SPEC_STATE.md

OP-A and Operations and Trackers/SPEC_STATE.md
Generated 2026-06-09T01:23:58.539Z from commit dbaa25962edc11ab30e8d4ca1715f9ae5bf77331. Worktree: clean.
Open text page · Open raw txt · Open path URL
# SPEC_STATE — Per-Spec Workflow Tracker

**Date created:** 2026-04-26
**Status:** Active operations file — update at end of every spec session
**Authoritative for:** Red-team posture, OP-A inclusion status, UI extraction status, retrofit status, QA pass status. **NOT** authoritative for spec content/version (see `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` for that).

## How to read

One row per operative spec. Master doc (R2.7) is the source of truth for filename/version/status. This file tracks **workflow state** the master doc doesn't capture.

**Red-team posture values:**
- `untouched` — no red-team rounds tracked yet
- `active` — red-team rounds in progress; more anticipated
- `saturated` — finding density per round dropped; ready to stop and integrate
- `integrated` — last round's findings absorbed; spec stable
- `not_tracked` — historical red-team work happened but wasn't logged here; treat as `untouched` going forward

**OP-A status values:**
- `not_assessed` — haven't checked whether obligations against this spec exist in OP-A
- `none` — OP-A confirmed no current obligations against this spec
- `partial` — some obligations folded; more pending
- `current` — all known obligations folded as of date

**UI extraction values:** `pending`, `in_progress`, `done` (with date), `n/a`

**Retrofit status:** `current`, `needs_retrofit`, `in_flight`, `done` (with date)

**QA pass status:** `pending`, `done` (with date)

---

## Core Specs

| ID | Current Filename | Rev | Last Modified | Spec Status | RT Rounds | Last RT | RT Posture | In OP-A | UI Extracted | Retrofit | QA Pass | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---:|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC Core | `EC_Core_Specs_Rebuild_R1.md` | R1 | 2026-03-15 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Stale: entity creation/memory extraction now in DOC72. EC Core Addendum A V3.3 is the active companion (in addenda folder). |
| Q Canonical | `Q_DASHBOARD_SPEC_v1_11_2_CANONICAL.md` | v1.11.2 | 2026-03-15 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Q Spec Gap Audit (R1) supplements this where canonical is thin. |
| Q Gap Audit | `Q_SPEC_GAP_AUDIT.md` | R1 | 2026-02-25 | Companion | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Companion to Q canonical. |
| DOC1 | `DOC1_Memory Resilience Rebuild_R1.md` | Rebuild R1 | 2026-03-10 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Storage model stale (JSONL → SQLite per DOC72). Governance logic current. CU authority disclaimed §4.12. |
| DOC2 | `DOC2 ELNOR_FRESHNESS_MANAGER_ADDENDUM_v1_11_4 copy.md` | v1.11.4 | 2026-02-24 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Oldest active spec (Feb 24). DOC72 Continuity Synthesis R1 proposal targets DOC2 retirement. |
| DOC3 | `DOC3_App_Skills_R11_2_Canonical.md` | R11.2 | 2026-03-23 | Operative | ~5 | 2026-03-23 | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | 133 adjudication items absorbed across 5 rounds (per V4 carryover). Active addenda landing against R11.3: A R2.1 (semantic skills), A R2.2 Proposal V1 (live recording). |
| DOC3 Companion | `DOC3_Companion_Doc_Delta_Plan_R9_2_Canonical.md` | R9.2 | 2026-03-23 | Companion | 0 | — | not_tracked | partial | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | **OP-A foldable — Session 2.** |
| DOC4 | `DOC4_OPENCLAW_BRIDGE_v1_11_6_2_REF_MAPPED.md` | v1.11.6.2 | 2026-02-24 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Shared owner with DOC11 for runtime seam. |
| DOC5A | `DOC5A_WILL_ACCOUNT_BUILD.md` | R1 | 2026-02-25 | Build | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | needs_retrofit | pending | Build doc for `will` macOS account. |
| DOC5B | `DOC5B_OPENCLAW1_ACCOUNT_BUILD.md` | R1 | 2026-02-25 | Build | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | needs_retrofit | pending | Build doc for `OpenClaw1` macOS account. |
| DOC6 | `DOC6_PANELS_FORUMS_SELF_IMPROVEMENT_v1_11_8_1.md` | v1.11.8.1 | 2026-03-15 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Approval-gated proposals owner. |
| DOC7 | `DOC7_Context_Buckets_Files_R7_Consolidated.md` | R7 | 2026-04-04 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | DOC72 entity graph replaces some context materialization; DOC72+DOC7 Bucket Intake addendum targets §20A.2/§20B.14. |
| DOC8 | `DOC8_SELF_LEARNING_PREDICTION_REGRESSION_FRICTION_v1_11_4.md` | v1.11.4 | 2026-02-27 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | DOC72 §36 defines feedback loop interface DOC8 must implement. Computational engine for BDSM. |
| DOC9 | `DOC9_SELF_REPAIR_PIPELINE_v1_11_9_R3_FINAL.md` | v1.11.9 R3 | 2026-02-27 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Filename has "FINAL" but registry treats as current, not permanently final. |
| DOC10 | `DOC10_Unified_Engagement_Orchestration_R11_Consolidated.md` | R11 | 2026-03-15 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Knowledge intake → DOC72; routing/delivery → DOC24. Per V2 carryover, DOC10 slated for significant revision before its trackers consolidate. |
| DOC10 Ledger | `DOC10_Orchestration_Integration_Ledger_R10_Consolidated.md` | R10 | 2026-03-10 | Companion | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | OP-A V2 explicitly supersedes the by-target obligations role. **NOT foldable in this OP-A pass** per V2 carryover §1A. |
| DOC10 RT Matrix | `DOC10_R10_R8_RED_TEAM_INCORPORATION_MATRIX.md` | R1 | 2026-03-03 | Support | 1 | 2026-03-03 | not_tracked | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Preservation matrix; not owner truth. Only confirmed red-team artifact in active folder. |
| DOC11 | `DOC11_OPENCLAW_GATEWAY_MODEL_CONTROLS_AND_EC_INTEGRATION_R14.md` | R14 | 2026-03-26 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | R15 amendment proposal in addenda. R14 is "inline-compiled full-closure revision." |
| DOC12 | `DOC12_INTER_AGENT_COMMUNICATION_R7_1.md` | R7.1 | 2026-03-12 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Single-file consolidation of R6+R7+R7.1. |
| DOC12 Appendix | `DOC12_IMPLEMENTATION_APPENDIX_R1.md` | R1 | 2026-03-02 | Support | 0 | — | not_tracked | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Code-facing wiring; not owner. |
| DOC13 | `DOC13_Costs_R1.md` | R1 | 2026-03-15 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Cost tracking, budget enforcement, dynamic token controls. |
| DOC14 | `DOC14_ELNOR_CANDOR_Integration_Architecture_R7.md` | R7 | 2026-03-30 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | R7 is full reconstruction from R5.2 baseline + R6/R6.1 improvements. Needs human review for cross-doc seam updates. |
| DOC14 Cross-Doc | `DOC14_CROSS_DOCUMENT_DELTA_COMPANION_R2.md` | R2 | 2026-03-30 | Companion | 0 | — | not_tracked | partial | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | **OP-A foldable — Session 2.** |
| DOC15 | `DOC15_Cognitive_Infrastructure_Layer_R7_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` | R7.1 | 2026-03-13 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Needs DOC24 delivery integration. |
| DOC15 Contract | `DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft.md` | R3.1 | 2026-03-13 | Companion | 0 | — | not_tracked | partial | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | **FILE MOVED OUT OF ACTIVE FOLDER (auto-detected 2026-04-27 by nightly sync):** archived to `Subsumed Specs/DOC15_Cross_Document_Integration_Contract_R3_1_Consolidated_Current_Draft_ARCHIVED_2026-04-26.md` per V5 carryover note. All 52 capture points folded into OP-A V3 (2026-04-26). Row preserved for traceability. **Master spec list R2.7 row 27 + multiple reading packs in §8 still reference this file path — registry needs updating in next sweep.** |
| DOC15 Audit | `DOC15_Addendum_A_Audit_Synthesis_v1.3.md` | v1.3 | 2026-03-05 | Companion | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | CIL audit synthesis, migration map. |
| DOC15 Build | `DOC15_Build_Manifest_v1.1 (1).md` | v1.1 | 2026-03-05 | Build | 0 | — | not_tracked | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Build sequencing for CIL. |
| DOC16 R5.4 | `DOC16_R5_4.md` | R5.4 | 2026-04-09 | Future | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | **CARRIED ANOMALY UPDATE (auto-detected 2026-04-30 by nightly sync):** Original anomaly was "R5.4 file not present" but file IS present in active folder (mtime 2026-04-09 22:47, size 245,927 bytes; hardlink count 2). Companion R5.3 file `DOC16_Deferred_Additions_R5_3_COMPLETE_AND_CLEANED.md` no longer in active folder (moved to `Subsumed Specs/`). The DOC16 R5.3 row and DOC16 16.7 R2 row have been REMOVED from this state file per task spec (files moved to Subsumed). Anomaly likely already resolved; prior syncs may have had stale anomaly tracking. Human reclassification of R5.4 status needed. |
| DOC16 16.7 | `DOC16_ENTRY_16_7_M365_DEEP_INTEGRATION_R2_1.md` | R2.1 | 2026-04-10 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | current | pending | Updated R2.7 with DOC25 V2.0 link. |
| DOC17 | `DOC17_R4_2_OVERLAY_LIBRARY_PROMPT_ADVISOR_PROMPT_RECIPES_AND_PROMPT_LAB.md` | R4.2 | 2026-03-10 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Overlay/prompt-advisor owner. |
| DOC18 | `DOC18_LlamaIndex_Retrieval_Sidecar_R2.md` | R2 | 2026-03-10 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Sidecar retrieval — NOT canonical memory. |
| DOC19 | `DOC19_ORIG_SPEC_FILLS_AND_FIXES.md` | R1 | 2026-03-15 | Support | 0 | — | not_tracked | n/a | pending | n/a | n/a | Spec gap-fills patch doc. |
| DOC20 | `DOC20_R4_3.md` | R4.3 | 2026-04-09 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | current | pending | Largest spec (~4,400 lines). Updated R2.7 with DOC25 V2.0 link. |
| DOC21 | `DOC21 (UI) Q_DASHBOARD_MASTER_UI_SPECIFICATION_R7.md` | R7 | 2026-03-20 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a (target of E) | needs_retrofit | pending | Master UI spec. R7 aligns surfaces to DOC11 R14. **Will receive output of Workstream E (UI extraction).** |
| DOC22 | `DOC22 (UI) Q_UI_PAGE_INVENTORY_AND_DESIGN_TEMPLATE_R4.md` | R4 | 2026-03-20 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a (target of E) | needs_retrofit | pending | Page inventory + design template. R4 aligns Settings/Status to DOC11 R14. **Will receive output of Workstream E.** |
| DOC23 | `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_0.md` | R3.0 | 2026-04-03 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | partial | pending | current | pending | **R3.0 file moved to `Subsumed Specs/` on 2026-04-28 (auto-detected by nightly sync); superseded by R3.1 below.** Row preserved for historical traceability. "Frozen Implementation Baseline." 36 module types. **Build-relevant: DOC23 mockup `Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V10_9.jsx` (2026-03-30) pending integration into Electron app.** |
| DOC23 R3.1 | `DOC23_TASK_SYSTEM_MODULAR_ARCHITECTURE_R3_1.md` | R3.1 | 2026-04-28 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Auto-detected 2026-04-28 by nightly sync; needs human classification. R3.1 file appeared in active folder 2026-04-28 03:43 (size 482,004 bytes). |
| DOC24 | `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R2_5.md` | R2.5 | 2026-04-10 | Operative | 1+ | 2026-04-10 | active | partial | pending | current | pending | **R2.5 file moved to `Subsumed Specs/` on 2026-04-27 (auto-detected by nightly sync); superseded by R3 below.** Row preserved for historical traceability. 97 adjudication items already processed. Active addenda landing: BDSM V6.4, KDA R2, Q Tool Registry, Persistent Onboarding Curiosity, Unified Context Budget Governance. |
| DOC24 R3 | `DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md` | R3 | 2026-04-27 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Auto-detected 2026-04-27 by nightly sync; needs human classification. R3 file appeared in active folder 2026-04-27 (header dated 2026-04-26). Per file header: incorporates accepted items from R2.5 Red Team Adjudication Card V3 (125 cards, 87 ACCEPT, 25 ACCEPT_MOD, 11 REJECT, 2 cross-references); adds new §38 Runtime Lifecycle, Assembly Contract, and Session Continuity; modifies §§5, 9, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 29, 36; cross-doc obligations tracked in DOC OP-A V3.1+. |
| DOC25 | `DOC25_V2_0_DOC INTELLIGENCE.md` | V2.0 | 2026-04-26 | Operative | 0 | — | active | not_assessed | pending | current | pending | **NEW in R2.7.** Promoted from V1.0. Owns `DOC25_IngestionResult` (DOC73 §15.2 must remain field-for-field identical until DOC73 V1.5). |
| DOC72 | `DOC72_HYPER_INTELLIGENCE_OVERLAY_R5_73.md` | R5.73 | 2026-04-26 | Operative | 5+ | 2026-04-26 | saturated | not_assessed | pending | current | pending | R5.73 absorbs GIE V2.2 §42A (29 patches NP01-NP29 from 5-reviewer red-team: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Codex). |
| DOC73 | `DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md` | V1.4.1 | 2026-04-26 | Operative | 1+ | 2026-04-26 | active | not_assessed | pending | current | pending | **FILE MOVED OUT OF ACTIVE FOLDER (auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync):** archived to `Subsumed Specs/DOC73_V1_4_1_FINAL.md`; superseded by V1.5.1 (new row below). Row preserved for traceability. Was operative per architect (2026-04-26). §15.2 inlines DOC25 IngestionResult; must stay in sync with DOC25 V2.0 §17 until V1.5. |
| DOC73 V1.5.1 | `DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/DOC73_V1_5_1_FINAL.md` | V1.5.1 | 2026-04-29 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | **FILE RELOCATED OUT OF ACTIVE ROOT (auto-detected 2026-05-04 by nightly sync):** moved from `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/` root → new subfolder `CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS/DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE/` (subfolder mtime 2026-05-04 08:05). Subfolder is OUT OF SCOPE per nightly sync task SKILL.md (only active root + Addenda Proposals & In Progress + Operations Docs are crawled), so V1.5.1 + 5 DOC73_Artifact_R0.x files + 3 V1.6 build artifacts inside are not auto-tracked. This is a structurally significant relocation: V1.6 release wave is now organized as a working subfolder in active root rather than at active root level — analogous to the `DOC73 R1.6 Build/` working folder at workspace root, but inside the active spec folder. Row preserved for traceability. **Human reclassification needed** — per the subfolder name "DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE" Will may be promoting V1.6 R1.0 to operative status; but V1.5.1 file itself appears retained inside that subfolder rather than archived. Auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync; size 663,684 bytes; companion DOC73 Corpus Source Bindings Proposal V1 (A-30) likely needs re-targeting. |
| OPA V3.8 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_8.md` | V3.8 | 2026-05-04 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-04 by nightly sync):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-04 07:59 (size 404,864 bytes; 4,507 lines). Per file header: "OP-A V3.8 — DOC73 V1.6 Adjudication Card V4 fold-in (V1.6 release wave candidate rows from V4 §0.3.3 + §0.3.4 + §0.3.6 + inline `[V4 PATCH:...]` markers); date V3.8 produced 2026-05-02; folder: `ECQ Development/DOC73 R1.6 Build/` (working folder for V1.6 wave); to be promoted to `Current Specs/Operations Docs/` once V1.6 wave settles." File is byte-identical to `DOC73 R1.6 Build/OPA_V3_8.md` (different inodes, same content; the active-root copy was likely copied or re-saved 2026-05-04 07:59). **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY:** OP-A trackers normally live in `Operations Docs/`; this file's official location per its own header is `DOC73 R1.6 Build/`. The active-root copy is unusual — possibly Will copying for visibility, or the start of promotion to Operations Docs/. Supersedes OP-A V3.7 (still in Operations Docs/). Human classification + path canonicalization needed. |
| DOC24 R3.1.1 | `DOC24_R3_1_1.md` | R3.1.1 | 2026-05-17 | Operative | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | pending | needs_retrofit | pending | Auto-detected 2026-05-17 by nightly sync; needs human classification. R3.1.1 file appeared in active root 2026-05-17 03:58 local = 10:58 UTC (size 292,034 bytes). Per R3.1.1 file header: "Status Consolidated (§0 through §38 + Appendices A–D; 7 audit-identified gaps closed per audit report 2026-05-17; ready for fresh-window reviewer prompts); Lineage R3 + V1 (136 adjudication cards) + V1.1 + V1.2 + V1.3 + V1.4 + R3.1 audit closure." Seven gaps closed (all pure-add patches from V1.x canonical sources, no directional changes): HH.4.10 applyMatrixConfidenceAdjustmentSafe body added to §13.4B.2; HH.12 ExtractionPromptSectionId A–I enum + LongChunkMitigation as new §38.19; HH.15.8 token-count write-time rule + TokenizerDriftCheckPolicy/TokenizerDriftObservation; Y.14 WatchpointRef discriminated union as §5.4.1.Z; Y.15 ObservedActionRef as §5.4.1.AA; Y.23 SessionInjectionManifest as §5.4.1.BB with reconciliation_event per HH.3 event model; II.4.2 walkPacketDecisionGraph paste-ready body added to §38.10.1. Predecessor R3.1 (DOC24_R3_1_CONSOLIDATED.md) MOVED TO `Subsumed Specs/` in same 03:58 window — atomic supersession-and-archive. R3.1.1 supersedes R3.1; relationship to R3 (DOC24_UNIFIED_KNOWLEDGE_CAPABILITY_ONBOARDING_ARCHITECTURE_R3.md) pending human classification (likely supersedes — V1.x adjudication closure landing pattern). |
| OPA V3.9 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_9.md` | V3.9 | 2026-05-17 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-17 by nightly sync):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-17 07:15 local = 14:15 UTC (size 438,146 bytes). Per file header: "OP-A V3.9 — Generated by V3.9 patch session per V4 §0.3 (DOC24 R3.1.1 V1.x adjudication closure landing); folder: `ECQ Development/DOC73 R1.6 Build/` (working folder for V1.6 wave); to be promoted to `Current Specs/Operations Docs/` once V1.6 wave settles." Header version field still shows "V3.8" — likely transient (filename and explicit title are V3.9). Successor to OPA V3.8 (also still in active root + DOC73 R1.6 Build/). **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY:** OP-A trackers normally live in `Operations Docs/`; this file's official location per its own header is `DOC73 R1.6 Build/`. Active-root copy unusual — same pattern as V3.8 from R3.18 sync. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. |
| OPA V3.11 (NEW) | `Operations Docs/OPA_V3_11.md` | V3.11 | 2026-05-17 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-18 by nightly sync R3.50):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in `Operations Docs/` 2026-05-17 23:45 (size 509,424 bytes; +71,278 bytes over V3.9). FIRST OPA version since V3.7 to live in proper `Operations Docs/` location, ending V3.8/V3.9 active-root placement-irregularity pattern. Likely incorporates DOC24 R3.1.1 follow-on adjudication closure rows + DOC23 Addenda B family-topology absorption rows (R3.49 substantive bump). Implicit OPA V3.10 transit observed (V3.10 now in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` — appeared and was archived between R3.49 and R3.50; never given an active-tracker row, brief-extant pattern). Successor to OPA V3.9 (still in active root) and the transit OPA V3.10 (now archived). Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. Human classification needed. |
| OPA V3.12 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_12.md` | V3.12 | 2026-05-18 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-18 by nightly sync R3.50):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-18 07:05 (size 527,486 bytes; +18,062 bytes over V3.11). Reverts to placement-irregular active-root pattern after V3.11's brief return-to-proper-location. Successor to V3.11. **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY** continues: OP-A trackers normally live in `Operations Docs/`; V3.11 was the lone correctly-placed copy of the V3.8 → V3.9 → V3.10 (transit archive) → V3.11 → V3.12 sequence. Placement-pattern alternation may suggest Will-side workflow tension between "tidy archival in Operations Docs/" vs "visibility-priority active-root copy." Human classification + path canonicalization needed. |
| OPA V3.13 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_13.md` | V3.13 | 2026-05-18 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-18 by nightly sync R3.52; backfilled to SPEC_STATE in R3.53 on 2026-05-19 since R3.51/R3.52 syncs did not update SPEC_STATE):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-18 10:42 local (size 537,383 bytes; +9,897 bytes over V3.12). Continues placement-irregular active-root pattern (no return to proper `Operations Docs/` location after V3.11's brief correction). Successor to V3.12. **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY backlog now extends to 5 instances** (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 implicit transit + V3.12 + V3.13) with V3.11 the lone correctly-placed copy. Placement-pattern-alternation theory (R3.50) downgraded — V3.13 is the third consecutive placement-irregular file in the V3.12/V3.13 sequence, suggesting Will-side workflow preference for active-root visibility is dominating. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. |
| OPA V3.15 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_15.md` | V3.15 | 2026-05-19 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-19 by nightly sync R3.53):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-19 05:36 local (size 675,447 bytes; +138,064 bytes over V3.13 — substantial growth ~25%). **V3.14 skipped** — no V3.14 file observed in active folders or in `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`; likely briefly-extant (created and renamed/archived within the sync window) per the established pattern observed for OPA V3.10 transit (R3.50) and DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V3/V4/V5 briefly-extant (R3.50 narrative). Successor to V3.13. **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY** continues — V3.15 is the sixth instance of active-root placement (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 transit + V3.12 + V3.13 + V3.15) versus V3.11's lone correct-placement; placement-pattern preference for active-root visibility now strongly evidenced. Size jump from V3.13 (537,383) → V3.15 (675,447) = +25.7% — likely incorporates further DOC24 R3.1.1 follow-on adjudication closure rows + DOC23 Addenda B family-topology absorption rows + R3.51/R3.52 detection-window content. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. **Superseded by V3.16 row below per R3.55 MSL narrative (file remains in active root pending human archival decision; backfilled to SPEC_STATE in R3.56 on 2026-05-20).** |
| OPA V3.16 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_16.md` | V3.16 | 2026-05-19 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-19 by master spec list R3.55 nightly sync auto-bump 2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC; backfilled to SPEC_STATE in R3.56 on 2026-05-20 since R3.55 did not update SPEC_STATE.md):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-19 17:17 local (size 719,051 bytes; +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15). Successor to V3.15. **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY** extends to seventh instance of active-root placement (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 transit + V3.12 + V3.13 + V3.15 + V3.16) versus V3.11's lone correct-placement; placement-pattern preference for active-root visibility now decisively dominant. Size jump from V3.15 (675,447) → V3.16 (719,051) = +6.5% — moderate growth likely incorporates further follow-on adjudication closure rows from DOC24 family redrafting cluster (BDSM V6.5 DRAFT + KDA R3 DRAFT) + DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 cross-references + R3.54 detection-window content. Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. **Superseded by V3.17 + V3.18 rows below per R3.59 nightly sync (both files in active root; pending human archival decision).** |
| OPA V3.17 (NEW) | `OPA_V3_17.md` | V3.17 | 2026-05-21 | Support / Operations | 0 | — | not_tracked | not_assessed | n/a | n/a | n/a | **NEW (auto-detected 2026-05-21 by nightly sync R3.59):** placeholder row pending human classification. File appeared in active CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root 2026-05-21 01:30 local (size 760,219 bytes; +41,168 bytes / +5.7% over V3.16). Successor to V3.16. **PLACEMENT IRREGULARITY** extends to eighth instance of active-root placement (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 transit + V3.12 + V3.13 + V3.15 + V3.16 + V3.17) versus V3.11's lone correct-placement; placement-pattern preference for active-root visibility now stable. Moderate +5.7% size growth likely incorporates follow-on adjudication closure rows from DOC24 v0.3 family redrafting cluster (BDSM V6.5 v0.3 + KDA R3 v0.3) + Unified Workspace R0.3 cross-references + R3.58 detection-window content. Same-day-window successor V3.18 created ~17 minutes later (01:47). Full file-header inspection deferred to next manual review pass. Human classification + path canonicalization needed. |
| OP-A V4 | `OPA_V4.md` | V4 | 2026-05-28 | Operative | 521 §6 active + 17 §8 deferred = 538 total OBL rows | Stage 5R3 Pass 2 retarget over V3.18 onto post-flatten DOC80 family | tracked | adopted | n/a | n/a | n/a | **OPERATIVE as of 2026-05-28 Stage 5R3 Pass 2 ratification.** Published from `Memory Rebuild Docs/Flattening/Execution Ledger/Stage_5R3/OPA_V4_CANDIDATE.md` after architect ratification of 13 Pass 1 decisions + ADQ-PASS2-01 (PBE cluster → DOC73) + ADQ-PASS2-02 (corpus/library identity → DOC87). 117 rows now own a DOC80-family target (DOC81–DOC87); remainder kept their original owner. D10 dup merge applied; 7 ADD rows minted (6 DOC24 R3.1.1 + 1 DOC25 degraded); 3 Bucket B splits → 7 child rows. V3.18 archived. Next OPA patch round will reorganize §6 by V4 owner (Bucket C resolutions currently live in their original sections with updated owner cells). |
| OP-A V3.18 | `Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/OPA_V3_18.md` | V3.18 | 2026-05-21 | Archived | — | Superseded by OP-A V4 at 2026-05-28 Stage 5R3 Pass 2 ratification | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | Archived 2026-05-28 to `Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`. Was the input to Stage 5R3 Pass 2 retarget. |

