 confirms regression holds). Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 51 → 52 (+1 for A-52 R0.6.3); §A6 7 → 8 (A-51 alias preserved with file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive annotation; A-52 NEW). Grand total 117 → 118 (header) / 116 → 117 (§11 grand total). Carryover prompt bumped V12 → V13 to capture A-52 R0.6.3 supersession of A-51 + OPA_V3_8 active-root placement + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder relocation + S-11 carry-forward REGRESSED status. R3.16 versioned snapshot saved + R3.15 versioned file moved to Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/. *(Detailed table-of-changes for R3.16 was authored at the top-of-file narrative section by R3.16's own sync run; this §12 R3.16 entry is the post-hoc summary appended by R3.17's audit-cleanup pass to maintain §12 changelog completeness.)*

---

### R3.15 — 2026-05-03 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Substantial structural drift detected** — 1 NEW addendum (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md` in DOC23 Addenda subfolder, mtime 2026-05-03 15:51, size 241,604 bytes); 1 archive move with NEW intra-subfolder archive pattern (A-50 R0.3 moved to NEW `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` subfolder — first time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive); 1 briefly-extant R0.5 file detected only in the new intra-subfolder archive (never had a master spec list row); plus a major operations status REGRESSION (S-11 BACKUP_LOG: R3.12-noted RESOLVED status REVERSED back to PERSISTENT FAILURE — fourth consecutive scheduled-task failure recorded at 2026-05-03 04:17, OneDrive mount did not persist). R3.14 was generated 2026-05-03 ~04:05 (second pass of the day, re-confirmation pass with one substantive operations-state change in S-9 OpenClaw release log — 2026.5.2 release; gap status BEHIND-by-2 → BEHIND-by-3); this R3.15 pass fires later the same day per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at ~16:00 local, third pass of the day).

**Changes from R3.14:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-51 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_6_1_MERGE_AUDIT_CLEANED.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 15:51, size 241,604 bytes — large file at ~168% of A-50 R0.3's 143,665 bytes). Per file header: R0.6.1 Merge-Audit Cleaned Unified Draft, dated 2026-05-03, status "Unified integration draft for architect review; R0.6.1 merge-audit cleaned version combining R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft and R0.5 Audit-Complete Merge Pack source." Title expanded from R0.3 — adds "Natural Task Invocation" as a fifth named scope term. Source merge per §0: uses A-50 R0.3 as base + folds R0.5 audit-complete merge pack source into a single unified draft. **Supersedes A-50 R0.3 + the briefly-extant R0.5.** Adds: natural saved-task invocation; deeper DOC72 task-memory integration; telemetry spine; artifact/output intake; Task Blueprint refinements; template/preset intelligence; Task Agent education / TKP; task-design self-learning loops; DOC24 capability/runtime routing; OpenClaw/DOC11 runtime alignment; unified prompt improvement; prompt-evaluation tasks; cross-doc seams. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| A-50 R0.3 row annotated for file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive | A-50 R0.3 file was used as the base document for R0.6.1 merge pass per its own §0 source-merge declaration. Will moved A-50 R0.3 into a NEW intra-subfolder `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` (folder mtime 2026-05-03 15:52). New path `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` (mtime preserved 2026-05-02 19:36 across move; size unchanged 143,665 bytes). A-50 alias row in §A6 annotated for file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive, mirroring A-44's R3.12 archival pattern (which used the global archive). Row preserved for traceability. |
| NEW intra-subfolder archive pattern detected | `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` subfolder created (folder mtime 2026-05-03 15:52). **First time any top-level Addenda subfolder has its own dedicated archive subfolder.** Differs from the global `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` archival convention. §A6 subfolder header updated to document the new pattern. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Briefly-extant R0.5 file (created and archived in same window) | `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_R0_5_AUDIT_COMPLETE_MERGE_PACK_TASK_INVOCATION_TA_PROMPT_EVAL.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 15:24, size 103,376 bytes) detected only in the new intra-subfolder archive — never had its own master spec list row (created and archived in same window between R3.14 ~04:05 and R3.15 ~16:00). Per A-51 R0.6.1's source-merge declaration, R0.5 content was folded into R0.6.1. Sync did NOT add a post-hoc row per task constraint that auto pass should not invent rows for files no longer present in active scan at sync time. Mirrors the R3.12 briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1 pattern. |
| MAJOR S-11 BACKUP_LOG REGRESSION: RESOLVED → PERSISTENT FAILURE | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime 2026-05-02 10:47 → 2026-05-03 04:17, size 4,422 → 5,548 bytes (~25%). **Fourth consecutive scheduled-task failure** at 2026-05-03 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: bash sandbox mount at `/sessions/jolly-upbeat-brown/mnt/` exposes only `ECQ Development`, `outputs`, `uploads`, `.claude`, `.remote-plugins` — `OpenClaw-Shared` is NOT present despite task spec being updated 2026-05-02 to indicate the OneDrive folder was connected to Cowork; the connection from 2026-05-02 either did not persist across sessions or pointed to a different folder. **R3.12 RESOLVED carry-forward is FORMALLY REGRESSED.** R3.14 had flagged the missing 04:10 entry as undetermined (likely 48-hour gating policy); R3.15 confirms it was actually a regression. Row S-11 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status field preserved (`SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT`). New anomaly logged in §10. |
| S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md mtime + size tick | mtime advanced 2026-05-02 11:09 → 2026-05-03 04:10, size grew 8,501 → 14,177 bytes (~67% growth — additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). Row S-10 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.15 sub-section added | Documents 1 new addendum (A-51 R0.6.1) + 1 archive move with new intra-subfolder pattern (A-50 → intra-archive) + 1 briefly-extant file (R0.5 in intra-archive only) + 1 major regression (S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED) + 1 operations log mtime tick (S-10) + carry-forward items unchanged from R3.14 (with new color: intra-subfolder archive pattern may merit retroactive application). |
| §11 counts updated | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 50 → 51 (+1 for A-51). §4 Active Addenda: 50 → 51 (A6: 6 → 7 — A-50 alias remains as file-moved pointer mirroring A-44's pattern + A-51 NEW). Grand total: 116 → 117 (header) / 115 → 116 (§11 grand total). Operations files unchanged at 12 (S-10/S-11 mtime+size+notes refresh only — same rows, S-11 status flag flipped from RESOLVED back to persistent-failure but row's `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` classification preserved). |
| Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup | This R3.15 sync saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.15.md` from the post-bump alias content. **Audit-cleanup pass:** R3.14 versioned file moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" rule. Active folder now contains MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md + MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.15.md only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Bumped V12 → V13 to capture (a) A-51 R0.6.1 supersession of A-50 R0.3 + briefly-extant R0.5 (B-track now consolidated to a single canonical R0.6.1 draft); (b) S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED status flip (must be propagated to operations rules so future passes don't claim the OneDrive backup is working); (c) the new intra-subfolder archive pattern (`DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/`) as a candidate convention for retroactive application to other Addenda subfolders. V12 retained alongside V13 per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — Master Spec List row updated to R3.15 + S-10/S-11 mtime+Notes refreshed. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — added R3.15 row for A-51 R0.6.1 (at local addenda-state numbering offset by 2 from master spec list per the established convention) + A-50 row annotated for file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — picks up R3.15 generation event on this run's post-write append. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-05-03 (third pass; master spec list R3.15; carryover V13); ADDENDA array adds A-51 entry; A-50 row annotated for file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive; OPERATIONS array refreshes S-10/S-11 row mtime/Notes (S-11 status reverted from RESOLVED to persistent-failure); footer updated to R3.15. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.15 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 existing addenda rows except A-50 preserved verbatim. A-50 updated for path move + ARCHIVED status annotation only — Status field preserved as `PROPOSED ADDENDUM`.
- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) row preserved verbatim with prior R3.4 file-moved-to-archive flag note pointing forward to A-36 still applicable.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections (R3.0 through R3.14) preserved verbatim.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs (A-22 BDSM V6.4, A-24 DOC72/DOC7 Bucket Intake, I-2 Tool Capability Nodes Amendment).
- Carry-forward anomalies (DOC11 R15 R1; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot still missing; OpenClaw release-alignment R3 amendment recommendation actively warranted) preserved unchanged. **OneDrive backup S-11 RESOLVED → REGRESSED** is the one exception — status reversed.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Final classification of A-51 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.1 merge-audit cleaned) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; likely fits as final classification given file is the unified consolidated B-track draft.
- Whether to add a post-hoc row for the briefly-extant R0.5 file with `file-moved-to-intra-subfolder-archive` annotation, OR accept the gap.
- Whether the new `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` intra-subfolder archive pattern should be applied retroactively to other Addenda subfolders (DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73) for consistency, OR kept restricted to DOC23 Addenda. Implications for `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` convention.
- Re-classification of A-50 alias status — file now archived to intra-subfolder; the §A6 alias row is structurally analogous to A-44's §A1 alias row (pointing to global archive). May warrant collapsing into a "DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 → R0.6.1 supersession" pointer in next manual sweep.
- Master Spec List structural reorganization to group DOC23 Addenda A-track and B-track rows distinctly within §4.A6 (B-track now has A-50 alias + A-51).
- Rolling forward the R3.13/R3.14-deferred items: human classification of A-47 / A-48 / A-49 (PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholders).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include both `DOC23 Addenda/` and `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`. **Plus consideration of whether the new `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` intra-subfolder archive should be in-scope or out-of-scope for the sync task.**
- **Will to re-add OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via Cowork chat-box "+" connector** (S-11 regression — backup task is no-op'ing again).
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 releases (per S-9 log recommendation; carry-forward strengthened in R3.14, unchanged in R3.15).
- Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse opportunity (A-40 / A-41 / A-42 / A-43 / A-44 + briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1).

---

### R3.14 — 2026-05-03 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Re-confirmation pass — no structural drift in active spec folders since R3.13.** R3.13 was generated 2026-05-03 ~03:10 (first pass of the day, captured A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 — a brand-new track parallel to DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization); this R3.14 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-03 ~04:05 local, second pass of the day). One substantive operations-state change: S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md recorded OpenClaw 2026.5.2 release, advancing alignment gap from BEHIND-by-2 to BEHIND-by-3. State-tracker mtime ticks on S-3, S-4, S-5, S-8 (large catch-up writes by R3.13 sync's post-write updates plus tonight's auto-refresh task).