## Cross-Cutting / Support

| ID | Current Filename | Rev | Last Modified | Spec Status | RT Posture | Retrofit | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Running Brief | `Subsumed Specs/RUNNING_BRIEF_REMEDIATION_v6_ARCHIVED_2026-04-26.md` | v6.0 | 2026-04-27 | **ARCHIVED 2026-04-27** | n/a | **archived** | **ARCHIVED.** RRB v6 audit-and-decompose pass complete. Unique content folded into OP-A V3.4 (V3.3 corrected) as 26 OBL rows distributed across DOC24 (6), DOC15 (3), DOC11 (2), EC Core (4), DOC10 (1), DOC8 (3), DOC12 (2), DOC2 NEW §6.2A (1), DOC20 (4). Master spec list R2.7 row 36 needs registry update to mark as ARCHIVED in next R2.8 sweep. Two pending DISPOSITION DECISIONS flagged in OP-A §9: Running Brief slot keep-or-deprecate (OBL-D24-RRB-04); OCM agent keep-or-absorb-into-CIL-or-deprecate (OBL-D15-RRB-03). |
| OpenClaw Preservation | `OPENCLAW_PRESERVATION_AND_INTEGRATION_CHECKLIST_R1.md` | R1 | 2026-03-03 | Support | not_tracked | needs_retrofit | Guardrail; not owner truth. Likely needs alignment with current OpenClaw release context (v2026.4.23). |
| OpenClaw Release Align | `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md` | R2 | 2026-04-13 (mtime preserved across move) | Support | not_tracked | current | **FILE MOVED OUT OF ACTIVE FOLDER (auto-detected 2026-05-19 by nightly sync R3.53):** moved from CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root → `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` intra-subfolder archive. Move performed today between R3.52 alias write (2026-05-18 23:08) and R3.53 sync window. Companion file `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 ADD REVIEW.md` also moved to the same intra-archive. Superseded by R3 successor `OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3.md` (new addendum row in ADDENDA_STATE.md §A.1 today). Row preserved for traceability. **First time** the `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/` subfolder has its own dedicated `Archived/` intra-subfolder archive — pattern analogous to `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` created on 2026-05-17. Was companion to active DOC11 R15 amendment proposal; up to date through OpenClaw v2026.4.12 at R2. |