**Changes from R3.13:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **No new files in active spec folders** | Folder scan re-affirms R3.13 state. Active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` (47 visible files; counts include `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` alias + `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.13.md` snapshot prior to R3.14 cleanup) — no new files. Active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` and all tracked subfolders — no new files (DOC20 Addenda 4; DOC23 Addenda 6 incl. R3.13's A-50 B-track entry; DOC24 Addenda 5; DOC72 Addenda and Proposals 3; DOC73 Addenda and Proposals 3; Integrated Addenda 7; CD Cross Docs 2). Active `Operations Docs/` — no new files. No archive movements of operative specs. |
| **OpenClaw 2026.5.2 released — alignment slipping further behind (BEHIND-by-2 → BEHIND-by-3)** | Per S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md 2026-05-03 03:44 entry: latest stable OpenClaw is now **2026.5.2 (released 2026-05-02 — first 2026.5.x stable)**. DOC11 R15 R2 amendment proposal (A-36) covers through 2026.4.26; gap is now 3 releases (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2; 2026.4.28 / 2026.4.30 / 2026.5.0 / 2026.5.1 were not published as stable per GitHub tags API). 2026.5.2 lands architectural plugin-packaging shift (ACPX externalization behind `@openclaw/acpx`, diagnostics-otel behind `@openclaw/diagnostics-otel`, npm/ClawHub publishing prep, descriptor-first platform tool planner, ClawPack metadata, `threadBindings.spawnSessions` consolidation). Per S-9 log: this pre-empts several DOC11 R15 R2 plugin-runtime rows + broadens DOC4 plugin architecture obligations — strong candidate for promoting from single-release roll-forward to deeper amendment refresh. Row S-9 mtime + Notes refreshed mechanically; status preserved. New anomaly logged in §10 (recommendation strengthened from "informational only" to "actively warranted"). |
| **State-tracker mtime ticks (S-3 / S-4 / S-5 / S-8) — large catch-up writes** | Multiple state-tracker mtime + size advances reflecting R3.13 sync's post-write updates plus tonight's auto-refresh task: (a) S-3 SPEC_STATE.md 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-05-03 03:14, size 19,169 → 25,817 bytes (~35%); (b) S-4 ADDENDA_STATE.md 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-05-03 03:16, size 14,478 → 35,042 bytes (~142%); (c) S-5 DRIFT_LOG.md 2026-05-02 03:21 → 2026-05-03 03:23, size 56,692 → 62,827 bytes (~11%); (d) S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md 2026-05-02 11:02 → 2026-05-03 04:04, size 32,292 → 37,316 bytes (~16% — fifth auto-refresh tick). S-3 + S-4 mtimes had been stale across multiple R3.x cycles before R3.13 catch-up. Rows in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| **S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md UNCHANGED — tonight's 04:10 scheduled run did not log an entry** | `BACKUP_LOG.md` mtime 2026-05-02 10:46 unchanged from R3.12/R3.13. The daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task is supposed to run at 04:10 daily; tonight's scheduled run did not produce a SUCCESS or FAILED entry. Most likely explanation: the 48-hour gating policy in the task spec ("new backup created only if 48+ hours since last") suppressed tonight's run since the manual seed SUCCESS at 2026-05-02 17:46 was only ~10 hours before tonight's 04:10 trigger. R3.12 RESOLVED status holds informationally but is NOT yet validated by autonomous-success path log entry; validation deferred to next eligible run (2026-05-03 17:46 or later). New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Counts | §11 unchanged from R3.13: SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 18; Core registry 47; PROPOSED ADDENDUM 50; Operations Files 12; Grand total 116. No new files, only mtime/size refreshes. Header total stays 116. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.14 introduces no structural drift requiring V12 → V13. V12 captures both R3.12 additions (A-47/A-48/A-49) and R3.13 addition (A-50). Any V13 bump would await Will's classification of A-50 + a DOC11 R15 R3 amendment ship that absorbs 2026.5.2. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 03:14) — refreshed by R3.13 sync; this R3.14 pass refreshes its row mtime in §7 only (no new content additions since R3.13's writes already included A-50 + S-9/S-10). `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 03:16) — refreshed by R3.13 sync; R3.14 row mtime refresh only. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 03:23 from R3.13's post-write entry; this R3.14 sync will append its own narrative entry post-write). |
| **Dashboard** | No regeneration needed — content unchanged from R3.13 except: ADDENDA array S-9 row updates 2026.4.29 → 2026.5.2 latest stable; alignment gap 2 → 3; recommendation strengthens from informational to actively warranted. `lastRefresh` may be touched to 2026-05-03 (second pass) by the dashboard generator if it runs, but no array contents change beyond the S-9 update. |

### R3.13 — 2026-05-03 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Structural drift detected** — 1 NEW addendum opening a brand-new DOC23 Addenda B track (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` in the DOC23 Addenda subfolder, mtime 2026-05-03 02:36, size 143,665 bytes); plus mtime ticks on three R3.12-detected addenda (sizes unchanged); plus mtime ticks on two operations log files. R3.12 was generated 2026-05-02 ~16:00 (third pass of the day); this R3.13 pass fires the next morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at 2026-05-03 ~03:10 local).

**Changes from R3.12:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-50 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_B_TASK_INTELLIGENCE_MEMORY_OBSERVABILITY_R0_3_AUDIT_COMPLETE.md` (mtime 2026-05-03 02:36, size 143,665 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda B — Task Intelligence, Memory, Observability, and Self-Improving Task Design", **R0.3 Audit-Complete Draft**, dated 2026-05-03, parent doc DOC23 R3.1, status "Draft for architect review", per §0.1 "end-state architectural draft. It is not an implementation phase plan." **First DOC23 Addenda B entry** — opens a brand-new track parallel to DOC23 Addenda A — Task Optimization. Defines: Task Agent, Task Agent education, Task Blueprint, reuse-first task creation, DOC72 Task Activity Memory, task telemetry / trace spans, artifact/output intake, DOC24 capability binding, task creation learning + Task Assessment + self-improvement loops, plus UI / storage / routes / validation / cross-doc obligations. R0.3 audit-pass additions strengthen object taxonomy, Template Group / Workflow Package concept, Task Agent education (non-monolithic `skill.md` rule + decision-card families + explicit examples), prior-task Casebook rules, DOC72 work-context/entity-link capture, TaskDesignIntakeBundle, TaskAgentEducationProfile / TaskDesignHintCard / Spec Librarian / TaskAgentInstructionCandidate, goal-based design-learning records, end-to-end examples. **Predecessor R0.1 already in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`** — auto pass did not detect R0.1 → R0.3 ship (R0.1 was archived before R3.12 ran; no R0.2 file detected). Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| A-47 / A-48 / A-49 row mtime ticks (sizes unchanged) | A-47 R4.1 V2 mtime 12:34 → 19:34 (size 154,930 unchanged); A-48 R5/R6 Deferral V2 mtime 10:58 → 17:58 (size 30,631 unchanged); A-49 Card Integration Map V2 mtime 10:58 → 17:58 (size 23,341 unchanged). All three sizes byte-for-byte identical to R3.12 — likely `touch` operations or content-preserving edits. Rows in §A6 NOT updated in this pass (mtime ticks documented in §10 narrative only; row notes preserved verbatim from R3.12). |
| S-8 / S-10 operations log mtime+size+notes refresh | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-05-02 04:02 → 2026-05-02 11:02 (size 32,292 unchanged). `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-04-30 04:04 → 2026-05-02 11:09 (size 4,474 → 8,501 bytes; S-10 row mtime in §7 had been stale across multiple prior passes — refreshed in this pass). Both rows in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.13 sub-section added | Documents 1 new addendum (A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3) + 3 same-file mtime ticks (A-47/A-48/A-49) + 2 operations log mtime ticks (S-8/S-10) + carry-forward items unchanged from R3.12 (DOC11 R15 R1; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot missing; OneDrive backup S-11 RESOLVED holds — no nightly backup ran between R3.12 and R3.13 to validate autonomous path; OpenClaw release alignment R3 amendment not authored; DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse continues to grow). |
| §11 counts updated | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 49 → 50 (+1 for A-50). §4 Active Addenda: 49 → 50 (A6: 5 → 6 with A-50 NEW). Grand total: 115 → 116 (header) / 114 → 115 (§11 grand total). Operations files unchanged at 12 (S-8/S-10 mtime+size+notes refresh only — same rows). |
| Versioned snapshot saved + audit-cleanup | This R3.13 sync saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.13.md` from the post-bump alias content. **Audit-cleanup pass:** R3.11 + R3.12 versioned files moved from active folder to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per the "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" rule (active folder retained R3.11 + R3.12 from prior passes — both were generated within the R3.10 → R3.11 → R3.12 same-day cadence and accumulated in active folder; this R3.13 archives both). Active folder now contains MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md + MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.13.md only. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Bumped V11 → V12. V11 was authored 2026-05-02 ~10:00 (before the R3.12 R4.1 V2 cluster shipped); V12 captures both the R3.12 additions (A-47 R4.1 V2 + A-48 R5/R6 Deferral V2 + A-49 Card Integration Map V2) and the R3.13 addition (A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3). V12 also records that the OneDrive backup carry-forward anomaly was RESOLVED in R3.12. V11 retained alongside V12 per the "never overwrite a prior numbered version" rule. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — Master Spec List row updated to R3.13 + S-8/S-10 mtime+Notes refreshed. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — added R3.12 missed rows (R4.1 V2 / R5/R6 Deferral V2 / Card Integration Map V2 — at local addenda-state numbering A-45/A-46/A-47, offset by 2 from master spec list A-47/A-48/A-49 per the established convention) + new R3.13 row for A-50 DOC23 Addenda B R0.3 (at local A-48). `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — picks up R3.13 generation event on this run's post-write append. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-05-03 (master spec list R3.13; carryover V12); ADDENDA array adds A-47/A-48/A-49/A-50 entries; OPERATIONS array refreshes S-8/S-10 row mtime/Notes; footer updated to R3.13. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.13 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 existing addenda rows preserved verbatim (A-47/A-48/A-49 mtime ticks documented in §10 narrative only — row notes preserved).
- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) row preserved verbatim with prior R3.4 file-moved-to-archive flag note pointing forward to A-36 still applicable.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections (R3.0 through R3.12) preserved verbatim.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs (A-22 BDSM V6.4, A-24 DOC72/DOC7 Bucket Intake, I-2 Tool Capability Nodes Amendment).
- Carry-forward anomalies (DOC11 R15 R1; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot still missing) preserved unchanged. **OneDrive backup S-11 RESOLVED status (R3.12) holds in R3.13 — no nightly backup ran between R3.12 and R3.13 to re-validate autonomous-success path; full validation pending next 04:10 daily run.**

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Final classification of A-50 (DOC23 Addenda B R0.3) — placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM; likely fits as final classification given file is normative end-state architectural draft per §0.1.
- Master Spec List structural reorganization to group DOC23 Addenda A-track and B-track rows distinctly within §4.A6 (now that B-track is established with A-50).
- Rolling forward the R3.12-deferred items: human classification of A-47 (PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholder; likely final), A-48 (may warrant `STAGING / SUPPORT`), A-49 (likely needs `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / NAVIGATION / REFERENCE` reclassification per file's own non-normative header).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include both `DOC23 Addenda/` and `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 6 active files: A-45 / A-46 / A-47 / A-48 / A-49 / A-50).
- Verification of next scheduled 04:10 daily backup run (after Will's Cowork mount fix in R3.12) to confirm autonomous-success path works.
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 releases (per S-9 log recommendation; carry-forward from R3.11/R3.12).
- Final disposition of the now-7-rows-deep DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse opportunity (A-40 / A-41 / A-42 / A-43 / A-44 + briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1).

---

### R3.12 — 2026-05-02 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Substantial structural drift detected** — 3 new addenda in the DOC23 Addenda subfolder (R4.1 V2 of DOC23 Task Optimization at 154,930 bytes; R5/R6 Deferral List V2 at 30,631 bytes; Context Mgmt Proposal V1 → V5 Card Integration Map V2 at 23,341 bytes); 3 archive moves (A-44 R4.0 (1) the prior canonical R4.0; briefly-extant R4.1 V1; briefly-extant R5/R6 Deferral V1); plus a major operations status change (S-11 BACKUP_LOG: third consecutive scheduled failure followed by first SUCCESS via manual seed backup after Will fixed the OneDrive Cowork mount). R3.11 was generated 2026-05-02 ~10:00 (second pass of the day, alias-only re-confirmation no-op); this R3.12 pass fires later the same day (third pass, sync run at ~16:00 local).

**Changes from R3.11:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-47 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 12:34, size 154,930 bytes — large file). Per file header: R4.1 V2 (Draft), 2026-05-02, status "Draft — V2 closes 25 row gaps + 2 deviations from V1 audit. Pending Will's review against V5 adjudication card. Compiles into DOC23 R3.2." Research basis: CheckEval / FLASK / RULERS / G-Eval / CyclicJudge / MT-Bench / GEPA. Closes contract for five capabilities (Experiments, Claim Extraction, Judges, Sub-Agent Awareness, Prompt Optimization — last one RESERVED FOR R5) plus two cross-cutting capabilities (DOC24 Context Injection §A8, Session Continuity §A9). Per its own §A1 scope: R4.1 = contract closure + schema cleanup + safety items + minimum context-management subset that makes Pattern 7 runnable; reserves DSPy + Optimization Platform + Human Eval + Code-Based Scorers + full Context Management Proposal V1 substrate + Campaigns/Dataset Library for R5+. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. **Supersedes A-44 R4.0 (1) and a briefly-extant R4.1 V1** (the R4.1 V1 file mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 103,002 bytes — created and archived in same window per archive listing; V2 changelog explicitly identifies V2 as "Audit-pass additions"). |
| New addendum row A-48 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R5_R6_DEFERRAL_LIST_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 30,631 bytes). Per file header: V2 status "Pre-adjudication — will be revised after Will fills the V5 Decision column to V3 (post-adjudication)." Companion to `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_ADJUDICATION_CARD_V5.md` (V5 = 238 rows, not registered in master spec list). V2 supersedes a briefly-extant V1 (V1 file mtime 2026-05-02 09:58, size 24,682 bytes — archived in same window). Three top-level sections: §1 R5 work plan grouped by functional area A–N; §2 R6 work plan (4 items); §3 external documents that compile into R5/R6. Cross-doc obligations OB-A14 through OB-A18 flagged. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| New addendum row A-49 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_CONTEXT_MGMT_PROPOSAL_V1_TO_CARD_INTEGRATION_MAP_V2.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 23,341 bytes). **Per file header: meta/navigation document — non-normative.** Date 2026-05-02. Status "Complete. All proposal spec content is accounted for — either as a card row or a deferral list entry." V2 changes per file: V1 identified 5 candidate elevations and 6 calibration items; card V5 absorbed all 5 elevations as rows #234–#238; calibration items moved to deferral list §6 (= A-48). Closed-loop integration map between A-45 (the proposal) and the V5 card. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification — likely needs reclassification to `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / NAVIGATION / REFERENCE` (file is non-normative by purpose, like A-34). |
| A-44 row in §A6 annotated for file-moved-to-archive | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` no longer in active subfolder; new path `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime preserved 2026-04-30 23:44, size unchanged 41,659 bytes). Disposition: superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2. R3.9 had moved A-44 from §A1 root to §A6 treating it as canonical R4.0; R3.12 archives it as R4.1 V2 supersedes. Mirrors A-43 R3.9 archival pattern. |
| Two briefly-extant files (R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1) created and archived in same window | Neither got a master-spec-list row of its own (created and archived too quickly between R3.11 ~10:00 and R3.12 ~16:00 to be detected by an intermediate sync). R4.1 V1 file mtime 2026-05-02 10:58, size 103,002 bytes; R5/R6 Deferral V1 file mtime 2026-05-02 09:58, size 24,682 bytes. Both now in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. Informational only. |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md row updated with mtime+size+notes refresh: persistent-failure → RESOLVED | Size 2,366 → 4,422 bytes (~87%) across two new entries: third consecutive `failed` scheduled-task entry at 2026-05-02 04:17 local, then **first SUCCESS entry at 2026-05-02 10:46 local** — manual seed backup, archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-02_174643.tgz` (4.84 MB compressed from 16 MB source). Per success-entry notes: Will mounted the OneDrive folder via Cowork's chat-box "+" connector, scheduled task SKILL.md updated to use workspace-mount path resolution. **Carry-forward anomaly tracked since R3.6 is now RESOLVED.** Future scheduled runs should produce SUCCESS entries on the daily 04:10 cadence. Row mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status field preserved (`SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT`). |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.12 sub-section added | Documents 3 new addenda + 1 archive move + 2 briefly-extant files + S-11 status change + carry-forward items (DOC11 R15 R1; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; OpenClaw release alignment slipping further behind). |
| §11 counts updated | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 46 → 49 (+3 for A-47/A-48/A-49). §4 Active Addenda: 46 → 49 (A6: 2 → 5 with A-44 alias unchanged but its file archived). Grand total: 112 → 115 (header) / 111 → 114 (§11 grand total). Operations files unchanged at 12 (S-11 status changed but row count unchanged). |
| Versioned snapshot saved | This R3.12 sync saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.12.md` from the post-bump alias content alongside the existing R3.10 + R3.11 snapshots. Pattern of "alias bump misses versioned snapshot save" (R3.5/R3.6 → R3.7 backfill; R3.9 → R3.10 backfill) is NOT recurring at R3.10/R3.11/R3.12 — three consecutive alias bumps now save snapshots correctly. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.12 is structural drift in the addenda layer + an operations status change; both are tracked in the master spec list update itself. V11 carryover prompt remains current. Architect to confirm in next manual sweep. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — Master Spec List row should pick up R3.12 on next state-file regeneration; no row content change beyond mtime/Notes refreshes. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — should add A-47/A-48/A-49 rows + annotate A-44 for archival on next regeneration. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — should pick up R3.12 generation event on this run's post-write append. None of these state files were refreshed between R3.11 ~10:00 and R3.12 ~16:00. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-05-02 (third pass; master spec list R3.12; carryover V11 unchanged); ADDENDA array adds A-47/A-48/A-49 entries + annotates A-44 for archival; OPERATIONS array updates S-11 row with the SUCCESS entry; footer updated to R3.12. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim. R3.12 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 existing addenda rows except A-44 alias annotation in §A6 preserved verbatim.
- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) row preserved verbatim with prior R3.4 file-moved-to-archive flag note pointing forward to A-36 still applicable.
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections (R3.0 through R3.11) preserved verbatim.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs (A-22 BDSM V6.4, A-24 DOC72/DOC7 Bucket Intake, I-2 Tool Capability Nodes Amendment).
- Carry-forward anomalies (DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot still missing) preserved unchanged. **OneDrive backup carry-forward (tracked since R3.6) RESOLVED in R3.12.**

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**
- Final disposition of A-44 archive-row collapse (in next manual sweep, A-44 alias row could be collapsed into a "DOC23 Task Optimization R4.0 (1) superseded by A-47 R4.1 V2" pointer alongside the existing A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 collapse opportunity from R3.9; full chain now 6 rows deep).
- Optional post-hoc rows for the briefly-extant R4.1 V1 + R5/R6 Deferral V1 files (created and archived in same window — no master-spec-list rows ever assigned).
- Human classification of A-47 (PROPOSED ADDENDUM placeholder; likely fits as final classification given file is normative spec content).
- Human classification of A-48 (may warrant `STAGING / SUPPORT` rather than `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` since file is explicitly a work-plan staging buffer).
- Human classification of A-49 (likely needs reclassification to `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT / NAVIGATION / REFERENCE` since file is non-normative meta/navigation by its own header — like A-34 ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include both `DOC23 Addenda/` and `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` (DOC23 Addenda gap especially salient now with 5 active files).
- Verification of next scheduled 04:10 daily backup run to confirm autonomous-success path works after Will's Cowork mount fix.
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 releases (per S-9 log recommendation; carry-forward from R3.11).