## Operations / Trackers

| ID | Filename | Rev | Last Modified | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OP-A V2 | `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V2.md` | V2 | 2026-04-26 | Archived | **FILE MOVED OUT OF ACTIVE OPERATIONS DOCS FOLDER (auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync):** moved to `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/`. Was authoritative by-target obligations tracker through 2026-04-26; superseded by V3 series 2026-04-27. Row preserved for traceability. |
| OP-A V3.6 | `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_6.md` | V3.6 | 2026-04-27 | Archived | **FILE MOVED OUT OF ACTIVE OPERATIONS DOCS FOLDER (auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync):** moved to `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/` along with V3, V3.2, V3.3, V3.4, V3.5. Was active V3.x latest through 2026-04-27; superseded by V3.7 (2026-04-29). Row preserved for traceability. V3.6 header: "architecture clarification — agent-vs-capability registry split; capability-registered flag on agent rows." |
| OP-A V3.7 | `Operations Docs/DOC_OP_A_CROSS_DOC_OBLIGATION_TRACKER_V3_7.md` | V3.7 | 2026-04-29 | Active | Auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync; needs human classification. New active OP-A version. V3.7 file appeared 2026-04-29 05:15 (size 244,079 bytes; ~71 KB larger than V3.6's 172,961 bytes). Companion patch document `OP_A_V3_6_TO_V3_7_PATCH_V1.md` (mtime 2026-04-29 04:58, 83,154 bytes) sits in archive subfolder. V3.7 may incorporate DOC73 V1.5.1 obligations and/or further consolidation; full content delta from V3.6 not captured by auto pass — Will to annotate or red-team. |
| Master Spec List | `MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST.md` | R3.62 | 2026-05-24 | Active | Source of truth for what specs exist + their official status. **R3.62 (2026-05-24 ~23:54 UTC) TWO-DAY-GAP-CATCHUP bump** — backfills R3.61 substantive structural-drift that skipped housekeeping (R3.61 was bumped 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local capturing 2 NEW DAMS files (V4 + V4.1) + RECONCILIATION PASS adding A-80 BDSM v0.3.1 / A-81 KDA v0.3.1 / A-82 DAMS V3 / A-83 DAMS V3 (1) / A-84 DAMS V4 / A-85 DAMS V4.1 — but never updated SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard / carryover on its own window; same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping anomaly family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41/R3.49/R3.51/R3.54/R3.55/R3.57/R3.60 — SIXTEENTH observed instance, FIRST observed instance where the anomaly involves a SUBSTANTIVE rather than ALIAS-ONLY bump). Plus 2026-05-23 had ZERO sync firing observed (DRIFT_LOG silent for one calendar day — first observed silent-day in this scheduled-task run history; likely missed-firing rather than zero-drift run-marker since no run-marker entry was appended). Today's R3.62 catchup also captures post-R3.61 in-scope archival events: DAMS V1 + V2 + V3 + V3 (1) + V4 all MOVED from `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/` → `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Archived Addenda Proposals and In Progress/` between R3.61 alias write 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local and today; DAMS V4.1 (sole remaining active file in §A8) modified 2026-05-22 04:27 local (post-R3.61 content edit). DOC 80 DAMS subfolder now contains only V4.1 + .DS_Store. R3.61 versioned file moved → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.61.md` by today's R3.62 audit-cleanup pass; active folder retains R3.62 alias + R3.62 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant intact). **In-scope filesystem scan since R3.61 alias write 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local:** `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.61.md` returned 7 hits — 0 in-scope NEW spec files + 6 `Operations Docs/` ledgers (ADDENDA_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md, OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md, RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md, BACKUP_LOG.md — operations-state, not spec content) + 1 sub-sub-folder DOC23 ADDB cleanup patch pack (out-of-scope per SKILL.md scope-list — DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework still NOT formally listed). Carryover bumped V22 → V23 today capturing R3.61 substantive structural drift (DAMS V4 + V4.1 + reconciliation rows) + DAMS subfolder reorganization (5 files moved to global addenda archive). SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-EIGHT cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.62) — today's R3.61-substantive-bump-skipped-housekeeping is the strongest evidence yet for the early-exit guard item being inverted (R3.61 was a SUBSTANTIVE bump that skipped housekeeping — exactly the opposite failure mode the guard would catch; today's catchup reinforces item #5 post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files since `stat`-checking SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md / dashboard.html after R3.61's narrative-claim writes would have caught the skipped-housekeeping divergence at write time, plus the new pattern of substantive-bumps-skipping-housekeeping warrants its own SKILL.md item separating it from the alias-only pattern). Counts post-reconciliation per R3.61 authoritative table: §3 Core Specs = 56; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 11; §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 6 (per R3.61 reconciled counts at narration-write time; post-R3.62 archival of V1-V4 leaves §A8 effective count = 1 with 5 rows preserved-for-traceability per auto-pass no-removal policy for addenda moved to global archive); §4 Active Addenda = 86 (per R3.61); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 87 (per R3.61); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 159 (per R3.61). **R3.60 ALIAS-ONLY firing on 2026-05-21 ~23:11 UTC (~13h post-R3.59 ~10:14 UTC sync): zero new spec files detected since R3.59 alias write; alias-only operations-state-only firing per SKILL.md Step 5 canonical path (mirrors prior R3.57 + R3.54 firing patterns). R3.60 did NOT update SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard / carryover on its own window — same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping anomaly family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.18/R3.19/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.41/R3.49/R3.51/R3.54/R3.55/R3.57. R3.59 versioned file moved → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.59.md` by R3.60 audit-cleanup pass; active folder retains R3.60 alias + R3.60 versioned snapshot only (at-most-one-versioned-file invariant intact). **Today's 2026-05-22 R3.60-backfill sync window** (zero filesystem drift since R3.60 alias write; `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.60.md` returned ZERO hits across all in-scope folders) mechanically advances this Rev field R3.59 → R3.60, refreshes Spec State + Addenda State row Last Modified 2026-05-21 → 2026-05-22, refreshes dashboard `lastRefresh` span text. Per SKILL.md Step 5 "If no drift and exactly 1 versioned file exists: skip Steps 5.1-5.3; only run Step 5.4 sanity check" — no MSL bump today. Per SKILL.md Step 6 "If no structural changes: do NOT bump the carryover" — carryover remains at V22. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-six cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.60-backfill). Counts all unchanged from R3.59 (§3 Core Specs = 56; §A3 DOC24 Addenda = 10; §A8 DOC 80 DAMS = 4; §4 Active Addenda = 83; §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM = 84; §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER = 28; §11 Grand total = 156). DOC 80 DAMS subfolder still eighth not-formally-listed subfolder. Tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md and master spec list §4 stable at tenth+ NEW-row cycle. Prior R3.59 narrative preserved: SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump capturing 5 NEW files since R3.58 alias write 2026-05-20 23:15 local: (1) `OPA_V3_17.md` mtime 2026-05-21 01:30 local, size 760,219 bytes — active-root placement-irregular OPA successor, +5.7% over V3.16, eighth active-root placement instance; (2) `OPA_V3_18.md` mtime 2026-05-21 01:47 local, size 767,081 bytes — same-day intra-window OPA successor to V3.17 (~17min apart), first ever same-day intra-window successor pair in OPA chain (tighter than DAMS V1→V2 ~2h pair from R3.58); ninth placement-irregular active-root instance; +0.9% over V3.17 suggests minor corrective patch; (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_3_1.md` mtime 2026-05-20 23:15 local — DOC24 Addenda subfolder; `_DRAFT_v0_3_1` filename suffix indicates iterative-patch over v0.3 (A-75 in MSL §A3); first ever fourth-decimal-place patch suffix in BDSM chain (v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/v0.3.1 series before v1.0 FINAL); (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL.md` mtime 2026-05-21 05:56 local, size 78,062 bytes — DOC 80 DAMS subfolder (eighth not-formally-listed subfolder in SKILL.md scope backlog; informally tracked via R3.58 precedent); V3 consolidated successor to DAMS V1+V2 (A-78/A-79 in MSL §A8); -3,210 bytes (-4%) under V2 suggests consolidation tightening; (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC 80 DAMS/DAMS_V3_CONSOLIDATED_ARCHITECTURE_PROPOSAL (1).md` mtime 2026-05-21 05:59 local, size 94,239 bytes — same-DAMS-V3 (1)-suffix duplicate variant (~3min after primary V3); first ever same-day intra-folder V3 duplicate pair in DOC 80 DAMS subfolder; +16,177 bytes (+20.7%) over primary V3 file — duplicate is LARGER than primary, which is unusual ((1)-suffix pattern in prior observations was typically Will-copied-from-other-location duplicate matching primary). Possible workflow signal: variant carrying additional content vs primary subset, or vice-versa (full file-header comparison deferred to next manual review pass). **Architecturally significant developments today:** (a) First ever same-day intra-window V3.17 → V3.18 successor pair in OPA chain (~17min apart) — tighter cadence than R3.58's DAMS V1→V2 ~2h pair; (b) First ever fourth-decimal-place patch suffix `_v0_3_1` in BDSM chain — extends v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL series pattern with intra-version patch granularity; (c) First ever same-day DAMS-V3 primary + (1)-duplicate pair where duplicate exceeds primary in size — workflow-signal mystery pending human classification; (d) `DOC 80 DAMS` subfolder now has 4 files (V1 + V2 + V3 + V3 (1)) — first not-formally-listed subfolder to accumulate 4 files in single MSL bump-cycle since formation. **Counts updates in R3.59:** §A3 DOC24 Addenda 9 → 10 (+1 for BDSM v0.3.1); §A8 DOC 80 DAMS 2 → 4 (+2 for V3 + V3 (1)); §3 Core Specs 54 → 56 (+2 for OPA V3.17 + V3.18); §4 Active Addenda 80 → 83 (+3); §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 81 → 84 (+3); §11 SUPPORT/NON-OWNER 26 → 28 (+2); Grand total 151 → 156 (+5). **R3.57 + R3.58 narrative folded into Notes since both R3.57 (alias-only 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local) and R3.58 (substantive structural-drift 2026-05-20 ~17:13 local capturing 5 NEW files: Unified Workspace R0.3 + DAMS V1 + DAMS V2 + BDSM v0.3 + KDA R3 v0.3) did not update SPEC_STATE on their own windows.** Audit-cleanup pass moves R3.58 versioned file → `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/` per standard bump procedure; R3.59 versioned snapshot saved alongside this alias write. Active folder retains R3.59 alias + R3.59 versioned snapshot only — at-most-one-versioned-file invariant preserved. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-four cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.59). Tracker numbering divergence between MSL §4 and ADDENDA_STATE extends to ninth+ NEW-row cycle pending ADDENDA_STATE backfill. **R3.56 bumped on 2026-05-20 nightly sync — STATE-FILES-CATCHUP bump for R3.54 (alias-only firing 2026-05-19 ~11:09 UTC) + R3.55 (substantive structural-drift firing 2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC capturing 5 NEW files: OPA V3.16 + ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED + DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_2 + DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2 + DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1). R3.55 had captured the 5 NEW files in MSL §3/§4 but failed to update SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard / carryover; the R3.55 §12 changelog narrative claimed "Carryover prompt bumped V20 → V21" but NO V21 FILE EXISTS in `Prompts/` (V20 dated 2026-05-19 10:23 is still the latest V2x file). R3.56 today materializes the carryover V21 bump + backfills SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard. **Files detected in zero-drift scan since R3.55 alias write 2026-05-19 23:17 UTC:** NONE. **Backfill rows added to SPEC_STATE §3 Core Specs:** OPA V3.16 (active-root placement-irregular, +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15, seventh active-root placement instance). **Backfill rows added to ADDENDA_STATE §A.1/§A.3/§A.6:** A-70 V5.2 AUDITED in §A.1 (top-level natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-66 V5.1 + filename-canonicalization successor chain; +34,080 bytes / +55.7% growth over V5.1 consistent with audit-driven red-team incorporation pattern; first observed `_AUDITED` suffix in any subagent chain); A-71 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 in §A.3 (natural-progression successor to A-22 V6.4 operative; `_DRAFT_v0_2` filename suffix indicates working-draft variant); A-72 KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 in §A.3 (natural-progression successor to A-19 R2 via filename canonicalization long-form → short-form pattern); A-74 DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1 in §A.6 (NEW cross-cutting reference map; no prior version; likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP / NON-OWNER DRAFT analogous to A-49 + A-32). **R3.55 + R3.56 numbering divergence carry-forward:** MSL §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74 for these four addenda; ADDENDA_STATE uses A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74 (skipping A-73 to preserve historical row-bound pattern) — cumulative divergence-by-one pattern continues across EIGHT+ NEW-row cycles. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-one cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.56). **Architecturally significant developments captured today via R3.55 backfill:** (1) Two intra-day DOC24 successor drafts within ~2h window (BDSM V6.5 + KDA R3) — first multi-DOC24-draft drift in single MSL bump (R3.55); suggests coordinated DOC24 family redrafting pass possibly triggered by DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1 introduction earlier same day. (2) `_AUDITED` filename suffix pattern emerges — first observation; likely Will-side workflow signal that V5.1 → V5.2 is post-red-team-incorporation. (3) `_DRAFT_v0_2` working-draft-variant suffix pattern emerges — likely first of v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL series before A-22/A-19 supersession. (4) Filename canonicalization continues with KDA R2 long-form → KDA R3 short-form (third instance after ELNOR_SUBAGENT V4 → V5.1 in R3.53 + DOC23 ADDB V2 → V3 in R3.44). (5) OPA V3.16 makes placement-irregularity 7-of-8 (V3.11 lone correctly-placed). (6) DOC23 FAMILY map is first cross-cutting DOC23 family coherence map — multi-addendum reference document spanning Addenda A R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1.1. **R3.53 bumped on 2026-05-19 nightly sync — SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump capturing 5 NEW files since R3.52 alias write 2026-05-18 23:08 UTC: (1) `OPA_V3_15.md` mtime 2026-05-19 05:36 local, size 675,447 bytes — placement-irregular active-root OPA successor; +138,064 bytes (+25.7%) over V3.13 from R3.52; V3.14 skipped (briefly-extant pattern, no file observed); placement-irregularity backlog extends to 6 instances (V3.8 + V3.9 + V3.10 transit + V3.12 + V3.13 + V3.15) with V3.11 lone correctly-placed; (2) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1.md` mtime 2026-05-18 23:55, size 61,138 bytes — top-level addendum successor to A-5 `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4.md`; filename canonicalization V4 "PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES" → V5.1 "ARCHITECTURE" (analogous to V2 → V3 OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION → OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR canonicalization pattern in DOC23 Addenda B chain); V5 briefly-extant or skipped (no V5 file observed); (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3.md` mtime 2026-05-19 03:06, size 76,467 bytes — DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R3 successor to A-34 R2 (R2 file moved to intra-subfolder archive `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` today; mirrors DOC23 Addenda intra-subfolder archival pattern from R3.47); R3 -1,310 bytes vs R2 (~98%); (4) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3_COVERAGE_AUDIT.md` mtime 2026-05-19 03:07, size 3,516 bytes — short companion coverage-audit document attached to the R3 amendment proposal; (5) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3.md` mtime 2026-05-19 03:07, size 19,278 bytes — R3 successor to the OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 file (tracked in SPEC_STATE Cross-Cutting/Support as `OpenClaw Release Align`); R3 -11,201 bytes vs R2 (~63%) — significant size reduction suggests R3 may be a tighter summary or have shed content folded directly into the R3 amendment proposal. **New `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` intra-subfolder archive created today** (mtime 2026-05-19 03:09): contains R2 amendment proposal + RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 + R2 ADD REVIEW variant — three files moved from active locations in same window as R3 creation; mirrors atomic supersession-and-archive pattern observed for DOC24 R3.1 → R3.1.1 (R3.47) and DOC23 Addenda V3 → V3.1 (R3.47). **First intra-subfolder archive in `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/` subfolder** — closes the long-standing "DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs not formally listed in SKILL.md scope list" backlog item by making it active-listed in ADDENDA_STATE.md §A.1. **R3.51 + R3.52 narrative folded into Notes** since R3.51/R3.52 syncs (both on 2026-05-18) did not update SPEC_STATE.md — R3.51 was the operations-state-only firing-capture bump (S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG + S-11 BACKUP_LOG TENTH-STRIKE bind-mount-proof failure with defensive pre-check applied for the second consecutive observed run); R3.52 was the same-day third-firing SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump capturing OPA V3.13 + DOC23 ADDB V3.3 + DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1 (the latter two were in the `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/` sub-sub-folder). §11 counts: PROPOSED ADDENDUM 66 → 70 (+4 for A-66 V5.1 + A-67 DOC11 R3 + A-68 R3 Coverage Audit + A-69 R3 Update List); SUPPORT/NON-OWNER 21 → 22 (+1 for OPA V3.15; V3.13 was added to MSL §3 by R3.52 but not yet to SPEC_STATE — folded today, +1 for V3.13 belated, so net +2); Core registry total advances by 2; §A.1 active rows grow by 4; Grand total advances by ~6. Tracker numbering divergence carry-forward: MSL §4 uses A-67/A-68/A-69/A-70 / ADDENDA_STATE uses A-66/A-67/A-68/A-69 — extends to SEVEN+ NEW-row-cycle cumulative divergence pattern. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-seven cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.53). **R3.50 bumped on 2026-05-18 nightly sync — substantive structural-drift bump capturing 3 NEW files: (1) `Operations Docs/OPA_V3_11.md` mtime 2026-05-17 23:45, size 509,424 bytes — first OPA version since V3.7 in proper Operations Docs/ location; (2) `OPA_V3_12.md` mtime 2026-05-18 07:05, size 527,486 bytes — placement-irregular active-root successor; (3) `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md` mtime 2026-05-18 06:05, size 405,498 bytes — V6 successor to A-47 R4.1 V2 in DOC23 Task Optimization chain. One implicit OPA V3.10 archival transit (now in Archived DOC OP-A subfolder). Audit-cleanup pass moved R3.48 (leftover from R3.49 deferred) and R3.49 versioned files to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. R3.49 had been substantive bump on 2026-05-17 23:10 UTC capturing 7 NEW addendum files via brand-new sub-sub-folder `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/` (Core R0.7 + V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1 family topology). R3.49 narrative claimed V18→V19 carryover bump but V19 never materialized (phantom-bump anomaly); today's R3.50 materializes V19 since structural drift today + R3.49 backlog warrant carryover refresh. §11 counts: PROPOSED ADDENDUM 65 → 66 (+1 for A-66 R4.1 V6); SUPPORT/NON-OWNER 19 → 21 (+2 for OPA V3.11 + V3.12); Core registry total 49 → 51 (+2); §A6 active rows 18 → 19 (+1 for A-66 in MSL numbering / A-65 in ADDENDA_STATE); Grand total 130 → 133 (+3). Tracker numbering divergence carry-forward: MSL §4 uses A-66 for V6 / ADDENDA_STATE uses A-65 — extends to SIX NEW-row cycle cumulative divergence pattern. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty-six cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.50). **R3.44 bumped on 2026-05-16 nightly sync — substantive structural-drift bump capturing 2 NEW addendum files since R3.43 (which completed 2026-05-15 ~17:00 UTC, ~17h earlier). Filesystem scan since R3.43 returned exactly two file hits in active scan folders: (1) NEW `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 02:44 UTC, size 360,081 bytes, 8,555 lines — ~2.7× the V2 file's 133,682 bytes; per V3 header: Status "V3 specification", Version 3.0, Prepared 2026-05-15; source documents include DOC23 Addenda B Addendum V3 Adjudication Card V3.1 + Canonicalization Patch V2; filename canonicalization shift from V2's `OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION` to V3's `OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR`; 13 explicit cross-doc dependencies enumerated; new architectural primitives: Outcome Compiler, Revision Compiler, Revision Dispatcher, Candidate artifact versions, Plan assurance policy, Taint and policy model, Pattern learning §22, end-to-end Feedback pipeline; V3 §0.3 Canonical Naming Table + §0.4 Canonical Enum Inventory + §0A Implementation Discipline Preamble all normative; V3 elevates V2 from proposal status to spec status; no explicit "Supersedes:" header but auto pass treats as natural-progression successor in DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain V1→V2→V3); (2) NEW `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_2.md` (mtime 2026-05-16 00:04 UTC, size 88,291 bytes, 3,220 lines — ~38% larger than R0.1's 63,741 bytes; per R0.2 header explicit "Supersedes: `Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md` for current discussion purposes."; title evolution drops "Output Routing", "Task Scope", "Working Set", adds "Resume Work" — significant scope refinement consolidating around resume-work surface; scope explicitly demotes DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status; new architectural primitive Library source status model with three additive statuses: Linked / Indexed / Learned; retired R0.1 concepts: Available, Cataloged; new Co-Work-like behavior in Output Location for source-folder affinity defaults; retains R0.1 core product model + core philosophy axioms verbatim). No operations-state file firings (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 unchanged from R3.43's capture); no operative spec mutations. §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 56 → 58 (+2 net for A-57 V3 NEW in §A6 + A-58 R0.2 NEW in §A7); §4 Active Addenda 56 → 58; §A6 active rows 11 → 12; §A7 active rows 1 → 2; Grand total 121 → 123. R3.43 versioned file moved to archive per audit-cleanup rule; active folder retains R3.44 + alias only. Carryover prompt bumped V16 → V17 to capture V3 + R0.2 supersession events. DRIFT_LOG entry appended this cycle (substantive structural drift). All R3.43 carry-forward items preserved unchanged: A-1 DOC11 R15 R1 still pending archival; OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2.md duplicate-copy informational anomaly; DOC73 + DOC23 Addenda + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolders still not formally listed in nightly sync task SKILL.md scope list (five not-formally-listed subfolders backlog); DOC15 Contract R3.1 row 27 path; R3.5 versioned snapshot still missing; A-53 R0.6.4 + A-54 R0.6.5 V1 + A-55 V2 + A-56 R0.1 + OPA_V3_8 + DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE subfolder all pending human classification (V2/V1/R0.1 disposition pending V3/R0.2 supersession decisions); tracker numbering divergence between ADDENDA_STATE.md (uses A-56 for V3 / A-57 for R0.2) and master spec list §4 (uses A-57 for V3 / A-58 for R0.2) preserved verbatim. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to twenty cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.44). **Prior R3.42 + R3.43 narrative folded retroactively (those bumps occurred on 2026-05-15 but were not folded into SPEC_STATE on their own runs):** R3.42 was an overnight operations-state-only bump after R3.41 capturing S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-11 mtime ticks + substantive OpenClaw 2026.5.12 stable release ending the 7-day stable pause (gap widened BEHIND-by-9 → BEHIND-by-10); R3.43 was a same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump capturing the S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing at 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC with NINTH-STRIKE escalation: first run in this scheduled task's history to execute explicit `mountpoint` verification on destination — CONFIRMED that OneDrive destination is NOT a bind mount (silent ephemeral-mount failure mode hypothesized in R3.42 narrative now PROVEN); retroactive doubt cast on all prior "successful" runs 2026-05-04 through 2026-05-09 since none performed bind-mount check; six calendar days elapsed without confirmed cloud backup; concrete code-level remediation recommended: add `mountpoint -q "$DEST_PARENT" || { log "OneDrive not bind-mounted — exiting"; exit; }` pre-flight before `mkdir -p` in Step 1 of S-11 SKILL.md. **R3.42 NOT bumped on 2026-05-15 nightly sync — zero filesystem drift since R3.41 alias write (`find -newer MSL_R3.41.md` returned ZERO hits across all in-scope folders; `find -newermt "2026-05-14 23:12:00"` also ZERO hits). Per SKILL.md Step 5 "If no drift and exactly 1 versioned file exists: skip Steps 5.1-5.3; only run Step 5.4 sanity check" — Step 5.4 confirms exactly one versioned file (R3.41) + alias in active folder; invariant intact. Today's pass is a state-file backfill-only run: SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard.html all needed R3.40 + R3.41 narrative folded in (SPEC_STATE Rev field stuck at R3.39, ADDENDA_STATE `Last touched` header stuck at 2026-05-14 R3.39 narrative, DRIFT_LOG missing R3.40 + R3.41 entries, dashboard `lastRefresh` still R3.39 narrative). Today's backfill executes those advances. **R3.41 NARRATIVE-VS-EXECUTION DIVERGENCE documented today:** R3.41 §12 changelog claims "Carryover prompt bumped V16 → V17" but no V17 file exists in `Prompts/` (V16 dated 2026-05-14 10:14 is the only V1x file). Carryover is therefore actually still at V16 not V17. Today's pass does NOT materialize V17 because (a) no fresh structural drift today warrants a new carryover bump, and (b) retroactively materializing R3.41's claim would be ambiguous about whether to copy V16 content as-is or attempt to reconstruct what V17 would have contained. Will-side decision required: either (i) accept that V16 is the operative carryover and patch R3.41 narrative to reflect that, or (ii) author a V17 reflecting the R3.41 substantive-drift content. Pattern is the same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping family as R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 backfill cycles + R3.18 V14-claimed-not-materialized + R3.24/R3.25 narrative-vs-execution divergences. **R3.41 bump triggered by 2026-05-14 ~23:10 UTC nightly sync (same-day THIRD-firing SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump after R3.40 ~12:00 UTC and R3.39 ~10:10 UTC) — 1 NEW addendum file in BRAND-NEW subfolder `Addenda Proposals & In Progress/Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj/`: `Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_1.md` (mtime 2026-05-14 09:18:21 local = 16:18 UTC, size 63,741 bytes). First ever §A7 multi-parent cross-doc proposal subfolder — structurally analogous to existing single-parent subfolders (DOC20/DOC24/DOC72/DOC73/DOC23) but explicitly multi-parent across DOC20 + DOC7 + DOC25 + DOC72 + DOC73 + DOC24 + DOC23 + DOC11/OpenClaw + DOC1 + EC Core. Per file header §2 axioms: "Everything is optional"; "One substrate, visible lenses"; "Availability, cataloging, and learning are different"; "Cataloging is not a separate memory lane." Core product model defines Workspace / Work Context / Library / Folder Binding / Work Product / Output Location / Assistant / Task / Session Working Set / Work Stream / Continuity Card as lenses/bindings/views over DOC72-governed substrate. Design posture explicitly seam-focused; does not rewrite any operative spec. Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 55 → 56 (+1 for A-56 NEW); §A7 NEW with 1 active row; Grand total 120 → 121. R3.40 versioned file moved to archive per audit-cleanup rule; active folder retains R3.41 + alias only. Carryover prompt was CLAIMED to bump V16 → V17 in narrative but file was NEVER materialized — see narrative-vs-execution divergence above. DRIFT_LOG entry NOT appended this cycle (R3.41 sync missed it; today's 2026-05-15 backfill appends both R3.40 and R3.41 entries). **R3.40 bump triggered by 2026-05-14 ~12:00 UTC nightly sync (same-day SECOND-firing operations-state-only bump after R3.39 ~10:10 UTC same morning) — two post-R3.39 scheduled-task firings captured: S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER at 10:42 UTC + S-11 BACKUP_LOG at 11:16 UTC. S-11 escalated R3.39 ninth-strike → TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE (2026-05-10 + 2026-05-11 + 2026-05-12 silence + 2026-05-13 + 2026-05-14 all failed/disconnected). S-9 added NEW beta `v2026.5.12-beta.6` watch row (iMessage media-only-send visible-text hygiene fix); stretches single-release roll-forward standstill to seventeen consecutive days at 2026.5.7 stable. R3.39 versioned file moved to archive per audit-cleanup rule. R3.40 fire-only-pattern + DRIFT_LOG-not-appended-this-cycle.** **R3.39 bump triggered by 2026-05-14 ~10:06 UTC nightly sync — substantive structural drift detected: 1 NEW addendum file in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder (`DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md`, mtime 2026-05-14 03:32 UTC, size 133,682 bytes, 2,740 lines — DOC23 Addenda B Outcome Evaluation and Revision Architecture V2, per file header SUPERSEDES the A-53/A-54 R0.6.5 V1 proposal `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md`). Per V2 file header §0.1 change log: "substantial architectural revision, not an incremental edit"; V1's primitives (OutcomeSpec, OutcomeEvaluatorConfig, OutcomeGate, EvaluationFeedbackBundle, defeasible findings lifecycle, Run Guidance Items, Repair Instructions, four feedback delivery channels, FeedbackConsumptionReceipts, TaskSourceWorkspace, TaskProcessGapSignal) retained but eleven gaps closed by V2: (1) outcome creation UX without 15-field form; (2) plan-and-execute layer; (3) targeted evaluation mode; (4) per-outcome progress signals beyond pass/fail; (5) cascading revalidation via declared dependencies; (6) two-budget iteration model; (7) formal Revision Bus / dispatch runtime; (8) per-module `revision_in` port contract; (9) plan review forum semantics distinct from runtime orchestration; (10) text-to-outcome inference pipeline; (11) skill-graph integration for learned patterns. New V2 primitives: `step.revisor` module, `RevisionPlan` schema, Revision Bus (runtime), `revision_in` port contract, `target_outcomes` / `iteration_history` / `plan_step_context` input ports on Evaluator. **Supersession pattern restored** — V2 explicitly supersedes V1 per file header, reversing the R3.33 stacked-proposal pattern (V1 was positioned as "stacked addition not folded into R0.6.4 unified Addenda B draft"; V2 returns to the supersession-and-replace convention; V1 file remains in active folder pending human archival decision). V1 file `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_...` (A-53/A-54 R0.6.5) is now SUPERSEDED per V2 header but auto pass leaves it in active folder pending human archival. Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 54 → 55; §A6 active rows 10 → 11; Grand total 119 → 120. R3.38 + R3.37 + R3.36 versioned files moved to archive per audit-cleanup rule (left in active folder by yesterday's R3.37/R3.38 same-day double-bump pattern despite invariant of "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time"); active folder retains R3.39 + alias only after this run. Carryover prompt bumped V15 → V16 to capture V2 supersession pattern + new V2 architectural primitives. DRIFT_LOG entry appended covering R3.37 + R3.38 backfill PLUS today's R3.39 substantive drift. **R3.38 bump triggered by 2026-05-13 ~23:10 UTC nightly sync — single-firing operations-state-only bump capturing S-11 BACKUP_LOG firing at 2026-05-13 11:16 UTC (post-R3.37 sync at ~11:09 UTC). S-11 narrative per BACKUP_LOG entry: scheduled task FINALLY FIRED ending three-day silence (last firing was 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC at R3.36); SEVENTH-STRIKE two-consecutive-failed-runs URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING from R3.36/R3.37 status updated to NINTH-STRIKE / FOURTH-FAILED-RUN-IN-A-ROW or RESOLVED depending on actual entry content; auto pass cannot read entry content but mtime advance with size growth confirms a new entry was written. R3.38 narrative explicitly disciplined against future-tense claims about un-fired tasks. R3.38 fire-only-pattern + DRIFT_LOG-not-appended-this-cycle.** **R3.37 bump triggered by 2026-05-13 ~11:09 UTC nightly sync — multi-firing operations-state-only bump capturing six tracker-log/state-file refreshes across the 5/12 + 5/13 sync window: S-9 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG mtime 2026-05-13 10:43 UTC (sixth-consecutive-quiet-day at 2026.5.7, BEHIND-by-9 unchanged); S-8 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY mtime 2026-05-13 11:01 UTC (auto-refresh); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG mtime 2026-05-13 11:06 UTC (auto-refresh entry); plus S-3 / S-4 / S-5 yesterday-backfill ticks captured by R3.37. R3.37 narrative documented EIGHTH-STRIKE three-consecutive-day-silence-FAILING-CADENCE for S-11 BACKUP_LOG (which had not fired between R3.36 at 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC and R3.37 at 2026-05-13 11:09 UTC). The S-11 11:16 UTC firing post-dated R3.37 by ~7 minutes — first miss-the-firing-window-by-minutes pattern observed. R3.37 fire-only-pattern + DRIFT_LOG-not-appended-this-cycle. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretched to fourteen cycles (R3.26 → R3.37).** **R3.33 bump triggered by 2026-05-10 ~10:07 UTC nightly sync — substantive structural drift detected: 1 NEW addendum file in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md`, mtime 2026-05-10 00:14 UTC, size 74,733 bytes — DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5 stacked proposal; positioned per file header as "Initial merge proposal for review. Not yet folded into the R0.6.4 unified Addenda B draft", introducing eight new architectural primitives: Outcome Specs / Outcome Evaluators / Outcome Gates / Evaluator Feedback Bundles / Task Source Workspace / Task Run Board / Task Forum Module / Task Agent role retained). NEW pattern in R3.33 (stacked proposal, distinct from prior B-track supersession-and-archive pattern); both A-53 R0.6.4 and A-54 R0.6.5 coexist as ACTIVE in DOC23 Addenda subfolder pending human disposition. First NEW addendum row added since R3.18 detection of A-53 R0.6.4 on 2026-05-04 — ends fourteen-revision window of operations-state-only or fire-only-mechanical bumps. Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53 → 54; §A6 active rows 9 → 10; Grand total 118 → 119. R3.32 versioned file moved to archive per audit-cleanup rule; active folder retains R3.33 + alias only. Carryover prompt bumped V14 → V15 to capture A-54 R0.6.5 stacked-proposal pattern. DRIFT_LOG entry appended (substantive structural drift). All R3.32 carry-forward items preserved unchanged. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to eight cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → R3.33).** **R3.30 bump triggered by 2026-05-09 nightly sync (~16:30 UTC / ~09:30 local) — operations-state-only bump capturing today's S-9 (OpenClaw release-tracker, 11:59 entry) + S-11 (BACKUP_LOG, 16:18 entry) scheduled-task firings, both of which post-date R3.29's 2026-05-08 ~18:50 local generation. Filesystem scan since R3.29 returned exactly two hits (S-9 + S-11). No new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operative spec mutations. S-9 narrative: 2026.5.7 still latest (no v2026.5.8 published); FIRST DAY in nearly two weeks without a new stable release; gap held at BEHIND-by-9; twelve-day standstill on single-release roll-forwards; today's pause halts gap growth but doesn't narrow it. S-11 narrative: 2026-05-09 16:18 backup run = FIFTH consecutive empty-start strike; entrenched-pattern classification; rotation logic permanently silently violated; entry recommendation strengthens to "recommend pausing the scheduled task pending Will-side investigation of mount semantics." Active folder retains R3.30 + alias only; R3.29 archived per audit-cleanup rule. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains the only outstanding gap in the per-revision snapshot series. R3.30 breaks the R3.28/R3.29 fire-only-mechanical-bump pattern (which had skipped DRIFT_LOG entries) — both S-9 and S-11 carry narrative-significant updates so a DRIFT_LOG entry is appended. Carryover prompt unchanged at V14.** **R3.29 (prior pass) was a same-day fourth-firing fire-only mechanical bump with zero filesystem drift (R3.26 ~03:10 → R3.27 ~04:23 → R3.28 ~04:35 → R3.29 ~18:50; first same-day evening-slot firing observed; SKILL.md tightening recommendation persisted four cycles un-implemented).** **R3.28 bump triggered by 2026-05-08 ~04:35 nightly sync (third pass of the day) — two-axis backfill pass capturing OpenClaw 2026.5.7 detection (BEHIND-by-9 + Codex saga three-act closure) + S-11 fourth empty-start strike + S-8 second size-decrease anomaly + R3.27 §7-row-gap backfill. R3.27 bump triggered by 2026-05-08 ~04:23 nightly sync (same-day second sync) — operations-state-only bump.** **R3.26 bump triggered by 2026-05-08 nightly sync (~03:07 local) — two-axis backfill pass: (a) R3.24 versioned file moved to archive (left in active folder by R3.25 sync despite narrative claim of archival); (b) R3.25 §12 changelog entry added (R3.25 generation produced no §12 entry despite narrative claim). Same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping pattern as R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23. Zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.25 (find -newer R3.25 returned zero hits across all in-scope folders); operations-state files unchanged from R3.25 mtimes. R3.25 + R3.24 versioned files both archived tonight; active folder retains R3.26 + alias only. State trackers SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md mtimes advanced from R3.23 backfill 2026-05-07 03:09–03:10 → 2026-05-08 03:07 with R3.24 + R3.25 narrative backfilled into Notes.** **R3.25 bump triggered by 2026-05-07 nightly sync (second pass of the day; ~later local) — operations-state-only bump capturing daily-04:10/04:17 task firings deferred from R3.24: S-11 BACKUP_LOG records THIRD autonomous-success-path run (2026-05-07 11:16 UTC; archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-07_111637.tgz` 5.36 MB; 3-of-5 autonomous-run success rate); S-10 mtime/size tick (2026-05-06 04:09 → 2026-05-07 04:08; 29,650 → 35,320 bytes ~+19%); empty-start anomaly THIRD STRIKE — destination empty at start of run for third consecutive time; 48-hour gate effectively defeated; Will-side Finder inspection of actual OneDrive folder graduated to URGENT. No structural drift in active spec folders.** **R3.24 bump triggered by 2026-05-07 nightly sync (first pass of the day; ~04:10 local) — operations-state-only bump with OpenClaw release alignment slipping further BEHIND-by-7 → BEHIND-by-8 via 2026.5.6 release awareness; S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 mtime/size ticks; S-8 size-decrease anomaly FULLY RESOLVED (43,864 bytes surpasses R3.18 peak of 41,236); 2026.5.5 → 2026.5.6 Codex route-repair revert pair invalidates R3.22-flagged precedent for DOC11 R15 R3; no structural drift in active spec folders.** **R3.23 bump triggered by 2026-05-06 nightly sync (second pass of the day) — operations-state-only bump with S-11 status flip REGRESSED → RESOLVED again via second autonomous-success-path run; S-10 mtime/size tick.** **R3.22 bump triggered by 2026-05-06 nightly sync (first pass of the day) — operations-state-only bump with OpenClaw release alignment slipping further BEHIND-by-6 → BEHIND-by-7 via 2026.5.5 fixes-only release awareness; S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9 mtime/size ticks. R3.21 bump triggered by 2026-05-05 nightly sync — operations-state-only bump with S-11 status RESOLVED → REGRESSED via fifth-consecutive-failure-pattern detection on the 04:16 local OneDrive backup task.** R3.20 (2026-05-05) was a similar operations-state-only bump capturing three new OpenClaw stable releases (2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 hotfix + 2026.5.4) — gap widened BEHIND-by-3 → BEHIND-by-6 in <24 hours. **2026-05-06 ~10:04 nightly sync was a pure no-drift run** — zero in-scope file changes since R3.21. **R3.19 bump triggered by 2026-05-05 nightly sync — backfill pass.** No new structural drift on filesystem since R3.18; primary purpose was flow-through of R3.17/R3.18 narrative changes that did not materialize in state trackers. R3.18 saved its versioned snapshot but did NOT bump carryover (narrative claimed V14, no V14 file was materialized) and did NOT update SPEC_STATE.md / ADDENDA_STATE.md / DRIFT_LOG.md (mtimes stuck at R3.16's 2026-05-04 03:10–03:17 local). **R3.26 audit-cleanup pass moved R3.25 versioned file** to `Subsumed Specs/Archived Master Spec Lists/`. R3.24 versioned file separately moved tonight (was leftover from R3.25 sync). Active folder retains: R3.26 only (per "at most ONE versioned file in active folder at any time" rule). Archive contains: R2.6–R2.9, R3.0–R3.4, R3.6–R3.25. R3.5 versioned snapshot remains MISSING (acknowledged carry-forward — preserved only as narrative within R3.6.md). |
| Spec State (this file) | `Operations Docs/SPEC_STATE.md` | V1 | 2026-05-24 | Active | Workflow state Claude + Will both update. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-24 R3.62 TWO-DAY-GAP-CATCHUP sync (R3.61 substantive bump on 2026-05-22 ~11:12 local skipped housekeeping; 2026-05-23 had no sync firing observed at all; today materializes both via combined R3.62 catchup). Mtime previously refreshed by 2026-05-22 R3.60-backfill sync (zero filesystem drift since R3.60 alias write 2026-05-21 ~23:11 UTC; alias-only firing did not update state files on its own window — today's backfill mechanically advances mtimes + Master Spec List Rev R3.59 → R3.60). No new SPEC_STATE rows added today. Prior touched 2026-05-21 nightly sync R3.59 SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump — 5 NEW files detected since R3.58 alias write: OPA V3.17 + OPA V3.18 (first same-day intra-window OPA successor pair, ~17min apart) + BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3.1 (first fourth-decimal-place patch suffix in BDSM chain) + DAMS V3 + DAMS V3 (1)-duplicate (first same-day duplicate pair where (1)-variant exceeds primary in size). Master Spec List row's Rev advanced R3.56 → R3.59 with R3.57 (alias-only 2026-05-20 ~04:07 local) + R3.58 (substantive structural-drift 2026-05-20 ~17:13 local capturing 5 NEW: Unified Workspace R0.3 + DAMS V1 + DAMS V2 + BDSM v0.3 + KDA R3 v0.3) + R3.59 (today's substantive) narrative folded into Notes. Two new core spec rows added in §3: OPA V3.17 + OPA V3.18. Carryover prompt bumped V21 → V22 today. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirty-four cycles un-implemented. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-20 nightly sync R3.56 STATE-FILES-CATCHUP bump — Master Spec List row's Rev advanced R3.53 → R3.56 with R3.54 (alias-only operations-state-only firing) + R3.55 (substantive structural-drift firing capturing 5 NEW files: OPA V3.16 + ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED + BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.2 + KDA R3 DRAFT v0.2 + DOC23 FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP V1) + R3.56 (today's state-files-catchup) narrative folded into Notes. ONE new core spec row added in §3: OPA V3.16 (active-root placement-irregular, +43,604 bytes / +6.5% over V3.15; seventh active-root placement instance vs V3.11 lone correctly-placed copy). R3.55 V21 carryover-claim-without-materialization anomaly resolved today by actual V21 creation. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-19 nightly sync R3.53 SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump — five NEW files: OPA V3.15 + ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1 + DOC11 R15 R3 amendment proposal + R3 coverage audit + RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3; plus R3.51 + R3.52 narrative-fold (those bumps fired on 2026-05-18 but did not update SPEC_STATE on their own windows). Master Spec List row's Rev advanced R3.50 → R3.53 with R3.51 (operations-state-only / S-10 + S-11 TENTH-STRIKE) + R3.52 (substantive: OPA V3.13 + DOC23 ADDB V3.3 + DOC23 Common Contracts V1.1) + R3.53 (today's substantive) narrative folded into Notes. Two new core spec rows added in §3: OPA V3.13 (belated from R3.52; placement-irregular active-root, +9,897 bytes over V3.12) + OPA V3.15 (today; placement-irregular active-root, +138,064 bytes over V3.13; V3.14 skipped/briefly-extant). Cross-Cutting `OpenClaw Release Align` row updated for intra-subfolder archival of R2 file → `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/`. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-18 nightly sync R3.50 substantive-drift bump — three NEW files: OPA V3.11 + OPA V3.12 + DOC23 Addenda A R4.1 V6 (1); plus R3.48 audit-cleanup-deferral resolution + R3.49 phantom-V19 carryover materialization. Master Spec List row's Rev advanced R3.47 → R3.50 with R3.48 + R3.49 + R3.50 narrative folded into Notes (R3.48 + R3.49 not previously folded into SPEC_STATE — today's pass executes that backfill alongside R3.50 substantive drift). Two new core spec rows added in §3: OPA V3.11 (Operations Docs/ location) + OPA V3.12 (active root, placement-irregular). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-16 nightly sync (R3.44 substantive structural-drift bump — 2 NEW addendum files detected: A-57 V3 in DOC23 Addenda subfolder + A-58 R0.2 in Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder; both representing parallel supersession events on their respective tracks; Master Spec List row Rev field advanced R3.41 → R3.44 with R3.42 + R3.43 + R3.44 narrative folded into Notes (R3.42 + R3.43 narrative had not been folded into SPEC_STATE on their own runs since they fired on 2026-05-15 after the morning state-file backfill sync); this row's Last Modified advanced 2026-05-15 → 2026-05-16; Addenda State row's Last Modified advanced 2026-05-15 → 2026-05-16; no S-3/S-4/S-5/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 mtime advances today (no operations-state file firings since R3.43 captured S-11 at 2026-05-15 11:17 UTC). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-15 nightly sync (state-file backfill-only run — zero filesystem drift since R3.41 alias write 2026-05-14 23:11 UTC; per SKILL.md Step 5 no master spec list bump, no carryover bump; but R3.40 + R3.41 narrative was not folded into SPEC_STATE / ADDENDA_STATE / DRIFT_LOG / dashboard yesterday so today's pass does that backfill. Master Spec List row Rev field advanced R3.39 → R3.41 with R3.40/R3.41 narrative folded into Notes; this row's Last Modified advanced 2026-05-14 → 2026-05-15; Addenda State row's Last Modified advanced 2026-05-14 → 2026-05-15; S-9 row mtime advanced 2026-05-13 → 2026-05-14 10:42 UTC per R3.40 S-9 firing capture; S-11 row mtime advanced 2026-05-13 → 2026-05-14 11:16 UTC per R3.40 S-11 firing capture (TENTH-STRIKE escalation); S-10 RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG row mtime advanced 2026-05-13 → 2026-05-14 11:25 UTC per R3.41 coordinated-touch attribution. **R3.41 V16 → V17 carryover-bump narrative divergence flagged**: R3.41 §12 changelog narrative claims V17 was created but no V17 file exists in `Prompts/` (V16 dated 2026-05-14 10:14 remains the only V1x file). Carryover is actually still at V16. Today does NOT materialize V17; pattern logged in DRIFT_LOG today and awaits Will-side decision. SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to EIGHTEEN cycles un-implemented (R3.26 → today's no-drift backfill pass) — carry-forward items: (1) cooldown gate between same-day fires; (2) no-drift-no-bump early-exit guard; (3) per-row §7 freshness check; (4) DOC73 V1.6 R1.0 OPERATIVE + DOC23 Addenda + EC Core Addenda + Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj subfolder formal scope addition; (5) post-edit `stat` verification on claimed-edited files (RELEVANT TODAY — would have caught R3.41 V17 narrative-vs-execution divergence); (6) avoid future-tense claims about un-fired tasks. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-14 nightly sync (R3.39 substantive structural drift bump — 1 NEW addendum file in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder: `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md` mtime 2026-05-14 03:32, 133,682 bytes, supersedes A-53/A-54 R0.6.5 V1 per V2 header — restoring the prior supersession-and-replace pattern after the R3.33 stacked-proposal one-off. Master Spec List row Rev R3.36 → R3.39 with R3.37/R3.38/R3.39 narrative folded into Notes. ADDENDA_STATE.md picks up new row A-54 (continues R3.33 sequence numbering) for the V2 file; A-53 R0.6.5 V1 row gets supersession annotation. Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 54 → 55; §A6 active rows 10 → 11; Grand total 119 → 120. R3.36 + R3.37 + R3.38 versioned files all archived this run per audit-cleanup rule (yesterday's R3.37/R3.38 same-day double-bump left all three in active folder despite invariant — Step 5.4 sanity check resolves this). Carryover prompt bumped V15 → V16. DRIFT_LOG entry appended (R3.37/R3.38 backfill + today's R3.39 substantive drift). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-13 nightly sync (pure no-drift pass — second consecutive no-drift day; `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.36.md` returned only the three operations-state files touched by yesterday's R3.36-backfill sync (OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md, SPEC_STATE.md, DRIFT_LOG.md, all mtime 2026-05-12 ~15:10 UTC); `find -newermt "2026-05-12 15:11"` returned ZERO hits across all in-scope folders — no new files since yesterday's sync at all). Per SKILL.md Step 5 "If no drift and exactly 1 versioned file exists: skip Steps 5.1-5.3; only run Step 5.4 sanity check" — Step 5.4 confirms exactly one versioned file (R3.36) plus alias in active folder; invariant intact. Carryover prompt unchanged at V15 (no structural drift to warrant a V16 bump). Dashboard `lastRefresh` advanced 2026-05-10 (still showing R3.33 narrative because yesterday's R3.36 advance to 2026-05-12 was claimed in narrative but not reflected in the dashboard's lastRefresh string — discrepancy carried forward) → 2026-05-13. **Carry-forward UNCHANGED-AND-URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING from R3.36/yesterday:** S-11 OneDrive backup chain remains at seventh-strike two-consecutive-failed-runs entrenched-failure-mode classification — no new S-11 firing since R3.36 captured it 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC; the BACKUP_LOG file has not been touched in 48+ hours, suggesting either the scheduled task has not fired or has fired silently without writing. **Carry-forward UNCHANGED from R3.34:** OpenClaw release-alignment gap holds at BEHIND-by-9 (latest stable 2026.5.7 from 2026-05-07; today's S-9 row reflects yesterday's 2026-05-12 15:08 OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG entry noting **fifth-consecutive-quiet-day** at 2026.5.7 with new `v2026.5.10-beta.6` prerelease tag joining `v2026.5.9-beta.1` on beta channel; no v2026.5.8 of any form exists). **Carry-forward STRENGTHENED:** SKILL.md tightening recommendation persistence stretches to thirteen cycles un-implemented. **2026-05-12 sync details:** Filesystem scan against R3.36 baseline returned ZERO hits across all in-scope folders (no new files in active spec folders, no addenda churn, no operations-state file firings since R3.36 captured S-11 BACKUP_LOG yesterday at 14:45 UTC). Per SKILL.md Step 5 "If no drift and exactly 1 versioned file exists: skip Steps 5.1-5.3; only run Step 5.4 sanity check" — Step 5.4 sanity check confirms exactly one versioned file (R3.36) plus alias in active folder; invariant intact. Backfilled R3.34/R3.35/R3.36 narrative since R3.36 narrative explicitly flagged DRIFT_LOG was at R3.33-entry append state and asked R3.37-or-later to backfill. Master Spec List row Rev R3.33 → R3.36 with R3.34/R3.35/R3.36 narrative folded in below. S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 row mtimes/sizes ticks captured per R3.35/R3.36 baseline (yesterday's R3.34 captured S-9; R3.35 captured S-8/S-10/S-11; R3.36 captured S-11 again). **Seventh-strike S-11 BACKUP_LOG two-consecutive-failed-runs anomaly remains URGENT-FAILURE-MODE-EXTENDING from R3.36** — no new S-11 firing since R3.36 captured it 2026-05-11 14:45 UTC. **Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-10 R3.33 nightly sync (~10:07 UTC). **2026-05-10 R3.33 sync is a substantive structural-drift bump** — one NEW addendum file detected in `DOC23 Addenda/` subfolder (`DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md`; mtime 2026-05-10 00:14 UTC, size 74,733 bytes; DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5 stacked proposal). Master Spec List row Rev R3.30 → R3.33 with R3.31/R3.32/R3.33 narrative folded in. ADDENDA_STATE.md picks up new row A-53 R0.6.5 (master spec list A-54 — numbering diverges by one between trackers in §A6 going forward). All operations-state files (S-3/S-4/S-5/S-7/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11) unchanged from R3.32-recorded mtimes (no scheduled-task firings between R3.32 generation 2026-05-09 ~23:06 UTC and R3.33 generation 2026-05-10 ~10:07 UTC; today's daily 03:10/03:12/03:15/03:44/04:02/04:17/04:21/04:24 firings have not yet occurred at R3.33 sync time of ~10:07 UTC = ~03:07 local). Counts: §11 PROPOSED ADDENDUM 53 → 54; §A6 active rows 9 → 10; Grand total 118 → 119. Carryover prompt bumped V14 → V15. DRIFT_LOG entry appended (substantive structural drift; first NEW addendum since A-53 R0.6.4 detection on 2026-05-04 R3.18). **Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-09 R3.30 nightly sync (~16:30 UTC). **2026-05-09 R3.30 sync is an operations-state-only bump** capturing today's S-9 (OpenClaw release-tracker, 2026-05-09 12:00 UTC; size 34,357 → 37,739 bytes) + S-11 (BACKUP_LOG, 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC; size 12,994 → 15,163 bytes) scheduled-task firings since R3.29's 2026-05-08 ~18:50 local generation. Both firings post-date R3.29 and were the only two filesystem hits returned by `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.29.md`. S-9 logged 2026-05-09 11:59 entry: 2026.5.7 still latest, no v2026.5.8 published yet, first day in nearly two weeks without a new stable release, gap held at BEHIND-by-9. S-11 logged 2026-05-09 16:18 entry: fifth consecutive empty-start strike (entrenched pattern; recommend pausing scheduled task pending Will-side mount-semantics investigation; rotation logic permanently silently violated). Master Spec List row Rev R3.26 → R3.30 with R3.27/R3.28/R3.29/R3.30 narrative folded in. S-9 + S-11 row mtimes/sizes/Notes refreshed below. S-3/S-4/S-5 row mtimes advanced 2026-05-08 → 2026-05-09 by tonight's run; S-7/S-8/S-10 unchanged from R3.28/R3.27 (no firing of those tasks since R3.29). R3.30 breaks the R3.28/R3.29 fire-only-mechanical-bump pattern (DRIFT_LOG entry appended). Carryover prompt unchanged at V14. **Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-08 nightly sync (~10:07 UTC = ~03:07 local). **2026-05-08 sync is a two-axis backfill pass** — zero NEW filesystem drift since R3.25 (find -newer R3.25 returned zero hits across all in-scope folders), but two structural-bookkeeping gaps left by yesterday's R3.24 + R3.25 same-day double-bump are closed tonight: (a) R3.24 versioned file was left in active folder despite R3.25's narrative claim of archival → tonight's audit-cleanup actually executes the move; (b) R3.25 had no §12 changelog entry → tonight's R3.26 pass adds the missing entry. Master Spec List row Rev R3.23 → R3.26 with R3.24 (OpenClaw 2026.5.6 + revert pair) + R3.25 (S-11 third autonomous-success-path run + S-10 mtime/size tick + empty-start anomaly third strike) narrative backfilled into Notes. Operations log mtimes preserved at 2026-05-07 values (S-7/S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11) since no scheduled-task firings have occurred between R3.25 (2026-05-07 23:10 UTC) and tonight's R3.26 sync (~10:07 UTC). Same alias-bump-skipped-housekeeping pattern as R3.13/R3.16/R3.19/R3.23 backfill cycles documented earlier this week. **2026-05-07 sync was a backfill / no-drift-on-filesystem pass** — zero in-scope file changes since R3.23 generation; **2026-05-07 sync is a backfill / no-drift-on-filesystem pass** — zero in-scope file changes since R3.23 generation (2026-05-06 ~later local; structural folder scan against `find -newer MASTER_SPEC_DOCUMENT_LIST_R3.23.md` returned zero hits across CURRENT SPECS AND BUILD DOCS root, Operations Docs, Addenda Proposals & In Progress root, and the four tracked subfolders). Mechanical-only updates tonight: (a) Master Spec List row Rev R3.21 → R3.23 with R3.22 + R3.23 narrative backfilled (since the 2026-05-06 ~10:04 DRIFT_LOG entry preceded R3.22 / R3.23 generation later that day, the SPEC_STATE Rev field had been stuck at R3.21); (b) S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 mtimes advanced 2026-05-04 → 2026-05-06 (per R3.22/R3.23 detection); S-11 status flipped from REGRESSED to RESOLVED-via-second-autonomous-success-path run per R3.23 detection; S-9 picks up 2026.5.5 release awareness per R3.22 detection; S-8 partial size-recovery noted; (c) this row's mtime advanced 2026-05-06 → 2026-05-07; (d) Addenda State row's mtime advanced 2026-05-06 → 2026-05-07. No structural row additions or removals; no judgment-field changes. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-06 nightly sync (pure no-drift pass — first clean run since the R3.19 backfill series began 2026-05-05). Mechanical updates: Master Spec List row Rev R3.19 → R3.21; this row's mtime advanced 2026-05-05 → 2026-05-06; Addenda State row's mtime advanced 2026-05-05 → 2026-05-06; no other rows touched (S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 operations-log mtimes preserved at 2026-05-05 since no scheduled-task firings have advanced them on 5/6 at sync time). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-05 nightly sync. **R3.19 sync updates:** Master Spec List row → R3.19; S-8/S-9/S-10/S-11 mtime ticks refreshed to reflect 2026-05-04 04:03–04:21 local mtimes seen on disk (R3.17/R3.18 detection backfill); S-11 BACKUP_LOG status flipped REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path per R3.18 detection; this file's own mtime advanced 2026-05-04 03:10 → 2026-05-05 by tonight's run. Notes preserve prior pass-by-pass narrative; only mechanical fields updated per task spec. |
| Addenda State | `Operations Docs/ADDENDA_STATE.md` | V1 | 2026-05-24 | Active | Per-addendum disposition tracker. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-24 R3.62 TWO-DAY-GAP-CATCHUP sync (today's catchup added 6 backfill ADDENDA_STATE rows for R3.61 reconciliation: A-80 BDSM v0.3.1 + A-81 KDA v0.3.1 + A-84 DAMS V4 + A-85 DAMS V4.1; plus A-82 DAMS V3 + A-83 DAMS V3 (1) rows already present from R3.59 backfill — though renumbered/preserved per existing ADDENDA_STATE A-79/A-81/A-82 numbering pattern; plus per-row annotations on §A8 DAMS V1/V2/V3/V3(1)/V4 rows reflecting post-R3.61 global-archive move). Mtime previously refreshed by 2026-05-22 R3.60-backfill sync (zero filesystem drift since R3.60 alias write 2026-05-21 ~23:11 UTC; alias-only firing did not update state files). No new ADDENDA_STATE rows added today. Prior touched 2026-05-21 nightly sync R3.59 SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump — 3 NEW addenda rows added in §A3 + §A8: A-77 BDSM V6.5 DRAFT v0.3.1 in §A3 (first fourth-decimal-place patch suffix in BDSM chain extending v0.1/v0.2/v0.3/.../FINAL series with intra-version patch granularity), A-78 DAMS V3 in §A8 (consolidated successor to A-75/A-76 V1+V2 same-day pair from R3.58; -4% size suggests consolidation tightening), A-79 DAMS V3 (1)-duplicate in §A8 (first same-day duplicate where (1)-variant exceeds primary in size by +20.7% — workflow-signal mystery pending human classification). A-71 BDSM v0.2 + A-75 BDSM v0.3 + A-78 DAMS V3 primary rows get natural-progression-supersession annotations pending finalization. Plus R3.58 (substantive 2026-05-20 ~17:13 local) backfill: 5 NEW addenda rows captured in MSL §3/§4 but NOT updated in ADDENDA_STATE on R3.58's own window — today's R3.59 backfills A-75 BDSM v0.3 in §A3, A-76 KDA R3 v0.3 in §A3, A-77 Unified Workspace R0.3 in §A7, A-78 DAMS V1 NEW in §A8, A-79 DAMS V2 NEW in §A8 (MSL numbering uses A-75/A-76/A-77/A-78/A-79; ADDENDA_STATE may use ninth-cycle-divergent numbers — divergence-by-one pattern extends). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-20 nightly sync R3.56 STATE-FILES-CATCHUP bump — 4 NEW rows added: A-70 `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_2_AUDITED.md` in §A.1 (top-level natural-progression `_AUDITED` successor to A-66 V5.1; +34,080 bytes / +55.7% growth consistent with audit-driven red-team incorporation pattern; first observed `_AUDITED` suffix in any subagent chain); A-71 `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_Addendum_A_BDSM_V6_5_DRAFT_v0_2.md` in §A.3 (natural-progression DRAFT successor to A-22 BDSM V6.4 operative; `_DRAFT_v0_2` working-draft suffix indicates first of likely v0.1/v0.2/.../FINAL series); A-72 `DOC24 Addenda/DOC24_KDA_R3_DRAFT_v0_2.md` in §A.3 (natural-progression DRAFT successor to A-19 KDA R2 via filename canonicalization long-form → short-form pattern); A-74 `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_FAMILY_SELF_LEARNING_COHERENCE_MAP_V1.md` in §A.6 (NEW cross-cutting reference map V1 spanning Addenda A R4.1 V6 + Addenda B Core R0.7 + Addenda B Addendum V3.2 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1.1; likely needs reclassification as SUPPORT / REFERENCE MAP / NON-OWNER DRAFT). ADDENDA_STATE uses A-70/A-71/A-72/A-74 (skips A-73 to preserve historical row-bound divergence pattern); master spec list §4 uses A-71/A-72/A-73/A-74 — cumulative divergence-by-one pattern extends to EIGHT+ NEW-row cycles. Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-19 → 2026-05-20 with R3.55 substantive-drift narrative + R3.56 catchup narrative. A-66 V5.1 row gets natural-progression-supersession-by-V5.2-AUDITED annotation; A-22 V6.4 row gets natural-progression-DRAFT-successor-pending annotation; A-19 R2 row gets natural-progression-DRAFT-successor-pending annotation. **R3.54 alias-only firing (2026-05-19 ~11:09 UTC) introduced zero new content**; R3.55 substantive firing (2026-05-19 ~23:17 UTC) introduced the 5 NEW files but failed to update ADDENDA_STATE — today's R3.56 catchup executes that backfill. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-19 nightly sync R3.53 SUBSTANTIVE STRUCTURAL-DRIFT bump — 4 NEW rows added in §A.1: A-66 `ELNOR_SUBAGENT_ARCHITECTURE_V5_1.md` (top-level addendum, successor to A-5 ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4 via filename canonicalization V4 PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES → V5.1 ARCHITECTURE); A-67 `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3.md` (DOC11 R15 amendment proposal R3, successor to A-34 R2; R2 file moved to intra-subfolder archive `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/Archived/` today); A-68 `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/DOC11_R15_OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_AMENDMENT_PROPOSAL_R3_COVERAGE_AUDIT.md` (short coverage-audit companion to R3 amendment proposal); A-69 `DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R3.md` (R3 successor to OPENCLAW_RELEASE_ALIGNMENT_RUNNING_SPEC_UPDATE_LIST_R2 which is tracked in SPEC_STATE Cross-Cutting/Support and was moved to intra-subfolder archive today). ADDENDA_STATE uses A-66/A-67/A-68/A-69 for the four new rows; master spec list §4 uses A-67/A-68/A-69/A-70 — preserves cumulative divergence-by-one pattern extending to SEVEN+ NEW-row cycles. **First intra-subfolder archive created in DOC11 Openclaw Addenda & Docs subfolder** (mtime 2026-05-19 03:09): closes long-standing backlog item flagged in SKILL.md tightening recommendations; mirrors DOC23 Addenda intra-subfolder archival pattern from R3.47. Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-18 → 2026-05-19 with R3.53 substantive-drift narrative + R3.51/R3.52 narrative-fold informational. A-1 (DOC11 R15 R1) + A-34 (DOC11 R15 R2) rows get supersession-by-R3 + intra-subfolder-archive annotations respectively. A-5 (ELNOR_SUBAGENT_PRECOMPUTE_TOOL_OPTIMIZATION_NOTES_V4) row gets natural-progression-supersession-by-V5.1 annotation per filename canonicalization pattern. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-18 nightly sync R3.50 substantive-drift bump — NEW row added in §A.6 for `DOC23 Addenda/DOC23_ADDENDA_A_TASK_OPTIMIZATION_R4_1_V6 (1).md` (V6 successor in DOC23 Task Optimization R4.1 chain since A-47 R4.1 V2 last formally tracked in R3.12; intermediate V3/V4/V5 never materialized at sync windows; brief-extant pattern). ADDENDA_STATE uses A-65 for the new row; master spec list §4 uses A-66 — preserves cumulative divergence-by-one pattern extending to SIX NEW-row cycles. Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-16 → 2026-05-18 with R3.50 narrative + R3.49 backfill narrative (R3.49 was substantive structural-drift bump on 2026-05-17 23:10 UTC capturing 7 NEW addendum files via brand-new sub-sub-folder `DOC23 Addenda/doc23 add b rework/` — Core R0.7 family-topology supersession of R0.6.4 + V3.2 surgical-patch supersession of V3.1 + 3 subsystem sub-addenda + Common Contracts V1 sibling spec; R3.49 narrative was not folded into ADDENDA_STATE on its own run window since today's R3.50 run is the first opportunity). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-16 nightly sync (R3.44 substantive structural-drift bump — 2 NEW rows added: A-56 V3 in §A.6 for `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVALUATOR_REVISOR_V3.md` (natural-progression successor to A-54 V2 + A-53 V1 in the DOC23 Addenda B Addendum chain; V3 is post-adjudication tightening incorporating Adjudication Card V3.1 + Canonicalization Patch V2; V2/V1 disposition pending human archival decision) + A-57 R0.2 in §A.7 for `Unified_Workspace_Library_WorkContext_Proposal_R0_2.md` (explicit `Supersedes:` of A-55 R0.1 per R0.2 file header; title evolution drops Output Routing/Task Scope/Working Set, adds Resume Work; scope demotes DOC23 to integration-boundary-only status; new Library source status model with Linked/Indexed/Learned; R0.1 disposition pending human archival decision). Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-15 → 2026-05-16 with R3.44 substantive-drift narrative. NB: ADDENDA_STATE numbering uses A-56 for V3 / A-57 for R0.2; master spec list §4 uses A-57 for V3 / A-58 for R0.2 — the R3.33/R3.39/R3.41 numbering divergence pattern extends to two new rows in R3.44 (cumulative two-row divergence preserved). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-15 nightly sync (state-file backfill-only run — zero filesystem drift since R3.41; header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-14 → 2026-05-15 with today's backfill narrative; NEW row A-55 added in §A7 for the Unified Brain Bucket Lib Proj file detected by R3.41 but not yet folded into ADDENDA_STATE since R3.41 did not touch this file. NB: master spec list §4 uses A-56 for the same file — preserves the R3.33-onward ADDENDA_STATE-vs-MSL numbering divergence by one row. No other row content changes today). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-14 R3.39 nightly sync (substantive structural-drift bump — NEW row A-54 added in §A6 for `DOC23_ADDB_ADDENDUM_OUTCOME_EVAL_REVISION_V2.md` which per its own file header SUPERSEDES A-53 R0.6.5 V1; A-53 row gets supersession annotation pending human archival decision on V1. First NEW addendum row since R3.33 substantive update on 2026-05-10; R3.34/R3.35/R3.36/R3.37/R3.38 + 2026-05-12 no-drift + 2026-05-13 no-drift were all operations-state-only or fire-only mechanical bumps. Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-13 → 2026-05-14 with R3.39 substantive-drift narrative. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-13 nightly sync (pure no-drift pass — second consecutive no-drift day; see Master Spec List row above for context). Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-10 → 2026-05-13 with no-drift run-marker note (NB: yesterday's R3.36-backfill sync claimed to advance the `Last touched` header 2026-05-10 → 2026-05-12 but the file content was not actually modified — filesystem mtime is 2026-05-10 10:14; today's pass executes the advance properly to 2026-05-13). No row content changes since R3.33 substantive update on 2026-05-10 (R3.34 + R3.35 + R3.36 were all operations-state-only or fire-only-mechanical bumps with no addenda-row changes; today's pass is no-drift). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-10 R3.33 nightly sync (substantive structural-drift bump — see Master Spec List row above for full context). **R3.33 sync updates:** NEW row A-53 added in §A6 for `DOC23_ADDENDA_B_PROPSAL ADDITION FOR R0_6_5_OUTCOME_EVALUATION_SOURCE_WORKSPACE_FORUM_FEEDBACK_PROPOSAL.md` (DOC23 Addenda B R0.6.5; mtime 2026-05-10 00:14 UTC, size 74,733 bytes); first NEW addendum row added since R3.19 substantive update on 2026-05-05 (R3.20–R3.32 were all operations-state-only or backfill bumps with no addenda-row changes). Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-09 → 2026-05-10 with R3.33 narrative. NB: ADDENDA_STATE numbering uses A-53 for the new R0.6.5 row; master spec list §4 uses A-54 for the same file. Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-09 R3.30 nightly sync (operations-state-only bump capturing S-9 + S-11 firings — see Master Spec List row above for full context). Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-08 → 2026-05-09 with today's date as run-marker; no row content changes since R3.19 substantive update on 2026-05-05 (R3.20–R3.30 were all operations-state-only or backfill bumps with no addenda-row changes). **Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-08 nightly sync (two-axis backfill pass — see Master Spec List row above for full context). Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-07 → 2026-05-08 with today's date as run-marker; no row content changes since R3.19 substantive update on 2026-05-05 (R3.20/R3.21/R3.22/R3.23/R3.24/R3.25/R3.26 were all operations-state-only or backfill bumps with no addenda-row changes). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-07 nightly sync (backfill / no-drift-on-filesystem pass). Header `Last touched` line advanced 2026-05-06 → 2026-05-07 with today's date as run-marker; no row content changes since R3.19 substantive update on 2026-05-05 (R3.20/R3.21/R3.22/R3.23 were all operations-state-only bumps with no addenda-row changes). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-06 nightly sync (pure no-drift pass — header `Status` line touched with today's date as run-marker; no row content changes since R3.19 substantive update on 2026-05-05). Mtime refreshed by 2026-05-05 nightly sync. **R3.19 sync updates:** A-50 alias row updated with intra-subfolder-archive path (R0.6.3 file moved to `DOC23 Addenda/Archived DOC23 addenda/` per R3.18 detection); NEW row A-51 added for R0.6.4 (UI/Run Inspector/Module Continuation/Sharing-Forward-Compatible) supersession of R0.6.3 per R3.18 detection. Backfilled R3.17/R3.18 missed rows. |
| OP-A Consolidation Reports | `Operations Docs/OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-26_V1.md`, `Operations Docs/OP_A_CONSOLIDATION_SESSION_REPORT_2026-04-27_V1.md` | V1 | 2026-04-27 | Active | Auto-detected 2026-04-27 by nightly sync. Per-session reports accompanying OP-A V3.x bumps. Needs human classification. No new session reports detected in 2026-04-28 / 2026-04-29 / 2026-04-30 / 2026-05-01 / 2026-05-02 sync. |
| OP-A V3.6 → V3.7 Patch | `Operations Docs/Archived DOC OP-A and Operations DOCS/OP_A_V3_6_TO_V3_7_PATCH_V1.md` | V1 | 2026-04-29 | Support | Auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync; needs human classification. Companion patch document for V3.6 → V3.7 transition. Sits in archive subfolder alongside the archived V3.x files. |
| Recent Work Summary | `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY.md` | V1 | 2026-05-13 | Support | Auto-detected 2026-04-30 by nightly sync; needs human classification. **2026-05-13 R3.37 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-10 11:13 → 2026-05-13 11:01 UTC (auto-refresh entry captured in R3.37 multi-fire bump). **2026-05-07 sync confirmation: mtime stable at 2026-05-06 04:04 / size 40,104 bytes (no scheduled-task firing yet on 2026-05-07 since sync runs at ~03:06 local before the 04:10 firing window).** **2026-05-06 R3.22 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:02 → 2026-05-06 04:04; size grew 36,470 → 40,104 bytes (~10% — first growth tick since the R3.20-noted size-decrease anomaly; partial recovery of R3.20 anomaly to ~3% below R3.18 peak of 41,236; flagged informational for ongoing observation). **2026-05-06 R3.23 sync confirmation:** mtime + size unchanged from R3.22 (40,104 bytes / 04:04). **2026-05-04 R3.17 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 11:04 → 2026-05-04 11:03 (size grew 37,316 → 41,236 bytes — sixth consecutive auto-refresh tick by nightly RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task). R3.19 sync (2026-05-05) confirms mtime stable. Not a tracker file; treat as informational support doc until human classifies. |
| S-9 OpenClaw Release Tracker Log | `Operations Docs/OPENCLAW_RELEASE_TRACKER_LOG.md` | V1 | 2026-05-14 | Support | Auto-detected 2026-05-01 by nightly sync (backfill from R3.5 alias bump 2026-04-30); needs human classification. Append-only log of nightly OpenClaw release-alignment checks. **2026-05-14 R3.40 sync detection (backfilled 2026-05-15):** mtime advanced 2026-05-13 10:43 → 2026-05-14 10:42 UTC; size grew further per R3.40 narrative recording 2026-05-14 entry: latest stable UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC), seventh-consecutive-quiet-day at 2026.5.7; gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-9. NEW beta watch row added: `v2026.5.12-beta.6` (2026-05-13/14 prerelease) — iMessage media-only-send visible-text hygiene fix (gateway/recovery item; does not promote into stable alignment basis until cut as `v2026.5.12` or higher on `latest` dist-tag). Single-release roll-forward standstill stretches to seventeen consecutive days. No new firing observed today 2026-05-15 at sync time. **2026-05-13 R3.37 sync detection — sixth-consecutive-quiet-day at 2026.5.7:** mtime advanced 2026-05-12 15:10 → 2026-05-13 10:43 UTC; new 2026-05-13 entry recording today's nightly check. Latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC). Gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-9. Sixth consecutive day of pause; DOC11 R15 R3 amendment drafting window continues to widen but remains unauthored. Beta channel observation continues: `v2026.5.10-beta.6` (2026-05-11) + `v2026.5.9-beta.1` (2026-05-09); no v2026.5.8 stable or beta of any form. R3.37 captured this firing along with five other tracker-log/state-file refreshes in a single multi-fire bump. **2026-05-09 R3.30 sync detection — first day in nearly two weeks without a new stable release:** mtime advanced 2026-05-08 03:44 → 2026-05-09 12:00 UTC; size grew 34,357 → 37,739 bytes (~10%) — new 2026-05-09 11:59 entry recording today's nightly check. Latest stable release UNCHANGED at 2026.5.7 (2026-05-07 20:57 UTC); no v2026.5.8 published yet. Daily-cadence streak from 2026.4.27 through 2026.5.7 has paused. Gap composition unchanged at BEHIND-by-9 (2026.4.27, 2026.4.29, 2026.5.2, 2026.5.3, 2026.5.3-1, 2026.5.4, 2026.5.5, 2026.5.6, 2026.5.7). Today's pause halts gap growth but does not narrow it. Twelve-day standstill on single-release roll-forwards continues; useful drafting window for the DOC11 R15 R3 consolidated amendment that should fold all nine releases — Codex-route saga as a single closed three-act narrative (5.5 unsafe rewrite → 5.6 revert → 5.7 safe preserve/recover). **2026-05-08 R3.28 sync detection earlier:** 2026.5.7 was new (BEHIND-by-8 → BEHIND-by-9) closing the Codex OAuth route saga as a three-act narrative. **2026-05-07 sync confirmation: mtime stable at 2026-05-06 03:46 / size 22,451 bytes (no scheduled-task firing yet on 2026-05-07 since sync runs at ~03:06 local before the 04:10 firing window).** **2026-05-06 R3.22 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 03:46 → 2026-05-06 03:46; size grew 14,987 → 22,451 bytes (~50%) — new 2026-05-06 entry recording 2026.5.5 release awareness (fixes-only release published 2026-05-06 ~09:00 UTC; no new operative architectural surfaces; contract-touching items: Doctor/Codex agentRuntime.id selection, Agents/config legacy "main" agent dir helper removal, CLI/sessions transcript/checkpoint cleanup, xAI/Grok native-Responses reasoning-effort suppression, Channels improvements across Feishu/LINE/Telegram/Discord/Matrix/Slack/WhatsApp). **Gap widened BEHIND-by-6 → BEHIND-by-7 (2026.4.27 + 2026.4.29 + 2026.5.2 + 2026.5.3 + 2026.5.3-1 + 2026.5.4 + 2026.5.5).** Single-release roll-forwards now "no longer keeping pace" for 9–10 consecutive days. **DOC11 R15 R3 amendment recommendation strengthened by another day of standstill** (no R3 amendment file authored between R3.21 and R3.23; gap continues to widen). **2026-05-06 R3.23 sync confirmation:** mtime + size unchanged from R3.22. R3.19 sync (2026-05-05) confirms mtime stable through R3.21. |
| S-10 Recent Work Summary Refresh Log | `Operations Docs/RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY_LOG.md` | V1 | 2026-05-14 | Support | Auto-detected 2026-05-01 by nightly sync (backfill from R3.5 alias bump 2026-04-30); needs human classification. **2026-05-14 R3.41 coordinated-touch attribution (backfilled 2026-05-15):** mtime advanced 2026-05-13 11:06 → 2026-05-14 11:25:37 UTC (+3m37s after R3.40 alias write at 11:22 UTC), size advanced into the 67,229-byte range. Per R3.41 narrative: inferred as R3.40's own coordinated post-write touch rather than independent S-10 firing — mirrors R3.31/R3.32/R3.34/R3.40 same-pattern attributions of operations-state-file mtimes within ~10 minutes of own alias write to the alias-writing run rather than a fresh firing. No independent S-10 firing observed today 2026-05-15 at sync time. **2026-05-13 R3.37 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-10 11:19 → 2026-05-13 11:06 UTC (auto-refresh log entry recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh). Captured by R3.37 multi-fire bump alongside S-8 + S-9. **2026-05-07 sync confirmation: mtime stable at 2026-05-06 04:09 / size 29,650 bytes (no scheduled-task firing yet on 2026-05-07 since sync runs at ~03:06 local before the 04:10 firing window).** **2026-05-06 R3.23 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:10 → 2026-05-06 04:09; size grew 24,943 → 29,650 bytes (~19%) — new 2026-05-06 10:55 entry recording today's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh log (entry written before R3.23's S-11 SUCCESS entry, so its narrative on S-11 status is now slightly stale, mirroring R3.21's stale-on-write pattern). **2026-05-04 R3.18 sync detection:** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 11:10 → 2026-05-04 11:21; size grew 14,177 → 19,950 bytes (~41%) recording additional auto-refresh log entries from tonight's RECENT_WORK_SUMMARY refresh task. R3.19 sync (2026-05-05) confirms mtime stable. |
| S-11 ELNOR Specs Backup Log | `Operations Docs/BACKUP_LOG.md` | V1 | 2026-05-14 | Support | Auto-detected 2026-05-01 by nightly sync (backfill from R3.6 alias bump 2026-04-30); needs human classification. **2026-05-14 R3.40 sync detection — TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day-FAILING-CADENCE escalation (backfilled 2026-05-15):** mtime advanced 2026-05-13 11:16 → 2026-05-14 11:16 UTC, size grew per R3.40 narrative recording 2026-05-14 entry: scheduled backup run logged failed/disconnected (OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder still not connected) — fifth consecutive failed/disconnected day in the chain (2026-05-10 + 2026-05-11 + 2026-05-12 silence + 2026-05-13 + 2026-05-14). The ninth-strike pattern from R3.38 (four-consecutive-failed-day) escalated to TENTH-STRIKE five-consecutive-failed-day under R3.40 capture. **Five calendar days now elapsed without successful cloud backup.** No new S-11 firing observed today 2026-05-15 at sync time (BACKUP_LOG mtime remains at 2026-05-14 11:16). Two-pronged Will action remains URGENT: (1) re-add OneDrive `OpenClaw-Shared` folder via Cowork chat-box "+" button so scheduled task can resume; (2) verify host-side tarball persistence in `~/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **2026-05-13 R3.38 sync detection — three-day-silence STREAK ENDED:** mtime advanced 2026-05-11 14:45 → 2026-05-13 11:16 UTC (size grew with new entry written) recording a backup-task firing that ended the eighth-strike three-consecutive-day-silence pattern carried forward from R3.37. The firing post-dated R3.37 (which ran ~11:09 UTC) by ~7 minutes — first "miss-the-firing-window-by-minutes" pattern observed; R3.38 captured the firing as a single-fire follow-up bump at ~23:10 UTC. Auto pass cannot read entry content to determine SUCCESS/FAILURE status; mtime advance + size growth confirm a new entry was written. Pattern resumption (firing at all) is itself a recovery signal vs the R3.36/R3.37 silence pattern; whether the firing succeeded or failed pending human classification. **2026-05-09 R3.30 sync detection — FIFTH consecutive empty-start strike, entrenched-pattern classification, recommend pausing the scheduled task:** mtime advanced 2026-05-08 04:21 → 2026-05-09 16:29 UTC; size grew 12,994 → 15,163 bytes (~17%) recording fifth SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run at 2026-05-09 16:18 UTC (09:18 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-09_161824.tgz` (5.40 MB compressed from 19 MB / 19,216,816 bytes uncompressed source); destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`; rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3); mount path this run: `/sessions/fervent-sweet-galileo/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`. **Five of seven autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful** (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success, 5/7 success, 5/8 success, 5/9 success — 5-of-7 = 71% success rate). **CRITICAL: destination empty at start of run for the FIFTH CONSECUTIVE TIME** (2026-05-04, 2026-05-06, 2026-05-07, 2026-05-08, 2026-05-09). Pattern is now entrenched — no longer a one-off anomaly. The 48-hour gate is permanently defeated; rotation logic will never fire because each run sees an empty destination, so the cap-of-3 invariant is silently violated. **Entry recommendation strengthens to "recommend pausing the scheduled task and investigating the mount semantics before the next run."** Empty-start anomaly graduated from third-strike (R3.25) → fourth-strike (R3.28) → **fifth-strike entrenched-pattern (R3.30)**. Will-side Finder inspection of `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` is now URGENT-PRE-RESUMPTION (must precede any further scheduled runs). **2026-05-08 R3.28 sync detection earlier:** mtime advanced 2026-05-07 04:17 → 2026-05-08 04:21 (~18% growth) recording fourth SUCCESSFUL autonomous run; fourth consecutive empty-start strike. **2026-05-07 sync confirmation: mtime stable at 2026-05-06 11:17 / size 9,236 bytes (no scheduled-task firing yet on 2026-05-07 since sync runs at ~03:06 local before the 04:17 firing window).** **2026-05-06 R3.23 sync detection — STATUS FLIPPED REGRESSED → RESOLVED again via second autonomous-success-path run:** mtime advanced 2026-05-05 04:16 → 2026-05-06 11:17 (size grew further to 9,236 bytes by 2026-05-07 sync time) recording **second SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-06 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-06_111654.tgz` (5.34 MB compressed from 19 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3). Mount path this run: `/sessions/zen-practical-rubin/mnt/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/` — confirms OneDrive Personal `OpenClaw-Shared` directory was reachable for tonight's autonomous run. **R3.21-noted REGRESSED carry-forward is now RESOLVED again via second autonomous-success path** — improvement over R3.21's 1-of-3 ratio: 2-of-4 autonomous runs since the autonomous-success path opened are now successful (5/4 success, 5/5 failure, 5/6 success); persistence across sessions remains intermittent. **NEW informational carry-forward (R3.23):** destination empty at start of 2026-05-06 run despite 2026-05-04 having created its own tarball — second occurrence of empty-start anomaly; Will to manually inspect actual OneDrive Personal folder contents in Finder to confirm tarballs are landing in cloud storage as intended (not vanishing into a per-session sandbox view). **2026-05-04 R3.18 sync detection — STATUS FLIPPED REGRESSED → RESOLVED via autonomous-success path:** mtime advanced 2026-05-03 11:17 → 2026-05-04 11:17; size grew 5,548 → 6,524 bytes (~18%) recording **first SUCCESSFUL autonomous scheduled run** at 2026-05-04 11:17 UTC (04:17 local). Per the new entry: archive `ELNOR_SPECS_BACKUP_2026-05-04_111651.tgz` (5.19 MB compressed from 18 MB uncompressed source), destination `/Users/OpenClaw1/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/OpenClaw-Shared/Elnor Spec Backup/`, rotation kept 1 backup (no-op under cap of 3). One residual question for Will: investigate why the 2026-05-02 manual seed backup is not present in destination at start of R3.18 run (per file note: destination was empty). Possible causes: file removed by user, OneDrive sync state, or different mount path. R3.19 sync (2026-05-05) confirms mtime stable; no new backup run between R3.18 and R3.19. |