---

### R3.11 — 2026-05-02 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **No structural drift detected** — re-confirmation pass. R3.10 was generated 2026-05-02 ~03:16 (first pass of the day); this R3.11 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence (sync run at ~10:00 local). Three post-R3.10 mtime ticks on operations log files; no new specs/addenda; no archive movements.

**Changes from R3.10:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-5 / S-8 / S-9) — informational only | `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) advanced 2026-05-02 03:21, size 40,253 → 56,692 bytes (~41%) — appended by R3.10's own sync run as the post-write narrative entry (large because R3.10 documented 4 archive moves + new DOC23 Addenda subfolder + 2 new addenda + state-tracker backfill + versioned-snapshot backfill). `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) advanced 2026-05-02 03:47, size 2,538 → 4,039 bytes — new 2026-05-02 entry advances "latest stable release" reference from 2026.4.27 to 2026.4.29 (2026-04-29); gap status now BEHIND by 2 releases. `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-05-02 04:02, size 25,227 → 32,292 bytes (~28%) — fourth auto-refresh tick. All three rows in §7 mtime+Notes refreshed mechanically; status fields preserved. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.11 sub-section added | Documents the three mtime ticks plus the OpenClaw release-alignment slip-by-1 development (latest stable advanced to 2026.4.29; informational recommendation in S-9 log to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment + new R of running spec update list — neither file authored yet). Carry-forward items (DOC11 R15 R1; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; OneDrive backup destination still failing — no third `failed` entry yet because no nightly run between R3.10 and R3.11; DOC23 Task Optimization archive-row collapse deferred) all unchanged. |
| §11 counts unchanged | No new specs, no new addenda, no archive movements, no operations file additions. Grand total stays at 112 (per header) / 111 (per §11 grand total — header includes row 44 placeholder). |
| Versioned snapshot saved | This R3.11 sync saves `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.11.md` from the post-bump alias content alongside the existing `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.10.md`. Pattern of "alias bump misses versioned snapshot save" (R3.5/R3.6 → R3.7 backfill; R3.9 → R3.10 backfill) is NOT recurring at R3.11. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.11 introduces no structural drift beyond what V11 already covers. Architect to confirm in next manual sweep. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — Master Spec List row should pick up R3.11 on next state-file regeneration; no row content change beyond mtime/Notes refreshes for S-5/S-8/S-9. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — no row content change (no new addenda). `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — should pick up R3.11 generation event on this run's post-write append. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-05-02 (second pass; master spec list R3.11; carryover V11 unchanged); ADDENDA / IN_FLIGHT / OPERATIONS arrays unchanged in count; OPERATIONS array refreshes S-5/S-8/S-9 row mtime/Notes; footer updated to R3.11. |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows preserved verbatim.
- All §4 active addenda rows preserved verbatim (no new addenda; A-46 placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM unchanged).
- All §5 / §6 rows preserved verbatim.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections (R3.0 through R3.10) preserved verbatim.
- All carry-forward anomalies preserved unchanged.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs (A-22 BDSM V6.4, A-24 DOC72/DOC7 Bucket Intake, I-2 Tool Capability Nodes Amendment).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review** (carry-forward from R3.10, no new items):
- Final disposition of A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 archive-row collapse (in next manual sweep, the four annotated rows could be collapsed into a single "DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0/R3.0/R4.0/Running-Additions superseded by A-44 R4.0 (1)" pointer).
- Human classification of A-45 (Judge Context Management Proposal V1) and A-46 (DOC23 Re-Prompt System Addendum).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include both `DOC23 Addenda/` and `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/`.
- Whether to author DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal absorbing OpenClaw 2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 releases (per S-9 log recommendation).
- Whether to resolve the OneDrive backup failure now (Cowork directory configuration) or accept the persistent failure state.

---

### R3.10 — 2026-05-02 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. Minor structural drift detected — 1 NEW addendum in DOC23 Addenda subfolder, 1 NEW mockup variant (informational), R3.9 versioned snapshot backfilled, multiple state-tracker mtime ticks. R3.9 was generated 2026-05-01 ~23:14 (alias-only bump; versioned snapshot was missing); this R3.10 pass fires the next morning per the scheduled-task cadence.

**Changes from R3.9:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-46 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md` (mtime 2026-05-02 00:31, size 22,818 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Red Line — Sequential Re-Prompt System", date 2026-05-01, status "Draft addendum for compilation into DOC23 R3.2." Affects DOC23 R3.1 §3.2.1 (step.agent_task), §3.2.8 (step.coding), §6.5.2 (agent task execution), §6.5.8 (coding execution), §4.5 (output popups), §4.8 (validation). Latest entry in DOC23 addendum cluster (alongside A-44 = R4.0 (1) canonical relocated, A-45 = Judge Context Management Proposal V1). Note: targets DOC23 R3.2 compilation revision, distinct from A-45 which targets DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 — implies parallel evolution of operative DOC23 spec (R3.1 → R3.2) alongside its addenda (R4.0 → R4.1). Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| New mockup variant (informational only — not formally tracked in §3-§7) | `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx` (mtime 2026-05-01 21:54, size 180,080 bytes — ~22% larger than V11.0's 147,393 bytes). The "ALT_A" suffix suggests parallel A/B variant rather than supersession; both V11.0 and V11_ALT_A coexist. Likely tied to the DOC23 addendum cluster shipping in same window (A-45 mtime 2026-05-01 17:26; A-46 mtime 2026-05-02 00:31). Master spec list does not formally track mockup files; SPEC_STATE.md Build Surface section updated to reflect this. |
| R3.9 versioned snapshot backfilled | The R3.9 alias bump (2026-05-01 ~23:14) registered version revision in alias content but did NOT save a versioned snapshot file (carry-forward gap pattern from prior R3.5 / R3.6 alias bumps). R3.10 sync saves the pre-bump alias content (representing R3.9 state) as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.9.md` to preserve the snapshot. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (acknowledged carry-forward — preserved only via R3.6.md narrative section). |
| State-tracker mtime ticks (S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11) | `BACKUP_LOG.md` (S-11) advanced 2026-04-30 11:16 → 2026-05-01 11:17, size 1,159 → 2,366 bytes (second consecutive `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` entry). `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (S-9) advanced 2026-04-30 10:42 → 2026-05-01 10:42, size 1,013 → 2,538 bytes. `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (S-8) advanced 2026-04-30 11:01 → 2026-05-01 11:00, size 18,228 → 25,227 bytes. `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (S-10) advanced 2026-04-30 10:55 → 2026-05-01 11:04, size 1,947 → 4,474 bytes. All four mtime+size updates are mechanical; status fields preserved. |
| State-tracker backfill (SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md) | The R3.9 alias bump (2026-05-01 ~23:14) registered DOC23 archive moves + new subfolder + new addendum in alias content but did NOT flow them through to SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md trackers (state files mtime 2026-05-01 10:09 / 10:11, both predate R3.9 alias bump). R3.10 sync corrects: ADDENDA_STATE.md rows A-38/A-39/A-40/A-41 annotated as file-moved-to-archive; A-42 annotated as relocated to new DOC23 Addenda subfolder; new §A.6 DOC23 Addenda subsection added with rows A-43 (Judge Context Management Proposal V1) and A-44 (Re-Prompt System Addendum). SPEC_STATE.md Master Spec List row updated to R3.10; S-9/S-10/S-11/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY rows mtime-updated; Build Surface section updated for new V11_ALT_A mockup. **Note: ADDENDA_STATE.md ID series (A-38…A-44) is independent of master spec list ID series (A-40…A-46). Intentional asymmetry — see R3.4 changelog convention note.** |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.10 sub-section added | (will reference: NEW DOC23_REPROMPT_SYSTEM_ADDENDUM.md detected; NEW Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx mockup variant; R3.9 versioned-snapshot backfilled; state-tracker mtime ticks; state-tracker backfill of R3.9 changes into SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md; carry-forward items unchanged.) |

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved):**
- All §3 core spec rows (DOC1–DOC73 + EC Core + Q canonical etc.) preserved verbatim. R3.10 made no §3 row updates.
- All §4 existing addenda rows except the additions noted above preserved verbatim.
- A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) row preserved verbatim with prior R3.4 file-moved-to-archive flag note pointing forward to A-36 still applicable.
- All §10 prior-revision anomaly subsections (R3.0 through R3.9) preserved verbatim.
- "Undated" rows preserved as in prior runs (A-22 BDSM V6.4, A-24 DOC72/DOC7 Bucket Intake, I-2 Tool Capability Nodes Amendment).
- Carry-forward anomalies (DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolders not in SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot still missing; OneDrive backup still failing) preserved unchanged.

---

### R3.9 — 2026-05-01 (nightly sync auto-bump — fourth pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Substantial structural drift detected** — 4 DOC23 files moved from active root to archive, NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder created with 1 relocated file (A-44) and 1 entirely new file (A-45 Judge Context Management Proposal V1), BACKUP_LOG ticked second consecutive failure entry. R3.8 was generated 2026-05-01 ~04:06; this R3.9 pass fires later the same morning per the scheduled-task cadence to capture significant DOC23 cluster reorganization that occurred between 04:06 and ~10:30.

**Changes from R3.8:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| Four DOC23 Task Optimization files moved to archive | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` (A-40), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` (A-41), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (A-42), `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` (A-43) all moved from active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. R3.7-R3.8 had flagged all four for likely archival. Rows in §4.A1 annotated with file-moved markers, mirroring A-2/A-3/A-12 (DOC3 Addenda A) and A-25 (DOC72 CSA R1) patterns. R3.7's "two parallel R4.0 files" (A-43 vs A-44) canonical-determination question is now resolved by the move pattern: A-43 (no-suffix, larger size 52,949 bytes) was archived; A-44 ((1)-suffix, smaller size 41,659 bytes) was kept active. A-44 is therefore the operative R4.0 going forward. |
| New §4.A6 DOC23 Addenda subfolder section | New subfolder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/` (folder mtime 2026-05-01 10:27) detected. Subfolder structurally analogous to existing DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73 Addenda subfolders. Contains 2 files: A-44 (relocated from §A1 root, mtime preserved 2026-04-30 23:44, size 41,659 bytes) and new A-45. New §4.A6 subsection added with alias row for A-44 + new row for A-45. |
| New addendum row A-45 added in §4.A6 | `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_R4_0_CONTEXT_MANAGEMENT_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 10:26, size 53,884 bytes). Per file header: "DOC23 Addenda A R4.0 — Judge Context Management Proposal V1" by Claude Opus 4.7, target compilation revision DOC23 Addenda A R4.1, supersedes nothing (new proposal), status "Draft proposal — pending review, calibration, red team, and compilation into R4.1." Closes the per-dimension context-duplication gap flagged by two same-day red team reviews (40 + 34 findings) — defines a regime-classification preparation pipeline, three new variant-bundle schemas, sub-agent fan-out dispatch modes, per-dimension context-requirement flags, a DOC25 ingestion contract, and supporting validation/SSE/UI surfaces. Concrete ambition: enable a 4-variant × 5-dimension × 3-judge ensemble pairwise scoring of a 60-page complaint draft to run within model context windows AND under $25 per run AND in under 90 seconds wall-clock. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| A-44 row in §4.A1 annotated for file-moved-to-§A6 | Path now `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md`. Row preserved in §A1 with file-moved-to-§A6 annotation; A-44 is also referenced from §A6 with an "alias" / "previously listed in §A1" pointer for cross-section traceability. |
| S-11 BACKUP_LOG.md mtime + size refresh | mtime 2026-04-30 04:16 → 2026-05-01 04:17; size 1,159 → 2,366 bytes (~2x). Second consecutive `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` entry recorded. Per the 2026-05-01 entry's notes, Will needs to add the OneDrive Personal folder (or `~/Library/CloudStorage/`) to Cowork's connected directories before this task can succeed. Row S-11 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status preserved. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.9 sub-section added | Documents the 4 archive moves, NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder + 2 files (A-44 alias + A-45 new), S-11 mtime+size refresh, plus carry-forward items (DOC11 R15 R1/R2; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 + NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolder both not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned-snapshot still missing; R3.9 versioned-snapshot pending). |
| §11 counts updated | PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda) 44 → 45 (+1 for A-45). §4 Active Addenda: 44 → 45 (A1 unchanged at 28; A6 new with 1 entry counted [A-45]; A-44 in §A6 is an alias pointer to A-44's primary row in §A1, not separately counted). Grand total: 110 → 111 (+1 for A-45). Operations files unchanged at 12. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.9 deferred-detect items do not introduce new structural changes beyond what V10 already covers. Architect to confirm in next manual sweep. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — should pick up new DOC23 Addenda subfolder structure on next state-file regeneration. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — should add A-45 entry; A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 should be annotated for file-moved; A-44 should be annotated for path-change. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — should pick up R3.9 generation event. None of these state files were refreshed between R3.8 (04:06) and R3.9 (10:30); their next refresh will be the next nightly sync state-file pass. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-05-01 (fourth pass); ADDENDA array should add A-45 entry and annotate A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 for archive + A-44 for path-change to DOC23 Addenda subfolder; OPERATIONS array should refresh S-11 entry with new mtime/size/note about second consecutive failure; footer updated to R3.9. |

**Carry-forward anomalies still requiring human action** (unchanged from R3.8 except DOC23 archival decisions now resolved): A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder (likely supersession by A-36 R2 per S-9 log); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; both DOC73 Addenda and NEW DOC23 Addenda subfolders still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG continues to record `failed` — count now 2; Will action required per S-11 row).

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**

- Final disposition of A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43 archive moves (rows preserved per registry convention; in next manual sweep, the four annotated rows could be collapsed into a single pointer if Will prefers).
- Confirmation that A-44 is canonical R4.0 (the move pattern strongly implies this, but a `diff` between A-44 active content and A-43 archived content would document the editorial difference for future readers).
- Human classification of A-45 (placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending review).
- Updating the nightly sync task SKILL.md in-scope folder list to formally include both `DOC23 Addenda/` (NEW in R3.9) and `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` (carry-forward from R2.9).
- Whether to backfill `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.9.md` snapshot file from current alias content.
- Whether to resolve the OneDrive backup failure now (Cowork directory configuration) or accept the persistent failure state.

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved per task constraints):**
- All RT posture, In-OP-A, UI Extracted, Retrofit, QA Pass fields — preserved verbatim.
- All status fields on existing rows — placeholder rows for new files (A-45) use `PROPOSED ADDENDUM`; archive-moved rows (A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43) preserved at their R3.7 status with appended R3.9 file-moved annotation.
- A-45 content delta and architectural assessment — auto pass cannot determine whether the proposal is technically sound; placeholder only.
- A-44 vs A-43 canonical determination — auto pass infers from move pattern but does NOT actually `diff` the files to document what changed; human review needed for the editorial record.

### R3.7 — 2026-05-01 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Substantial structural drift detected** — 4 new addendum-folder files in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root reflecting a rapid DOC23 Task Optimization iteration burst (R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 in <16 hours plus a Running Additions staging file plus a duplicate-name R4.0 (1) file). Also: state-tracker backfill (SPEC_STATE.md and ADDENDA_STATE.md updated to register S-9/S-10/S-11/A-38 entries that prior R3.5/R3.6 alias bumps did not flow through). Also: versioned-snapshot backfill (R3.6.md created from prior alias content; R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING — narrated only within R3.6.md/R3.7.md narrative sections).

**Changes from R3.6:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-41 added in §4.A1 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R3_0.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 23:40, size 24,266 bytes — ~60% smaller than R2.0). Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) per filename pattern. Companion to A-42 RUNNING_ADDITIONS staging doc. Likely already superseded by A-43 R4.0 within hours. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| New addendum row A-42 added in §4.A1 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_RUNNING_ADDITIONS.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 00:57, size 108,578 bytes — large file). Per file header: "Staging document for changes to compile into the next revision of DOC23 Addenda A (Task Optimization). Items are added during iterative discussion and compiled in batch." Header references "for R3.0" but R4.0 already shipped — may need re-targeting. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification (could warrant STAGING / SUPPORT classification instead). |
| New addendum row A-43 added in §4.A1 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0.md` (mtime 2026-05-01 05:50, size 52,949 bytes). Supersedes A-40 (R2.0) and A-41 (R3.0) per filename pattern. Most recent revision in R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 chain. Treat as latest DOC23 Task Optimization addendum going forward pending human disposition. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| New addendum row A-44 added in §4.A1 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_0 (1).md` (mtime 2026-05-01 06:44, size 41,659 bytes — DIFFERENT from A-43). Filename "(1)" suffix is the macOS download-collision pattern; `diff -q` confirms files differ. Both coexist in active folder. Human disposition needed: which file is canonical R4.0? Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. Sync did NOT delete or rename either file per task constraint #1. |
| Existing addendum row A-40 annotated for supersession | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` row updated with R3.7 note: SUPERSEDED by A-41 (R3.0) and then by A-43 (R4.0). All three revisions remain in active folder pending human archival decision. |
| State-tracker backfill | SPEC_STATE.md updated to add rows S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG, S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG, S-11 BACKUP_LOG (all originally added to alias content in R3.5/R3.6 alias bumps but not flowed through to SPEC_STATE.md). ADDENDA_STATE.md updated to add row A-38 DOC23 Task Optimization R2.0 (originally added to alias content in R3.6 alias bump but not flowed through to ADDENDA_STATE.md). Plus new rows A-39/A-40/A-41/A-42 for today's drift. |
| Versioned-snapshot backfill | Pre-bump alias content (representing R3.6 state) saved as `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.6.md` to preserve at least one versioned snapshot for the R3.5/R3.6 changes. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (preserved only via R3.6.md narrative section). |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.7 sub-section added | Documents 4 new files plus state-tracker backfill and versioned-snapshot backfill items. Carry-forward items (DOC11 R15 R1/R2; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 Addenda subfolder; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; OneDrive backup destination) all unchanged. |
| §11 counts updated | Active addenda 40 → 44 (+4 in R3.7). Grand total 106 → 110 (+4 active addenda). Operations files unchanged at 12. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Bumped V9 → V10 by this R3.7 sync to capture the four new DOC23 addenda + state-tracker backfill. V9 retained alongside V3–V8. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — updated with backfill rows + new mtime. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — updated with new rows A-38/A-39/A-40/A-41/A-42 + new mtime. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — updated with R3.7 entry. |
| **Dashboard** | Regenerated: `lastRefresh` updated to 2026-05-01 (nightly sync; master spec list R3.7; carryover V10); ADDENDA array adds entries A-38 to A-42; IN_FLIGHT array adds entries for new DOC23 files; footer updated to R3.7. |

**Carry-forward anomalies still requiring human action** (unchanged from R3.6): A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder (likely supersession by A-36 R2 per S-9 log); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; OneDrive backup destination still not visible to bash sandbox (BACKUP_LOG continues to record `failed`). New R3.7 disposition deferral: A-40/A-41/A-42/A-43/A-44 archival decisions for the DOC23 Task Optimization iteration burst.

**Things this auto pass deferred for human review:**

- Disposition / archival decisions on A-40/A-41/A-43 supersession chain (R2.0 → R3.0 → R4.0 — may want to mass-archive after Will confirms R4.0 is the keeper).
- Canonical determination for A-43 vs A-44 (both labeled R4.0; differ in size and content).
- A-42 RUNNING_ADDITIONS classification (PROPOSED ADDENDUM vs STAGING / SUPPORT).
- Whether R3.5 versioned snapshot needs reconstruction or the gap is acceptable.

### R3.6 — 2026-04-30 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Minor structural drift detected** — 1 new addendum in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` root + 1 new operations log file in active `Operations Docs/`. R3.5 was generated 2026-04-30 04:08 (second pass of the day); the scheduled task fired again later the same day to capture two new files that appeared after that pass.