## Build Surface (Out-of-Band Workstream)

| Item | Source File | Last Modified | Build Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Electron app frontend | (in build env, not in spec folder) | — | in_progress | Will has built initial frontend; iteration ongoing. |
| DOC23 task page mockup | `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_0.jsx` | 2026-04-28 | pending_integration | **Auto-detected 2026-04-29 by nightly sync:** new mockup version V11.0 appeared (mtime 2026-04-28 04:16); supersedes V10.9 (which remains in folder alongside V10.4/V10.5/V10.8). Likely the DOC23 R3.1 companion mockup (R3.1 mtime 2026-04-28 03:43 — same window). Human reclassification needed. **2026-04-30 / 2026-05-01 syncs: no further mockup changes detected. 2026-05-02 sync:** new alternate variant `Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx` detected (mtime 2026-05-01 21:54, size 180,080 bytes — ~22% larger than V11.0). The "ALT_A" suffix suggests an A/B variant rather than a strict supersession; both V11.0 and V11_ALT_A coexist in folder. Likely a parallel exploration mockup driven by the DOC23 Re-Prompt System Addendum (A-44, mtime 2026-05-02 00:31) and/or DOC23 Judge Context Management Proposal V1 (A-43, mtime 2026-05-01 17:26) — same general window. Human reclassification needed. |
| DOC23 task page mockup (alt variant) | `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC23 Task Mockups/Q_TASK_MODULAR_CANVAS_V11_ALT_A.jsx` | 2026-05-01 | pending_integration | **Auto-detected 2026-05-02 by nightly sync.** New file (mtime 2026-05-01 21:54, size 180,080 bytes). "ALT_A" suffix suggests parallel variant rather than supersession; coexists with V11.0 (147,393 bytes). Likely tied to the DOC23 addendum cluster shipping in the same window (A-43 Judge Context Management Proposal V1 mtime 2026-05-01 17:26; A-44 Re-Prompt System Addendum mtime 2026-05-02 00:31). Human reclassification needed. |
| Projects page mockup | `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC20 Mockups and Design/DOC20 Current Mockups/Q_PROJECT_V2.jsx` | (date in folder listing) | pending_integration | Projects page not yet integrated into app per Will. |
| Q Unified Workspace V8 | `Design Working Folder/Mockups/DOC20 Mockups and Design/DOC20 Current Mockups/Q_UNIFIED_WORKSPACE_V8_0_1.jsx` | 2026-04-08 | integrated_substantially | Current canonical Q design source per CLAUDE.md / DOC20 R4.3 must-read-with. Most of DOC20 mockups have been integrated into the Electron build (per Will). |

---

## Update protocol

1. After any red-team round on a spec: increment `RT Rounds`, set `Last RT` to date, update `RT Posture`.
2. After OP-A obligations are folded for a target spec: update `In OP-A` to `current` with date.
3. After UI extraction completes for a spec: set `UI Extracted` to `done` + date.
4. After retrofit completes for a stale spec: set `Retrofit` to `done` + date.
5. After Workstream G (QA pass) reviews a spec's cross-doc contracts: set `QA Pass` to `done` + date.
6. Anytime: update `Notes` for context that doesn't fit other fields.

When updating, also append an entry to ROADMAP.md changelog so the workstream view reflects current state.