**Changes from R3.5:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-40 added in §4.A1 | `DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R2_0.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 13:43, size 61,420 bytes). DOC23 R3.1 addendum (R2.0 Draft, dated 2026-04-02) defining `system.experiment`, `step.judge`, and DSPy prompt optimization as DOC23 modules. Status header notes "not yet compiled into DOC23." Companion to Prop-A R6.3. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM pending human classification. |
| New operations row S-11 added in §7 | `BACKUP_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 04:16, size 1,159 bytes — small file). Append-only log of the automated daily `elnor-onedrive-backup` task; first entry 2026-04-30 11:16 (UTC) recorded `failed (OneDrive destination unreachable from sandbox)` due to OneDrive Personal cloud path not visible to bash sandbox in this run. Placeholder SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT pending human classification. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.6 sub-section added | Documents 2 new files plus carry-forward items (DOC11 R15 R1/R2 active-folder coexistence; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy; DOC73 Addenda subfolder not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path). |
| §11 counts updated | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT: 17 → 18 (+1). PROPOSED ADDENDUM (active addenda): 39 → 40 (+1). Operations Files: 11 → 12 (+1). Grand total: 104 → 106 (+2). §4 A1 count: 23 → 24. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.6 deferred-detect items do not introduce new structural changes beyond what V8 already covers. Architect to confirm in next manual sweep. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (S-3) — should pick up A-40 / S-11 entries on next state-file regeneration. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (S-4) — should pick up A-40 entry. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (S-5) — should pick up R3.6 generation event. |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-04-30 (third pass); ADDENDA array should add A-40 entry; OPERATIONS array should add S-11 entry; footer updated to R3.6. |

**Carry-forward anomalies still requiring human action** (unchanged from R3.5): A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder (likely supersession by A-36 R2 per S-9 log); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list.

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved per task constraints):**
- All RT posture, In-OP-A, UI Extracted, Retrofit, QA Pass fields — preserved verbatim.
- All status fields on existing rows — placeholder rows for new files use `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` / `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` per task spec.
- A-40 content-impact assessment — auto pass cannot determine whether this proposal is additive or supersedes earlier DOC23 addenda. Placeholder only.
- S-11 BACKUP_LOG status — auto pass records the file's first-entry failure mode but does not attempt to remediate the underlying sandbox/permissions issue.

### R3.5 — 2026-04-30 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Minor structural drift detected** — 2 new operations files; 4 state-tracker mtime refreshes; no new specs or addenda. R3.4 was generated 2026-04-30 03:15; the scheduled task fired again later the same day to capture two new tracker logs that appeared in the active `Operations Docs/` folder (S-9 at 03:42 and S-10 at 04:04).

**Changes from R3.4:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New operations row S-9 added in §7 | `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 03:42, size 1,013 bytes — small file). Append-only nightly OpenClaw release-alignment log; first entry 2026-04-30 10:42 (UTC) records gap status BEHIND by one release (covered through 2026.4.26 per A-36 vs latest stable 2026.4.27). Placeholder SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT pending human classification. |
| New operations row S-10 added in §7 | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 04:04, size 1,947 bytes — small file). Append-only log accompanying RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md (S-8) refreshes; first auto-refresh entry 2026-04-30 10:55 (UTC). Placeholder SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT pending human classification. |
| S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md mtime + size refresh | Promoted from manual-only to nightly-auto-refresh in this pass per S-10 log. mtime 2026-04-29 19:05 → 2026-04-30 04:01; size 15,496 → 18,228 bytes (~18%). Row S-8 mtime + Notes updated mechanically; status preserved. |
| State tracker mtime refreshes (S-3, S-4, S-5) | `SPEC_STATE.md` mtime 2026-04-28 03:09 → 2026-04-30 03:08 (size 19,169 → 21,993 bytes); `ADDENDA_STATE.md` mtime 2026-04-28 03:10 → 2026-04-30 03:09 (size 14,478 → 20,040 bytes); `DRIFT_LOG.md` mtime 2026-04-29 03:23 → 2026-04-30 03:20 (size 29,727 → 40,253 bytes). Auto-refresh by this same nightly sync run; no row content change. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.5 sub-section added | Documents 2 new files, 1 mtime+size refresh on S-8, 3 state-tracker mtime refreshes, 2 carry-forward items (DOC11 R15 R1/R2 active-folder coexistence; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy). |
| §11 counts updated | SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT: 15 → 17 (+2). Operations Files: 9 → 11 (+2). Grand total: 102 → 104 (+2). |

**Carry-forward anomalies still requiring human action** (unchanged from R3.4): A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still in active folder (likely supersession by A-36 R2 per S-9 log); OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy in two locations; DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list.

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved per task constraints):**
- All RT posture, In-OP-A, UI Extracted, Retrofit, QA Pass fields — preserved verbatim.
- All status fields on existing rows — placeholder rows for new files use `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` per task spec.
- S-3/S-4/S-5 state-tracker rows — only mtime + Notes touched (per state file update spec); status preserved.
- A-1 archival decision — preserved from R3.4 pending human action.

### R3.4 — 2026-04-30 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **Structural drift detected** — 4 new addenda + 1 new operations file + 1 archive movement; 2 carry-forward DOC16 anomalies resolved.

**Changes from R3.3:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| New addendum row A-36 added in §4.A1 | `DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R2.md` (mtime 2026-04-30 00:45). Supersedes A-1 (R1 remains in active folder pending archival). Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM. |
| New addendum row A-37 added in §4.A4 | `DOC72_PROPOSAL_CONTINUITY_SYNTHESIS_ARCHITECTURE_R2.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 18:28). Supersedes A-25 (R1 file moved to archive). Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM. |
| New addendum row A-38 added in §4.A5 | `DOC73_PROPOSAL_SECTION_6_4_MECHANISM_4_ROLLUP_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 18:31). Companion to A-37 (CSA R2 Tier 2 dependency). Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM. |
| New addendum row A-39 added in §4.A5 | `DOC73_V1_6_ADJUDICATION_CARD_ARCHITECT_NOTES_V1 (1).md` (mtime 2026-04-30 04:14). Architect notes for forthcoming DOC73 V1.6 red-team. Placeholder PROPOSED ADDENDUM. |
| New operations row S-8 added in §7 | `RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 19:05). Likely Will-authored summary; placeholder SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT. |
| A-1 row annotated for likely supersession by A-36 | DOC11 R15 Amendment Proposal R1 still in active folder; R2 supersedes per filename pattern. |
| A-25 row annotated for file-moved-to-archive | DOC72 Continuity Synthesis Architecture R1 moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`. |
| Carry-forward anomaly #2 RESOLVED | `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` no longer in active folder. SPEC_STATE.md row REMOVED. |
| Carry-forward anomaly #3 RESOLVED | `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` no longer in active folder. SPEC_STATE.md row REMOVED. |
| Carry-forward anomaly #1 status update | `DOC16_R5_4.md` IS PRESENT (mtime 2026-04-09 22:47, size 245,927 bytes; hardlink count 2). May have been there all along. SPEC_STATE.md row mtime + Notes updated. Master row 30 judgment fields preserved. |
| §10 anomaly section: new R3.4 sub-section added | Documents the 4 new files, 1 archive move, 2 anomalies resolved, 1 mtime-change observation. |
| §11 counts updated | Active addenda: 35 → 39 (+4). Operations files: 8 → 9 (+1). Grand total: 97 → 102. |

**Carry-forward anomalies still requiring human action** (unchanged from R3.3 except DOC16 #2 and #3 resolved): DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; DOC73 Addenda subfolder still not in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list.

**Items intentionally NOT changed (judgment fields preserved per task constraints):**
- All RT posture, In-OP-A, UI Extracted, Retrofit, QA Pass fields — preserved verbatim.
- All status fields on existing rows — placeholder rows for new files use `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` / `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` per task spec.
- DOC16 R5.4 anomaly status decision — file IS present; row's `FUTURE / PLANNING DRAFT` status preserved pending human reclassification.
- A-37 / A-38 content delta — auto pass cannot determine whether these new proposals fully supersede earlier work or are additive. Placeholders only.

### R3.3 — 2026-04-29 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. **No structural changes since R3.2** — this is a re-confirmation no-op pass. R3.2 was generated 2026-04-29 03:16; the scheduled task fired again later the same day (this is the second R-pass of 2026-04-29, mirroring the R2.9/R3.0/R3.1 same-day cadence on 2026-04-28).

**Changes from R3.2:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **(none — no new artifacts detected)** | Folder scan re-affirms R3.2 state. Active `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` (47 visible files, including `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.2.md` snapshot mtime 2026-04-29 03:16) — no new files. Active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` and all tracked subfolders (DOC20 Addenda / DOC24 Addenda / DOC72 Addenda and Proposals / DOC73 Addenda and Proposals / Integrated Addenda / CD Cross Docs) — no new files. Active `Operations Docs/` — no new files; only V3.7 OP-A tracker remains alongside the three state-tracking artifacts (S-3 SPEC_STATE, S-4 ADDENDA_STATE, S-5 DRIFT_LOG) and the two consolidation session reports (S-6, S-7). |
| `DRIFT_LOG.md` mtime refresh | `DRIFT_LOG.md` mtime advanced from 2026-04-28 03:17 to 2026-04-29 03:23 (size now 29,727 bytes, up from 19,385 bytes in R3.0 registration) — a state-tracking refresh by the nightly sync job that generated R3.2 itself. No content effect on the registry; row S-5 unchanged. Listed here for traceability only. |
| Carry-forward placeholders unchanged | All R3.2 placeholder rows pending human classification remain open: row 39b (DOC23 R3.1), row 40b (DOC24 R3), row 43b (DOC73 V1.5.1), row A-31 (DOC25 File Materialization V1, archived — confirms R3.1 prediction), row A-34 (ELNOR Search Architecture Reference R1, likely-reclassify-as-reference), row A-35 (DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 consolidated, may subsume A-2/A-3/A-12/A-33), row S-2b (OP-A V3.7), rows S-3/S-4/S-5 (state-tracking artifacts), rows S-6/S-7 (OP-A consolidation session reports). All unchanged. |
| Counts | §11 unchanged from R3.2: SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 14; Core registry 47; PROPOSED ADDENDUM 35; Operations Files 8; Grand total 97. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.3 is a pure no-op re-confirmation. V8 carryover prompt remains current. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:09) — no expected refresh by this pass; nothing structurally new to record. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:10) — no expected refresh. `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 03:23) — already refreshed by the R3.2 generation pass. |
| **Dashboard** | No regeneration needed — content unchanged from R3.2. `lastRefresh` may be touched to 2026-04-29 (second pass) by the dashboard generator if it runs, but no array contents change. |

### R3.2 — 2026-04-29 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. No human content judgments changed. All structural classification decisions deferred to a future human R3.3 sweep. R3.1 was generated 2026-04-28 23:09 (third pass of that day); this R3.2 reflects new artifacts that appeared overnight and into 2026-04-29 morning.

**Changes from R3.1:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| **DOC73 bumped V1.4.1 → V1.5.1** | New file `DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md` in active folder (mtime 2026-04-29 04:36; size 663,684 bytes — ~187 KB / ~39% larger than V1.4.1's 476 KB). Predecessor `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. Row 43 (V1.4.1) annotated for file-moved; new row 43b (V1.5.1) added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder pending human reclassification (likely promotes to `CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT` / `PRIMARY OWNER` since V1.4.1 was operative per architect 2026-04-26). New anomaly logged in §10. |
| **OP-A bumped V3.6 → V3.7** | New file `DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_7.md` in active `Operations Docs/` (mtime 2026-04-29 05:15; size 244,079 bytes — ~71 KB larger than V3.6). Active `Operations Docs/` now contains only V3.7. All prior V3.x files (V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5, V3.6) moved to `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` alongside V2. Companion patch document `OP_A_V3_6_TO_V3_7_PATCH_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 04:58, 83,154 bytes) sits in archive subfolder. §7 row S-1 path corrected to archive subfolder; row S-2 (V3.6) annotated for archive; new row S-2b (V3.7) added with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2.md` (consolidated) detected | New file (mtime 2026-04-29 08:32, size 193,966 bytes) in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Filename drops `_PROPOSAL_V1` suffix → likely the post-RT consolidated R2.2. New row A-35 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. May consolidate A-2, A-3, A-12 (all archived in same pass). New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Five active-folder addenda files moved to archive | `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (A-2), `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_SEMANTIC SKILLS R2_1.md` (A-3), `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (A-12 — already in archive at R3.0; reaffirmed), `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (A-31 — confirms R3.1 prediction), `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md` (A-33). A V3 of the DOC3 R11.3 R2.2 proposal also archived. All affected rows annotated with file-moved markers. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| `Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_0.jsx` mockup detected | New file (mtime 2026-04-28 04:16) in `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/`. Likely DOC23 R3.1 companion mockup (R3.1 mtime 2026-04-28 03:43 — same window). V10.4, V10.5, V10.8, V10.9 all remain alongside. SPEC_STATE.md Build Surface row updated. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Counts | §11 incremented: SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 13→14; Core registry 46→47; PROPOSED ADDENDUM 34→35; Operations Files 7→8; Grand total 94→97. Header `Total listed documents` updated 84→87. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` updated: DOC73 V1.4.1 row annotated for file-moved + new V1.5.1 row added in Core Specs; OP-A V2/V3.6 rows annotated for archive + new V3.7 row added in Operations / Trackers; Master Spec List row updated to R3.2; mockup row updated to V11.0; mtimes refreshed. `ADDENDA_STATE.md` updated: A-2, A-3, A-12 rows annotated for file-moved; new rows A-31 (DOC25 V1.1), A-32 (ELNOR Search Reference), A-33 (DOC3 R2.2 consolidated). Note: ADDENDA_STATE row IDs A-31/A-32/A-33 reflect the state-file's own ID sequence (last assigned was A-30 in R2.9); master spec list row IDs A-31/A-32/A-33/A-34/A-35 reflect the master list's separate R3.0/R3.1/R3.2 sequence. The two ID series are intentionally not synchronized (state file groups by detection order; master list groups by category and history). |
| **Carryover prompt** | Bumped V7 → V8 to reflect DOC73 V1.5.1 + OP-A V3.7 + DOC3 R2.2 consolidated. V7 retained alongside V3/V4/V5/V6. |
| **Dashboard** | Regenerated: `lastRefresh` → 2026-04-29; SPECS array adds DOC73 V1.5.1 row and annotates V1.4.1 row; ADDENDA array adds A-31/A-32/A-33 entries (per ADDENDA_STATE.md numbering) and annotates A-2/A-3/A-12; workstream descriptions updated for V3.7; in-flight items updated; footer updated to R3.2. |

### R3.1 — 2026-04-28 (nightly sync auto-bump — third pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. No human content judgments changed. All structural classification decisions deferred to a future human R3.2 sweep. This bump is the third R-pass of the day (R2.9 was generated 2026-04-28 03:13; R3.0 was generated 2026-04-28 04:10; R3.1 is generated later the same day to reflect new artifacts that appeared in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` after the R3.0 pass).

**Changes from R3.0:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| Two `DOC25_FILE_MATERIALIZATION_AND_PROVIDER_PROFILES_PROPOSAL` versions detected | V1 (mtime 2026-04-28 13:57, size 33,664 bytes) and V1.1 (mtime 2026-04-28 15:48, size 38,285 bytes) both new in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. New rows A-31 (V1) and A-32 (V1.1) added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. V1.1 explicitly supersedes V1 per its `Supersedes:` header field; V1.1 is a documentary refinement of V1 (no schema/behavioral/failure-mode changes). Targets DOC25 V2.0 with file-materialization tri-state (`materialized` / `placeholder` / `network_unreachable` / `permission_denied` / `stale`), expanded sync-provider profiles, pre-flight probe, materialization trigger sequence. Source: 2026-04-27 brief-bank search session — 18 of 26 OneDrive Personal MTD briefs returned `errno 35` placeholder failures. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| `DOC3_R11_3_ADDENDA_A_R2_2_PROPOSAL_V2.md` detected | New file (mtime 2026-04-28 11:43, size 49,607 bytes) in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. New row A-33 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder. Header indicates "Patch A applied" per 18-item red team adjudication. Supersedes A-2 V1 (V1 file remains in active folder). Row A-2 annotated for likely supersession. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| `ELNOR_SEARCH_ARCHITECTURE_REFERENCE_R1.md` detected | New file (mtime 2026-04-28 15:27, size 23,818 bytes) in active `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. New row A-34 added with `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` placeholder, annotated for likely reclassification. **Per file header: non-normative reference document, NOT an operative spec — synthesizes search routing across DOC24 §13.2, DOC16 16.7 §C, V4 §§1.7–1.9, DOC25 §16, DOC18 R2, DOC72, DOC73 in one place for navigation.** Likely needs reclassification to `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` / `SUPPORT / AUDIT` (or new `REFERENCE / NAVIGATION` category) and possible relocation out of the addenda folder. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Counts | §11 incremented: PROPOSED ADDENDUM 30→34; §4 Active Addenda 30→34 (A1: 17→21); Grand total 90→94. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.1 deferred-detect items do not introduce new structural changes beyond what V7 already covers. Architect to confirm in next manual sweep. |
| **State files** | `SPEC_STATE.md` and `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (registered in R3.0 as rows S-3, S-4) — `ADDENDA_STATE.md` should pick up A-31/A-32/A-33/A-34 entries on next state-file regeneration. The R3.1 pass updates the master registry in turn (mtime refresh expected on `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` and any snapshot file). |
| **Dashboard** | Pending regeneration: `lastRefresh` should update to 2026-04-28; ADDENDA array should add A-31, A-32, A-33, A-34 entries; A-2 row annotated for V2 supersession; A-31 row annotated for V1.1 supersession. |

### R3.0 — 2026-04-28 (nightly sync auto-bump — second pass of the day)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. No human content judgments changed. All structural classification decisions deferred to a future human R3.1 sweep. This bump is the second R-pass of the day (R2.9 was generated 2026-04-28 03:13; R3.0 is generated later the same day to reflect new artifacts and deferred-detect items).

**Changes from R2.9:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| `SKILLS_LIVE_RECORDING_UPGRADES_V1.md` (A-12) file-moved annotation added | File found in `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` (mtime 2026-04-14 02:58, archived parent-folder mtime 2026-04-27 18:50). The R2.9 auto pass missed this move at the same time it caught the A-8 PACER move; R3.0 corrects by adding a file-moved annotation to row A-12 mirroring the A-8 pattern. Likely supersession by A-2 DOC3 R11.3 Addenda A R2.2 Proposal V1. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| OP-A version cluster (S-1) reflected | Active `Operations Docs/` no longer contains V2, V3, V3.2, or V3.3 (all moved to `Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`). Active folder contains V3.4, V3.5, V3.6 only. Row S-1 (V2) preserved with file-moved annotation; new row S-2 added with V3.6 (latest in active folder, mtime 2026-04-26 23:25) as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Three state-tracking artifacts registered | `SPEC_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:09), `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:10), `DRIFT_LOG.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:17 — NEW since R2.9). Registered as new rows S-3, S-4, S-5 with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder status. `DRIFT_LOG.md` is the only file truly new since R2.9; the other two were referenced in R2.8/R2.9 changelogs as "state file updated" but never formally registered until R3.0. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Two OP-A consolidation session reports registered | `OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-26_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-26 17:32) and `OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-27_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-27, V1 cohort). Registered as new rows S-6 and S-7 with `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` placeholder status (deferred-register from R2.8 anomaly note). |
| Counts | §11 incremented: SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 7→13; Operations Files 1→7; Grand total 84→90. Section §7 count 1→7. |
| **Carryover prompt** | No bump triggered by this pass — R3.0 deferred-detect items do not introduce new structural changes beyond what V7 already covers. Architect to confirm in next manual sweep. |
| **State files updated** | `SPEC_STATE.md` and `ADDENDA_STATE.md` are themselves now registered as state-tracking artifacts in §7 (rows S-3, S-4). The R3.0 pass updates them in turn (mtime refresh expected). `DRIFT_LOG.md` first appears in R3.0. |
| **Dashboard** | Regenerated: `lastRefresh` updated to 2026-04-28; OPERATIONS array adds S-2 through S-7 entries; A-12 row annotated for file-moved; S-1 row annotated for file-moved. |

### R2.9 — 2026-04-28 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. No human content judgments changed. All structural classification decisions deferred to a future human R2.10 sweep.

**Changes from R2.8:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| DOC23 R3.1 detected in active folder | New file `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_1.md` (mtime 2026-04-28 03:43, size 482,004 bytes) appeared in active folder. R3.0 file moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. New placeholder row 39b added to §3.J as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human re-classification (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER). Row 39 (R3.0) preserved with mark-up note pointing forward to R3.1. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| New subfolder `DOC73 Addenda and Proposals/` detected | Subfolder created 2026-04-27 22:50 in `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/`. Contains one file: `DOC73_CORPUS_SOURCE_BINDINGS_PROPOSAL_V1.md`. New §4.A5 subsection added with row A-30. Subfolder is structurally analogous to existing `DOC72 Addenda and Proposals/` but is NOT in the in-scope folder list in the nightly sync task SKILL.md — flagged as anomaly for human update. |
| Three new top-level addenda detected | `EC_CORE_ADDENDUM_A_INTAKE_ROUTING_FOR_CORPUS_BINDINGS_PROPOSAL_V1.md` (2026-04-27, row A-27), `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC_V1.1.md` (2026-04-27, row A-28), `CROSS_SPEC_ISSUES_PUNCH_LIST_V1.md` (2026-04-28, row A-29). All registered with placeholder `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` status pending human classification. |
| `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md` (A-8) file moved out of active folder | Original file moved to `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC.md`; superseded by `PACER_PLUGIN_SPEC_V1.1.md` (new row A-28). Row A-8 preserved with file-moved annotation. |
| Counts | §11 incremented: SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 6→7; PROPOSED ADDENDUM 26→30; Core registry total 45→46; Grand total 79→84. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Bumped V6 → V7 in same nightly sync run (DOC23 R3.1 + new DOC73 subfolder + 3 new top-level addenda are structural changes). |
| **State files updated** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (DOC23 R3.1 row added; DOC23 R3.0 row annotated for file-moved; mtime refreshed for Operations Docs section). `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (3 new top-level rows A-27/A-28/A-29 added; new §A.5 subsection added with row A-30; A-8 PACER row annotated for file-moved). |
| **Dashboard** | Regenerated: `lastRefresh` updated to 2026-04-28; SPECS array adds DOC23 R3.1 entry (preserves DOC23 R3.0 row with note); ADDENDA array adds A-27/A-28/A-29/A-30 entries; A-8 row annotated; workstream/in-flight descriptions reflect new arrivals. |

### R2.8 — 2026-04-27 (nightly sync auto-bump)

**Origin:** Mechanical/auto-detected bump by the autonomous nightly spec-sync job. No human content judgments changed. All structural classification decisions deferred to a future human R2.9 sweep.

**Changes from R2.7:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| DOC24 R3 detected in active folder | New file `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md` (mtime 2026-04-27 05:00, header date 2026-04-26) appeared in active folder. R2.5 file moved to `Subsumed Specs/`. New placeholder row 40b added to §3.J as `SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT` pending human re-classification (likely CURRENT OPERATIVE DRAFT / PRIMARY OWNER). Row 40 (R2.5) preserved with mark-up note pointing forward to R3. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| DOC15 R3.1 contract no longer in active folder | Per V5 carryover prompt: archived to `Subsumed Specs/DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft_ARCHIVED_2026-04-26.md` after fold-in to OP-A V3 (52 capture points, 56 obligation rows). Registry row 27 + multiple §8 reading-pack references still point at the old active-folder path; auto pass did NOT modify those (judgment fields preserved). New anomaly logged in §10. |
| OP-A version drift detected | §7 row S-1 references V2; folder now contains V2 plus V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5, V3.6. V3 series is operative per V5 carryover and `SPEC_STATE.md`. Auto pass did NOT modify §7 (judgment field preserved). New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Two new OP-A consolidation session reports detected | `OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-26_V1.md` and `OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-27_V1.md` new in `Operations Docs/`. Not yet registered. New anomaly logged in §10. |
| Counts | §11 incremented: SUPPORT / NON-OWNER DRAFT 5→6; Core registry total 44→45; Grand total 78→79. |
| **Carryover prompt** | Bumped V5 → V6 in same nightly sync run (DOC24 R3 + OP-A V3.6 are structural changes). |
| **State files updated** | `SPEC_STATE.md` (DOC24 R3 row added; DOC15 Contract note added; OP-A row split into V2 + V3.6 + session reports rows; mtime refreshed). `ADDENDA_STATE.md` (no Date drift detected; no edits). |
| **Dashboard** | Regenerated: `lastRefresh` updated; SPECS array adds DOC24 R3 entry; workstream descriptions reflect V3.6. |

### R2.7 — 2026-04-26

**Changes from R2.6:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| DOC72 updated to R5.73 | `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md` (2026-04-26) replaces the R2.6-registered `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_6.md` (which the R2.6 scan noted was absent from the active folder). R5.73 absorbs the Graph Intelligence Enhancement V2.2 (29 normalized patches NP01–NP29) into §42A. Registry entry #42 updated: filename, revision label (R5.6 → R5.73), notes. Front-door pack item 16, knowledge/capability/intelligence pack, and DOC24/DOC20/DOC23 must-read-with cross-links updated. |
| DOC25 added (NEW operative spec) | `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md` (V2.0, 2026-04-26) registered as new row 41 — Document Intelligence and Universal Ingestion Architecture. Owns universal ingestion orchestration, content-addressable storage, cross-surface deduplication, `DOC25_IngestionResult` consumer contract, runtime retrieval tools, marker scheme. Three predecessor files (`DOC25_DOC INTELLIGENCE_SPEC.md` V1.0, `DOC25_PLANNING_NOTES_V2.md`, `DOC_INTELLIGENCE_EXTRACTION_PIPELINE_PROPOSAL_R1.md`) registered as INTEGRATED in §5. New "Document intelligence / ingestion pack" reading pack added. Front-door pack item 15 added. Must-read-with cross-links propagated to DOC18, DOC20, DOC23, DOC24, DOC16 Entry 16.7. |
| DOC73 added (NEW concept draft) | `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` (V1.4.1, 2026-04-26) registered as new row 43 — Positronic Brain Enhancement (PBE) concept. **Status: CONCEPT DRAFT — NOT an operative spec.** V1.4.1 is a self-containment patch over V1.4 (V1.3 retained-content reproduced inline; no architectural changes). Front-door pack item 17 added. Knowledge/capability/intelligence and document intelligence reading packs updated. |
| OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT updated to R2 | `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` (2026-04-13) replaces the prior unversioned `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST.md`. Registry entry #38 updated: filename, revision label (R1 → R2). Gateway/model/search/ACP/channels reading pack updated to reference R2 and the active R15 amendment proposal. |
| New §4 Active Addenda section | First-time inventory of the `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/` folder (excluding `Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/`). 26 documents registered across four sub-areas: top-level addenda (14), DOC20 Addenda (4), DOC24 Addenda (5), DOC72 Addenda and Proposals (3). |
| New §5 Integrated Addenda section | First-time inventory of the `Integrated Addenda/` subfolder. 5 documents registered with their parent-spec integration status (DOC24 R2.5: 2 items; DOC25 V2.0: 3 items). |
| New §6 Cross-Document References section | First-time inventory of the `CD Cross Docs/` subfolder. 2 documents registered. `CD_MASTER_INTEGRATION_INDEX_R1.md` flagged as superseded by DOC OP-A V2. |
| New §7 Supporting Documents section | First-time inventory of `Operations Docs/`. `DOC OP-A V2 — Cross-Doc Obligation Tracker` registered as the active by-target obligations file. Front-door pack item 18 added. Cross-document delta / integration reading pack updated. |
| R2.6 anomalies — three resolved | (a) `DOC20_R4_3.md` confirmed present in active folder (R2.4–R2.6 reports were incorrect or have since been corrected). (b) `DOC72 R5_6.md` filename retired; replaced by `R5_73.md`. (c) DOC73 and the DOC25 file family registered for the first time. Three R2.4-era anomalies remain carried forward (DOC16 R5_4 file missing; DOC16 R5_3 file still present in active folder; DOC16 Entry 16.7 R2 file still present in active folder). |
| New legend entries | Three new status values added: `CONCEPT DRAFT` (DOC73), `PROPOSED ADDENDUM` (active addenda), `INTEGRATED ADDENDUM` (already-merged addenda). New owner type: `OPERATIONS`. |
| Counts updated | §11 reorganized: counts by status include new categories; counts by section added; grand totals computed. |

### R2.6 — 2026-04-10

**Changes from R2.5:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| DOC16 Entry 16.7 updated to R2.1 | `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2_1.md` found in active folder during R2.6 scan; replaces `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md`. Registry entry #31 updated. |
| Task system/automation reading pack updated | `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2 (1).md` → `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2_1.md`. |
| R2 file moved to removed section | Added to §9 "Removed in R2.6" (was §7 in R2.6) table. |
| File-system anomalies updated | Three prior anomalies carried forward; new anomaly added for the now-superseded R2 file still present in active folder. |

### R2.5 — 2026-04-10

**Changes from R2.4:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| DOC24 updated to R2.5 | `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md` replaces R2.4. R2.5 incorporates 97-item red team adjudication. |
| Front-door pack item 14 updated | Points to DOC24 R2.5 (was R2.4). |
| Reading packs updated | Task system/automation pack and knowledge/capability/intelligence pack updated. |
| DOC72 / DOC23 / DOC16 Entry 16.7 / DOC20 must-read-with updated | All reference DOC24 R2.5. |
| File-system anomalies section added | §8 added. |

### R2.4 — 2026-04-09

**Changes from R2.3:**

| Change | Detail |
|---|---|
| DOC16 updated to R5.4 | `DOC16_R5_4.md` replaces `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md`. |
| DOC20 updated to R4.3 | `DOC20_R4_3.md` (2026-04-09) replaces `DOC20_R4_2.md`. R4.3 adds §6.29 Skills & Connectors page. |
| Front-door pack item 11 updated | Points to DOC20 R4.3. |
| Reading packs updated | Q/UI/dashboard pack and task system/automation pack updated. |
| DOC15 Contract must-read-with updated | References DOC16 R5.4. |